Glass Industry Webinar 2020
Glass Industry Webinar 2020
3. Pitfalls (Daniel)
2
Manufacturing process & Industry
Glass Industry overview
• Before COVID overview
– Glass Packaging Market Size was worth over USD 45 billion in 2016.
– The industry will grow by a CAGR of about 4.5% up to 2024.
• This Industry growth expectations are still looks promising, even after COVID
4
Glass containers manufacturing process
IS Machine (vacuum)
5
Glass forming methods
Forming & Shaping from IS machines
Individual section (IS) machine is separated into varying sections to
produce several containers of the same size simultaneously. The molten
glass is cut with a shearing blade into a specific gob size. The gob falls into
the machine by force of gravity down into the mold, where it starts to take
shape and become a parison. The parison is then flipped 180 in a second
mold to finish off the dimensions of the glass.
Compressed air 3.5 - 7bar is used to force glass gobs into the shape of
moulds
Vacuum is also applied through small holes in the walls of the mould
– Vacuum makes faster moulding, quicker cooling and sharper final dimensions,
better dimensional control allows thinner bottles = lighter product, less raw
material.
– Vacuum also lowers compressed air requirement by 80% reducing total energy
cost.
Increased productivity, Improved product quality, lower energy, lower material useage
7
Glass bottle making Process
A Short Video
8
Global OEM for IS machines
Glass forming machine manufactures
USA
Italy
Germany IS Machines:
“Individual Section”
Czech Or
“Independent Section”
Italy
9
END customers
Glass bottles manufacturers
Vacuum application and plant overview
11
Glass containers manufacturing process
Vacuum requirement
• Moulds are divided in two half that are closed and rapidly evacuated by
equalization with a Vacuum network through very small holes in the
mould (0.4 mm) resulting in almost constant flow demand at vacuum
pump.
• Vacuum level between 150 and 300 mbar depending on manufacturer
and type of product.
• The vacuum requirement of each section of IS Machine varies from
type of machine and type of product between 100 and 250 m3/h flow.
• A standard IS machine may require from 600 to 1500 m3/h. But very
large ones can require up to 4000 m3/h.
12
Plant overview
Customer information
A production site capable of 1M bottles/day can
have up to 5 production lines lined up to give
continuous production 24/7.
A typical layout = IS machine connected through
DN100 lines to a vacuum network with following
characteristics:
- Main manifold can be DN200 or even bigger.
- Plants can have a buffer tank (1).
- A filtration system (2) required to protect the
pumps.
- Vacuum pumps system (3) is designed with
redundancy to grant 24/7 operation.
13
The vacuum system
How utility room will look like
14
Problematics and Pitfalls
Problematics for vacuum system and pitfalls
Best installation practices towards filtration
• Pitfalls
– Unexpected events as production machine breaks which lead to excessive vacuum pipe contamination
– Age of the machines or of built in filtration
– Type and quantity of the Kleenmold oil used => local process engineering projects
– Pipeline layout & sizing
– Filter sizing and draining practices
Pitfalls ?
What happens in case of an
Some of the problems encountered so far. excessive contamination of
the vacuum line because of a
machine break
17
Pitfalls ?
What happens when I just
Some of the problems encountered so far. open the valve underneath
the LRS filter in order to drain
18
Expressway to the oil party
Hey you
are also
on the
party ?
Yeah, sure. It
was really
easy to get in
here
Who takes the detour when the direct route is so quick and easy ?
19
Why oil contamination must be avoided
Process oil is entrained, saturates filters and contaminates the vacuum pumps
• The Kleenmold oil is not compatible with our pump Graphite 1.5 to 2.5 %
oil which will lead to excessive oil consumption and Sulfur 4.0 to 5.0 %
cooling and lubrication issues. Petroleum Oil 70 to 80 %
Additives 20 to 30%
• Vacuum pump oil filters clog and cause
temperature problems with downtime
• The graphite added for the lubrication of the glass
machines leads to higher wear in the vacuum
pumps
• Shorter service intervals = higher costs
• The saturation of the inlet filter causes high
pressure drops
• The pump will consume more power to achieve the
desired pressure = more costs
20
Party is over, the runway is closed
Hey, were
are the
other
guys?
I don’t know
…heard that
they stuck in
a detour
21
Roadmap to a successful installation
Pre-separation as part of the problem solution
Droplet separation by gravity
Droplet separation with demister or wire mesh
How can we eliminate oil mist from gas flow?
