G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant.

: January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Home Law Firm Law Library Laws Jurisprudence

January 2011 - Philippine Supreme Court Decisions/Resolutions

Philippine Supreme Court

Jurisprudence
Search

Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence > Year 2011 >

January 2011 Decisions > G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011
ChanRobles PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. ROGELIO
Professional Review, DOLORIDO y ESTRADA, Accused-Appellant. :
Inc.

FIRST DIVISION

G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 1 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v.

ROGELIO DOLORIDO y ESTRADA, Accused-Appellant.

DECISION

VELASCO, JR., J.:

The Case

This is an appeal from the November 27, 2009 Decision 1 of the cralaw

Court of Appeals (CA) in CA-G.R. CR-H.C. No. 00575-MIN

ChanRobles On-Line entitled People of the Philippines v. Rogelio Dolorido y Estrada,
Bar Review which affirmed the September 14, 2007 Decision 2 in Criminal cralaw

Case No. 5027 of the Regional Trial Court (RTC), Branch 27 in

Tandag, Surigao del Sur. The RTC found accused-appellant
Rogelio Dolorido y Estrada guilty of murder.

The Facts

The charge against Dolorido stemmed from the following

Information: chanrob1esvirtwallawlibrary

That on the 9th day of May 2006 at around 8:30

o'clock in the morning, more or less, at Barangay
Cagdapao, Municipality of Tago, Province of Surigao
del Sur, Philippines and within the jurisdiction of this
Honorable Court, the above-named accused, armed
ChanRobles CPA with a bolo with evident premeditation and
Review Online treachery and with intent to kill, did then and there,
willfully, unlawfully, and feloniously, attack, assault
and hack one, DANIEL ESTOSE, causing his
instantaneous death, to the damage and prejudice
of the heirs of the deceased as follows: chanrob1esvirtwallawlibrary

P70, 000.00 - as life indemnity

P10, 000.00 - as moral damage

P10, 000.00 - exemplary damages

CONTRARY TO LAW. 3 cralawredlaw

On November 15, 2006, Dolorido was arraigned, and he

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 2 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

pleaded "not guilty" to the crime charged.

During the pre-trial conference on January 18, 2007, Dolorido

admitted that he killed the deceased-victim Daniel Estose but
invoked self-defense. Likewise, the prosecution and the defense
stipulated that the Joint Affidavit of Aniolito Avila and Adrian
Avila (the Avilas) would constitute as their direct testimony,
subject to cross-examination by the defense; and the Counter
Affidavit of the Accused and the Affidavit of Mario Jariol would
also constitute as their direct testimony, subject to cross
examination by the prosecution.

During the trial, the prosecution offered the testimonies of the

Avilas and Loreta Estose. On the other hand, the defense
ChanRobles Special
presented, as its sole witness, accused-appellant Dolorido.
Lecture Series
The Prosecution's Version of Facts

The Avilas were hired laborers of the victim, Estose, tasked to

harvest the coconuts in the latter's farm in Cagdapao, Tago,

Surigao del Sur. 4 cralawredlaw

On May 9, 2006, while the Avilas were walking towards the

coconut plantation at around 8:30 in the morning, they saw
Dolorido standing near the coconut drier of Estose, appearing
very angry. After some time, Dolorido proceeded to Rustica
Dolorido's coconut drier located a hundred meters away and hid

behind a coconut tree. 5 cralawredlaw

Moments later, they saw Estose on his way to his own coconut
drier. When Estose passed by Rustica Dolorido's coconut drier,
they saw Dolorido suddenly hack Estose twice, resulting in
wounds on his arms. When Estose tried to retreat, he fell down
and it was then that Dolorido stabbed him on the left portion of
his chest, which caused his death. Dolorido suddenly left the
place.

Afraid of Dolorido's wrath, the Avilas did not immediately

proceed to the scene of the crime. It was only after 20 or so
minutes that they felt it was safe to approach Estose. When

they were near, they saw Estose was already dead. 6 They then cralaw

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 3 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

waited for Estose's wife and the police.

criminal case
Version of the Defense

+nd law cases Dolorido's defense, on the other hand, consisted of the story of
self-defense:
civil cases
chanrob1esvirtwallawlibrary

On the day of the death of the victim, Dolorido

criminal law 2
asked Estose why he was gathering Dolorido's
criminal lawyer harvested coconuts. Estose just replied, "So, what
about it?" and tried to unsheathe his bolo from its

scabbard. 7 Upon seeing this, Dolorido drew his own

cralaw

criminal law 2 bolo and stabbed Estose. When Estose tried to

wrestle for the bolo, he sustained some wounds.
criminal lawyer
Afterwards, while Dolorido was pointing the bolo at
Estose, the latter suddenly lunged at Dolorido,
rules of evidence
causing Estose to hit the bolo with his own chest
scotus law which resulted in his death. 8 cralaw He denied the

prosecutor's claim that he hid behind a coconut tree

civil law court
and waited for Estose to come. Thereafter, Dolorido,
accompanied by one Mario Jariol, voluntarily
surrendered to the Tago Police Station.
scotus law
Rulings of the Trial and Appellate Courts
civil law court
After trial, the RTC convicted accused Dolorido. The dispositive
supreme court portion of its September 14, 2007 Decision reads: chanrob1esvirtwallawlibrary

appeals court WHEREFORE, finding accused Rogelio Dolorido y

Estrada GUILTY beyond reasonable doubt of the
court serve
crime of MURDER qualified by treachery, and
appreciating in his favor the mitigating circumstance
of voluntary surrender, without any aggravating
circumstance to offset the same, the Court hereby
January-2011
sentences him to suffer the penalty ofReclusion
Jurisprudence
Perpetua, to pay the heirs of deceased-victim
Daniel Estose y Langres the sum ofP50, 000.00 as
civil indemnity, P50, 000 as moral damages and
G.R. No. 181298 :
P25, 000.00 as temperate damages; and to pay
January 10, 2011 BELLE
the cost.
CORPORATION,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 4 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Petitioner, v. xxx
COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL REVENUE, SO ORDERED. 9 cralawredlaw

Respondent.
On November 27, 2009, the CA affirmed in toto the judgment of

the RTC. 10
G.R. No. 176339 :
cralawredlaw

January 10, 2011 DO-

The Issues
ALL METALS
INDUSTRIES, INC., SPS. Accused-appellant assigns the following errors: chanrob1esvirtwallawlibrary

DOMINGO LIM and LELY

KUNG LIM, Petitioners, v. I.

SECURITY BANK CORP., The court a quo gravely erred in not appreciating
TITOLAIDO E. self-defense interposed by accused.
PAYONGAYONG,
EVYLENE C. SISON, II.

PHIL. INDUSTRIAL
The court a quo gravely erred in convicting the
SECURITY AGENCY
accused-appellant of murder despite the failure of
CORP. and GIL SILOS,
the prosecution to prove the elements of treachery.
Respondents.
III.
G.R. No. 188792 :
The court a quo gravely erred in awarding damages
January 10, 2011
despite failure of the prosecution to present
SPOUSES GEORGE R.
evidence to support their claim.
TAN and SUSAN L. TAN,
Petitioners, v. BANCO DE The Court's Ruling
ORO UNIBANK, INC.,
The appeal has no merit.
Respondent. G.R. Nos.
190677-78 : January 10, Self-defense is absent
2011 GEORGE R. TAN
and SUSAN L. TAN, In his Brief, accused-appellant argues that the trial court failed

Petitioners, v. BANCO DE to consider the circumstance of unlawful aggression on the part

ORO UNIVERSAL BANK, of the victim. He contends that he only acted in self-defense,

Respondent. G.R. Nos. and this is the reason why he voluntarily surrendered to the

190699-700 : January authorities.

