Anticancer Effects of Annona Muricata
Anticancer Effects of Annona Muricata
3, December 2018
Muricata Fruit
Djabir Daddiouaissaa & Azura Amidb
a
Kulliyyah of Engineering, International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM), Jalan Gombak, 53100 Kuala
Lumpur, MALAYSIA
b
International Institute for Halal Research and Training (INHART), Level 3, KICT Building, International
Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM), Jalan Gombak, 53100 Kuala Lumpur, MALAYSIA
ABSTRACT
Medicinal plants become very important in our days for their therapeutic benefits to humankind. It sustains
human health, and it is commonly known as herbal medicines since ancient times. Annona muricata is a
heart-shaped fruit that is consumed raw or as the fruit juice in the tropical area. A. muricata is used in
traditional and alternative medicine to treat different ailments such as diabetes, hypertension, respiratory
and skin illness, inflammation and cancer. A. muricata contains essential anticancer agents named
acetogenins that play the significant role in various cancer types. Acetogenins are strong nicotinamide
adenine dinucleotide oxidase inhibitors of the cancer cell's mitochondrial membrane but showed neurotoxic
effects in rats. Therefore, acetogenins need to be further investigated to determine the exact mechanisms
of action, long-term safety, optimal dosage, and potential side effects. Given the extensive studies on A.
muricata, this review focuses on the phytochemistry, medicinal uses, biological activities and the
mechanisms of action for the fruit extracts and acetogenins, to stimulate further studies on the fruit pulp
used for human consumption.
INTRODUCTION
Natural products from plants have been used for a traditional uses is Annona muricata L.2 A. muricata is
considerable period by many cultures and a species in the Annonaceae family that obtained
civilizations to help humankind maintain its health much interested in the last decades due to its
and treat different diseases. Over the centuries, the pharmaceutical potential. A long time ago, many
phytochemical compounds have been an essential studies reported on the medicinal use of the
discovery in pharmaceutical applications. The Annonaceae family, since then, the bioactivity and
significance of the active compounds from plants in toxicity of this species attracted the attention of
medicine and agriculture has stimulated scientific many researchers.2,3 Among the critical subject
interest in its biological properties.1 In a studied related to A. muricata is its acetogenins.
pharmaceutical area, plants used in ethnomedicine This study will extensively collect relevant
are the most abundant source of active information regarding A. muricata acetogenins to
phytochemicals that afford health benefits against identify the uncover information so that further
different ailments and diseases. One of it with many investigation will be made.
103
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
more than 70 species in which A. muricata is widely with a diameter which varies between 5-20 cm and
grown.3 A. muricata distributes in the warmest an average weight of 0.4 to 1.0 kg (Figure 1). Each
tropical region of Central and South America, fruit may include 55–170 black seeds.4 The pulp of
Southeast Asia and Western Africa.4 It grows at the fruit has a sweet flesh, and typical flavor which
altitudes below 1200 m above sea level, and can be eaten and used as an ingredient in the
temperatures between 25 and 28 °C, with humidity preparation of many foods and is perfect for making
between 60 and 80% and annual precipitation over drinks, candy and ice cream. Also, the edible fruit,
1500 mm. leaves, seeds, and root are known to have attractive
medicinal properties.5
104
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
Recently, A. muricata fruit consumption Many phytoconstituents and compounds found in
11
increased. Researchers identified bioactive different parts of A. muricata, including alkaloids
compounds such as acetogenins and polyphenols in (ALKs), phenolics (PLs), megastigmanes (MGs),
its pulp, which are related to different pathology flavonol triglycosides (FTGs), cyclopeptides (CPs)
prevention including neurodegeneration, diabetes, and essential oils.1 Additionally, A. muricata has
cardiovascular and anti-inflammatory diseases.8 At shown to be the most abundant source of the
present, the attention is being focused on annonaceous acetogenin compounds (AGEs), in
anticancer properties of A. muricata acetogenins which, researchers have identified more than 120
which are the primary bioactive compounds found acetogenins from methanolic, ethanolic or another
in the fruit.9 organic extract of different part of A. muricata such
as leaves, seeds, bark, stems, pulp and fruit
PHYTOCHEMICALS peel.20,21
OH OH
2 4 O O 32/34
n m
OH
O
35/37 O 1
AGEs are the main bioactive compounds of the ubiquinone oxidoreductase).25 Biological studies
Annonaceae family.23 Since 1982 when Jolad et al. and phytochemical investigations of the A. muricata
discovered uvaricin from Uvaria accuminata, more fruit brought a wide range of AGE compounds, as
than 500 AGEs have been identified from various summarized in Table II.
