UIJRT | United International Journal for Research & Technology | Volume 02, Issue 02, 2020

Comparison of Rutting Resistance of Stone Mastic

Asphalt with Convention Mix
Usman Ghani1, Asad Iqbal2, Shafi Ullah3, Muhammad Rizwan4 and Musharraf Javed5
1
Civil Engineering Department, Abasyn University Peshawar, Pakistan
2,4,5
Civil Engineering Department, The University of Lahore, Lahore, Pakistan
3
School of Transportation Science and Engineering HIT PR, China

Abstract— Rutting in flexible pavements is one of the SMA is found as a resilient asphalt egress alternative for
common distress displayed on national highways of residential highways and streets in Australia, Europe,
Pakistan. Various factors are related to these distress North American nation, and U.S. The mixture while not
including overloading, high temperatures, and empirical extreme losses through the dirt removal system, instead of
design approach used for structural design but not limited combination feed are the most well-liked Filler directly
to them. Stone mastic asphalt (SMA) considered an adds into the drum.
effective solution in heavily trafficked areas because of
Generally, pelletized fibers add through a system designed
the larger single size aggregate that can be used with the
for the addition of recycled materials, however, a lot of
increased bitumen thus controlling rutting. This study
economical procedure is adding pelletized fiber through a
examined the rutting behavior of two stone mastic asphalt
mail line that uses mix with the hydrocarbon delivery. so
(SMA) mixtures selected on basis of nominal maximum
that the fiber is caught by hydrocarbon at the amount of
aggregate size (NMAS):19 mm, and 12.5 mm using Glass
adding to the mixture. Stone mastic asphalt became an
fiber 0.3% of the total SMA mixtures aggregate. On the
additional ANd established for the 1960s in Deutschland
other hand, NHA class A and Class B gradation to be used
as an asphalt resistant damage by exploitation adorned
for convention mixtures for the rutting comparison with
tires. this sort of asphalt is well-liked in Europe to supply
SMA mixtures. Superpave mix design used to be obtained
egress for closely trafficked roads, harbor areas, and
optimum binder content for each mixture of SMA and
airfields. It’s referred to as hack mastic asphalt in
convention mix. Wheel tracker test to be used to find out
German’s speaking international locations, grit mastic
the rutting in each sample of SMA and Convention mixes.
asphalt or stone matrix asphalt is another name for it.
The SMA rutting results to be compared with convention
Australian unremarkably referred to as it SMA or stone
mixes rutting and then SMA rutting results to be compared
mastic asphalt There are many definitions of Stone Mastic
with each other i.e. SMA 19mm (NMAS) and SMA
Asphalt, APRG Technical observe two (1993) defines
12.5mm (NMAS).
Stone Mastic Asphalt (SMA) as a gap hierarchal sporting
course asphalt with an excessive proportion of coarse
Keywords— Mastic, Sone, Asphalt, Convention, HMA,
combination that interlock to make a stone on the stone
Pavement, Aggregate.
skeleton to repel everlasting deformation. the mixture
stuffed with hydrocarbon and filler then fibers are
I. INTRODUCTION
introduced in entail to supply enough stability of the
Since the discovery of SMA in Europe throughout the bitumen and to avoid evacuation of the binder during
Sixties, and when several trials in America, Australia, and transportation and website. at the constant time because
alternative countries; it's up to such status/level that these the definition of SMA by the manner of (Michaut,1995)
days it's considered as the most effective pavement egress that Stone mastic asphalt is gap hierarchal carrying route
course for serious duty pavements, high-speed composed of crushed aggregates sure by means that of
motorways, highways, and alternative roads have large mastic mortar”. owing to segregation problems binder
traffic of trucks. (Craig mythologist, 1999) The basic content material is often extended. “these materials aren't
purpose of SMA is to produce egress that offered the most pourable, it's communal apply to use an additive or
resistance to wreck by adorned tires. Over the decades it modified binders within the assembly of those materials
well-tried to own a high resistance to plastic deformation completely to allow the binder content material to be
from serious vehicle masses at high temperatures, at the raised and to decrease segregation among the mortar and
constant time exhibiting smart vasoconstrictor properties. therefore the coarse fraction”.

