Opacifier
Opulyn
Sylvie DOULUT
Valbonne - 19th April 2011
Agenda
• Value Proposition
• Product Line
• Features and Benefits
• Market overview
• Product Family & Application Area
• Functionality/Technical Attributes and Key Applications
• Positioning Statement
• Technical Issue
• Regulations
• Selling Tools
• Competitive Landscape
• Summary and conclusion
19-April-2011 2 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Value proposition
For formulators of economy to luxury toiletries (shower
gels, shampoos, liquid soaps,..)
the Opulyn™ Opacifiers
offers the best way to opacify formulations with ease of
use and cost-effectiveness
because Dow Personal Care’s core competency in
acrylates technology has lead to unique styrene/
acrylate and styrene/acrylamide polymer design
19-April-2011 3 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
product line
Opulyn
Presentation
Trade name: pH solids Particle size Ionicity
Opulyn ™ 301 2.05-2.5 40 % 170 nm Anionic
Opulyn ™ 302 B 2.05-3.0 40 % 210 nm Anionic
Opulyn ™ 303 B 2.05-3.0 40 % 250 nm Nonionic
Opulyn ™ 305 2.05-2.5 40 % 300 nm Anionic
All products < 50 cPs (Brookfield LV #1, 60 rpm, 25°C)
INCI names:
Styrene/Acrylates copolymer (Opulyn 301, Opulyn 302B)
Styrene/Acrylamide copolymer (Opulyn 303B)
Acrylates / PEG-10 Maleate / Styrene copolymer (Opulyn 305)
19-April-2011 4 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Features and Benefits
OPULYN™ Opacifier
Opulyn™ Opacifier technology that Light Scattering Model
modify the appearance of formulations
Incoming light
through efficient light scattering. Scattered
light
Effective at low use levels (0.1-1%)
Impart a translucent to milky and/or lotionized Opulyn™ opacifier particle
appearance with uniform opacity to formulations
Enable formulators to make sensory claims
such as: “luxurious texture”, “creamy formula”,
“rich feel” Opulyn™ opacifier particle
19-April-2011 5 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Opacifier Market Overview
Key Insight: Body washes is the key market for opacifiers
Opacifiers usage pattern among new products
Source: Mintel March 09-March11
New product launched over the
past two years and containing Liquid Hand
Soaps;
opacifiers are mostly body washes 15,69%
Shampoos;
& liquid hand soaps followed by 12,21%
shampoos
Deodorants;
0,85%
Occurrence of opaque products in
Hair styling;
the new body washes launches has Body 0,46%
Washes;
been stable over the past years 70,09% Conditioners;
(2006-2011, Mintel source) 0,39%
Others;
0,31%
Dow is the market leader in
Opacifiers
19-April-2011 6 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Product Family & Application area
Critical ingredients/ parameters for opacifier stability:
Betaines (0.5%-4%): cationic at low pH (below 5.5)
Soaps (8-12%): Soap-based products are at high pHs (9-10) and high
temperature during manufacturing required
Cationic polymers (0.1%-0.5%):
cetrimonium chloride, polyquaternium-7, polyquaternium-10, guars
Many suppliers, various product types (differences in efficiency, in their
compatibility with opacifiers for ex,….)
Critical compatibility issues with opacifiers, especially at low pHs
pH: the lower the pHs the more critical for opacifier stability - the presence
of Soft preservatives (benzoic or sorbic acid, …) brings formulations to pHs
slightly below biological pH.
Electrolytes : the higher the electrolyte concentration the more critical for
opacifier stability.
19-April-2011 7 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Product Family & Application area
Top quality product (high foaming* – low irritation):
high betaine level + soft preservation (= low pH)
Ex: 7-10% SLES + ∼3% betaine + …….+ 0.5-0.8% NaCl, pH 4.5-5.5
critical parameter for opacifier stability = high cationic character of the system.
Lower quality product (basic cleansing – less foaming**):
low betaine level => higher salt content needed to achieve viscosity target.
