Organizational Behavior - Study Guide - Chapters 6, 9 & 10
Organizational Behavior - Study Guide - Chapters 6, 9 & 10
Summary:
Individuals base their behavior not on the way their external environment actually is, but
rather on the way they see it or believe it to be. An understanding of the way people make
decisions can help us explain and predict behavior, but few important decisions are simple or
unambiguous enough for the rational model’s assumptions to apply. We find individuals looking
for solutions that satisfy rather than optimize, injecting biases and prejudices into the decision
process, and relying on intuition. Managers should encourage creativity in employees and
teams to create a route to innovative decision making.
Slides:
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: After studying this chapter, you should be able to:
1. Explain the factors that influence perception.
2. Describe attribution theory.
3. Explain the link between perception and decision making.
4. ---
5. Explain how individual differences and organizational constraints affect decision making.
1
■ Background
■ Proximity
■ Similarity
2
○ Occurs when we do not evaluate a person in isolation.
○ Our reaction to one person is influenced by other people we have recently
encountered.
■ Ex: We compare one person to another. The second looks better or
worse in light of the first.
● Stereotyping
○ Judging someone on the basis of our perception of the group to which he or she
belongs.
■ We have to monitor ourselves to make sure we’re not unfairly applying a
stereotype in our evaluations and decisions.
● Self-fulfilling prophecy: The Pygmalio effect suggests that people’s expectations
determine their behavior.
● Applications of Shortcuts in Organizations
○ Employment Interview Expectations
■ Evidence indicates that interviewers make perceptual judgments that are
often inaccurate.
● Interviewers generally draw early impressions that become very
quickly entrenched.
● Studies indicate that most interviewers’ decisions change very
little after the first four or five minutes of the interview.
○ Performance Expectations
■ Evidence demonstrates that people will attempt to validate their
perceptions of reality, even when those perceptions are faulty.
● Self-fulfilling prophecy, or the Pygmalion effect characterizes
the fact that people’s expectations determine their behavior.
● Expectations become reality.
○ Performance Evaluation
■ An employee’s performance appraisal is very much dependent upon the
perceptual process.
● Many jobs are evaluated in subjective terms.
● Subjective measures are problematic because of selective
perception, contrast effects, halo effects, and so on.
3
■ Conscientiousness
■ High self-esteem
○ Gender
■ Rumination
○ Mental Ability
○ Cultural Differences
○ Nudging
● Organizational Constraints
○ Performance Evaluation Systems
○ Reward Systems
○ Formal Regulations
○ System-Imposed Time Constraints
○ Historical Precedents
4
QUESTIONS FOR REVIEW
1. What are the factors that influence our perception?
○ The process used for organizing and interpreting the impression of senses so
that the environment is given importance is known as perception.
■ What one perceives may be different in reality
■ This can be described as an employee feels that the firm he is working
with has favorable working conditions, good job assignments, good pay
scale, excellent benefits, understanding and responsible management;
but in reality, it is very difficult to find such agreements.
■ Perception is given more importance as people trust on their perception
rather than what reality is.
○ The factors that influence perception are the perceiver, the target, and the
situation.
■ Perceiver factors include attitudes, motives, interests, experiences and
expectations.
■ Target factors include novelty, motion, sound, size, background,
proximity, and similarity.
■ Situation factors include time, work setting, and social settings.
2. What is attribution theory?
○ Attribution theory tries to explain the ways we judge people differently,
depending on the meaning we attribute to a behavior.
○ Attribution theory suggests that when we observe an individual’s behavior, we
attempt to determine whether it was internally or externally caused.
■ That determination depends largely on three factors: (1) distinctiveness,
(2) consensus, and (3) consistency.
■ It attempts to understand the people’s behaviour to interpret the behavior
of others.
3. What is the link between perception and decision making?
○ Perception is the process of interpreting the behavior of the individual.
■ It may be different from reality.
■ It is the interpretation of the individual’s sensory impression which is used
to provide meaning to the situation
○ Decision-making is the process of choosing the best among the alternatives.
○ The decision and choices of a person depends on his/her perception regarding
the alternatives.
■ Every decision requires the interpretation and evaluation of the
information or choices that is available to an individual.
