JGR 7551 Moos
JGR 7551 Moos
net/publication/248792888
Elastic wave velocities within oceanic layer 2 from sonic full waveform logs in
Deep Sea Drilling Project Holes 395A, 418A, and 504B
CITATIONS READS
22 10
3 authors:
Mike Lovell
University of Leicester
157 PUBLICATIONS 1,060 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Deep drilling of ocean basement 1: DSDP/ODP Hole 504B (equatorial Pacific Ocean) View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Philippe Adrien Pezard on 04 February 2020.
Elastic Wave Velocities Within Oceanic Layer 2 From Sonic Full Waveform
Logs in Deep Sea Drilling Project Holes 395A, 418A, and 504B
DANIEL MOOS
PHILIPPE PEZARD
MICHAEL LOVELL
Multichannel full waveform acoustic logs were recorded in Deep Sea Drilling Project (DSDP) hole
418A during Ocean Drilling Program (ODP) leg 102, DSDP hole 395A during ODP leg 109, and DSDP
hole 504B during ODP leg 111, to provide nearly continuous measurementsof elastic wave velocities
as a function of depth within oceanic layer 2 for different spreading rates and crustal ages. The
velocities depend primarily on the morphologyof the basalt. Massive units have Vp above 5 km/s, Vs
above 2.8 km/s, and Vp/Vs below 1.9. Their velocities increase with depth as expected from crack
closure due to confiningstressand are lower where fractures are present. Vp and Vs within pillows are
quite variable but in general are lower than in massive units, and Vp/Vs is higher. Velocities within
breccias are similar to or lower than those of pillows. Within a given morphology the elastic properties
do not depend on spreadingrate. Within pillows, velocity variations depend primarily on the degree
of alteration infilling and the mineralogy of the infilling matedhal,and secondadhlyon conditions at
emplacement. Coherent shear arrivals are sometimesnot found within shallow pillows, and in extreme
casesthe compressionalarrival is also incoherent, because of scattering resulting from the similarity
between the sonic wavelength and the pillow size. This "sampling bias" in the sonic log is the most
likely cause of somewhat higher average sonic than seismic velocities measured within extrusive
basalts at shallow depths. Other causes include the fact that laterally finite massive units may be
oversampledby borehole measurementsand that voids between pillows and fractures, whose size is
within an order of magnitude of the sonic wavelength, have less effect on sonic than on seismic
velocities. The crustal section can be separatedonly roughly into seismic layers on the basis of the
sonic velocities. Changesin velocity with depth within the extrusive section at a single site giving rise
to previously defined seismiclayers 2A and 2B are due to a changewith depth in the properties of the
pillows, associated with differences in the amount and type of infilling matedhals,rather than to a
change with depth in the relative proportion of pillows and massive units. Because alteration occurs
early and its history is different at different depths,depth-dependentvariationsin pillow properties are
(1) establishedat young age and (2) persisteven in old crust. Within the intrusive section of DSDP hole
504B, velocities are similar to or higher than those measured in saturated minicores at atmospheric
pressure, and seismic and sonic velocities are approximately equal, suggestingthat little large-scale
porosity is present.
basaltic layer of the oceanic crust (Figure 1, panel a). Layer Multichannel full waveform acoustic logs have been re-
2A, with P wave velocities averaging 3.64 km/s; layer 2B, corded to date in oceanic basalts at three sites, the locations
with velocities averaging 5.19 km/s; and layer 2C, with of which are shown in Figure 2. Hole 395A was drilled into
velocities averaging6.09 km/s, are underlain by layer 3, with 7.3-Ma crust near the center of magnetic anomaly 4, approx-
P wave velocities averaging 6.87 km/s. By analogy with imately 110 km west of the mid-Atlantic Ridge. Hole 418A
ophiolites and direct comparison to the core recovered by was drilled into 110-Ma crust on the southern tip of the
Bermuda Rise in the western Atlantic Ocean. The crust at
DSDP drilling, layer 2A is assumed to be composed prima-
rily of pillow basalts, 2B of pillows and massiveunits, 2C of sites 395 and 418 is inferred to have been produced at the
sheeted dikes, and 3 of gabbros. The thickness of layer 2A same point (approximately 23øN) on the mid-Atlantic Ridge.
Hole 504B was drilled into 5.3-Ma crust about 200 km south
decreases with increasing age, in the Pacific from 700 m at
the ridge to 100 m in 30-Ma crust and in the Atlantic from of the Costa Rica Rift. As such, these three holes sample
1500 m at the ridge to 100 m in 60-Ma crust. Spudich and young and old crust generated at the slow spreading rate
Orcutt [1980] pointed out that the seismic layering was an mid-Atlantic Ridge and young crust generated at the inter-
artifact introduced by the refraction geometry and developed mediate spreading rate Costa Rica Rift.
an alternative model using inversion techniques and syn-
Hole 395A
thetic seismograms that included velocity gradients (e.g.,
Figure 1, panel b). However, seismicand borehole geophys- Hole 395A, drilled during DSDP leg 45, penetrates 93 m of
ical data are still interpreted using the terminology of Houtz sediments and 571 m of basement [Melson et al., 1978]. The
and Ewing [1976]. uppermost112 m were cased, and well bore instabilitiesat a
More recent seismic investigations [Purdy, 1987] reveal brecciated dolerite zone caused loss of the hole below that
extremely low velocities (<2.35 km/s) at the top of basement depth, leaving the basement section open between 112 and
in very young (mid-Atlantic Ridge) crust. Young (< 180 kyr) 609 meters below sea floor (mbsf). Core recovery was
crust on the East Pacific Rise (EPR) has a -100- to 200- extremely low, ranging from less than 6% in a sedimentary
m-thick surfacelayer with P wave velocities of 2.35-2.6 km/s breccia at the top of basement(now largely behind casing)to
and S wave velocities below 0.8 km/s [Harding et al., 1989; 32% in the interval 174-210 mbsf. The recovered basalts
Vera, 1989]. Results further off the axis of the mid-ocean were subdivided into phyric and aphyric units. Combined
ridges suggestthat this feature is ephemeral. For instance, a analysisof recovered cores and of geophysicallogs recorded
singlevelocity of 4.1 km/s provides an adequatefit to seismic during ODP leg 109 resulted in the lithostratigraphic column
resultsfor the uppermost250 m of 7.3-Ma Atlantic crust near shown in Figure 3. Although the recovered material includes
DSDP hole 395A [Purdy, 1987], and in 15-Ma Pacific crust most of the lithologies inferred from later logging, the log
the uppermost low-velocity layer is similarly not observed measurements indicate their true vertical extent. For exam-
[Spudich and Orcutt, 1980]. On the EPR, velocities increase ple, the cobbles (unit 3) are thicker than indicated in the
abruptly at the base of the shallow low-velocity layer and core, and the positions and thicknessesof breccia units 13,
continue to increase smoothly with depth to the inferred top 15 and 17 are somewhat different than a standard treatment
of the magma chamber at about 1.3 km. At 180 ka, layer 3 of the recovered cores might suggest.
