Dhaka Slum Upgrade Plan Proposal
Dhaka Slum Upgrade Plan Proposal
2|Page
Acknowledgement
Firstly, all praises go to the Almighty Allah who has blessed us with the ability to acquire
knowledge and strength in the pandemic period to apply for the welfare of mankind and society.
We would like to express our sincere gratitude to our respected teachers and supervisors of this
project: Dr. Ishrat Islam, Professor, DURP, Bangladesh University of Engineering and
Technology; Dr. Afsana Haque, Professor, DURP, Bangladesh University of Engineering and
Technology; and Ms. Sadia Afroze, Lecturer, DURP, Bangladesh University of Engineering and
Technology for their sincere guideline and consistent support for the project. We would also like
to show our profound thankfulness to all the faculty member of DURP for the knowledge they
have conveyed to us. Without their support and assistance it would be not possible to complete
the work. Especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, it was quite impossible to pull out that
amount of work and finish this project, but their encouragement helped us all the way in this
research.
We would like to thank RAJUK, LGED for providing us with necessary documents required for
the project.
We would like to thank our classmates and fellow seniors for all their help and corporation in the
study.
And finally we would like to thank our parents for their continuous support and inspiration
without which it was impossible to accomplish the work.
3|Page
Abstract:
Slums are urban areas where access, informality, high residential density, insufficient
infrastructure, and a lack of basic services are a concern (World Bank, 2008). Nearly 30% of the
population of Dhaka, Bangladesh's capital, lives in slums. This paper aims to address existing
slum problems by proposing an on-site slum upgrade plan for Dhaka Match Colony that can
serve as a guideline for the upgrade of various other slums in Dhaka city. Numerous case studies
of slum upgrading both domestically and internationally were reviewed. Community
participation, ensuring tenure security, and so forth were deemed to be good practices, whereas
forcible eviction, altering community culture, and so forth were deemed to be practices that
resulted in failed slum upgradation. Additionally, existing national and international policies
were examined, and discrepancies in the standards proposed by these policies were discovered.
The existing state of our study area was appalling, with deficiencies in physical infrastructure,
water supply, and sanitation. Our team developed a policy for the study area's upgradation in
light of the existing standard of basic facilities reviewed and site condition. On the basis of this
policy, an upgradation plan was developed in which multiple apartment buildings with upgraded
infrastructure will be constructed and sold to the slum population. They will be able to own the
apartments after paying affordable monthly instalments for eight to ten years. We hope that the
proposed plan will serve as a model for future slum redevelopment efforts.
4|Page
Table of Contents
Acknowledgement...........................................................................................................................3
Abstract:...........................................................................................................................................4
Chapter One: Introduction...............................................................................................................9
1.1 Background of the Study........................................................................................................9
1.1.1 Definition of Slums:........................................................................................................9
1.1.2. Slum Upgradation:.........................................................................................................9
1.1.3. Global Policies regarding Slum Upgradation:..............................................................10
1.1.4. Slum Upgrading Practices:...........................................................................................10
1.2 Study Area:..........................................................................................................................11
1.3 Goal of the project:..............................................................................................................12
1.4 Objectives of the Study:.......................................................................................................12
1.5 Rationale of the Study:.........................................................................................................12
1.6 Methodology........................................................................................................................12
1.6.1 Identifying the basic terminologies related to urban slum:...........................................13
1.6.2 Literature review:..........................................................................................................13
1.6.3 Selection of study Area.................................................................................................13
1.6.4 Collection of data..........................................................................................................13
1.6.5. Formulation of Development Plan...............................................................................13
1.6.5.1 Generation of vision and policies...............................................................................13
1.6.5.2 Preparing a design concept.........................................................................................13
1.6.6 Preparation of Final Report...........................................................................................13
1.7 Limitations of the Study:......................................................................................................14
1.8 Scope of the Study:..............................................................................................................14
Chapter Two: Literature Review...................................................................................................14
2.1 Definition of Slum...............................................................................................................14
2.1.1 Bangladesh Perspective:................................................................................................15
2.1.2 Asian Perspective: India:...............................................................................................15
2.1.3 South American Perspective: Brazil..............................................................................15
2.1.4 African Perspective: South Africa.................................................................................16
2.2 Definition of Slum Upgradation..........................................................................................16
5|Page
2.2 Slum Upgrading: Good Practices.....................................................................................16
2.3 Slum Upgrading: Bad Practices.......................................................................................18
Chapter Three: Review of related Policy Documents Review......................................................20
3.1 Global and National Policies:..............................................................................................21
SDG 1 No Poverty..................................................................................................................21
SDG 3 Ensure Healthy Lives and Promote Well-being for All at All ages:..........................21
SDG 11 Sustainable Cities and Communities........................................................................21
Challenges of Slum, 2013......................................................................................................21
A Practical Guide to Design, Plan, and Execute Citywide Slum Upgrading Program, 2014:
................................................................................................................................................22
Eighth Five Year Plan (July 2020 - June 2025):....................................................................22
Dhaka City Corporation Act 2009:........................................................................................22
Sector Development Plan (FY 2011-2025):...........................................................................22
National Policy for Arsenic Mitigation, 2014:.......................................................................23
Housing Related Policies:..........................................................................................................23
The Human Rights-Based Approach to Housing and Slum Upgrading, 2017:......................23
Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana Housing for All (Urban), 2016:.............................................23
The Private Residential Land Development Rule, 2004........................................................23
National Housing Policy, 2016..............................................................................................24
Khas Land Management Policies:..........................................................................................24
Water and Sanitation Related Policies:......................................................................................24
SDG 6: Ensure Availability and Sustainability Management of Water and Sanitation for All:
................................................................................................................................................24
PRO POOR STRATEGY for Water and Sanitation Sector in Bangladesh, 2005:................24
National Strategy for Water Supply and Sanitation, 2014:....................................................25
Bangladesh Water Act, 2013:.................................................................................................25
Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority (DWASA) Annual Report 2018-2019:........25
Solid Waste Management and Sanitation:..............................................................................25
Table: Comparative Matrix Identifying the Gap among Policies:.........................................26
Chapter Four: Study Area Profile..................................................................................................30
3.1 Location of the Site..............................................................................................................31
3.2 Site Boundary.......................................................................................................................31
3.3 Historical Development of the Area:...................................................................................31
6|Page
3.4 Demographic Characteristics (Assumed):...........................................................................32
3.5 Environmental Condition:....................................................................................................32
3.6 Socio Physical Characteristics:............................................................................................32
3.7 Community Facilities:..........................................................................................................33
Chapter Five: Vision & Policies....................................................................................................33
Vision:........................................................................................................................................33
Mission:......................................................................................................................................33
1.1 Housing Policies:..............................................................................................................33
2.1 Water Related Policies:....................................................................................................34
2.2 Sanitation Policies:...........................................................................................................34
3.1 Road Policies:...................................................................................................................34
3.2 Drainage Policies:.............................................................................................................34
3.3 Waste Management Policies:...........................................................................................34
3.4 Open Space:......................................................................................................................35
3.6 Disaster Management:......................................................................................................35
Chapter Six: On-site Development plan and proposals for the improvement of living condition of
the residents...................................................................................................................................36
6.1Housing Development:.........................................................................................................36
6.1.1 Housing Unit design:.....................................................................................................36
6.2 Community facilities development:.....................................................................................37
6.2.1 Community school:.......................................................................................................37
6.2.2 Community Mosque:.....................................................................................................37
6.2.3 Commercial facilities:...................................................................................................37
6.2.4 Multipurpose building:..................................................................................................38
6.2.5 Central Waste Collection Point:....................................................................................38
6.3 Roads....................................................................................................................................38
6.4 Water....................................................................................................................................38
6.5 Sanitation.............................................................................................................................38
6.6 Drainage and Sewage System:.............................................................................................39
6.6 Open space and parks:..........................................................................................................39
6.7 Buffer:..................................................................................................................................39
6.8 Water body:..........................................................................................................................39
6.9 Lighting and ventilation:......................................................................................................39
7|Page
6.10 Phase Development:...........................................................................................................39
Phase 1:...................................................................................................................................39
Phase 2:...................................................................................................................................40
Phase 3:...................................................................................................................................40
Phase 4:...................................................................................................................................40
6.11 Waste Management:...........................................................................................................40
6.12 Rent Collection:.................................................................................................................41
6.13 Community Involvement:..................................................................................................41
Chapter Seven: Recommendation & Conclusion..........................................................................43
7.1 Major Findings.....................................................................................................................43
7.2 Recommendation.................................................................................................................43
7.3 Conclusion...........................................................................................................................43
References:....................................................................................................................................44
Appendix A....................................................................................................................................47
Cost Estimation:.........................................................................................................................47
Monthly income from EMI/Rent:..............................................................................................48
Affordability scheme:................................................................................................................48
Land use:....................................................................................................................................49
Appendix B....................................................................................................................................50
Appendix C....................................................................................................................................52
List of Tables
Table 2.1: Comparative analysis of Successful and Unsuccessful Slum Upgradation…………..20
Table 3.1: Comparative Matrix Identifying the Gap among Policies……………………………26
Table 6.1: Housing Unit distribution…………………………………………………………….36
List of Figures
Fig 6.1.1: 300 sq. ft. unit design…………………………………………………………………36
Fig 6.1.2: 500 sq. ft. unit design…………………………………………………………………37
Fig 6.1.3: 400 sq. ft. unit design…………………………………………………………………37
8|Page
Fig 6.14: Proposed Site design for Dhaka Match……………………………………………......42
This chapter includes a general overview about why and how the study was conducted. The
objectives of the study and how the objectives are fulfilled through sequential steps are described
here. The chapter also includes some unavoidable limitations of the study.
Slum upgrading, not eviction, is critical as the world urbanizes. This means improving living
conditions of informal settlements in a responsible manner, providing access to decent housing in
the short term and the long term. Viratkapan & Perera (2006) distinguish five factors
determine slum upgrading results, i.e.: 1) the convenience of the new location; 2) the
9|Page
compensation; 3) the unity of the community or the cohesion and strength of leadership; 4) the
participation of community members; and 5) the attitude of the community members towards the
new location.
10 | P a g e
Due to the government's incapacity to offer public housing, developers into the building trade.
Slum rehabilitation programs profit from TDR (Transferable Development Rights) for the
developers involved. The reduction in building time and cost without compromising quality
may encourage more private developers to embark on similar projects (Sorate et al.2014; Tiwari
et al. 2014). Slum dwellers' constitutional rights (SDG) are not met due to private sector profit
motive. For example, in the Turkish Gecekondu Slum, the private sector was involved in the
TOKI (Turkish Housing Authority) upgrade failure. The initiative failed due to Top-Down
planning, forced banks loan system, personal behavior engagement, and insufficient slum
formalization strategy.
