Framework of The Study
Framework of The Study
This part of the research paper discusses the review of related studies including the
local literature, foreign literature as well as local and foreign studies. Theoretical
Foreign Study
Family business pertains to a group of people who are blood-related that has a
position or control over the company. It is usually starts on its founders who intend to
pass the business on their descendants up to the time where a business dynasty is build.
According to Galvan, Martinez & Rahman (2017), family business may have a lot of
definitions but it will always have three dimensions: one or several families hold a
significant part of the company’s capital, family have also control over the company, and
family members usually hold the top management positions. Based on their study, family
development in the most countries. Over two-thirds of the businesses worldwide are
Gross Domestic Products (GDP). In the countries like USA and Canada, family
businesses are very prominent. Approximately, 90% of all the businesses there are said to
be a family business. In Australia, half of the businesses are owned by a family. On the
6
7
other hand, other countries like India, family businesses are greatly needed in order for
the progression of their own country. It is not impossible that family-owned businesses
are really the foundation or what you called the ‘backbone’ of many economies around
the world. In Spain, supermarkets are the largest grocery channel where it has a
generating sales of 32.5 billion and grew year-by-year by 2.5% driven by eight biggest
competitors including Mercadonna, El Corte Ingles, Distributions Froiz, S.A., DIA and
etc. Most supermarkets in Spain are said to be family-owned business. For the
Spain providing different job opportunities and contributing to the GDP of the country.
two family business owner the Wallenberg and Ehrnrooth Both families had same values
duty and hard work, both were in politics, both invested in emerging businesses, both
were in constant renewal, both had diverse businesses and both were very cautious with
their investments. Both had many children out of which at least two were chosen to run
the family businesses. Although the succession strategies differed, both chose the most
able ones among the children to run the businesses.Wallenberg and Ehrnrooth shared
similar ideas and values of duty, hard work, and diligence. But these were shared by their
peers in all protestant Europe at the time.Both families send many of their sons abroad for
education. This is a connecting point, although not a rarity in Europe in high society and
business circles.The Wallenberg dynasty was built by giving the family business position
to the first son to handle the mutual wealth of the foundations. However, the son had to
show his abilities in business competing against other candidates. Ehrnrooth succession
8
strategy was to make many children and carefully choose the most competent sons to
Family enterprises’ existence has been dominating all over the world and has an
important role on economy and society of the whole country. As the year goes by, many
definition of family business has emerged but there was no degree to which clearly
satisfied what a family business really are. Some elements were highlighted when
defining family business such as ownership, family involvement, family control and the
intention of transferring the business to future generations. Even if some elements are
questionable, these elements present the focus variable that are crucial in describing a
family firm (Chrisman, Chua, & Sharma, 2005). Chrisman et al. also found out that
family business is classified not only by ownership, governance and control that retained
by the family but also by the succession of next generation. Villalonga and Amit
specified three main factors common to any family business: First, one or more families
detain a significant part of capital (Villalonga & Amit, 2006). Second, family members
have significant control over the company that may include statutory or legal boundaries
over the voting right and the capital distribution among none family shareholders. Third,
in today’s world. Family businesses have the potential to outperform any other form of
business organization through their inherent synergies between capital and management.
advantage of firms. If firms are able to identify the factors that determine improved
9
performance, they could take advantage of their specific features. The purpose of the
Family business teaching are important for family businesses as it is a key for a
family business to continue its legacy. The aim of this study is to determine the
According to Westhead and Howrth (2006), board of directors shouldn't only be members
of the family. Family-owned firms should hire more independent directors and outsiders
to widen the knowledge in strategic department. Based on the findings of the study, more
management. The study shows that university students does not perceived family
their own business as family entrepreneurs. There is a need for business academic
education to keep the quality standards high. More knowledge is needed on how to
develop family business education from the views of students, teachers, and family firms.
Local Study
According to Adarna et.al (2017), the Department of Trade and Industry affirms that
which between 80%- 90% are family-owned and these businesses are succeeded by the
heir of the founders. On the other hand, Chinese businesses are continuously spreading in
10
the Philippines even though they only comprise 1% of the Philippine population. In order
for a family-owned business to continuously operate in the future, they will need a
However, millennial nowadays have their own minds in choosing the path that they want.
