Rising Star:: Vietnam's Role in Asia's Shifting Supply Chains
Rising Star:: Vietnam's Role in Asia's Shifting Supply Chains
Given that many of the issues facing the world have an international (if not global) dimension, The EIU is ideally positioned to be
commentator, interpreter and forecaster on the phenomenon of globalisation as it gathers pace and impact.
EIU Consulting
EIU Consulting is a bespoke service designed to provide solutions specific to our customers’ needs. We specialise in these key
sectors:
•H
ealthcare: Together with our two specialised consultancies, Bazian and Clearstate, The EIU helps healthcare organisations
build and maintain successful and sustainable businesses across the healthcare ecosystem. Find out more at: eiu.com/
healthcare
•P
ublic Policy: Trusted by the sector’s most influential stakeholders, our global public policy practice provides evidence-
based research for policy-makers and stakeholders seeking clear and measurable outcomes. Find out more at: eiu.com/
publicpolicy
The Network is part of The Economist Intelligence Unit and is led by experts with in-depth understanding of the geographies and
markets they oversee. The Network’s membership-based operations cover Asia-Pacific, the Middle East, and Africa. Through a
distinctive blend of interactive conferences, specially designed events, C-suite discussions, member briefings, and high-calibre
research, The Economist Corporate Network delivers a range of macro (global, regional, national, and territorial) as well as
industry-focused analysis on prevailing conditions and forecast trends.
RISING STAR:
VIETNAM’S ROLE IN ASIA’S SHIFTING SUPPLY CHAINS
Contents
Introduction 2
Cautious optimism 12
Introduction
V ietnam has received increasing attention as an alternative manufacturing hub to China amid the
US-China trade war. However, its rise as a low-cost manufacturing base in Asian supply chains
predates these more recent international tensions. Among many aspects, its appeal to investors owes
much to the country’s internal political stability in recent decades. This is in contrast with many of its
regional neighbours, which, while able to offer low-cost labour, have suffered policymaking instability
and intermittent breakdowns in relations with major countries.
The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) expects Vietnam’s upcoming leadership transition, at the 13th
National Congress of the Communist Party of Vietnam in late January 2021, to proceed smoothly and
put in place another administration committed to policy continuity in regards to foreign investment
and the improvement of the business environment. This is not to say that Vietnam is not without
major obstacles to doing business—for one, corruption among public officials remains a major
issue. However, the assurance of overall political stability, means that other elements of the business
environment are of more immediate concern: what are Vietnam’s current key advantages over regional
competitors and how will these evolve over time?
Vietnam is rated more highly than China in some aspects of its business environment
(Score out of 10 in key aspects of The EIU’s Business Environment Rankings)
FDI policy Foreign trade & exchange controls Labour market
Singapore 10.0 10.0 7.2
Taiwan 7.8 8.2 7.0
Malaysia 7.3 8.2 6.9
Japan 6.9 8.7 6.8
Thailand 6.4 8.7 6.6
South Korea 6.9 8.2 6.0
Philippines 6.0 7.8 5.8
Vietnam 6.0 7.3 5.6
Sri Lanka 6.0 6.0 6.4
Indonesia 5.1 7.3 5.3
China 5.5 6.4 5.7
India 5.5 5.5 5.4
Bangladesh 4.6 5.5 5.5
Pakistan 6.0 4.6 5.1
Note: Scores cover the forecast period of 2021-25.
Source: The Economist Intelligence Unit, Business Environment Rankings.
In this paper we consider three areas in Vietnam’s business environment that have contributed
the most to its competitiveness as a manufacturing hub—labour, investment incentives and trade
relations—drawing on proprietary EIU datasets such as the Business Environment Rankings
and Risk Briefing. Analysis of each of these areas will help investors and supply chain managers to
understand Vietnam’s potential compared with the wider region:
lF
or labour, we highlight how low-skilled manufacturing wages will remain competitive
for years to come, while scarcity of specialised labour will persist as a disadvantage of the
business environment.
lV
ietnam’s proliferating membership of free trade agreements represents a strong point of
its trade relations, reducing export costs. There are only modest risks to this advantage,
mainly in the form of trade tensions with the US.
For many businesses in the years ahead the main concern will not be rising wages, but rather
a shortage of skilled labour. Advanced manufacturing and services skills will remain scarce.
Nonetheless, the ample supply of low-skilled labour will remain an overarching strength of
Vietnam’s business environment.
As a result of strong growth in the fertility rate after the end of the Vietnam war in 1975, the number
of people of working age in Vietnam is now estimated at 68m, or just over 70% of the total population.
A more recent decline in average births per woman has led to the dependency ratio falling in the last
two decades. Consequently, Vietnam is enjoying a “demographic dividend”: the share of the working-
age population is large relative to those under 15 and over 64 years of age, and we predict that it will
continue to grow in absolute terms until 2045.
The working age share of the population will The agricultural sector continues to dominate
decline slowly over the next two decades employment. As of 2019 over one-third of the
(m) workforce was employed in the combined
Elderly (aged 65 or above) agriculture, fisheries and forestry industries (with
Children (aged 14 or below)
Working age (aged 15-64) agriculture accounting for the vast majority of
120
jobs). Workers from rural areas have been a key
100 source of labour for industry as the manufacturing
80 sector expands.
