Requara. H. Wickens Fundamentals of Rail Vehicle Dynamics Guidance and Stabilite
Requara. H. Wickens Fundamentals of Rail Vehicle Dynamics Guidance and Stabilite
Stepper motors are electromagnetic incremental devices that convert electric pulses to shaft
motion (rotation). These motors rotate a specific number of degrees as a respond to each input
electric pulse. Typical types of stepper motors can rotate 2°, 2.5°, 5°, 7.5°, and 15° per input
electrical pulse. Rotor position sensors or sensor less feedback based techniques can be used to
regulate the output response according to the input reference command. Stepper motors offers
many attractive features such as:
• Available resolutions ranging from several steps up to 400 steps (or higher) per
revolution.
• Printers.
• Disk Drives.
• Machine Tools.
• Robotics.
• Tape Drives
Stepper motors are usually classified into three main categories, namely,
Fig. 1 presents the basic circuit configuration of a typical 4-phase, 2-pole, single-stack,
variable reluctance stepper motor. The stator is made of a single stack of steel laminations
with the phase windings wound around the stator poles. The rotor is made of stack of steel
laminations without any windings. The main principle of operation depends on aligning
one set only of stator and rotor poles by energizing the stator windings. Therefore, the
number of poles in the stator and rotor windings has to be different. The stator windings are
energized by a DC source in such a sequence to generate a resultant rotating air-gap field
around the rotor in steps. The rotor is made of ferromagnetic material that provides a
tendency to align the rotor axis along the direction of the resultant air-gap field. Therefore, the
rotor tracks the motion of this stepped field.
Fig. 2 illustrates the different modes of operation of the 4-phase, 2-pole, single-stack,
variable reluctance stepper motor for 45° step in the following energizing sequence A,
A+B, B, B+C, C, C+D, D, and then D+A. Then this switching sequence is repeated.
• Energizing winding A: The resultant air-gap flux will be aligned along the axis of pole A
windings. Consequently, the rotor aligns itself along the phase A axis as shown in the upper part of
Fig. 2.
• Energizing windings A and B: The resultant air-gap flux will be oriented in the midway
between pole A and pole B i.e., the resultant mmf rotated 45° in the clockwise direction.
Consequently, the rotor aligns itself with the resultant mmf (45°) as shown in the middle part of
Fig. 2.
• Energizing winding B: The resultant air-gap flux will be aligned along the axis of pole B
windings. Consequently, the rotor aligns itself along the phase B axis as shown in the lower part of
Fig. 2.
The direction of rotation can be reversed by reversing the switching sequence to be A, A+D,
D, D+C, C, C+B, B, and then B+A. Then this switching sequence is repeated.
Fig. 2 Operation modes of single-stack, 2-poles, and variable reluctance stepper motor with
45° step
Smaller steps can be obtained by using multi-pole rotor configuration such as the one
shown in Fig. 3 that rotate in an anticlockwise direction with a 15° step in the following
energizing sequence A, A+B, B, B+C, C, C+D, D, and then D+A. Then this switching
sequence is repeated.
• Energizing winding A: The resultant air-gap flux will be aligned along the axis of
pole A windings. Consequently, the rotor pole P1 aligns itself along the phase A
axis as shown in the upper part of Fig. 3.
• Energizing windings A and B: The resultant air-gap flux will be oriented in the
midway between pole A and pole B i.e., the resultant mmf rotated 45° in the
clockwise direction. In this case, the nearest rotor pole to this direction is pole P 2.
direction.
• Energizing winding B: The resultant air-gap flux will be aligned along the axis of
pole B windings. In this case, the nearest rotor pole to this direction is pole P 3.
Consequently, the rotor rotates in an anticlockwise direction to align pole P 3 with
the resultant mmf (90°). Therefore, the net rotational step in this stage is also 15° in an
anticlockwise direction.
• and so on.
The direction of rotation can be reversed by reversing the switching sequence to be A, A+D,
D, D+C, C, C+B, B, and then B+A. Then this switching sequence is repeated.
