Hydrogen Embrittlement and Corrosion Fatigue of Corroded Bridge Wires - Nakamura, S., & Suzumura, K. (2009)
Hydrogen Embrittlement and Corrosion Fatigue of Corroded Bridge Wires - Nakamura, S., & Suzumura, K. (2009)
article info a b s t r a c t
Article history: Cables of old suspension bridges and stays of cable-stayed bridges often suffer from steel corrosion.
Received 11 October 2007 Corroded galvanized steel wires on different corrosion levels were produced at laboratories, and their
Accepted 25 March 2008 mechanical properties and remaining strength were investigated. Actual tensile strength of corroded
wires did not decrease with corrosion levels, whereas elongation decreased sharply after the zinc
Keywords: layer was partly depleted and the steel started to corrode. As the accumulated amounts of diffusive
Galvanized steel wires
hydrogen of corrosion level-2 wires – with and without added tension – were almost the same
Corrosion fatigue
Cables
and less than 0.2 ppm, the applied tension of steel wires did not affect the amount of diffusive
Suspension bridges hydrogen which was well below the critical concentration of 0.7 ppm to cause brittleness. This
Cable-stayed bridges indicates that hydrogen embrittlement is unlikely to occur. Fatigue tests showed that fatigue strength
did not change when only the galvanized layer was corroded, but it significantly decreased after
corrosion of the steel below the galvanized layer progressed. Fatigue strength further lowered when the
steel wire was cyclically stressed under wet environments when compared with the fatigue strength
under dry environments. The broken wires of an old suspension bridge were also investigated. The
fracture surface was similar to that caused by corrosion fatigue rather than hydrogen embrittlement.
It was estimated that the wires were fractured by the mixed effects of corrosion, cyclic stresses and
hydrogen.
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0143-974X/$ – see front matter © 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jcsr.2008.03.022
270 S. Nakamura, K. Suzumura / Journal of Constructional Steel Research 65 (2009) 269–277
2.1. Corroded specimens of about 100 g/m2 corresponds to the level-1 corrosion (zinc
corrosion), that of about 300 g/m2 to the level-2 corrosion (steel
Nakamura, Suzumura and Tarui investigated the remaining corrosion), and that of about 600 g/m2 to the level-3 corrosion
strength of corroded steel wires [5,6]. Some results are briefly (severe steel corrosion).
reviewed in Sections 2.1 and 2.2.
Suspension bridge cables are under severe corrosion environ- 2.2. Tensile strength and elongation
ments; wires are wet at high temperature. To simulate this envi-
ronment, galvanized steel wires are wrapped with wet gauze and Tension tests were performed with the corroded specimens [5].
kept in an enclosed box at a temperature of 40 ◦ C. Water and oxy- Tensile strength of the specimens, the breaking force divided
gen are needed to corrode steel, and the wet gauze supplies both. by the original cross sectional area, is shown in Fig. 2 with the
It was proved by the past study that this simulation test with wet mass loss that corresponds to the corrosion level. The tensile
gauze produced the steel wires corroded in an actual corrosion en- strength decreases with the mass loss due to corrosion both in
vironment of suspension bridge cables. The wire specimen is 5 mm the galvanized and bare steel specimens. Fig. 3 shows the actual
in diameter, its tensile strength is 1570 MPa and the attached zinc tensile strength, the breaking force divided by the reduced cross
mass is 350 g/m2 , which is equivalent to 50 µm in thickness. sectional area due to corrosion. The actual tensile strength does not
The specimens were taken out from the enclosed box after decrease with the corrosion level both for the galvanized and bare
90 days, 250 days and 360 days, producing the corroded wires steel specimens.
on different corrosion levels. Their appearances are shown in
On the other hand, elongation of the galvanized steel wire
Fig. 1. The galvanized steel wires after 90 days were covered with
specimens decreases sharply after the corrosion level-1 (the
white zinc corrosion substance (corrosion level-1), ferrous rust
reduced mass of about 100 g/m2 ) and that of the bare steel
occurred locally in the specimens after 250 days (corrosion level-
decreases linearly with the reduced mass due to corrosion, as
2), and ferrous rust spread widely in the specimens after 350 days
shown in Fig. 4. Elongation does not change when only the
(corrosion level-3).
galvanized layer is corroded (level-1 corrosion) but it decreases
The same simulation tests were carried out for bare steel wires.
when the steel part starts to corrode. Elongation corresponds to
The galvanized layer was removed by immersing galvanized steel
ductility. When the ductility of galvanized steel wires lowers,
wires in H2 SO4 to make the bare steel wire specimens. The bare
safety factor of the bridge itself is also jeopardized and should be
steel specimen is expected to clarify the effect of the galvanized
considered carefully. It is noted that each point in Figs. 2–4 is an
layer. The bare steel specimens after 180 days were covered with
average of several test data.
ferrous rust, and after 350 days were covered with severe ferrous
rust.
