All Your Yesterdays Extraordinary Visions of Extinct Life From A New Generation of Palaeoartists - C. M. Kosemen PDF
All Your Yesterdays Extraordinary Visions of Extinct Life From A New Generation of Palaeoartists - C. M. Kosemen PDF
co
All Your
Yesterdays
Extraordinary Visions of Extinct Life
from a New Generation of Palaeoartists
Featuring Art by
Artists of the
All Your Yesterdays Contest
4
The second reason for making this collection into a book
was the criticism we received for the original All Yesterdays.
It was found be too short by some reviewers. We felt that
we owed our fans a lengthier foray into the world of All
Yesterdays.
Right,
The cover of the original All Yesterdays volume.
5
On All Your Yesterdays seeking financial gain. It’s probably best here that we don’t
get into the whole issue of how palaeoartists (and, indeed,
by Darren Naish artists in general) can make a living from their work (for
the record, the deal isn’t any different for writers and some
scientists, either). The point worth making here is that the
When C. M. “Memo” Kosemen told me and John of his internet has changed everything: long gone are the days
where an artist had to strive to get work published in a
plans to invite people to send in their own All Yesterdays
style illustrations for an All Yesterdays-themed competition, mainstream published outlet (like a magazine or book) be-
I thought it was a tremendously bad idea. I expected a few, fore their work was noticed or considered worthy. While –
poor to mediocre bits of art that would most likely be silly given the hardships – we wouldn’t necessarily recommend
and outlandishly speculative. How wrong and stupid I that anyone try to get into palaeoart or even writing as a
was. The actual results – included in the volume you have possible career path, we sincerely hope that our promotion
in front of you now – are nothing short of spectacular; I’m of the work included here helps its creators in some way.
blown away by the quantity and quality of the work the in-
vitation attracted. Those interested in palaeoart – wherever
they find themselves in the world of science and art – will,
I think, relish this book and the quality of its illustrations.
Already I can’t stop thinking about some of my favourite
images and I’m secretly afraid that some of them will stay
in my mind whenever I look at, or think about, the crea-
tures concerned. The project that Memo decided to title All
Your Yesterdays has, in short, been an outstanding success.
All Your Yesterdays is a thing of great beauty.
6
Does the world need more speculation in palaeoart? about its living relatives; and we should try to incorporate
It’s complicated whatever data we have on environments, climates and the
local vegetation. The scientific palaeoart that I and many
Are we wise in encouraging people to speculate when it of my colleagues would consider ‘good’ ticks all of these
comes to palaeoart? This is a complex subject. Scientists boxes (though, at the risk of sounding like a stuck record, I
tend to think that palaeoart ‘belongs’ in some way to will repeat a point I often have; that some of the palaeontol-
Science, and that people who produce reconstructions of ogists who advise palaeoartists aren’t aware of the required
extinct animals can only do so when they portray ancient technical data, or honestly don’t care about the way ancient
animals and environments in rigorously accurate fashion, animals are depicted. These two problems explain the
paying attention to the most up-to-date knowledge. Scien- many terrible illustrations we still see in some mainstream
tifically rigorous art of this sort certainly has its place: we books).
would expect to see it, for example, accompanying a press
release on a newly announced fossil animal, or adjacent to However, when it comes to soft tissue anatomy and behav-
a fossil specimen in a museum (for palaeoart of this sort iour, many of the cherished ideas and themes of conven-
we very much recommend William Stout’s 2009 Prehistoric tional palaeoart are not always obviously less speculative
Life Murals and Steve White’s 2012 Dinosaur Art: the World’s than the sorts of images we explored in All Yesterdays: they
Greatest Paleoart). However, the fact that palaeoart combines frequently represent historical tropes that were arrived
an element of artistry and speculation – be honest, even the at by accident, they represent assumptions and conven-
most rigorous, most conservative piece of palaeoart still tions, and they are even, arguably, reflective of cultural
involves an amount of speculation – means that it is some- and societal expectations. Sure, there are some illustra-
times unclear where the ‘facts’ end and the speculations tions in All Yesterdays that might be a tad unlikely (exam-
begin. Remember that animals are often shown eating, ple: a stegosaur with a giant flexible penis, a plesiosaur
standing or resting in certain postures, frequenting specific that camouflages itself by lying on the seafloor), but they
environments, and are decorated in a given livery. Those aren’t any that are obviously more unlikely than many of
are speculations, and even when they appear conservative, the other illustrations that have been endorsed elsewhere
they aren’t necessarily correct or worthy. (for example, stegosaurs with hyper-mobile plates, skim-
feeding pterosaurs, ceratopsians that form defensive circles,
One of the criticisms levelled at All Yesterdays is that the theropods that roar at their prey, and so on).
entire project seemingly made it ok for people to speculate
away and do whatever the hell they liked, evidence, con- In short, speculation in palaeoart should be seen as a slid-
servatism and critical thinking be damned. By inviting peo- ing scale. At which point does a speculation render itself
ple to speculate away and produce even more artwork of too extreme? And is it even possible to reach said extreme
the same sort, maybe we’re exacerbating things, arguably given the ridiculous soft tissue structures and absurd
opening the floodgates to an endless torrent of evidence- behaviours present in the modern world? It is, in fact,
free arm-waving. surprisingly difficult to come up with a speculative piece
of palaeoart that is unconditionally ridiculous (at least, so
There are several responses that need to be made to this long as the basic rules of anatomy, biology and physics
claim. As we tried to make clear in All Yesterdays (look at p. are applied, as they are in science-based reconstructions).
10 in the Introduction), scientific reconstructions of fossil Critics and detractors would do well to remember this
animals should indeed incorporate whatever hard data we when criticising speculative palaeoart, especially when the
have on ancient animals and their environments (Conway art concerned is clearly labelled – as it is – as an exercise in
et al. 2012). We typically have detailed information on the speculation. Remember that, if we’ve learnt anything about
bony anatomy and thus the proportions and basic shape living animals and about palaeobiology, it’s that things are
of a given animal, for example; we can infer a lot about more complex, stranger, and more wonderful than we have
its musculature and integument based on what we know typically assumed.
7
It should also be accepted that depictions of ancient ani- References:
mals do not ‘belong’ wholly to science. Images of living
animals are frequently incorporated into abstract, fantasti- Conway, J., Kosemen, C. M. & Naish, D. 2012. All Yesterdays: Unique and
Speculative Views of Dinosaurs and Other Prehistoric Animals. Irregular
cal and surrealist works of art: nobody ever said that every Books.
image of an animal, ever, has to be an anatomically correct
study that faithfully depicts the creature in its natural envi- Stout, W. 2009. Prehistoric Life Murals. Flesk, Santa Cruz.
ronment. Art depicting extinct animals can obviously play
White, S. 2012. Dinosaur Art: the World’s Greatest Paleoart. Titan Books,
the same game. Speculative, fun, and even deliberately London.
‘wrong’ depictions of extinct animals are therefore ‘al-
lowed’ in cases where the artist is not claiming to produce a
rigorous scientific reconstruction. Some of the art included
here can be seen in this vein. It is not necessarily offered
as a scientific bit of palaeoart, but as a stylized image that
features a fossil animal.
8
9
All Your
Yesterdays
“Leptoceratops,”
artwork by Vitaly Melnik
Alessio Arena
Displaying Prenocephale and
Compsognathus at Play
Alessio Arena’s deceptively simple artwork shows dino-
saurs as we rarely see them; as small, fuzzy animals one
might call “cute.” Beyond this, his dinosaurs also engage
in complicated behaviors and interactions that are usually
reserved for more “complicated” animals such as mammals
and birds.
12
13
Alessio Ciaffi
Cancer
Disease, not predation, kills the majority of animals in real
life, but it is almost never represented in artwork, let alone
palaeoart. Italian artist Alessio Ciaffi highlights the grim
reality of disease with this poignant drawing of a female
Deinonychus infected with facial tumors.