10, 2011 BANCO DE ORO

We do not agree.
UNIBANK, INC.,
Petitioner, v. GEORGE R. In order for self-defense to be successfully invoked, the

TAN and SUSAN L. TAN, following essential elements must be proved: (1) unlawful

Respondents. aggression on the part of the victim; (2) reasonable necessity

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 5 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

of the means employed to prevent or repel such aggression;

G.R. No. 190889 : and (3) lack of sufficient provocation on the part of the person
January 10, 2011 resorting to self-defense. 11 cralawredlaw

ELENITA C. FAJARDO,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE OF A person who invokes self-defense has the burden of proof of
THE PHILIPPINES, proving all the elements. 12 cralaw However, the most important
Respondent.
among all the elements is the element of unlawful aggression.
Unlawful aggression must be proved first in order for self-
G.R. No. 180452 : defense to be successfully pleaded, whether complete or
January 10, 2011
incomplete. As this Court said in People v. Catbagan, 13 "There cralaw

PEOPLE OF THE
can be no self-defense, whether complete or incomplete, unless
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-
the victim had committed unlawful aggression against the
Appellee, v. Ng Yik Bun,
person who resorted to self-defense."
Kwok Wai Cheng, Chang
chanroblesvirtualawlibrary

Chaun Shi, Chua Shilou

In this case, we agree with the trial court that the accused-
Hwan, Kan Shun Min,
appellant failed to prove the existence of unlawful aggression.
and RaymOnd S. Tan,
But he maintains that Estose provoked him when the latter
Accused-Appellants.
started to unsheathe his bolo from his scabbard. Nevertheless,
as aptly found by the trial court, his testimony is too incredible
G.R. No. 171379 :
to be believed, viz: chanrob1esvirtwallawlibrary

January 10, 2011 JOSE

MARQUES and MAXILITE Accused's plea failed to impress the Court. To be
TECHNOLOGIES, INC., sure, his story on how the deceased was killed is too
Petitioners, v. FAR EAST incredible to inspire belief. According to him, it was
BANK AND TRUST the deceased who first unsheathed his bolo but did
COMPANY, FAR EAST not succeed in his attempt to fully unsheathe it
BANK INSURANCE because he (Accused) hacked him. Thereafter, the
BROKERS, INC., and deceased tried to wrest Accused's bolo but was
MAKATI INSURANCE injured instead. If the deceased failed to unsheathe
COMPANY, Respondents. his bolo because Accused was able to hack him, how
G.R. No. 171419 : could the deceased then have attempted to
January 10, 2011 FAR dispossess the Accused of the latter's bolo? The
EAST BANK AND TRUST truth, of course, is that the Accused waylaid the
COMPANY and MAKATI deceased, as testified to by the prosecution
INSURANCE COMPANY,
witnesses. 14 x x x
cralaw

Petitioners, v. JOSE
MARQUES and MAXILITE Unlawful aggression is an actual physical assault, or at least a
TECHNOLOGIES, INC., threat to inflict real imminent injury, upon a person. 15 In case cralaw

Respondents.
of threat, it must be offensive and strong, positively showing

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 6 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

the wrongful intent to cause injury. 16 It "presupposes actual, cralaw

G.R. No. 181930 :

sudden, unexpected or imminent danger - not merely
January 10, 2011
threatening and intimidating action." 17 It is present "only when
MILAGROS SALTING,
cralaw

Petitioner, v. JOHN VELEZ the one attacked faces real and immediate threat to one's

and CLARISSA R. VELEZ, life." 18 Such is absent in the instant case.

cralaw

Respondents.
Moreover, against the positive declarations of the prosecution
witnesses who testified that accused-appellant hacked Estose
A.M. No. RTJ-09-2188
twice and subsequently stabbed him without any provocation,
(Formerly A.M. OCA-IPI
accused-appellant's self-serving and uncorroborated assertion
No. 08-2995-RTJ) :
deserves scant consideration.
January 10, 2011
PROSECUTOR HILARIO Indeed, it is a well-settled rule that "a plea of self-defense
RONSON H. TILAN, cannot be justifiably entertained where it is not only
Complainant, v. JUDGE uncorroborated by any separate competent evidence but is also
ESTER PISCOSO-FLOR,
extremely doubtful in itself." 19 cralaw Moreover, "[a]bsent any
RTC, BRANCH 34,
showing that the prosecution witnesses were moved by
BANAUE, IFUGAO,
improper motive to testify against the appellant, their
Respondent.
testimonies are entitled to full faith and credit." 20 cralawredlaw

G.R. No. 184954 :

Therefore, absent any unlawful aggression from the victim,
January 10, 2011
accused-appellant cannot successfully invoke the defense of
PEOPLE OF THE
self-defense.
PHILIPPINES, Appellee,
v. JAY LORENA y LABAG,
Treachery is evident
Appellant.
In addition, accused-appellant argues that the trial court should

G.R. No. 190122 : not have appreciated treachery as a qualifying circumstance. He

January 10, 2011 argues that it was impossible for the two prosecution witnesses

SPOUSES ISAGANI and to see the inception and the actual attack of accused-appellant

DIOSDADA CASTRO, to the victim because both were busy gathering coconuts. Also,

Petitioners, v. SPOUSES they were 50 meters away from where the actual stabbing

REGINO SE and VIOLETA occurred, in rolling hills with tall and short shrubs between the

DELA CRUZ, SPOUSES witnesses and the place where the actual stabbing occurred.

EDUARDO and CHARITO

We disagree.
PEREZ and MARCELINO
TOLENTINO, Paragraph 16 of Article 14 of the Revised Penal Code (RPC)
Respondents. defines treachery as the direct employment of means, methods,
or forms in the execution of the crime against persons which

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 7 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

G.R. No. 188314 : tend directly and specially to insure its execution, without risk
January 10, 2011 to the offender arising from the defense which the offended
PEOPLE OF THE party might make. In order for treachery to be properly
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff- appreciated, two elements must be present: (1) at the time of
Appellee, v. KHADDAFY the attack, the victim was not in a position to defend himself;
JANJALANI, GAMAL B. and (2) the accused consciously and deliberately adopted the
BAHARAN a.k.a. Tapay, particular means, methods or forms of attack employed by
ANGELO TRINIDAD a.k.a. him. 21 cralaw The "essence of treachery is the sudden and
Abu Khalil, GAPPAL
unexpected attack by an aggressor on the unsuspecting victim,
BANNAH ASALI a.k.a.
depriving the latter of any chance to defend himself and
Maidan or Negro, JAINAL
thereby ensuring its commission without risk of himself." 22
SALI a.k.a. Abu
cralawredlaw

