Dixit
Dixit
* 1
88th Annual Meeting
International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on
Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
PRESENTATION OVERVIEW
1. INTRODUCTION
The Dam industry has contributed significantly towards meeting the growing water and power demand
of the human economic development , yet world over and specially in developing country like India is
facing increasing pressure on water resources due to population growth, urbanization and creeping
effect of climate change.
Ideal sites for building Dams have by and large been exploited in India and to meet the growing water
resources needs of the nation, challenging sites for construction of Dams are being explored. In spite of
the presence of adverse geological features under varied geological set-up, numerous dams have been
constructed world over including the Himalayas for the purpose of irrigation, hydel power-generation,
flood moderation etc.
Shahpurkandi Dam Project, a water infrastructure project across river Ravi in India is a National Project
of Importance declared by Govt. of India, on completion will deliver significantly to the sustainable
growth of Agriculture, Water supply and power needs of the state of Punjab and J&K, India in addition
to generating 206MW of Hydropower further helping in efficient management of significant area under
Upper Bari Doab Canal system, one of the oldest canal systems in India.
1. INTRODUCTION- cont’d
ICOLD Bulletin 61, Dam Design Criteria, defines two objectives for dam safety decision making stated in
terms of philosophy. The philosophy of design criteria, stated in terms of two basic criteria is that
the objective is to create a “structural form together with the foundation and environment [that]
will, most economically:
i. Perform satisfactorily its function without appreciable deterioration during the conditions expected
normally to occur in the life of the structure and,
ii. Will not fail catastrophically during the most unlikely but possible conditions (extreme conditions)
which may be imposed.”
The Shahpurkandi Dam, a major component of India’s national important water infrastructure project
conceived for the sustainable growth of agriculture, water supply and power needs of the state of
Punjab and J&K, India, is the first concrete gravity dam more than 50m high to be founded on
boulder bed foundation. No other high concrete dam in the world has so far been founded on
boulder bed foundations [refer figure 1]. The Dam is designed consistent with the ICOLD Bulletin
stated Dam design criteria.
Fig.3
12
April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
Results of numerical simulations show that floor thickness computed based on FEM works out less than that
calculated from Khosla theory except near the downstream cut off.
April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India 14
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
Fig.8 Stress distribution in Breast wall for Vertical Reinforcement for Load Case E with Earthquake force
acting from U/S to D/S
April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India 23
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
3. APPLIED MODELS, PARAMETER AND ANALYSIS - cont’d
3.1 FEM Models, Input Parameter and Analysis - 3.1.4 Results of analysis & Discussion
▪ It can be seen that the junction zone
of pier and spillway experience
tensile stresses and hence need to
be steel reinforced as vertical and
horizontal anchorages which has
been evaluated for the tension area.
Anchorages are extended at least up
to the zero tensile contours obtained
from the model. Breast wall also has
been reinforced in accordance with
stress distribution.
Fig.9 Stress distribution in spillway for horizontal anchorages for Load Case E with Earthquake in –Z direction
April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India 24
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
3. APPLIED MODELS, PARAMETER AND ANALYSIS - cont’d
3.1 FEM Models, Input Parameter and Analysis - 3.1.4 Results of analysis & Discussion
▪ It can be seen that the junction zone
of pier and spillway experience
tensile stresses and hence need to
be steel reinforced as vertical and
horizontal anchorages which has
been evaluated for the tension area.
Anchorages are extended at least up
to the zero tensile contours obtained
from the model. Breast wall also has
been reinforced in accordance with
stress distribution.
Fig.10 Stress distribution in spillway for horizontal anchorages for Load Case E with Earthquake in + Z direction
April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India 25
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
3. APPLIED MODELS, PARAMETER AND ANALYSIS - cont’d
3.1 FEM Models, Input Parameter and Analysis - 3.1.5 Seepage Analysis using Finite Element
simulation
▪ Finite element model was created from the dam geometry. The upstream and downstream water head
was modeled using hydraulic boundary conditions.
▪ Seepage analysis using commercial software SEEP/W has been carried out to observe the effect of
upstream clay blanket on exit gradient and uplift pressure distribution over the foundation to estimate the
floor thickness required with a parametric study of the effect of conductivity on uplift pressure.
▪ The hydraulic conductivity of the layered foundation has been idealized based on site specific
investigation into four layers namely layer 1 as RBM (River Born Material) in terms of 1000 lugeon, second
layer as boulder bed with permeability values of 20 lugeon third layer 12 lugeon and fourth deep
foundation layer with 10 lugeon.
Based on available geological information, the seepage analysis has been performed on possible three
cases as described above simulated as per the hydro-geology of the foundation, so as to cater to the
critical conditions for uplift and exit gradient. Calculations have been done for uplift pressure using both
FEM (Finite Element Analysis) analysis and Khosla theory. Results of calculations show that floor
thickness by FEM is comparable to that calculated from Khosla theory except near the downstream cut
off. April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India 26
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
3. APPLIED MODELS, PARAMETER AND ANALYSIS - cont’d
3.1 FEM Models, Input Parameter and Analysis - 3.1.5 Seepage Analysis using Finite Element
simulation
Fig. 11 Flow net Diagram for Case 1 type : Simulates situations
of entire Dam being founded on higher permeable foundation
Fig. 12 Case 2 type foundation Strata- Dam founded on boulder bed of low permeability
Fig. 13 Flow net Diagram for Case 2 type foundation (Drains Inoperative)
April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India 29
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
3. APPLIED MODELS, PARAMETER AND ANALYSIS - cont’d
3.1 FEM Models, Input Parameter and Analysis - 3.1.5 Seepage Analysis using Finite Element
simulation
Fig. 14 Case 3 type foundation Strata – Dam founded on medium permeable foundation
Fig. 15 Flow net Diagram for Case 3 type foundation (Drains Inoperative)-Dam founded on medium
permeable foundation April 4th – 10th 2020, New Delhi, India 31
88th Annual Meeting International Commission on Large Dams
&
Symposium on Sustainable Development of Dams and River Basins
3. APPLIED MODELS, PARAMETER AND ANALYSIS - cont’d
3.1 FEM Models, Input Parameter and Analysis
3.1.5 Seepage Analysis using Finite Element simulation - Comparison of floor thickness using FEM Analysis
with Khosla’s Theory
S
Distance from d/s cut off Floor Level of
.
Floor thickness using Khosla Floor thickness using
N
o
towards upstream Barrage Theory after accounting for Seep/W after accounting
. ‘m’ weight of water for weight of water
‘m’ ‘m’
4. CONCLUSIONS
The design of the more than 50m high concrete gravity dam on boulder foundation, discussed in this paper
is unique in following aspects:
a) This is the first high concrete dam in the world to be founded on boulder bed foundation.
b) Numerical simulation tools are of great help in iterative design of Dam while modeling the site specific
in-put parameters which otherwise incur greater approximations in manual computations.
c) FEM analysis of the seepage flow through the foundation has been carried out in addition to the
conventional Khosla’s method and Lane’s weighted creep theory further cross checked by Goyal’s
simplified analytical method to determine seepage uplift pressure on the Dam structure and the exit
gradient.
d) FEM analysis of stress and strains in the concrete dam and in the foundation material has been carried
out considering their material elastic properties and found that the stresses and strains in the concrete
structure remain within the permissible limits under all conditions of loading.