14
15
Alessio Ciaffi
Collaborative Camouflage by The
Trilobite Palaeolenus
It seems that dinosaurs and other mesozoic reptiles are the
stars of palaeoart in the public mind. Prehistoric mammals
and amphibians are only slightly less-commonly represent-
ed in artwork, and invertebrates, barring some spectacular
forms such as gigantic sea scorpions, usually come the last
when it comes to artistic popularity. This is a pity, because
fossil invertebrates, such as the ancient trilobites shown
here, come in a great diversity of interesting forms.
16
17
Alvaro Rozalen
Archaeopteryx and Ctenochasma
Talented palaeoartist Alvaro Rozalen offers us a glimpse
of a time in Earth’s past when two different lineages, the
pterosaurs and the newly-evolved birds, co-existed in the
planet’s skies. This scene depicts an Archaeopteryx, famous-
ly known as the “first bird,” (actually just a pretty ordinary
feathered theropod dinosaur which just happened to be
discovered the first,) looking up at a flock of Ctenochasma
pterosaurs flying in a V formation, much like migrating
geese or other large birds today.
1 Butler, Richard J.; Barrett, Paul M.; Nowbath, Stephen and Upchurch,
Paul (2009). “Estimating the effects of sampling biases on pterosaur diversity
patterns: implications for hypotheses of bird/pterosaur competitive replacement”.
Paleobiology 35 (3): 432–446. doi:10.1666/0094-8373-35.3.432.
18
19
Alvaro Rozalen
Shellfish-Eating Citipati
Oviraptorosaurs were a group of extremely bird-like dino-
saurs known for their bizarre head crests and extraordinary
mouth structure. Most animals in this group had mouths
that were devoid of all teeth, except for two spike-like pro-
tuberances on the mouth roof.
20
21
Alvaro Rozalen
A Parrot-Like Oviraptorosaur
Continuing the speculation on oviraptorosaur skulls and
diet, Alvaro Rozalen here reconstructs an oviraptorosaur
as a fruit-eating animal after observing the similarities of
the their beaks and those of parrots. Shellfish, hard fruits,
bones have all been suggested as parts of the oviraptoro-
saur diet. Perhaps these strange animals ate a bit of every-
thing.
22
23
Alvaro Rozalen
Epidexipteryx
Preserved with elongated, ribbon-like structures adorning
its tail, Epidexipteryx is one of the most unusual feathered
dinosaur discoveries of the past decade. 1 It is also notewor-
thy in having very large eyes and apparently featherless
arms, whereas most dinosaur fossils preserved with integu-
ment bear long feathers on their forelimbs. This could be an
artifact of preservation, or it could be a specialized adapta-
tion, especially if one considers that related species such as
Scansoriopteryx and Epidendrosaurus both have extremely
long fingers, which may have been used in probing trees
for insect larvae and other food items.
24
25
Alvaro Rozalen
Troodon: Young Hunters
If dinosaurs were as similar to birds as fossils show them to
be, this similarity may have extended to their development
and the care of their offspring too. 1 Certainly, the more
bird-like dinosaurs may have taken extensive care of their
young. This could have been especially true for bird-like
dinosaurs with large brains, such as Troodonts. Usually
hailed as the smartest dinosaurs, these animals may have
had complicated behaviors and elaborate social displays.
Such advanced cognitive skills would have necessitated a
relatively long period of infancy and learning.
26
27
Andrea Gassler
A Scansoriopterygid with Wings
Believe it or not, this bat-like creature is actually a specula-
tive reconstruction of a long-fingered scansoriopterygid
dinosaur, related to the owl-like Epidexipteryx shown in the
previous pages.
28
29
Andrew Dutt
Bones Away
One of the strangest flying reptiles, or pterosaurs, Dsun-
garipterus is famous for its extraordinary skull, which
combines an upturned, tweezer-like tip with tough, heavy
dentition. This odd morphology was possibly used for
consuming durable prey items, possibly shellfish. Here,
however, the New York-based palaeoartist Andrew Dutt
considers a different feeding strategy for this extraordinary
pterosaur;
“So what does a flying reptile with crushing jaws living in a ter-
restrial environment sustain itself with? Surely Dsungaripterus
wouldn’t pass on small terrestrial vertebrates if it came across
them, but it probably put those knobbly teeth and strong jaws (for
a pterosaur) to good use. Its beak could have probed into carcasses
and with its jaws it could have crushed bones to obtain nutritious
bone marrow. If its bite wasn’t strong enough to shatter larger
bones, it could have engaged in a behavior similar to the one
practiced by today’s bearded vulture: fly high up over cliffs and
outcrops and drop the bone in order to smash it against the rocks
below.”
30
31
Asher Elbein
Pterodactyl Mating Flight
As attested by their extraordinary crests and brain casts
showing enlarged optical lobes, Pterosaurs were visually-
oriented creatures. It is thus highly possible that their mat-
ing habits made use of visual signals as well. In fact, sexual
selection may have been the driving force in the evolution
of exaggerated crests on pterosaurs and dinosaurs. 1
1 Hone, D. & Naish, D. & Cuthill, I. C. 2012. Does mutual sexual selec-
tion explain the evolution of head crests in pterosaurs and dinosaurs? Lethaia 45,
139-156.
32
33
Bethany Vargeson
Ambulocetus Couple
It’s a pity that fossil whales, being the spectacular, transi-
tional forms they are, do not get more attention from
palaeoartists. Their transformation from land-living
animals to gigantic swimmers is one of the most extraordi-
nary stories in the history of mammal evolution. 1
34
35
Brian Engh The true nature of sauropod integument may never be
Diamantinasaurus in Caves
known, but considering that other dinosaurs have been dis-
covered with protofeathers or spiky filaments, it won’t be
surprising if in real life, these animals bore structures that
Sauropods are the iconic “big plant eater” dinosaurs with would make this reconstruction tame in comparison.
their long necks and tails. In the past, most sauropods
were reconstructed as slow, swamp-dwelling titans which
could not even stand up properly on land. Later on, ad-
ditional discoveries and new theories of dinosaur evolution
revised our image of sauropods. No longer consigned to
the swamps, they were seen as fully-terrestrial animals.
Ultimately, however, this view also turned into a sort of
orthodoxy. Sauropods are now drawn as sleek, unadorned
land-dwellers with monotonous regularity.
36
37
Carlos de Miguel Chaves
A Melanistic Sabretooth
Smilodon, or the saber-toothed tiger, is one of the most
familiar prehistoric mammals in public knowledge. What
is less commonly known is that there was not one species
Smilodon, but three or possibly more, the largest of which
was markedly different from others with its heavy struc-
ture, long front legs and hyena-like sloping back. Here,
artist Carlos de Miguel Chaves has illustrated this largest
species of Smilodon, S. populator, in an extraordinary mela-
nistic form.
38
39
Christian Masnaghetti
Miragaia and the Opportunists
In nature, smaller animals occasionally take shelter besides
larger, well-defended ones, usually herbivores, for protec-
tion, easier access to food, or both.
40
41
Christian Masnaghetti
Symbiosis
Christian Masnaghetti returns here with a more specula-
tive suggestion of symbiosis between a large herbivorous
dinosaur and an arachnid.
42
43
Christian Masnaghetti
Two-Headed Zupaysaurus
Bordering on the surreal, a small meat-eating dinosaur
known as Zupaysaurus surveys its lakeside territory with
two heads. While this looks like a complete work of fantasy,
it might be surprising to know that polycephaly, or the
presence of more than one head in a single organism, is a
very real phenomenon in nature.
44
45
Darren Naish
Therizinosaurs Old and New
Throughout paleontological history, certain fossil lineages have been interpreted in a variety of different ways.
Either due to scrappy fossils or poorly-formulated theories, a wide variety of identities have been suggested for certain
“problematic” lineages. Famous zoologist Darren Naish contributes to this collection with a parade of unusual forms, all
representing one such lineage, the therizinosaurids. Since their discovery, this lineage of long-clawed dinosaurs were as-
signed a succession of different identities.