Solaiman, ROHMAT
In the case at bar, it was clearly shown that Estose was
ABDURROHIM a.k.a. deprived of any means to ward off the sudden and unexpected
Jackie or Zaky, and other attack by accused-appellant. The evidence showed that
JOHN and JANE DOES, accused-appellant hid behind a coconut tree and when Estose
Accused, GAMAL B. passed by the tree, completely unaware of any danger,
BAHARAN a.k.a. Tapay, accused-appellant immediately hacked him with a bolo. Estose
ANGELO TRINIDAD a.k.a. could only attempt to parry the blows with his bare hands and
Abu Khalil, and ROHMAT
as a result, he got wounded. Furthermore, when Estose tried to
ABDURROHIM a.k.a. Abu
retreat, stumbling in the process, accused-appellant even took
Jackie or Zaky, Accused- advantage of this and stabbed him resulting in his death.
Appellants. Evidently, the means employed by accused-appellant assured
himself of no risk at all arising from the defense which the
G.R. No. 178895 : deceased might make. What is decisive is that the attack was
January 10, 2011 executed in a manner that the victim was rendered defenseless
REPUBLIC OF THE
and unable to retaliate. 23 Without a doubt, treachery attended
cralaw

PHILIPPINES,
the killing.
represented by the
DEPARTMENT OF Thus, this Court finds no reason to disturb the findings of the
AGRARIAN REFORM, trial court when it gave credence to the testimony of the
through the HON. prosecution witnesses. It is well-entrenched in our
SECRETARY NASSER C. jurisprudence "x x x that the assessment of the credibility of
PANGANDAMAN, witnesses and their testimonies is a matter best undertaken by
Petitioner, v. SALVADOR the trial court because of its unique opportunity to observe the
N. LOPEZ AGRI- witnesses first hand and note their demeanor, conduct and
BUSINESS CORP.,
attitude under grilling examination." 24 This rule is even more
cralaw

represented by
SALVADOR N. LOPEZ, binding and conclusive when affirmed by the appellate court. 25 cralawredlaw

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 8 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

JR., President and In conclusion, all the elements of the crime of murder, as
General Manager, defined in paragraph 1 of Art. 248 of the RPC, were successfully
Respondent. G.R. No. proved: (1) that a person was killed; (2) that the accused killed
179071 : January 10, that person; (3) that the killing was attended by treachery; and
2011 SALVADOR N. (4) that the killing is not infanticide or parricide. 26 cralawredlaw

LOPEZ AGRI-BUSINESS
CORP., represented by Verily, in criminal cases such as the one on hand, the
SALVADOR N. LOPEZ, prosecution is not required to show the guilt of the accused with
JR., President and absolute certainty. Only moral certainty is demanded, or that
General Manager, degree of proof which, to an unprejudiced mind, produces
Petitioner, v. conviction. 27 We find that the prosecution has discharged its
cralaw

DEPARTMENT OF burden of proving the guilt of accused-appellant for the crime of

AGRARIAN REFORM,
murder with moral certainty.
through the Honorable
Secretary, Respondent. Award of Damages

This Court has held in People v. Beltran, Jr. that "[w]hen death
G.R. No. 179446 :
occurs due to a crime, the following damages may be awarded:
January 10, 2011
(1) civil indemnity ex delicto for the death of the victim; (2)
LOADMASTERS
actual or compensatory damages; (3) moral damages; (4)
CUSTOMS SERVICES,
exemplary damages; and (5) temperate damages." 28
INC., Petitioner, v.
cralawredlaw

GLODEL BROKERAGE
Hence, in line with our ruling in People v. Sanchez, 29 when
CORPORATION AND R&B
cralaw

the imposable penalty for the crime is reclusion perpetua, the

INSURANCE
damages to be imposed are: PhP 50, 000 as civil indemnity, PhP
CORPORATION,
50, 000 as moral damages, and PhP 30, 000 as exemplary
Respondents.
damages. These are the amounts proper in this case because of
the appreciation of the mitigating circumstance of voluntary
G.R. No. 182547 :
surrender without any aggravating circumstance to offset it.
January 10, 2011 CHINA
BANKING As to the award of temperate damages in the amount of PhP
CORPORATION, 25, 000, such is proper "in homicide or murder cases when no
Petitioner, v. ARMI S. evidence of burial and funeral expenses is presented in the trial
ABEL, Respondent.
court." 30 cralaw Under Art. 2224 of the Civil Code, temperate

damages may be recovered as it cannot be denied that the

G.R. No. 168646 :
heirs of the victims suffered pecuniary loss although the exact
January 12, 2011 LUZON
DEVELOPMENT BANK, amount was not proved. 31 Therefore, we sustain the award of
cralaw

Petitioner, v. ANGELES the trial court of PhP 25, 000 for temperate damages.
CATHERINE ENRIQUEZ,
Finally, interest at the rate of six (6) percent should likewise be

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 9 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Respondent. G.R. No. added to the damages awarded. 32 cralawredlaw

168666 : January 12,

2011 DELTA WHEREFORE , the appeal is DENIED. The CA Decision in CA-
DEVELOPMENT and G.R. CR-H.C. No. 00575-MIN finding accused-appellant Rogelio
MANAGEMENT Dolorido y Estrada guilty of the crime charged is AFFIRMED
SERVICES, INC., with MODIFICATION. In addition to the sum of PhP 50, 000 as
Petitioner, v. ANGELES civil indemnity, PhP 50, 000 as moral damages, and PhP 25,
CATHERINE ENRIQUEZ 000 as temperate damages, accused-appellant is likewise
and LUZON sentenced to pay the heirs of the victim the amount of PhP 30,
DEVELOPMENT BANK, 000 as exemplary damages. Interest at the rate of six percent
Respondents. (6%) per annum on the civil indemnity and moral, temperate,
and exemplary damages from the finality of this decision until
G.R. No. 167291 : fully paid shall likewise be paid by accused-appellant to the
January 12, 2011 heirs of Daniel Estose.
PRINCE TRANSPORT,
SO ORDERED.
INC. and MR. RENATO
CLAROS, Petitioners, v. PRESBITERO J. VELASCO, JR.
DIOSDADO GARCIA, Associate Justice
LUISITO GARCIA,
WE CONCUR:
RODANTE ROMERO, REX
BARTOLOME, FELICIANO CORONA, C.J., Chairperson, LEONARDO-DE CASTRO, DEL
GASCO, JR., DANILO CASTILLO, and PEREZ, JJ.
ROJO, EDGAR
SANFUEGO, AMADO
GALANTO, EUTIQUIO
Endnotes:
LUGTU, JOEL
cralaw

GRAMATICA, MIEL
1 Rollo , pp. 3-18. Penned by Associate Justice
CERVANTES, TERESITA
cralaw

CABANES, ROE DELA Rodrigo F. Lim, Jr. and concurred in by Associate

CRUZ, RICHELO Justices Ruben C. Ayson and Leoncia R. Dimagiba.

BALIDOY, VILMA 2 CA rollo, pp. 33-40. Penned by Judge Ermelindo

PORRAS, MIGUELITO
cralaw

G. Andal.
SALCEDO, CRISTINA
GARCIA, MARIO 3 Records, p. 3.
cralaw

NAZARENO, DINDO
TORRES, ESMAEL 4 TSN, February 22, 2007, p. 5.
cralaw

RAMBOYONG, ROBETO*
MANO, ROGELIO 5 Records, p. 39.
cralaw

BAGAWISAN, ARIEL

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 10 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

SNACHEZ, ESTAQULO 6 Id.

cralaw

VILLAREAL, NELSON
MONTERO, GLORIA 7 Id. at 15.
cralaw

ORANTE, HARRY TOCA,

PABLITO MACASAET and 8 Id.
cralaw

RONALD GARCITA,
9 CA rollo, p. 40.
Respondents. cralaw

10 Rollo , p. 18.
G.R. No. 172508 : cralaw

January 12, 2011 HEIRS

11 People v. Silvano , G.R. No. 125923, January 31,
OF SANTIAGO C. cralaw

DIVINAGRACIA, 2001, 350 SCRA 650, 657; People v. Plazo, G.R. No.
Petitioner, v. HON. J. 120547, January 29, 2001, 350 SCRA 433, 442-443.
CEDRICK O. RUIZ,
12 People v. Almazan , G.R. Nos. 138943-44,
Presiding Judge, Branch
cralaw

39, Regional Trial Court, September 17, 2001, 365 SCRA 373, 382.

