Budget Control for Work Orders
Budget Control for Work Orders
LaGOV
Version 1.0
3
Ground Rules
4
Introduction
Roles
Process Analyst and Functional Consultant – lead and facilitate
the discussions, and drive design decisions
Documenter – take detailed notes to support formal meeting minutes
to be sent by the Process Analyst to all participants for review and
feedback
Team Members – provide additional support for process discussions,
address key integration touch points
Subject Matter Experts – advise project team members on the
detailed business processes and participate in the decisions required
to design the future business process of the State
Realization
Preparation
Preparation
Business
Blueprint
Support
Go Live
Project
Final
and
• Strategy & Approach Defined • Development & Unit Testing • Go-Live Support
• Project Team Training • Integration Testing • Performance Tuning
• End-User Training Materials
6
Project Organization - Functional Teams
General Ledger
Accounts Payable
Accts Receivable
Cash Management Fernando Figueroa
Cost Accounting Lucie Hidalgo
Funds Management Richard Lozano
Grants Mgt
Project Systems
Asset Accounting
Budget Prep
Grantor
Real Estate Mgt
7
Blueprint Objectives
Review expense types and reach budget control decision for each,
including exemptions from budget control
9
FM Sessions
Session
No of Schedul Description/Major
Session # Overview of major Session Topics
days e Business Process
Group
FM master data fields will be introduced. The use, mapping to legacy, naming convention and
FI-FM-001 1 days 7-Aug FM Master Data
maintenance process will be determined.
Need to coordinate Budget Prep design with FM, GM, GTR and PS in ECC 6.0 for budget
preparation and budget amendments. Define FM budgeting characteristics including Budget
Budget Preparation, Versions, Budget Types/processes (Original, Carry Forward, Supplementary, Transfers &
17-18
FI-FM-002 2 days Amendments and Returns), Budget & Posting address (Budget Structures), Budget Doc types. Discuss options
Sep
Integration for Budget Amendments/Adjustments (AS-IS & TO-BE). Determine the frequency of “Plan”
Retraction to SAP R3 (FM, GM, PS, HR-PBC) and update frequency of “Actual” data into BW
cubes, from ECC and other systems
Define budget control level (AVC addresses) in FM for departments/agencies, capital projects
22-23 Budget Availability and grant budgets (by FM Master Data) by fund and expense type. Define exceptions for
FI-FM-003 2 days
Oct and Control - General budget control. Define the FM standard and budget tolerance profiles used by SBBC. Review
other FM functionality which may be useful in budget control
Budget Availability Define budget control address for work orders from PM and Agile Assets. Determine use of
FI-FM-004 1 day 13-Nov and Control - Work automatic reservations at time of order creation. Determine the process for creating related FM
Orders master data and coordination with PM/Agile assets master data.
FM Budget Process by which FM gets updated for actual expenditures (posting address)
Consumption - Pre-encumbrances and encumbrances from MM
FI-FM-005 1 day 1-Oct
Expenses and FM Earmarked funds – type, use and liquidation process
Encumbrances Use of non-consumable budget types for reservations
Review FM Month End Activities including Opening / Closing FM Periods and Transferring
FM Period End Commitments to FI-GL. Review Additional FM Year End Activities including Commitment and
FI-FM-006 1.0 days 8-Oct
Processing associated budget balance carry-forwards, Residual Budget Carry-Forwards and Fund Balance
Carry-Forwards.
10
SAP Glossary – FM module
11
SAP Glossary – FM module
GRANT (REPORTING
CATEGORY) – Lower-level
funding instruments used to
document, control and report on
the results of an agreement
between a sponsor and an
organization. Represents
externally funded grants.
12
As Is: Budget Control – DOTD Work Orders
Work Orders are entered into SAP HR and interfaced to DOTD
accounting system:
– Salaries/Benefits: Recorded against home organization and are not allocated or
charged to the organization where the work order is being performed.
– Equipment usage: Cost of equipment usage is charged to the work order but no
budget is checked at work order. The equipment expense is charged to the
organization that purchased it at the time purchase.
– Inventory/materials: Like equipment, inventory is charged to work orders but is
not budget checked. Inventory is budget checked when it is purchased. There is
no budget check when inventory is consumed except when the consumption is
by another district or section than the issuing district.
13
As Is: Budget Control – DPS Work Orders
Actual costs are recorded in AFS as follows:
– Salaries/Benefits: Recorded against Facilities Management
organization and are not allocated or charged to the organization where
the work order is being performed.
– Equipment usage: Like salaries, cost of equipment usage is not
charged to the work order. The equipment expense is charged to the
organization that purchased it at the time purchase.