Ex: 5-8% SLES + 0-1% betaine +…… + 1.5-3% NaCl, pH > 6.0
critical parameter for opacifier stability = high level of electrolyte
(*: high foaming: high foam quality: creamy foam / fine bubbles
(**less foaming: lower foam volume or low foam quality: big bubbles)
19-April-2011 8 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Product Positioning
High betaine systems
2.0 4.0
Typical compositions:
Opulyn 301
-SLES: 8%-10% 1.8 3.5
% Betaine
-CAPB: 2.0%-4%
1.6 3.0
-NaCl: 0.3%-2.0%
% NaCl
-opacifier: 0.5-1%
-preservative 1.4 2.5
-perfume Opulyn 302B
1.2 2.0
4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0
pH
Opulyn™ 301: Whatever the betaine level, the %NaCl, but high pH (>5.5)
Opulyn™ 302B: Whatever the pH, but low %NaCl and “lower” betaine level
Opulyn™ 303B / Opulyn™ 305: not recommended at all
19-April-2011 9 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Product Positioning
Low betaine systems
3.0
Typical compositions:
2.5
-SLES: 5%-8%
% NaCl
-CAPB: 0.2-1% 2.0 Opulyn™ 305
-NaCl: > 1.5%
-opacifier: 0.5-1% 1.5
-preservative Opulyn™ 303B
-perfume 1.0 Opulyn™ 302B Opulyn™ 301
4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0
pH
Opulyn™ 305: highly recommended
Opulyn™ 303B: second choice product at higher pHs (pH 5.5)
Opulyn™ 301/ Opulyn™ 302B: not recommended at all
19-April-2011 10 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Product Positioning
Shower gel, shampoo, liquid hand soap (surfactant based)
Recommended opacifier will vary with:
- pH: <5.5, 5.4<>6.2 or >6.2
- betaine (amphoteric) level: low, intermediate or high
- NaCl (salt) level: <1.5% or >1.5%
pH < 5.5 5.4 < pH < 6.2 pH > 6.0
intermediate
intermediate
intermediate
high betaine
high betaine
high betaine
low betaine
low betaine
low betaine
[NaCl] 305 302 302 305 301 301 305 301 301
< 1.5 302 301 301 301 302 302 301 302 302
301 302 305
[NaCl] 305 303 301 305 305 301 305 303 301
> 1.5 303 305 303 303 303 303 301 303
301 301
high betaine levels (high quality shower gels)
low betaine levels (liquid hand soaps)
19-April-2011 11 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Product Positioning
Positioning by end-use application
Recommended Applications Opulyn™ 301 Opulyn™ 302B Opulyn™ 303B Opulyn™ 305
Bath and Shower Products
Shampoos
Cationic-containing Products
Hair conditioners
Liquid Soaps
Solid Soaps
Preferred Choice
Recommended
Recommended but formulation dependent
Comments:
Surfactant based-shower products, shampoos or liquid soaps: (SLES/betaine/…/ NaCl) -
4.5<pH<8.0, critical parameters: pH, betaine level, NaCl level and presence of cationics.
Hair conditioners: (silicones/cetrimonium chloride/……), critical parameters: presence of other
cationic.
Soap based- shower products or liquid soaps: (soaps/SLES/(betaine)/…) – pH > 8.5, critical
parameters: ionic strength (high KOH) and presence of cationics.
19-April-2011 12 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Product Positioning
Positioning by product
Opulyn™ 301: Highly versatile opacifier for anionic surfactant-based
systems. Best performance in slightly acid to moderate pH range. Tolerates
moderate levels of inorganic electrolytes. Recommended for shampoos,
shower gels.
Opulyn™ 302B: Specifically designed for anionic surfactant-based systems
across broad pH range and with low levels of inorganic electrolytes. Preferred
choice for systems with soft preservatives, such as, shampoos, shower gels.
Opulyn™ 303B: Specifically designed to enhance the opacity of cationic
surfactant-based formulations, such as, hair conditioners.
Opulyn™ 305: Designed for anionic-surfactant based systems with high levels
of inorganic electrolytes across a broad pH range. Preferred choice for low
betaine systems, such as, liquid hand soaps.
(Not recommended for systems with quaternary ammonium derivatives or systems with
amphoteric surfactants in acidic pH range)
19-April-2011 13 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Recommendations
Storage, handling and use recommendations
Storage:
– general brochure: +4°C / +40°C (MSDS: +4°C / +45°C)
Equipment cleaning:
– high pressure washing or appropriate cleaning solution (alkaline anionic
/ nonionic surfactant mixture)
Order of addition:
– Most of time can be added directly after initial water charge
– Be aware that fatty acid neutralization requires high temperatures. In
that case and/or in case of stability issues, opacifiers should be added
diluted with product water (held out of the formulation) and added slowly
with good agitation as the final component to the formulation (after pH
adjustments, addition of dye, salt, perfume, etc.).
