1 PDF
1 PDF
https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
1. Introduction
Water crisis is becoming one of the biggest threat in some countries. Especially, countries
in Middle East are facing severe water crisis due to drought. Countries with high population
also face water crisis due to high water usage [1]. Water crisis can be reduced by
controlling the water usage. One of the successful method to control water usage is by
recycling rain water and greywater. Government and non-government organisations are
encouraging industries to have water recycling system to reduce water crisis. DD Techniche
Sdn Bhd is a water recycling package Installer Company has seen the potential to market a
home scale greywater treatment for toilet flushing within the budget ranging between 3,000
USD to 5,000 USD.
1
Corresponding author: [email protected]
© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
The company has come out with this initiative due the attention gained by the industrial
scale greywater treatment package and the absence of home scale greywater treatment
system. Greywater is the water produced from the laundry, kitchen and toilet except the
toilet wastes [2]. Greywater contains phosphorus and nitrates due to the usage of detergent,
shampoo and dishwasher liquid [3]. Greywater also contains bacteria, total suspended
solids, oil and grease. The total suspended solids (TSS) are hair from the bathroom, dirt
from laundry and food particles from kitchen. These contents in the greywater causes
infection to the user if not treated. Therefore, the greywater must be treated before reusing
it for toilet flushing.
There are three types of treatment, which are the physical treatment, chemical treatment
and biological treatment. Physical treatment involves filtering out particles from water
based on the size using wire mesh or membrane [4]. This treatment is applicable to filter the
suspended solid and reduce the turbidity. Chemical treatment is process of adding
chemicals into the water to neutralise the bacteria through salt addition [5]. Chemical
treatment also involves coagulation process. Coagulation is the process of accumulating the
bacteria together to increase the size and filter out using the physical treatment [2].
Biological treatment is microbial reaction using microorganism to convert bacteria into gas,
water and biomass [6].
Greywater treatment must consist at least two types of treatment because chemical or
biological treatment can treat bacteria but need to be supported by the physical treatment to
filter the solid particles. The design of greywater treatment package for this project requires
to have dimension of 2 m x 2 m x 2 m and budget within 3,000 USD and 5,000 USD. The
design for this project is be inspired from the existing industrial scale water recycling
system. The existing industrial designs for greywater recycling system are slow sand
filtration, membrane bioreactor and water treatment with clarifiers.
The final design of greywater treatment package for this project is made up of pre-
treatment stage with wire mesh and followed by slow sand filtration. This design consists
all three types of water treatment stated above. The pre-treatment with wire mesh involves
physical treatment to filter out food particles, hair and other suspended solids. The slow
sand filtration involves physical treatment, biological treatment and chemical treatment.
The water is accumulated at the top of sand to form platform for biological treatment. Then,
the water passes through the sand and the waste from the biological treatment is filtered out
by the sand layer. The nitrates in the water are be treated through denitrification by the sand
layer.
The greywater treatment package consists of mechanical parts to control the flow and
store the greywater for toilet flushing. The mechanical parts are pumps, sand filtration tank,
wire mesh chassis and collection tank. The mechanical parts are designed based on the flow
rate of the greywater. The pumps are used to pump the water from the collection tank to
storage tank at the roof top for distribution. The sand filtration tank is designed based on the
flow rate entering the sand filtration and requirement of sand height by the environmental
organisations. Wire mesh are designed based on the size of particles to be filtered out and
budget.
The design is evaluated by comparing the treated water with standard water quality for
toilet flushing. The system must be able to meet the water quality for toilet flushing. The
water quality is compared by measuring the total suspended solid (TSS), chemical oxygen
demand (COD) and turbidity. These three parameters must meet the standard water quality
for toilet flushing. The final design is represented in 3D model with all the mechanical parts.
The objectives of this project are to design a home scale greywater recycling package
and optimise the design by having low cost compare to existing designs in the market. The
final design is able to treat the greywater for toilet flushing. The design is optimised by
having lower cost than existing home scale greywater package.
2
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
This project creates the chance for the public to use the greywater treatment system for
household. These reduces the water usage for the public, which will reduce the cost if the
system is used for long term. Reducing water usage results in reduction of water crisis. This
system able to gradually bring advantage to the economy and environment. Since, public
are not using any water recycling system currently because water recycling systems are
only manufactured in industrial scale, this project able to fulfil the gap of designing a home
scale water recycling system.
2. Methodology
This project involves designing, 3D modelling, prototyping and experimental evaluation.
The designing involves the designing of pre-treatment stage with wire mesh, slow sand
filtration and pump. The design is modelled into 3D prototype using SolidWorks Ver. 2016.
The performance of the design is evaluated using the prototype.
3
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
The height of sand filtration and gravel are designed based on the standard dimension
set by the environmental organisation from well-developed country. This dimensions are
set by the organisations based on the feedbacks gathered from the existing slow sand
filtration. The dimensions are listed in Table 3.