Again, slum upgrading best practices are sustainable. Participation of the community also helps.
It should change the slum's infrastructure and residents' lifestyle. The policy should reduce
poverty over time, or at least ensure that the poor do not get worse off or grow in number. A
project is more likely to be a best practice if it addresses multiple categories of urban poverty,
rather than simply one (yen 2004). For example, the BIP delivered beneficial change to roughly
67 percent of Calcutta's 3 million-person slums (Pugh 1990). During the 1970s, the project
lowered the death rate from waterborne infections, such as cholera (Werlin, 1999).
12 | P a g e
1.6 Methodology
Methodology is the process by which the objectives of a study are fulfilled. Methodology
includes a collection of theories, ideas as they relate to a particular discipline or field of
enquiry. The various steps through which the study has been conducted are given below:
14 | P a g e
mentions about inadequate infrastructures but adequacy standard is not established. It mentioned
informality, but in some places in the world we can see formal settlements that is also known as
slums. “Slums are settlements where a slum dweller faces issues like Insecurity of Tenure, Low
Structural Quality of Dwelling, Poor Access to Safe Water, Inaccessibility to sanitation
facilities and Insufficient Living Space.” (UN Habitat, 2015) The UN Habitat proclaimed that
definition of ‘slum is debatable, or there is some ambiguity because there is no specific definition
worldwide, and they couldn’t provide one. They stated that, a hypothetical slum dweller should
face some obstacles, like tenure insecurity, low structural quality, improper accessibility to safe
water, sanitation and living spaces
2.1.1 Bangladesh Perspective:
“A Slum is a cluster of compact settlements of 5 or more households which generally grow
very unsystematically and haphazardly in an unhealthy condition and atmosphere on
government and private vacant land. Slums also exist on the owner-based household premises.
(Census of Slum Areas and Floating Population, 2014)” In the context of Bangladesh, 5
households in quite rare and lot less in what we see.
Within Bangladesh, there are another two types of informal living settlements namely floating
population and squatter settlement. “Floating population constitutes the mobile and vagrant
category of rootless people who have no permanent dwelling units and they are found on the
census night during 00.00-06.00 AM of the 25th April, 2014 on the streets, rail station, launch
ghat, hat-bazar, Mazar, open spaces etc”. (Census of Slum Areas and Floating Population, 2014)
“Squatter settlements are lands which are illegally occupied, third-party constructed households
in which squatter people who lives on these lands with paying non-relatable land owners or
without paying to the owners at all.” (Census of Slum Areas and Floating Population, 2014)
Most people identify squatter settlements as slums but according to definition, similarities cannot
be found.
15 | P a g e
definitions of World Bank and UN Habitat; Thhe Indian definition of slum highlights the issue
of narrow and unacceptably narrow roads. Sanitation and ventilation issues are addressed in both
the Indian and global definitions.
16 | P a g e
political empowerment. It could also include providing slum inhabitants with legal rights and
tenure. (Corburn & Sverdlik, 2017)
This project managed to improve the drainage systems, sanitation, household connections for
water supply and electricity, and grey-water treatment units. It provided tenure security which
has helped to secure legal access to water, sanitation and electricity and reduced their cost. It has
also helped some to gain formal employment as many employers require a formal address The
main reason for this success was Community-driven slum upgrading, flexibility in design,
institutional and funding arrangements and also political commitment and leadership. (Bhatkha
& Lucci, 2015)
18 | P a g e
housing authority monitoring and previously occupied slum plots reserved for playground and
recreational purposes contributed to the failure of SRA's slum project in Mumbai. Anand et al.
Diverse major focus areas, authorities, and developers failed. Miscommunication, disconnect
between plan and action. Not enough environmental clearance and re-adjustment of the
surrounding area. An upgradation project in West Delhi's Kathputli Slum faced these issues.
(Asher, 2010)
The main objectives were to (i) improve Ankara's image by relocating slum dwellers and (ii)
change their lifestyle from poor to middle class. In order to upgrade slum dwellers, the Turkish
Housing Development Administration (TOKI) forced them into the banking system for
apartment ownership and relocated them to housing estates built by TOKI, and governed the
housing estates via TOKI's private management company (Erman, 2016; Kuyucu, 2014). Legal
residents were relocated to 80 square meter apartments built on the original 333 square meter
land (Erman, 2016). The rules of conduct sparked disputes between residents and management.
The crowded environment in high-rise blocks hindered the reproduction of informal maintenance
practices (Erman, 2016). The residents finally endorsed the TOKI project. The complexities and
ambiguities of bringing a massive piece of land with varying degrees of informality in terms of
land tenure and house type into a formalized land tenure led to abuse (Erman, 2016; Kuyucu,
2014). The slum formalization strategy in Gecekondu led to conflicts and failed planning. Slum
relocation requires residents to change their lifestyles. The government saw Gecekondu as an
illegal slum that needed revitalization. The private sector stigmatized Gecekondu dwellers and
squatters as lower middle class. The project failed due to the residents, government, and private
sector's differing perspectives.
The established good and bad practices assist us in determining the procedure for dealing with
various aspects of slum upgradation.
19 | P a g e
Case of Failed Slum Case of Successful Slum
Comparative Aspects
Upgradation Upgradation
Planning approach Top-down. Participation and collaboration.
Provision of adequate housing
Planning orientation Market oriented. for
lower class people.
