Composite Fish Farming: A Review On Economic Enterprise For Rural Empowerment and Livelihood Generation
Composite Fish Farming: A Review On Economic Enterprise For Rural Empowerment and Livelihood Generation
E-ISSN: 2347-5129
P-ISSN: 2394-0506
(ICV-Poland) Impact Value: 5.62 Composite fish farming: A review on economic
(GIF) Impact Factor: 0.549
IJFAS 2018; 6(4): 545-550 enterprise for rural empowerment and livelihood
© 2018 IJFAS
www.fisheriesjournal.com generation
Received: 15-05-2018
Accepted: 16-06-2018
Bhanu Prakash CH, Sachin Onkar Khairnar, Amit Mandal, Anil Kumar
Bhanu Prakash CH
Farm Science Centre, Tarn Taran
and Balwinder Kumar
Guru Angad Dev Veterinary and
Animal Sciences University, Abstract
Ludhiana, Punjab, India Composite farming is poly-species farming at any scale, which is found to be highly profitable because
of the low input costs. But no longer continues, as the cost of basic inputs like cow dung, poultry manure,
Sachin Onkar Khairnar ground nut oil cake, mustard oil cake, rice bran and land costs has increased by many folds while the gate
Department of Aquaculture
value of the fish remained almost constant. Quality of water, fish seed, feed and health management is
College of Fisheries, Guru Angad
essential prerequisite for optimizing production and productivity from inland fisheries and aquaculture in
Dev Veterinary and Animal
Sciences University, Ludhiana, the country. Composite fish farming in pond culture system consists of Indian major carps (IMC) (Catla
Punjab, India catla, Labeo rohita and Cirrhinus mrigala) and exotic major carps (Hypophthalmicthys molitrix,
Ctenopharyngodon idella and Cyprinus carpio). This system is a practical alteration of the original three
Amit Mandal species IMC polyculture so as to fulfill the vacant niches in a pond ecosystem for optimizing internal
Department of Aquaculture resource utilization and thereby a means of increasing productivity. Polyculture of compatible fish
College of Fisheries, Guru Angad species is the most ecologically sound fish culture practice which facilitates efficient utilization of all
Dev Veterinary and Animal ecological zones within the pond environment enhancing the maximum standing crop and the
Sciences University, Ludhiana, empowerment for rural youth, which in turn will enhance food and nutritional security.
Punjab, India
Keywords: Composite culture, species composition, fish production, sustainable development, food
Anil Kumar security, livelihood generation
Farm Science Centre, Tarn Taran
Guru Angad Dev Veterinary and
Animal Sciences University, 1. Introduction
Ludhiana, Punjab, India Indian fisheries and aquaculture is an important sector of food production, providing
nutritional security to the food basket, contributing to the agricultural exports and engaging
Balwinder Kumar about fourteen million people in different activities. It ranks second in the world in fish
Farm Science Centre, Tarn Taran
Guru Angad Dev Veterinary and
production which increased from 0.7 metric tonnes in 1951 to 10.79 metric tonnes in 2015-16
Animal Sciences University, where, aquaculture contributed 78% of the country's total fish production [1]. Constituting
Ludhiana, Punjab, India about 6.3% of the global fish production, the sector contributes to 1.1% of the total GDP and
5.15% of the agricultural GDP with annual export earnings of 33, 441.61 crore rupees for the
year 2016-17 [2]. Besides, 14 million people are employed in fisheries related auxiliary
activities. Paradigm shifts in terms of increasing contributions from inland sector and further
from aquaculture are significations over the years. In 1957, the first successful induced
breeding on major carps was done by Dr. Hiralal Chaudhuri, father of blue revolution on
Cirrhinus mrigala, C. reba and Labeo rohita, which ultimately triggered the growth of inland
aquaculture sector of the country. Even though hatchery bred seed was available, farming of
major carps primarily continued as IMC polyculture with combinations of three to four species
incorporating with minor carps.
India offers a huge potential for freshwater aquaculture development as it is blessed with
extensive river and canal system of about 195.210 km, consisting of 14 major rivers, 44
medium rivers and numerous small rivers and streams. In addition, pond and tank resources
are estimated at 2.36 mha [3, 4]. Aquaculture development is closely related to the development
Correspondence of the ability of the farmer’s understanding and adoption of new technology and they should
Bhanu Prakash Ch be supplied with recent, useful and practical information on the subject [5]. Aquaculture
Farm Science Centre, Tarn Taran production models are highly dynamic, unless we assess the economics and understand the
Guru Angad Dev Veterinary and scale of economy of any given activity, system not sustains [6].