Iloilo City; GERRY D.

13 G.R. Nos. 149430-32, February 23, 2004, 423
SUMACULUB, as Clerk of
cralaw

Court of the Regional SCRA 535, 540.

Trial Court; BOMBO

14 CA rollo, p. 39.
RADYO HOLDINGS, INC.,
cralaw

and ROGELIO M. 15 People v. Basadre , G.R. No. 131851, February

cralaw

FLORETE, SR.,
22, 2001, 352 SCRA 573, 583.
Respondents

16 People v. Catbagan , supra note 13, at 557.

cralaw

G.R. No. 178296 :

January 12, 2011 THE 17 People v. Escarlos , G.R. No. 148912, September
cralaw

HERITAGE HOTEL
10, 2003, 410 SCRA 463, 478.
MANILA, acting through
its owner, GRAND PLAZA 18 Id. cralaw

HOTEL CORPORATION,
Petitioner, v. NATIONAL 19 People v. Aburque , G.R. No. 181085, October
cralaw

UNION OF WORKERS IN
23, 2009, 604 SCRA 384, 394; citing Del Rosario v.
THE HOTEL,
People, G.R. No. 141749, April 17, 2001, 356 SCRA
RESTAURANT AND
627, 634.
ALLIED INDUSTRIES-
HERITAGE HOTEL 20 People v. Aburque , id.
cralaw

MANILA SUPERVISORS
21 People v. Reyes , G.R. No. 118649, March 9,
CHAPTER (NUWHRAIN- cralaw

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 11 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

HHMSC), Respondent. 1998, 287 SCRA 229, 238.

22 People v. Escote, Jr. , G.R. No. 140756, April 4,

G.R. No. 179419 : cralaw

January 12, 2011 2003, 400 SCRA 603, 632-633.

DURBAN APARTMENTS
23 People v. Honor , G.R. No. 175945, April 7,
CORPORATION, doing
cralaw

business under the name 2009, 584 SCRA 546, 558.

and style of City Garden

24 People v. Bantiling , G.R. No. 136017, November
Hotel, Petitioner, v.
cralaw

PIONEER INSURANCE 15, 2001, 369 SCRA 47, 60. See also People v.

AND SURETY Godoy, G.R. Nos. 115908-09, December 6, 1995,

CORPORATION, 250 SCRA 676.

Respondent. 25 Vidar v. People , G.R. No. 177361, February 1,

cralaw

2010, 611 SCRA 216, 230.

G.R. NO. 189806 :
January 12, 2011 26 People v. Sameniano , G.R. No. 183703, January
cralaw

PEOPLE OF THE
20, 2009, 576 SCRA 840, 850.
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-
Appellee, v. FRANCISCO 27 Rules of Court, Rule 133, Sec. 2.
cralaw

MANLANGIT y
TRESBALLES, Accused- 28 cralaw G.R. No. 168051, September 27, 2006, 503
Appellant.
SCRA 715, 740.

G.R. No. 191721 : 29 cralaw G.R. No. 131116, August 27, 1999, 313 SCRA
January 12, 2011
254, 271-272.
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff- 30 cralaw People v. Dacillo , G.R. No. 149368, April 14,
Appellee, v. ROGELIO 2004, 427 SCRA 528, 538.
DOLORIDO y ESTRADA,
Accused-Appellant. 31 People v. Surongon , G.R. No. 173478, July 12,
cralaw

2007, 527 SCRA 577, 588.

G.R. No. 175330 :
32 See People v. Tabongbanua, G.R. No. 171271,
January 12, 2010 cralaw

PEOPLE OF THE August 31, 2006, 500 SCRA 727.

PHILIPPINES, Appellee,
v. RODOLFO CAPITLE
and ARTURO NAGARES,
Appellants.

Back to Home | Back to Main

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 12 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

G.R. No. 175891 :

January 12, 2011
REPUBLIC OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Petitioner,
v. RESINS,
INCORPORATED,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 176019 :

January 12, 2011 BPI
FAMILY SAVINGS BANK,
INC., Petitioner, v.
GOLDEN POWER DIESEL
SALES CENTER, INC. and
RENATO C. TAN,
Respondents.

A.M. No. P-09-2696

[Formerly A.M. OCA IPI
No. 08-2956-P] :
January 12, 2011
FREDDY H. REYES,
Complainant, v. VIVIAN
L. PABILANE, COURT
INTERPRETER,
MUNICIPAL TRIAL
COURT, TAGKAWAYAN,
QUEZON, Respondent.

G.R. No. 190640 :

January 12, 2011
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Appellee,
v. LUIS PAJARIN y DELA
CRUZ and EFREN
PALLAYA y TUVIERA,
Appellants.

A.M. No. P-06-2179

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 13 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

(Formerly A.M. No. 06-5-

169-MCTC) : January 12,
2011 OFFICE OF THE
COURT ADMINISTRATOR,
Complainant, v.
MERLINDA T. CUACHON,
Clerk of Court, and FE P.
ALEJANO, Court
Stenographer, both of
the MCTC, Ilog-Candoni,
Negros Occidental,
Respondents.

A.C. No. 8620 :

January 12, 2011 JESSIE
R. DE LEON,
Complainant, v. ATTY.
EDUARDO G. CASTELO,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 190521 :

January 12, 2011
LETICIA TAN, MYRNA
MEDINA, MARILOU
SPOONER, ROSALINDA
TAN, and MARY JANE
TAN, MARY LYN TAN,
CELEDONIO TAN, JR.,
MARY JOY TAN, and
MARK ALLAN TAN,
represented herein by
their mother, LETICIA
TAN, Petitioners, v. OMC
CARRIERS, INC. and
BONIFACIO ARAMBALA,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 148076 :

January 12, 2011

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 14 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

ANTONIO M.
CARANDANG, Petitioner,
v. HONORABLE ANIANO
A. DESIERTO, OFFICE OF
THE OMBUDSMAN,
Respondent. G.R. No.
153161 : January 12,
2011 ANTONIO M.
CARANDANG, Petitioner,
v. SANDIGANBAYAN
(FIFTH DIVISION),
Respondent.

G.R. No. 172378:

January 17, 2011
SILICON PHILIPPINES,
INC., (Formerly INTEL
PHILIPPINES
MANUFACTURING, INC.),
Petitioner, v.
COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 185163 :

January 17, 2011
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-
Appellee, v. CARLO
MAGNO AURE y
ARNALDO and MELCHOR
AUSTRIACO y AGUILA,
Accused-Appellants.

G.R. No. 176389 :

January 18, 2011
ANTONIO LEJANO,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE OF
THE PHILIPPINES,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 15 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Respondent. G.R. No.