Only self-serving strategies Long term residence and tenure
Planning strategy
were prioritized. ship disagreement
Only government or private Joint partnership of government
Supervising Authority
authority in control and NGO’s
No Ground level Multiple Ground level
Actor participator Organizations to ensure organizations mobilized
successful implementation successful implementation.
The convenience of the new Forced transformation of the Accommodate community
location (related to the community lifestyle into culture and encourage to
expected transformation unsuitable community transform community lifestyle
pattern) culture. into healthier lifestyle.
No empowerment to Community empowerment to
Supporting element
improve life quality of the improve economic and social
(empowerment)
community. capacity of the community.
Eviction or loans at higher Giving relocation grants to slum
Compensation
interest rates. dwellers.
Reasonable manifesto which are
Others Overreaching manifesto able to resonate with the target
group
20 | P a g e
Chapter Three: Review of related Policy Documents Review
We have selected a bunch of policy documents, both international and national documents to
review the policies, plans, or strategies. These documents contain global commitments, national
and sectoral level policies, and strategies to identify the gaps between the policy frameworks,
addressing the improvement of the overall environment of the slum areas.In the following, we’ve
sorted out a total of 23 reviewed documents that are divided into the following categories:
(Appendix C)
SDG 3 Ensure Healthy Lives and Promote Well-being for All at All ages:
SDG goal 3 deals with health issues. It has 13 targets and 28 indicators, but among them, only
3.3, 3.5, 3.7, 3.8, 3.9 and 3.a is relevant to slum upgrading and they contain 15 indicators. 5 of
the indicators discuss different types of diseases like AIDS, Malaria and provide guidelines for
reducing the diseases. The other indicators discussSD issues about the mortality rates, drug
abuse, sexual and reproductive issues, less affordability of medicines, and essential health care
and tobacco control. Those are the common issues in the slums of Bangladesh. The SDG goal 3
guidelines will provide many solutions to those problems of slum upgrading. (UN General
Assembly, 2015)
21 | P a g e
Challenges of Slum, 2013
The Challenge of Slums is a global report on human settlements which was published by United
Nations Human Settlement Program in 2003. The Challenge of Slums presents the first global
assessment of slums, emphasizing their problems and prospects. It presents estimates of the
numbers of urban slum dwellers and examines the factors that underlie the formation of slums,
as well as their social, spatial, and economic characteristics and dynamics.
A Practical Guide to Design, Plan, and Execute Citywide Slum Upgrading Program, 2014:
This guide advocates a citywide approach to slum upgrading, from a fundamental shift of
haphazard project interventions to a citywide approach. This program has some steps regarding
initiating and setting up the program; design, implementation of projects, and post-
implementation strategies. This upgrading program requires including slums in the city’s overall
development plans but provokes imposing unrealistic standards and regulations. In the case of
upgrading the Dhaka Match Colony, this policy document can provide a good guideline.
22 | P a g e
Sector Development Plan (FY 2011-2025):
SDP was published by the Local Government Division, Ministry of Local Government in
November 2011. It provides a framework for planning, implementing, coordinating, and
monitoring all activities in the Water Supply and Sanitation (WSS) sector. Applicable for a
period of 15 years. The period was divided into long‐term planning, medium‐term planning, and
short‐term planning, each of five years’ duration and will coincide with the Five‐Year Plan
cycles of the government’s development planning. SDP is a quality guideline for the water and
sanitation part of slum upgrading.
23 | P a g e
structural safety against natural disasters like earthquakes, floods, landslides. This project has
similarities with the Dhaka Match Colony slum upgradation.
24 | P a g e
Water and Sanitation Related Policies:
SDG 6: Ensure Availability and Sustainability Management of Water and Sanitation for
All:
Among the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) the goal 6 is for water and sanitation. The
goal has two targets. Target 6.1 is to make sure every part of the world has universal and
equitable access to safe drinking water. On the other hand, target 6.2 is to achieve access to
adequate and equitable sanitation and hygiene. As we know in Bangladesh most of the people
living in slums have no access to safe drinking water and proper sanitation facilities, so the
indicators and guidelines provide by SDG 6 will work as a shield to the water and sanitation
issues. (UN General Assembly, 2015)
PRO POOR STRATEGY for Water and Sanitation Sector in Bangladesh, 2005:
The document was published in February 2005 by the Ministry of Local Government, Rural
Development & Cooperatives. This policy provides a complete guideline in how to identify,
target, and administrate relief to the hardcore poor regarding water and sanitation. It defines a
hardcore poor household as those who are landless, homeless, or day laborers owning little land
or rented accommodation and households whose family heads are disabled or very old. As slum
dwellers often fall in that category, this document becomes a framework on how to standardize
the water and sanitation services in the slum.
25 | P a g e
This document stated “Right to use water” for the first time in our policy which is a prime issue
in the slum areas.
Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority (DWASA) Annual Report 2018-2019:
The report is related to ADB, World Bank, UNICEF, Water Aid Bangladesh, and much more
local and international NGOs; and mainly for water and sanitation issues. It is a good model for
tackling water and sanitation problems especially for the slum dwellers and the floating people.
This report suggests 3 types of water supply lines for the low-income communities like slums;
namely water point stand post, water point reservoir, and ATM booth.
Non-agricultural Khas Each PSUP must Ensuring total adult Secure tenure ship and
land can be distributed develop community- population with secure proper land rights have
among the family who initiated and managed tenure rights to land, got highlighted in both
has become destitute local projects with legally recognized the international and
by natural disasters or supported by the documentation and sectoral documents,
any family legally Community Managed who perceive their and properly reflected
resettled by the Funds and create an rights to land as secure, in SDG 1.
effective team with by sex and by type of
26 | P a g e
government. decision-makers. tenure (SDG 1.4.2)
(HRBA, 2017)
(MoL, 1995).