All rights are reserved by UIJRT.COM. 22

 UIJRT | United International Journal for Research & Technology | Volume 02, Issue 02, 2020

Australian Requirements (AS2150 1995) define SMA as sure of the characteristics of the thickness and durability
"high-grade hierarchical asphalt concrete of a toxic of the SMA. B. E. Gite et al (2013) Stone mastic asphalt
mixture giving a hard matrix material that is drained by a (SMA) had its origins in Deutschland before the 1960s as
first-rate mixture, binder, and filler". BCA (1998) evidence of asphalt resistance to decorated tires. The
describes Stone Mastic Asphalt as "a hydrocarbon mixture asphalt-built stone quarry is known as asphalt in Europe
of a gap that contains an excess of coarse and filler by the highly-trafficked freeway, airports, and districts. it
mixture, with only a few parts of sand size. while milling is collectively grown as a mastic asphalt isolated from
leads to waterproofing through proper local drainage. German estates and is referred to as mastic asphalt, asphalt
”SMA includes unmatched composite and aggregate sizes or stone asphalt. In Australia, it is sometimes developed
to support themselves through a combination of as stone asphalt or SMA at high speed. there are various
pigmented colors. stability is required to produce definitions of SMA [1]. The SMA was designed as a
sufficient hydrocarbon and stability to avoid spilling out carrier course with high resistance to decorated tires
of the steam during travel and site despite the appearance within the Nineteen Sixties. It became the major genre that
and internal layer thickness, voids are pronounced developed and manufactured asphalt video game
perfectly in the form of mastic in the composite form, equipment built in conjunction with a tv bit six inside
while beyond the bottom voids it is partially formed. and where asphalt mastic was applied to the surface by hand
open and provide a favorable skidding resistance to any or distribution boxes. the top five chippings versus eight
respect speed and surface water relocation services (Nunn, or 8 according to the eleven were then exposed and glued
1994). The SMA structure is different from the royal to the ground (see for example). Stacked stone asphalt
circular asphalt. that is pure and obvious that when the exerts the same amount of strength and durability as gauss
mixture is considered to be just stone and mastic (bitumen, asphalt but is often transported and made like concrete [2].
fine, filler and stabilization agent) the SMA inserts a solid SMA can be a delicate balance between mastic and
stone bone by the rich (excess) exploitation of the mastic. therefore a cohesive fraction that requires the best
by comparison; standard surface asphalt inserts AN aggregates, the relative reliability of ANd with an
underneath in a lean (lean) interior where a few stones are unparalleled quantity of mineral fibers to avoid volatility.
resolved by volume type.SMA incorporates a thick Production differences will control the combo
aggregate mixed material that forms a stone that is surprisingly, hence the use of additive and/or modified
resistant to permanent conversion. The stone skin is filled binders. The design revolves around building a solid stone
with hydrocarbon mastic and filler in the fibers is added boat with high stone content, excessive hydrocarbon, and
to transfer the energy content of the bitumen energy and cement content and bonding service. the general limits are
to the binder exterior while transporting the surface. that the composite mixture (> two.36 millimeters) makes
standard SMA formulations include 70-80% coarse up 70-80% of the weight of the mixture, the fine mixture
mixture, 8-12% filler, 6.zero-7.zero% binder, and is 12-17% so the filler fraction is within the eighth and
zero.three% fiber. the main objectives of this analysis are third% range. within the SMA study, its% throughput, 0.1
to study the fine-grained asphalt corrosion resistance / 2 mm, 2.36 millimeters, and 4.75 millimeters are 10%,
(SMA) through the use of optical fiber as a stabilizer. to 20%, and 30% respectively so local growth comes to life.
look at the light resistance of various Stone Mastic Fifteen stone crushed above 5 millimeters uses 70%,
Asphalt (SMA) mixtures. to investigate the impact of minerals, and high asphalt content and some
gradation on rutting resistance of the Stone Mastic reinforcement materials (using fibers or polymers) (Shen,
Asphalt (SMA) bearing route et al, undated). The binder content is sometimes within the
range of 6.5 - 7.5% by exploiting a mixing weight of 14
II. LITERATURE REVIEW mm and 10 mixes. The mastic fills the voids that store the
Stone mastic asphalt (SMA) can be a form of stone such chips in the ANd have the added effect as the distribution
as a canoe of a hierarchal gap mixture, reinforced along of air gaps and consequently the strong asphalt (AAPA,
with the mastic support. what is the high content of binder, 1993) [3].
filler, and fiber to reduce binder drain? This structure SMA is best described as an issue heat mixing asphalt
enhances the facility and therefore SMA performance HMA containing a hazardous compaction vessel based on
exceeds the maximum strength of asphalt. a large portion gradient-graded gradation and high bitumen content mud.
of the content of the binder content is important to make