19-April-2011 14 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
What can affect opacifiers stability and how?
Critical parameters that affect opacifier stability in various formulations:
pH
amphoteric surfactant level
salt / electrolytes
cationic polymers
Stability issues
Dispersion
Flocculation Sedimentation
with / without
Coalescence
Creaming
19-April-2011 15 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
How to check opacifiers long term stability ?
Light scattering technique
Scan identification /
Principle : Equipment: recognition
Transmitted
Incident light light
35 cm
Backscattered 40 cm
light 35 cm
The higher the backscattering (BS), the higher the opacity
BS values vary with particle size (flocculation) and volume fraction (creaming or
sedimentation)
The lower the changes of BS all over the tube height, over time, the better the
stability
4 to 10 times earlier evaluation compared to visual observation
19-April-2011 16 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Technical Issues example of (non stable) flocculation - 24 days study - 20°C stability
Delta Backscattering
>0:00<
4%
Stability issue examples 2%
0% 1:05
-2%
-4%
example of sedimentation - 148 days study -40°C sta bility.lab 2:22
(days) -6%
Delta Backscattering
>0:00< -8%
14%
7:04
-10%
12%
-12%
10% Sample of shower gel stored at
-14% 24:04
8%
40°C for 5 months 1:22
flocculation +10mm
0mm sedimentation20mm
example - 25°C
30mm 40mm
Scan Code barre Ref 0:00
Delta Backscattering
6% 25%
>0:00<
4% 20%
6:20
15%
2%
7:23
10% Potential
0%
evolution
5%
-2%
148:00 0% 18:23
-4%
0mm 10mm 20mm 30mm 40mm -5%
Scan Code barre Ref 0:00
-10% 35:18
Tube height
-15%
Increase of BS -20%
56:17
in the low part of -25%
0mm 10mm 20mm 30mm 40mm
the tube = Scan Code barre Ref 0:00
sedimentation
19-April-2011 17 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Regulations
Opulyn versus Acusol OP
Opulyn: specific trade name for personal care use
Opulyn 30X: same polymer composition than Acusol OP30X
Acusol™ OP302 and Acusol™ OP303 will change their preservation system
and thus differentiate from Opulyn grades.
microbiological specifications (present on CoA) only for Opulyn™ grades
Global Cosmetic dossier available for all Opulyn™ grades incl:
- global inventory status (Cf next slide)
- cosmetic approvals
- composition information
- certifications
- cosmetic approvals
- specifications (CoA + analytical)
- toxicological information
19-April-2011 18 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Regulations (Global Inventory Status)
Australia Canada China EU** Japan Korea Philippines US
Opulyn 301 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Opulyn 302B Restrict. Yes No Yes Exempt Yes Yes Yes
Opulyn 303B Restrict. Yes Yes Yes Restrict. Yes Yes Yes
Opulyn 305 Restrict. Yes Restrict. Yes Exempt Yes Yes Yes
** Please Note: The EU status is the current status. It does not necessarily reflect the future status under
REACH.
Yes: - The product is listed on the country inventory. There are no volume limit restrictions for sale in
that country.
No: - The product is not listed on country inventory and cannot be sold into or manufactured with in the
country.
Restrict.: - The product is limited in annual quantity allowed. All orders are blocked and submitted to
Regulatory for approval.
Exempt: - The product is allowed if used in a cosmetic application.
19-April-2011 19 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Selling tools
Aculyns to stabilize Opulyns in specific conditions
For some specific conditions (high betaine levels, presence of
cationics,…), ACULYN™ 28 or ACULYN™ 88 can be used as a primary or
secondary thickening agent and greatly help solving stability issues.
=> Royal Shower formulation
(Aculyn 88, Opulyn 301 and Neolone PE, with PQ-10)
Creamy texture, smooth appearance, paraben-free
Remember:
- space is narrow (not efficient under every conditions with any PQ-10
concentration).