Water
Right to potable water A settlement has an By 2030, achieve Water right was
and water for hygiene inadequate drinking universal and equitable distinctly pointed out
and sanitation shall be water supply if less access to safe and in both national and
treated as the highest than 50% of affordable drinking SDG policies.
priority. (PSU, 2013) households have an water for all. (SDG
improved water supply 6.1)
(UN-Water 2003)
The drinking water Piped water, boreholes A water body is Water quality Standard
must meet the national or tube wells, protected classified as "good" is mentioned in both
water quality dug wells, protected quality if at least 80% national and SDG
standards. (LGRD, springs, and delivered of monitoring values policy except in UN-
2005) water are considered like physical or Habitat.
safe water systems. chemical parameters
meet target quality
(UN-Habitat, 2020) levels. (SDG 6.1)
The minimum level of The daily water supply At least basic drinking Daily per capita water
water consumption is of a person should be water represents an supply was not
20 liters per capita per around 20 liters within improved source mentioned but specific
day for household a collectible range. within 30 minutes’ water availability
chores. The source of (UNHSP, 2003) round trip to collect parameter was
safe drinking water water (SDG 6.3.1) mentioned in SDG.
should be within 50
meters of the
household premise.
(LGRD, 2005)
27 | P a g e
Testing new tube- A safely managed No international policy
wells, screening and drinking water service has been found about
monitoring potential is defined as one policies emphasizing
contaminated tube- located on-premises, water supply
wells, and using available when needed infrastructures.
arsenic mitigating and free from
technologies. Arsenic contamination. (SDG Both SDG and
Standard 10 mg/l 6.1.1) international policies
(PSU,2013) come up with arsenic
mitigation standards.
Sanitation
Subject to a maximum The excreta disposal Each household has to The different policies
of two households (or system is considered use separate latrines described many
10 persons) for one adequate if it is private for ensuring a safe households sharing the
latrine, subject to a or shared by a sanitation system. same latrine
maximum of 10 maximum of two (SDG 6.2.1) differently.
persons per latrine. households (UN-
(LGRD, 2005) Habitat,2020) In national policy, the
shared number is more
as it is based on our
huge population.
Expanding National WSSCC advocates for SDG didn’t took
Sanitation Campaign improved sanitation initiative for improving
(NSC) with LG at the and hygiene for the sanitation facilities.
center to ensure most vulnerable and
sanitation for all. marginalized people in Also, no standard
the world (UN-Habitat, about updating existing
Update existing 2020) latrine conditions is
latrines (LGRD.2005) mentioned in
international and SDG
28 | P a g e
policies.
Basic Amenities
Enough reserved space By 2030, provide The need for universal
for different utility universal access to access to green and
facilities and protected safe, and accessible, public spaces has been
by related agencies green and public recognized in both
like- WASA, spaces, particularly for national and global
Municipal Authority, women and children, policies.
DESCO, Titas Gas, older persons, and
etc. (MHPW, 2004) persons with
disabilities (SDG,
11.4)
Health
Establish and manage Achieve universal While the SDG decrees
Primary health care health coverage, universal health care
complex and health including for all, the national
care unit for people. policies only mandate
(LGRD, 2009) financial risk primary health care.
protection,
(SDG 3.8)
Disaster
Reduce the number of By 2030, build the National and Global
deaths and decrease the resilience for those in policies both focused
economic losses vulnerable situations to on resilience and
relative to GDP caused climate-related reduction of loss
by disasters with the extreme events caused by disasters.
focus on protecting the But SDG also takes
poor and people in and other into account the
vulnerable situations environmental shocks economic, social, and
by 2030 (GED.2020) and disasters (SDG environmental shocks.
1.5)
Poverty Reduction
29 | P a g e
of all ages (SDG 1.2) aims to reduce urban
poverty first.
Policy document review is an important part of the literature review. These document analyses
are essential to our slum upgradation project. If we correctly analyze to pros and cons of these
documents and find possible loopholes, we can implement new and improved policies for our
project and the stakeholders will be benefitted.
This chapter provides an overview of Dhaka Match Colony, including socio-economic and
demographic characteristics, community facilities, and local authorities. These figures are
derived from secondary sources.
30 | P a g e
3.2 Site Boundary
Pagla sewage treatment plant is located to the North of this area. Bakchor Government Primary
School, Igloo Ice-cream factory, and Salam steel mills are also around the slum area The entire
slum area is divided into three blocks-Block A, B, and C. (Haque.A et al, 2021)
31 | P a g e
noise pollution, according to the FGD participants Eye irritation, laryngeal issues, etc. are caused
by industrial pollution. (Haque.A et al, 2021)
Mission:
1. Provide affordable housing for every household in the slum area.
2. Ensure Basic Services by providing water and sanitation
3. Improve the basic Infrastructure to support the slum population
4. Achieve sustainable community by improving condition of both the environment and the
people.
32 | P a g e
Mission 1: Provide affordable housing for every household in the slum area.
1.1 Housing Policies:
1.1.1 Provide adequate housing as per dwellers’ economic situation.
1.1.2 Provide pucca mid-rise buildings with small dwelling units.
1.1.3 Housing location should be in a higher elevation area.
1.1.4 Ensure affordability of houses with low interest loans and if that is not possible then houses
would be made available with subsidized rent.