In this type, the motor is divided along its axis into a number of stacks. Each stack is
energized by a separate winding (phase) as shown in Fig. 6. These stacks are magnetically
isolated from each other. The most common type is the three-stack, three-phase motors;
however, number of stacks and phases up to seven are also available.
Fig. 6 Cross section view of a typical three-stack variable reluctance stepper motor
Fig. 7 Teeth position for a 3-phase, 4-pole, 12-teeth, three-stack, variable reluctance stepper
motor when phase a is energized
Fig. 7 also illustrates the rotational sequence of a 3-phase, 4-pole, 12-teeth, three-stack,
variable reluctance stepper motor for 10° step in a clockwise direction according to the
following energizing sequence A, B, and C. Then this switching sequence is repeated.
• Energizing phase (stack) A: when stack A winding is energized, the rotor teeth
will move to align themselves with the stator teeth is stack A as shown in Fig. 7.
• Energizing phase (stack) B: when stack B winding is then energized while stack A
winding is de-energized, the rotor teeth will move to align themselves with the
stator teeth is stack B. This will result in a clockwise rotation of the rotor by 10° as
shown in Fig. 7.
• Energizing phase (stack) C: when stack C winding is then energized while stack B
winding is de-energized, the rotor teeth will move to align themselves with the
stator teeth is stack C. This will result in another clockwise rotation of the rotor by
10°. After this stage the rotor has moved one rotor tooth pitch as illustrated by Fig.
7.
• And So on
The direction of rotation can be reversed by reversing the switching sequence. Assume that
the total number of stacks (phases) is N while the total number of teeth in each stack is x.
The tooth pitch ( τ p ) can be expressed by,
36 O
τp =
0
x
0
Δθ = 360
xN
Consequently, the number of steps per revolution (n) is given by
0
36
n= = xN
0
Δ
θ
As an example, for the motor in Fig. 7, x = 12 and N = 3. Therefore,
36 O 360 0
τ p= 0
0 = = 30
12
x
0 0
Δ θ = 360 360 0
xN = = 10
12 *3
0
n = 360 = 36
1
0
2.2.4. Permanent Magnet Stepper Motors
Permanent magnet (PM) stepper motors are similar in construction to that of single-stack;
variable reluctance stepper motors except that the rotor is made of permanent magnet. Fig.
8 presents the circuit configuration and different operation modes for a 2-phase, permanent
magnet stepper motor that rotate in an anticlockwise direction with a 90° step. Table 2 and
Fig. 9 present each phase switching sequence for one revolution of the rotor. Reversing the
switching sequence will result in reversing the direction of rotation.
PM stepper motors offer many features compared to variable reluctance type such as
• Higher inertia and consequently lower acceleration (deceleration) rates.
• Maximum step pulse rate is 300 pulses per second compared to 1200 pulses per
second for variable reluctance stepper motors.
• Larger step sizes, ranging from 30° to 90° compared to step sizes as low as 1.8° for
variable reluctance stepper motors.
• Generate higher torque per ampere of stator currents than variable reluctance
stepper motors.
Table 2 Phase switching sequence: “1”, “-1” and “0” corresponds to positive, negative, and zero
phase voltage (currents), respectively
Hybrid stepper motors have similar stators‟ construction to that of variable reluctance
stepper motors. However, their rotors constructions combine both variable reluctance and
permanent magnet constructions. The rotors are made of an axial permanent magnet at the
middle and two identical stacks of soft iron poles at the outer ends attached to the north and
south poles of the permanent magnet. The rotor poles connected to the north pole of the
permanent magnet forms North Pole, while the other forms the south poles as shown in Fig.
10. This figure also presents two different views of these motors types. Fig. 11 presents a
complete cross section view of 4-pole stator and 5-pole rotor hybrid stepper
motor while Fig. 12 presents the different components of standard hybrid stepper motor.
These types of motors have similar operation modes as the permanent magnet types.
Moreover, they are characterized by smaller step sizes but they are very expensive
compared to variable reluctance stepper motors.