The use of a buffer tank as pre-separation by gravity
23
Besides effective filtration, pre-separation is essential !
The importance of the correct filtration system with demister
24
Roadmap to a successful installation
Pre-separation as part of the problem solution
Droplet separation by gravity
Filtration with demister or wire mesh
Gas velocity is an important factor
A mist is a group of droplets of different sizes travelling with the gas flow
𝑉𝑉𝐺𝐺
𝑤𝑤𝐺𝐺 =
droplet
𝐹𝐹𝐺𝐺
26
Gas velocity is an important factor
The role of gravity
Outlet
hgas = the distance the droplet has to fall to the liquid level
in a shorter time than the gas passes the separator
27
Sizing an buffer tank as gravity separator
The permissible flow velocity in mist eliminators (here buffer) are determined as follows
28
For separation of droplets larger than 400 microns The deeper
the vacuum
the higher
The gas velocity in the buffer should be less than 2m/s (red line) is the
allowed gas
Permisable gas velocity in a gravity seperator velocity
12,00 0,70
0,60
10,00
0,50
permissable gas velocity m/s
8,00
6,00
0,30
4,00
0,20
2,00
0,10
0,00 0,00
10 50 250
Pressure mbar(a)
29
Gas velocity is an important factor
Important parameters are flow cross section FG, the length L and gas height hgas FG = 𝐴𝐴 = 𝜋𝜋𝑟𝑟 2
𝜋𝜋
= D²
4
Using the formula we can check correct size of buffer tank
𝑉𝑉𝐺𝐺
𝑤𝑤𝐺𝐺 = L D
𝐹𝐹𝐺𝐺
hgas
30
The time needed for the droplet to fall < gas residence time
Time for the droplets to settle down on the liquid Reservoir
∏ Pi 3,142
D Separator diameter (m) 1,4
L Separator length (m) 1,9
h Gas height in the separator (m) 2,1
fG Cross section share for gas flow =FG/Fges 1
FG Flow cross section for the gas flow (m²) 1,539
Fges Total cross-sectional area of the separator (m²) 1,539
VG Gas load (m³/h) 6000
wG Gas flow velocity (m/s) 1,083
wzul Permissible flow velocity (m/s) 1,686 L hgas
wFall Droplet fall velocity (m/s) 1,8
tFall Droplet fall time (s) 1,167
tresi residence time (s) 1,755
tzul Permissible residence time 1,127
K Cunningham Correction factor 0,04
Density fluid kg/m³ 800
Density Gas kg/m³ 0,45
wausl Design velocity (75% of wzul ) 1,265
32
Comparison of gas residence time with mist droplet fall time
t residence > t fall
Vessel Volume Seperator length L actual speed (flow in Am³/h)
500 1000 1500 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000
actual speed (flow in Am³/s)
0,139 0,278 0,417 0,556 0,833 1,111 1,389 1,667
t residence [s]
8092 3003 45 270 0,97 1,541 0,770 0,514 0,385 0,257 0,193 0,154 0,128
8092 3003 52 500 0,75 1,847 0,924 0,616 0,462 0,308 0,231 0,185 0,154
8092 3003 60 1000 1,16 6,560 3,280 2,187 1,640 1,093 0,820 0,656 0,547
8092 3003 78 2000 0,86 8,863 4,432 2,954 2,216 1,477 1,108 0,886 0,739
8092 3003 86 3000 1,8 18,551 9,275 6,184 4,638 3,092 2,319 1,855 1,546
33
Using our buffer tank as pre-seperator
How to estimate the right size ? Gas velocity wG should be less than 2m/s (better with safety fact. 75%)
Please also consider the dimensions of the inlet and outlet flange to avoid high pressure differences
34
Roadmap to a successful installation
Pre-separation as part of the problem solution
Droplet separation by gravity
Filtration with demister or wire mesh
Actions to improve the droplet separation
Introduce a wire mesh or demister pad
36
Actions to improve the droplet separation
Introduce a wire mesh or demister pad
38
Atlas Copco recommended set up
• The SKP filter installed next to the pumps ( lower than the inlet of the pump)
Use the force of gravity for the oil separation and to guarantee regular controls of the separation
(Use 1 micron Element)
40
Layout considerations
Expansion tank to slow down the flow
• Check if main line already includes a “large” buffer tank.