velocities of more than 6.5 km/s replace the low-velocity All of these materials have been altered by seawater to
Moos ET AL.: ELASTIC VELOCITIES IN OCEANIC LAYER 2 9191
45øNi.:::::..../.½!:...,,t:.
I.';'.L"•
• •:..: , .:::':?/'
)•:.":.'.,::'...•f:
'
...::...,..,.,/,•,•,
½...•,'i // .,,-,-
]•
' // I I / !
I i / !I/I/ / / I I
/ / i // d:::'-..
, ..'.'.••:'
I ':':'•:..":'
'"':'"" . .:?..:7."• 180 • 35 • • • 38 • I! ! ! ! • ¾:.'.'...'..'
-':......
• ..'½-"'.' ...:-:..'-•':",.•"/ /, / . , , u I_•38 • • / {i':.•:
I .'.:."•:Y-
'..i::.:-•:-:• / / // / 81
• • • 63
• 53 t ß 5363
ß 81 •?'i';.
i;:.i:!:.::.. .
I .,, _ ^zorn, -'.
'....
ß-.'
I :..:..','...."?:.,•• ., - / ,"• ?7øg½'o,7-,,"
';"-'- / • /-"-..'•'"'"':;'1
"."
•"
......
I ...::•.':.:.:j,• / / •errnuaa / / ,,.,•, /•/'& ,.',zer,•.•- ,', ! ../,.:.•:..': ' I
[:'...::..:.....'
.....'::i;'[ I / I " // ,/ .,• /,/'/ø 38 /•4 •:•<" / Madeira[.;':.'?
' J
30ø'•:-";"';••'":?'.-• , ,•/ • / / 4•-- z,/_/ / / zgø ?' / / 2:'::'
I• - '•i:.:•.l, '•4//114 / , , "%•ti• •'-•-/.z_ / / , _/ • M..,•':""' I
I •:.'::".?,• /,,•,•'• • / I / / i' '•" /' / '/ ø'ø• •' -.:•'""'"' I
II %i!.
• •
•.1:•
/ TM
©.418A ,
•on••. •.I/
P- --.. -•. /
// ./// ,/
/ / / /
Canaries
•F.":
/,.:%
,
I• ..•
'"••
z • 81 /
•'r'-,•,•Z.
.....
395A/
• I
z
/"-'::-':':"
•'•.•7.-'
œ"":'"'"
'"• - - '"'::"::'""•' ,, ,.... / 63 =•--"•""'•.
ß/ , ,.,•.
t-':"
'••'
-.":
•( -..-.• SanJuan • 53• t •o • •o {{(i:.;' • I
I':•ff
' (:• :•• ,• . / • • .., 9,,/9 ' 53•ø 8• Cape
Verde, ):•:; •00kr•
1' ¾.::.::L:
.... ß
! ½• ,,.•'..-:••' -':?,_L ATLANTIC
OCEAN FZ
0ø• ß,•U•,:' .
75øW 60 ø 45 ø 30 ø 15 ø
Fig. 2. Locationsof DSDP holes395A, 418A, and 504B, alongwith crustalagesin the Atlantic oceandeducedfrom
magneticanomalies[after Hyndman and Salisbury, 1984].
Lithology Unit
not
logged 1
2 A2
400
150
• 4 P2
200
5 P3
250
'6
500
7
P4
300
10
11 P5
12
13
350
600
400
??
A3
450 16
500
• '17
700
LEGEND
LEGEND
550 - 18
?? Pillow
basalt • Pillow
basalt
Massive
basalt '• Altered
pillow
A4 Breccia •:[• Massive
pillow
19
600
-- not logged - Cobbles I Massive
basalt
• Breccla
Fig. 3. Geologic column based on core recovered from DSDP
hole 395A during DSDP leg 45. Small numbers in the right-hand
column indicate lithologic units, labeledand positionedaccordingto Fig. 4. Lithology as a function of depth in DSDP hole 418A.
standardDSDP procedures[Melson et al., 1978]. Chemical units are Numbers and divisions in the right-hand column indicate lithostruc-
preceded by the letter A (aphyric) or P (phyric). The positionsand tural units inferred from core recovery [Donnelly et al., 1979]. In the
thicknesses of specific units in the left-hand column have been left-hand column the depths and thicknesses of these units have
shifted slightlyon the basisof geophysicallog data collectedduring been adjusted on the basis of geophysicallog data acquired during
ODP leg 109. The position of the seismiclayer 2A/2B boundary is ODP leg 102, and the position of the ancestrallayer 2A/2B boundary
chosen at the base of breccia unit 17, on the basis of log response at the base of breccia unit 6 is dictated by the abrupt decreasein the
[Moos, 1990]. degree of alteration infilling [Broglia and Moos, 1988].
Moos ET AL ß ELASTIC VELOCITIES IN OCEANIC LAYER 2 9193
Llthology Unit
2A
Llthology Unit
836
900
4
400 5
1400
9
16
17
7o
71
IOO0
5OO NO RECOVERY
87--
-89
• =4
25
1562.3
1100
LEG 111
6OO 28
30A
115
33
1200 118 j
.