A reconstruction of Alxasaurus, an early therizino-
saur species. Discovered in the 1990s with a reason-
ably complete skeleton, this animal revealed a lot of
anatomical details about the group. It also established
therizinosaurs as aberrant theropods and not a dis-
tinct lineage as suggested before. It is restored here as
a reptilian dinosaur, as the fashion was in the 1990s.
We now know that therizinosaurs were covered
extensively in feather-like integument.
1 Paul., G. S. 1984.
The segnosaurian dinosaurs:
relics of the prosauropod-or-
nithischian transition? Journal
of Vertebrate Paleontology 4,
507-515.
46
A “gumby” early reconstruction, based on the work
of artist Ely Kish, of a segnosaur/therizinosaur, with
long claws, an awkward, penguin-like body stance, a
long, stiff neck, no tail and no feathers. This was the
view of these animals during the later half of the 90’s.
They were believed by some researchers to be dig-
gers, and their long claws were seen as adaptations to
tear open insect nests.
47
Elia Smaniotto
A Violent Male Caviramus
Not knowing much about the way animals compete and
reproduce, one may falsely assume that nature is fairly
idyllic when it comes to relationships. Nothing could be
further from the truth. Without going too much into details,
suffice it to say that nature is full of acts and practices that
one might call depraved. It would be wrong to assume that
similar acts did not take place in the age of dinosaurs.
48
49
Emily Willoughby
Microraptor
Palaeoartist Emily Willoughby is well known for her
beautifully detailed renditions of dromaeosaurs, or “rap-
tor” dinosaurs. Her animals are exceptional for looking first
and foremost like birds, creating an unexpected surprise
for viewers who are used to outdated reptile or dragon-like
representations.
50
51
Emily Willoughby
Utahraptors on the Beach
Moving from one of the smallest to one of the larg-
est dromaeosaurs, Emily Willoughby has here depicted
Utahraptor, a veritable giant of the dromaeosaur lineage at
up to six, or even eleven meters long. 1 This was the ani-
mal whose distorted version became popular in the movie
Jurassic Park, although it was called a “Velociraptor” in the
film.
52
53
Ethan Schmunk
A Test of Strength
In this lovely, concise pen-and-ink image, artist Ethan Sch-
munk has portrayed a full-grown Tyrannosaurus rex in the
act of felling a tree with the help of his thick, muscular tail
- but why exactly is he doing it?
54
55
Fabio Manucci
Lazy Dimetrodons
Dimetrodon is everyone’s favorite “sail-backed reptile,”
mistakenly thought to be a dinosaur and frequently in-
cluded in toy sets and second-rate dinosaur books as one.
In fact, one might be surprised to know that this animal
actually lived before dinosaurs and is a distant cousin of us
mammals. It belongs to a lineage called synapsids, which
exhibit the first skull and teeth morphologies that would
later come to characterize mammals. More familiar mam-
malian characteristics such as a erect limbs, a covering of
fur, lactation, etc. evolved later on.
56
57
Gareth Monger
Bioluminescent Nyctosaurus
This painting by UK-based palaeoartist Gareth Monger, de-
picting a flock of flying reptiles from the genus Nyctoasau-
rus, can be considered fairly speculative with the surreal,
spear-like crests of these animals lighting up the night with
bioluminescence. It might surprise you, however, to learn
that the bioluminescence of their crests is the only specula-
tive detail about the animals in this picture. The compara-
tively gigantic, antler-like growths on the heads of these
Nyctosauri are all too real 1 - to the endless puzzlement of
palaeontologists and palaeoartists alike.
58
59
Geunhong Pius Park
Clidastes velox
This breathtakingly subtle composition was one of the best
works we received for the All Your Yesterdays contest. It
shows a mosasaur known as Clidastes, a large prehistoric
marine lizard related to today’s monitor lizards, swim-
ming about in its daily foray in the warm, shallow seas that
covered the North American continent at the end of the
Mesozoic era. It is a pretty ordinary scene, but it offers a
sublime new look at these extraordinary marine reptiles.
1 Lindgren, J.; Caldwell, M.W.; Konishi, T.; and Chiappe, L.M. (2010).
“Convergent Evolution in Aquatic Tetrapods: Insights from an Exceptional Fossil
Mosasaur”. In Farke, Andrew Allen. PLoS ONE 5 (8): e11998. doi:10.1371/journal.
pone.0011998. PMC 2918493. PMID 20711249.
60
61
62
63
H. Esdaile
Tool Use in Jinfengopteryx
This spectacular artwork addresses one of the most inter-
esting debates about dinosaurs: How intelligent were these
animals? Intelligence and tool-making were once seen as
exclusive gifts to mankind. Other animals were regarded as
little more than instinct-driven automata. As time passed,
however, signs of self-awareness and complex emotions 1
were observed in animals and this embarrassing stereotype
slowly began to be discarded.
1 Bekoff, M.; Jane Goodall (2007). The Emotional Lives of Animals. ISBN
1-57731-502-2.
64
65
Jaime Headden
“Giraffapteryx”
The extraordinary lineage of pterosaurs known as
azhdarchids have been the subject of much debate in recent
years. These flying reptiles were among the largest species
of their group, with certain species such as Quetzalcoatlus
and Hatzegopteryx growing as tall as giraffes and sporting
wingspans up to 12 meters wide. Their anatomies are also
unusual: azhdarchids have comparatively huge heads and
very long, stiff necks made up of elongated vertebrae.
66
67
Jessica Pilhede
Whiskered Albertonykus
Even the average person knows that dinosaurs came in
a variety of different lineages. There are the long necked
sauropods, the terrifying tyrannosaurs, the horn-faced cera-
topsians and so on. But there are also numerous groups of
little-known dinosaurs that are just as intriguing as their
larger, more popular relatives.
68
69
John Conway
Balloon-Headed Allosaurus
Celebrated palaeoartist and Irregular Books co-founder
John Conway also participates in this collection with a
selection of works that were created after the origial All
Yesterdays volume.
70
71
John Conway
Giraffatitan brancai
at the Mudbaths
In a spectacular, never-before-seen rendition of what he
calls “the best dinosaur,” Conway shows the long-necked,
giant herbivore Giraffatitan, also known as Brachiosaurus,
enjoying a fine day with a group of friends. There are litar-
ally thousands of renditions of this animal, but Conway has
made this particular one more interesting and more memo-
rable than most.
72
73
John Meszaros extraordinary species such as Anomalocaris were not one-off
“experiments,” but parts of distinct and consistent lineages.
Therefore, John Meszaros imagines that the anomalocarid
“Ceticaris” famil tree may have included filter-feeding representatives
as well.
In this extraordinary artwork, artist John Meszaros tackles
one of the most interesting epochs in the evolution of life, This artwork is also distinct in that it depicts the imaginary
the Cambrian period. Taking place long before the age of (but completely plausible) Ceticaris with a host of commen-
the dinosaurs, approximately from 541 to 485 million years sal organisms. Primitive fluke-like vertebrates swim after it
ago, the Cambrian was the first time when reasonably for morsels of food, and derived echinoderms, very distant
large, hard-bodied organisms diversified in the planet’s cousins of today’s starfish, cover its body like red barnacles.
oceans. Animals that evolved in this period included the Less familiar organisms are also tagging along with Ceti-
first ancestors of vertebrates and the great arthropod line- caris for the ride. The animal’s underside is colonized by
ages, but also certain forms which seem very different from orange, frond-like vendozoans and tiny, five-eyed, shrimp-
anything living today. like opabinids dwell among them. Small, tadpole-like ani-
mals from a group called vetulicolians attach to Ceticaris’
One such example was Anomalocaris, 1 a gigantic predator carapace like prehistoric remoras. All in all, Meszaros has
for its time. About as big as a cat, this animal bore large, depicted a colorful, congruent riot of life instead of a pro-
well-developed eyes, a series of frond-like fins, two crush- cession of Lovecraftian “freaks.” Just because it was ancient
ing, jaw-like appanages that lined the front section of its did not mean that the Cambrian period had to be devoid of
body and a mouth composed of serrated plates arranged sophisticated ecosystems.
in an overlapping, circular pattern. These unusual organs
were first discovered as disarticulated fossils, and each
was mistaken to be a separate creature. The jaw-like limbs
were thought to be crayfish-like arthropods, the body was
thought to be a big, sea-cucumber-like organism and the
circular mouth was mistaken for a jellyfish. Only later did
researchers realize the error, and correctly identified Anom-
alocaris as a large swimming predator.