parts of plants in the Annonaceae family. 24 In recent
years, many scientific studies focused on AGEs The chemical structures of the essential AGEs
because of their unusual structures and extensive extracted from A. muricata fruit were shown in
biological activities. Some studies have shown that Figure 3. To the best of our knowledge, at the time
AGEs are more cytotoxic than alkaloids and of preparation of this paper (May 2018), at least 20
rotenone.3 AGEs have been identified and isolated from the A.
muricata fruit pulp.
The biological activities of AGEs, which are known
as anticancer are initially by inhibiting the complex
I mitochondrial of the cell (mitochondrial NADH:
105
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
Table II: Annonaceous acetogenins extracted from A. muricata fruit (AGE) and its biological activities.
Stage of Mechanism of
Compounds Biological Activity References
study action
Annonamuricin A,
Inhibition of human prostate cancer
B, C, D In vitro NR 9
PC-3 cells
Inhibition of PC-3 cells
Annonacin In vitro NR 9
Inhibition of PC-3 cells
Muricin M In vitro NR 26
Inhibition of PC-3 cells
Muricin N In vitro NR 26
Inhibition of PC-3 cells
Muricenin In vitro NR 26
Inhibition of the
Muricin J In vitro Inhibition of PC-3 cells complex I 27
mitochondrial.
Inhibition of the
Muricin K In vitro Inhibition of PC-3 cells complex I 27
mitochondrial.
Inhibition of the
Muricin L In vitro Inhibition of PC-3 cells complex I 27
mitochondrial.
Cytotoxicity against human
Annoreticuin-9- pancreatic tumor (PACA-2), lung
In vitro 20
one carcinoma (A-549) and prostate NR
adenocarcinoma (PC-3) cell lines
Cytotoxicity against human
Cis-annoreticuin In vitro hepatoma cell line (Hep G2) 20
NR
NR
Sabadelin -- NR 20
NR
Epomuricenins-A -- NR 28
NR
Epomuricenins-B -- NR 28
NR
Epomusenin-A -- NR 28
NR
Epomusenin-B -- NR 28
NR
Epomurinin-A -- NR 28
Epomurinin-B -- NR NR 28
Anticancer Activity and Mechanism of Action of Previous data reported that A. muricata has an
Acetogenins ability on growth inhibition against a wide variety of
cancer cells, including solid breast tumor, lung
Cancer is among the most common causes of carcinoma cell lines, prostate adenocarcinoma,
morbidity and mortality in the world, about 1.73 colon adenocarcinoma cell lines. As well as on
million new cancer cases and 609,640 cancer deaths pancreatic carcinoma cell lines, human lymphoma
are projected to occur in the United States in cell lines, liver cancer cell lines and multi-drug
2018.29 Many studies reported on the significance resistant human breast adenocarcinoma.32,33
cytotoxicity of different extracts and isolated AGEs
from a different part of A. muricata towards various Among many active ingredients, acetogenins
cancer cell lines.30,31 However, few of these studies modulate the production of mitochondrial adenosine
have illustrated or focus on the benefits of the fruit triphosphate (ATP) of cancer cells. ATP reduces the
pulp against cancer disease. Mainly, the acetogenins nourishment of cancer cells by decreasing the
extracted from the fruit pulp of A. muricata and its growth of blood vessels. Previous studies have
mechanism of actions. proposed that the mechanism of the cytotoxic
action of acetogenins is the inhibition of the
106
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
mitochondrial complex I by the inhibition of complex I diminish NADH oxidation which lowers the
ubiquinone-linked NADH oxidase in the membrane proton gradient through the internal mitochondrial
causing apoptosis in cancer cells.34,35 membrane and the ATP synthesis. Moghadamtousi et
al. have confirmed it by demonstrating that the
Complex I, the most complicated proton pump of extracts of A. muricata can arrest cancer cells
the respiratory chain encoded by the nuclear and development in G0/G1 phase which caused by the
mitochondrial genomes, which is responsible for disruption of the mitochondrial membrane, and the