• If not propose to install one in line to CVS pumps installation
41
Installation of a proper sized manifold with Gooseneck connections
The manifold should be leaked with a gradient to a drainage point
• Reduce risk of heavy oil load to filters and pumps
42
Proper installation of the filter
Filter installation
The filter purpose
Stop and collect all residual oil mist before the pump
Extend service intervals of the pumps.
The filter position
Below the pump*
With goose neck connection to the pump
Isolation valves and a bypass
Allow Service and cleaning of the filter
Keeping vacuum pump in operation **
*Oil will not evaporate
**Work without filtration for short period does not harm the pump
43
Filter Sizing
Based on environment considerations
Filter should be selected based on:
Velocity of the max flow through the pump @ 150/200 mbar
Inspecting real site conditions and installation
Contamination due to age of installation or type of oil used
44
SKP When in doubt on an application?
SKP-DM30 485Z DN200* change 1 micron 30" demister 30" element 4000 for GHS3800 ( SKP30" demister with DN200 flange)
SKP-DM36 489Z DN200* change 36" vessel 36" demister max flow >5000 For GHS4600 and GHS5400 (SKP300 w DN200 flanges)
* = New
45
Proper Usage of the filter
Filter Service
• The Polyester filter
– Change-Out Differential: 10” to 15” / 250-380mm H2O Over Initial dP
– The polyester element may be washed in warm soapy water,
vacuumed, gently blown out or replaced. The element should be dry
before reinstallation.
– To be replaced after a maximum of three cleanings.
• Epoxy Coated Wire Mesh and Stainless Steel Wire Mesh Elements:
– Cleaning similar to polyester, except mild solvents may be used.
• Demister Pad:
– SS 304 or Polypropylene
– The demister pad may be washed in warm soapy water or replaced.
46
Proper Usage of the filter
Filter drain
• Manual Drain
– Set-up
• Do not reduce the size of the connection/valve
• Valve before, after drain container and Air inlet
– How?
• Drain SKP to container during operation
• Isolate drain container from SKP
Vent the container
Drain the container
50
Success story
O-I Manufacturing Italy S.p.A. (Aprilia)
52
Success Story
Drujba Glassworks, Bulgaria
• Our Solution:
– GHS 1900 VSD+ x 3
53
Success Story
Phoenicia Glass works, ISRAEL
54
Growing GHS VSD+ references globally!
Company Country Model qty
Ardagh Glass UK GHS 1900VSD+ 8
Verallia Chili GHS 900VSD+ 1
Verallia Chili GHS 1600VSD+ 1
• Over 80 units in operation
Orora glass Australia GHS 1300VSD+ 6
BA Glass Portugal Portugal GHS 1900VSD+ 1 • Over 40 Glass Factories world wide
BA Glass Spain Spain GHS 1900VSD+ 1
Allied Glass Contain UK GHS 1900VSD+ 2 • Sizes from GHS730 to GHS5400
STEKLARNA Slovenia GHS 1900VSD+ 1
• Our improved experience with the
Alver Oram Algeria GHS 1600VSD+ 1
filtration system
OI Argentina GHS 1900VSD+ 1
OI UK GHS 1900VSD+ 2
OI UK GHS 4600VSD+ 2
OI Italy GHS 900VSD+ 1
Noelle Von Campe Germany GHS 5400VSD+ 1
Sisecam (Yenisehir) Turkey GHS 3800VSD+ 1
Sisecam (Mersin) Turkey GHS 3800VSD+ 2
CAN Glass India GHS 3800VSD+ 1
AGI Glaspac India GHS5400VSD+ 1
AGI Glaspac India GHS1600VSD+ 2
55
Growing GHS VSD+ references globally!
Company Country Model qty
OWENS-ILLINOIS DO BR Brazil GHS 900VSD+ 1
AGC Flat Glass Czech Czech Republic GHS 350VSD+ 1
Ardagh Glass GmbH Germany GHS 3800VSD+ 3
OI Brazil GHS 900VSD+ 1
OI Brazil GHS 3800VSD+ 2
OI Brazil GHS 1900VSD+ 8 Growing
Yinan Sanhui Glass China GHS 730 VSD+ 1 references Due
Fuyao Group(Shenyang) Automobile Glass China GHS 900 VSD+ 1 to the Positive
Fuyao Group(Shenyang) Automobile Glass China GHS 900 VSD+ 1 word of Mouth
Druzba glass Plovdiv (BA Glass) Bulgaria GHS 1900VSD+ 3 feedback from
BA Romania GHS 1900VSD+ 1 the users!