All rights are reserved by UIJRT.COM. 23

 UIJRT | United International Journal for Research & Technology | Volume 02, Issue 02, 2020

since the eighties, the Stone Mastic Asphalt (SMA) site layer. however, most of those problems are usually caused
has been well used in Debcchland on best-selling streets. by production problems. another comment made during
In the wake of its unbelievable performance began a the performance analysis was that there was no evidence
national launch in Deutschland in 1984. If you think about of fiber in any future. the thought behind the SMA event
it, because of its great performance, the use of SMA was is completely misunderstood. The SMA combination
justified on behalf of the highway and commercial asphalt contains important components al, 1993). The APRG
managers (B. E. Gite et al). SMA provides an extremely (1998) suggests that the origin of the SMA can be
reliable and durable HMA mix by comparing the excessive aggregate content with high concentration and
composite asphalt mixture. This development is filter content. This binder/filler combination works
characterized by the creation of a stone boat that connects "mastic".
stones to SMA. It is largely based on several analytical
The stabilizing agent usually avoids evacuation of a
reports and traffic engineering research will reap the
specific shipping site. As a result of strokes between
potential for durability and durability.
coarse composites coated with synthetic mastic, the
SMA mixtures are designed to contain excessive, asphalt following voids of air are less dense than they may in one
content excess content sometimes to 5.5- 7% and high case have typical royal asphalt. Styl mastic asphalt has a
filter content. In traditional SMA, the use of unauthorized deformation that is unmatched in strength and strength
hydrocarbon in combination with a fibrous artifact as an characteristics, without being resistant to high fatigue.
escape is sufficient. at extremely high temperatures and Pebble asphalt incorporates a dense surface texture that
extreme loading, a strong hydrocarbon range is achieved. provides better skid resistance and lower noise
SMA has been active in Europe for over thirty years. characteristics than white asphalt. improved flexibility
SMAs became the first workers in Europe as a mixture resistance, or resistance to evaporation, compared to high-
that could deal with damage to decorated tires, but the strength asphalt is accomplished by using an optical
added benefit gained by SMA is that it lasted for a long material from the excess soluble content that forms the
time and with amazing body resistance. thanks to the solid stone. In dense hierarchal asphalt, high-quality
SMA initiative in Europe, five world-class businesses mastic provides durability. The increasing strength of
within the SMA engineer roads were created for a specific SMA arising from its sluggish corrosion cases is obtained
purpose in 1991. these groups design strategies to exploit from the low permeableness of the binder formed by
SMA congestion followed by processes. The formula mastic cementing combined.
unlimited contained an unbroken gradation band that
The increased resistance to fatigue may be the result of
adhered to the "60-30-10 rule. This rule states that sixty
higher hydrocarbon content, greater hydrocarbon image,
percent of composites are made of the hard mixture,
and lower air content. the high content of the binder
thirty% are satisfactory composites, and 10% are the
should be forced to contribute to the flexibility and
mineral artist. al (2004).
flexibility of the fracture arising from the broken bottom
The first folder within the American equivalent of the lanes. this is often based on expertise in tests conducted
structure of the SMA combos was created by the SMA within United States, where cracks (hot and reflective) are
Technical reduction (TWG) program and displayed in now no longer a spoken problem. fat areas are seen as the
1994. Within this book, one benchmarking brand was largest organ. this is a result of fragmentation,
awarded. within the group, SMA certification that met the degradation, and high content of asphalt or a negative
requirements of TWG may have an average length of amount of stability (Brown, et al, 1997). rich mastic gives
12,000 or 19,0 meters of high specification (in the a glorious performance and has great resistance to stress
definition of a roadmap). In 1997, the center heard on (integrated storage). Excessive binder and filling content
Asphalt technology (NCAT) carried out a feasibility study provide long-lasting elasticity, resistance to fatigue,
between over 40 SMA pipes and forty from everywhere durability asphalt egress in nearby commercial areas. An
we are. main all one hundred and forty SMA areas. In ambitious project in planning the AN SMA is to combine
terms of performance, over 80% of the SMA surveyed to form a specific stone bone that involves fitting the right
roads had a height of four miles or much less. there have amount of binder. A good amount of binder helps to
been six of the first 100 of the forty stages where teaching compress the aggregated particles, while the
(more than six meters) is usually included in the SMA imperfections end up in a poorly absorbed mixture,

All rights are reserved by UIJRT.COM. 24

 UIJRT | United International Journal for Research & Technology | Volume 02, Issue 02, 2020

contain excess air voids, and have a thick skin in the

adhesive layer and therefore are less attractive.

