Electrical Load Estimation
Electrical Load Estimation
At the beginning of the project,in the draft design (early design) stage, the electrical design
professional should do the following:
Electrical Load Estimation is very important in the draft design (early design) stage because it help
to:
there are many Important terms which must be understood before performing the load estimation,
these terms are:
1- Connected load
It is the Sum of all the loads connected to the electrical system, usually expressed in watts.
2- Demand load
It is The electric load at the receiving terminals averaged over a specified demand interval of time,
usually 15 min., 30 min., or 1 hour based upon the particular utility’s demand interval. Demand may
be expressed in amperes, kilo-amperes, kilo-watts, kilo-vars, or kilo-volt-amperes.
3- Demand Interval
It is The period over which the load is averaged, usually 15 min., 30 min., or 1 hour.
4- Maximum demand
It is The greatest of all demands that have occurred during a specified period of time such as 5
minutes, 15 minutes, 30 minutes or one hour. For utility billing purposes the period of time is
generally one month.
In normal operating conditions the power consumption of a load is sometimes less than that
indicated as its nominal power rating.
The demand factor is the ratio of the maximum demand on a system to the total connected load of
the system.
Notes:
This factor must be applied to each individual load, with particular attention to electric
motors, which are very rarely operated at full load.
Demand factors for buildings typically range between 50 and 80 percent of the connected
load. For most building types, the demand factor at the service where the maximum diversity is
experienced is usually 60 to 75 percent of the connected load. Specific portions of the system may
have much higher demand factors, even approaching 100 percent.
It is a matter of common experience that the simultaneous operation of all installed loads of a given
installation never occurs in practice, i.e. there is always some degree of diversity and this fact is
taken into account for estimating purposes by the use of a simultaneity factor (ks).
The coincidence factor is the ratio of the maximum demand of a system, or part under
consideration, to the sum of the individual maximum demands of the subdivisions.
Notes:
The factor ks is applied to each group of loads (e.g. being supplied from a distribution or sub-
distribution board).
5 storeys apartment building with 25 consumers, each having 6 kVA of installed load.
the solution:
The total installed load for the building is: 36 + 24 + 30 + 36 + 24 = 150 kVA
table#1
From table#1 in above, it is possible to determine the magnitude of currents in different sections of
the common main feeder supplying all floors. For vertical rising mains fed at ground level, the cross-
sectional area of the conductors can evidently be progressively reduced from the lower floors
towards the upper floors. These changes of conductor size are conventionally spaced by at least 3-
floor intervals.
so, The apparent-power supply required for the building is: 150 x 0.46 = 69 kVA
the current entering the rising main at ground level( main service size) is:
The current entering the third floor (the third level service size) is:
7- Diversity factor
The diversity factor is the reciprocal of the coincidence factor. Diversity factor = Sum of individual
maximum demands / Maximum system demand
Notes:
The Diversity Factor is applied to each group of loads (e.g. being supplied from a distribution
or sub-distribution board).
Example#2:
Consider that a feeder supplies five users with the following load conditions:
On Monday, user one reaches a maximum demand of 100 amps;
on Tuesday, two reaches 95 amps;
on Wednesday, three reaches 85 amps;
on Thursday, four reaches 75 amps;
on Friday, five reaches 65 amps.
The feeder’s maximum demand is 250 amps.
the solution:
Diversity factor = Sum of total demands ÷ Maximum demand on feeder = 420 ÷ 250 = 1.68
Example#3:
Calculate the size of a main feeder from substation switchgear that is supplying five feeders with
connected loads of 400, 350, 300, 250 and 200 kilovolt-amperes (kVA) with demand factors of 95,
90, 85, 80 and 75 percent respectively. Use a diversity factor of 1.5.
the Solution
1- Calculate demand for each feeder:
400 kVA × 95% = 380 kVA
350 kVA × 90% = 315 kVA
300 kVA × 85% = 255 kVA
250 kVA × 80% = 200 kVA
200 kVA × 75% = 150 kVA
3- If the feeder were sized at unity diversity, then 1,300 kVA ÷ 1.00 = 1,300 kVA
However, using the diversity factor of 1.5, the kVA = 1,300 kVA ÷ 1.5 = 866 kVA for the feeder.
most of the electrical engineers confuse between the demand and diversity factors, to solve this
confusion, don't forget that:
The Demand factor must be applied to each individual load, with particular attention to
electric motors, which are very rarely operated at full load.