– Inventory/Materials: May be charged directly to the organization
specifically for that work order. In some cases, inventory may be issued
from a central warehouse and charged to the work order organization at
that time, if different.
14
As Is: Budget Control – DPS Work Orders
15
As Is: Budget Control – OSB Work Orders
Actual costs are recorded in AFS as follows:
– Salaries/Benefits: Recorded against home organization and are not
allocated or charged to the organization/ reporting category (building)
where the work order is being performed, unless the salaries & benefits
is part of that organization (i. e. superintendents salaries for each
building)
– Equipment usage: Like salaries, cost of equipment usage is not
charged to the work order. The equipment expense is charged to the
organization that purchased it at the time purchase.
– Inventory/Materials: May be charged directly to the organization
specifically for that work order. In some cases, inventory may be issued
from a central warehouse and charged to the work order organization at
that time, if different
16
As Is: Budget Control – OSB Work Orders
17
As Is Availability Control – Work Orders
DOTD, Dept of Public Safety and OSB
18
SAP PM Work Order Process - Overview
Plant Maintenance Work Order Current Scope: DOTD, DPS and
OSB, including Fleet Maintenance
Individual PM work orders will be used to track labor, equipment
usage and materials (both stock and non-stock) at the individual
work order level within the one system
– SAP will support both operational and financial details
– Costs may be coded directly to the work order or may be
allocated to it through CO allocations (e.g. equipment usage)
Four types of work orders will be defined in PM with different
number ranges:
– Internally assigned numeric number
• Preventative
• Repair
• Capital Project
– Externally assigned number
• Agile
Upon completion of the work order, costs will be settled or closed
out the responsible cost center (organization) or Capital Projects
through the use of Secondary Cost Elements
19
Agile Assets / SAP DOTD Work Order
Process - Overview
Inserts
of Agile
Day Cards
Labor
(with attached WO SAP CAT
Daycards
Agile Day To connect with PM
Cards WO) Equipment SAP PM
actuals
Materials SAP PM
Goods Issues
Final costed
transactions IN
SAP ECC
Fund Accounting
FM Budgetary Controls
Budget Execution
Budgetary Basis
Reporting
Commitment Accounting
21
FM Master Data
22
23
Draft Funds - Numbering Convention
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)
Operating Funds:
(1)-(4) = CAFR Classifications (Fund Group / Fund Type / Fund Class)
(5)-(7) = CAFR / Agency Fund
(8)-(10) = MOF or zero filled
Capital Funds:
(1)-(4) = CAFR Classifications (Fund Group / Fund Type / Fund Class)
(5)-(7) = Capital Outlay Fund Number
(8)-(10) = Funding Source (LOC, Bond Series, Other)
24
Cost Centers: DOTD Proposed Numbering Scheme
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)
(1) – (3) (4) – (5) (6) – (7)
(8) (9) – (10)
Agency = Program DOTD District
Unit Crew
or Section
Business Area
Notes:
1. Crew (Old Gang #’s) will be renumbered (from 3 digits to 2); will be left as old where
ever possible.
2. At this time, Digit # 8 (Unit) is not used. Will be populated with “0” for now. Can be
used in future.
25
25
Cost Centers: Non-DOTD Proposed Numbering Scheme
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)
(1) – (3) (4) – (5) (6) – (7)
(8) – (9) (10)
Agency = Program Division
Section Unit
Business Area
26
26
Standard SAP Numbering Convention
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)
27
Draft Funded Program Proposal (1)
28
Functional Area - Numbering Convention
29
FM Budget Addresses
1. Budget Address
• FM account assignment on which budget and budget entries
are entered or can be entered in FM. May be at same level or
higher than posting address.
2. Posting Address
• FM account assignment on which actual / commitment postings
are received and allowed in FM.
• Typically is the lowest or most detailed level of the FM account
assignments
3. Availability Control Address
• FM account assignment on which budget control takes place.
• Typically takes place at higher roll-up level than budget
address to prevent unnecessary budget transfers (highest
possible legal level)
Control address
Budget address
Posting address
31
Proposal: Posting Address – Preventative, Regular & Agile Work
Orders
FUND (1) – The fund from the posting will be used.
FUND CENTER (2) – When posting to a work order, a cost center will not be entered
however the related FM fund center will be derived from the work order master record.
– The cost center (fund center) in the work order will be cost center where the work
order is being performed
COMMITMENT ITEM (3) – The commitment item will be derived from the GL expense
account used to record the work order expense
FUNCTIONAL AREA (1) – Will be transferred from the actual posting. The functional
area used in the posting should match the functional area in the work order master.