III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This study has been directed in a prearranged and
dependent style. first of all, to add clearness, the
prevailing literature regarding the situation turned into
located and reviewed in an element that helped in the
development of conceptual definitions and strategies to be
carried out for this research. The evaluation of literature
Figure2:WheelTracker
turned into keeps ongoing sports that become directed
constantly in similar to the opposite research paintings.
consequently, the suitable fabric became selected to
prepare the numerous mixes of conference and SMA. The
bitumen used becomes from Attock Refinery constrained
(ARL), having the penetration grade of 60/70 turned into
decided on whilst mixture from Margalla quarry site
become measured appropriate for these studies. The
ingredients of SMA and convention Mixes were mixed
with every other after foremost binder content material
and aggregate gradation is selected consistent with NHA Figure 3:Wheel Tracker Solid Rubber Tyre
specification magnificence A & B for conference blend
and NCAT gradation specification for SMA. The samples IV. RESULTS AND DISSCUSSIONS
have been then compacted in curler Compactor at precise Aggregate gradation curves for stone mastic asphalt
temperature with the desired range of passes and preferred (SMA) wearing course aggregate composition. According
stress. to the National Centre for Asphalt Technology (NCAT)
gradation specifications. Aggregate composition for
conventional mix asphalt wearing course gradation
according to NHA specifications.

Figure 4: Aggregate gradation for SMA mixtures

Figure 1: Research methodology flow chart

All rights are reserved by UIJRT.COM. 25

 UIJRT | United International Journal for Research & Technology | Volume 02, Issue 02, 2020

Figure 5: Aggregate gradation (NHA specifications) gradationWheel Tracker typically measure the rut, created
by the repeated passage of a wheel over asphalt concrete
samples. The temperature is taken 40ºc to perform a wheel
tracking test and the temperature was the same for each
sample of asphalt mix. The sustained load at wheel were
7KN and the number passed on the sample was fixed at
10000 for each mix.

Figure 6: SMA versus convention mix Aggregate

gradation

Figure 8: Rutting in Stone Mastic Asphalt(12.5mm

NMAS)

Figure 7: Rutting in Stone Mastic Asphalt (19mm

NMAS)

A super pave mix design is used for the calculation of

optimum binder content. The design perimeters and their
Figure 9: Rutting in convention mix (NHA Class A)
calculation of super pave mix design are explained briefly
in previous in the methodology portion. Optimum binder Then the rutting comparison is shown in Graph. For stone
for stone mastic asphalt obtained 5.6 percent for 19mm mastic asphalt (19mm NMAS) versus convention mix
(NMAS) gradation at 4% air voids while voids filled with asphalt (NHA class A). SMA (19mm NMAS) occurs just
asphalt (VFA) is 80 percent at 5.6 percent binder content. 31% rutting as compare to convention mix (NHA class A)
Optimum binder for stone mastic asphalt obtained 6.1 at normal temperature 40 ◦c, while maximum standard rut
percent for 12.5mm (NMAS) gradation at 4% air voids depth was taken 12mm, and the number of passes is
while voids filled with asphalt (VFA) is 80 percent at 6.1 10000. SMA gives 69% better results against rutting than
percent binder content. Optimum binder for stone mastic convention mix.
asphalt obtained 4 percent for NHA Class A gradation at
4% air voids while voids filled with asphalt (VFA) is 79
percent at 4 percent binder content. Optimum binder for
stone mastic asphalt obtained 4.2 percent for NHA Class
A gradation at 4% air voids while voids filled with asphalt
(VFA) is 78 percent at 4.2 percent binder content. The
effect of aggregate gradation from the rutting test also
discussed in the results. Gradation of aggregate highly
effect on asphalt rutting resistance of wearing course
asphalt. Various Aggregate gradation results of different
specifications used and optimum binder content for each Figure 10: Rutting in convention mix (NHA Class B)

All rights are reserved by UIJRT.COM. 26

 UIJRT | United International Journal for Research & Technology | Volume 02, Issue 02, 2020

Then the rutting comparison is shown in the graph. For

stone mastic asphalt (12.5mm NMAS) versus convention
mix asphalt (NHA class B). In SMA (12.5mm NMAS)
occurred just 40% rutting as compare to convention mix
(NHA class B) at normal temperature 40◦c, while
maximum standard rut depth was taken 12mm, and the
number of the pass was 10000. SMAgives 60% better
results against rutting than convention mix.
Figure 11: Rutting in of SMA (19mm NMAS) vs.
Conventional Mix (Class A)

Figure 16: Final rut depth of SMA (12.5mm NMAS)

vs. SMA (19mm NMAS)

Figure 12: Final rut depth of SMA (19mm NMAS) vs. Then rutting comparison is shown in GraphFor stone
Conventional Mix (Class A) mastic asphalt (19mm NMAS) versus SMA (12.5mm
NMAS). SMA (19mm NMAS) occurs just 35% rutting as
compare SMA (12.5mm NMAS) at normal temperature
40 ◦c, while maximum standard rut depth was taken
12mm, and the number of passes was 10000. SMA (19mm
NMAS) gives 65% better results against rutting than SMA
(12.5mm NMAS).

