0% found this document useful (0 votes)
37 views

04 Rake Example of Cause Effect Diagram PDF

The document analyzes factors that contribute to a rake's inability to effectively clear debris. It finds that the rake has blunt and numerous tines with wide spacing, a large total tine area, and low flexibility, which prevents it from gathering debris and adhering to soil. Additionally, the debris being cleared is deep and adhered to plants, while wind conditions are unfavorable, further hindering the rake's performance.

Uploaded by

Ebtehal Tamer
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
37 views

04 Rake Example of Cause Effect Diagram PDF

The document analyzes factors that contribute to a rake's inability to effectively clear debris. It finds that the rake has blunt and numerous tines with wide spacing, a large total tine area, and low flexibility, which prevents it from gathering debris and adhering to soil. Additionally, the debris being cleared is deep and adhered to plants, while wind conditions are unfavorable, further hindering the rake's performance.

Uploaded by

Ebtehal Tamer
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

Causal Analysis of Tine sharpness

is Blunt
Number of Tines
is High

Rake “leakage” .01 sq inches 14 Tines

Tine Spacing is Tine Spacing is Total Tine Area


Wide Narrow is High

A tines

1 inch .5 inch .14 sq inches

Range of Motion Soil Adhesive Debris depth is


Area of Amount of Debris Path of Wind is
is Low Forces are High deep
Positioning is in Bush or Tree Poor
Poor is High

5 inches 0.5 inches 0.5 inches


. . .

F=kx

Flexibility of Flexibility of Downward Force


Debris Exists Soil
Tines is Stiff Tines is Flexible Person is Low Tines
Plants A different function of
Air / Handle
rakes is in removing
Holds
Pushes Pushes embedded debris
Position
Positions

Debris
Tines Soil
Debris
Debris 2000 lb/inch 2 lb/inch 10 lbs Average
.

P=F/A

Ground Yield Extraction Debris Holding


Strength is High Pressure is Low Force is High
Amount of Debris Debris Size is Debris Flow Area Tine Height is Tine Height is Amount of Debris Amount of Debris Amount of Debris Unevenness of Tines
is High Small is High High Low being Pushed by being Pushed by is High Ground is High
the Rake is High
A different function of
the Rake is Low
Arrange rakes is arranging soil
and earth

Earth
200 psi 71 psi 15 psi
. . 3 sq in 2.5 inches 1 inch . . . .

Movement of
Earth and Rocks
is Difficult
Tines / Rake Do Tines / Rake Tines Soil
Tines
not Exist (no Exist (Are Tines Tines Tines
longer required) Required)
The smaller debris
tends to slip through Constrains
The debris is pushed Collects
into the depressions Position
Constrains the tines. Collects Extract
by the act of raking
Debris Debris 0 movement
Debris
Debris Debris Debris
. .

Flow = f( flow area, debris size, debris amount)

Amount of Debris Conformity to Debris Extraction


Leakage Over Number of Piles
??? in Depressions is Ground is Poor is Poor
Top is High is High
High

Collects

Debris
. . 10 % of possible
Every Few Inches
10 % per pull

Debris Texture Debris Exists Debris Color


Different than Different than Ground
Landscape Landscape
The debris is
captured in the
Constrains uneven surface of the
ground and goes
under the tines
Debris
. . .
Leakage
Through is High
L through ~ 100 A ( W tines – D debris)

10 % per pull Leakage Under


Debris
is High

Displeases

Beholder

10 % per pull

Beholder is
Displeased

. L total = L through + L under

Debris Leakage
is High

20 % per pull

Extra Effort is
High

20 % Extra Work

You might also like