176864 : January 18,
2011 PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Appellee,
v. HUBERT JEFFREY P.
WEBB, ANTONIO
LEJANO, MICHAEL A.
GATCHALIAN, HOSPICIO
FERNANDEZ, MIGUEL
RODRIGUEZ, PETER
ESTRADA and GERARDO
BIONG, Appellants.

CONCURRING
OPINION : SERENO, J. :
G.R. No. 176389 :
January 18, 2011
ANTONIO LEJANO,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE OF
THE PHILIPPINES,
Respondent. G.R. No.
176864 : January 18,
2011 PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Appellee,
v. HUBERT JEFFREY P.
WEBB, ANTONIO
LEJANO, MICHAEL A.
GATCHALIAN, HOSPICIO
FERNANDEZ, MIGUEL
RODRIGUEZ, PETER
ESTRADA and GERARDO
BIONG, Appellants.

A.M. No. P-10-2788 :

January 18, 2011 OFFICE
OF THE COURT
ADMINISTRATOR,
Complainant, v. CLAUDIO
M. LOPEZ, Process

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 16 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Server, Municipal Trial

Court, Sudipen, La
Union, Respondent.

A.M. No. RTJ-09-

2198*: January 18, 2011
OFFICE OF THE COURT
ADMINISTRATOR,
Complainant, v. FORMER
JUDGE LEONARDO L.
LEONIDA, OF THE
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
BRANCH 27, STA. CRUZ,
LAGUNA, Respondent.

G.R. No. 180388 :

January 18, 2011
GREGORIO R. VIGILAR,
SECRETARY OF THE
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
WORKS AND HIGHWAYS
(DPWH), DPWH
UNDERSECRETARIES
TEODORO E.
ENCARNACION AND
EDMUNDO E.
ENCARNACION AND
EDMUNDO V. MIR, DPWH
ASSISTANT SECRETARY
JOEL L. ALTEA, DPWH
REGIONAL DIRECTOR
VICENTE B. LOPEZ,
DPWH DISTRICT
ENGINEER ANGELITO M.
TWAÑO, FELIX A.
DESIERTO OF THE
TECHNICAL WORKING
GROUP VALIDATION AND
AUDITING TEAM, AND

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 17 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

LEONARDO ALVARO,
ROMEO N. SUPAN,
VICTORINO C. SANTOS
OF THE DPWH
PAMPANGA 2ND
ENGINEERING DISTRICT,
Petitioners, v. ARNULFO
D. AQUINO ,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 182591 :

January 18, 2011
MODESTO AGYAO, JR.,
Petitioner, v. CIVIL
SERVICE COMMISSION,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 165423:

January 19, 2011 NILO
PADRE, Petitioner, v.
FRUCTOSA BADILLO,
FEDILA BADILLO,
PRESENTACION
CABALLES, EDWINA
VICARIO (d) represented
by MARY JOY VICARIO-
ORBETA and NELSON
BADILLO, Respondents.

G.R. No. 168757:

January 19, 2011
RENATO REAL, Petitioner,
v. SANGU PHILIPPINES,
INC. and/ or KIICHI ABE,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 172577 :

January 19, 2011
SOLEDAD DALTON,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 18 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Petitioner, v. FGR REALTY

AND DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION, FELIX
NG, NENITA NG, and
FLORA R. DAYRIT or
FLORA REGNER,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 173085 :

January 19, 2011
PHILIPPINE VETERANS
BANK, Petitioner, v.
BASES CONVERSION
DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY, LAND BANK
OF THE PHILIPPINES ,
ARMANDO SIMBILLO,
CHRISTIAN MARCELO,
ROLANDO DAVID,
RICARDO BUCUD, PABLO
SANTOS, AGRIFINA
ENRIQUEZ, CONRADO
ESPELETA, CATGERUBE
CASTRO, CARLITO
MERCADO and ALFREDO
SUAREZ, Respondent.

G.R. No. 178044 :

January 19, 2011 ALAIN
M. DIÑO, Petitioner, v.
MA. CARIDAD L. DIÑO,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 177937 :

January 19, 2011
ROBINSONS
GALLERIA/ROBINSONS
SUPERMARKET
CORPORATION and/or

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 19 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

JESS MANUEL,
Petitioners, v. IRENE R.
RANCHEZ, Respondent.

G.R. No. 187725 :

January 19, 2011
BENJAMIN JESALVA,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE OF
THE PHILIPPINES,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 187917 :

January 19, 2011
METROPOLITAN BANK &
TRUST COMPANY,
Petitioner, v. SPOUSES
EDMUNDO MIRANDA and
JULIE MIRANDA,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 176264 :

January 10, 2011
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, APPELLEE,
VS. TERESITA "TESSIE"
LAOGO, APPELLANT.

A.M. OCA IPI No. 08-

127-CA-J : January 11,
2011 RE: LETTER-
COMPLAINT OF ATTY.
ARIEL SAMSON C.
CAYETUNA, ET AL., ALL
EMPLOYEES OF
ASSOCIATE JUSTICE
MICHAEL P. ELBINIAS
AGAINST ASSOCIATE
JUSTICE MICHAEL P.
ELBINIAS, CA -

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 20 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

MINDANAO STATION

G.R. No. 176264 :

January 10, 2011
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, APPELLEE,
VS. TERESITA "TESSIE"
LAOGO, APPELLANT.

A.M. OCA IPI No. 08-

127-CA-J : January 11,
2011 RE: LETTER-
COMPLAINT OF ATTY.
ARIEL SAMSON C.
CAYETUNA, ET AL., ALL
EMPLOYEES OF
ASSOCIATE JUSTICE
MICHAEL P. ELBINIAS
AGAINST ASSOCIATE
JUSTICE MICHAEL P.
ELBINIAS, CA -
MINDANAO STATION

A.M. No. 08-4-253-RTC

: January 12, 2011 IN
RE: REPORT ON THE
JUDICIAL AUDIT
CONDUCTED IN THE
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT,
BRANCH 45, URDANETA
CITY, PANGASINAN, AND
REPORT ON THE
INCIDENT AT BRANCH
49, SAME COURT.

G.R. No. 178741 :

January 17, 2011
ROSALINO L. MARABLE,
PETITIONER, VS. MYRNA

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 21 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

F. MARABLE,
RESPONDENT.

A.M. No. RTJ-10-2255

(Formerly OCA IPI No.
10-3335-RTJ) : January
17, 2011 SPOUSES
DEMOCRITO AND OLIVIA
LAGO, COMPLAINANTS,
UDGE GODOFREDO B.
ABUL, JR., REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH
43, GINGOOG CITY,
RESPONDENT.

G. R. No. 177790 :
January 17, 2011
REPUBLIC OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
PETITIONER, VS.
CARLOS R. VEGA,
MARCOS R. VEGA,
ROGELIO R. VEGA,
LUBIN R. VEGA, HEIRS
OF GLORIA R. VEGA,
NAMELY: FRACISCO L.
YAP, MA. WINONA Y.
RODRIGUEZ, MA.
WENDELYN V. YAP AND
FRANCISCO V. YAP, JR.,
RESPONDENTS, ROMEA
G. BUHAY-OCAMPO,
FRANCISCO G. BUHAY,
ARCELI G. BUHAY-
RODRIGUEZ, ORLANDO
G. BUHAY, SOLEDAD G.
BUHAY-VASQUEZ, LOIDA
G. BUHAY-SENADOSA,
FLORENDO G. BUHAY,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 22 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

OSCAR G. BUHAY, ERLYN

BUHAY-GINORGA,
EVELYN BUHAY-
GRANETA, AND EMILIE
BUHAY-DALLAS,
RESPONDENTS-
INTERVENORS.