FUNDED PROGRAM (2) – One high level, roll-up funded program by agency will be
derived in FM for all work orders to summarize actual costs for all work orders to
segregate these costs from regular operating fund center costs.
– The individual work order number will also be recorded in FM
FUND CENTER – A higher level fund center where the work order is being performed.
– For AFS Agencies, the budget will be entered in a fund center represent agency,
program, division and section (no unit).
– For DOTD, the budget will be entered in a higher level fund center representing
agency, program, DOTD district or section (no unit or gang)
COMMITMENT ITEM – The individual commitment items that will incur the expense
FUNDED PROGRAM – “Not Relevant” value since work order and non-work expenses
share the same budget at the appropriated program level. Any expenses subject to
budget control coded directly to work orders will consume the responsible fund center
budget. Question: Do we want to separate work order relevant budget in total from non-
work relevant budget for the appropriated program and organization?
In summary, similar to the current practice, the budget to support work orders will reside
at the operating fund, fund center (appropriation program and organization) and
commitment item (object code) where the work is being carried. Salary budget will reside
in the fund center whose carries out the work order, which may be different.
33
Proposal: Posting Address – Capital Project Work Orders
FUND (1) – The Capital Fund for the Capital Project from the posting will be used.
FUND CENTER (2) – When posting to a work order, a cost center will not be entered
however the related FM fund center will be derived from the work order master record.
– The cost center (fund center) in the work order will be the one responsible for the
Capital Project
COMMITMENT ITEM (3) – The commitment item will be derived from the GL expense
account used to record the work order expense
FUNCTIONAL AREA (1) – Will be transferred from the actual posting. The functional
area used in the posting should match the functional area in the work order master.
FUNDED PROGRAM (2) – Will be derived from the WBS element (Capital Project
phase) from the Work Order master record
– The individual work order number will also be recorded in FM
34
Proposal: Budget Address – Capital Project Work Orders
FUND CENTER – The fund center responsible for the Capital Project.
COMMITMENT ITEM – The individual commitment items that will incur the expense
FUNDED PROGRAM – The Capital Project WBS Element(s) representing the phase(s) of
the project. Any expenses subject to budget control coded directly to work orders will
consume the budget of the appropriate Capital Project phase.
– Question: Are maintenance work order expenses budgeted for separately in Capital
Projects?
GRANT (1) – Relevant only if it is a non-FHWA, grant funded capital project; otherwise ill
budget will be assigned to “Not Relevant” value
In summary, the budget to support Capital Project work orders will reside in the
appropriate phase of the Capital Project by Capital Funds and Commitment Item (object
category)
35
SAP Key Design Considerations
36
Proposal: SAP Budget Control
No major change to the current practice will take place for budget control by
types of expenses
– No separate budgeting or budget control will take place at the individual
work order or work order groups
– Budget will be consumed and checked, where necessary, at the fund
center or the Capital Project for which the work order is performed
Work Order Expenses Exempt from Budget Control:
– Salaries and benefits coded to the work order
– Inventory usage from warehouses in the same program and current two digit
object category (first three digits of commitment items in SAP)
• In the case of DOTD, no budget control if the inventory for the work order is
from the same district or section as the work order
– Activity allocations for Equipment usage
Work Order Expenses Subject to Budget Control:
– Inventory usage from warehouses in a different appropriated program and current
two digit object category or different district or section
– Direct purchases of inventory, materials or equipment to support work orders
For expenses subject to budget control, this will take place at the time of the
expense or commitment posting to the work order. No budget control takes
place on settlement of work order costs.
37
Summary Decision: Budget Control – Expense
Categories
Per Commissioner’s direction, all funds subject to budget control will be
budget checked according to current AFS Object Categories using high
level commitment item rollups:
FUND CENTER – Higher level Fund center where the work order is being
performed. Fund center derived from the Cost Center in work order master.
– For DPS and OSB, budget controlled to the first five characters, representing legacy
Agency and Appropriated Expense Unit.
– For DOTD, budget controlled to the first seven characters, representing legacy
Agency, Program, District or Section
PM Work Order Requirement: In the header of the work order, the fund and
cost center who requested the work order must be entered. Functional area will
also be entered but currently does not form part of budget control.
39
Proposal: Budget Consumption and Control –
Capital Project Work Orders
FUND – Budget will be by individual Capital Fund
COMMITMENT ITEM – Commitment Item roll-up equivalent to the current two digit
object category or DOTD ISIS group.
FUNDED PROGRAM – Funded Program representing the Capital Project Phase for
which the work order is being performed
PM Work Order Requirement: In the header of the work order, the Capital fund
and WBS Element (project phase) will need must be entered. The Cost Center
responsible for the Capital Outlay and the Functional area will also be entered but
won’t be applicable for budget control.