They want to explore multiple careers, relationships, lifestyle and technologies without
committing to any one path too soon. In conducting a survey, they input five main factors
that affect willingness to take over mainly, demographics-based perception, divided into
sex and birth order, predecessor’s trust in successor’s abilities and intentions, personal
needs alignment of successor, and rewards from the business. From that, researchers will
be able to determine the perceptions of the students regarding the said topic. They
result shows that birth order is highly significant where the eldest sibling has the
responsibility to take over their family business after pursuing his/her studies. All in all,
the five significant factors contribute to willingness and the perspective of the successor
about taking over family business is indispensable and over the years, the dynamics of
According to Santiago, A (2015) Business decline actually results from the failure of
family members to address the challenges brought about the change in the different life
approaches. While some family members may felt incapable of introducing innovation in
their business, the failure to act, by itself, was a guarantee of business failure.This study
brings attention to the need of family business owners to be more proactive in meeting
11
the changing needs of their family business. Formula that worked before may not be
This research is based on the proposition that although in-laws may be warmly
welcomed into a family, they may hold a tentative position in the family business. It set
out to determine whether in-laws loosely belong to the general category of “family” or if
they deserve separate attention, at least in the Philippine setting. Following the logic of
Pieper and Klein (2007) who zeroed in on the individual as the basis of the “bull eyes”
approach in understanding the family firm theory, the decision of whether in-laws should
participate in the business thus can be seen as a personal one and can only be assessed on
a case-to-case basis. When one combines the logic of Pieper and Klein with the findings
of Stafford et al. (1999), the assumption is that in-laws whom families may consider a
valuable resource for the business must relate well with members of the founding family
industries which are bound together by a persistent formal and informal ties". These
business groups has caught the attention of many for it relative performance across
countries. The aim of this study is to relate the observation of the development of
business groups in the Philippines as well as to to show the relationship between the
dynasty model of household behavior and nature of business groups in the country. For
the conclusions, the results show that dynastic motives in family-owned business groups
are evident in the Philippines. However, family-based enterprises tend to lose out
completion when choosing the right person for a position such as managers among the
12
family circle. The members must compete in order to show that they are the most capable
to take the role. Primogeniture was also observed wherein the only son is given the
highest position, bypassing the elder sister, and takes greater roles compared to the rest of
Foreign Literature
According to Ann (2016), before the conglomerates and revolutions happened in the
18th Century, the presence of family businesses have already taken the world. Over the
past years, the success of Business Dynasty is greatly seen because of what it can bring in
one country in terms of the economic growth. Up to this day, they are a lot of family-
owned businesses that still operating smoothly and wealthily. Based on the Global
Family Business Index, several businesses that pass from generations from generations
are continuously developing to increase their global presence. Some of the founding
dynasties worldwide are Wal-Mart, Volkswagen, Berkshire Hathaway, EXOR, and Ford.
These popular businesses are persistently making an incredible work for the reputation
not only to for their business but also for their family’s honor. Wal-Mart owned by
Walton Family has a revenue of $485.651 billion, Volkswagen owned by Porsche Family
has a revenue of $261.6 billion, Berkshire Hathaway managed by Buffett Family earned
$182.2 billion while EXOR owned by Agnelli Family has a revenue of $151.1 billion and
Lastly Ford, owned by Ford Family has an earnings of $146.9 billion. This proves that
two or more family members and the family holds majority control or ownership.Every
family has its struggles—like who gets stuck sitting next to Aunt Mimi at the next
holiday get-together. But when you combine business with family, those challenges
become even more complex. companies included less experienced family members on
committees and boards, with the goal of nurturing the younger generation’s management
and business skills. It’s a training ground that provides the valuable experience needed to
move the family business successfully into the future. Family-owned companies have
another big advantage over non-family firms: almost three-quarters of family businesses
report stronger values and culture which can be leveraged as strengths in areas like
Passing the family business to the next generation is not an easy resolve, there are
lots of consequence the business owner are facing and factors that need to consider before
making a decision. This will determine the fate of family’s lifelong business, there hopes,
crucial task that is more critical to securing private firm’s future especially in United
States. Other problems such as rising competition, government regulations, taxes and
other problem must handle properly because mishandling of plan and succession
management of the business will form the greatest threat in the survival of the business.
Many firms across the nation are facing the retirement or death of their founder or chief
executives without insufficient plans in succession and some firms that has plans, fail
because they mismanaged the succession planning process. It’s not surprising that 13
percent of the third generation make it to the end and only one-third of the business
14
survive for second generation.( Craig E. Aronoff, Stephen L. McClure, and John L.