G.R. No. 191459 :

January 17, 2011
BERNADETH LONDONIO
AND JOAN CORCORO,
PETITIONERS, VS. BIO
RESEARCH, INC. AND
WILSON Y. ANG,
RESPONDENTS.

[A.M. No. RTJ-09-2173

(Formerly A.M. OCA IPI
No. 09-3084-RTJ) :
January 18, 2011]
OFFICE OF THE COURT
ADMINISTRATOR,
Complainant, v. JUDGE
BENJAMIN P. ESTRADA,
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT,
BRANCH 9, MALAYBALAY
CITY, BUKIDNON, AND
JUDGE JOSEFINA
GENTILES-BACAL, RTC,
BRANCH 10,
MALAYBALAY CITY,
BUKIDNON,
Respondents.

[A.M. No. P-03-1730

(Formerly OCA IPI No.
02-1469-P) : January 18,
2011] JUDGE PHILBERT

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 23 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

I. ITURRALDE, MARTIN
GUMARANG, VIC
JUMALON, LEONARDO
LUCAS, WILFREDO
DEUS, CORAZON
AZARRAGA AND ALICE
BUENAFE, Complainants,
v. OIC BRANCH CLERK
OF COURT BABE SJ.
RAMIREZ, CLERK
VIOLETA P. FLORDELIZA
AND SHERIFF IV CARLOS
A. SALVADOR,
Respondents.

[A.M. No. RTJ-07-

2062* : January 18,
2011] IMELDA R.
MARCOS, Complainant,
v. JUDGE FERNANDO VIL
PAMINTUAN,
Respondent.

[A.M. No. RTJ-09-

2198* : January 18,
2011] OFFICE OF THE
COURT ADMINISTRATOR,
Complainant, v. FORMER
JUDGE LEONARDO L.
LEONIDA, OF THE
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
BRANCH 27, STA. CRUZ,
LAGUNA, Respondent

[A.M. No. P-11-2887

(Formerly A.M. No. 09-2-
32-MTCRe: Report on the
Financial Audit
Conducted on the Books

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 24 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

of Accounts of the
Municipal Trial Court,
Pantabangan, Nueva
Ecija) : January 18,
2011] OFFICE OF THE
COURT ADMINISTRATOR,
Complainant, v.
MARISSA U.
ANGELES,CLERK OF
COURT II, MUNICIPAL
TRIAL COURT,
PANTABANGAN, NUEVA
ECIJA, Respondent [A.M.
NO. P-10-2880
(FORMERLY OCA IPI NO.
08-2782-P) : January 18,
2011] JUDGE ANALIE C.
ALDEA-AROCENA,
Complainant, v.
MARISSA U. ANGELES,
CLERK OF COURT II,
MUNICIPAL TRIAL
COURT, PANTABANGAN
NUEVA ECIJA,
Respondent.

[A.M. No. 07-6-14-CA

: January 18, 2011] RE:
ANONYMOUS LETTER
RELATIVE TO THE
ALLEGED CORRUPTION
IN THE COURT OF
APPEALS, CAGAYAN DE
ORO CITY

[A.M. No. P-10-2799 :

January 18, 2011]
OFFICE OF THE COURT
ADMINISTRATOR,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 25 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Complainant, v.
VICTORIO A. DION,
FORMER CLERK OF
COURT, MUNICIPAL
CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT,
SAN FABIAN-SAN
JACINTO, PANGASINAN,
Respondents

[G. R. No. 175352 :

January 18, 2011]
DANTE V. LIBAN,
REYNALDO M.
BERNARDO AND
SALVADOR M. VIARI,
Petitioners, v. RICHARD
J. GORDON, Respondent.
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL
RED CROSS, Intervenor

[G. R. No. 175352 :

January 18, 2011] :
CONCURRING OPINION -
ABAD, J.: DANTE V.
LIBAN, REYNALDO M.
BERNARDO AND
SALVADOR M. VIARI,
Petitioners, v. RICHARD
J. GORDON, Respondent.
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL
RED CROSS, Intervenor.

[G. R. No. 175352 :

January 18, 2011] :
DISSENTING OPINION -
CARPIO, J.: DANTE V.
LIBAN, REYNALDO M.
BERNARDO AND
SALVADOR M. VIARI,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 26 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

Petitioners, v. RICHARD
J. GORDON, Respondent.
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL
RED CROSS, Intervenor.

[G.R. No. 179617 :

January 19, 2011]
COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL REVENUE,
Petitioner, v. ASIAN
TRANSMISSION
CORPORATION,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 187917 :

January 19, 2011]
METROPOLITAN BANK &
TRUST COMPANY,
Petitioner, v. SPOUSES
EDMUNDO MIRANDA
AND JULIE MIRANDA,
Respondents.

[G.R. No. 187725 :

January 19, 2011]
BENJAMIN JESALVA,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE OF
THE PHILIPPINES,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 173085 :

January 19, 2011]
PHILIPPINE VETERANS
BANK, Petitioner, v.
BASES CONVERSION
DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY, LAND BANK
OF THE PHILIPPINES,
ARMANDO SIMBILLO,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 27 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

CHRISTIAN MARCELO,
ROLANDO DAVID,
RICARDO BUCUD, PABLO
SANTOS, AGRIFINA
ENRIQUEZ, CONRADO
ESPELETA, CATGERUBE
CASTRO, CARLITO
MERCADO AND ALFREDO
SUAREZ, Respondents.

[A.M. No. MTJ-09-1734

[FORMERLY OCA I.P.I.
NO. 07-1933-MTJ] :
January 19, 2011]
FLORENDA V. TOBIAS,
Complainant, v. JUDGE
MANUEL Q. LIMSIACO,
JR., PRESIDING JUDGE,
MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT
TRIAL COURT,
VALLADOLID-SAN
ENRIQUE-PULUPANDAN,
NEGROS OCCIDENTAL,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 165423 :

January 19, 2011] NILO
PADRE, Petitioner, v.
FRUCTOSA BADILLO,
FEDILA BADILLO,
PRESENTACION
CABALLES, EDWINA
VICARIO (D)
REPRESENTED BY MARY
JOY VICARIO-ORBETA
AND NELSON BADILLO,
Respondents.

[G.R. No. 154462 :

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 28 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

January 19, 2011]

SPOUSES RUBEN AND
MYRNA LEYNES,
Petitioners, v. FORMER
TENTH DIVISION OF THE
COURT OF APPEALS,
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT,
BRANCH 21, BANSALAN,
DAVAO DEL SUR,
MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH
1, BANSALAN, DAVAO
DEL SUR, AND SPOUSES
GUALBERTO & RENE
CABAHUG-SUPERALES,
Respondents.

[A.M. No. RTJ-11-2267

(Formerly A.M. OCA IPI
No. 03-1788-RTJ) :
January 19, 2011]
MANSUETA T. RUBIN,
Complainant, v. JUDGE
JOSE Y. AGUIRRE, JR.,
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT,
BRANCH 55,
HIMAMAYLAN, NEGROS
OCCIDENTAL,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 185715 :

January 19, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Appellee,
v. ERLINDA CAPUNO Y
TISON, Appellant.