VII. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Figure 13: Rutting in of SMA (12.5mm NMAS) vs.
Conventional Mix (Class B) The extraordinary Stone Mastic Asphalt and convention
blend gradation combinations produced inside the
laboratory have been examined in wheel tracker machine
for his or her rutting performance and other factors that
drastically impact the performance of pavement and it was
concluded that the gradation of mixture maximum large
thing that effect the performance of the pavements in case
of studying rutting behavior of asphalt pavements. In
SMA (19mm NMAS) occurred simply 31% rutting as
examine to convention mix (NHA forty-six class A),
Figure 14: Final rut depth of SMA (12.5mm NMAS) sixty-nine % better effects against rutting than conference
vs. Conventional Mix (Class B) mix. In SMA (12.5mm NMAS) came about just forty%
rutting as evaluate to conference mix (NHA magnificence
B), offers 60% better consequences towards rutting than
convention mix. The outcomes executed standard that
stone mastic asphalt given better outcomes against rutting
than conference mix but when compare between stone
mastic asphalt 19mm NMAS and 12.5mm NMAS, In
Stone Mastic Asphalt (19mm NMAS) befell simply 35%
Figure 15: Rutting in SMA (12.5mm NMAS) vs. SMA rutting as examine Stone Mastic Asphalt (12.5mm
(19mm NMAS) NMAS), gives sixty-five % higher outcomes towards

All rights are reserved by UIJRT.COM. 27

 UIJRT | United International Journal for Research & Technology | Volume 02, Issue 02, 2020

rutting than SMA (12.5mm NMAS) consequently from [8] Farhana R, Mustaque H, “Review and Analysis of
the remaining result got here to understand that the Hamburg Wheel Tracking Device Test Data”, [2013]
gradation of the aggregate most huge element that affects [9] Prof. B. E. Gite, Mr.Momin Soyal Abjal “Stone
the overall performance of the pavements in case of Mastic Asphalt” Amrutvahini College of
studying rutting behavior of asphalt pavements. Engineering, Sangamner
This research can be further stretched to discover different
sizable factors that affect the rutting in the pavement along
with gradation of the mixture, alternate in temperature
while acting wheel monitoring take a look at and percent
of glass fiber, etc. additionally, this research technique
may be hired to calculate the performance of different
form of asphaltic pavement systems with special bitumen
contents. furthermore, the addition of diverse
performance-enhancing additives for asphaltic concrete
can also be searched in destiny to forecast the performance
of a pavement structure. further to above the software of
SMA should be recommended many of the specialists of
motorway engineering to unfold responsiveness,
specialists, and frauds and prospective benefits of Stone
Mastic Asphalt to the working professionals. This takes a
look at might additionally help to sensitize pavement
layout engineers about the mechanistic approach of
pavement layout. “

REFERENCES
[1] Rosli H, Wasid FR, Hamed N, “The Importance of
Stone Mastic Asphalt in Construction” Department
of geotechnics and transportation engineering,
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Vol. 17 [2012], pp.
49
[2] Lothar D, Berlin VS, “Stone Mastic Asphalt” German
Asphalt Association Deutscher Asphaltverband e.V.
Schieffelingsweg 6 53123 Bonn, [2000], pp. 4
[3] Rosli H, Wasid FR, Hamed N, “The Importance of
Stone Mastic Asphalt in Construction” Department
of geotechnics and transportation engineering,
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Vol. 17 [2012], pp.
51-52
[4] Lothar D, Berlin VS, “Stone Mastic Asphalt” German
Asphalt Association Deutscher Asphaltverband e.V.
Schieffelingsweg 6 53123 Bonn, [2000], pp. 6-7
[5] “Technical Note 16 Stone Mastic Asphalt”
Supersedes APRG Technical Note 2, August 1993
[6] NZTA M10:2014 “Specification for Dense Graded
and Stone Mastic Asphalts”
[7] Zhang Q, Chen Y, Li Xl “Rutting in Asphalt
Pavement under Heavy Load and High Temperature”

All rights are reserved by UIJRT.COM. 28