■ Perception allows the user to evaluate the information related to a
person’s choice.
○ Perception is the base for decision-making
■ The person will choose based on his/her perception.
5
4. How do individual differences and organizational constraints influence decision making?
○ Individual differences influence decision making, because every person is
different from another person.
■ So decision making is also different from person to person, on the basis
of their personality, gender, mental ability, cultural differences and many
more.
○ Personality includes thinking of a person’s self-respect, ego, dedication to work
and many more.
■ Decision making is also influenced by an individual’s gender.
1. Before making any decisions, women think a lot more than men,
2. Women carefully analyze the decision once made
■ Sometimes it is good to think and analyze the decision once made, but
sometimes it can create problems
○ Decision making is very quick and accurate, if a person is intelligent and has a
high mental ability.
○ Cultural differences also affect the decision making, especially in the selection of
problems and depth of analysis of a problem,
■ Different cultures have different beliefs and those beliefs play a role in
decision making.
○ Organization constraints influence decision making by the system imposed time
constraints, performance evaluation, reward system, formal regulations, and
historical precedents.
○ Reward systems also affect decision making.
■ In reward systems, manager makes a decision has a great personal
payoff.
■ In historical precedent, past decisions affect current decision making.
■ Formal regulations include rules and regulations which constraints that
make a freedom decisions and choices from limited alternative
6
Chapter 9: Foundations of Group Behavior
Summary:
We can draw several implications from our discussion of groups. First, norms control
behavior by establishing standards of right and wrong. Second, status inequities create
frustration and can adversely influence productivity and willingness to remain with an
organization. Third, the impact of size on a group’s performance depends on the type of task.
Fourth, cohesiveness may influence a group’s level of productivity, depending on the group’s
performance-related norms. Fifth, diversity appears to have a mixed impact on group
performance, with some studies suggesting that diversity can help performance and others
suggesting the opposite. Sixth, role conflict is associated with job-induced tension and job
dissatisfaction. Groups can be carefully managed toward positive organizational outcomes and
optimal decision-making.
7
LO2) Integrating Cohesiveness and Diversity for Group Effectiveness
● Diversity: degree to which members of the group are similar to, or different from, one
another.
○ Increases group conflict, especially in the short term.
● Culturally and demographically diverse groups may perform better over time.
○ May help them be more open-minded and creative.
● Fault Lines
8
○ In a brainstorming session:
■ The group leader states the problem.
■ Members then “free-wheel” as many alternatives as they can.
■ No criticism is allowed.
■ One idea stimulates others, and group members are encouraged to “think
the unusual.”
● The nominal group technique: restricts discussion or interpersonal communication
during the decision making process.
○ Group members are all physically present, but members operate independently.
○ Permits the group to meet formally but does not restrict independent thinking, as
does the interacting group.
● Nominal groups outperform brainstorming groups.
○ Steps for a nominal group:
■ Each member independently writes down his/her ideas on the problem.
■ After this silent period, each member presents one idea to the group.
■ The ideas are discussed for clarity.
■ Each group member rank-orders the ideas.
■ The idea with the highest aggregate ranking determines the final decision.
9
QUESTIONS FOR REVIEW
1. What are the different types of groups?
a. A group is defined as two or more individuals, interdependent, and interacting,
who have come together to attain particular objectives.
b. The different types of groups include:
i. Formal groups: Formal groups constitutes the one defined by the
organization’s structure; with designated work assignments ir established
tasks.
1. In formal groups, the behavior that the team members should
engage in are specified by and aligned towards the organizational
goals.
ii. Informal groups: In contrast, an informal group is neither formally
structured nor organizationally determined.
1. Informal groups are naturally formed in the workplace that appear
in retort to the need for social contact.
10
e. Different groups enforce different requirements on people
f. Majority of these roles are compatible while some create conflicts.
g. Research indicates that people enact multiple roles, people learn roles from
stimuli around them, and that people have the capability to swap roles rapidly
when they identify that the situation and its demands noticeably require major
changes.
11
i. Understanding the status and size of the group helps the team members
improve the performance of the group.
ii. The status and size of the group defines the social interaction within a
group.
c. It helps the manager to manage the group effectively, if the group size is less.
i. The social status will motivate members to work hard in order to attain the
goals and to retain the social image.
d. Ability of the person or the capability of the group and the personal character
decides the status of the group.
i. Status and size of the group determines the performance of the groups
and determines the ability of the group.
