Engineering research project: methodology
Example: Describing the instrument design and development
This study involved the analysis of data received from the 43-item MCAS, taken by
maintenance personnel from 27 Navy and Marine Corps aviation units. The MCAS is a self-
administered survey consisting of nine demographic and 43 maintenance-related items (see
Appendix A). The demographic items are: 1) rank; 2) total years aviation maintenance
experience; 3) work center; 4) primary shift; 5) current model aircraft; 6) status (active duty,
drilling reservist or active reservist); 7) parent command; and 8) unit’s location. The
maintenance items are grouped into the six HRO components: process auditing, reward
system, quality, risk management, command and control, and communication/functional
relationships. The MCAS utilizes a five-point Likert scale to capture participant responses:
Strongly Disagree, Disagree, Neutral, Agree, and Strongly Agree (note: options of Not
Applicable and Don’t Know are also available).
(Adapted from Hernandez 2001, p. 20)
Example: Justifying your choices
Radiographic techniques are the main non-invasive method used to determine … The
decision to use such techniques is in line with the aims of this project which are to …
The quantitative experimental techniques which will be used are laser doppler velocimetry
(LDV) and particle image velocimetry (PIV)…
The two most widely used media to record the light intensity maps of the flow fields are
charge-coupled device (CCD) chips or the complementary metal-oxide semiconductor
(CMOS) chips (Sherry 2012).
The second advantage of using the multivariate method is ….
Developed by Learning Advisers 1
Example: Acknowledging other possibilities
The primary focus of this project is to … While alternative methodologies have been used in
the past to … these are not considered appropriate for this study. These alternatives will be
discussed in a later section, specifically in relation to why they are not considered feasible.
Describing your data collection procedures
Example: describing the research site
A watershed on the Texas A&M University campus in College Station, Texas, is used to
demonstrate HFR calculations for a realistic watershed and its use for storm-water
management. Watershed D on the West Campus contributes to tributaries of White Creek,
which is in the headwaters of the Brazos River (Figure 4). Tributary D cuts through the West
Campus area, draining 3.2 square kilometers through a natural open channel of 2.0 km in
length (Figure 5). Soils in this area are clays and sandy clays with sand lens and are classified
as Group D hydric soils, and the CN is 77 (City of Bryan/College Station 2008; Thompson
2005). The upper subwatershed of the watershed is densely occupied by commercial and
university facilities, and the lower subwatershed is covered sparsely by urban land use.
Because of increased development, erosion and stream bed degradation occurred in
Tributary D (Figure 5). Gabions have been placed to alleviate increased velocities, and a
detention pond has been recommended for further mitigation of increased storm-water
runoff volumes (Thompson 2005).
(Giacomoni et al. 2012, p. 102)
Example: describing simulator instruments and procedures
Figure 1 is a photograph image of the simulator used in this study. Controllers
communicated via radio (voice communications) with pseudo-pilots, who were responsible
for controlling all of the aircraft in the simulation. Pseudo-pilots were located in an isolated
room adjacent to the tower simulator environment. The pseudo-pilots controlled aircraft via
a customized Graphical User Interface (GUI), which sent commands to an application that
managed all of the simulation displays. A head-mounted eye tracker (Applied Science
Laboratories: Mobile Eye) was used to record the local controllers’ visual gaze patterns. The
Ground and Local controllers stood side-by-side, facing the following tower components.
(Sanchez & Smith 2010, p. 51)
Developed by Learning Advisers 2
Example: describing tests/experiments
3.2 Experimental Methodology
3.2.1 Small-scale Tests
Small-scale tests were performed at the University of Maryland College Park. Both horizontal
and vertical tests were performed. The horizontal tests were similar to FMVSS 302 as stipulated
in the NHTSA Laboratory Test Procedure for FMVSS 302 (FMVSS 2013). Both insulation types, FR
Material and Current Material, were cut into 102 mm by 356 mm strips and laid on two thin
rods, to support the fabric, in a burn test cabinet. Ignition was caused by a methane Bunsen
burner with a flame height of approximately 38 mm placed under the sample (edge of the
burner top was 19 mm from the sample). The FMVSS-302 standard requires that the material
burn at a rate of no more than 102 mm per minute or stop burning before 60 second, so the
results of this study were gauged on these requirements. The vertical test was performed with
samples cut from each insulation of the same size as the horizontal test. The burn test cabinet
was placed in the vertical position and the samples secured one at a time in the cabinet. Once
again, the methane burner with a flame of 38 mm was placed under the sample with the burner
top 19 mm from the sample for ignition. The same requirements to be met during the
horizontal FMVSS 302 test could not be used in the vertical test because of the rapid nature of
vertical flame spread; a subjective approach was used to compare horizontal flame spread to
vertical flame spread and illustrate why FMVSS 302 does not correlate to vertical orientations.
