Risk Assessment & Disaster Management Plan: M/S. Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited
Risk Assessment & Disaster Management Plan: M/S. Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited
CHAPTER – 10:
Risk Assessment & Disaster Management Plan
10.1BACKGROUND
Identification analysis and assessment of hazards and risks provide vital information to the
risk management, that what should be the type & capacity of any on-site and off-site
emergency plan & what type of safety measures and maintenance is required. Risk and
consequence analysis has been carried out considering storage and handling of various
hazardous raw materials, intermediates and product as well as manufacturing process.
10.2 METHODOLOGY
Hazard Identification and Risk assessment is type of Quantitative risk assessment (QRA) is
mean of making a systematic analysis of the risks from hazardous activities, and forming a
rational evaluation of their significance, in order to provide input to a decision-making
process. The term ‘quantitative risk analysis’ is widely used, but strictly this refers to the
purely numerical analysis of risks without any evaluation of their significance. The study has
been conducted based on the premises of a traditional Quantitative Risk Assessment. The
key components of a QRA are explained below, and illustrated in Figure 10.1.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
FIGURE – 10.1
QRA METHODOLOGY
The purpose of Risk Assessment & HAZOP is to develop mitigation measures for
unacceptable generators of risk, as well as to reduce the overall level of risk to As Low as
Reasonably Practical.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
FIGURE – 10.2
ALARP PRINCIPLE
In order to help assess the viability of Risk Reduction Measures (RRM), the economic costs
of the measures can be compared with their risk benefits using Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA).
Sr. Name of the Material Type of Kind of Max. Storage Tank Dyke
No. Hazard Storage Quantity to Condition Dimensions Dimensions
be stored i.e. Temp., in (m)