700
37 o '
LEGEND
] Pillow
basalt
Massive
basalt
'• Breccla
45
47
836 1350
seawater deposited vein minerals, with a second stage of Core Physical Properties
vein mineral depositionat temperaturesup to 380øC.Later,
zeolites formed at temperaturesbelow 200øC.The degree of Shipboard measurementsof the porosity and compres-
alteration is apparently controlled by permeability and is sional wave velocity within cores recovered from holes
more pervasive in the transition zone, the uppermost 100 m 395A, 418A, and 504B were supplementedby further post-
of dikes, and within highly fractured intervals [e.g., Ship- cruise measurements. Porosities range from a few percent to
board Scientific Party, 1988]. more than 10%. In general, compressionalvelocities in-
9194 Moos ET AL..' ELASTIC VELOCITIES IN OCEANIC LAYER 2
crease with decreasing porosity, ranging from less than 5 Hole 395A
km/s in the mostalteredporousmaterialsto morethan 6.5
A full-waveform sonic log was run in DSDP hole 395A
km/s. No clear differencewas observedbetweenthe prop-
erties of cores taken from fresh massive basalts or fresh duringODP leg 109from just insidethe casingat 112mbsfto
pillows from within the extrusive sections(holes 395A and approximately 590 mbsf [Moos, 1990]. The lowermost sec-
418A and hole 504B above 846 mbsf). However, samples tion of available hole was not logged, as a 10-m-longtem-
recovered from below the transition zone within hole 504B perature/magnetometersonde was attached to the bottom of
had uniformly low porosities(below 3%) and high velocities the tool during the logging run. The raw data were contam-
[Christensen and Salisbury, 1985; Shipboard Scientific inated by a strongmode traveling along a steel cable within
Party, 1988]. the receiver sectionof the tool, in part becauseof this added
weight. However, strongarrivals refracted throughthe for-
DATA COLLECTION mation could be observed within the lowermost 100 m of the
hole and in isolatedsectionsat shallowerdepth.To eliminate
Sonicloggingtoolsare designedto optimizedetermination
the tool wave, the data were filtered using a zero-phase
of the compressionalwave velocity within the rock sur-
3dB/octaveButterworth filter, with 3-dB down points at 8
rounding a well bore from the measurement of the travel
and 30 kHz.
time of refracted compressionalwave energy along the
The filtered data are shown in Figure 7. Although the
borehole wall. Additional information, includingin many
casesthe shear wave velocity within the rock surrounding removal of the low-frequencytool wave also severelyatten-
the well bore, can be extracted from analysisof full wave- uated the shear and Stoneley wave modes, variations in the
form acousticlogs. However, accurateinterpretationof the first-arrivingP wave mode amplitudeare quite clear. Zones
full waveformsrequires some theoreticalknowledgeof the with strong, coherent arrivals occur at 180-185, 190-198,
properties of the generated wave field. 251-261, and 291-307 mbsf, and the interval from 320 to 420
Figure 6 shows a set of waveforms recorded in grano- mbsf is characterizedby steadily increasingwaveform co-
diorite, which show clearly the characteristicsof full wave- herence with depth. Below 420 mbsf the coherence de-
form sonic data. As shown in the figure, the first energy creasesabruptly and then increaseswith depth until at 520
arrivingat the receiversis a refractedcompressional wave, mbsf,strongringingarrivalsare present.Thesepersistto the
followed by a refracted shear wave, if the formation shear total loggeddepth, with the exception of a narrow zone at
wave velocity is higher than the propagationvelocity of 555 mbsf correspondingto a washed-out interval.
Ii• I ii , Ir
200
300
4OO
500
500 -
600 -
700 -
Fig. 8. (Left) Sonicwaveformsrecordedat receiver4, 2.55 m belowthe source,in DSDP hole418A duringODP
leg 102.The datawererecordedwith the tool movinguphole,anddepthswerereaddirectlyfrom a depthencoderon
the wire line. The waveformswerefilteredusinga band-pass filterwith 3-dBdownpointsat 5 and 20 kHz. (Right)
Single-pass semblanceanalysiscalculated
usingall 12receiverswitha timewindowof 300/xsis shown.The semblance
is depicted as solid above 0.2.
Moos ET AL.' ELASTIC VELOCITIES IN OCEANIC LAYER 2 9197
Time (ms)
0.0 1.0
Velocity
(kin/s) Hole 418A
? ,• 12
Full waveform acoustic log data were recorded in DSDP
hole 418A from just above the bottom of the hole at 789 mbsf
to just above a bridge at 464 mbsf, with the sonde moving at
a constant rate up the hole and with a constant gain applied
to the data [Moos, 1988]. This is the optimum mode of
recording, but of the three boreholes, hole 418A is the only
400 one where data were recorded in this manner. The upper-
most 140 m of basement were not logged with the multichan-
nel logging tool. To remove "road noise" associated with
the motion of the tool, the data were filtered prior to analysis
using a zero-phase 3dB/octave Butterworth filter with 3-dB
500
down points at 5 and 20 kHz.
Figure 8 presents the filtered waveforms recorded at
receiver 4, 2.4 m below the source. The first arrival is the
refracted compressional wave. The low-frequency constant
600 arrival time phase at about 1.7 ms is the Stoneley wave. The
shear wave can be seen clearly in the lowermost 50 m of the
hole and within massive units (for instance, units 10 and
ß.,,_,j. Its arrival time, shortly after the compressional first
break, varies in the same sense but more than the compres-
700
sional arrival as the elastic properties of the formation
change. A breccia (cored unit 6A) can be seen by late
arrivals at 504-514 mbsf. Within the altered pillows above
this depth, amplitude and coherence are much lower than in
the remainder of the hole. A narrow breccia/fractured inter-
800
val at about 620 mbsf is associated with lower amplitudes
and later arrivals. Comparing these data with those obtained
at holes 395A and 504B reveals considerably higher ampli-
tudes within this section of older crust.