(Patronik 2008, p. 30)
Example: describing programming and calculations (Electrical Engineering)
A computer program was developed (Canaletti 1990). It gives for each minute and each day
of the year the spot width on the boiler, the geometric concentration in the same time and
the quantity of energy harvested per square meter of mirrors based on a typical weather
year. The relationship between collectible radiation and radiation type gives the geometrical
concentrator efficiency. By calculating the geometrical concentration, the boiler width is
taken equal to the focal width spot. When computing the focal spot width the opening angle
under which the solar disk is seen is taken into account (0.0095 Rad), manufacturing
tolerances and pointing mirror precisions. The width of the focal spot and the geometrical
concentration are closely linked but the greatest concentration does not always match to
the smaller spot according some parameters variation. In this case, optimization was done
on the concentration. There are no simple methods giving better optimization of two
criteria that depend on seven parameters. The optimization was done separately on each
item starting with those who seemed the most sensitive. Several "passages" as in the
method of convergence were necessary before reaching a satisfactory geometry.
Technological imperatives arbitrarily limited the range of variation of certain parameters
like the number of mirrors and their minimum width or height of the boiler. Given all these
reservations and according to the latitude under which the system operates, a compromise
was found and it was from these data that the concentrator were performed:
T = 0.15m ; Q = 0.125m ; D = 1m ; i = 60 ; h = 0.5m ; N = 16 ; l = 0.1m
(Canaletti, Cristofari & Notton 2012, p. 1416)
Developed by Learning Advisers 3
Example: Describing data analysis procedures
Example 1
The data from the semi-structured interview was organised and transcribed before the data
was keyed into analysis software for qualitative data. The software used for this research is
QSR NVivo version 9. Bazeley and Richards (2000) highlighted that NVivo is able to
categorise data from interview session into nodes that can be explored, organised or
changed to answer the research questions. This software allowed the researcher to browse
all the data coded at a node, to review the data, to return to the context, or to rethink the
idea in interpreting the results. In this way the coding was more systematic and easy to
access.
(Adapted from Yunus 2012)
Example 2
The data for the quantitative approach was analysed using statistical tools. Descriptive and
inferential statistics were used to analyse the data collected from the questionnaires. As
mentioned in Section 3.1, PASW Statistics 18 were used to analyse the quantitative data.
This software is a comprehensive system for analysing data and it is able to assist data
interpretation more easily (Allen & Bennett, 2010). Tabulated reports, charts, and plots of
distributions and trends were generated to show the significance and similarity among the
data evaluated.
(Adapted from Yunus 2012)
References
Canaletti, J, Cristofari, C & Notton, G 2012, 'Autonomous heat production from solar concentrator',
Energy Procedia, vol. 14, pp. 1415-1420.
Giacomoni, M, Zechman, E & Brumbelow, K 2012, 'Hydrologic footprint residence: environmentally
friendly criteria for best management practices', Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, vol. 17, no. 1, pp.
99-108.
Hernandez, AE 2001, Organizational climate and its relationship with aviation maintenance safety,
Master’s Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California.
Patronik, EA 2008, An analysis of vehicle fires and potential methods to reduce their severity through
more stringent material standards, ProQuest, UMI Dissertations Publishing.
Sanchez, J & Smith, EC 2010, 'Tower controllers' response behavior to runway safety alerts',
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, vol. 54, no. 1, pp. 50-54.
Yunus, R 2012, Decision making guidelines for sustainable construction of industrialised building
systems, PhD Thesis, Queensland University of Technology.
Developed by Learning Advisers 4