(MT) Pressure
1 Fire and OH Tanks 156 Ambient As per PESO As per PESO
PETROLEUM [Class- A in bulk] Explosion
License License
2 Fire and OH Tanks 125 Ambient As per PESO As per PESO
PETROLEUM [Class- B & C] Explosion License
License
3 Fire and OH Tanks 60 Ambient As per PESO As per PESO
PETROLEUM [Class- B] Explosion License
License
4 Fire and UG Tanks 124.5 Ambient As per PESO As per PESO
PETROLEUM [Class- A in bulk
Explosion License
& otherwise then in bulk] License
5 STOREGE OF COMPRESSED Fire and OH Tanks 3 Vessels Ambient As per SMPV As per SMPV
GAS IN PRESSURE VESSEL – Explosion License License
Liquid N2
6 Fire and OH Yard Diff Types of Ambient As per SMPV As per SMPV
STOREGE OF COMPRESSED
Explosion License License
GAS IN CYLINDER Cylinders
7 Acid Storage Area Corrosive AG Yard Diff Types of Ambient - -
Containers
8 Hazardous & Flammable Fire and AG Yard Diff Types of Ambient - -
Chemicals
Explosion Containers
and Toxic
9 Fire and AG Yard Diff Types of Ambient - -
Recovered Solvent Storage
Yard Explosion Containers
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Table -10.2
Properties of Chemicals
SR. NAME OF HAZARD FLASH BP LEL % UEL SP.GR. VD SOLUBILITY NFPA HAZARDOUS TLV IDLH LC50 CARCINO ANTIDOTE
0 0
CHEMICAL POINT C % 20 C WITH H F R COMBUSTIO PPM PPM mg/m3 GENIC
0
C WATER at 20 N PRODUCT TWA CHARACT
0
C ERISTIC
1. Toluene F 4.0 111 1.1 7.1 0.87 3.2 Insoluble 2 3 0 Irritating 50 2000 400 ppm No Diazem –
CAS # 108-88-3 Vapour for 24Hr mg/Kg.(Intraveno
generated Rat us), Epinephina,
Efidrine
2. Sulfuric Acid C -- 340 -- -- 1.84 -- Water 3 0 2 Non 1 15 510 mg/m3 No Sodium Hydro
3
CAS # 7664-93-9 reactive combustible mg/m3 mg/m for 2H Rat Carbonate (4
Conc.), Milk, Li
Juice, Milk of
Megnesia
3. Hydrochloric Acid C/T NF 108 NF NF 1.12 - 1.267 Soluble 3 0 1 NA 5 ppm 50 ppm 3124 ppm No Sodium Hydro
HCL 1.19 for 1h rat Carbonate (4%
Conc.), Milk, Lim
Juice, Milk of
Megnesia
4. Nitric Acid C -- 121 -- -- 1.408 2.5 Soluble 3 0 0 - 4 67 ppm 260 Yes Sodium Hydro
CAS # 7697-37-2 (NO2)/4 mg/m3/30 Carbonate (4%
H. M Rat Conc.), Milk, Lim
Juice, Milk of
Megnesia
5. Ethylene F/T 13 83 6.2 15.9 1.253 3.4 0.87 %0 2 3 1 HCl, 10 50 ppm 1414 Yes N.A.
Dichloride (EDC) Phosgene
CAS #107-06-2
6. Xylene F 25 140 1.7 7.5 0.878 4.5 Insoluble 2 3 0 Fire will - - 4550 ppm 4 Yes Diazem – 1
CAS No.1330-20-7 produce hour(s) mg/Kg.(Intraven
irritating, ous), Epinephina
corrosive
and/or toxic
gases
7. Methanol F 11 64.5 6 36.5 0.793 1.11 Very soluble 1 3 0 Fire will 200 - 64000 Yes 10 mg diazepam
CAS No. 67-56-1 produce ppm/4h through
irritating, injection
10-5
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
corrosive
and/or toxic
gases
8. Hydrogen F -18 -252.8 4 76 - 0.07 0.17 mg 3 4 0 Heating may - - - No No specific
CAS No.1333-74-0 100 ml cause violent Antidote
combustion or
explosion
9. Liq. Ammonia T 11 -33.34 15 30 0.9 0.597 54 g/100 ml 3 1 0 Hock-sensitive 50 300 2000 No Wash with Lactic
CAS No.7664-41-7 compounds ppm/4-hr Acid, Apply
are formed soframycin
with mercury, Smelling Ethanol
silver and gold or Ether
oxides.
10. Dimethyl Formamide F 57.8 153 2.2 15.2 0.949 2.51 Easily soluble in 2 2 0 These 10 - 2800 mg/kg Yes Calcium
CAS No.68-12-2 cold water, hot products are Gluconate
water carbon oxides 10 ml
(CO, CO2), in 10% solution
nitrogen through injection
oxides (NO,
NO2)
11. Dichloromethane T -4 39.8 13 22 1.325 2.9 10-50 mg/ml 2 1 0 Dissociation 50 2300 14400 Yes Hydrocortisone
CAS No.75-09-2 products ppm/7H (200 mg at every
generated in a 4 hrs.) Aspirin
fire may be and if pneumonia
irritating or gives antibiotics
toxic
12. MIBK F 14 115.9 1.4 7.5 0.802 3.45 Insoluble 2 3 0 -- 50 ppm 300 ppm 8000 ppm Yes Not available
CAS # 108-10-1 for 4 hr
(Rat)
13. Sodium Hydroxide C -- 142 -- -- 2.12 -- Soluble 200 -- 2 -- -- No --
CAS No. 67-56-1
14. Sodium Nitrite T -- 120 -- -- 1.28 -- Miscible 102 -- 0.1 -- 88 mg/kg No --
CAS No. 67-56-1
15. Acetic anhydride Flammab 51 139.9 3.52 2.7 1.09 3.52 Not Soluble -- -- 10.3 5 ppm 200 ppm Yes Hydrocortisone
le/Toxic (200 mg at every
4 hrs.) Aspirin
and if pneumonia
gives antibiotics
16. Phosphoric Acid Toxic -- 108 -- -- 1.685 3.4 Easily 3 0 2 -- 3 -- 1530 No Sodium Hydro
soluble in (mg/m3 mg/kg Carbonate (4
hot water. ) [Rat]. Conc.), Milk, Lim
10-6
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Soluble in Juice, Milk
cold water. Megnesia
17. Tri Ethyl Amine F,T -8.3 89.7 1.2 8 0.73 3.48 Soluble 2 2 0 -- 10 1.2 8 NO --
18. Thionyl Chloride T -- 76 -- -- 1.638 4.1 Insoluble 3 0 0 -- 1 4.87 500 ppm NO Sodium Hydro
1Hr Rat Carbonate (4
Conc.), Milk, Lim
Juice, Milk
Megnesia
19. Butanol Flammabl 35 117.6 1.4 11.2 0.8100 2.55 Soluble 1 3 0 -- 1 -- 790 mg/kg, No 10 mg diazepam
e rat through
injection
20. Formaldehyde F/T 50 98 3 36.5 1.08 1.03 Soluble 1 3 0 -- 2 200 64000 ppm No --
4 hours
[Rat]
F = FIRE T = TOXIC
E = Explosive R = REACTIVE
BP = BOILING POINT LEL = LOWER EXPLOSIVE LIMIT
UEL = UPPER EXPLOSIVE LIMIT SP.GR = SPECIFIC GRAVITY
VD = VAPOUR DENSITY ER = EVAPORATION RATE
H = HEALTH HAZARD CLASS F = FIRE HAZARD CLASS
R = REACTIVE HAZARD BR = BURNING RATE
TLV = THRESHOLD LIMIT VALUE PPM = PARTS PER MILLION
STEL = SHORT TERM EXPOSURE LIMIT NFPA = NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION-USA
10-7
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
FIGURE –10.3
SITE PLAN
Tank Farm
Area
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
10.4 Facilities / System for process safety, Storage, transportation, fire fighting
system and emergency capabilities to be adopted.