Several other factors will also serve to restrain wage growth. In terms of labour supply, government
will maintain flexibility towards labour mobility. Vietnam bears many similarities to China in its legacy
of central planning, but it has a less restrictive household registration system, removing a potential
disincentive to worker relocation. For instance, access to healthcare and government-subsidised
schooling are generally better for Vietnamese internal migrants and their dependents, compared with
their Chinese counterparts.
business environment in the coming years. *Guangdong, Jiangsu, Shandong and Zhejiang provinces.
Since it embarked on liberalising reforms in the 1980s Vietnam has moved towards an export-
oriented development strategy that has prioritised foreign investment in fledgling industries. Zones
that give priority to foreign investment have played a key role in this strategy since the first Industrial
Park opened in Ho Chi Minh City in 1991. Vietnam has incentivised foreign direct investment (FDI)
into specific sectors via a combination of three main types of economic zones: industrial zones, which
include industrial parks and export-processing zones; special economic zones; and technology parks.
Incentives offered under the three broad categories of economic zone vary for different jurisdictions
and industries. Eligible FDIs can benefit from corporate and personal income tax exemption and rate
reduction. Below-market land rents are offered as well. Firms in high-technology sectors, automotive,
machinery, and those involved in the production of advanced capital goods are among those eligible.
A firm may even secure the incentives offered within export-processing zones while operating
outside the zone itself, as an “export processing enterprise”, if it maintains customs procedures on
site. Moreover, eligibility criteria are flexible, with options for large firms to enter discussion with the
government.
Nonetheless, for many firms the array of benefits that they qualify for is of less value than a decade
or so ago. This is largely because of the proliferation of trade deals that Vietnam has secured, leading
to the reduction of import tariffs, which have made the previous benefit of duty-free intermediate
imports under the export-processing zones (EPZ) regime largely redundant. Indeed, EPZs were
formerly a focus of foreign investment activity, but have diminished in popularity among investors and
become less of a priority for the government as Vietnam’s effective tariff rate has fallen.
In the decade ahead, the eligibility for investment incentives will narrow to increasingly focus on
higher value-added industries, as the government deprioritises foreign investment in low-value-added
manufacturing industries, including chemicals, plastics and fabricated metals. Notably, this process
will be much slower for less developed provinces located in the country’s interior. This trend will
signal the end of the government’s long-term strategy to establish major industrial clusters, and to
facilitate foreign technology and knowledge transfer to local firms and labour. For business, the positive
outcomes of this will be increased domestic availability of intermediate inputs and a deepening pool of
skilled labour.
Although a range of manufacturing industries exist in the country, only a few have developed into
large clusters and some are yet to benefit from increasing economies of scale. Many of the major
clusters are based within four geographical areas that the Vietnamese government has also designated
as priority regions for industrial development. These are the Northern, Central, Southern and
Mekong Delta Key Economic Zones. Notably, these are administrative designations and include
a mix of the above three economic zone types. The Northern and Southern zones host the highest
amount of industrial activity.
Hanoi
Pharmaceuticals
ances
Household appliances
d related machinery
Automobiles and
ts
Integrated circuits
Major seaports
Population : 21.3m
Ho Chi Minh
Population : 6.1m
Sources: The Economist Intelligence Unit; General Statistics Office of Vietnam; Population and Housing Census 2019.
Among these clusters, Vietnam’s footwear, and textile and garment industries are now well
developed with advanced labour specialisation and scaled-up manufacturing operations in multiple
areas throughout the country. The highest concentration is in southern Vietnam, in Ho Chi Minh City
municipality and surrounding provinces, with a smaller cluster in the north close to Hanoi. A longer-
standing but less developed wood-processing cluster that produces intermediate goods exports and
feeds into a growing furniture manufacturing industry is located close to Hanoi, proximate to major
forest areas in the north-west. A new and smaller cluster is located in the far southern province of
Ca Mau.
At the other end of the spectrum, the value of electronics exports has surged in recent years.
Nonetheless, the value of shipped goods conceals an underdeveloped domestic industry with limited
local linkages. Vietnam is beginning to secure vertical integration in the production of smartphones,
with the largest foreign investor in this industry, Samsung, opening a research and development facility
and a phone screen manufacturing plant, in addition to its existing assembly operations.
In sum, this varied picture points to a continuation of lucrative incentives for many foreign
manufacturing firms for years to come, as Vietnam struggles to move beyond labour-intensive
production. Lower down the goods value chain incentives will be pared back, but this will be a gradual
process. A bigger concern for businesses will be rising land prices, as rents increase rapidly close to
major port areas. However, the supply of accessible interior options will remain strong, presenting only
modest additional logistics costs.