Bormioli Rocco Spain GHS 1600VSD+ 1
Embalvidro Portugal --> Angola GHS 1300VSD+ 3
Steklarna Slovenia GHS 1900VSD+ 2
Hebei Yanjin Glass China GHS 730 VSD+ 1
Jiangxi Shengli Glass China GHS 730 VSD+ 2
OI France GHS 3800VSD+ 2
Ardagh Glass UK GHS 4600VSD+ 3
56
Competition
overview
58
Main COMPETITORS
Competitors
Pneumofore, Italy
• Main focus product: Rotary Vane vacuum pump and compressor
• Known player in Glass bottle and can manufacturing application
• Pneumofore was almost like a monopoly in the global glass market so far
– They keep very high pricing level & not much negotiation
– UV 16 : Above 35000 EUR / UV 24 : Above 40000 EUR / UV 30 : Above 50000 EUR / UV 50 : Above 85000 EUR
– These are approx. minimum price levels and inclusive of filters.
• In the exhibition, they showcase 5 years warranty for the vane element
– For UV 50, the approx. Vane replacement cost quoted in India was : 25000 Euros approx
• Trying to offer free spares along with the new pump or for the existing pumps
– Instead of dropping prices
– They also extend the buy back of old pumps
61
Data Sheet 2019
62
Technology difference
How reliable is the GHS VSD+ screw technology?
• Pneumofore
• Atlas Copco
– Conventional Vane technology
– 4:6 Profile patented Oil-Sealed screw element - Industry
– Reliable but Inefficient compared to the latest screw pumps
leading efficiency.
– Vane technology:
– Pulsation free – Capable of More flow for less power
– More wearing than on screw technology
– Limitation of max speed
63
Variable Speed Drive ( VSD)
Does it have EMC (Electro Magnetic Compliance) certification??
• Integrated VSD with additional RFI filters and Line • Seems to operate at specific frequency points
reactors to control to harmonics. EMC certification Retrofitted VSD and need to educate the
is available customer about EMC certification.
• Special VSD Duty motor to give wide turn down & • Standard Duty motor can not give wider
Runs at all the rpm seamlessly operating flow range
64
Know bit about the service factor
You may face this argument
• “Atlas Copco motor is with service factor. Will it can consume more than nominal power ”
– The motors are invertor duty specially designed for VSD applications. And is designed with Service Factor.
– The motor has additional power capabilities to handle the continuous peak loads.
– What matters is the SER (kW/m3) ; real power consumption divided by real flow.
– The savings are really coming from the “Wide operating flow range” & How efficient are we at the part load savings
Highlight the user friendly “Elektronikon”
Microprocessor based controller
• Models: X-WPSO 204 | X-WPSO 264 | X-WPSO 324 | X-WPSO 404 X-WPSO 504 | X-WPSO 644 | X-WPSO 764
• X-WKP-WPSO WITTIG Rotary Vanes with rotary lobe: 2000 to 18000 m3/hr
– Vacuum range 10 to 100 mbar (abs.)
Wittig Elmo-Rietschle
Points to remember
68
Wittig Elmo-Rietschle
Points to remember
• Catalog says
– Operating Vacuum level is 1 to 200 mbar.a
• Price Positioning
– For 4500 m3/hr : Approx 125,000 USD
69
Competition
Sullair
• Screw technology
• Not optimized for Vacuum Application
– Bigger Motor rating & oversized bearings
OTHER COMPETITORS
• Nash is the most diffused supplier of LRP in existing installation…. Target for replacement
• KAESER can be found in companies with same brand compressor
• Aerzen is looking at this market but limited by their ultimate vacuum capability
72
CONCLUSION
Key take aways
• The machine for producing containers is called Individual Section machine (IS)
– Number of sections 6 to 20
– Vacuum level 150-300 mbar
– Average flow for new machine 1000/1300 m3/h (medium), 3000 m3/h (large)
• A good layout of vacuum line is key
– Buffer tank to reduce velocity and have pre separation
– Avoid draining straight into the pump
– Size correctly the filter
• We are an important player with global references
• Our key competitor is Pneumofore
Thank you