Fig. 10 Construction of 4-pole stator and 5-pole rotor hybrid stepper motor
Fig. 11 Cross section view of 4-pole stator and 5-pole rotor hybrid stepper motor
Working Principle of Hybrid Motors
Consider a 2-phase, 4-poles stepper motor as shown in Fig. 13. When energizing phase B,
the rotor starts to rotate in an anticlockwise direction to align itself with pole 2. It is
supposed theoretically, that the rotor will come to rest once its axis is aligned with pole 2
axis. However, practically, due to the inertia of the rotor, the rotor will overshot and pass
the central line of pole 2. After that, the magnetic field generated from pole 2 pulls the rotor
in the opposite direction. The rotor will swing around the central line of pole 2 until finally
it comes to rest after being aligned. Fig. 14 a presents the variation of the rotor position and
the rotor speed as a result of energizing phase B.
Fig. 14 b Effect of viscous damping on rotor angular speed and angular position
2.3. Modes of Operation
There are two main modes of operation of stepper motors that can be summarized as follows:
Start-Stop Mode: In this mode the motor is controlled to settle down (rest) after each step
before advancing to the next step. The rotational speed will be in the form of pulses that drops
to zero at the end each step while the rotor position will be in the form of pulses also but with
an increasing steady state value with time as shown in Fig. 15. This mode is sometimes
referred to by the start without error mode. A maximum permissible stepping rate is required
for this mode of operation; otherwise, the motor will not be able to track the control current
pulses and the step will be lost. This minimum rate depends on the motor inertia and the
loading condition. Fig. 16 presents the torque speed (steps per second, where each step
• Curve 1: Low inertia. If the motor drives a load of 1.4 N.m then the maximum
permissible pulse rate is 500 steps per second.
• Curve 2: Higher inertia. If the motor drives a load of 1.4 N.m then the maximum
permissible pulse rate is 400 steps per second.
Fig. 15 Rotor angular speed and angular position for different operating modes
Slewing Mode: In this mode the motor is controlled to rotate at a constant uniform speed
without stopping at the end of each step and the rotor position varies linearly with time as
shown in Fig. 15. The torque speed characteristic of this mode will not be affected by the
system inertia because of the constant speed. Moreover, for a specific pulse rate (500 steps per
second) this mode allows the motor to drive higher torque load as in the start-stop mode as
shown in Fig. 16.
Where Vs is the DC source voltage in V, I is the phase winding rated current in A,Rph is the
phase winding resistance in Ω , and Rext is the external resistance connected in series to the
phase winding in Ω .
The phase winding inductance is very large and consequently results in slow rate of
building the phase winding current that might result in unsatisfactory operation of the
stepper motor at high stepping rates. Therefore, the external resistance is connected in
series with the phase winding to reduce the time constant. The net ON Mode circuit time
constant will be very large and can be expressed by,
L ph
τ ON =
(R +R )
ph ext
OFF Mode: In this mode, the base drive current of the transistor is removed and the
switch is turned OFF and acts as an open circuit. The phase winding current will
continue to flow through the freewheeling path formed by the freewheeling diode
(Df) and the freewheeling resistance (Rf). The maximum OFF state voltage appears
across the transistor (switch) (VCE (max)) can be expressed by,
VCE (max) = Vs + I Rf
During this mode of operation, phase current decays in the OFF mode circuit with a net
OFF Mode circuit time constant that can be expressed by,
L ph
τ OFF =
(R +R +R )
ph ext f
The energy stored in the phase inductance during the ON mode is dissipated in the OFF
mode circuit resistances during the switch turn OFF period.
Fig. 17 Uni-polar drive circuit for three-phase variable reluctance stepper motor
Fig. 18 presents a schematic diagram for one phase of a bi-polar drive circuit. This circuit is
suitable for permanent magnet or hybrid stepper motors. Each phase winding of the motor is
controlled by a separate drive circuit with a transistor as its controllable power switch. All drive
circuits are energized by the same DC source. Each two transistors (power switches) of each
phase winding are turned ON simultaneously. Two modes of operation occur as follows:
T1 and T2 are in the On Mode: This is done by injecting sufficiently high base
current through their bases simultaneously. Each transistor acts ideally like a short
circuit. Consequently, the current will flow as indicated by the solid line in Fig. 18.
The inductor is then energized.