2.2 3D Modelling
The design of the pre-treatment stage and slow sand filtration are modelled as software
prototype using SolidWorks Ver. 2017. The pre-treatment stage consists of three parts,
which are the mesh holder, filtration chassis and chassis connector. The mesh holder is
placed in the filtration chassis and the coarse filtration chassis is connected to the fine
filtration chassis using the chassis connector. Since, 4 inches PVC pipe commonly used as
4
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
greywater outlet, the pre-treatment stage is designed to have same dimension as 4 inches
PVC pipe for ease of installation. The drawing of mesh holder is shown in Figure 1.
The slow sand filtration chassis was designed based on the calculations carried out
using the equations and requirements as discussed in Section 2.1. The slow sand filtration
consists two parts which are the chassis and connector. The chassis is used to fill the sand
and gravel. The connecter is used to connect the sand filtration to the pre-treatment stage.
The complete 3D model is shown in Figure 2.
Coarse filtration
Fine filtration
5
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
2.3 Prototyping
The prototyping stage involves the manufacturing of the pre-treatment filter and the sand
filtration to evaluate the design. The pre-treatment filter is built using the 110 mm PVC
pipe with PVC pipe connector. The wire mesh for fine screening and coarse screening are
glued in the pipe using adhesive bonding. The complete prototype model for pre-treatment
filter is shown Figure 3.
Coarse screening
Fine screening
The slow sand filtration is manufactured using plastic tanks. The slow sand filtration is
manufactured in scaled down dimension because the prototype is only needed to evaluate
whether the system can treat the greywater to meet standard quality of water for toilet
flushing. The prototypes are manufactured for use of experiments to evaluate the design.
2.4 Experiments
The project involves the experiments to measure the flow rate entering the sand filter from
the pre-treatment stage, total suspended solid (TSS), chemical oxygen demand (COD) and
turbidity. The TSS, COD and turbidity is measured to evaluate whether the treated water
meets the standard water quality for toilet flushing. The standard water quality for toilet
flushing is gathered from various water quality department as shown in Table 2. The
performance of the design is evaluated by comparing the treated water with parameters in
Table 2.
6
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
7
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
Fig. 4. Filling the treated water until the maximum level, where the disk is visible
Chemical oxygen demand, COD is the total oxygen consumption by all the organic
substances in the water [16]. High values of COD indicate the water has high level of
microorganisms and pollution [17]. The COD experiments is carried out by adding nitric
acid into the treated water. Then, the mixture is heated until the oxidation process
completed and the remaining unreacted nitric acid is weighed. The mass of reacted nitric
acid is calculated by subtracting the remaining unreacted nitric acid added to the treated
water. The mass of dissolved nitric acid represents the COD of the treated water in g/L.
2.5 Limitation
Limitation in this project is the usage of instruments for the measurement of COD, TSS and
turbidity of the water. The COD, TSS and turbidity of the water are measured using manual
experimental method. The instruments are not used because budgets or facility to borrow
the instruments are not allocated by the industry supervisor. Therefore, the manual methods
of determining this parameter involve limitation such as the scale and sensitivity. The
turbidity test only able to give minimum value of 5 NTU.
8
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
Graph in Figure 5 represents the relationship between the flow in rate and flow out rate.
The relationship equation is obtained to calculate the flow entering the slow sand filtration.
The flow out rate is represented as y and the flow in rate is represented as x. The flow out
rate represents the flow rate entering the slow sand filtration. Then, the surface area
required for the slow sand filtration is calculated using equation 1 and tabulated in Table 5.
Therefore, the slow sand filtration is designed based on the calculated surface area as
shown in Table 5. The sand filtration surface has 21 cm of radius. Therefore, the design can
be used up to maximum of 4-bedroom house. Based on Table 5, the maximum flow rate
entering the slow sand filtration is 54.76 L/h. Therefore, the maximum flow rate can be
handled by the slow sand filtration can be calculated using the Darcy’s equation as shown
below. The sand depth, d is recommended to be at least 50 cm by the environmental bodies
from United States. The hydraulic conductivity of the fine sand is given 2×10-4 m/s. The
depth of clearance above the sand layer is 10 cm.
9
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
0.08
0.06
0.04
y = 0.9257x + 0.0004
0.02
0
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1
Flow In Rate (L/s)
Qmax = k.A.(h+d)/d
= (2×10-4) (π0.212) [(0.1+0.5)/0.5]
= 3.325×10-5 m3/s
= 119.70 L/h
Based on the calculated Qmax, the sand depth is designed to be 50 cm. This is because
the flow of water entering the sand filtration is lower than the maximum flow rate can be
handled by the slow sand filtration system with 50 cm sand depth. Based on the
experiments and calculation the final design of the system with collection tank is shown in
Figure 6 and Figure 7. The collection tank is design to collect 1000 L of capacity.
Table 5. Flow rate entering the slow sand filtration and surface area of sand
10
MATEC Web 3 of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
2 1
Eureca 2017
0.50
0.11
C
1
B
NISH: DEBURR AND
DO NOT SCALE DRAWING REVISION
BREAK SHARP
EDGES
11
TURE DATE TITLE:
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
The design is evaluated by carrying out experiments to determine the COD, TSS and
turbidity value of the treated water using the small-scaled prototype. The data collected are
shown in Figure 8.