Hole 504B
Slowness (ias/ft)
ELASTIC VELOCITIES FROM FULL WAVEFORMS
Fig. 11. The magnitudeof the semblanceas a function of offset
The velocities of compressional and shear waves are time at the first receiver and slowness(inverse velocity), for the data
calculated using a modified semblancetechnique. This tech- shown in Figure 7. The P, S, and Stoneley velocities can be
nique has been employed by a variety of researchers to computed from the positions of the associated maxima. One-
dimensional trajectories through the data illustrate (path a) a 260-/xs
analyze sonic waveforms and was first discussedby Kimball offset time fixed at the source, for a source-to-first-receiver offset of
and Marzetta [1984]. Semblance is simply a measure of the 1.95 m, (path b) an offset time fixed at the first receiver to optimize
coherenceof a windowed portion of a signalrecorded by an the measurement of P wave velocity, and (path c) an offset time
array of receivers. The window is chosen to coincide with a fixed at the first receiver to optimize determination of the S wave
mode whose velocity one wishes to determine, as illustrated velocity. Trajectory a defines the single-passpath for which sem-
blance is displayed as a function of depth in Figures 8 and 9. Both
in Figure 10. Its position at each receiver is the product of the semblanceimage and the path for data from hole 395A (Figure 7)
the receiver offset and an assumed slowness (inverse veloc- are somewhat different, because of the longer source-to-
ity). Semblance varies between 0 and 1, where 1 is perfect first-receiver offset (see Table 1).
Moos ET AL ' ELASTIC VELOCITIES IN OCEANIC LAYER 2 9199
and path c for the shear wave in Figure 11. Only the six
closest receivers were used in these calculations, and veloc-
ity ranges were restricted to 6.5-3.2 km/s (compressional
window) and 4.3-1.7 km/s (shear window). The choice of
receivers was a compromisebetween optimizingthe discrim-
ination of short-wavelengthvelocity variations by keeping
the array length small and improving the stability of the
method by increasing the number of receivers. The veloci-
ties determined in this way were consideredmeaningful only
if the semblance was above 0.4. In hole 504B this criterion
was relaxed somewhat, as semblances in this well were low
becauseof "road noise" and the occasionalpresencewithin
the waveform suites of "dead" traces. In hole 418A, veloc-
ities in the depth interval above 490 mbsf were determined
from Schlumbergerlong-spacedsonic data, using the proce-
dures outlined by Barton et al. [1989].
The results are plotted in Figures 12, 13, and 14. P wave
velocities are shaded where they are above 5.0 km/s, and S
P-wave
] S-wave
] Depth
velocity(km/s) velocity(km/s) (m bsf)
1 2 3 4
Vp/Vs
i
2 3456 7 1 2 3
wave velocities where they are above 2.8 km/s. Also plotted
in these figures are seismic velocity profiles from experi-
ments near each hole and shipboard-determinedcompres-
sional velocities measured at ultrasonic frequencies within
core samples.
Hole 395A
234567
1
I
2
I
(km/s) (mb•i)
3
1
Vp/Vs
2
• 3
Jacobsonet al. [1984]tabulatedthe velocityresultsof four
seismicsurveys,includingtwo near site 395. The bestmodel
fit of theirseismicdatarequiredan averagevelocityof 4.47
km/sin thedepthintervalpenetrated by the hole.However,
Hussonget al. [1978]earlierfounda higherregionalaverage
velocityof 4.61 km/s, belowa 150-m-thicksedimentcap.
The resultsof a recent surveyare consistentwith a constant
velocityof 4.12 (+0.05) km/s in the uppermost250 m near
site395 [Purdy,1987].Theseare all somewhathigherthan
the average of the sonic compressionalwave velocities.
Giventhe fact that the lowestvelocitymaterialscouldnot be
measured by the log, the differences between seismic and
sonicvelocitiescouldeasilybe simplydueto "samplebias."
Hole 418A
Hole 504B
TABLE2. Results
of Semblance
Analyses
ofWaveform
Suites
at Selected
Depths
WithinDSDPHoles395A,418A,and504B
LithologicUnit Morphology(From
Hole Depth,
mbsf (From
Core) Core) Velocity,
km/s Ratio Semblance
395A 208 4 (bottom) massivebasalt 5.7/3.2 1.78 0.8/0.7
418A 684 10 massivebasalt 5.8/3.2 1.81 0.7/0.6
504B 318 2D massive(aquifer
cap?) 6.1/3.0 2.01 0.9/0.8
504B 969 61 massivebasalt/fractured 5.5/3.1 1.77 0.6/0.5
504B 1407 163 massive(dikes) 6.5/3.4 1.91 0.5/0.7
418A 484 5 pillow
(shallow) 4.7/none ... 0.4/none
504B 275 1 pillow 3.2/none "- 0.6/none
504B 326 3A pillow
(acquifer?) 3.6/none '" 0.8/none
327.5 3.2/none '" 0.75/none
504B 825 48 pillow 5.5/none -" 0.4/none
395A 174 3 (bottom) cobbles 4.9/none ... 0.75/none
395A 472 pillow 4.5/none ... 0.8/none
504B 393 3C pillow
(highrecovery) 5.4/2.7 2.00 0.8/0.8
418A 584 6B pillow 6.0/2.8 2.14 0.5/0.4
418A 764 13C pillow 6.0/3.3 1.82 O.8/0.5
395A 543 pillow
(altered/infilled) 5.3/2.7 1.96 0.8/0.7
395A 585 pillow
(highly
altered) 5.6/2.9 1.93 0.9/0.8
418A 509 6A breccia 4.4/2.3 1.91 0.6/0.4
395A 350 breccia 3.6/none '" 0.8/none
ities could be determined throughout the logged depth, breccias,or massivebasalts.In thissectionthe propagation
although in largesections
of thehole,shearsemblanceswere characteristicsof each of these will be studiedby consider-
below0.4, andthusshearwavevelocitiesareconsidered less ingmeasurements
of VpandVsanda qualitative
estimate
of
reliable.Velocitiesgenerallyincreasewith depth,but in a coherencedeterminedfrom analysis of semblancepanels
stepwisefashion.Compressional velocitiesas low as 3.2 (seeFigure11).Thevelocities arethe semblance-weighted
km/swere measuredin the shallowestpillows,but below 350 averageof the slownesses withinthe semblance maximum
mbsf,Vp is above4 km/sevenin thepillowunits.Vsvaries for eachphase,computed withina windowchoseninterac-
between 2 and 3 km/s above 900 m. Within the sheeteddikes, tivelywhichspansa rangeof slownesses (+-10/as/ft)and
highvelocities (Vp above6 km/s;Vs above3.5 km/s)were start-times (200/as),asillustrated
onthefigure.Thevalueof
measured. Where both velocities were measured, Vp/Vs is thevelocitycalculated in thisway is relativelyinsensitive
to
generally between1.8and2.1, exceptwithinthetransition the size of the window and is generallyquite closeto the
zone,whereratiosareashighas2.5.Below1250mbsfVp/Vs velocityvaluecomputed from the (slowness, starttime)
is between 1.75 and 1.9. pointforwhichtheactualmaximum semblance isfound.The
Shipboardlaboratorymeasurements on recoveredcore qualitativeestimateof coherence is simplythe maximum
[Cannet al., 1983;Andersonet al., 1985;ShipboardScien- semblancewithin the window. A given phaseis assumedto
tificParty, 1988]generally
boundthe sonicvelocities
from be presentonlyif a semblance
maximumis foundin the
above,with laboratoryand sonicmeasurements
beingap- expectedregionof the semblance panel.