1. Class A petroleum products will be received through road tanker and stored in storage
tank as per petroleum rules.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
2. Tank farm will be constructed as per explosive department requirement and separation
distance will be maintained.
3. Static earthing provision will be made for road tanker as well as storage tank.
4. Flame arrestor with breather valve will be provided on vent line.
5. Road tanker unloading procedure will be prepared and implemented.
6. Fire load calculation will be done and as per fire load Hydrant System will be provided as
per NFPA std. and Fire extinguishers will be provided as per fire load calculation.
7. Spark arrestor will be provided to all vehicles in side premises.
8. Flame proof type equipment and lighting will be provided.
9. Lightening arrestor will be provided on the top of chimney.
10. Trained and experience operator will be employed for tank farm area.
11. NFPA label (hazard identification) capacity and content will be displayed on storage tank.
12. Solvents will be transferred by pump and through drum dispensing in plant area and day
tank will be provided wherever required. Overflow line will be return to the storage tank or
Pump On-Off switch will be provided near day tank in plant.
13. Jumpers are be provided on solvent handling pipe line flanges.
14. Flexible SS hose will be used for road tanker unloading purpose and other temp.
Connection.
15. Tanker unloading activity will be proceeding through Unloading/loading of flammable /
hazardous chemical work permit.
Transportation
1. Class A petroleum products will be received through road tanker and stored in storage
tank as per petroleum Act & Rules.
2. Road tanker unloading procedure will be in place and will be implemented for safe
unloading of road tanker.
3. Static earthing provision will be made for tanker unloading.
4. Earthed Flexible Steel hose will be used for solvent unloading from the road tanker.
5. Fixed pipelines with pumps will be provided for solvent transfer up to Day tanks/reactors.
6. Mechanical seal type pumps will be installed.
When in contact with human tissues, most corrosive substances will produce chemical burns,
while certain other substances produce deep ulceration. Many corrosive substances have a
defeating action on the skin and may cause dermatitis.
Corrosive substances will be not allowed to come in contact with materials that may
react.
All the containers, pipes, apparatus, installations and structures used for the
manufacture, storage, transport or use of these substances will be protected by
suitable coatings, impervious to and unaffected by corrosives.
All containers or receptacles are clearly labeled to indicate their contents and should
bear the danger symbol for corrosives.
Personal protective devices will be used depending upon the nature of work viz.
o Corrosion-resistant and impervious suits, or hand-gloves, aprons etc.
o Respirator, gas mask or self contained breathing apparatus,
o Barrier cream when exposure is not severe.
First aid treatment facilities are provided and all concerned will be instructed to
follow safe practices such as
o Prolonged washing with water
o Removing contaminated clothing
o Seeking immediate medical help
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Fire Alarm
150 V AC operated fire alarm, with manual call points shall be provided in plant call points
location to start, activate alarm, siren shall be indicated in site plant provided in ECC, control
rooms and OHC. Zone indication is received at main gate. To identify problem area and
communicate to main gate security officer, coordinate with OHC / fire station, to organize
help to respective zones with ambulance and fire tender.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Fire hydrant Pump Details:-
Technical Details of
Electrical Pump Diesel pump Jockey pump
Hydrant Pumps
Mather & Platt pump
Make Kirloskar Kirloskar
Ltd
Capacity 75.83 L/S 273 M3/Hr 14.97 L/S
167 HP
Motor Power 110 KW 22 KW
(DG Rating)
Motor RPM 2900 1800 2900
Head 88 M 88 M 88 M
1. You are required to maintain fire control equipment in good working condition and
measures at your department / section.