40
Process Improvement Opportunities
41
Organizational Impacts
Since there are no major changes to the budgeting for work orders,
thus no major organizational impacts
For expenses subject to budget control, if any, budget will be
checked at the fund center or Capital project where the work
order is being performed
42
Next Steps
43
Questions?
? ? ? ?
? ? ? ? ?
? ? ? ? ?
? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
?
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
? ? ?
? ? ?
? ? ? ? ? ? ?
? ?
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
? ? ? ?
?
? ? ? ? ? ??
? ? ? ? ? ?
? ? ?
? ? ? ?
? ? ? ? ? ?
? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ?
? ?
? ?
?
FM Budget Control System (BCS) -
Overview
FM-BCS is the sub-component of FM where budget control is
configured.
47
Budget Execution and Control – Summary Decisions
Non-payroll related costs will consume budget and be subject to budget control unless
otherwise noted (general rule)
FM integration with Purchasing – Will consume budget and be subject to budget control
for all stages of the purchasing cycle. If the value of follow-on documents are greater than
the previous document in the chain, a budget check is triggered at that stage. Budget is
returned if no further activity is expected and purchasing document is updated.
– Purchase requisitions - Pre-encumbrance against budget
– Purchase orders – Encumbrance established; will reduce the referenced purchase
requisition’s pre-encumbrance for the lesser of the value of purchase order or purchase
requisition
– Goods receipts – Expenditure established against budget; Will reduce the referenced
purchase order’s encumbrance for the lesser of the value of good receipt or purchase
order
– Invoice receipts – Expenditures established (with Invoice status); will reduce the
referenced goods receipt’s expenditure for the lesser of the value of invoice receipt or
goods receipt
Payroll and Payroll Related Costs will consume budget (real FM postings) but AVC will
be configured not to hard stop on budget overruns
48
FM Budget Control – Budget Tolerance Profiles
Decision: As a starting point, the Standard Tolerance for the State
will incorporate the following:
For expenses subject to budget control:
No warning message issued to end user when budget nears consumption
An error message issued to end users when budget consumption exceeds
100%
No email messages to fund center owner
No use of absolute tolerances (amounts)
Payroll postings will be excluded from budget control in tolerance profile
Standard Tolerance Profile will be used for all agencies and funds,
including capital outlay and grants
Alternative Tolerances will be defined and will be used to override
the Standard Tolerance when necessary.
Warning Message at 100% Consumption
No Message at 100% Consumption
Use of Alternative Tolerances, if necessary, and fine tuning of
Standard Tolerance or creation of additional tolerances to be
determined during Realization
Budget Consumption
There are two options for when work order costs consume budget:
Consume budget for stock and non-stock expenses at the time of the expense
or commitment posting
– Purchase Requisitions / Orders, Goods Issue or FI/CO expense postings
directly to the work order
Consume budget for stock and non-stock expenses at the time of the work
order release. Budget control would take
– Automatic creation of purchase requisition(s) for non-stock items. Purchase
orders would reference the purchase requisition(s)
– Automatic creation of material reservations for stock items. Material
reservations would be referenced in the good issue transaction.
– Creation of these documents would creation funds commitment documents
in FM to reserve the budget. Funds commitment status is updated
throughout the process (commitment to expense, etc).
• Subsequent budget check performed if subsequent transaction value is greater than initial
commitments.
Decision:??
Note: Budget consumption and control to occur at the time of work order
postings. No budget control takes place on settlement of work order costs.
50
FM Addresses: Proposal
For regular (non-capital project) PM maintenance work orders (both Agile and
SAP):
Posting Address: Actual expenses and commitments will be updated in FM from other modules
(MM, HR, FI, CO) at the individual / lowest level FM dimensions* -
– The operating Fund, Fund center responsible for the work order, and Functional Area will be
derived from the work master record
– One high level funded program by agency will be used to summarize actual costs for all work
orders to segregate these costs from regular operating fund center costs. The individual
work order number will also be recorded in FM
– The commitment item will be derived from the GL account used in the posting
– Grant will equal “Not Relevant” value.
– FM Derivation rules will be used to derive the FM master data objects
Budget Address: Budget will be entered at and adjusted at the individual / lowest level FM
dimensions* . Possible Exception: Budget to reside at a higher level Fund Center, depending on
how on the level of budgeting within the new Fund Center (cost center) number
– Similar to current practice, any budget that supports maintenance work orders will reside in
the respective fund center that carries out the work, in addition to the fund and commitment
item for that fund center budget
– Functional area will also be budgeted for if appropriation program (and possibly sub-
program) will be mapped to the functional area in SAP (tbd)
– Funded Program will equal the capital project phase. Any costs subject to budget control will
consume the project phase budget.