1.1.5 The EMI (Equated Monthly Instalment) should be bearable for the slum dwellers.
1.1.6 Ensure adequate sunlight and air ventilation for every houses.
1.1.7 Housing units should support every available utility.
Mission 2: Ensure Basic Services by providing water and sanitation
2.1 Water Related Policies:
2.1.1 Right to potable water (that must meet the national water quality standards) and to water
for hygiene and sanitation shall be treated as highest priority for all.
2.1.2 Provision of accessible, affordable and acceptable safe drinking water facility to each and
every individual
2.1.3 Piped water lines both for drinking and household purpose should be ensured for every
household
2.1.4 Subsidize the capital cost of water bills for the slum dwellers.
2.1.5 Coordination among Non-profitable organizations to provide the services to all.
2.2 Sanitation Policies:
2.2.1 Provide access to hygienic latrines for every household.
2.2.2 Access to a flush or piped sewer system or septic tank for the sanitation.
2.2.3 Subsidization on sanitary materials for the target people.
2.2.4 Raise Awareness about sanitation related problems through the coordination of local NGO
Mission 3: Improve the basic Infrastructure to support the slum population
3.1 Road Policies:
3.1.1 Create accessibility to the main road with the slum area
3.1.2 Provide Road security at night by ensuring adequate lighting
3.1.3 Provide at least one road for access of emergency vehicles.
33 | P a g e
3.2 Drainage Policies:
3.2.1 Repair the drainage system of the area to prevent water-logging.
3.2.2 Cover the drainage system appropriately.
3.3 Waste Management Policies:
3.3.1 Assign designated spots for dumping household waste
3.3.2 Provide accessibility of the dumping spot to every building
3.3.3 Create van service carrying the wastes from household to dumping spot
3.3.4 Discourage dumping waste in the near-by waterbodies
3.3.5 Promote and train the dwellers about the 3Rs (Reduce, Reuse and Recycle)
3.4 Open Space:
3.4.1 Provide adequate open space which is accessible for all
3.4.2 Landscape the open space
3.5 Health Care and Educational Policies:
3.5.1 Ensure basic healthcare and educational facilities are accessible.
3.6 Disaster Management:
3.6.1 Place fire extinguisher at a designated point in case of emergencies.
3.6.2 Use the open space to take shelter against natural disasters like earthquake etc.
Mission 4: Achieve sustainable community by improving condition of both the environment
and the people
4.1 Introduce various financial support services like low interest loans, government funds, social
schemes etc.
4.2 Increase job opportunities for the slum dwellers by organizing training programs
4.3 Organize seminars on gender equality, delinquency and other social issues
4.4 Reduce air, water and sound pollution by landscaping the area with pollution reducing trees
4.5. Discourage the slum people from infilling the nearby waterbody
4.6 Clean the waterbody to eliminate water pollution
4.7 Landscape the bank of waterbody to give it a scenic view and create a healthy environment
34 | P a g e
Chapter Six: On-site Development plan and proposals for the improvement of
living condition of the residents
This chapter details the study area's proposed strategy and development plans, which are based
on the vision and policies stated in the previous chapter. Along with the full plan, the land use
distribution and building cost recovery are included.
6.1Housing Development:
As stated in the policy, the plan's
principal objective was to provide
housing for individual families.
While designing the residential area,
it was necessary to consider
appropriate open space and building
orientation for proper lighting and
ventilation. Blocks of four and five-
story buildings will serve as the
Table 6.1: Housing Unit distribution
foundation for the housing. There will be two house blocks on either side of the street facing
north and south. The blocks will have a variety of shapes and sizes according to income classes
and dwelling members. Each building will include large hallways of 6 feet width for air
circulation and lighting, as well as a common area for gathering and socializing.
35 | P a g e
apartment will have three windows, one in each of the bedrooms and one in the kitchen. In the
washroom, there will be a ventilation system installed.
Fig 6.1.2: 500 sq. ft. unit design Fig 6.1.3: 400 sq. ft. unit design
6.2 Community facilities development:
A community facility is a fundamental requirement for the development of healthy and
sustainable housing. When developing the site, it is taken into account that both families and
bachelors would have equal access to community facilities. As a result, they are built and
situated in such a way that each individual may benefit fully from the amenities. Our suggested
design seeks to provide necessary community facilities while retaining low-income residents'
requirements.
6.2.1 Community school:
There are two schools near Dhaka Match Colony: Bakchor Government Primary School and
Bakchor Adorsho High School, yet there is no colony school. We intend to build a secondary
school building in four stories of 10,000 sqm with a playground connected to the park. The main
road offers direct access to the school
6.2.2 Community Mosque:
There is currently a two-story mosque at the center of the colony. We do not plan to relocate the
mosque, but to extend it to 5,832 sq ft, taking into account the projected population in 2035. The
main road provides direct access to it
6.2.3 Commercial facilities:
We intended to construct a two-story commercial structure with a floor size of approximately
309 square feet. It will be located adjacent to the mosque, at the intersection of the principal
36 | P a g e
access road's turn. On the first floor, supermarket and organic food markets will be located. On
the top floor, there will be a hotel dedicated to the colony's single residents. Additionally, this
hotel will be accessible to individuals of all backgrounds.
6.2.4 Multipurpose building:
In the heart of the match colony, we propose a two-story multipurpose building. It will serve as a
community center, disaster shelter, and day care center for the children of female manufacturing
workers ranging in age from one to five years. It is 3250 square feet in size. It has direct access
from the principal road and is connected to the park.