2. You are required to regularly impart awareness to fire wardens on fire prevention,
protection & emergency preparedness.
3. You are required to inform the FPPC through Monthly Report for your department /
section highlighting the following:
a. Status on fire control measures
b. Operational status of Fire Extinguishers and other Fire Fighting Equipment
c. Operational status of Emergency Exits and Escape / Emergency Lighting
d. Operational condition of fire proof doors if applicable
Nearest fire station is DPMC which is away around 2.5 Km from the organization &
maximum five minute time required to reach at the site.
TABLE 10.3
Details of Fire fighting installation:
Mitigation Measures for OSH: It is proposed to formulate and implement a structure for
Occupational Safety and Health with following aims…
• To keep air-borne concentration of toxic and hazardous chemicals below PEL and TLV.
• Protect general health of workers likely to be exposed to such chemicals
• Providing training, guidelines, resources and facilities to concerned department for
occupational health hazards.
• It is proposed that this EMP be formulated on the guidelines issued by Bureau of Indian
Standards on OH&S Management Systems: IS 18001:2000 Occupational Health and Safety
Management Systems
• Proposed EMP will be incorporated in Standard Operating Procedure also.
The proposed EMP will also include measure to keep air-born concentration of toxic and
hazardous chemicals below its PEL and TLV, like…
– Leak Surveys
– Separate storage for toxic chemicals
– Exhaust Ventilation
– Proper illumination
– Close processes to avoid spills and exposures
– Atomization of process operations to hazards of manual handling of chemicals
– Supply of proper PPEs like Air mask, Berating canisters, SCBA sets, On-line breathing
apparatus at the places where there is possibility of presence of toxic chemicals
– Decontamination procedure for empty drums and carboys.
– Regular maintenance program for pumps, equipment, instruments handling toxic and
corrosive chemicals
– Training to persons handling toxic and corrosive chemicals
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
It is proposed that management will devise a plan to check and evaluate the exposure
specific health status evaluation of workers.
Workers will be checked for physical fitness with special reference to the possible health
hazards likely to be presented where he/she is being expected to work before being
employed for that purpose. Basic examinations like Liver Function tests, chest x ray,
Audiometry, Spirometry Vision testing (Far & Near vision, color vision and any other ocular
defect) ECG, etc. will be carried out. However, the parameters and frequency of such
examination will be decided in consultation with Factory Medical Officer and Industrial
Hygienists.
M/S. GLENMARK
ENVIRONMENTAL
M/S. GLENMARK
ENVIRONMENTAL
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
10.7 Risk Management
M/s. Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited will be managed the economical and social aspects
of risk. Improvement in scientific and factual basis for risk assessment is necessary for better
risk management decisions and public creditability of those decisions. However, M/s.
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited will do the QRA to be undertaken prior to risk
management decisions.
M/s. Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited will consider the Risk management strategies
including all the specific activities. First step involves taking a decision about the weather
any actions are necessary and if so, what nature of the action should it be. Industries’ risk
management decision shall be based not only computed risk in terms of fatality probability
(fatality/year), but also on judging the acceptability of the risk – a matter of personal and
social value judgement. The risk management includes implementing the actions, decided
upon and evaluating their effects.
Identify Consequence
Estimate
The procedure for QRA starts with identification of major risk areas in the installation.
Operation carried out in chemical Industry usually come under certain board, general
categories.
• Bulk storage of liquids (e.g. Solvent) area in M/s. Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited at
ambient temperature and atmospheric pressure.
• Hydrogenation area ( High Pressure reactions)
• Process Plant involving Piping, pumping, transportation, reactors, distillation, heating,
cooling, electricity etc.
• Drum Storage Area.
10.9CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS
In a plant handling hazardous chemicals, the main hazard arises due to storage, handling &
use of these chemicals. If these chemicals are released into the atmosphere, they may cause
damage due to resulting fires or vapour clouds. Blast Overpressures depend upon the
reactivity class of material and the amount of gas between two explosive limits.
Operating Parameters
Potential vapour release for the same material depends significantly on the operating
conditions. Especially for any liquefied gas, the operating conditions are very critical to
assess the damage potential.
Inventory
Inventory Analysis is commonly used in understanding the relative hazards and short listing
of release scenarios. Inventory plays an important role in regard to the potential hazard.