74
75
The Art of Dueling Cotylorhynchus
Joschua Knuppe
Growing over six meters long with enormous bodies,
massive limbs and tiny heads, the mammal-like reptiles
known as caseids were doubtless some of the most comi-
cal animals to ever walk the Earth. Here, two of the largest
German palaeoartist Joschua Knuppe is one of the most
caseids, of a species known as Cotylorhynchus, engage in a
accomplished young palaeo-artists of the decade. His art-
clumsy, sumo-like wrestling match for social dominance
work, executed with color pencils and gouache over brown
while a female watches them with interest. Cotylorhynchus
paper, depicts such vivid and believable creatures that one
and relatives lived in the Permian period, long before the
wonders if Knuppe’s visions come from actual glimpses of
appearance of the first dinosaurs.
the fossil past. Beyond pure artistry, Knuppe also stands
out in showing the animals’ behavior as realistically as
their forms, which deviate refreshingly from the tropes Protoceratops in Snow
we’ve grown accustomed to as a generation. Needless to
say, we migwht expect to see more of this young artist’s The horn-faced dinosaurs known as ceratopsians had a
work in the future. remarkable image revision after the recent discovery of
hair-like integument on the tail of an ancestral form. 1
Knuppe has participated in All Your Yesterdays with a di- Knuppe has extrapolated from this discovery and has illus-
verse selection of scenes, each depicting a different species trated Protoceratops, one of the most familiar ceratopsians,
from the past, in a new perspective. entirely covered with fur-like body hairs. On top of this, he
has also shown it walking bipedally across a cold, snow-
covered landscape. The result looks strikingly alien, yet it is
no less plausible than the traditional image of Protoceratops
as a naked, quadrupedal reptile in a desert.
76
77
Masiakasaurus knopfleri Nanshiungosaurus:
Masiakasaurus is an extraordinary meat-eating dinosaur A Mesozoic Moose
from the Late Cretaceous period of Madagascar. This ani-
mal is famous for its jaws, which are lined at the tips with Here, the large therizinosaur known as Nanshiungosaurus is
long teeth that project outwards. Many reconstructions of seen having a perfectly ordinary day as it wades through
this animal exaggerate these features, but in real life teeth a swamp, browsing for food and keeping its young safe
as long as Masiakasaurus’ would be protected by oral tis- on its back. Therizinosaurs were bird-like members of the
sues and consequently be less prominently visible. Thus, meat-eating dinosaur lineage known as theropods. Unlike
Knuppe has restored Masiakasaurus as a more convention- many theropods, they had adapted to a herbivorous diet.
al, bird-like dinosaur instead of a snaggle-toothed monster. Portraying dinosaurs as “ordinary” animals is one of the
hardest tasks in palaeoart, and Joschua Knuppe has done a
masterful job with this portrait of Nanshiungosaurus.
78
79
Can You Recognize Hesperonchus?
Able to form a myriad different crests, patterns and colors,
feathers are a very versatile form of body covering. Most
dinosaur artists thoroughly underestimate the visual po-
tential offered by feathers. Even bird-like reconstructions
of dinosaurs shy away from extreme crests, wings or tail
feathers, opting mostly for a contour-hugging outline that
immediately gives away the skeletal details of the animal.
Epidexipteryx Burrows In real life, things may not have been so easy to tell. Can
We know from previous pages that the long-fingered, bird- you recognize this portrait as Hesperonyhus, a smaller rela-
like dinosaurs known as scansoriopterygids might have tive of Velociraptor? Possibly not. The animal’s characteristic
been specialized for a climbing life. Conventional wisdom muzzle is almost completely obscured by a circular crest
assumes these animals were tree-climbers, but what if they of feathers. Many animals in the past possibly had such
lived in a different environment? Here, a few Epidexipteryx striking integument, and Joschua Knuppe thinks that pal-
are seen nesting in burrows constructed in a rocky canyon aeoartists can afford to be more daring in their portrayal of
wall. feathered dinosaurs.
80
Tasty Soil
A bird-like dinosaur known as Incisivosaurus is engaging in what at first seems to be an unusual act - it’s using its chisel-
like teeth to eat soil from a hillside. The act of eating soil, clay, rocks or other minerals is known as geophagy and is not as
uncommon as one might believe. In today’s world many animals, especially birds, ingest earthy substances to obtain vital
minerals such as calcium and sodium.
Dinosaurs would not have been much different in their need of mineral supplements.
81
Shuuvia deserti
Current reconstructions of bird-like dinosaurs dress them up with bird-like feathers, but for some reason the avian attire
abruptly stops at the animals’ heads, which are still drawn in a reptilian manner. It’s as if the illustrators, no matter how
modern, are still stuck to the old template of dinosaurs as reptiles, at least when it comes to their faces. Here, Joschua
Knuppe breaks this tradition by portraying Shuuvia deserti, a one-fingered alvarezsaur, in a complete covering of bird-like
feathers. It looks like an ordinary bird, but then again, perhaps most dinosaurs did so as well.
82
Dust Bath
A lot of animals, especially birds, like to roll around in
sun-baked dust in order to clean themselves and get rid of
parasites. This Struthiomimus is following suit by cleansing
its feathers in a similar manner.
Projectile Defence
No matter how complete, fossils almost never preserve the
behaviors of extinct animals. Even “ordinary” dinosaurs
could have had extraordinary defense mechanisms. Here,
Joschua Knuppe speculates on Heterodontosaurus, one of the
early plant-eating dinosaurs, defending itself from preda-
tors with a jet of foul-smelling feces.
83
Beipiaosaurus
A wary Beipiaosaurus is here seen scanning its
surroundings as it feeds on plants. Beipiaosaurus
was one of the earliest therizinosaurs, a lineage
of feathered, bird-like dinosaurs famously known
from gigantic, long-clawed species like Therizino-
saurus. At slightly less than two meters long,
Beipiaosaurus was nowhere as large. Nevertheless,
it caused quite a stir in palaeontological circles
because at the time of its discovery, Beipiaosaurus
was one of the largest dinosaurs preserved with a
feathery integument. 1
A Violent Game
Play behavior is an important part of many ani-
mals’ lives. Here, Joschua Knuppe illustrates a dino-
saur at play to challenge conventional ideas about
dinosaurian predators and prey. In this painting, a
herbivorous Edmontosaurus is playing with a dead
juvenile Albertosaurus, (a relative of the famous
Tyrannosaurus,) tossing its body about.
84
A Sleeping Trinisaura
There is a recursive pattern to certain hypotheses in the world of palaeontology. A case to the point is arboreality, tree-
living, in small dinosaurian herbivores. In the beginning of the century, a tree-living way of life was proposed for small,
plant eating dinosaurs known as hypsilophodonts. 1 This idea was based on the structure of their feet, which was seen
more or less like that of perching birds. Indeed, the entire group that included hypsilophodonts was named ornithopoda,
or bird-feet. Later on, however, this idea was discredited and ornithopod feet were understood to be adapted for walking
and running over firm ground.
As we look more into nature, however, it becomes apparent that not all animal behavior can be discerned from the anato-
my of their bones. Even if their feet were not adapted for perching, it is not implausible that some ornithopods may have
sought refuge in trees. To illustrate this point, Joschua Knuppe has painted the small ornithopod known as Trinisaura,
sleeping in a tree. Trinisaura is also one of the few dinosaur species known from Antarctica. 2
1 Abel, O., 1912, Grundzüge der Palaeobiologie der Wirbeltiere, E. Schweizerbart’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung Nägele und Dr Sproesser, Stuttgart
2 Coria, R. A.; Moly, J. J.; Reguero, M.; Santillana, S.; Marenssi, S. (2013). “A new ornithopod (Dinosauria; Ornithischia) from Antarctica”. Cretaceous Research.
doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2012.12.004.