Animal Sciences University,
Ludhiana, Punjab, India
~ 545 ~
International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies
Fish is the cheapest and most easily digestible animal protein recent years in the development of agriculture and human
and was obtained from natural sources from time immemorial health. The study concluded that the increased application of
for consumption by human beings. This significant growth in technological tools could certainly revolutionize country’s
fish consumption has enhanced people’s diets around the fish farming besides its roles in biodiversity conservation.
world through diversified and nutritious food [7]. The quality Farmers and entrepreneurs tend to go under great loss by
of fish protein is high because it contains amino acids in the investing in aquaculture activities without understanding the
amount and proportions required for good nutrition and economics of fish farming in ideal condition. Many of the
provides a good source of vitamins, minerals and iodine [8]. research results are lacking the critical evaluation from the
However, due to over exploitation and pollution, the economic edge and do not find a place in the field.
availability of fish in natural waters has declined considerably
forcing scientists to adopt various methods to increase its 1.2 Fish species for composite fish culture
production. Fish farming in controlled or under artificial Depending on the compatibility and type of feeding habit of
conditions has become the easier way of increasing the fish the fishes, the following Indian as well as Exotic carp species
production and its availability for consumption. Farmers can has been recommended for culture in the composite fish
easily take up fish culture in village ponds, tanks or any new culture technology (Table-1) [12]. Both catla and silver carps
water body and can improve their financial position are surface feeder. Catla feeds on zooplankton while silver
substantially. It also creates gainful employment for skilled carp mainly prefers phytoplankton [13] and it has ecological
and unskilled youths. and socio-economic potential advantages with having a strong
impact on the pond ecology because it is a fast growing and
1.1 Composite fish farming very efficient filter-feeder [14, 15]. Grass carp consume low
The technology developed for fish culture in which value vegetative waste and increase natural food production in
compatible and non-competing fishes are cultured the pond by nutrient recycling and faecal production [16].
simultaneously through the utilization of different feeding Mrigal is bottom feeder and considered to monitor culture and
zones (all the natural niches) from a pond so as to increase the health status in farm condition [17]. Common carp has more
total production from unit area of water is known as rapid growth and known as bioturbator [18]. However, it not
composite fish farming and it is the most popular culture only increases food availability but also changes feeding
technique in the country. Any perennial fresh water pond behavior and food intake of Rohu [19].
retaining water depth of 2 m can be used for fish culture
purpose. However, the minimum level should not fall below 1 Table 1: List of fishes for composite carp culture with their feeding
m. Even seasonal ponds can also be utilized for short duration habits and feeding zones
fish culture [9]. Species Feeding habit Feeding zone
Carp composite culture where compatible carp species, Indian Indian Major Carps (IMCs)
major carps (catla, Catla catla; rohu, Labeo rohita; mrigal, Catla Zooplankton feeder Surface feeder
Cirrhinus mrigala) and exotic carps (grass carp, Rohu Omnivorous Column feeder
Ctenopharyngodon idella; silver carp, Hypophthalmichthys Mrigal Detritivorous Bottom feeder
molitrix; common carp, Cyprinus carpio) are reared together Exotic carps (ECs)
in the same pond was introduced by the Central Inland Silver carp Phytoplankton feeder Surface feeder
Fisheries Research Institute during the 1970s [10]. Three Grass carp Herbivorous
Surface, column
strategies can be followed in composite carp fish farming as and marginal areas
the first one is the low input or fertilizer based system, Common carp Detritivorous/Omnivorous Bottom feeder
practiced mostly in small community ponds, with multiple
uses and open access. It requires only low levels of 1.3 Potential
investment. The level of adaption and impact are also low The inland fisheries sector in India is endowed with rich
since aquaculture is practiced mostly in community village aquatic and fishery resources. The sector offers ample scope
ponds with multiple uses. These are utilized as common pool for fisheries and aquaculture development. But there is wide
resources and it is difficult to adopt all culture practices gap between actual fish production and potential as open
recommended in the technology. Further, privatization of water bodies are not utilized to the optimum. The potential
aquaculture activity in general and the returns from it in fishery resources and areas are untapped. Generally, culture
particular is constrained by management and property regimes practices are highly eco sustainable and compatible with other
for these water bodies. The second strategy is to medium farming systems. Therefore there is scope for intensification
input or fertilizer and feed based system which is prevalent in and diversification of aquaculture practices for optimal
medium sized to large sized private ponds with moderate to utilization of aquatic resources. The area under tanks and
high investments. The levels of adoption and impact are high, ponds available for warm fresh water aquaculture including
despite problems of scarcity of quality input, limited access to swamps, beels etc, and low lying water logged area not good
infrastructures and low remuneration. The last strategy for agriculture as also any land where there is copious water
prevalent in composite carp farming is a high input or supply can be converted for fish farming. Out of the total
intensive feed and aeration based system. This practice is inland fish production of 10.79 lakh tonnes around 65% is
generally followed in medium sized private ponds with high contributed by the aquaculture sector. More than 5
investments and risk bearing ability. In this practice, generally tonnes/ha/yr fish production is achieved from the average
inputs use is higher than recommended levels, and therefore, pond size of 0.6 to 1 ha [20]. This shows the tremendous scope
the adoption level is very high. It leads to high risk, low for fish culture in the country. Only 15 % of the potential area
ecological sustainability and low benefit cost ratios. The of tanks and ponds available is developed so far, showing
impact in this case is moderate. Lakra and Ayyappan [11] immense possibilities for horizontal expansion of composite
revealed that the subject has assumed greater importance in fish culture [21].