proximately
equalwithinmassiveunits.Laboratoryultra- Table 2 showsa summaryof the resultsfor a set of 19
sonicvelocitiesmeasuredduringleg 111are generallylower waveforms, sampling eachof the differentlithologieswithin
than sonic velocities below 1325 mbsf. They are also sys- eachborehole.Comparison of thesedatabothwithina given
tematicallylower than velocitiesmeasuredduringleg 83, well and acrossthe set of three wells reveals the range of
whichsuggests perhapsa systematic differenceassociated characteristicsof wavepropagation withinthesebasaltsand
with a changein the measurementtechnique. providesinsights intothevelocityresults whicharethemain
The compressional velocitiesarecloseto thosemeasured theme of this paper.
by vertical seismicprofiling(VSP) duringODP leg 111 Massivebasaltshave highvelocities,essentiallyequalto
[Shipboard Scientific Party, 1988],exceptin the shallowest those determined in the laboratory on cores, and high
section(above500 mbsf),wherelog velocitiesare higher semblancecoherences,even at shallowdepths.Fracturing
than seismic velocities, and within the transition zone,
within massiveunits, as, for example,at 969 mbsf in hole
where sonic velocities are lower than seismic velocities. In
504B,lowersthe velocitiesbut in this casedoesnot affect
contrast to results at holes 395A and 418A, relatively com-
the velocityratio. The semblance is a bit lower, however.
pletesoniclogdatain theuppermost fewhundred metersof Pillowshave quite variablecompressional wave veloci-
basementrevealsignificantly higherlog than seismicveloc-
ities.
ties, rangingfrom lessthan 3.5 to as muchas 6 km/s.
Althoughalmostall of thesepillowunitsare expectedto
propagate a refractedshearwave,sheararrivalsare often
SLOWNESS/ARRIVAL TIME PROCESSING notdetected,except(for example)in unitscharacterized by
OF FULL WAVEFORM SUITES
highrecovery(e.g., 393mbsfin hole504B)or significant
In order to studythe systematics of wave propagation amountsof infilling(e.g., the lowermostsectionof hole
within the differentmorphologicunits encounteredin oce- 395A)or a "massive"character (e.g., 764m in hole418A).
aniclayer2, we followthe systememployedto describethe This is likely due to scatteringwithin the pillowswhich
recoveredcoresand categorizetheseunitseitheras pillows, affects the shear wave more than the compressionalwave.
9202 MoosETAL.'ELASTIC
VELOCITIES
IN L)CEANIC
LAYER
2
. •
3.0-
•- 3.0-
E
I
,
._
2.0-
2.0-
1.0
I I I I I 1.0
Compressionalvelocity (km/s)
Compressional
velocity(km/s)
DSDP HOLE 395A 7.3 Ma DSDP HOLE 395A 7.3 Ma
4.0 4.0
3.0 •
3.0-
; i i ':'
2.0 m 2.0 -
1.0
I
1.0
i i
2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0
[ ,
3,0 i 3.0
2.0
1.0 1.0
i I i
2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0
Compressional
velocity
(km/s) Compressional
velocity
(km/s)
Fig. 15. Summary crossplot
of Vsversus
Vpin (a) massive
units,(b)pillows,
and(c)breccias,
Dataareshown
separately
foreachofthethreeboreholes
tohighlight
differences
between basalts
ofdifferent
ageandorigin.
Datafrom
breccias
inhole395Awhere
bothVpandVsweremeasured
weretoofewtobeincluded
inthissummary.
Linesof
constant
Vp/Vs(1.8and2.0forthetopandbottomlines,respectively)
areshown,along
with(dashed
line)a linearleast
squares
fittoultrasonic
velocities
measured
atinferred
insitudifferential
t}ressures,
averaged
bySalisbury
etal.[1985].
Moos ET AL.' ELASTIC VELOCITIES IN OCEANIC LAYER 2 9203
c BRECCIA infilling, on the basis of both log response and core descrip-
tions [see Moos, 1990].