[G.R. No. 177570 :

January 19, 2011]

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 29 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-
Appellee, v. NELIDA
DEQUINA Y DIMAPANAN,
JOSELITO JUNDOC Y
JAPITANA & NORA
JINGABO Y CRUZ,
Accused-Appellants.

[G.R. No. 183843 :

January 19, 2011]
GOLDEN ARCHES
DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION,
Petitioner, v. ST.
FRANCIS SQUARE
HOLDINGS, INC.,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 180909 :

January 19, 2011]
EXXONMOBIL
PETROLEUM AND
CHEMICAL HOLDINGS,
INC. - PHILIPPINE
BRANCH, Petitioner, v.
COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 178039 :

January 19, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-
Appellee, v. ERNESTO
UYBOCO Y RAMOS,
Defendant-Appellant.

[G.R. No. 184063 :

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 30 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

January 24, 2011]

CYNTHIA E. YAMBAO,
Petitioner, v. REPUBLIC
OF THE PHILIPPINES
AND PATRICIO E.
YAMBAO, Respondents.

[G.R. No. 176438 :

January 24, 2011]
PHILIPPINE DEPOSIT
INSURANCE
CORPORATION (PDIC),
Petitioner, v. PHILIPPINE
COUNTRYSIDE RURAL
BANK, INC., RURAL
BANK OF CARMEN
(CEBU), INC., BANK OF
EAST ASIA
(MINGLANILLA, CEBU)
INC., AND PILIPINO
RURAL BANK (CEBU),
INC., Respondents.

[G.R. No. 160923 :

January 24, 2011]
MOISES TINIO, JR. AND
FRANCIS TINIO,
Petitioners, v. NATIONAL
POWER CORPORATION,
Respondent. [G.R. NO.
161093 : January 24,
2011] NATIONAL POWER
CORPORATION,
Petitioner, v. MOISES
TINIO, JR. AND FRANCIS
TINIO, Respondent.

[G.R. No. 169942 :

January 24, 2011]

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 31 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

BARANGAY DASMARIÑAS
THRU BARANGAY
CAPTAIN MA.
ENCARNACION R.
LEGASPI, Petitioner,
v.CREATIVE PLAY
CORNER SCHOOL, DR.
AMADO J. PIAMONTE,
REGINA PIAMONTE
TAMBUNTING, CELINE
CONCEPCION LEBRON
AND CECILE CUNA
COLINA, Respondents.

[G.R. No. 172804 :

January 24, 2011]
GONZALO VILLANUEVA,
REPRESENTED BY HIS
HEIRS, Petitioner, v.
SPOUSES FROILAN AND
LEONILA BRANOCO,
Respondents.

[G.R. No. 192280 :

January 25, 2011]
SERGIO G. AMORA, JR.,
PETITIONER, VS.
COMMISSION ON
ELECTIONS AND
ARNIELO S. OLANDRIA,
RESPONDENTS.

[A.M. No. P-07-2364 :

January 25, 2011]
REPORT ON THE
FINANCIAL AUDIT
CONDUCTED ON THE
BOOKS OF ACCOUNT OF
SONIA L. DY AND ATTY.

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 32 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

GRACIANO D. CUANICO,
JR., REGIONAL TRIAL
COURT, CATARMAN,
NORTHERN SAMAR. A.M.
NO. P-11-2902
(FORMERLY OCA I.P.I.
NO. 08-2790-P)
VIRGILIO O. GALLANO,
COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY.
GRACIANO D. CUANICO,
JR., CLERK OF COURT,
AND SONIA L. DY,
SOCIAL WELFARE
OFFICER II, BOTH FROM
THE OFFICE OF THE
CLERK OF COURT,
REGIONAL TRIAL
COURT,CATARMAN,
NORTHERN SAMAR,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 167622 :

January 25, 2011]
GREGORIO V. TONGKO,
PETITIONER, VS. THE
MANUFACTURERS LIFE
INSURANCE CO.
(PHILS.), INC. AND
RENATO A. VERGEL DE
DIOS, RESPONDENTS.

[A.M. No. P-90-488 :

January 25, 2011]
OFFICE OF THE COURT
ADMINISTRATOR
COMPLAINANT, VS. JOSE
M. RAMANO, DEPUTY
SHERIFF, REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 33 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

140, MAKATI CITY,

RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 191198 :

January 26, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-
APPELLEE, VS. NENE
QUIAMANLON Y MALOG,
ACCUSED-APPELLANT.

[G.R. No. 187320 :

January 26, 2011]
ATLANTA INDUSTRIES,
INC. AND/OR ROBERT
CHAN, PETITIONERS, VS.
APRILITO R. SEBOLINO,
KHIM V. COSTALES,
ALVIN V. ALMOITE, AND
JOSEPH S. SAGUN,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 186528 :

January 26, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-
APPELLEE, VS. HEMIANO
DE JESUS AND RODELO
MORALES, ACCUSED-
APPELLANTS.

[G.R. No. 184202 :

January 26, 2011]
AQUINAS SCHOOL,
PETITIONER, VS.
CARPIO, J.,
CHAIRPERSON,
NACHURA, PERALTA,
ABAD, AND MENDOZA,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 34 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

JJ. SPS. JOSE INTON

AND MA. VICTORIA S.
INTON, ON THEIR
BEHALF AND ON BEHALF
OF THEIR MINOR CHILD,
JOSE LUIS S. INTON,
AND SR. MARGARITA
YAMYAMIN, OP,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 181833 :

January 26, 2011]
INTERNATIONAL
FREEPORT TRADERS,
INC., PETITIONER, VS.
DANZAS
INTERCONTINENTAL,
INC., RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 181146 :

January 26, 2011] THE
UNIVERSITY OF THE
IMMACULATE
CONCEPTION AND MO.
MARIA ASSUMPTA
DAVID, RVM,
PETITIONERS, VS.
NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS
COMMISSION AND
TEODORA AXALAN,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 192237 :

January 26, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-
APPELLEE, VS.
JACQUILINE PAMBID Y

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 35 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

CORTEZ, ACCUSED-
APPELLANT.

[G.R. No. 179428 :

January 26, 2011]
PRIMO E. CAONG, JR.,
ALEXANDER J.
TRESQUIO, AND
LORIANO D. DALUYON,
PETITIONERS, VS.
AVELINO REGUALOS,
RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 159471 :

January 26, 2011] ATLAS
CONSOLIDATED MINING
AND DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION,
PETITIONER, VS.
COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL REVENUE,
RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 167459 :

January 26, 2011] JOSE
REYNALDO B. OCHOSA,
PETITIONER, VS. BONA
J. ALANO AND REPUBLIC
OF THE PHILIPPINES,
RESPONDENTS.

[A.M. No. P-09-2627 :

January 26, 2011] REINA
EDENLYNE GARCIA,
COMPLAINANT, VS.
ROBERT V. ALEJO,
SHERIFF IV, REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH
142, MAKATI CITY

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 36 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

RESPONDENT.

[A.M. No. P-10-2817

[Formerly OCA I.P.I.
No.09-3089-P] : January
26, 2011] CORAZON
TENORIO, REPRESENTED
BY IMELDA TENORIO-
ORTIZ, COMPLAINANT,
VS. ALYN C. PERLAS,
SHERIFF
III,RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 185166 :

January 26, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-
APPELLEE, VS. MARK
LESTER DELA ROSA Y
SUELLO, ACCUSED-
APPELLANT.