Ward)
According to Magnuson (2016), if we look at all the great companies’ history, almost
all of them are started by a powerhouse individual who stops at nothing to build a great
company. But love and idealism can cloud business judgment, effectively causing harm
in the end. When the company starts getting traction, the profits and benefits are
disbursed, along with family jobs. Just because a son or daughter or in-law is related does
not mean they are the best qualified for the job. Often, responsibility and ownership
shares are not clarified in writing, which allows entitlement and resentment to seep in.
Family feuds over money are not just for the Fords, DuPonts and Pritzkers. They happen
in every class. When the money and power struggle begins, any love and trust that held a
family together can be replaced by suspicion and hatred. Many family fortunes are lost in
three generations. Some family fortunes have withstood fighting, entitlement and family
war. Good examples are the Houghton family who founded Corning Glass in 1851, Wal-
Mart, Kohler, Bechtel, Ford and Mars Candy. Dynasties are not just something started
before our time by someone else. We each have all the tools we need to become the next
Hilton, Ford or Rockefeller. Everything we do starts today, in this moment. If you are
running a family business, always lead with clarity, transparency and trust. Because when
According to Dalal (2018), teachings such as leadership must be passed down to the
next generation in hopes to make them better leaders for tomorrow. The difference
between a business model and corporate model cannot be questioned. The influence of
15
values, ethics and experiences of the founders in the work culture makes the atmosphere
friendlier and people are more approachable. Leadership form each generation may share
a common heritage and same values but each generation may still differ when it comes to
the medium of command and approach, even so it is about leading the family business to
success. It is said that new generations may adopt a more democratic approach where
ideas are accepted more easily than the first one who would be focused on the
functionality of each position. It is said that family business who make it to the third
generation are lesser than 30 percent. Family learns together at home and the office,
continuing the family legacy makes the workplace and home one and the same. "A true
leader motivates one’s team to surge ahead with full confidence and is always there to
Local Literature
businesses continuously to dominate the entire business industry in the Philippines. They
also released about the country ranking 11th globally in terms of number of family runs-
firms. The research institute classified around 1,000 family businesses and review the
investment cases of the firms. The gathered data shows that ever since year 2006, family
businesses in the Philippines are dramatically growing by an average of 3.9% every year.
It is much faster compared to all countries in Asia Pacific Region except Japan. They also
noted that Family businesses are doing a great job in terms of the sales growth and
generating revenues compared to non-family owned firms. It seems that the investors are
much more concerned on how each family member are involved in the business rather
16
than testing its level of ownership. An average of market capitalization of $5.6 billion are
said to be from the family-owned firms making it the sixth country with the highest
market cap in Asia Pacific (except Japan) and ranked 25th in the world. Top companies
Based from Premier Family Consulting (2017), strengthening family businesses lies
on the premise that family businesses being a key driver to economic development are
also vulnerable to the unique and inherent challenges of being a family in business. The
Challenges of a Family in Business However, with the inherent tension between the
family and the business, family businesses has to waver through their unique challenges
between Family Welfare vs. Business Growth. There is a need to help them be organized
as a family and establish solutions to address their challenges; to encourage them to find
more sustainable ways to maintain their position and lay the groundwork to take
advantage of the opportunities of a more open market; to help them be prepared as the
The Filipino family plays a critical part in the economic, political, religious and
educational life of the people. "Family" wrote Keren Blankfeld in her article "Bloodlines
and Bottom Lines" published in Forbes magazine, "is at the core of many of Asia's
biggest and most far-flung conglomerates and some of its best-known brands." while luck
and genes have some bearing with family business success, the more significant factors in
17
the prosperity of any enterprises are trust, talent, tenacity, technique, timing and
flexibility. Some family business have lasted for several generation with no end while
other are doomed. A country's stability and prosperity can be intricate tied to the strength
According to Cruz (2014), While it is evident that family dynasties dominate the
world of business in the Philippines and most parts of Asia,only two to three generations
is normally the rule for a family dynasty in both business and politics. The public
impression is that family businesses will eventually become extinct or, at least, will be
limited to small entrepreneurial ventures which is very far from the reality in the business
world. Family business continues, and will continue, to be the most dominant form of
business organization in the Philippines, in Asia, and surprisingly in the Western world
increasingly. It is also said that there is also evidence that family businesses can be
fact, in times of economic downturns family businesses have proven to be more resilient
and capable of surviving volatile environments. Behind this is the reason that families are
not motivated by profit alone like professional managers. Many families sacrifice profits
because they view their family business as a legacy they have inherited and something
they would want to pass on to the next generation. For the Philippines to have rapid
economic growth in the future, the Filipino family businesses must eventually become
the primary engine of growth. This will require professionalizing family business
management and reconciling the family’s needs and desires with the demands of running
Survey 2018, around 85 percent of businesses in the Philippines are family-owned, which
are mostly small and medium-sized enterprises(SME). This survey generated insights
from 2,953 family-owned firms across 53 countries and found out that Filipino family
business on the global scale are "conservative" for it only sticks to a single sector and
operates in a single country. PwC Philippines Assurance Partners Aldie P. Garcia stated
that majority of the family businesses in the country are still in the first-generation that
puts it on "survival mode". Family-owned businesses are more likely to expand into new
sectors and practices during the second and third generations of succession while in third
and fourth generations are more likely to expand overseas. PwC's study also showed that
compared to having the values deeply rooted in a family businesses' identity. “If
technological innovation and disruption is being adopted for the sake of being adopted
without regard to the core values and without regard to the purpose of the organization,
that’s when conflict would arise between your spirit and your values and your
organization versus your tech-powered growth ambitions,” Garcia said. Family values
provides the direction of the business, while innovation and adoption of new technologies
Theoretical Framework
There are various theories regarding family business and through the help of these
theories, the researchers will be able to come up to the effects of business dynasty on
the progress of the business. In addition, the perspectives of the students will be also
included at the end of the research study to arrive in a definite and absolute result.