The corrosion substances on the specimen surface were 2.3. Hydrogen embrittlement of wires corroded under tension
removed by a cloth containing 10% H2 SO4 , and the mass loss
was obtained by subtracting the final mass from the initial mass. It is important to measure an amount of absorbed hydrogen
The mass loss due to corrosion increased exponentially with because occurrence of hydrogen embrittlement depends on the
the elapsed days both for the galvanized specimens and the amount of hydrogen. The absorbed hydrogen emits from the steel
bare specimens. For the galvanized specimens, the reduced mass wire when it is heated. The specimen is therefore placed in a tube.
S. Nakamura, K. Suzumura / Journal of Constructional Steel Research 65 (2009) 269–277 271
tension and that without tension are almost the same and less than
0.2 ppm. Summarizing Figs. 10 and 11, introduced tensions of steel
Fig. 9. Method to produce corroded wires with introduced tension. wires do not affect the amount of diffusive hydrogen which is well
below the critical concentration to cause brittleness.
Fig. 17. Appearance of broken parts of new and corrosion level -1 wires (wire diameter 5 mm) (Upper & Lower: before & after corrosion substance is removed).
274 S. Nakamura, K. Suzumura / Journal of Constructional Steel Research 65 (2009) 269–277
(a) Fatigue tests under dry condition. (b) Fatigue tests under wet condition.
Fig. 18. Appearance of broken parts of corrosion level -2 wires (wire diameter 5 mm) (Upper & Lower: before & after corrosion substance is removed).
(a) Fatigue tests under dry condition. (b) Fatigue tests under wet condition.
Fig. 19. Appearance of broken parts of corrosion level -3 wires (wire diameter 5 mm) (Upper & Lower: before & after corrosion substance is removed).
Fig. 20. SEM photo (a: crack initiation point, b: crack propagation area).
Fig. 21. SEM photo of level -2 corrosion (a: crack initiation point, b: crack propagation area).
are shown in Fig. 22. In all of these SEM photos, cracks initiate whole section, the rest of the wire section was suddenly broken.
from the corroded parts, the top part of the wire in these pho- This shows a typical fatigue fracture section.
The width L and depth d of the corroded parts of specimens
tos (point a). Then the cracks propagate downwards, where the are summarized in Table 1. For the level-2 specimens L is about
area is flat (area b). When the crack reached about one third of the 5 mm and d is about 0.1 mm. For the level-3 specimens L is about
S. Nakamura, K. Suzumura / Journal of Constructional Steel Research 65 (2009) 269–277 275
Fig. 22. SEM photo of corrosion level -3 (a: crack initiation point, b: crack propagation).
Fig. 23. Broken wire of an old suspension bridge main cable (A: crack initiation point, wire diameter 5 mm).
Table 1 the lower part followed. The top part is the inside of the curved
Size of pitting at broken sections specimen, which has a tensile residual stress. After the corrosion
Specimens Width Depth substance was removed from the fractured cross section, it was
L (mm) d (mm) photographed by a scanning electric microscope (SEM). Fig. 24
Corrosion level 2 3 0.12 shows the top part of the specimen. A locally corroded part is
Dry condition 6 0.32 observed at point A in Fig. 24, from where a crack initiates. Then the
3 0.10 crack gradually progresses from that point, and the black parallel
Corrosion level 2 4 0.10 lines can be seen in this photo. These lines resemble beech marks
Wet condition 5 0.20
5 0.17
in appearance, which usually associate with fatigue.
Fig. 25 shows the specimen that was purposely fractured
6 0.27
Corrosion level 3 6 0.33 by hydrogen embrittlement at a laboratory. The outer layer of
Dry condition 7 0.22 the specimen was circumferentially notched about 0.5 mm to
11 0.37 accelerate fracture. Hydrogen was charged into a galvanized steel
5 0.25 wire in the liquid of 3% NaCl and 0.3% NH4 SCN with an electric
Corrosion level 3 6 0.38 current of 0.04 mA/cm2 for 18 h. It was then statically tensioned
Wet condition 10 0.30
with 90% of the tensile strength. The specimen fractured after 4.5 h.
10 0.35
Fig. 25 shows a fractured section of the specimen that is very rough
and clearly different from the actually fractured surface of Fig. 24.