85
Live-Birthing Drepanasaur
With lizard-like bodies, very muscular arms and fragile,
bird-like heads, the reptiles known as drepanosaurs were
among the strangest animals in history. It is thought that
their lives may have been convergent with those of chame-
leons; drepanosaurs may have lived by clinging to branch-
es and snapping up small insect prey with their long necks
and delicate heads.
Live-Birthing Hesperornis
In this picture, we see the prehistoric marine bird known
as Hesperornis in a rather unlikely act; it’s giving live birth!
The possibility of dinosaurs and kin bearing live ofspring
has been considered before, for dome-headed dinosaurs
known as pachycephalosaurs, sea-going crocodiles, large,
herbivorous sauropod dinosaurs and the Hesperornis
shown here. So far, however, there are no confirmed fossils
that suggest dinosaurs or their relatives may have given
birth rather than laying eggs. This may be so because dino-
saur and bird embryos depend on their eggshells as a vital
calcium reservoir during development. 1
86
87
Caviramus and the Frog
This splendidly naturalistic illustration depicts Caviramus, a
primitive pterosaur known from the late Triassic period of
Switzerland, impaling its amphibian prey onto branches,
much like shrikes (Laniidae,) living today.
88
89
A Climbing Mosasaur
Pannoniasaurus is a mosasaur, from a lineage of large,
prehistoric marine lizards that also includes the Clidastes il-
lustrated on the previous pages. Pannoniasaurus was unique
among its relatives because so far, it is the only mosasaur
known to have lived in freshwater. 1
90
Umoonasaurus
Dinosaurs shared their world with a diverse host of marine reptiles. We picture all these animals as sea-dwellers, but cer-
tainly some must have adapted to estuarine, if not freshwater habitats in the 186 million-year-span of the Mesozoic era. In
today’s world, dolphins, marine mammals, have given rise to different freshwater species in the rivers of Asia and South
America. Artist Joshchua Knuppe has here decided to portray a species of marine reptile, Umoonasaurus, as a freshwater-
living form. Unlike its sleek, streamlined marine relatives, Knuppe’s Umoonasaurus has a cryptic body shape evolved to
hide in riverbeds and marshlands. Fast pursuit in open waters is no longer its forte. It has another adaptation for freshwa-
ter life in its tongue; the organ shaped like a worm in order to lure in inquisitive prey animals.
Umoonasaurus belonged to a group of marine reptiles called leptocleididae, some members of of which seem to be special-
ized for a freshwater lifestyle. 1 As a result, the portrayal of Umoonasaurus as a river-dweller may not be entirely specula-
tive.
1 Kear, B. P. & Barrett, P. M. 2011. Reassessment of the Early Cretaceous (Barremian) pliosauroid Leptocleidus superstes Andrews, 1922 and other plesiosaur
remains from the nonmarine Wealden succession of southern England. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 161, 663-691.
91
Julio Lacerda
Taboo
Talented palaeoartist Julio Lacerda, known for his photore-
alistic compositions of birdlike dinosaurs, presents us here
with a thought-provoking picture that is only “taboo” for
people, and only certain people at that. His artwork depicts
a homosexual couple of bird-like dinosaurs known as
caenagnathids.
1 Eric Silver (2 August 1999). “Gay vulture couple raise surrogate chicks”.
London: The Independent News. Retrieved 2009-09-21.
2 Braithwaite, L. W., ‘Ecological studies of the Black Swan III – Behaviour
and social organization’, Australian Wildlife Research 8, 1981: 134-146.
92
93
Lew Lashmit
“Georgosaurus”
In the history of palaeontology, there are certain fos-
sils which, through their sheer strangeness, have led to
wildly different theories about their origin and the way
they looked in life. A classic case is that of Therizinosaurus,
known only from a set of forearms with claws that were
almost a meter long.
94
95
Michael Hanson
A Diving Rhamphorhynchus
With its rudder-tipped tail, short beak and needle-like
teeth, Rhamphorhynchus is one of the most familiar ptero-
saurs, second only to the crested Pteranodon in the public
eye. This animal is mostly portrayed as a bat-like flyer,
clinging to branches and rocks and soaring around seaside
landscapes. Here, however, Michael Hanson has specula-
tively illustrated it in an unfamiliar ecological role - this
Rhamphorhynchus is adapted for aquatic life as a diver.
96
97
Mike Keesey
Texan Mama: Dimetrodon
Dimetrodon, the familiar, sail-backed cousin of mammals,
is usually portrayed as a lizard-like beast. The fact that it is
related to mammals is overshadowed by its more “reptil-
ian” features such as the sprawling limbs and the unusual
sail of skin. But what if mammalian characteristics such
as a moist skin full of sweat glands, appeared earlier on in
mammal evolution than we think? If this was indeed the
case, then Dimetrodon would not have looked like a reptile
at all. Artist Mike Keesey explains:
“In this piece, I have pushed the origin of fur and milk back to an
extremely early time - Dimetrodon is one of the furthest stem-
mammals from mammalia proper. While we know that a later
stem-mammal, Estemmenosuchus, had glandular skin without
any sign of fur, (1) it is possible that fur evolved earlier and was
simply lost or reduced in some lineages, as it has been in many
placental mammals today.
98
99
Mike Keesey
A Siberian Denisovan
The Denisova hominin, or “the Denisovan,” is one of the
most enigmatic chapters in the story of human evolution.
Known from a few fragmentary bones from the Denisova
caves in Siberia, it preserves a DNA trace that is distinct
both from modern people, Homo sapiens, and the closely-
related neanderthals, Homo neanderthalensis. 1 Before the
Denisova discovery, us and the neanderthals were thought
to be the only major groups of humans in the ice-age world.
Now, it seems that a distinct third sub-species also existed.
It is a pity that only finger and toe bones are left from this
puzzling lineage of human beings. This lack of remains is
frustrating, but it also opens up room for speculation. Mike
Keesey elaborates on what our distant cousin might have
looked like, and their attitudes towards Homo sapiens.
1 Krause, Johannes; Fu, Qiaomei; Good, Jeffrey M.; Viola, Bence; Shun-
kov, Michael V.; Derevianko, Anatoli P. & Pääbo, Svante (2010), “The complete
mitochondrial DNA genome of an unknown hominin from southern Siberia”,
Nature 464 (7290): 894–897, doi:10.1038/nature08976, PMID 20336068.
100
101
Mitchell Seymour
Diplocaulus, an Amphibian Stingray
Mitchell Seymour’s naive and vivid, cartoon-like artwork
was a great addition to this book. Combining reasonable
speculation with a sense that prehistoric animals don’t
need to be portrayed as photorealistic figures or “gritty”
monsters, they encourage the viewer to look at extinct life
in a new perspective.
102
103
Miyess Mitri
A Feathered Spinosaurus
Out of all the meat-eating dinosaurs, the superficially
crocodile-like spinosaurs proved to be the most resistant,
in the mind’s eye, to the “feathering” brought about by
new discoveries of dinosaurian integument. One can easily
imagine bird-like Velociraptors and even the famous Tyran-
nosaurus rex covered in feathers, but it is difficult to men-
tally picture the extraordinary spinosaurs with plumage.
1 Amiot, R.; Buffetaut, E.; Lécuyer, C.; Wang, X.; Boudad, L.; Ding, Z.;
Fourel, F.; Hutt, S.; Martineau, F.; Medeiros, A.; Mo, J.; Simon, L.; Suteethorn, V.;
Sweetman, S.; Tong, H.; Zhang, F.; and Zhou, Z. (2010). “Oxygen isotope evidence
for semi-aquatic habits among spinosaurid theropods”. Geology 38 (2): 139–142.
doi:10.1130/G30402.1.
104
105
Peter Buchholz
Parksosaurus Dreaming
Palaeoartist Peter Buchholz has created this whimsical-but-
plausible scene of an adult Parkosaurus, a plant-eating dino-
saur, in an inebriated state after eating some mushrooms
with psychoactive ingredients.