1. Resource-Based Theory
complex. They have multiple resources because many people are involved
a high level of value creation. The more you have the connection and
relation within and outside the organization, the business will be effective
and will continuously operate in many years. But on the other hand, it
might also have disadvantages when interaction between content and flow
will result in unbalanced exchange, the capital stock of the business might
suffer. Other studies show the impact of bunch of family resources on the
strategic decision of the firm. The result depicts that the business will have
2. Stewardship Theory
approach implies that managers are motivated due to the family’s tradition
and culture. They feel that they have a responsibility to do in order for that
business to prosper and grow. Managers might also feel the sense of
belongingness which can be a driving force for them to work hard. As for
wealth of the business or the resources of the family and the whole
3. Agency Theory
E. Peruffo in a contract can operate in his or her interest rather than the
Meckling 1976).
4. Social-capital Theory
embedded in two ways, on one hand within the family and on the other
Conceptual Framework
PROCESS
INPUT OUPUT
1. Gathering Determining the
1.Demographic information Perception of
• Age (16-19) through interviews Grade 12 ABM
2. Students of
• Gender Formulating
(Female/Male) 2. University of the
questionnaires East- Caloocan on
Students who have 3. Conducting the
family business Business Dynasty
survey S.Y. 2018-2019
3. Factors of 4. Assessing the
Business Dynasty gathered data
5. Statistical
treatment of data
25
To have a clear execution of tasks involved in the study, the researchers used the
conceptual framework which comprises the input, process and output. The framework
begins with the input in which the researchers determine the demographic of the
respondents (ages 16-19 years old, male or female), factors of business dynasty and also
finding students who have a family business. Next stage is the process wherein the
researchers start to perform actions in order to come up with an output. It includes the (1)
the survey, (4) assessing the gathered data, and (5) statistical treatment of data. Finally,
the researchers will now arrived with the output which is determining the Perception of
Grade 12 ABM Students of University of the East- Caloocan on Business Dynasty S.Y.
2018-2019.
Null Hypotheses
Guided by the stated problems, the study will test the following hypotheses:
1. Peers were not able to influence and teach their successors the values and hard
2. Family businesses only survived from 2nd to 3rd generation, only some
family businesses can sustain the continuous changing preferences of the market.
26
there have been found many evidences that there are various disadvantages in
4. Engaging into a family business will likely hinder a business than venturing
Definition of Terms
n.d.)
Business growth can be achieved either by boosting the top line or revenue of
the business with greater product sales or service income, or by increasing the
27
Dictionary, n.d.)
Business Dynasty- happens when one family member takes over the owner’s position
Capital Distribution - any dividend or other distribution in cash or in kind made with
respect to any shares of, or other ownership interest in, an enterprise, except a
Webster, n.d.)
effectively vary its output within a certain range and given time frame
Globally competitiveness – the set of skills that help someone be a productive member
(Fukuyama, 2013)
Gross Domestic Product - the final value of the goods and services produced within
Legacy – money or property which someone leaves to you when they die; an event or
Predecessor - one that precedes, esp. a person who has previously occupied a position
Successor - One who succeeds to the rights or the place of another: particularly, the
Dictionary, n.d.)
Top Level Management - consists of managers at the highest level in the management
(Kalpana, n.d.)