~ 546 ~
International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies
2. Pond management protocols with increase in pond depth from 5 to 9 feet [31]. Weed fishes
The main criteria to be kept in mind while selecting the pond (e.g. Puntius sp., Oxygaster sp., Ambassis sp.,
is that the soil should be water retentive, adequate quality Amblypharyngodon mola, Colisa sp., Rasbora sp., etc.) are
water supply is available and that the pond is not in a flood those which compete with the culturable species of fishes for
prone area. Derelict, semi derelict or swampy ponds can be food, space and oxygen and causing serious problem to fish
renovated for fish culture by dewatering, desilting, repair of culture [32]. Removal of unwanted fish through physical
the embankments and provision of inlet and outlet. The pond methods like dewatering and de-silting of ponds, repeated
may be owned by the individual or taken on lease. Technical netting operations, hooks and lines with baits are found to be
parameters of composite fish culture which includes site incomplete and uneconomical [36]. In practical field farmers
selection, pre-stocking, stocking and post stocking operations. use pesticides viz. Nuvan (Dichlorvos or 2, 2-dichlorovinyl
Pond Management plays a very important role in fish farming dimethyl phosphate), Ustaad (Cypermethrin) etc [32].
before and after the stocking of fish seed. Management
protocols adopted in composite fish culture can be divided 2.1.3 Liming
into pre-stocking management, stock management and post- Lime is used to bring the pH to the desired level. In addition,
stocking management. lime also acts as buffer and avoids fluctuations of pH,
increases the resistance of soil to parasites, its toxic effect
2.1 Pre-stocking management kills the parasites; and it accelerates organic decomposition.
The popular English proverb “prevention is better than cure” Lime application has many benefits in culture pond system
teaches us to follow preventive methods is perfectly viz. (i) neutralization of acidity (ii) increase in pH of bottom
applicable in aquaculture, therefore proper management soil and thereby enhancing the availability of phosphorus
starting from the pond preparation is very essential. added in fertilizer, (iii) accelerating the microbial activity and
thereby diminishing the accumulation of organic matter in
2.1.1 Eradication of aquatic insects and weeds pond bottoms and favouring recycling of nutrients, (iv)
The major pond preparation phase starts with removal of maintaining the alkalinity and other physico-chemical
aquatic insect and weed clearance by manual/mechanical characteristics of soil which in turn helps in enhancing
effort or by chemical means, as aquatic weeds hamper fish/shrimp production, and, (v) improving the hygienic
primary productivity and prevents normal penetration of sun condition of pond bottom [30]. The normal doses of the lime
light at the pond bottom and reduce the disturbance of water ranges from 200 to 250 Kg/ha. However, the actual dose has
surface due to wind action upsetting the oxygen balance, to be calculated based on pH of the soil and water is given in
creates obstruction for fishes and during netting operations. (Table-2):
However noval and different methods must be employed to
control aquatic insects. Spraying oil to kill the insects, which Table 2: Lime doses with respect to soil pH
come up to the surface to respire, is a well-known principle Soil pH 4.5-5.0 5.1-6.5 6.6-7.5 7.6-8.5 8.6-9.5
and a routine practice in malaria control. It is well known that Lime (kg/ha) 2,000 1,000 500 200 Nil
aquatic insects and other predators cause considerable damage
to the carp fry in the nursery ponds and there are several The pond is required to be filled with rain water or water from
methods to control them [21-25]. A successful method for other sources viz., canal, tube well etc. after liming in case it
control of predatory insects to be applied 12 to 24 hours is a new pond.