The CPTPP entered into force for Vietnam in early 2019 and links together 11 economies on both
sides of the Pacific. Vietnam is the only low- or middle-income country in Asia to have ratified the
deal. Although the pact extends well beyond tariff liberalisation, the market access afforded via tariff
reductions alone is substantial. For Vietnam, the largest gains will be made on the back of widened
access to Canada and Mexico, which Vietnam did not have agreements with before. Vietnam
previously traded with these economies under most favoured nation (MFN) arrangements, which
maintained high tariffs for many of Vietnam’s key exports. For instance, sports footwear, Vietnam’s
third-largest export into Canada in 2019, boasted MFN tariffs as high as 16%, while telephone sets,
Vietnam’s top export to Mexico, registered high tariffs of 15%.
The more recently signed EUVFTA came into force in August 2020, providing greater access for
Vietnam to a market that accounted for 15.7% of Vietnam’s merchandise exports in 2019 (or 13.5% as
the EU27). The deal led to the immediate elimination of 71% of EU tariff lines, and will extend to cover
almost all goods over a ten-year period. Similarly, 65% of tariffs on EU goods entering Vietnam were
eliminated immediately, with tariffs on most of the remainder falling to zero over the next decade.
Several industries stand out as key beneficiaries of the deal.
Tariffs on roasted coffee (dominated by the robusta variety in Vietnam) fell to 0% in August under
the trade deal, from 9-12% previously. Vietnam is the second-largest source of coffee imports to the
EU. Although there are only modest prospects for market entry by foreign firms into Vietnam’s coffee
industries, the tariff reduction will be a consideration for EU-based coffee importers.
In addition, the implementation of these agreements comes against a backdrop of souring relations
between some regional competitors and Western countries. The US-China trade war has resulted
in the US introducing a wide range of high tariff rates on Chinese merchandise that The Economist
Intelligence Unit does not expect to be fully rescinded within the next two years. Meanwhile,
Cambodia, a rising competitor to Vietnam in the footwear and garments sector, lost preferential trade
access to the EU in mid-2020 owing to concerns over political repression, resulting in an uptick in tariff
rates on these key goods. Its access to the US market is similarly at risk for political reasons.
Vietnam is not entirely free from risks to its current trade relations, but we expect only modest
upward pressure on the cost of trade in the next five years as a result of international tensions. Chief
among these will be frictions with the US over Vietnam’s growing bilateral trade surplus and persistent
currency intervention. We anticipate that the US will impose a narrow range of import tariffs in 2021 on
the grounds of alleged currency manipulation (it has already imposed preliminary tariffs on Vietnam-
manufactured vehicle tyres in late 2020). We expect duties to target industries with low-value added
output, in which the US still has a domestic stake, such as metals, wood manufacturing and fisheries.
Crucially though, these tariffs will be low in value and not wide-ranging enough to seriously damage
Vietnam’s competitiveness.
Cautious optimism
The brisk pace of FDI into Vietnam and the diversity of foreign-invested industries now operating in
the country suggest that the economy is moving rapidly up the value chain. In reality the economy is
at an incipient stage in its industrial development. Domestic manufacturing capabilities will remain
overwhelmingly labour-intensive in the next few years, and production processes will be limited by a
small pool of skilled labour. Nonetheless, the wide range of incentives offered to foreign businesses and
market access granted by numerous free-trade agreements, combined with competitive wage costs
at the low-skilled end, will ensure Vietnam remains an attractive option for manufacturing operations
and those seeking to diversify their supply chain in Asia.
Country Analysis provides you with the best forward-looking data and analysis to understand a
country’s political, policy and economic outlook.
From financial institutions to corporates, governmental departments and universities, the world’s
leading organisations rely on our Country Analysis service to keep them informed about the world and
what it will look like tomorrow. Included in our service:
l Global outlook and daily insights spanning politics, economics and market-moving topics.
l Regulatory intelligence on the policies that will impact the business environment in 50 key economies.
l Industry data on demand and supply of key goods, now and in the future.
360-degree view - our approach is unique; deliberately designed to intersect politics, policy and the
economy, our methodology leads to a more nuanced perspective than simple number crunching.
Beating consensus - with over 70 years of experience, we have a track record of making bold calls and
getting them right.
“Severe contest” - our editorial team is fiercely independent and rightly so. This ensures you can trust
our analysis and apply the insights it offers with confidence.
Find out more information about our service features, delivery platforms and how Country Analysis
could benefit your organisation by visiting:
eiu.com/n/solutions/country-analysis
GURGAON
The Economist Intelligence Unit HONG KONG
Skootr Spaces, Unit No. 1, The Economist Intelligence Unit
12th Floor, Tower B, Building No. 9 1301 Cityplaza Four
DLF Cyber City, 12 Taikoo Wan Road
Phase – III Taikoo Shing
Gurgaon – 122002 Hong Kong
Haryana Tel: + 852 2802 7288
India Email: [email protected]
Tel: + 91 124 6409486
Email: [email protected] DUBAI
The Economist Intelligence Unit
NEW YORK PO Box No - 450056
The Economist Intelligence Unit Office No - 1301A
The Economist Group Aurora Tower
750 Third Avenue 5th Floor Dubai Media City
New York, NY 10017, Dubai
United States United Arab Emirates
Tel: + 1 212 698 9717 Tel +971 4 4463 147
Email: [email protected] email: [email protected]