Previewpdf
Previewpdf
Systems for
High-Voltage Applications
POWER ENGINEERING
Series Editor
H. Lee Willis
ABB Inc.
Raleigh, North Carolina
Vladimir Gurevich
Israel Electric Corp.
Haifa, Israel
M A R C E L
ISBN: 0-8247-4056-4
Headquarters
Marcel Dekker, Inc.
270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016
tel: 212-696-9000; fax: 212-685-4540
The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more infor-
mation, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above.
Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any
means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or
by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the
publisher.
Power engineering is the oldest and most traditional of the various areas within
electrical engineering, yet no other facet of modern technology is currently
undergoing a more dramatic revolution in both technology and industry
structure. Certainly protection engineering, one of the fundamental areas of
power engineering, is no exception. While the goals of protection engineering -
public and employee safety, equipment protection, and power supply reliability -
have never changed, both the needs for and methods to achieve power system
protection have changed dramatically in the last decades and will continue to
evolve as electrical appliances and digital equipment become ever smarter,
faster, and more integrated into the fundamental infrastructures of our society.
Protection Devices and Systems for High-Voltage Applications presents
several interested new switching technologies - reed switch contacts, hybrid
reed-transistors and hybrid reed-thyristors - that have heretofore received little
comprehensive coverage in references and textbooks. Vladimir Gurevich's focus
is on the switching technologies and the devices themselves. His book
comprehensively reviews these new devices, the concepts behind their operation,
their design, and their construction and usage. As is often the case with high-
speed, high-power switching devices, these switching devices have applications
in both RF and power protection equipment. The author highlights both the
similarities and the differences in these two application areas and shows how
these new technologies are applied to each. Industrial and power equipment
engineers will find the book interesting and thought-provoking, whether these
devices are directly applicable to their areas of engineering, or merely of interest
from a professional and technical development standpoint.
Like all the volumes in the Series, Protection Devices puts modern
technology in a context of practical application; useful as a reference book as
well as for self-study and advanced classroom use. The series includes books
iii
iv Series Introduction
covering the entire field of power engineering, in all its specialties and
subgenres, all aimed at providing practicing power engineers with the knowledge
and techniques they need to meet the electric industry's challenges in the 21st
century.
H. Lee Willis
Preface
v
vi Preface
The described devices and systems were first mentioned in the author's
previous book: "High-Voltage Devices with Reed Switch" - 2000 (in Russian).
This previous book contains further information about the author's work in the
field. For the readers' convenience, Appendix A lists some other author
publications in English, which are available internationally and a list of libraries
and institutions that have this book.
All the described devices and systems were constructed by the author and
successfully tested. Some of them have been successfully used in different
power installations. Moreover, in some cases the devices were put to use in
industry beyond their intended scope. For example, some RG-series relays were
used for transmission of discrete control commands from ground potential to
electronic modules, with high voltage applied to them. Another example: high-
voltage HVTS-5 switching devices were used for generation of strong high-
voltage pulses in a special transformer bench-test.
The author will be pleased to reply to the readers' questions and will
appreciate any constructive criticism. Send your comments to:
vii
viii Contents
Index 291
Acronyms
xi
xii Acronyms
High voltage (HV) equipment (10-100 kV) has become very popular over the
last few years. It is utilized in military and civil radar stations, powerful signal
transmitters for communication, broadcasting and TV systems, technological
lasers, X-ray devices, powerful electronic and ion devices, devices for inductive
heating and melting of metals, technological electron accelerators for materials
irradiation, electro-physical and medical equipment, and industrial microwave
ovens, among others.
Despite considerable success in each of these fields, the problem of current
overload protection (level current trip) of such devices, caused by HV circuit insu-
lation breakdowns or breakdowns in the high voltage devices, still remains acute.
The first is related to unfavorable conditions that cause moisture and dust penetra-
tion into the equipment, and the second to unpredictable internal breakdowns in
high voltage vacuum electronic elements (klystrons, tetrodes, etc.) or semiconduc-
tor elements (HV rectifier).