[G.R. No. 177685 :

January 26, 2011] HEIRS
OF RAMON C. GAITE,
CYNTHIA GOROSTIZA
GAITE AND RHOGEN
BUILDERS,
PETITIONERS, VS. THE
PLAZA, INC. AND FGU
INSURANCE
CORPORATION,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 176819 :

January 26, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, Petitioner,
v. ROBERT P. BALAO,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 37 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

JOSEPHINE C. ANGSICO,
VIRGILIO V. DACALOS,
AND SANDIGANBAYAN,
FIRST DIVISION,
Respondents.

[G.R. No. 174725 :

January 26, 2011]
ALEXANDER B. GATUS,
Petitioner, v. SOCIAL
SECURITY SYSTEM,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 172224 :

January 26, 2011]
OFFICE OF THE
OMBUDSMAN, Petitioner,
v. COURT OF APPEALS
AND DINAH C. BARRIGA,
Respondents.

IN RE: IN THE MATTER

OF THE PETITION TO
APPROVE THE WILL OF
RUPERTA PALAGANAS
WITH PRAYER FOR THE
APPOINTMENT OF
SPECIAL
ADMINISTRATOR,
MANUEL MIGUEL
PALAGANAS AND
BENJAMIN GREGORIO
PALAGANAS, Petitioners,
v. ERNESTO PALAGANAS,
Respondent.

[G.R. No. 184091 :

January 31, 2011]
EDWARD GARRICK

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 38 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

VILLENA AND PERCIVAL

DOROJA, Petitioners, v.
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, NOMAR B.
DEGERON, CHRISTIAN
DANDAN, AND
ELIZABETH BORCELIS,
Respondents.

[G.R. No. 182301 :

January 31, 2011] JAIME
ALFEREZ, Petitioner, v.
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES AND
PINGPING CO,
Respondents.

[G.R. No. 188847 :

January 31, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-
APPELLEE, VS. RUFINO
VICENTE, JR. Y CRUZ,
ACCUSED-APPELLANT.

[G.R. No. 175404 :

January 31, 2011]
CARGILL PHILIPPINES,
INC., PETITIONER, VS.
SAN FERNANDO REGALA
TRADING, INC.,
RESPONDENT.

[G.R. Nos. 187912-14

: January 31, 2011]
JOEY P. MARQUEZ,
PETITIONER, VS. THE
SANDIGANBAYAN 5TH
DIVISION AND THE

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 39 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

OFFICE OF THE SPECIAL

PROSECUTOR,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 176287 :

January 31, 2011]
HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT
SERVICES, INC. -
MEDICAL CENTER
MANILA, PETITIONER,
VS. HOSPITAL
MANAGEMENT
SERVICES, INC. -
MEDICAL CENTER
MANILA EMPLOYEES
ASSOCIATION-AFW AND
EDNA R. DE CASTRO,
RESPONDENTS.

[A.M. No. RTJ-11-2270

[FORMERLY A.M. NO.
OCA IPI NO. 10-3380-
RTJ] : January 31, 2011]
ELADIO D. PERFECTO,
COMPLAINANT, VS.
JUDGE ALMA CONSUELO
DESALES-ESIDERA,
PRESIDING JUDGE,
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT,
BRANCH 20, CATARMAN,
NORTHERN SAMAR,
RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 185685 :

January 31, 2011]
OFFICE OF THE
OMBUDSMAN,
PETITIONER, VS. NIETO
A. RACHO,

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 40 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 191889 :

January 31, 2011] SPS.
IRENEO T. FERNANDO
(SUBSTITUTED BY THEIR
HEIRS, RONALDO M.
FERNANDO, CONCORDIA
FERNANDO-JAYME,
ESMERALDA M.
FERNANDO, ANTONETTE
M. FERNANDO-
REGONDOLA,
FERDINAND M.
FERNANDO, AND JEAN
MARIE FERNANDO-
CANSANAY), AND
MONSERRAT MAGSALIN
FERNANDO,
PETITIONERS, VS.
MARCELINO T.
FERNANDO,
RESPONDENT. MATIAS I.
FERNANDO AND PANFILO
M. FERNANDO,[1] IN
THEIR CAPACITY AS
ADMINISTRATORS [OF
THE ESTATE] OF THE
LATE JULIANA T.
FERNANDO,
RESPONDENTS-
INTERVENORS.

[G.R. No. 175473 :

January 31, 2011]
HILARIO P. SORIANO,
PETITIONER, VS. HON.
MARIA THERESA V.
MENDOZA-ARCEGA, AS

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 41 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

PRESIDING JUDGE OF
BRANCH 17, REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT, MALOLOS,
BULACAN; AND THE
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 181039 :

January 31, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, APPELLEE,
VS. SEVILLANO DELOS
REYES Y LANTICAN,
APPELLANT.

[G.R. No. 185535 :

January 31, 2011]
MANILA INTERNATIONAL
AIRPORT AUTHORITY,
PETITIONER, VS.
REYNALDO
(REYMUNDO[1]) AVILA,
CALIXTO AGUIRRE, AND
SPS. ROLANDO AND
ANGELITA QUILANG,
RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 180013 :

January 31, 2011] DEL
MONTE PHILIPPINES
INC. EMPLOYEES
AGRARIAN REFORM
BENEFICIARIES
COOPERATIVE
(DEARBC), PETITIONER,
VS. JESUS SANGUNAY
AND SONNY LABUNOS,
RESPONDENTS.

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 42 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

[G.R. No. 179961 :

January 31, 2011]
KEPCO PHILIPPINES
CORPORATION,
PETITIONER, VS.
COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL REVENUE,
RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 192898 :

January 31, 2011]
SPOUSES ALEXANDER
TRINIDAD AND CECILIA
TRINIDAD,
PETITIONERS, VS.
VICTOR ANG,
RESPONDENT.

[G.R. No. 168501 :

January 31, 2011]
ISLRIZ TRADING/
VICTOR HUGO LU,
PETITIONER, VS. EFREN
CAPADA, LAURO LICUP,
NORBERTO NIGOS,
RONNIE ABEL,
GODOFREDO MAGNAYE,
ARNEL SIBERRE,
EDMUNDO CAPADA,
NOMERLITO MAGNAYE
AND ALBERTO DELA
VEGA, RESPONDENTS.

[G.R. No. 186120 :

January 31, 2011]
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-
APPELLEE, VS.

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 43 of 44
G.R. No. 191721 : January 12, 2011 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plai…ed-Appellant. : January 2011 - Philipppine Supreme Court Decisions 12/22/20, 3:20 PM

EVANGELINE SOBANGEE
Y EDAÑO, ACCUSED-
APPELLANT.

[G.R. No. 190889 :

January 10, 2011]
ELENITA C. FAJARDO,
PETITIONER, VS. PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES,
RESPONDENT.

[A.M. No. RTJ-09-2189

(Formerly A.M. OCA IPI
No. 08-2837-RTJ) :
January 18, 2011]
VICTORIANO
SY,COMPLAINANT, VS.
JUDGE OSCAR E.
DINOPOL, REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT, BRANCH
24, KORONADAL CITY,
RESPONDENT. D E C I S I
ON

Copyright © 1995 - 2020 REDiaz

https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2011januarydecisions.php?id=21 Page 44 of 44