DSDP HOLE 504B 5.4 Ma
4.0
DISCUSSION
by semblance.Moos et al. [ 1986]foundthat velocityratiosin greatly improve the material's ability to transmit shear
pillows and flows were different in the shallowest 150 m of energy, whereas in hole 395A the alteration which increases
basement in hole 504B. Effective medium theories would the velocities also significantlyenhancesthe material's abil-
predictthis resultif the voidsbetweenpillowswere ordersof ity to transmit sonic waves. In hole 504B, alteration at
magnitudesmallerthan the sonicwavelength.However, the intermediatetemperaturesallows the propagationof shear
propertiesof the matrix basalt are quite similar for pillows energywithin the pillows, except within the shallowaquifer
and flows [e.g., Broglia and Moos, 1988], and the size of the (unit 3A).
pillows is similarto the sonicwavelength.Thus the effect of These changesin the characterof the pillows with depth
the voids between pillows on sonic velocities cannot be due to changesin alteration and infilling correspond in all
describedusingeffectivemediumtheories.One possibilityis three holes to the depth ranges within which boundaries
that either cooling cracks within the pillows or the pillow between the oceanic layers are placed. For example, the
contacts themselves contribute a componentof microcrack ancestrallayer 2A/2B boundary in hole 418A is placed at the
porosity, which affects the velocities in the same manner as base of the breccia unit 6A, which separatesmaterial filled
do the stressrelief microcracksin the laboratorysamples. with large amounts of clays from less infilled materials at
Data from breccias represent only one interval in hole greater depths. In hole 395A the steady increasein velocity
418A and two intervals in hole 504B; no shear velocities over the depth range 450-520 mbsf associated with infilling
were recorded in the breccias of hole 395A. Although and alteration of the pillows, leading to the presence of
brecciasare the least important structuraltype volumetri- coherent shear arrivals, led to the placement of the layer
cally, they may be quite important structurally, representing 2A/2B boundary within that depth interval [e.g., Hyndman
faults or "sedimentary" talus and providing high- and Salisbury, 1984]. Thus changesin velocitieswith depth
permeability conduits for geothermal fluids. Velocities are givingrise to the zonation of oceaniclayer 2 extrusives(e.g.,
generally quite low, although not as low as in the slowest Figure 1) may be due to changesin the type or amount of
pillows. In breccias from hole 418A, Vp/Vs decreaseswith alteration, as suggestedby Vera [1989] for the boundary
Vp; in breccias from hole 504B it increases. between layers 2 and 3.
Elastic Wave Velocities and Alteration Effects of Emplacement on Elastic Wave Velocities
Alteration infilling is the largest factor contributing to Although alteration infilling is the primary influenceon the
variations in the elastic velocities of pillows. However, the elastic properties of pillows, there is some evidence that
importance of alteration infilling in raising the velocity of depositionalphenomenaaccompanyingthe emplacementof
oceanicpillows dependson the nature of the infilling mate- these basalts is also important. Pezard [this issue] discusses
rial. For example, alteration infilling by weak clays in the the variation of electrical properties as a function of depth
uppermostintervals of DSDP hole 418A raisesthe compres- within individual units in hole 504B. In particular, he finds a
sional wave velocity significantly,but velocities within this systematicchangein the electrical propertieswithin individ-
interval still do not approachthoseat greater depths.Veloc- ual massiveunits of a particular extrusive sequence,related
ities within the lowermost portion of hole 395A are quite to changes in the magma source.
high, because of significantamounts of "harder" infilling Similarly, Moos [1990] delineates systematic changes in
materials. Comparison of the data from these two holes properties of the different chemical units within the cored
indicates that the effects of alteration on the velocities of sectionof DSDP hole 395A, on the basis of natural gamma,
pillows is not a simple function of age, as at equivalent resistivity, and sonic measurements. These systematics
depthsbelow a few hundred meters subbasementwithin hole were previously recognized in this hole by Mathews et al.
418A at 110 Ma and hole 395A at 7.3 Ma, velocitiesare quite [ 1984],but the poor data quality of the logs used in that study
similar. However, in the shallowercrust, systematicinfilling constrainedfurther analysis. The log variations reveal that
with clays may result in a more gradual changewith age in within each chemical unit, gamma intensity decreaseswith
the properties of the basalts. The absence of a shallow zone depth, and resistivity and sonic velocities increase with
in DSDP hole 417D (drilled near site 418) similar to that in depth, both within the pillows and within individual thin flow
hole 418A suggeststhat the degree of infilling in old crust units. Generally, each unit is initiated by a massiveunit at its
may be quite variable [Donnelly et al., 1979]. Thus the base, grading upward into less massive, more altered, more
degreeto which infilling occursin old crust is quite likely a rubbley pillows, with the highestdegreeof alteration and the
function of locally varying conditionssuchas the accessibil- least competent material at the top. This is then capped by
ity of the material to seawater or other fluids. another flow which initiates the next chemical unit. This
The degreeand type of infilling material also influencesthe characteristic sequence is particularly pronounced in the
scatteringproperties of oceanic pillow basalts. The fact that phyric units which make up most of the uppermost350 m of
shearwaves do not propagateefficiently at sonicfrequencies basement, although it is much less evident in the aphyric
within oceanicpillows at shallow depthsis a consequenceof basalts.
scatteringof the sonicwave from voids between the pillows. Evidence for a similar trend can be found in the compres-
This is more prevalent at young ages (holes 504B and 395A) sional velocities in hole 418A. Several such sequencescan
but also occurswithin older crust which has been infilled by be observed in unit 5, of which the intervals 410-435 mbsf
alteration products (as in the shallow sectionsof hole 418A). and 435-465 mbsf are most obvious. In each of these a
As a result, shear velocities cannot be determined for the high-velocity "massive" unit initiates a sequencein which
"slowest" pillows. At greater depths, both shear and com- velocities decrease upward, until the onset of another high-
pressional waves can be seen, even in young crust. For velocity unit which starts the next sequence.
example, in hole 418A, low-temperature alteration does not Pezard [this issue] suggestson the basis of the electrical
MoosETAL.:ELASTIC
VELOCITIES
IN OCEANIC
LAYER
2 9205
logsa similar
sequence points valueto helpconstrain
forhole504Bandinparticular suchmodels.