6.2.5 Central Waste Collection Point:
A central waste collection point with a total area of 1948 square feet will be constructed. The
community will have access to the collection point via a secondary access road and a primary
access road from outside the colony area. The area will be buffered so that bad odors do not
disturb the community.
6.3 Roads
The roads in the area will be divided in two categories- major access road and minor access road.
The major access road will be 20 ft wide while the minor would be 15 ft wide. The roads were
planned is such a way for efficient access of the residents along with the ease of access of for
emergency vehicles. The access to main road was lessened to avoid gentrification of the
community. The main access road has access to all the community facilities while the minor
access road mainly gives access to the individual buildings of the block. There is also a footpath
in the middle-income block which gives access to the open space of middle-income housing.
6.4 Water
The water will be supplied from the nearby existing municipal water line. If that is not possible
then then water pumps will be placed to supply the population with ground water. Each building
will be equipped with pumps and water tanks so that water can be stored and supplied to every
storey. Each unit will have a minimum of three water taps. One water tap for the kitchen and two
for the bathroom.
6.5 Sanitation
Each housing unit will have a bathroom (6 ft* 6ft for 300 and 400 sq. ft units, 8 ft* 6 ft for 500
sq. ft units). The bathrooms should have one commode, two water taps and a ventilator. It will be
used as both a toilet and a bathroom. Each storey will have common basins in the corridors for
hand washing.
37 | P a g e
6.6 Drainage and Sewage System:
Drainage should be connected to Pagla sewage treatment plant (Sewerage Master Plan,DWASA)
Drains should be capable of retaining surplus water during the rainy season. Drainage channels
will be sealed off. Sewerage pipe lines will follow the area's elevation map. (Appendix B Map-2)
6.7 Buffer:
We will create a buffer zone across the match colony's perimeter by planting various types of
trees in order to mitigate air and noise pollution caused by industries and train service.
Phase 1:
• Establishment of a 20-foot-wide major access road.
• Establishment of two entrances on either side of the site.
• The construction of a 15-foot-wide secondary access road for the Community School.
• Filling in the road to raise it three feet in height
• Demolition of homes on the north side of the Main Road
38 | P a g e
• A seventeen-story structure with eight units will be developed for middle-income
residents.
Phase 2:
• Filling in the northerly side of the khal;
• Construction of nine four-story buildings for low-income persons.
• The mosque in the center has been preserved;
• The mosque in the middle has been preserved;
• The waste collection point located on the northern corner;
• A commercial building located next to the mosque; and a wall is being built around the
perimeter to prevent intruders from entering.
Phase 3:
• During Phase 3, two small access roads on the site's southern boundary will be constructed.
• Destruction of structures on the south side of a minor road.
• A four-story structure for persons with higher incomes is being constructed.
• A four-story secondary school in the southern part of the city.
• Excavation of earth in the south-eastern area of the city of Khal.
Phase 4:
39 | P a g e
dumping point. They will use van for this purpose. They have to do these 3 days per week. The
committee will decide who will be in charge in this section.
40 | P a g e
• Fish policy issue: The water body will be purified, cleaned, and leased to the relevant
authority or possible seller for fishing. When leasing, community members must be
included in the fish cultivation process.
Legends
IC2 Buildings Mosque Outer Road
Central Major Access
IC1 Buildings
Waste Road
IC3 Buildings Disposal
Trees Secondary
Point Access Road
Single (women) Open Space Footpath
Buildings
Single (men) Water Body Community
Buildings Canter
Setback Area Area to be Primary
sold School/
Corner Shop Nursery
41 | P a g e
Chapter Seven: Recommendation & Conclusion
7.1 Major Findings
• Community participation, among other factors, is critical to a successful slum upgrading
program. Other practices that contribute to the success of slum upgradation include
improving physical infrastructure, managing utilities, compensating residents for relocation,
and ensuring tenure security.
• After analyzing international policy documents and comparing them to the SDGs, we
discovered that, while certain housing criteria, land rights, and tenure security are
emphasized in all major documents, international policies on water rights and quality
standards are conspicuously absent. Additionally, while hygienic latrines were mentioned in
the SDG, the SDG did not emphasize the importance of improving existing sanitation
facilities. While national policies mandated only primary healthcare, the SDGs emphasized
the importance of universal coverage. The current state of slums is dire, with problems with
infrastructure, water scarcity, and a lack of sanitation, to name a few. Numerous serious
accidents have occurred in the slum, most notably a large fire in 2005. (Haque et. al, 2016)
• The proposed plan aims to improve the slum's current living conditions by constructing
apartment buildings of a minimum standard that are also affordable to slum dwellers. Within
8-11 years, slum dwellers would be able to own an apartment through affordable monthly
instalments.
7.2 Recommendation
It is recommended to raise the elevation level of the area to reduce water logging. The lake
should also be reshaped and dredged to accommodate more water so that the lake does not
overflow during rainy season. As the area is situated in an industrial area with a sewage
facility and railway tracks on one side, it is recommended to apply the latest technology to
reduce water, air and sound pollution of the area.
7.3 Conclusion
The people of Match Colony slum have made efforts toward legalizing their habitat since long
ago. The proposed plan might achieve that dream along with enhancing their current way of life.
42 | P a g e
We are hopeful that this plan may effectively solve their current predicaments and set a
precedent for future slum upgrading programs.
References:
Adama, O. (2020). Slum upgrading in the era of World-Class city construction: the case of
Lagos, Nigeria. International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development, 12(2), 219-235.