Larger the inventory of a vessel or a system, larger the quantity of potential release.
The potential vapour release (source strength) depends upon the quantity of liquid release,
the properties of the materials and the operating conditions (pressure, temperature). If all
these influencing parameters are combined into a matrix and vapour source strength
estimated for each release case, a ranking should become a credible exercise.
Loss of Containment
Plant inventory can get discharged to Environment due to Loss of Containment. Certain
features of materials to be handled at the plant need to the clearly understood to firstly list
out all significant release cases and then to short list release scenarios for a detailed
examination. Liquid release can be either instantaneous or continuous. Failure of a vessel
leading to an instantaneous outflow assumes the sudden appearance of such a major crack
that practically all of the contents above the crack shall be released in a very short time. The
more likely event is the case of liquid release from a hole in a pipe connected to the vessel.
The flow rate will depend on the size of the hole as well as on the pressure, which was
present, in front of the hole, prior to the accident. Such pressure is basically dependent on
the pressure in the vessel. The vaporisation of released liquid depends on the vapour
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
pressure and weather conditions. Such consideration and others have been kept in mind
both during the initial listing as well as during the short-listing procedure. In the study,
Maximum Credible Loss accident methodology is to be used, therefore, the largest potential
hazard inventories have been considered for consequence estimation.
Damage criteria
In consequence analysis, use is made of a number of calculation models to estimate the
physical effects of an accident (spill of hazardous material) and to predict the damage
(lethality, injury, material destruction) of the effects. The calculations can roughly be divided
in three major groups:
a) Determination of the source strength parameters;
b) Determination of the consequential effects;
c) Determination of the damage or damage distances.
The basic physical effect models consist of the following.
Consequential effects
Dispersion of gaseous material in the atmosphere as a function of source strength,
relative density of the gas, weather conditions and topographical situation of the
surrounding area.
Intensity of heat radiation [in kW/ m2] due to a fire or a BLEVE, as a function of the
distance to the source.
Energy of vapour cloud explosions [in N/m2], as a function of the distance to the
distance of the exploding cloud.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Concentration of gaseous material in the atmosphere, due to the dispersion of
evaporated chemical. The latter can be either explosive or toxic.
Selection of Damage Criteria
The damage criteria give the relation between extent of the physical effects (exposure) and
the percentage of the people that will be killed or injured due to those effects. The
knowledge about these relations depends strongly on the nature of the exposure. For
instance, much more is known about the damage caused by heat radiation, than about the
damage due to toxic exposure, and for these toxic effects, the knowledge differs strongly
between different materials.
The Maximum Credible Loss (MCL) scenarios have been developed for the Facility. The MCL
cases considered, attempt to include the worst “Credible” incidents- what constitutes a
credible incident is always subjective. Nevertheless, guidelines have evolved over the years
and based on basic engineering judgement, the cases have been found to be credible and
modelling for assessing vulnerability zones is prepared accordingly. Only catastrophic cases
have been considered and not partial or small failures (as is the case in Quantitative Risk
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Assessment where contributions from low frequency - high outcome effect as well as high
frequency - low outcome events are distinguished). The objective of the study is emergency
planning; hence only holistic & conservative assumptions are used for obvious reasons.
Hence though the outcomes may look pessimistic, the planning for emergency concept
should be borne in mind whilst interpreting the results.
Dispersion
The dispersion models within Phast are able to model the following phenomena
• Dispersion of gas, liquid and two-phase releases
• Liquid droplet thermo dynamics calculations and liquid droplet rainout
• Pool spreading and vaporization
• Building wake dispersion effects for vapor releases
Flammable Effects
For releases of flammable material Phast calculates
• Radiation profiles and contours from a range of fire scenarios including pool fires,
flash fires, jet fires and fire balls, including cross-wind effects on a jet fire
• Vapor Cloud Explosion modeling using industry standards models including the TNO
Multi-energy, Baker Strahler Tang and TNT Equivalence models
• Overpressure contours from Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapour Explosions
Toxic Effects
• Graphs of toxic concentration profile
• Indoor and outdoor toxic dose prediction
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
• Reporting of distance to specific dose and concentration
• Calculated exposure time and use as “averaging time” for passive dispersion effects
Phast Risk
Phast Risk allows you to combine the flammable and toxic consequences from each
scenario in your QRA model with their likelihood to quantify the risk of fatalities. Phast Risk
allows you to take account of local population distribution, sources of ignition, land usage
and local prevailing weather conditions. It is designed to perform all the analysis, data
handling and results presentation elements of a QRA within a structured framework.