The Diversity Factor is applied to each group of loads (e.g. being supplied from a distribution
or sub-distribution board).
Example #4:
An industrial building consists of (3) nos. workshops A, B & C, each workshop will include the
following loads: Workshop A:
4 nos. lathe with 5 KVA each,
2 nos. pedestal drill with 2 KVA each,
5 nos. sockets outlets 10/16 A on one circuit with 18 KVA total,
30 nos. fluorescent lamps on one circuit with 3 KVA total.
Workshop B:
Workshop C:
2 nos. ventilation fans with 2.5 KVA each,
2 nos. Oven with 15 KVA each,
5 nos. sockets outlets 10/16 A on one circuit with 18 KVA total,
20 nos. fluorescent lamps on one circuit with 2 KVA total.
table#2
table#3
The solution:
fig.2
Step#1: List all the loads in each workshop and write the apparent power of each load in KVA beside
it.
Step#2: write the utilization factor for each load , IEC gives Ku estimation values for these loads as
follows:
Step#3: calculate the Max. demand apparent power in KVA for each load = apparent power X Ku for
each load.
Step# 4: group same type of loads on one distribution panel/box and this will be the first Level of
distribution (LEVEL 1).
Step# 5: in level 1 and from table #2, write the simultaneity factor for each distribution panel/box
and from table # 3 write the simultaneity factor for each for each separate load.
Step# 6: calculate the Max. demand apparent power in KVA for each distribution panel/box = sum of
all branch loads’ Max. demand apparent power in KVA X simultaneity factor for each distribution
panel/box.
Step# 7: group the distribution panel/box in each workshop in one main distribution panel/box. So,
we will have (3) main distribution panel/box for the (3) workshops and this will be the second level
of distribution (LEVEL 2).
Step# 8: in level 2 and from table #2, write the simultaneity factor for each main distribution
panel/box.
Step# 9: calculate the Max. Demand apparent power in KVA for each main distribution panel/box =
sum of all branch distribution boxes’ Max. Demand apparent power in KVA X simultaneity factor for
each main distribution panel/box.
Step# 10: group the (3) main distribution panel/box in one main general distribution board MGDB
and this will be the third level of distribution (LEVEL 3).
Step# 11: in level 3 and from table #2, write the main general distribution board MGDB.
Step# 12: calculate the Max. Demand apparent power in KVA for main general distribution board
MGDB = sum of the (3) workshop main distribution boxes’ Max. Demand apparent power in KVA X
simultaneity factor for main general distribution board MGDB.
8- Load factor
The load factor is the ratio of the average load over a designated period of time, usually 1 year, to
the maximum load occurring in that period. Load factor = Average load / Maximum load
Free download
you can download tables for different factors listed above by clicking the following links:
In the next topic, I will explain these methods for Electrical load estimation. so, please keep
following.
In the previous topic " Electrical Load Estimation – Part One " , I explain the definitions of the
most important terms in electrical load estimation and provides download links for factors used
in the electrical load estimation.
Note:
I will explain the (3) preliminary load estimation methods only in this course, and the two other
methods, NEC load calculations and Final load calculations will be explained later in course
" EE-3: Basic Electrical design course – Level II " , because these two methods are applied in
the final stages of design.
Note:
A particular design may use one Preliminary load estimate method or a combination from two or
even the three methods.