NADH oxidation, the hydrogenase of released induction of apoptosis to suppress the invasion and
electrons to electron acceptor ubiquinone and the migration of cancer cells.37
proton translocation module.36 Inhibition of
trans
threo OH threo
( )8 ( )5
O
OH O
HO HO
O
Annonamuricins A
trans
threo threo
() () ( )5
n m O
HO HO OH OH O
O
Annonamuricins B) m=2 n=7
C) m=1 n=8
trans
threo threo HO
() ()
9 O 6
HO OH O
HO
O
Annonamuricins D
() () ()
9 O 2 3
HO OH OH O
HO
O
Annonacin
trans
HO threo
() ()
O 7
6
OH O
threo OH OH
O
Muricin M
107
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
trans
threo threo
() ()
8 O 7
OH OH OH O
OH
O
Muricin N
trans
threo threo OH
() ()
9 O 4
OH OH O
OH
O
Muricenin
trans
erythro threo
() ()
9 O 6
OH OH OH O
OH
O
Muricin J
trans
threo threo
() ( )5 O ()
4 5
OH OH O
OH OH
O
Muricin K
trans
threo HO threo
() ()
5 O 8
OH O
OH OH
O
Muricin L
HO HO O O
32 O
() () () O
11 5 3
OH
35
Annoreticuin-9-one
HO HO HO O
O
() () () O
11 5 3
OH
Cis-annoreticuin
OH
O
()
()
11 7
O O
Sabadelin
O 1 O
2
32 35
19 O 15 33
Epomuricenins-A
108
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
O
O
32 35
17 O 13
Epoxymurin-A
O 1
O
2
34 37
21 O 17 35
Epomusenins A
O
O
34 37
15
19 O
Epomusenins B
O 1
O
2
32 15 35
O 33
Epomurinins-A
O
O
32 13 35
O
Epomurinins-B
Figure 3: Chemical structures of the major acetogenins isolated from A. muricata fruit.
Moreover, the complex I dysfunction provoke muricata were suggested including the inhibition of
the activation of the mitochondrial-dependent multiple signaling pathways, metastasis, cell cycle
apoptotic machinery via triggering liberation of arrest and induction of necrosis.33,40 Ko and co-
apoptogenic molecule cytochrome c from defective workers also reported that bullatacin extracted from
mitochondria.36 Another study reported that A. muricata at doses of 0.4 g/kg could reduce a
Annomuricin E caused depletion of mitochondrial tumor induced in rodents 300 times better than the
membrane potential (MMP) which leads to the drug Taxol (paclitaxel).41 Meanwhile, Wang and co-
formation of apoptosome and the activation of workers reported that annonacin decreased tumour
caspase 9 and caspase 3/7, which have a relation size in murine models at doses of 0.01 mg/kg
with mitochondrial death pathway.38 Additionally, compared to the commercial drugs such as
Annonacin E upregulated Bax protein and down- adriamycin and cisplatin.42
regulates Bcl-2 proteins. This result confirms
that Annonacin E caused apoptosis through the Although there are many AGEs isolated and
mitochondrial-mediated pathway. The AGEs identified from A. muricata fruit, there is
apoptosis effect is selective for cancer cells is insufficient understanding of its mechanisms of
related to high ATP demand in cancer cells as action in reducing tumor or cancer cells.20,21
suggested by McLaughling that selective cytotoxicity Therefore, more study is needed to understand how
of A. muricata extracts is because of the enhanced AGEs work entirely. These significance anticancer
ATP request of tumor cells compared to the healthy and antitumor activities selected for A. muricata is
cells.39 due to the active compounds, especially AGEs that
can be utilized as a cancer adjuvant treatment. 30
In vivo studies reported the anticancer activity of
isolated acetogenins from A. muricata fruit reduced Study on Neurotoxin Effect of Acetogenins
a breast tumor in rats when treated with A. The dysfunction of mitochondrial CI relates to a wide
muricata fruit extract for 5 weeks.40 Many range of neurodegenerative diseases.36 A published
mechanisms of action of the cytotoxicity of A. study in the Lancet Journal in 1999 investigated the
109
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
relationship between the consumption of A. More research is needed to identify AGEs mechanism
muricata fruit and the occurrence of atypical of actions and quantify the neurotoxic molecules
parkinsonian syndromes observed in the French effects and determine the toxicity level to human.