Phast Risk allows you to quickly identify major risk contributors so that time and efforts can
be directed to mitigating these highest risk activities. Based on effects calculations and
population vulnerabilities, Phast Risk can integrate over all scenarios and weather
conditions to estimate the total risk. The established individual and societal risk indicators
are predicted by Phast Risk across your facility and surrounding area using the classical QRA
methodology. Risk ranking reports can be produced at points of strategic importance to
show the relative influence of the various failure scenarios and their contribution to both
the individual and societal risk metrics.
A key benefit of Phast Risk is the ability to identify major risk contributors and differentiate
these from incidents with worst case consequences which might otherwise dominate the
safety reviews. Whilst medium scale incidents have lesser consequences, they may have a
higher frequency, which, when combined with their hazardous effects, generate a higher
level of risk. Time and effort directed to mitigating high consequence but often low
frequency events may not be well spent. Phast Risk helps you direct this effort more
effectively.
Phast Risk also provides facilities to help you manage large quantities of input data,
including scenarios, parameters, wind roses, ignition and population, and combine these in
many ways. This is critical when looking at sensitivity analyses and assessing the merits of a
range of risk reduction measures.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Benefits
• Facilitates cost reduction in terms of losses and insurance
• Allows optimization of plant and process design
• Assist in compliance with safety regulators
• Enables quicker response to hazardous incidents
• Improve engineer’s understanding of potential hazards
• Regular software upgrades incorporate industry experience and expertise, and
advances in consequence modeling technology
Financial Extension
The Financial Consequence extension is used to assess situations which present potential
hazards not only to life but also to the environment, property and business and help
quantifying their severity in financial terms. Phast Financial helps you to estimate the cost
of a particular release of a given material under specified conditions. The Financial Risk
extension helps you to calculate the broader financial risks associated with accidents and
can be used to help manage your business risk and assess appropriate levels of insurance.
Multi-Component Extension
The multi-component extension to Phast provides greater accuracy for liquid or two-phase
mixture releases compared to the standard pseudo-component approach. The composition
of each component of the mixture is calculated throughout the discharge and dispersion
phases of the release.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
10.9SCENARIOS
TABLE –10.4
_______________________________________________________________________
POSSIBLE ACCIDENT SCENARIOS
Conséquence Analysis
Introduction
In this, the source terms for each defined failure cases are presented, including calculated
release rate, release duration and total released mass of fluid. Subsequently consequence
results from selected failure cases are also presented in order to give overview on the
extent of impact from potential major accident scenarios. Five types of consequences are
presented, i.e. jet fire, pool fire, flash fire, explosion and toxic impact.
CONSEQUENCE DISTANCES
Pool Fire, Fire ball, Flash Fire
The extent of the consequence of a Pool fire is represented by the thermal radiation
envelope. Three levels of radiation are presented in this report, i.e.:
· 4 kW/m2; this level is sufficient to cause personnel if unable to reach cover within
20s;however blistering of the skin (second degree burn) is likely; 0: lethality.
· 12.5 kW/m2; this level will cause extreme pain within 20 seconds and movement to a safer
place is instinctive. This level indicates around 6% fatality for 20 seconds exposure.
· 37.5 kW/m2; this level of radiation is assumed to give 100% fatality as outlined above.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
10.9.1 DETAILED SUMMARY OF RESULTS:
Detailed Results of the consequence analysis of above-mentioned scenarios have been given
below:
Scenario-1Release of Acid (Sulphuric Acid)
Spill pool evaporation module for Acid due to Catastrophic Rupture of 20 MT Storage Tank
Input Data
Stored quantity - 20 KL
Failure Mode: Catastrophic failure
Release rate: 1000 g/s
Results indicate
LC50 – 510 ppm 42.00 meter
IDLH – 3 ppm 560.00 meter
TLV –1 ppm 880.80 meter
Results:-
Results indicate:
Scenario: Diffusion Jet Fire Simulation for 1.0 cm copper connecting pipe to PRV station
In put Data Results of Computations
Stored quantity 100 Cylinder Max. IHR at flame center height 52.49 Kw/m2
Gas Jet diameter 1 (cm) Flame center height 63 meter
Gas velocity in the 143463 m/s Maximum Flame width 12 meter
leakage hole/ pipe
Wind speed 2.31 m/s Heat Flux 8.5 KW/ m2
Gas Density 0.067 kg/m3 Flame Surface Area 3778 m2
Results
♦ In the 21.5 meter radius area is considered as 100% fatality in 1 min.