In the Space-by-Space Method, the building will be divided into different space based on its
function like offices, conference halls, corridors and lobbies, shops, parking areas, workshops
and etc. The Load density in (W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2) is prescribed for these different spaces,
these load densities in addition to spaces area will be used to estimate the preliminary
electrical load of this building as described in below.
The Space-by-Space Method is used only for individual spaces in the building.
The Space-by-Space Method may be used for any building or portion of a building.
Area Measurement in space by space method
The square footage is measured from the outside surface of exterior walls to the centerline of
walls between interior partitions of the spaces. The sum of the Gross Interior Area equals the
total Gross Area of the building.
First case: availability of grouped load density (i.e. one value covering all lighting,
general power and power loads) in (W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2) for each space.
Second case: availability of individual load density (i.e. individual values for lighting,
general power and power loads) in (W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2) for each space.
First case
3- Determine the grouped load density for each space (from tables).
4- Multiply each space gross interior area by its grouped load density to get the estimated
electrical load for this space.
5- Sum all the estimated electrical loads for all spaces to get the total preliminary electrical
load for the whole building.
6- Multiply the total preliminary electrical load for the whole building by the power factor value
(= 0.8) and a suitable load factor (for future extensions and losses compensations) to get the
main service size.
Example# 1:
For a high-rise office building with shopping arcade, the power supply has to be planned for a
10-story building (12 floors) with a floor area of approx. 25 m x 60 m.
There is a car park for customers in front of the building, the access way to the parking garage
(levels -1 to -3 for employees) and a fountain (80 m x 20 m). (Fig. 1)
Real floor area approx. 1350 m2 (14 levels + technical equipment on roof level).
Floor heights of levels 00 to +10: 4 m, levels -1 to -3: 3 m
Calculate main electrical service size for this building.
Fig (1)
The solution:
Consider first case: availability of grouped load density for each space. Hence, calculations will
be as follows:
Parking garage / utilities areas (incl. roof area) Basement levels -1 to -3 with 1,350 m2 each +
utilities areas ca. 210 m2 (areas between utilities hubs), Area = (3 x 1,350 m2 + 210 m2) = 4260
m2
Shopping center / bank Ground level 00 with 1,350 m2 Area = 1 x 1,350 m2 = 1350 m2
Table# 1
3- Determine the grouped load density for each space (from table#1) as follows:
4- Multiply each space gross interior area by its grouped load density to get the estimated electrical
load for this space as follows:
Parking garage / utilities areas (incl. roof area) Estimated electrical load = (3 x 1,350 m2 + 210 m2)
x 10 W/m2 = 42,600 W
Shopping center / bank
Estimated electrical load = 1 x 1,350 m2 x 120 W/m2 = 162,000 W
5- Sum all the estimated electrical loads for all spaces to get the total preliminary electrical load
for the whole building.
Total preliminary electrical load for the whole building = 42,600 + 162,000 + 1,485,000 = 1,690
kW
The established total power demand determines the required transformer output. The
determination is based on a cos phi = 0.85 and a transformer load level of 70%.
Transformer output rating = 1,690 kW / (0.7 x 0.85) = 2,840 kVA
Second Case
1- Divide the building into different space based on its function (for example, office, storage,
mechanical, and corridor).
3- Calculate the estimated lighting, small appliance and power loads for each space as follows:
Electric power loads shall include all loads other than lighting loads and those served by
general purpose receptacles and comprise the environmental system electric power requirements
and the facility occupancy equipment electric power requirements.
HVAC Equipment
Use the same method for small appliance loads
These loads are related to the whole building and not related to the divided spaces. So, The
Space-by-Space Method cann’t estimate the required ratings for these loads and we must use the
building method for this purpose.
4- After computing the preliminary electrical loads for each space, we must sum all of them to get
the total preliminary electrical load for the whole building.
