0% found this document useful (0 votes)
53 views12 pages

MEP Project Feedback Guide

The document provides feedback on three potential issues encountered on projects: 1) The manhole installation for a domestic water tank was flush with the pump room floor, allowing dirty water to drip into the tank. Installing the manhole cover 100-150mm above the floor would prevent contamination. 2) Ventilation ducts not treated with anti-corrosion paint rusted where in contact with cement mortar. Applying the treatment to contact areas would prevent rusting. 3) Proper beveling and spacing of pipe joints during welding allows effective root passes and good welding quality.

Uploaded by

amirudin safrie
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
53 views12 pages

MEP Project Feedback Guide

The document provides feedback on three potential issues encountered on projects: 1) The manhole installation for a domestic water tank was flush with the pump room floor, allowing dirty water to drip into the tank. Installing the manhole cover 100-150mm above the floor would prevent contamination. 2) Ventilation ducts not treated with anti-corrosion paint rusted where in contact with cement mortar. Applying the treatment to contact areas would prevent rusting. 3) Proper beveling and spacing of pipe joints during welding allows effective root passes and good welding quality.

Uploaded by

amirudin safrie
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 12

Feedback Sheet

Good Case ✘ Failure Case Proposal Others ( )


Category
Quality Cost Delivery Safety Enviroment Others
Division/Country Abbreviation name/Code Name Date Created

YYYY/MM/DD

Topic Name In case of proposal


implemented ✘ Not

The Manhole Installation for Domestic Water Tank


inside Pump Room

Content to be pointed out:


Domestic Water Tank cover is flush with the Pump Room FFL.

potential when doing servicing, or cleaning of pump room, or leakages from pipes above,
the dirty water may drip into the Water tank and may cause contamination.

Way of correction :
Instal manhole cover c/w rubber gasket

Measure
During design & planning stage should be coordinate “SAME,
coordination should be done at the time of shop drawing /before build.
It is advisable to raise the Domestic Water tank cover around 100 to 150mm above the pump room FFL
in order to avoid any dirty water from dripping into the Domestic Water tank.

Other
Design Our design design Structure SRC Others
Facility usage Office Store Housing Welfare Hotel Facotry Logistics School Research Cultural
Primary Evaluator Comment (Each Country MEP Director)
Committee staff Cloumn
Committee staff Remark

☆Document Flow
※When Completion of the project, Each PIC have to submit at least one topic for each project.
Author → Primary Evaluator (Each Country MEP Director) → Committee staff → Share Point

※Reference
Reference No.
No.

     
     
Others ( )

Date Created No.

YYYY/MM/DD
Remark

Core, finishing, equipment, temporary, cost, others

Others

Cultural ✘ Others
Evaluater
Manager
Manager

Committee

Revised 2019.04.01
Feedback Sheet
Good Case Failure Case Proposal Others ( )
Category
✘ Quality Cost Delivery Safety Enviroment Others
Division/Country Abbreviation name/Code Name Date Created

YYYY/MM/DD

Topic Name In case of proposal


implemented Not

Ventilation Duct penetration to wall

Content to be pointed out:


Ventilation Duct not painted with Anti Corrosion treatment at the Mortar area
GI Sheet when contact directly with cement mortar may get rusty over a period of time

Way of correction :
gave space between duct and wall, caulking
with rock wool and sealant

Measure
Apply Anti Corrosion treatment at the area where it is directly contact with the cement mortar area.

Other
Design Our design design Structure SRC Others
Facility usage Office Store Housing Welfare Hotel Facotry Logistics School Research Cultural
Primary Evaluator Comment (Each Country MEP Director)
Committee staff Cloumn
Committee staff Remark

☆Document Flow
※When Completion of the project, Each PIC have to submit at least one topic for each project.
Author → Primary Evaluator (Each Country MEP Director) → Committee staff → Share Point

※Reference
Reference No.
No.

     
     
Others ( )

Date Created No.

YYYY/MM/DD
Remark

Not Core, finishing, equipment, temporary, cost, others

ere it is directly contact with the cement mortar area.

Others

Cultural ✘ Others
Evaluater
Manager
Manager

Committee

Revised 2019.04.01
Feedback Sheet
✘ Good Case Failure Case Proposal Others ( )
Category
Quality Cost Delivery Safety Enviroment Others
Division/Country Abbreviation name/Code Name Date Created

YYYY/MM/DD

Topic Name In case of proposal


implemented Not

Pipe Welding Joint Process

Content to be pointed out:


Beveling of pipe and spacing
based on Standard.

Welding process will be able to weld root pass effectively


and the entire welding process is good.

Other
Design Our design design Structure SRC Others
Facility usage Office Store Housing Welfare Hotel Facotry Logistics School Research Cultural
Primary Evaluator Comment (Each Country MEP Director)
Committee staff Cloumn
Committee staff Remark

☆Document Flow
※When Completion of the project, Each PIC have to submit at least one topic for each project.
Author → Primary Evaluator (Each Country MEP Director) → Committee staff → Share Point

※Reference
Reference No.
No.

     
     
Others ( )

Date Created No.

YYYY/MM/DD
Remark

Core, finishing, equipment, temporary, cost, others

Others

Cultural ✘ Others
Evaluater
Manager
Manager

Committee

Revised 2019.04.01

You might also like