Forexample,
thesonic
to massiveunit 2D cappinga shallowaquiferwithinlayer resultsdemonstratethat velocitiescharacteristicof layer 2A
2A, and massiveunit 27 whichprovidesa permeability arepresent in hole504Bonlyin theuppermost 100m andin
barrierandseparates different
alterationregimeswithinhole hole 395A only in the uppermost150 m. In hole 418A,
504B,asevidence of thissequence. As he suggests,sucha semblancevelocitiesof the Schlumbergerdata, for which
sequence is idealfor creatingnarrowconfined aquifersto lowervelocitieswererecordedabovethe subunit6a breccia,
controlhydrothermal withinthe extrusiveba- andthelargeamounts
circulation of alterationinfillingin thesepillows
salts.Sharpboundaries between different
alterationregimes suggestthatthe uppermost 185m of thisholemayat one
in theseholes(for example,in hole418Aat brecciaunit6A) timehavehadhigherporosities andhencevelocitieschar-
maybe similarlydueto structural controlof fluidflow. acteristic
of layer
2A [Brogliaand Moos,1988].However,in
all three holes, massiveunits with high P and S wave
velocities
arepresentevenwithintheshallowest
intervals.
Relationship
BetweenSonicand SeismicVelocities
Seismicand sonicvelocitiesdo not generallyagreewithin SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
the shallowestextrusivebasalts,evenwithin the limits of the
measurements.Thisispredominantlydueto thelossof sonic Analysisof full waveformmultichannel
sonicdata in
velocityinformation
in the leastcompetent (slowest)pil- DSDP holes395A,418A, and504Bprovidescompressional
lows. The benefitof the semblanceanalysistechniqueis that and shear sonic velocitieswithin the extrusive sectionof
spurious velocitymeasurements canbe eliminated usinga bothyoungandoldcrustgenerated on the slow-spreading
reasonablecriterion(the semblancemagnitude),and thus mid-Atlantic Ridgeand for both extrusiveand intrusive
these results are less contaminated by error than those basalts withinyoungcrustproduced at thefaster-spreading
reported previously. Swiftet al. [1988]suggested thatthe Costa Rica Rift. Velocities within these oceanicbasaltsare
sonicresultsare not representative of the crustover the systematically higherfor massive unitsthanfor pillows.
largelateralareassampled seismically.Furthermore, the Breccias, whicharevolumetrically unimportant in determin-
averaging of the seismicvelocities overthe seismic wave- ingcrustalseismic velocities, havevelocities slightlylower
lengthmayalsoexplaindifferences in velocity[e.g.,Mutter thanthosewithinadjacentpillows.Thereis no measurable
and Newmark,1986],as laterallyfiniteunitswill be effec- difference
betweentheproperties
of morphologically
similar
tivelyoversampled by the soniccompared to the seismic basaltsthat is relatedto spreadingrate. Differencesin the
data. Thus sonicor core "stratigraphy"shouldbe treated grossvelocitystructure withinthe extrusivesectionof
with cautionin generatinggroundtruthvelocity-depthpro- youngcrustaredueto differences in therelativepercentages
files. However, there is almostcertainlya relationship of pillows and flows.
betweenlateralandverticalheterogeneity,
and measuresof Massivebasaltsare generallycharacterizedby compres-
the variabilityof velocityverticallymay be of value to sionalvelocitiesabove5 km/s and shearvelocitiesabove2.8
the sonicresultslaterallyawayfromthebore- km/s(Vp/Vsbelow1.9),equivalent
extrapolate to velocitiesmeasured
hole. oncoresamples at ultrasonic
frequencies.
Velocities in situ
A numberof authorshave suggested that horizontalve- increasewith depth,becauseof the effectof confining
pressure
locities are different than vertical velocitiesbecauseof the whichcloses smallaspectratiocracks,leadingto
presence of macroscopic fractures [e.g., Stephen,1981]. highersonicthanultrasonic
velocities
(measured at atmo-
Thiswill be a problemif sonicvelocities measured in the spheric
confining
pressure)
withinthesheeted dikesof hole
verticaldirectionare comparedto seismicrefractionveloc- 504B.Fracturingwithinmassivebasalts(asis observedin
ities or the resultsof velocity analysesfrom "diving" rays the transitionzonepenetrated
by hole504B)reducesboth
for compressional
[e.g.,Swiftet al., 1988].However,thisis nota problem andshearvelocities
withoutaffecting
their
the interval velocitiesmeasuredbetweenreceiversin a VSP ratio.
about 5 Ma. The increase in velocity with crustal age in the vol. 69, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C.,
1983.
shallower extrusive pillows is due to alteration infilling with
claysand weaker materialsand can raisetheir compressional Cheng, C. H., and M. N. T6ksoz, Elastic wave propagationin a
fluid-filledborehole and syntheticacousticlogs, Geophysics,46,
velocities by more than 1 km/s over the time interval from 1042-1053, 1981.
7.3 to 110 Ma, which is sufficientto explain the disappear- Christensen,N. I., and M. H. Salisbury, Seismic velocities, densi-
ance of seismic layer 2A. However, differencesbetween the ties, and porosities of layer 2B and layer 2C basalts from hole
properties of shallow pillows filled with clays and those of 504B, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 83, 367-370, 1985.
deeperpillows filled with "harder" alterationproductsper- Donnelly, T., et al., Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Project,
sist. vol. 51-53, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington,D.C.,
1979.
In the extrusive pillows sonic velocities are generally Harding, A. J., J. A. Orcutt, M. E. Kappus, E. E. Vera, J. C.
lower than laboratory-determinedvelocities, becauseof the Mutter, P. Buhl, R. S. Detrick, and T. M. Brocher, Structure of
presence in situ of large-scale voids and fractures, and/or young oceanic crust at 13øN on the East Pacific Rise from
"softer" materials, not sampledby coring. However, some expandingspread profiles, J. Geophys. Res., 94, 12,163-12,196,
1989.
laboratory-determinedvelocitiesare equal to or even lower Holmes, M. A., Evidence for continuous and discontinuous alter-
than those in situ, suggestingthat in some cases lower- ation in DSDP hole 418A basalts and its significanceto natural
velocity materials have been successfullyrecovered. gamma-ray log readings, in Proceedings of ODP, Scientific Re-
Averaged sonic velocities within the entire extrusive sec- sults, vol. 102, edited by M. H. Salisbury et al., pp. 136-154,
tion are generally equal to or slightly higher than seismic Ocean Drilling Program, Houston, Tex., 1988.