Example# 2 :
Consider the same building in example# 1 to be solved if individual load densities are known for
each load type as follows:
Lighting 7
Parking Garage / Utilities Areas (Incl. Roof
Small Appliance 3
Area)
Power Load Inc. in building power
Lighting 28
Shopping Center / Bank Small Appliance 20
Power Load Inc. in building power
Lighting 28
Offices Small Appliance 20
Power Load Inc. in building power
HVAC - Pumps -
Building Power Load 60
Elevators - Others
Estimated
Load Estimated Electrical
Space Area Load
Density Load Load For
Space
Small
Offices 13,500 20 270,000 648,000 VA
Appliance
HVAC –
Building Power Pumps –
14,850 60 891,000 891,000 VA
Load Elevators –
Others
Free download
In the next topic, I will explain Other methods for preliminary electrical load calculations. So,
please keep following.
In the previous topic " Electrical Load Estimation – Part One ", I explain the definitions of the
most important terms in electrical load estimation and provides download links for factors used
in the electrical load estimation.
I explained the first method of preliminary load calculations; Space by space (functional area
method)in the previous topic " Electrical Load Estimation – Part Two "
Today, I will explain other methods for electrical load estimations, which are:
The Building Area method is used for buildings, to some extent, bigger than that can be handled
by the Space by space method, although it is easier than the Space by space method as you
estimate the electrical load based on the activity of the whole building unlike the Space by
space method which need dividing the building into multi-areas with different activities.
Power Allowances (densities) under the two methods are similar for buildings with typical
space distributions, but may vary depending on the space distributions in particular buildings.
In general the Building Area Method is easier to use than the Space-by-Space Method, but
the Space-by-Space Method offers greater flexibility.
In addition, the Space-by-Space Method allows the use of the Additional Interior Lighting
Power Allowance for certain specific uses.
Total Gross Area will be used in the Building Area Method and the square footage is
measured from the outside surface of exterior walls, or from the outside surface of exterior
walls to the center line of walls between building types.
First case: availability of grouped load density (i.e. one value for the whole building) in
(W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2).
Second case : availability of individual load density (i.e. individual values for lighting,
general power and power loads) in (W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2) for the whole building.First case
First Case:
availability of grouped load density (i.e. one value for the whole building) in (W/ft2) or/and
(VA/ft2). Hence, Method of estimation by using building area Method will be as follows:
2. Determine the building type/usage (use a reasonable equivalent if the specific building type
is not listed);
3. Determine the load density in (W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2) from the Tables for that building
type,
4. Calculate the preliminary electrical load by multiplying the total gross area of the building by
its load density.
5- Multiply the preliminary electrical load for the building by the power factor value (= 0.8) and
a suitable load factor (for future extensions and losses compensations) to get the main service
size.
Example #1:
15 90
Calculate the total preliminary electrical load for transformer(s) feeding an academic building
which has (4) floors with a floor area 3250 m2, and calculations to be done for the following
cases:
Building with air conditioning,
Building without air conditioning.
The solution:
Second case:
availability of individual load density (i.e. individual values for lighting, general power and power
loads) in (W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2) for the whole building. Hence, Method of estimation by using
building area Method will be as follows:
1- Calculate the total Gross Area for the building;
2- Determine the building type/usage (use a reasonable equivalent if the specific building type is
not listed);
3- Determine the load density in (W/ft2) or/and (VA/ft2) from the Tables for that building type for
each load type i.e. for lighting, small appliances, power loads.
4- Multiply the total gross area of the building by the assigned Lighting / small appliances /power
load densities to get the estimated lighting / small appliances /power electrical loads for this
building.
5- Take into your consideration the following points:
6- Sum the estimated lighting load plus the estimated small appliances load plus the estimated
power loads to get the total estimated electrical loads.
7- Multiply the total estimated electrical load for the whole building by the power factor value (=
0.8) and a suitable load factor (for future extensions and losses compensations) to get the main
service size.