♦ In the 32.8 meter radius first degree burn in 10 sec.
♦ In the 51.6 meter radius area will give pain after 20 seconds. Blistering unlikely.
M/S. GLENMARK
ENVIRONMENTAL
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Over pressure / explosion for rupture of 1.0 cm copper pipe line of Hydrogen cylinder to
PRV station
Results indicate:
In put Data Results of Computations
Stored quantity 7 m3 Visible Flash Fire Height 0.52 m
Mass of Gas 1 kgs Visible Flash Fire Width 0.26 m
Heat of combustion 42267 KJ/Kg Duration of Flash-Fire in Sec. 2 sec
Fuel-Air volume ratio in 0.600 Radius of fuel-air cloud mixture 4.19 m
Flash fire cloud
Stoichiometric Fuel-Air 00:29 Total energy release 283720 KJ
Mixture
Wind speed 2.31 m/s Max. Heat Radiation from 1 m from Flash 750 KW/ m2
Fire
Gas Density 0.067 kg/m3 Combustion efficiency 0.5
Results
♦ In the 23 meter radius area is considered as 100% fatality in 1 min.
♦ In the 36 meter radius first degree burn in 10 sec.
♦ In the 62 meter radius area will give pain after 20 seconds. Blistering unlikely.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
TED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Scenario: Over pressure / explosion for rupture
♦ In the 23 meter radius ♦ In the 36 meter radius ♦ In the 662 meter radius
area is considered as first degree burn in 10 area will give pain
100% fatality in 1 min. sec. after 20 seconds.
Blistering unlikely.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Scenario-4 Tank on Fire for 18 KL Class A petroleum storage tank
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Pool Fire for Class A petroleum storage tank catastrophic failure
M/S. GLENMARK
ENVIRONMENTAL
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Fire Ball simulation for Class A petroleum storage tank catastrophic failure:
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
TED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
Scenario:
EMERGENCY RESPONSE
DO NOT EXTINGUISH A LEAKING GAS FIRE UNLESS LEAK CAN BE STOPPED.
Small Fire
Dry chemical or CO2.
Large Fire
Water spray or fog.
Move containers from fire area if you can do it without risk.
Fire involving Tanks
· Fight fire from maximum distance or use unmanned hose holders or monitor nozzles.
· Cool containers with flooding quantities of water until well after fire is out.
· Do not direct water at source of leak or safety devices; icing may occur.
· Withdraw immediately in case of rising sound from venting safety devices or discoloration
of tank.
· ALWAYS stay away from tanks engulfed in fire.
· For massive fire, use unmanned hose holders or monitor nozzles; if this is impossible,
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
withdraw from area and let fire burn.
SPILL OR LEAK
· ELIMINATE all ignition sources (no smoking, flares, sparks or flames in immediate area).
· All equipment used when handling the product must be grounded.
· Do not touch or walk through spilled material.
· Stop leak if you can do it without risk.
· If possible, turn leaking containers so that gas escapes rather than liquid.
· Use water spray to reduce vapors or divert vapor cloud drift. Avoid allowing water runoff
to contact spilled material.
· Do not direct water at spill or source of leak.
· Prevent spreading of vapors through sewers, ventilation systems and confined areas.
· Isolate area until gas has dispersed.
Packing
The containers must be able to withstand normal handling and retain integrity for a
minimum period of six months. In general, packaging for hazardous substances must meet
the following requirements:
Labeling
There are two types of labeling requirements:
i. Labeling of individual transport containers and
ii. Labeling of transport vehicles.
- All hazardous Material containers must be clearly marked with current contents. The
markings must be waterproof and firmly attached so that they cannot be removed.
Previous content labels shall be obliterated when the contents are different. Proper
marking of containers is essential.
- Color code is to be provided to the tanker to indicate the type of material present in
that.
- Containers that contain HM shall be labeled with the words "HAZARDOUS
MATERIAL" in Vernacular language, Hindi / English. The information on the label
must include the code number of the Material, the Material type, the origin (name,
address, telephone number of the supplier and receiver), hazardous property (e.g.
flammable, corrosive), and the symbol for the hazardous property.
- The label must withstand the effects of rain and sun. Labeling of containers is
important.