before stocking, developed at CIFRI’s Cuttack centre,
consists of spraying, on a still day, an emulsion of mustard or 2.1.4 Fertilization/Manuring
coconut oil and cheap washing soap in the ratio 56:18 kg per Fertilization of the pond is an important means for
ha [26]. The back swimmers (Notoneclidae) are killed within intensifying fish culture by increasing the natural productivity
half an hour. Higher doses, however, kill water boatman of the pond and as a means of increasing fish production is
(Family: Corixidae) beetle larvae and bugs. Teepol B-300 (a well accepted [31]. The fertilization schedule has to be
detergent synthesized by Burmah Shell) in the emulsion is prepared after studying the quality of the pond soil. A
substitution of soap [27]. It is a neutral amber-coloured liquid, combination of both organic and inorganic fertilizers may be
readily soluble in water, unaffected by hard or brackish water used for best results. The fertilizer schedule has to be suitably
and is easy to mix with oil. The commended dose of Teepol is modified depending on the growth of the fish, available food
560 ml, emulsified with 56 kg of mustard oil. reserve in the pond, physic-chemical conditions of the pond
and climatic conditions. Organic manure to be applied after a
2.1.2 Eradication of predatory and weed fish gap of three days from the date of liming. Cowdung @ 5000
It is done by repeated netting or by using mahua oil cake @ kg/ha or any other organic manure in equivalent manurial
2500 kg/ha or by sun drying the pond bed, maintenance of value is also used for aquaculture ponds. Inorganic
physico-chemical quality of water, manuring by using cow fertilization to be undertaken after 15 days of organic
dung, poultry droppings etc. and liming with quick lime for manuring. Requirement of nitrogenous and phosphate
regulating pH of pond water [28]. Depth of the pond is fertilizers would vary as per the nature of the soil fertility
considered as one of the most important factors in indicated below (Table-3). However any one of the nitrogen
productivity [29]. In general, productivity declines with and phosphate fertilizers could be used as per given rate.
increase in pond size [30], while production level decline’s
~ 547 ~
International Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Studies
3. Vertical expansion of fish culture Fisheries Development Board (NFDB) details of which may
A number of measures are now being employed by the be obtained from concerned Fisheries Departments or from
entrepreneurs to increase the per hectare production of fish. the website of NFDB.
Important measures adopted are stocking of advanced
fingerlings/yearlings by stunning the growth of fish seed 3.2 Eligible Borrowers
during first year, heavy stocking and multiple harvesting after The following categories of borrowers are eligible to avail
the fishes attain a size of 500 g [40]. Multiple stocking and subsidy.
multiple harvesting, use of aerators, integrated fish farming An Individual.
with animal husbandry activities like dairy, poultry, piggery A company.
or duckery to get daily organic manuring to the pond thus A Partnership firm.
increasing its fertility. It is possible to increase the per hectare A co-operative society.
production of fish to 5-7 tonnes per ha per year by employing A group of fish farmers.
different methods as indicated above.
Training in fish farming is being provided by the FFDA's to
3.1 Subsidy the eligible borrowers and it is essential that the borrower has
Subsidy is available for various items like renovation/ repair prior knowledge of fish farming before availing the
of ponds, construction of new ponds, first year inputs etc. subsidy/bank loan.
under a centrally sponsored subsidy scheme implemented by
majority of the State Governments through FFDA's for 4. Financial Outlay
different categories of farmers and also from National
production. Aquaculture Extension Manual New Series, effect on fish growth in composite culture. Pakistan
No. 2, CIFRI, Barrackpore. 1985; 4:6-26. Journal Agricultural Science. 2011; 48(4):321-326.
13. Lazzaro X. A review of planktivorous fishes: their 31. Chakrabarty RD, Sen PR, Chatterjee DK, Jena S. On the
evolution, feeding behaviours, selectivities and impacts. use of fertilizers and supplementary feed for enhancing
Hydrobiologia. 1987; 146:97-167. fish production in freshwater ponds, National Academy
14. Milstein A. Ecological aspects of fish species interactions of Science, India. 1975; 45B(3):192-196.
in polyculture ponds, Hydrobiologia. 1992; 231:177-186. 32. Huet M. Text book of fish culture- breeding and
15. Milstein A, Hepher B, Teltsch B. Interactions between cultivation of fish London, Fishing News (Books)
fish species and the ecological conditions in mono and Limited, 1986, 1-436.