Example#2:
A (4) floors office building with a floor area 2000 SF, calculate the total preliminary electrical load
for the transformer(s) feeding this building By using The following tables from ASHRAE and IEEE.
The solution:
3- From above ASHRAE and IEEE tables, the load densities will be as follows:
Lighting = 1.81 W/SF
Small appliances = 1 VA/SF
Air conditioning = 6 VA/SF
5- The total estimated electrical load for the Building = 14,480 + 8,000 + 48,000 = 70,480 Watt =
70.5 KW
6- The preliminary electrical load is based on a cos phi = 0.85 and a transformer load level of 70%.
7- Transformer output rating for the Building = 70.5 kW / (0.7 x 0.85) = 118.5 kVA (in some
regulations, this load can be feed from utility low voltage network without the need for a
transformer substation inside the user’s premises)
Free download
In the next topic, I will explain the Third method for preliminary electrical load calculations;
Area method. So, please keep following.
In the previous topic " Electrical Load Estimation – Part One ", I explain the definitions of the most
important terms in electrical load estimation and provides download links for factors used in the
electrical load estimation.
I explained the first method of preliminary load calculations; Space by space (functional area
method) in the previous topic " Electrical Load Estimation – Part Two ". Also, I explained the
second method; Building Area method in the previous topic " Electrical Load Estimation – Part
Three “.
Today, I will explain the third method for electrical load estimations which is Area method.
Area method is used for Area loads which consist of groups of individual building loads that be
constructed on a large area and will be served by a same subdivision of the electric distribution
system.
Examples for cases where area loads method will be applied are industrial, residential, commercial
and military areas. The area method will be used for the design of substations serving these areas.
Industrial Area
This method is used for one level of electrical distribution inside the area (i.e. the feeders for
individual buildings originated from the main substation switchgear) and the steps of calculations
will be as follows:
Step #1: list the buildings names included in the area and determine the numbers of
identical buildings.
Step#2: calculate the total connected load for each building by using the one or both of the
previous methods; Space by Space and building area.
Step#3: determine the classification of each building from table #1.
Step#4: determine the demand factor for each building from table #1.
Step# 5: determine the load factor for each building from table #1.
Step# 6: find the coincidence factor for each building from table #1.
Step# 7: calculate the building demand load, where:
Building Demand load = building connected load (step# 2) x demand factor (step# 4) x coincidence
factor (step# 6)
Step# 8: calculate the total building demand for the identical buildings, where
Total building demand (for identical buildings) = building demand (step# 7) X number of identical
buildings
Step# 9: calculate the general loads for this area which include roadway lighting, area
lighting, obstruction lighting, and other loads not included in individual building loads.
Step# 10: calculate the total Area demand, where:
Total Area demand = ∑ (All total buildings demands from step# 8)+ general load (step# 9)
Step# 11: apply a load growth factor of 25% and calculate the final total Area demand,
where:
This method is used for multi levels of electrical distributions inside the area (i.e. each group of
individual buildings can be connected to sub-main switchgear far from the main substation
switchgear. The calculation steps will be as follows:
Example:
An airforce base has a maintenance area including the following buildings:
Calculate the main electrical service size for this area using the building connected loads indicated
above.
The solution:
By using table #1 and the basic method described above for estimating the electrical load of an
area, the following table summarizes the solution steps:
Free download
You can download an excel worksheet for preliminary load calculation as per area method b y
clicking Here.
1- Method combination
A particular design may use one Preliminary load estimate method or a combination from two or
even the three methods.
2- System loss
A system loss of approximately 6 %, based on calculated maximum demand, should be added to the
preliminary building load.
3- Load growth
Determine the requirements for load growth for anticipated usage and life expectancy with
particular attention to the possibility of adding heavy loads in the form of air conditioning, electric
heating, electric data processing, and electronic communication equipment. No more than 10%
spare capacity will be considered during design unless otherwise noted.
Free download