10.11 RECOMMENDATIONS
From the Risk Analysis studies conducted, it would be observed that by and large, the risks
are confined within the factory boundary walls in case of fire & explosion, except in the
event of a catastrophic failure. In case of catastrophic failure of toxic chemical storage tanks,
it will also create OFF site emergency situations and required more attention and
emergency preparedness for combat such situations. To minimize the consequential effects
of the risk scenarios, following steps are recommended.
1. Plant should meet provisions of the Manufacture, storage & Import of Hazardous
Chemicals Rules, 1986 & the factories Act, 1948.
2. Sprinkler system is installed in tank farm area.
3. Air line respirator provision to be made in respective area
4. For bromine emergency details are provided in report to be implemented.
5. Fire hydrant system for proposed plant to be installed as per TAC/NFPA Norms in
each plant and buildings.
6. Dyke wall and collection pit with drain valve needs to be provided in acid storage
area
7. Tanker unloading procedure needs to be displayed at tanker unloading area.
8. Periodic On Site Emergency Mock Drills and occasional Off Site Emergency Mock
Drills to be conducted, so those staffs are trained and are in a state of preparedness
to tackle any emergency.
9. Emergency handling facilities to be maintained in updated condition at all time.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
10. Safe operating procedure to be prepared for hazardous process and material
handling process.
11. Safety devices and control instruments to be calibrated once in a year.
12. Permit to work system to be implemented 100 % for hazardous work in the plant.
13. The details of emergency equipments are given in on site emergency Plan along with
its quantity. As per our site visit, these was found in order & working condition and
sufficient for existing production Activates.
14. Manual call points for fire location identification to be installed in plant premises.
15. Fog type Pressure sprinkler to be installed at storage tank farm.
16. For proposed plant Fire & Safety organization setup to be replanted for better plant
process safety.
17. All Acid vents to be connected with scrubber system.
18. Induction safety program to be prepared and trained all new employees before
starting duties in plant.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
LEVEL - 3:
The emergency, which is not confinable within the factory premises and general public in
the vicinity likely to be affected. It may arise due to -
a) Heavy / Profuse leakage of toxic / flammable gases for a long duration
b) Explosion of high magnitude affecting the adjacent area
c) Major fire inside the factory premises.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
STRUCTURE OF EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited will develop an emergency management team. The
management structure includes the Following personnel’s;
• Site Main Controllers
• Incident Controllers and Deputy Incident Controllers
• Key Personnel’s
• Essential Workers
The other elements of Disaster Management Plan are:
• Assembly points
• Emergency control center
• Fire control arrangements
• Medical arrangements
• Other arrangements
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
SITE MAIN CONTROLLER
Plant head will be the Site Main Controller. In absence of Plant Head, Safety in Charge will
act as a SMC. His task will be to co-ordinate all internal and external activities from the
Emergency Control Centre at Main Security Gate from where all operations will be directed.
He shall…
• Immediately on being informed of the emergency and its location, will arrive at the
site, review the situation and control further actions.
• Direct all Emergency Operations within the approved area with the following
priorities:
a) Personnel Safety,
b) Plant, Property and Environment Safety and
c) Minimum loss of production.
• Co-ordinate to avail services from external agencies like fire brigade, hospitals etc, if
called for, following the declaration of major emergency. If necessary, major
installations in the vicinity may also be informed of the situation.
• Exercise direct operational control of the unaffected section of the plant.
• In consultation with the advisory team, expedite the shutting down of loading /
unloading operations of tankers and if necessary, instruct the supervisor / security
personnel to evacuate tankers.
• Ensure that all employees are evacuated from the affected area and the casualties, if
any, are given necessary medical attention. Instruct P & A Assistant / Security for
rushing casualties to hospitals if required.
• Liaise with fire and police officials, pollution control board officials and other
statutory bodies and advise them of all possible consequence effects outside the
premises.
• Arrange for relief of personnel when emergency is prolonged.
• Issue authorized statement or press release to the news – media.
• Ensure preservation of evidence for enquiries to be conducted by statutory
authorities.
• Authorize the sounding of “All Clear” and “Evacuation Siren”.
M/S. GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT & RISK ASSESSMENT REPORT
• Arrange for obtaining the head – count of all personnel within the premises and
cross-checking with the data from records available for no. of persons within the
premises.
• Nominate a person from advisory team, to maintain chronological log of event
during the entire period of emergency.
M/S. GLENMARK
ENVIRONMENTAL