– Grant = Not Relevant
* FM dimensions include Fund, Fund Center, Functional Area, Funded Programs, Commitment Item and Grant
51
FM Addresses: Proposal
For Capital project relevant PM maintenance work orders (both Agile and SAP):
Posting Address: Actual expenses and commitments will be updated in FM from other modules
(MM, HR, FI, CO) at the individual / lowest level FM dimensions* - rolled up funded program for all
work orders? By order types?
– Capital Fund, Funded Program (Project phase), Functional Area and Fund Center
(responsible for the capital project) will be derived from the master data in the work order.
The individual work order number will also be recorded in FM.
– The commitment item will be derived from the GL account used in the posting
– Grant will equal “Not Relevant” value.
– FM Derivation rules will be used to read the master data off the work order master header
and derive the equivalent FM master data
Budget Address: Budget will be entered at and adjusted at the individual / lowest level FM
dimensions* . Possible Exception: Budget to reside a higher level Fund Center, depending on
how on the level of budgeting within the new Fund Center (cost center) number
– Similar to current practice, budget that supports capital project relevant maintenance work
orders will reside in the respective Capital Fund, Fund Center and Capital Project funded
program (WBS element – project phase) that requested the maintenance work. In addition,
the budget will be entered in the Capital Projects by Commitment Items.
– Functional area will also be budgeted for if appropriation program (and possibly sub-
program) will be mapped to the functional area in SAP (tbd)
– Funded Program will equal Not Relevant since no budget control is carried out for work
orders. Any miscellaneous costs subject to budget control coded directly to work orders will
consume the responsible fund center budget.
– Grant = Not Relevant
* FM dimensions include Fund, Fund Center, Functional Area, Funded Programs, Commitment Item and Grant
52
As-Is Process Flow
53
As-Is Process Flow
Fund Group
FIDUCIARY
GOVERNMENTAL
PROPRIETARY
COLLEGES & UNIVERSITIES
SUSPENSE CLASSIFICATION
DISCRETE
54
As-Is Process Flow
Fund Type
CAPITAL PROJECT FUNDS
DEBT SERVICE FUNDS
ENTERPRISE FUNDS
REVENUE SHARING FUNDS
GEN FIXED ASSET GROUP SPECIAL REVENUE FUNDS
GENERAL FUND SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FUNDS
INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS EXPENDABLE TRUST/AGENCY FUNDS
GEN LONG TERM DEBT GROUP COLLEGE & UNIVERSITY FUNDS
NON-EXPENDABLE TRUST/AGY INVESTMENT POOL FUNDS
FUNDS SUSPENSE CLASSIFICATION FUNDS
DISCRETE FUNDS
55
As-Is Process Flow
Fund Category
Original
56
As-Is Process Flow
Fund Class
JUDICIARY
AGRICULTURE DEPT OF JUSTICE
BOND SECURITY AND REDEMPTION DEPT OF LABOR
CONSTITUTIONALLY CREATED LEVEE DISTRICTS
CORRECTIONS PARISH & MUNICIPAL
CULTURE RECREATION & TOURISM PAYROLL CLEARING
CUSTODIAL PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
DEPT OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ROCKEFELLER
DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY RUSSELL SAGE
DEPT OF HEALTH AND HOSPITALS SECRETARY OF STATE
DEPT OF NATURAL RESOURCES STATE TREASURER'S OFFICE
DEPT OF PUBLIC SAFETY TRAVEL CLEARING
DEPT OF REVENUE AND TAXATION TRANSPORTATION TRUST
DEBT SERVICE DEPT OF WILDLIFE & FISHERIES
DEBT SERVICE RESERVE GENERAL FUND
DEPT OF SOCIAL SERVICES CAPITAL OUTLAY (77)
DEPT OF EDUCATION CAPITAL OUTLAY (78)
ESCROW ENTERPRISE/INTERNAL SERVICE
FREE SCHOOL AGENCY OPERATING
GAMING COLLEGE/UNIVERSITY OPERATION
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR NONGENERAL FUND OPERATING
DEPT OF HIGHWAYS INTERFACE FUNDS
DEPT OF INSURANCE
57
Funds - Numbering Convention (2)
58
Funds - Numbering Convention (3)
Fund Class and MOF may be renumbered. Fund # will be kept, where possible
Note: No periods will be part of the fund number;used for ease of segregation only
59
FM Budget Control – Budget Tolerance Profiles