D3 and D4 are in the On Mode: This mode follows the switching OFF of T1 and T2.
In this mode, the phase winding current cannot change its direction or decay to zero
instantaneously after turning OFF of T1 and T2 because of the phase winding
inductances. Thus the current continue to flow through of D3 and D4 as indicated by
the dotted line in Fig. 18. The inductor discharges and the energy is returned back to the
DC source.
Fig. 18 One phase of a Bi-polar drive circuit for permanent magnet or hybrid stepper motors
A reverse flow of current in the phase windings and hence a reverse direction of rotation of
the motor can be achieved by activating T 3 and T4. When T 3 and T4 are turned OFF the
freewheeling path will provided through D1 and D2. The bi-polar circuit is characterized by,
Higher efficiency than the uni-polar drive circuit as part of the stored energy in the
phase winding returns back to the DC source during the power switches turn OFF
mode.
Fast decaying of the freewheeling current as the inductor discharge through the
phase winding resistance, phase external resistance and the DC source.
No freewheeling resistance is required.
More power switches (devices) than the uni-polar drive circuit.
More expensive than the uni-polar drive circuit.
Most of the large stepper motors types (> 1 kW) are driven by the bi-polar drive
circuit including variable reluctance types.
3.Discuss the various switching sequence of stepper motor
Consider the 4-pole hybrid stepper motor shown in Fig. 11. The motor is drived by a Bi-
polar drive circuit where the power switches are represented by contacts as illustrated by
Fig. 19. Four contacts are used with each coil set of the motor (A1 and A2) and (B1 and
B2). The two coil sets are energized by the same DC source. There are three main
switching techniques for controlling these contacts namely; Wave Switching, Normal
Switching, and Half-Step Switching.
step and the generated flux rotates by 90° per step. Table 3 presents the switching
sequence for clockwise rotation. The corresponding coils‟ current pulses and the
Normal Switching Sequence: In this technique, the two sets of coils are switches
each step. The generated flux also rotates by 90° per step; however, it is oriented in
the midway between the stator‟s poles. Table 4 presents the switching sequence for
clockwise rotation. The corresponding coils‟ current pulses and the generated fluxes
are shown in Fig. 21. This technique is characterized by slightly greater torque than
the wave switching sequence.
Table 4 Normal switching sequence for clockwise rotation
Fig. 21 Current pulses and generated fluxes for normal switching sequence
Half-Step Switching Sequence: In this technique, both the wave and the normal
switching sequence are combined. The generated flux also rotates by 45° per step.
Table 5 presents the switching sequence for clockwise rotation. The corresponding
coils‟ current pulses and the generated fluxes are shown in Fig. 22. This technique
is characterized by better resolution of position and reduction in the resonance
problem.
Table 5 Half-step switching sequence for clockwise rotation
Fig. 22 Current pulses and generated fluxes for half-step switching sequence
L 3L
constant ( τ O = R ) i.e. time to reach rated current is 3 xLo = . The load current
R
continue to flow with its rated value (i = I) until the transistor is switched OFF
at t = Tp
Mode 2 (Transistor is OFF): The transistor behaves as open circuit. The load
current (I = i2) will continue to circuit in the freewheeling circuit path as shown in
Fig. 23-c. This current starts to decay until it reaches zero in approximately 3 times
3L
the circuit time constant i.e. time to decay to zero is also 3 xLo =
R
This practical pulse shape is characterized by:
Fig. 24 Circuits to modify the rise and fall time of the current pulse and the associated current
Bi-level Drive: In this method, two controllable switches (transistors) and two
diodes are used in each phase as shown in Fig. 25-a. Moreover, an additional DC
source (Eext) with higher magnitude than the original source (E) is also used. This
circuit has three modes of operation that can be explained briefly, with numerical
values, as follows:
Q1 and Q2 are switched ON: This is represented by the equivalent circuit
shown in Fig. 25-b. The transistors behave as short circuits.
The load (motor‟s phase) current starts to flow with an increasing magnitude until it
reaches its rated value of,
E 3
I=
R 0 3 = 10 A
=
Q1 and Q2 are switched OFF: The current will remain flowing in the phase
winding circuit until switch Q2 is turned OFF. Both switches are now in their OFF
state and behave as open circuits. In this case the two diodes D1 and D2 will conduct
and the current flows as shown in Fig. 25-e.