106
107
Rachel Lowrie
Vanquished
In this colorful piece, palaeoartist Rachel Lowrie has depict-
ed two male Fruitadens, plant-eating dinosaurs, in a duel
for social dominance. Although nature can be host to a va-
riety of unfortunate and violent interactions, same-species
duels for social dominance rarely end in death. Usually,
animals have a surrender signal that lets their conspecifics
know that they have given up.
108
109
Rachel Lowrie
Wrestling Plateosaurus
Once more, Rachel Lowrie focuses her art on the theme of
social dominance. On this occasion, the combatants are of
the genus Plateosaurus - the forerunners of the long-necked
sauropods.
110
111
“Ramul”
Tastes Like Chicken
As told before, palaeoart has developed its own unques-
tioned conventions and typecast roles when it comes to
certain scenes. The almost classical scene of a mid-sized,
herbivorous ornithischian being viciously torn apart by a
pack of predatory Deinonychi is one such trope.
112
113
Raven Amos
Swamp Dragon - Ichthyovenator
With this gorgeously stylized painting, talented palaeoartist
Raven Amos addresses the unusual sail-like ridges found
in spinosaurid dinosaurs. As seen before in this book,
spinosaurs were a group of meat-eating dinosaurs with
possible adaptations for an aquatic lifestyle. Some members
of this group bore very tall vertebral ridges on their backs.
While these structures were conventionally assumed to
have been “skin sails,” Raven Amos interprets them as an
adaptation for an exitence spent in water.
114
115
Raven Amos
Bowertyrants
In today’s world, bowerbirds (family Ptilorhynchidae,) are
well-known for their extraordinary mating habits, in which
males carefully curate and arrange a selection of brightly-
colored objects with hopes of getting the females’ attention.
With this piece, Raven Amos has speculated on a similar
behavior for the famous tyrannosaurs. For her, the tyranno-
saur species known as Gorgosaurus has become the “lesser
bowertyrant.”
1 Xu, X.; Wang, K.; Zhang, K.; Ma, Q.; Xing, L.; Sullivan, C.; Hu, D.;
Cheng, S. et al. (2012). “A gigantic feathered dinosaur from the Lower Cretaceous
of China” (PDF). Nature 484: 92–95. doi:10.1038/nature10906. PMID 22481363.
116
117
Robinson Kunz
Guardpost
Not many dinosaur-themed artworks show mutually ben-
eficial interactions between animals. Done mostly for “awe-
some” value, mainstream palaeoart focuses on predator-
prey scenes with almost predictable repetition. Couldn’t
these animals have done something other than attacking,
killing and eating each other all the time?
118
119
Robinson Kunz
Darwinopterus as a Nest Parasite
Nest parasitism is an unusual phenomenon where an
animal, usually a bird, lays its eggs in the nest of a differ-
ent species. The unsuspecting hosts will accept the parasite
hatchling as their own and raise it at expense of their own
offspring. The parasite hatchling may even kill its nest-
mates in order to ensure its survival.
1 Unwin, David M. (2006). The Pterosaurs: From Deep Time. New York:
Pi Press. p. 246. ISBN 0-13-146308-X.
120
121
Rodrigo Vega Put together, these small, speculative tweakings create a
fantastically different picture of Spinosaurus than the run-
ning, sail-backed crocodile we have gotten used to. Artist
A Speculative Spinosaurus Rodrigo Vega admits that his interpretation is possibly too
extreme, but it serves a very important purpose for people
As seen before, the predatory dinosaur Spinosaurus has interested in dinosaurs and palaeontology - it gets us think-
been the center of much palaeontological speculation with ing about the relation between fossils and the features they
its possible lifestyle and the soft-tissues covering of its supported in real life.
extraordinary bony sail. With this spectacular work, con-
ceptual artist Rodrigo Vega purposefully delivers the most
outlandish interpretation of Spinosaurus he can conceive.
Every detail of the animal’s anatomy, from the skull to the
sail-like bones on its back, has been interpreted as a basis of
an unconventional anatomical feature.
122
123
124
125
Santa Mazzei
Austroraptor Chicks
At first glance, this artwork seems to depict a tiny duckling
about to be snatched by a vicious, long-jawed predator.
Look closer, however, and details hint that this is not the
case. To begin with, the “duckling” is not a duck. It has tiny
claws where its wings should be, and small, nascent teeth
gleam in its beak. Its tail is also longer than one would
expect a duck’s to be. This chick is a dinosaur chick, of
a species known as Austroraptor. The toothy maw in the
picture it is not that of a menacing predator, but of one of
its protective parents.
1 Novas, Fernando E.; Diego Pol, Juan I. Canale, Juan D. Porfiri and Jorge
O. Calvo (2008-12-16). “A bizarre Cretaceous theropod dinosaur from Patagonia
and the evolution of Gondwanan dromaeosaurids”. Proceedings of the Royal So-
ciety B (The Royal Society) 276 (1659): 1101–7. doi:10.1098/rspb.2008.1554. PMC
2679073. PMID 19129109.
126
127
Sarah Goss
Mating Dance - Tapejara
Tapejara was one of the most elaborately crested pterosaurs.
In this evocative digital painting by Sarah Goss, a Tapejara
couple is seen “sky dancing,” holding each other’s feet
and nuzzling while in a downward plunge. We have no
evidence of such a ritual in the fossil record, and pterosaur
wing membranes likely did not leave their legs free for
such activities, but nevertheless this piece leaves a momen-
tous impact.
128
129
Sarah Goss
A Flamboyant Therizinosaurus
The strange, long-clawed dinosaur Therizinosaurus is
rendered even stranger, but also more lifelike with this
portrayal, featuring an attention-gathering suite of display
markings, long feathers and bulging throat sac.
130
131
Simon Roy
Cyclops
Comic artist and illustrator Simon Roy is famous for his
subtly detailed, down-to-earth portrayals of alien cultures,
people and animals. Aided with a vast reservoir of knowl-
edge on anatomy, evolutionary biology and anthropology,
he adds layers of details to his concepts and characters,
resulting in an engrossing, world-building experience.
Here, Roy has produced a “what if” speculation on the
cyclops, one of the oldest palaeontological misconceptions.
132
133
Simon Roy
Retro-Dinosauroid Tribesmen
Simon Roy here addresses one of the most interesting spec-
ulations about dinosaurs: If they hadn’t died out, would
some dinosaurs evolve into an intelligent species? Differ-
ent models have been proposed for intelligent dinosaurs
in recent decades. The most famous of these is Dale Rus-
sel’s “dinosauroid,” 1 which was hypothetically derived
from small, smart, meat-eating dinosaurs such as Troodon.
Published in 1978, when dinosaurs were thought to be
reptile-like creatures, Dale Russel’s dinosauroid looked
like a green, scaly humanoid with large eyes, an upright
stance and only the vestige of a tail. This model was later
criticized because it looked too much like a human being.
Would there really be an evolutionary pressure for all intel-
ligent animals to develop a humanoid body plan? Indeed,
the main theme of Russel’s 1978 hypothesis seems to be the
suggestion of a common, humanoid body form for intel-
ligent animals rather than a detailed speculation on intel-
ligent dinosaurs. More recently, in 2006, zoologist Darren
Naish suggested that due to their bird-like anatomy,
intelligent dinosaurs would look more like birds. Their
bodies would be horizontally aligned, and their tails would
not need to disappear. Like parrots and crows today, they
would use their beaks to manipulate objects.They wouldn’t
need to evolve a humanoid body plan. 2
134
135
Smyslov Alexander
Seasonal Feathers
The presence of feathers in dinosaurs is almost universally
accepted now, but the debate on the extent of feather-
ing still goes on. Russian palaeoartist Smyslov Alexander
brings in a suggestion a few have considered - what if cer-
tain dinosaurs only had seasonal feathering? In his hypo-
thetical scenario, the early plant-eating dinosaur
Heterodontosaurus has two distinct morphs for different
times of the year. The animals lose their hair-like body
covering during the warm season, and re-gain their plum-
age with the arrival of colder weather and rains. The green
color of the autumnal feathering also helps the animal
disguise itself from predators.