Current overload protection in such devices is usually resolved by inclusion
of current sensors and electronic relays into the low voltage (LV) or grounded
circuits. However, such protection is not necessarily efficient and implies some
problems:
1. Complicated devices include more than one HV circuit, often having dif-
ferent potential relative to ground, as well as different internal resistance
and operational currents. This produces difficulties in adjustment of the
1
2 Chapter 1
sensor connected to the common ground circuit and is not appropriate for
equal protection efficiency of all these circuits.
4. Internal high voltage power supplies (PS) have a powerful filter with re-
active elements used for leveling the high voltage rectifier pulsations. If
such power supplies are disconnected from the low voltage power supply
net (220, 380, 440 V), the reactive filter elements will still replenish the
arc in the breakdown point up to their complete discharge. On the other
hand, a "crowbar" connecting to the HV source at the high voltage side,
rather than disconnection at the LV side, will cause a heavy overload of
the high voltage rectifier and the feeding transformer elements. In this
way, their risk of failure will drastically increase.
This generates a need for selective tuning-out of the emergency current sen-
sor, which considerably lowers protection efficiency.
istics of the galvanic decoupling unit. For example, according to the decoupling
voltage level:
opto-electronic,
pneumatic,
radio-frequency,
electrohydraulic,
transformer,
ultrasonic,
electromagnetic, and with mechanical transmission.
According to speed:
Although such classification may seem arbitrary, it fully reflects the most
important properties of interface relays that have a decisive effect on the functions
performed by them.
The simplest interface relays of the opto-electronic type typically consists of
a light-emitting element (LED) built into the semiconductor structure (power SCR,
triac) or LED and matching low power photothyristor or phototransistor in switch-
ing mode, mounted close together and optically coupled within a light-excluding
package having a galvanic decoupling voltage up to 4 kV.
Some companies (EAC Electronics, Aleph, Crydom, Magnecraft) are pro-
ducing high voltage reed relays for commutation voltage up to 10 - 12 kV DC, and
therefore, have a galvanic decoupling voltage on the same level. All these relays
are intended for use only in DC circuits under normal climatic conditions and have
no reserves for withstanding voltage.
In order to significantly increase the galvanic decoupling level of interface
relays of the opto-electronic type, a fiber optic cable of appropriate length is
installed between the LED and photo-receiving elements. These relays are also
equipped with an electronic pulse shaper and an electronic amplifier. At a length
of about 1 to 3 meters of fiber optic cable connecting the transmitting and re-
ceiving units, the galvanic decoupling voltage ensured by the interface relay can
reach 40 kV and more.
Problems of Overload and Spark Protection 5
2 3
4 5
6 8
All this indicates that the preferred use of an opto-electronic galvanic de-
coupling unit in interface relays is not always warranted, and it sometimes is
merely the consequence of stereotypical thinking of developers or a peculiar tech-
nical style.
In 1985, the Brown Bowery Co. started a special program for development
of the "Sigma-Switch" interface relays. The development and introduction of
essentially new interface relays were contemplated together with the usual opto-
electronic system, especially with a galvanic decoupling unit of the
electromagnetic type. However, we should mention that BBC does not have
priority in the creation of interface relays that function on this principle. As early
as 1977, such relay interfaces (based on the reed switch), were proposed by the
author of this book. By the time the "Sigma-Switch" program was published, there
had been already a number of varieties protected by dozens of certificates of
authorship (in ex-USSR). These instruments greatly surpassed proto-types of the
BBC and other companies in terms of their parameters. Analysis of the
characteristics of the new type reed switch-based HV interface relays developed
by author ("Relay of Gurevich" or "RG-relay"), as well as experience in creating
and using them, shows that they have a definite area of use within which they
enjoy distinct advantages over other types of interface relays. These parameters
include transmission of discrete control commands, protection and binary warning
transfered by a frequency up to 50 - 100 Hz and an admissible speed 0.8 - 1.5
msec, between parts of equipment under a potential difference to 100 kV. Within
these values of the parameters, the RG-interfaces are characterized by the highest
degree of simplicity and reliability and possess broad functional capabilities.
Particularly attractive are such RG-relay properties as a large overload capacity of
the control circuit and a large power output circuit, insensibility to pulse noise,
mechanical strength of the design, preservation of serviceability over a wide range
of temperatures, pressure and humidity. The relatively low cost of RG-relays is
also of no small importance in a number of cases. These properties of RG-relays
are responsible for their widespread use for industrial and military applications in
on-board, mobile and stationary powerful radio-electronic equipment, in relay
protection and automation systems of electrical networks of the 6 - 24 class, in
electro-physical installation, in power converter technology, etc.