West Indies on 87 patients.43 Furthermore, the Finally, more clinical studies are required to verify
etiology of that disease in Guadeloupe and validate the plant extracts safety, to be
Island showed a close correlation between adopted as a therapeutic anticancer agent.
acetogenins consumption and appearance of the
neurodegenerative illness.44 A recently published REFERENCES
study reported that annonacin as a significant AGE
in A. muricata might be a potential risk factor for 1. Moghadamtousi SZ, Fadaeinasab M, Nikzad S,
neurodegenerative diseases.45 In rodent striatal et al. Annona muricata (Annonaceae): A
neurons, annonacin minimized the ATP supply and review of its traditional uses, isolated
interrupted the mitochondrial transportation to the acetogenins, and biological activities.
cell soma; this caused perturbations in the protein International Journal of Molecular Sciences
tau which led to similar characteristics of 2015a;16(7):15625–15658.
neurodegenerative diseases.44 It is anticipated that 2. Billo´ nH. Histoire des plantes. Librairie de L.
if somebody consumes one fruit of A. muricata Hachette, Paris 1869 ; pp. 275–276.
daily, following one year, the aggregate amount of 3. Coria-Téllez AV, Montalvo-Gónzalez E, Yahia
annonacin that has ingested is adequate to induce EM, et al. Annona muricata: A comprehensive
brain lesions in rats.46 review of its traditional medicinal uses,
phytochemicals, pharmacological activities,
However, the number of the human population mechanisms of action and toxicity. Arabian
studied and the study in the rat may not represent a Journal of Chemistry 2015.
broader community of human in another area or 4. Pinto AC, de Q, Cordeiro MCR, et al. Annona
continents. Because A. muricata is not new to those muricata. In: Williams, J.T. (Ed.), Annona
in warm tropical regions and a study by Muangpaisan species, taxonomy and botany international
and co-workers showed that the prevalence of centre underutilised crops. University of
Parkinson's diseases in Asian countries was slightly Southampton, Southampton, UK 2005; pp. 3–
lower than that in Western nations, although A. 16.
muricata consumption is a routine practice among 5. Ioannis P, Anastasis S, and Andreas Y.
this people.47 Despite some in vitro and in vivo Graviola : A systematic review of Its aticancer
studies reported on its neurotoxic compounds, properties 2015;3(6):128–131.
Awodele and co-workers demonstrated that 6. Gajalakshmi S, Vijayalakshmi S, Rajeshwari
consumption of A. muricata fruit for 60 consecutive Devi V. Phytochemical and pharmacological
days did not induce any significant toxicity in a rat properties of Annona muricata: A review, Int J
model.48 Therefore, an in-depth study on the Pharm Sci 2012;4(2):3-6.
mechanism of action in vitro and in vivo and 7. Yajid AI, Ab Rahman HS, Wong MPK, et al.
optimize consumption dosage at a specific AGEs Potential benefits of Annona muricata in
must be carried out. combating cancer: A review. The Malaysian
journal of medical sciences: MJMS 2018;25
CONCLUSION (1):5.
8. Badrie N, and Schauss AG. Soursop (Annona
A. muricata fruit, an indigenous medicinal plant muricata L.): composition, nutritional value,
used for ages to treat many diseases. Many types of medicinal uses, and toxicology. Bioactive
research have proven that A. muricata possesses a Foods in Promoting Health 2010;621-643.
wide range of biological activities, and the most 9. Sun S, Liu J, Sun X, et al. Novel Annonaceous
likely are anticancer, antidepressive and acetogenins from Graviola (Annona muricata)
antiparasitic activity. However, there are limited fruits with strong anti-proliferative activity.
studies on A. muricata phytoconstituents and Tetrahedron Letters 2017;58(19):1895–1899.
compounds, especially acetogenins reported on its 10. Hajdu Z, and Hohmann J. An
cytotoxic to the cancer cells especially on its ethnopharmacological survey of the traditional
mechanism of actions. Nevertheless, it is also said medicine utilized in the community of
to have a neurotoxic effect. Porvenir, Bajo Paraguá Indian Reservation,
110
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
111
IMJM Volume 17 No. 3, December 2018
112