Anand, N., & Rademacher, A. (2011). Housing in the Urban Age: Inequality an Aspiration in
Mumbai. The Authors, 1748-1772.
Archer, D. (2010). Empowering the Urban Poor through Community-based Slum Upgrading:
The Case of Bangkok, Thailand. The 46th ISOCARP Congress 2010.
AUC (American University in Cairo). 2014. Egypt’s Strategy for Dealing with Slums. Cairo:
American University in Cairo.
Bah, E.h. M., Faye, I., & Geh, Z. F. (2018). Housing Market dynamics in Africa. London:
Palgrave Macmillan.
Barker, J. (2009). Negara Beling: Street-level authority in an Indonesian slum. State of authority:
The state in society in Indonesia, 47-72
Bashar, S. (2016). Dinajpur, Bangladesh Jogen Babu Math Slum – Infrastructure. Retrived from:
Architecture In Development - Jogen Babu Maath slum - infrastructure
Bureau of Statistics. (2015). Census of Slum Areas and Floating Population 2014 (1st ed.).
Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. http://www.bbs.gov.bd/
Das, A., & King, R. (2019). Surabaya: The Legacy of Participatory Upgrading of Informal
Settlements. (World Resources Report Case Study). Washington, DC: World Resources
Institute.
Ehresmann, P. (2004). Nairobi's housing crisis: an analysis of the Kenya Slum Upgrading
Programme.
43 | P a g e
Ettyang, K. (2011). Empowering the Urban Poor to Realize the Right to Housing: Community-
Led Slum Upgrading in Huruma—Nairobi. Les Cahiers d’Afrique de l’Est/The East
African Review, (44), 147-158.
IDB. Shelter from the Storm: Upgrading Housing Infrastructure in Latin American Slums. In:
IDB Working Paper Series No. IDB-WP-528, 2014.
Minnery, J., Argo, T., Winarso, H., Hau, D., Veneracion, C. C., Forbes, D., & Childs, I. (2013).
Slum upgrading and urban governance: Case studies in three South East Asian
cities. Habitat international, 39, 162-169.
Njihia, S. M. (1982). Problems of housing finance for the urban low-income group: A Case study
of the Dandora site and services project in Nairobi (Doctoral dissertation,
University of Nairobi).
Patel, K. (2013). A successful slum upgrade in Durban: A case of formal change and informal
continuity. Habitat International, 40, 211-217.
Rahman, K. M. & Hasi, N.A. (2014). Impact of Urban Partnership for Poverty Reduction
(UPPR) Project: A Case Study on Ward No. 35 of Chittagong City Corporation. Paper
presented at 2nd International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering 26 –28
Dec, 2014 CUET, Chittagong, Bangladesh.
Reimers, C. A. (2002). After sites and services: planned progressive development strategies in
low-income housing during the 1990s (Doctoral dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of
Technology).
United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (Habitat). (1994). HAI EL SALAM PROJECT
AN
UPGRADING AND SITE AND SERVICES PROJECT ISMAILIA, EGYPT. (1996). Nairobi:
United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (Habitat).
44 | P a g e
United Nations Centre for Human Settlements. (1987). Case Study of Sites and Services
Schemes in Kenya: Lessons from Dandora and Thika. United Nations Centre for Human
Settlements (UN HABITAT).
UN-Habitat. Informal Settlements; UN-Habitat: New York, NY, USA, 2015; pp. 1–8.
45 | P a g e
Appendix A
Cost Estimation:
Building No of building No of floors Total floor area Cost (per sq. Total cost
Type (sq. ft) feet ) tk
Housing 70,47,89,728
total
Water 100000
installation
Phases of Road Area/ Volume of Cost per Area/ Volume Total Cost
Road
Earthwork in road 6931.152 cubic m 111 tk per cubic m 769357
embankment
Single layer Brick Flat 6822 sq m 368 tk per sq m 2550664
46 | P a g e
Soiling
Premixed Bituminous 6822 sq m 626 tk per sq m 4338902
carpeting with stone
chips
Providing Bituminous 6822 sq m 104 tk per sq m 720840
painting
Total Project Cost 76,44,24,123
Total Project spend 76,44,24,123 taka
Category Monthly income Monthly EMI/Rent Number of units Total income (per
month)
Single <10000 taka 1000 taka per 360 960000
person
IC 1 <10000 taka 2000 taka 288 576000
IC 2 (70%) 10000-15000 3000 taka 381 1143000
IC 2 (30%) 15000-20000 4500 taka 163 733500
IC 3 (50%) 20000-25000 5000 taka 24 120000
IC 3 (50%) > 25000 taka 7500 taka 24 180000
Total 5354500
Affordability scheme:
47 | P a g e
IC 1 <10000 taka 2000 taka 10 years 9 months
IC 2 (70%) 10000-15000 3000 taka 10 years 9 months
IC 2 (30%) 15000-20000 4500 taka 7 years 2 months
IC 3 (50%) 20000-25000 5000 taka 10 years 9 months
IC 3 (50%) > 25000 taka 7500 taka 7 years 2 months
Land use:
48 | P a g e
Appendix B
49 | P a g e
Legends
9.2-10 7.6-8.3
8.4-9.1
6-6.6
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
Phase 4
50 | P a g e
Map 3: Proposed Phase Development Map for Dhaka Match Colony
Appendix C
Table: List of Documents Reviewed
Type of Documents Title of the Documents
51 | P a g e
52 | P a g e