40
20
0
COD (mg/L) Turbidity (NTU) TSS (mg/L)
Standard water quality Treated water
Fig. 8. Bar chart comparison for standard flushing water quality and treated water
12
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
The turbidity of the treated water in this experiments is less than 5 NTU. The total
suspended solid in the treated water is 3.33 mg/L. The TSS value required for the toilet
flushing water is less than 10 mg/L. Therefore, the design fulfils the requirement for the
TSS value. The COD of the treated water is 40 mg/L. The required COD for the toilet
flushing water is less than 30 mg/L. The COD requirement was not able to fulfilled because
of the small-scale prototype.
Based on the finalised design, the price to manufactured one complete filter system is
estimated. The complete system includes the plastic filter chassis for the pre-treatment filter
and slow sand filtration, filter sand, wire mesh, auto water pump and collection tank. The
price for each product is obtained and the total cost is calculated as shown in Table 6. The
experiments to evaluate the performance of system by measuring the TSS, COD, and
turbidity of the treated water are conducted using the prototype.
As can be seen in Table 6, the budget to manufacture one complete system using the
design in this project is lower than cost of the existing greywater recycling package. The
existing home scale greywater system in the market is a down-scaled of industry greywater
recycling design. Therefore, the cost of this existing home scale greywater recycling
package design is 8,100 USD. This design has high cost due to the technology that are used
in this system. This system consists physical treatment using different size of mesh and
membrane. Then, the biological treatment is carried out using the UV ray. The UV ray
neutralises the microorganism in the water. The parts that cause the system to be expensive
are the membrane, UV ray and pump. This design is relatively cheaper because this designs
does not uses any membrane as the physical filtration and high performance pump for the
water movement through the membrane. The membrane is replaced by the sand filtration
which able to meet the same turbidity and pump is replaced by the gravitational force in the
sand filtration. The UV ray is replaced by the sand filtration because the water and residue
accumulated at the top of the sand layer forms biological reaction bed layer. The
microorganisms are neutralised at top of the sand through biological treatment.
Therefore, the optimisation of the design involves the cost of the system. The recycling
package is designed at relatively lower cost with same function and requirement. This low
cost provides more chances for the customer to buy this product. This can increase the
attention and business value of greywater recycling package.
13
MATEC Web of Conferences 152, 02005 (2018) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201815202005
Eureca 2017
4. Conclusion
The greywater treatment package is successfully designed within proposed budget The
design of the system is within 6 m3 including the collection tank. The greywater treatment
package contains the pre-treatment filter, slow sand filtration and collection tank. The effect
of the pre-treatment stage on the flow entering the slow sand filtration is studied to design
the slow sand filtration. Based on the experiments, the slow sand filtration is designed
based on the volumetric flow rate and Darcy’s law. The material budget of a complete
system is lower than the existing home scale greywater recycling system. This design is
able to treat greywater to meet the standard water quality of toilet flushing.
References
[1] K. Bani-melhem and E. Smith, Chem. Eng. Journal., 198-199, 201–210, (2012).
[2] M. S. Fountoulakis, N. Markakis, I. Petousi, and T. Manios, Sci. Total Environ.
Journal, 551–552, 706–711, (2016).
[3] J. A. Peeples, Wastewater Use Agric., II, 119–131, (2006).
[4] B. Je, A. Laine, S. Parsons, T. Stephenson, and S. Judd, Journal of Elsevier, 1, 1999,
(2000).
[5] F. Li, K. Wichmann, and R. Otterpohl, Sci. Total Environ. Journal, 407, 11,. 3439–
3449, (2009).
[6] B. A. Mittal, “Biological Wastewater Treatment,” FullTide Corporation, 2–9,
(2011).
[7] Y. Dunets, Siobhan; Zheng, “Slow sand filtration,” Greenh. Nurs. Watery, (2011).
[8] W. T. Course, Sci. Total Environ. Journal, 1–2, (2012).
[9] B. Lesikar, R. Melton, D. Smith, and C. O. Neill, “AgriLife Communications and
marketing, 3–08, (2003).
[10] Centre for Affordable Water TEchnilogy, “What is the minimum depth of filtration
sand, underdrain gravel and separating gravel? (particularly.” Cisco Foundation, 1,
(2017).
[11] Members of WQA, “Residential Water Reuse Fact Sheet,” Water Quality
Association, 1–5, (2013).
[12] T. Bruursema, Plumbing Systems & Design Magazine, 15–22, (2011).
[13] American Water Standard, “NSF/ANSI Standard 350 For Water Reuse Treatment
Systems,” (2011).
[14] V. Lazarova, Milestones in Water Reuse. The International Water Association,
(2013).
[15] Chicago School Network, “Turbidity,” Turbid. Test Procedure., 1–2, (2013).
[16] Y.-C. Kim, S. Sasaki, K. Yano, K. Ikebukuro, K. Hashimoto, and I. Karube, Anal.
Chim. Acta, 432, 1, 59–66, (2001).
[17] J. Chen, J. Zhang, Y. Xian, X. Ying, M. Liu, and L. Jin, Water Res.Journal, 39, 7,
1340–1346, (2005).
14