2
High-Voltage Interface RG-series
Relays
RG interface relays are a new type of high-voltage device designed for automation
systems for overload protection, fault indicating, interlocking of HV equipment as
well as for transfer of control signals from ground potential to HV potential (re-
verse connection).
Figure 2.1 High voltage interface RG series relays for industrial and military
applications.
9
10 Chapter 2
Dia. 28
2 1
5
4
47
7
Epoxy Encapsulant
Epoxy Encapsulant
6
1
5
3
70
4
2
15 27
50
56
Figure 2.3 RG-25 series design for power lasers, industrial microwave ovens,
medium power radar.
The RG-75 (and RG-50) relay (Fig. 2.5) is comprised of the main insulator 1
formed as a dielectric glass, whose cylindrical part is extended beyond flange 2.
3
Epoxy Encapsulant
5
17
Silicon
66
4
1
2
Dia. 13
The flat external surface of bottom 3 of this glass smoothly mates with the
extended cylindrical part 4 having threaded internal 5 and external 6 surfaces.
The relay also includes control coil 7 with a II-shaped ferro-magnetic core 8 lo-
cated inside the main insulator and reed switch 9 located in an element for reed
switch rotation through 90° 10. This element 10 is formed as an additional
thin-walled dielectric glass with walls grading into the bottom and mating with the
HV RG-series Relays 13
inner surface of cylindrical part 4. These mated surfaces are coated with conduct-
ing material 11. Reed switch outputs 9 are conveyed through additional insulator
12 formed as a tube extending beyond reed rotation element body 10. The lower
end of this tube is graded into oval plate 13 covering the reed formed with the
conducting external coating. Control coil 7 outputs are also conveyed through
tube-shaped insulator 14 extending beyond the main insulator. The reed switch
position fixation element is formed as disk 15 with a threaded side surface and a
central hole with insulator 12 conveyed through it External attachment of the de-
vice is effected with dielectric nut 16. Lower layer 17 of epoxy compound filling
the main insulator to the control winding performs conduction by the addition of
copper powder (60-70% of the volume). The rest of the filling compound 18 has
been made dielectric. Element space 10 is filled with the same dielectric epoxy
compound.
The shape of the main insulator and the reed switch rotation element are
chosen so that their mating surfaces, which contact with the conducting coating,
do not form sharp edges emerging on the main insulator surface and, at the same
time, provide for safe shunting of the air layer between them and removing the
thin conducting sharp-edged layer from the design.
Significantly reducing the field intensity generated by the sharp outputs of
the reed switch is achieved by adding one more tube-shaped insulator extending
beyond the main insulator used to convey the reed switch outputs and executing
the inner end of this tube as a plate with conducting coatings covering the reed
switch.
Applying the lower layer of epoxy compound, which fills the main insulator
conducting space (holding the control coil with a ferromagnetic core), thus reduces
the intensity of the field generated by the winding outputs and neutralizes the ac-
tion of the air bubbles remaining between the coil windings.
Implementing the reed fixation element as a simple threaded disk, which is
threaded into the respective part of the main insulator, forces the reed rotation
element. Use is made of an additional dielectric nut threaded on the appropriate
part of the main insulator as an element of the relay external attachment assembly,
and the main insulator flange is used as a stop for this attachment assembly.
Device operation is based on the action of the magnetic field of the control
coil (penetrating through bottom 3 of high voltage insulator 1) to reed switch 9.
When the reed switch threshold magnetic flux value is attained, it becomes en-
gaged and appropriately switches the external circuits of the installation.
The reed switch engagement threshold value is adjusted by changing its po-
sition relative to the magnetic field source. This change is effected by rotation of
element 10 with reed switch 9 by an angle of 90° relative to the poles of -shaped
ferromagnetic core 8. The position of element 10 with the reed is fixed by forcing
element 10 as disk 15 is screwed in.
14 Chapter 2
14
.18
.1
.17
7
3
13
11 2
4 8
6
9
5
16
18
10 15
12