6. How can cohesiveness and diversity support group effectiveness?
a. Group cohesiveness is the point at which the group members are attracted
towards each other and are motivated to stay in the group for the next task.
b. Group diversity is the degree to which the members of the group are similar or
different from one another.
i. It is the uniqueness of each individual
c. Cohesiveness and diversity of the group have greater impact on the productivity
of the group.
i. It affects the group’s efficiency
ii. A research states that high cohesive group is more effective and
productive than low cohesive group
d. The group that is lagging in diversity will lead to conflict within the group
members during the early stages of group formation.
i. Low cohesive group without diversity will increase conflicts between the
members.
ii. They will not be able to attain the goal efficiently.
e. The group members should take steps to make their group cohesive and diverse.
i. It will increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the group
ii. It will also increase the social status of the members. The group members
can attain the goal successfully
7. What are the strengths and weaknesses of group (versus individual) decision making?
a. Strengths of group (versus individual) decision making:
i. Access to more knowledge and information
1. Groups generate more comprehensive knowledge and
information.
2. By combining the abilities of several individuals, groups, bring in
more contribution as well as heterogeneity into the decision
process
ii. Increased diversity of views:
1. The group provides greater variety of views. This opens up the
prospect to consider more alternatives and approaches.
iii. Hamper creativity
12
1. Diversity can inflict performance even in the creative teams.
iv. Increased acceptance of solutions
1. Group decision result in increased approval of solutions.
2. Group members who have actively participated in decision making
are more likely to strongly support and influence others to accept
it.
b. Weakness of group (vs individual) decision making
i. Time consuming
1. Group decisions are time consuming because groups typically
take time to reach a solution
2. Conformity pressures
a. Conformity pressures exist.
b. The yearning by group member to be considered and
accepted as strength to the group can crush any explicit
disagreement
3. Dominance
a. The group discussion is likely to be dominated by one or a
few authoritative members.
b. If the group consists of members with low and medium
ability members, the group’s overall efficiency will suffer.
4. Ambiguous responsibility
a. Group decisions suffer from ambiguous responsibility.
b. In any individual decision, it is clear who is accountable for
the final outcomes. However, in a group decision the
accountability of any single member is weakened.
13
Chapter 10: Understanding Work Teams
Summary:
Few trends have influenced jobs as much as the massive movement of teams into
the workplace. Working on teams requires employees to cooperate with others, share
information, confront differences, and sublimate personal interests for the greater good of the
team. Understanding the distinctions between problem-solving, self-managed, cross-functional,
and virtual teams as well as multiteam systems helps determine the appropriate applications for
team-based work. Concepts such as reflexivity, team efficacy, team identity, team cohesion, and
mental models bring to light important issues relating to team context, composition, and
processes. For teams to function optimally, careful attention must be given to hiring, creating,
and rewarding team players. Still, effective organizations recognize that teams are not always
the best method for getting the work done efficiently. Careful discernment and an understanding
of organizational behavior are needed.
14
LO4) Identify the Characteristics of Effective Teams
● Exhibit 10-3 Team Effectiveness Model
● Team Processes
○ Common Plan and Purpose
■ Reflexivity
○ Specific Goals
○ Team Efficacy
○ Team Identity
○ Team Cohesion
○ Mental Models
○ Conflict Levels
15
○ Social Loafing
16
Questions for Review
17
5. Multi-team systems
c. Problem-solving teams: is a group of employees in every department who
address the problems of the department.
i. This team discusses the quality, efficiency, and other problems of the
organization and the employees.
d. Self-managed team is a group of employees who carry out the responsibilities of
former supervisors
e. Virtual team is the team in which the employees are separated by location and
they contact each other using computer technology
f. Multi-team system is a team of teams.
i. Here, a collection of two or more teams shares a superordinate goal.
g. Cross-functional team is a team that accomplishes a common task.
i. Here, the memebers of the teamaer from the same hierarchical level, but
different work areas.
h. Every process or activity of the organization depends on the performance of the
teams.