polyculture pond system 1, Aquaculture and Fisheries 33. Rahman MM, Verdegem MCJ, Nagelkerke LAJ, Wahab
Management. 1985; 16:305-317. MA, Milstein A, Verreth JAJ. Growth, production and
16. Li SF, Mathias J. Fresh water fish culture in China: food preference of rohu Labeo rohita (H.) in monoculture
Principles and practices, Elsevier. 1990; (2):34-39. and in polyculture with common carp Cyprinus carpio
17. Ahmed GU, Konica K, Ali MF, Khatun T. Investigation (L.) under fed and non-fed ponds, Aquaculture. 2006;
on culture and health status of Mrigal Cirrhinus cirrhosus 257:359-372.
from the farming system of Mymensingh region, Journal 34. Datta MK. Advances in composite fish farming of carps
of Bangladesh Agricultural University. 2013; 11(2):391- in tropical state of Tripura, India, 2014.
397. 35. Ahmad M, Abbas S, Javid A, Ashraf M, Khalid JI,
18. Dey MM, Rab MA, Paraguas FJ, Piumsombun S, Azmat H et al. Effect of varying stocking density of
Ramachandra B, Alam MF et al. Fish consumption and bottom feeder fish Cirrhinus mrigala and Cyprinus
food security: a disaggregated analysis by types of fish carpio on growth performance and fish yield in
and classes of consumers in selected Asian countries, polyculture system, International Journal of Fisheries and
Aquaculture Economics and Management. 2005; 9(1, Aquaculture. 2013; 5(11):278-285.
2):89-111. 36. Nandeesha MC, Sentilkumar V, Antony Jesu Prabhu P.
19. Anras MLB, Beauchaud M, Juell JE, Coves D, Lagardere Feed management of major carps in India, with special
JP. Environmental factors and feed intake: rearing reference to practices adopted in Tamil Nadu. In M.R.
systems. In: Food Intake in Fish (Ed. by D. Houlihan, T. Hasan and M.B. New, eds. On-farm feeding and feed
Boujard & M. Jobling), Blackwell, Oxford. 2001, 157- management in aquaculture. FAO Fisheries and
188. Aquaculture Technical Paper No. 583. Rome, FAO,
20. Biswas B, Das SK, Mandal A. Socio-economic 2013, 433-462.
dimensions and their impacts upon productivity of 37. Debnath M, Nandeesha MC, Dhawan A, Anand V, Paul
composite fish farming in north 24 parganas district, A, Roy M. Economics of aquaculture feeding practices:
West Bengal, Journal of Entomology and Zoology Punjab, India. In M.R. Hasan, ed. Economics of
Studies. 2018; 6(2):1131-1135 aquaculture feeding practices in selected Asian countries,
21. Alikunhi KH. On the food of young carp fry. Journal of pp. 101–122. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper No. 505.
Zoological Society of India. 1952; 4(1):77-84. Rome, FAO. 2007, 205.
22. Alikunhi KH. Fish culture in India. Farmers Bulletin 38. Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR).
(Indian Council of Agricultural Research). 1957; 20:1- Composite Fish Culture in Ponds Extension Folder
144. Number 69 Goa, India, 2014.
23. Chaudhuri H. Contribution to the techniques of pond fish 39. Asala G. Principles of Integrated Aquaculture. In: AA
culture in India. D. Phil Thesis, University Of Calcutta, Olatunde; Gabriel et al. 1994, 307.
1960. 40. Hussain SM, Sen D, Pathak M, Singh MP. Comparative
24. Ganguly DN, Mitra B. Observation on the fish fry study of composite fish culture (CFC) and local practices
destroying capacity of certain aquatic and the suggestion of fish culture in East Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh,
for their eradication. Indian Agriculturist. 1961; Indian Journal of Hill Farming. 2013; 26(2):32-34.
5(11):184-188.
25. Khan, Hussain A. A note on the destruction of carp fry by
larvae of aquatic insects. Proceedings of Indian Science
Congress. 1947; 34(3):184.
26. Pakrasi B. Preliminary observations on the control of
aquatic insects in nursery ponds. Proceedings of the
Indian Academy of Sciences B. 1953; 38(4):211-213.
27. Chatterjee SN. Central Institute of Fishery Education,
Annual day Souvenir, 1970.
28. Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). Farm ponds
for water, fish and livelihoods, diversification booklet
number 13. Eds, James W. Miller. Rural Infrastructure
and Agro-Industries Division Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations, Rome, 2009.
29. Rath RK. Freshwater Aquaculture, Scientific Publisher,
Jodhpur, India, 1993, 493
30. Hussain M, Hussain SM, Afzal M, Raza SA, Hussain N.
Mubarik MS. Comparative study of replacement of maize
gluten with rice bran (3:1 and 1:3) feed supplement:
~ 550 ~