Assume that the switch Q2 is turned OFF after 5 ms from the instant at which the current
reached its rated value. The circuit time constant is given by,
L 2 4 x 10−3
τ O=
R= = 8 ms
03
Fig. 25 Bi-level drive circuits to modify the rise and fall time of the current pulse and the associated
current
Therefore the current approximately decreases linearly with an decreasing rate (Rate2) as
shown in Fig. 25-f that can be expressed by,
E 57
est
R 03
Rate 2 = τ O = 0 008 = 23 ,750 A / sec
The time required for the current to decay to zero (t2) is therefore approximated to,
I 10
t2 = Rate 2 = 23 = 0 42 ms
,750
Once the current reaches zero, switch Q1 is switched ON to force the phase current to
remain zero until the next pulse.
Chopper Drive Circuit
This drive circuit - illustrated in its unipolar form in Fig.26 - has a high supply voltage
which is applied to the phase winding whenever the current falls below its rated value. If the
phase excitation signal is present, the base drive for transistor T2 is controlled by the voltage
Vc dropped across the small resistance Rc by the winding current. At the beginning of the
excitation interval the transistor T1 is switched on and the base drive to T2 is enabled. As
the phase current is initially zero there is no voltage across Vc and the transistor T2 is switched
on. The full supply voltage is therefore applied to the phase winding, as shown in the timing
diagram, Fig.27.
The phase current rises rapidly until it slightly exceeds its rated value (I). Consequently the
control voltage is Rc I+e and this is sufficient to switch off transistor T2. There is now no
voltage applied to the phase winding and the current decays around a path which includes
T1, Rc and diode D1. This current path has a small resistance and no opposing voltage, so
the decay of current is relatively slow. As the resistance Rc is still included in the circuit the
winding current can be monitored and when the control voltage has fallen to R c I-e the
transistor T2 is switched on again. The full supply voltage is applied to the winding and the
current is rapidly boosted to slightly above rated. This cycle is repeated throughout the
excitation time, with the winding current maintained near its rated value by an 'on-off'
closed-loop control.
At the end of the excitation interval both transistors are switched off and the winding
current freewheels via diodes D1 and D2. The current is now opposed by the supply
voltage and is rapidly forced to zero. A high proportion of the energy stored in the winding
inductance at turn-off is returned to the supply and therefore the system has a high
efficiency.
The chopper drive incorporates more sophisticated control circuitry, e.g. the T2
base drive requires a Schmitt triggering of the control voltage V c to produce the transition
levels. If these levels are not well-separated the transistor T2 switches on and off at a very
high frequency, causing interference with adjacent equipment and additional iron losses in
the motor. However the chopper drive does have the advantage that the available supply
voltage is fully utilized, enabling operation over the widest possible speed range, and the
power losses in forcing resistors are eliminated, giving a good system efficiency.
4.Explain the Characteristics of Stepper motor
Static Characteristics
The characteristics relating to stationary motors are called static characteristics.
\
Fig.28 T/θcharacteristics
T/θcharacteristics
The stepping motor is first kept stationary at a rest (equilibrium) position by supplying a
current in a specified mode of excitation, say, single-phase or two phase excitation. If an
external torque is applied to the shaft, an angular displacement will occur. The relation
between the external torque and the displacement may be plotted as in Fig.28. This curve is
conventionally called the T/characteristic curve, and the maximum of static torque is
termed the 'holding torque', which occurs at θ=θM in Fig.28. At displacements larger than
θM, the static torque does not act in a direction towards the original equilibrium position,
but in the opposing direction towards the next equilibrium position. The holding torque is
rigorously defined as 'the maximum static torque that can be applied to the shaft of an
excited motor without causing continuous motion'. The angle at which the holding torque is
produced is not always separated from the equilibrium point by one step angle.