4. What conditions or context factors determine whether teams are effective?
a. The four contextual factors that are contextually related to team performance are
adequate resources of effective leadership, a climate of trust, and performance
evaluation and reward system that reflects team contributions.
b. Adequate resources
i. Teams that are part of larger organization system, and every work team is
dependent on the resources external to the group
ii. A paucity of resources directly decreases the ability of a team to perform
its job successfully and reach its goal
iii. One of the most important factors of effective work group is backing it
received from the firm which includes timely formation, proper equipment,
adequate staffing, encouragement and administrative assistance
c. Effective Leadership and Structure
i. Teams cannot function in case of ambiguity when they don’t agree upon a
common goal and allocate work accordingly.
1. Agreeing to the details of the assignment and how each member
fit together to incorporate individual skills requires leadership and
structure, either from the team members or from management
ii. Leadership is especially important to in multi-team systems, in which
diverse teams synchronize their efforts to produce a desired result
1. In this case, leaders need to endow power to the teams by
entrusting responsibility to them, and take up the role of facilitator,
to make sure that the teams work together rather than against one
another
2. Teams that institute shared leadership by efficiently entrusting it
are more effective than teams which follow the traditional
single-leader format.
18
d. A Climate of Trust
i. Members of effective team entrust each other and also their leaders
ii. Interpersonal trust within the members of the team enables cooperation,
reduces the need to monitor behavior, and bond members around the
belief that others on the team are trustworthy
iii. Team members are more likely to move ahead and take required risks
and expose liabilities when they believe they can trust others on their
team
e. Performance Evaluation and Reward Systems
i. Individual performance incentives and evaluations may interfere with the
development of high-performance teams
ii. Therefore, in addition to appraising and rewarding employees for their
individual contributions, management should alter the traditional and
individual oriented reward and assessment system to reflect team
performance and emphasize on hybrid systems that recognize individuals
for their exceptional performance and reward the entire group for positive
results.
iii. Group based appraisals, profit and gain sharing, small group incentives,
and other system changes can strengthen team effort and commitment
5. How can organizations create team players?
a. Organizations can create better team players through hiring people who exhibit
the ability of functioning well in teams, investing in training programs for team
management training for leaders, and offering team rewards and recognitions
b. Hiring team players
i. While hiring team members, the hiring manager should be sure that the
candidates can fulfill their teams’ roles as well as technical requirements
ii. Teams made up of members who like to work through difficult mental
puzzles also seem more effective in capitalizing on the multiple points of
view that arise from diversity in age and education.
c. Training: creating team players
i. Provide training to all members of the team on effectiveness of team
bonding and the importance of being a team player
ii. Training specialists conduct exercises and trainings that allow employees
to experience the satisfaction resulting from teamwork
iii. These trainings will help employees improve their problem-solving skills,
communication, negotiation, conflict-management, and coaching skills.
d. Rewarding: Providing incentives to be a good team player
i. An organization’s reward system must be designed to motivate
cooperative efforts rather than competitive ones
ii. Promotions, bonus, and other forms of recognition should be given to
individuals who work effectively as team members by training new
colleagues, sharing information, helping resolve team conflicts, and
mastering needed new skills.
19
iii. Provide intrinsic rewards such as camaraderie, that employees can
receive from team work.
6. When is work performed by individuals preferred over work by teams?
a. Individual work is more preferred than team work depending on the following
factors:
i. Complexity of the work
1. If the task is not complex and can be handled by a single person,
then there is no requirement of assembling a team to execute the
task.
a. It would waste time and resources
ii. Need for different perspectives
1. Simple tasks don’t need diverse inputs and are probably better left
to individuals
iii. Work creates common goals
1. Assess whether the work creates a common purpose or set of
objectives for the individuals in the group that is more than the
cumulative of individual goals
iv. Inter-dependency
1. DEtermine whether the members of the group are interdependent.
a. Using temas makes sense when there is interdependence
among tasks
i. The success of the task is dependent on the
success of each member, and the success of each
member on the success of other members
b. Work is preferred by individuals when the decision can be clearly made that there
are no sufficient short or long term benefits for engaging the team application.
c. The task should justify the investments of time and money for the entire team
d. In some cases, concerns of confidentiality and privacy require individual
accountability.
20