- further developments on going in Valbonne for a solution sheet
19-April-2011 20 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Royal Shower formulation
Phase Trade Name % Wt. INCI Name Supplier
A Deionised Water 58.14 Water/Aqua
Empicol ESB-70
A 17.14 Sodium Laureth Sulfate Huntsman
(70% Active)
Acrylates/Steareth-20
B ACULYN™ 88 1.07 The Dow Chemical Company
Methacrylate Crosspolymer
Empigen BSFA
B 10.00 Cocamidopropyl Betaine Huntsman
(30% active)
C UCARE™ Polymer LK 0.20 Polyquaternium-10 The Dow Chemical Company
C Deionised Water 8.00 Water/Aqua
D Sodium Hydroxide, 30% 0.20 Sodium Hydroxide
E OPULYN™ 301 1.00 Styrene/Acrylates Copolymer The Dow Chemical Company
E Deionised Water 3.00 Water/Aqua
F Citric Acid 0.04 Citric Acid
G Sodium Chloride 0.58 Sodium Chloride
Methylisothiazolinone,
G NEOLONE™ PE 0.55 The Dow Chemical Company
Phenoxyethanol
Framboise Hibiscus
G 0.08 Perfume/Parfum Robertet
G108 24594
100.00
Processing Instructions:
1. Mix ingredients of Phase A until uniform. 5. Increase the pH above 7.0 (do not exceed pH 11.0) by adding Phase D.
2. Add ingredients of Phase B individually under stirring. 6. Add ingredients of phase E previously mixed.
3. In a separate vessel, mix ingredients of Phase C. 7. Add ingredients of Phase F and G individually under stirring.
4. Add Phase C to Phase A+B under stirring. 8. Adjust pH back to specification as required.
19-April-2011 21 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Selling tools
Brainshark :
Opulyn™ 305 : The product of choice
for liquid hand soaps
Web Tool
19-April-2011 22 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Selling tools
Opulyn™ SMART FORMULATION Tool
The tool is:
- based on our expertise : T&SD and research projects
- on application area
- on critical ingredients for opacifier stability
- able to predict the stability of an opacifier by combining information for
specific criteria (provided by the tool user).
- provide two solutions at most above a minimum level of
confidence
application
Special Chem link
19-April-2011 23 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Competitive Landscape
Competitor Trade names Comments
taking share from our Opulyn301 business. Have
Cognis Euperlan positioned their grade as easy to use (no pre-dilution
required). Aggressive in Asia & EU.
Offers a range with a differentiated positioning as hR&H.
Interpolymer Syntran
Aggressive in Asia & EU.
Lytron was the old trademark of Morton (prior to R&H
Omnova Lytron
acquisition in 1999), mostly active in UK and NAR
Derypol OPM quite strong in Spain
Indulor Indunal very aggressive in Italy
EOC
Europacif me-too approach, target medium & small customers
surfactants
Synthron Modarez me-too approach, target medium & small customers
Cognis & Interpolymer are building production capacity in Asia
Evonik and ISP are indirect competitors with their pearlizing agents (EGDS,…)
Dow is offering a range with differentiated grades in terms of performance
Dow has developed a unique on-line tool, the Opulyn™ Smart Formulation tool, enabling customers
to select the most appropriate grade for a given formulation. This tool can help to differentiate your
recommendation versus competitors recommendation
Dow has extensive formulation expertise with Opacifiers
19-April-2011 24 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Competitive Landscape
How to defend against Cognis arguments?
“We are cheaper……”:
– Euperlan PCO contains a lower amount of polymer and a high level of
nonionic surfactant (20%) => brings less opacity at same dosage.
< 0.8% Opulyn 301 = 1% Euperlan PCO
“Our product do not require to be diluted…”:
– In most cases, Opulyn 301 can be blended without dilution in the initial
water charge
“You have some stability issues with Opulyn 301…”:
– Liquid soap products: Euperlan PCO ~ Opulyn 301, but
recommendation: Opulyn 305
– Traditional shower products at low pHs: Euperlan PCO ~ Opulyn 301, but
recommendation: Opulyn 302B
– Higher quality products (higher betaine levels) at low pHs: Euperlan PCO
outperforms Opulyn 301: Opulyn PQG.
19-April-2011 25 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Summary and conclusion
Who we are and what we have:
Leading opacifiers supplier
Great knowledge on application areas and chemical ingredients
Good understanding of opacifiers market and how to formulate with
opacifiers
Unique expertise on critical parameters for opacifier stability
What we offer:
Our technical support to customers:
lab application tests
Long term stability assessment
Global supply
19-April-2011 26 DOW Confidential - Do not share without permission
Thank You