136
137
Smyslov Alexander
A Skin-Clad Stegosaurus
The plate-backed Stegosaurus is one of the most readily
recognizable dinosaurs of all time. Discovered back in 1877,
1
this bus-sized dinosaur soon became a palaeontological
enigma. No one could make sense of its bizarre plates, nor
could guess exactly how they were attached to the ani-
mal’s body in real life. At first, the plates were thought to
be fused to its skin, like the scales of a gigantic pangolin.
Later on, other interpretations were proposed with the
plates standing erect in a single row, a side-by-side double
row and so on. Some researchers though the plates were
independently movable, while others disagreed. An eccen-
tric writer even reconstructed them as tiny wings, which
helped the immense animal glide from cliffs! 2 In the end,
Stegosaurus’ plates were understood to lie in a staggered
double row across its back. There is still some debate over
what function they performed, but it is certain that this did
not extend to aeronautical capabilities.
138
139
Oscar Mendez
Rumbling Ichthyovenator
Palaeoartist Oscar Mendez is well-known online with his concise, colorful and sharp lineart of dinosaurs,
mostly meat-eating theropods.
In this image, he shows a male Ichthyovenator, a possibly aquatic spinosaur, conducting a “rumble” display
in the water for females of his kind. He has immersed himself in a calm river and is causing the water around
him to vibrate and bubble with sound waves. The extensive system of air sacs 1 in his lungs and chest is help-
ing him better transmit vibrations from his body to the water. We obviously don’t have direct evidence for this
kind of display in Ichthyovenator, but it is not unlikely. In today’s world, crocodiles perform a similar ritual,
causing the water on their backs to “boil” with sonorous vocalizations.
1 Wedel MJ. Evidence for bird-like air sacs in saurischian dinosaurs. Journal of Experimental Zoology Part A: Ecological Genetics and Physiol-
ogy. 2009 Oct 1;311(8): 611-28. doi: 10.1002/jez.513.
140
141
Oscar Mendez
Saurolophus and alvarezsaurs
Interactions between different animal species are thought
to fall into one of two categories. They can either be symbi-
otic, beneficial for both parties, or parasitic, in which one
animal benefits at the expense of another. But real life is not
so clear-cut. Nature is full of opportunistic relationships
that can change back and forth between symbiosis and par-
asitism. Indeed, this is how distinctly parasitic or symbiotic
relations evolve in the first place. An animal might initially
approach another as a parasite, but may inadvertently
cause beneficial side-effects. In due time, such relationships
may evolve into symbiosis - and vice versa.
142
143
Oscar Mendez a maw of sharp teeth on the predator, and a stubby beak
on Oryctodromeus. Perhaps Troodon would have sported a
144
related species. 1 Almost all prior illustrations showed these strides. Accurate representations not only make dinosaurs
animals with specifically and only those patches present. In more interesting, they also help convey the evolutionary
reality, the patchy preservation is a by-product of fossiliza- relationship they have with birds. They make us realize
tion, and these animals must have sported a more extensive how much of conventional palaeoart is based on repetitions
integument that even covered their faces. of patterns and tropes. Perhaps one day, new discoveries
will make this artwork seem as dated as the reptile-like
Likewise, Oscar Mendez has illustrated Troodon as a proper, dinosaurs of the past.
bird-like animal - instead of a reptile with a token covering
of feathers. Based on careful observations of real-life birds,
Mendez has given it subtle nuances of movement such
as its folded wings and the flexing posture of its feet as it
1 Zheng, Xiao-Ting; You, Hai-Lu; Xu, Xing; Dong, Zhi-Ming (19 March
2009). “An Early Cretaceous heterodontosaurid dinosaur with filamentous integu-
mentary structures”. Nature 458 (7236): 333–336. doi:10.1038/nature07856. PMID
19295609.
145
Oscar Mendez
A Tangent Bird
Eosinopteryx was a tiny, bird-like dinosaur, known from a
well-preserved fossil from China, complete with a full suite
of feathers. 1 Eosinopteryx had an unusual set of character-
istics; its head had an extremely short snout and very large
eyes. Unlike most related species, its legs and tail were not
extensively feathered. Despite its small size, it did not seem
to have the ability to fly. Artist Oscar Mendez has here
interpreted this puzzling animal as a nocturnal, gruond-
scurrying hunter of insects and other small animals, a dino-
saur converging with shrews and other small mammals.
1 Godefroit, P.; Demuynck, H.; Dyke, G.; Hu, D.; Escuillié, F. O.; Claeys,
P. (2013). “Reduced plumage and flight ability of a new Jurassic paravian theropod
from China”. Nature Communications 4: 1394. doi:10.1038/ncomms2389. PMID
23340434.
146
147
Thomas Duffy Using a method which no one else can replicate, he has
claimed to have seen features that nobody else can see,
such as a long finger supporting a small wing, a very long
Longisquama tail and extra fronds on the animal’s back, head and tail.
Thomas Duffy is well-known among today’s fantasy and Thomas Duffy has based his fantastic drawing on this
palaeo-artists with his outlandish, cheerfully irreverent improbable view. Instead of trying to argue the errors of
hybrids of different fossil animals and even machines. For Peters’ Longisquama, (which many people have tried,) he
this collection, he has chosen to tackle the enigmatic fossil has accepted it as a fantasy and added onto it.
known as Longisquama, whose extraordinary anatomy 1 is He has made this improbable being into a photosynthetic
almost as strange as one of Duffy’s fantastic creations. animal - one that can feed on sunlight, much like plants.
Its fronds are full of symbiotic algae colonies that convert
Longisquama is known mainly from one fossil, which only sunlight into energy and it spends most of its life hanging
preserves its front half. It is a small, lightly-built animal upside down like a sun-powered reptilian sloth,
with very long, feather-like projections emerging from its “grazing” on sunlight that dapples the jungle canopy.
back. A variety of purposes have been suggested for these Although certain invertebrates have recently been discov-
fronds, from camouflaging the animal in trees to display ered to integrate photosynthesis into their metabolisms, 5
devices for mating, or as winglets to help it glide from no evidence exists for similar phenomena in vertebrates. As
branch to branch. The fronds have also been discovered fantastic as it might be, Duffy’s Longisquama in tongue-in
in isolated fossils, which led some researchers to interpret cheek warning against unsupported speculations in palae-
them as vegetative remains unrelated to the animal. 2 ontology.
148
149
Tom Parker
Uncommon Scenes
It can be safe to say that most of today’s novel ideas about
palaeontology are not generated in universities, labs or dig
sites, but on online discussions. Countless forums, blogs,
blogs’ comment sections and even art sites host a lively and
constant discussion about ancient animals and new theo-
ries about how they might have lived and looked like.
One such site is the Hell Creek Forums page, from which
artist Tom Parker has gathered this nice selection of
uncommon scenes people would like to see represented
more in palaeoart. It must be noted that these ideas were
coined and drawn before this book, and even the first All
Yesterdays was published - suggesting that today’s new
dinosaur renaissance was already brewing in a lot of inde-
pendent minds before its current blossoming.
150
An attack by a mosasaur, a
large, predatory marine lizard,
on a terrestrial dinosaur.
151
An ornithischian dinosaur is
drinking water, acting like a
bird rather than a mammal.
152
Dust bathing by a Velociraptor.
This is a common feather-cleaning (and
possibly fun,) activity undertaken by
many birds living today.
153
A reversal of the “raptor” trope, with
a large herbivorous dinosaur success-
fully defeating an attack by a predatory
Deinonychus.
154
An act of prehistoric river combing,
where an animal ranges across a stream
for food. Featuring a Gorgosaurus,
prowling a slow river for frogs and
turtles.
155
Tuomas Koivurinne
An Accidental Death
Most of us assume that animals are immune to accidental
death. In the popular, idealized and false vision of nature
there are no accidents; animals always move and act in
harmony with their surroundings, and death is brought
about only by the “natural” act of predation, or through the
“unnatural” transgressions of man.