10 mm and d is over 0.3 mm. In general, the width and depth of the Mechanism of hydrogen absorption into the corroded steel is
corroded parts increase with the corrosion level. shown in Fig. 26. When the galvanized layer is consumed and the
steel layer starts to corrode, both anode and cathode reactions
4. Mechanism of broken wires take place. At the anode reaction steel becomes steel ion emitting
electrons. At the cathode reaction hydrogen ion in water receives
A broken wire cut from an old suspension bridge was these electrons and produces hydrogen. Then the hydrogen is
investigated [5]. The wire is about 200 mm long and 5.0 mm in absorbed in the corroded part of steel.
diameter. The wire was curved when it was released from the There are three possible mechanisms for broken bridge wires:
bridge. Wires were wound on a reel when they were manufactured hydrogen embrittlement, corrosion fatigue and stress corrosion
at a factory, and a reel was transported to the construction site. cracking. Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) is defined as the delayed
They were then unwound from the reel and installed between the failure of alloys by cracking when exposed to certain environments
towers and the anchorages by the air spinning method. They were in the presence of static tensile stress. This environment for high
naturally straightened when they were tensioned by dead and live strength steel is usually in sodium nitrate solutions and caustic
loads, producing residual stresses in the wires. NaOH solutions. Therefore, SCC is not considered to be the cause
Fig. 23 shows the fractured part of the broken wires. Ferrous of wire fracture.
rust is visible near the fractured part. It was estimated from Hydrogen embrittlement is defined by harmful effect of
observation that the top part of these photos was first broken and hydrogen penetration of steel. The hydrogen comes from the
276 S. Nakamura, K. Suzumura / Journal of Constructional Steel Research 65 (2009) 269–277
shown in (d). Therefore, fracture mechanism of bridge wires is estimated that the wires were fractured by the mixed effects of
a mixed phenomenon of corrosion, cyclic stress fluctuation and corrosion, cyclic stresses and hydrogen.
hydrogen.
Acknowledgments
5. Conclusion
The authors are grateful to Mr. Makoto Kitagawa and Mr.
Bridge cables in suspension bridges and cable-stayed bridges Kazuhiko Furuya (Honshu Shikoku Bridge Authority, Japan), Mr.
are under severe corrosion environments due to water and Sante Camo (Weidlinger Associates, USA), Prof. Alan Pense,
high temperature inside the cables. Mechanical properties and Prof. John Fisher and Dr. Eric Kaufman (ATLSS, Lehigh University,
remaining strength of corroded galvanized steel wires at dif- USA), and Mr. Toshimi Tarui (Nippon Steel Corporation, Japan) for
ferent corrosion levels were investigated. Corroded galvanized their useful advice on this research.
steel wires on different corrosion levels were produced at
References
laboratories.
Actual tensile strength of corroded wires did not decrease with [1] Betti R, Yanev B. Conditions of suspension bridge cables. In: Proc., The New
corrosion levels, whereas elongation strength decreased sharply York city cable study, Workshop on safety appraisal of suspension bridge main
after the zinc layer was partly depleted and the steel started cables. New Jersey: NCHRP; 1998. p. 1–13.
[2] Mayrbaurl R. Corrosion in suspension bridge cables. In: Proc., congress,
to corrode. The accumulated amounts of diffusive hydrogen of international association of bridge and structural engineers, Paper no. 199.
corrosion level-2 wires with and without induced tension were 2000.
almost the same with the amounts of less than 0.2 ppm that was [3] Stahl FL, Gagnon CP. Cable corrosion. New York: ASCE Press; 1996.
[4] Furuya K, Kitagawa M, Nakamura S, Suzumura K. Corrosion mechanism and
well below a critical value of 0.7 ppm. Therefore, induced tensions new protection methods of suspension bridge cables, structural engineering
of steel wires did not affect the amount of diffusive hydrogen and international. Journal of International Association of Bridge and Structural
below the critical concentration to cause brittleness. Engineers, Zurich, Switzerland 2000;10(3):189–93.
[5] Nakamura S, Suzumura K, Tarui T. Mechanical properties and remaining
Fatigue strength of corroded wires was obtained by cyclically strength of corroded bridge wires, structural engineering international. Journal
stressing them under dry and wet environments. It was found that of International Association of Bridge and Structural Engineers, Zurich,
fatigue strength did not change when only the galvanized layer was Switzerland 2004;14(3):50–4.
[6] Suzumura K, Nakamura S. Environmental factors affecting corrosion of
corroded, but it significantly decreased after the steel corrosion galvanized steel wires. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, ASCE 2004;
below the galvanized layer progressed. The fatigue strength under 16(1):1–7.
wet conditions was lower than that under dry conditions. [7] Tarui T, Maruyama N, Eguchi T, Konno S. Development of high strength
galvanized steel wires for bridge cables. In: IABSE conference on cable
The broken wire of an old suspension bridge was also
supported bridges. 2001.
investigated. The fracture surface was similar to that caused by [8] Uhlig HH, Revie RW. Corrosion and corrosion control. New York: John Wiley &
corrosion fatigue rather than by hydrogen embrittlement. It was Sons; 1963.