Honnorez, J., C. Laverne, H.-W. Hubberton, R. Emmermann, and
velocities. This difference is also partly a function of sam-
K. Muehlenbachs,Alteration processesin layer 2 basalts from
pling bias, as (1) sonic velocities within the slowestpillows Deep Sea Drilling Project hole 504B, Costa Rica Rift, Initial Rep.
are difficult to determine, raisingthe "average" sonicveloc- Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 69, 509-546, 1983.
ity, and (2) laterally finite flows penetrated by the drill bit Houtz, R., and J. Ewing, Upper crustal structure as a function of
may not affect velocities in the larger rock volume sampled plate age, J. Geophys. Res., 81, 2490-2498, 1976.
by the seismicwaves. However, it is alsolikely that the scale Hussong, D. M., P. B. Fryer, J. D. Tuthill, and L. K. Wipperman,
The geologicaland geophysicalsettingnear DSDP site 395, North
of the sonicwave is suchthat it scattersfrom heterogeneities Atlantic Ocean, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 45, 23-37,
that behave like flaws in an effective medium at the scale of 1978.
the seismicmeasurement.Within the deeper sectionof hole Hyndman, R. D., and M. H. Salisbury, The physical nature of
418A, and within the intrusives in hole 504B, sonic and young upper oceanic crust on the mid-Atlantic Ridge, Deep Sea
seismic velocities are similar. Drilling Project hole 395A, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 78B,
839-848, 1984.
Jacobson, R. S., R. Adair, and J. Orcutt, Preliminary seismic
refraction results using a borehole seismometer in Deep Sea
Acknowledgments. The existenceand quality of the ODP ship- Drilling Project hole 395A, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 78B,
board geophysical logging program is due to R. N. Anderson of 783-794, 1984.
Lamont-Doherty Geological Observatory. We also gratefully ac- Juteau, T., F. Bingol, Y. Noack, H. Whitechurch, M. Hoffert, D.
knowledgethe help and cooperationof the OceanDrilling Program Wirrman, and C. Courtois, Preliminary results: Mineralogy and
staff and shipboard personnel, without which none of these data geochemistryof alteration products in leg 45 basement samples,
couldhave been collected.K. Becker was onboardfor all three legs Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 45, 613-646, 1978.
duringwhich the data was collectedand was chief scientiston leg Kimball, C. V., and T. L. Marzetta, Semblance processing of
111. We also thank the other chief scientists, J. Scott and M. borehole acoustic array data, Geophysics,49, 274-281, 1984.
Salisburyon leg 102, W. Bryan and T. Juteau on leg 109, and H. Lawrence, J. R., J. J. Drever, and M. Kastner, Low temperature
Sakai on leg 111, for their help and support.D. Shahand K. Peters alteration of basaltspredominatesat site 395, Initial Rep. Deep
helped implement the data collection and analysis software. The Sea Drill. Proj., 45, 609-612, 1978.
authors of this paper greatly benefited from discussionswith D. Mathews, M., M. H. Salisbury,and R. Hyndman, Basementlogging
Goldbergand C. Broglia. Constructivereviews by P. Lysne and F. on the mid-Atlantic Ridge, Deep Sea Drilling Project hole 395A,
Paillet greatly improved the manuscript. The first author was Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 78B, 717-730, 1984.
supported during this work by NSF contracts JOI-66-84 and OCE- Melson, W. G., et al., Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling
8704609. Project, vol. 45, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington,
D.C., 1978.
Moos, D., Elastic properties of 110-Ma oceanic crust from sonic full
REFERENCES waveformsin DSDP hole 418A, in Proceedingsof ODP, Scientific
Results, vol. 102, edited by M. H. Salisbury et al., pp. 49-62,
Alt, J. C., C. Laverne, and K. Muehlenbachs, Alteration of the Ocean Drilling Program, College Station, Tex., 1988.
upper oceanic crust: Mineralogy and processesin Deep Sea Moos, D., Petrophysical results from logging in DSDP hole 395A,
Drilling Project hole 504B, leg 83, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. ODP leg 109, in Proceedings of ODP, Scientific Results, vol.
Proj., 83, 217-247, 1985. 106/109,edited by R. Detrick et al., pp. 237-253, Ocean Drilling
Anderson, R. N., et al., Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Program, College Station, Tex., 1990.
Project, 83, U.S. GovernmentPrintingOffice, Washington,D.C., Moos, D., D. S. Goldberg, M. A. Hobart, and R. N. Anderson,
1985. Elastic-wave velocities in layer 2A from full waveform sonic logs
Barton, C., D. Moos, and J.-P. Blangy, Analysis of full waveform at hole 504B, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 92,563-570, 1986.
acousticloggingdata at ODP site 642--Outer VOring Plateau, in Mutter, J. C., and R. L. Newmark, Seismic responseof detailed
Proceedingsof ODP, Scientific Results, vol. 104, edited by O. structureat DSDP hole 504B: Synthetic seismogramsin the tau-p
Eldholm, et al., pp. 953-964, Ocean Drilling Program, College domain, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 92,571-584, 1986.
Station, Tex., 1989. Newmark, R. L., R. N. Anderson, D. Moos, and M.D. Zoback,
Becker, K., et al., Drilling deep into the oceanic crust at hole 504B, Sonic and ultrasonicloggingof hole 504B and its implicationsfor
Costa Rica Rift, Rev. Geophys,27, 79-102, 1989. the structure,porosity, and stressregime of the upper 1 km of the
Broglia C., and D. Moos, In situ structureand propertiesof 110Ma oceanic crust, Initial Rep. Deep Sea Drill. Proj., 83, 479-510,
crustfrom geophysicallogsin DSDP hole 418A, in Proceedingsof 1985.
ODP, ScientificResults, vol. 102, editedby M. H. Salisburyet al., O'Connell, R. J., and B. Budianski, Seismic velocities in dry and
pp. 29-47, Ocean Drilling Program, College Station, Tex., 1988. saturatedcracked solids, J. Geophys. Res., 79, 5412-5426, 1974.
Cann, J. R., et al., Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Project, Paillet, F. L., and J. E. White, Acoustic modesof propagationin the
MoosETAL..'ELASTIC
VELOCITIES
IN OCEANIC
LAYER
2 9207