156
157
Vitaly Melnik
Prehistoric Portraits
Ukrainian palaeoartist Vitaly Melnik has participated in
this collection with artwork that lets us look at dinosaurs in
a new perspective - as portraits.
158
Portrait of Tyrannosaurus rex, everyone’s favorite meat-eating dinosaur. This time, however, T-rex is
feeding on plants, perhaps in order to relieve itself of a digestive ailment.
159
Portrait of Cryolophosaurus, a crested predatory dinosaur whose remains were discovered in
Antarctica. Vitaly Melnik has speculated that its crest could have sported flexible, leathery folds
that mimicked palm fronds. This would help conceal the animal from its quarry.
160
Portrait of Anurognathus, a tiny flying pterosaur with no tail and a wide, frog-like mouth.
These animals possibly occupied the ecological niches taken up by bats today.
In real life, this beast would be as small as a mouse.
161
Portrait of a baby ornithischian dinosaur with a drool of “crop milk,” a nutritious substance regurgitated
by its caring mother. In today’s world, certain birds also use crop milk to feed their offspring.
162
Portrait of two Pachycephalosaurs, locked in combat for social dominance. Pachycephalosaurs are famous for
their sturdy, dome-shaped skulls. Vitaly Melnik has interpreted the domes as the foundations of even larger
horns, much like the ones found in rhinoceroses today. Based on fiber-like fossils found in related animals, he
has also restored them with shaggy, ox-like pelts.
163
Portrait of Estemmenosuchus, a very large, bear-like cousin of the early mammals that lived before the age of
dinosaurs. It possibly fed on meat as well as plants. Estemmenosuchus had numerous horn-like protrusions on
its face. Artist Vitaly Melnik has interpreted some of them as the bases of keratinous, reindeer-like horns.
164
Portrait of Majungasaurus, a predatory dinosaur from Madagascar. Since many dinosaur fossils
have been discovered with feather impressions, artist Vitaly Melnik has dressed out
Majungasaurus with an extremely-bird-like coat of feathers.
165
Vitor Silva
A Shedding Mosasaur
Sharing the seas with the last dinosaurs, mosasaurs were
ancient marine reptiles descended from lizards. While new
discoveries are showing them to be more fish-like than
shown here, Italian palaeoartist Vitor Silva has produced
his artwork with emphasis on the animals’ skin rather than
their bodies.
166
167
Vitor Silva
Drop-Kill Triceratops
As we know from today’s natural world, a herbivorous
diet does not always translate to strict vegetarianism. As
surprising as it might seem, many herbivores will try to eat
carrion or even live flesh if the opportunity becomes avail-
able. For example, animals like deer and cows have been
observed feeding on bird nestlings, possibly in order to
gain additional vitamins and minerals.
Artist Vitor Silva has here illustrated a similar case with the
familiar herbivorous dinosaur Triceratops. In his specula-
tive scenario, the heavyweight dinosaur allows commensal
birds to approach it as they look for parasites on its skin.
Seeking a suitable moment, the larger dinosaur unexpect-
edly drops all of its weight onto the bird, instantly crushing
it. The Triceratops then eats the bird for a helpful boost of
minerals. The larger herbivore might even be doing this
fun, as play behavior.
168
169
Vladmir Nikolov
An Albino Eosinopteryx
From the common pet white rabbit to extraordinary white
whales, many animals exhibit albinism in nature. Albinism
is characterized by an absence of melanin and other skin
pigments, and is found in most animal groups, from birds
to reptiles, fish and even mollusks. Doubtlessly, the phe-
nomenon must have existed in dinosaurs as well.
170
171
Vladmir Nikolov
Damaged Feathers
Now that feathers in small dinosaurs have become popu-
larly accepted in palaeoart, the challenge is to produce art-
work that will get people to think about the implications
of feathers in the animals’ daily lives. For example, disease
and damage to feathers is a rarely tackled subject. In this
picture, artist Vladmir Nikolov has illustrated a Microrap-
tor, the famous “four winged” predatory dinosaur, 1 with
half of its plumage lost in a forest fire. Fortunately the small
hunter is not seriously hurt and the feathers will grow back
in due time. Until then, however, this Microraptor won’t be
able to glide from branches like it used to do.
172
173
Vladmir Nikolov
Bone-Headed Dinosaur Hiding
Most people think that pachycephalosaurs, the famous
bone-headed dinosaurs, used their extremely thick skulls
for dominance duels and also as weapons against preda-
tors. With this meticulously-detailed work in pencil, how-
ever, artist Vladmir Nikolov suggests another alternative:
174
175
Vladmir Nikolov
Moonlight Attack
Current reconstructions of dinosaurs are unnaturally stark.
Perhaps because of a desire to represent skeletons accu-
rately, contemporary palaeoartists leave as much soft tissue
out as possible, resulting in “shrink wrapped” depictions.
We can never tell all the fat, muscle mass, meat, hair, feath-
ers and display features each dinosaur bore in real life,
but after comparing existing animals and their skeletons,
we can be certain that “shrink wrapped” dinosaurs are all
wrong. Some parts of the animals have been lost, forever
unknown.
176
177
Afterword and Credits
We at Irregular Books would like to thank everyone who participated in our contest. What you saw in
this book was but a sliver of the new ideas, artwork and ways of thinking that will revolutionize not
only palaeoart, but possibly the scientific process itself. We could not include all of the art we received
for this volume, but your support, enthusiasm and creativity were the greatest driving forces for this
book, and our other, upcoming projects. Palaeoartists are unique in carrying the torches of art and
science tohether. Only a few people can do this. Whatever the future holds for your lives or careers, we
hope that your passion in palaeoart never fades away.
- C. M. Kosemen
178
“Austroraptor”
artwork by Vitaly Melnik
179
“A cheeky Psittacosaurus”
artwork by Chris di Piazza
180
www.irregularbooks.co
181
The Irregular Books Crew
C. M. Kosemen John Conway
Author and Artist C. M. Kosemen holds a Media and Com- John Conway is a palaeontological and fine artist, who’s
munications Masters’ degree from Goldsmiths College, work has been used for National Geographic, Discovery
and has worked as an editor in Benetton Company’s Colors Channel and the American Museum of Natural History,
magazine. He has had several exhibitons of his evolution- among others. His work has most recently appeared in
themed fine art at galleries and science festivals interna- Dinosaur Art: the World’s Greatest Paleoart. John’s interest in
tionally. Kosemen’s areas of specialization are speculative the methodology and culture of reconstructing of palaeon-
& real zoology, history and unusual things in general. His tological subjects was the genesis of the original All
previous work includes Snaiad, a self-initiated web project Yesterdays project.
about life on an alien planet. Kosemen wrote and illustrat-
ed sections of the original All Yesterdays and initiated the Website: johnconway.co
contest behind this book. Twitter: @nyctopterus
Facebook: facebook.com/nyctopterus
Website: cmkosemen.com
Facebook: facebook.com/memo.kosemen
Email: [email protected]
Darren Naish
Author Darren Naish is a science writer, technical editor
and a palaeozoologist. Darren works mostly on theropod
and sauropod dinosaurs, but also on pterosaurs, marine
reptiles and other tetrapods. With colleagues, he named the
dinosaurs Eotyrannus, Mirischia and Xenoposeidon. Darren
has written several books, including Walking With Dino-
saurs: The Evidence (co- authored with David M. Martill),
Great Dinosaur Discoveries, and more recently Tetrapod Zool-
ogy Book One. He is also the co-author of All Yesterdays.
His blog, Tetrapod Zoology, is widely considered the world’s
foremost zoology blog.
Website: blogs.scientificamerican.com/tetrapod-zoology/
Twitter: @TetZoo Oveleaf,
John Conway, C. M. Kosemen and Darren Naish during
the All Yesterdays book launch event in London.
182
183
Coming Soon: A new title from
Irregular Books authors
John Conway, Darren Naish
and C. M. Kosemen!
184
185
186
187