T/I characteristics
The holding torque increases with current, and this relation is conventionally
referred to as T/I characteristics. Fig.29 compares the T/I characteristics of a typical hybrid motor
with those of a variable-reluctance motor, the step angle of both being 1.8º. The maximum
static torque appearing in the hybrid motor with no current is the detent torque, which is
defined as the maximum static torque that can be applied to the shaft of an unexcited motor
without causing continuous rotation.
Fig.29 Examples of T/I characteristics: (a) a 1.8ºfour phase variable reluctance motor; and
(b) a 1.8º four phase hybrid motor.
Dynamic Characteristics
Clock State R 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
To rotate a motor into clockwise direction, the excitation sequence is
for counter clockwise rotation the excitation sequence is
2) Four-phase motor
Clock State R 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
Phase 4
Half-Step mode
Clock State R 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Phase 1 (S1)
Phase 2 (S2)
Phase 3 (S3)
Phase 4 (S4)
Phase 5 (S5)
Phase 6 (S6)
Clock State R 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
------- (1)
---------- (2)
Where
--------- (3)
Substitute in (1)
--------- (4)
--------- (5)
In the above equation if viscous friction constant is neglected the equation will be linear
equation, the corresponding analysis is a linear analysis. If the damping co-efficient is also
considered the corresponding acceleration will be non-linear and the equation will be a
nonlinear which given rise to non-linear analysis.
Linear acceleration on Linear Analysis:
If the damping co-efficient is neglected D=0 .The expression for motor torque becomes
---------- (6)
------------- (7)
----------- (8)
Divide by we get
And
---------- (10)
Divide by we get
Or
-------------- (11)
Here
y=f, x=t, P=D/J
----------- (13)
----------- (14)
-------------- (15)
------------------- (16)
------------ (17)
Divide by
The above equation is a nonlinear exponential equation which gives rise to nonlinear
acceleration of the rotor of the motor.
6.Explain the THEORY OF TORQUE PREDICTION
Mechanism of static torque production in a VR Motor
Basic field theory approach of torque production depends on
• Magnetic energy and Co-energy
• Ideal case of torque production, in which stator and rotor cores have infinite
permeability
• Cores when subjected to magnetic saturation
The case of infinitely permeable cores
To analysis the situation of an iron piece being drawn into a magnetic field created by
electromagnet as shown in figure below.
A current I is flowing in the coil of „n‟ turns to yield magnetic flux and force „f‟ is acting on the
iron piece in the x-direction. The iron piece may be regarded as a tooth of the rotor of a stepping
motor, and the electromagnet corresponds to a pair of teeth of the stator in a VR motor.
Ampere‟s circuit law along the closed loop is expressed as
------------- (1)
= ---------- (2)
Where
= Magnetic field intensity in airgaps
---------- (3)
( ) ----------- (4)
---------- (6)
Now let as assume that there is an incremental displacement of the tooth during a time
interval then the incremental flux linkage, is given by
----------- (7)
The emf induced in the coils by change in flux linkage is given by,
--------- (8)
The minus sign in the equation implies that the direction of the emf is opposing the current.
Since the current I is supplied by the power source for the time interval overcoming the
counter-emf, the work (energy) done by the source is
The coil resistance is assumed to be zero, to simplify the analysis using (4), is
expressed in terms of as follows
The work done by the source is converted partly to mechanical work, and the rest is
spent in increasing the magnetic field energy in the gaps. The increase in the gap field
energy is given by
From the observations of the equations (10) & (11) we find that a half of is
converted into magnetic energy in the airgaps, consequently we are allowed to say that the
other half of is converted into mechanical work. Since the mechanical work is the force
„f‟ multiplied by the displacement , we obtain
--------- (12)
Attention must, however, be paid to the assumption that the current I is kept constant during
the displacement. Hence (16) must be described in the rigorous from
--------------- (2)
If the iron piece undergoes a displacement during the time interval , the inductance L
will increase by . The emf induced in the coil is
If the power supply is a current source and provides a current I during displacement (3)
become
Since the voltage at the source is equal but opposite to the counter emf of equation (4), the
work done by the source on the circuit is,
From comparison of equations (5) and (6) it is seen that half of the work done on the circuit by
the source is converted into mechanical energy. Hence it is supposed that the other half is
converted to mechanical work