Chapter 1 3 Updated New
Chapter 1 3 Updated New
A Thesis
Presented to
The Faculty of the College of Communication and Information Technology
President Ramon Magsaysay State University
Masinloc, Zambales
In Partial Fulfilment
Of the Requirement for the Degree
Bachelor of Science in Information Technology
By:
Afable, Kristyl E.
Asia, Mary M.
Balonso, John Hollan P.
Sangalang Reggie Jr. D.
July 2021
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Project Context
Any work a human can do in an hour, a machine can do in a minute. Technology
indeed has a great part in our lives. It cannot deny that without technological advancements,
people's lives would not have been easier and faster. In today's modernization, technologies
succeeded in reducing human efforts and the risk of doing a lot. As we live in a
technological world, we need technology in every single matter of our life. However, some
researchers noticed that some sectors in today's society seem to be left behind in adopting
organization throughout the records-life cycle. A records management system is more than
just storage. It's a complete end-to-end solution that adheres to a strictly defined policy to
create, store, and destroy all hard and digital information assets. It usually involves records
management software as well, but it's not just software or scanning either. Electronic
Records Management System (ERMS) is an electronic system for managing paper records
in a records center or registry. ERMS could also be a system for managing electronic
Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) programs, plans, projects, and activities of the province.
They are also responsible for developing strategies on disaster risk reduction and
management through better partnership and working relationship among the departments
within the Local Government Unit, civil society organizations, private sectors and other
volunteers.
For many years, the PDRRMO Zambales has been using traditional way of storing
and managing files and records. Although they have access to technology like computers,
they are not using it to the most useful ones that might help them in their work, like using
the computerized record management system. There are things that they can do with their
computers, yet they are doing it manually. With manual processing, it would take much
time to search for the records and files. But with the aid of computers, the documents are
only one click away compared to manual processing or work done by hand. And due to
the COVID19 pandemic, the PDRRMO limits the number of employees allowed to work.
Since the manual record system requires many human resources, and the employees are
In this regard, the researchers aim to develop an Online Records and Documents
(PDRRMO) Zambales. The researchers are determined to develop a system that will take
the manual record system into an Online Records and Documents Management System.
The proposed system will help employees manage their important files and documents
properly and make their work faster, easier, and more convenient. It can also ensure the
confidentiality of the files and documents since only authorized employees can access the
system.
PURPOSE AND DESCRIPTION
system may help them resolve the current issues that they are encountering with their
current manual system. This system will take place all their manual systems into Online
Information Systems. Since the system will help lessen their work, a faster transaction
saves more time for other activities. Lost data will also be avoided because the database is
system, the thirteen (13) Municipal Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Office
(MDRRMO) of Zambales can easily send and request files directly to the PDRRMO office.
record and document management system will help both the employee of PDRRMO and
To the Zambaleños. In this system, the Zambaleños can easily acquire information
To the Researchers. This study will help the researchers increased their learning
To Future Researchers. This study would serve as a ready reference for the other
researchers who would embark on a similar study in the future, especially on certain aspects
System.
1. To determine the level of system quality of the Online Records and Documents
Reduction and Management Office (PDRRMO) using ISO 25010:2011 using the
2. To determine the level of system quality of the Online Records and Documents
Reduction and Management Office (MDRRMO) using ISO 25010:2011 using the
Scope
The Online Records and Documents Management system is an online system which
requires internet connection to use or generate. This study provides information about the
(PDRRMO) Iba, Zambales under the three sections: admin and training; research and
The Online Records and Document Management System has four types of users:
The administrator has the full access to the system, they are the one who will
confirm and give restriction to the other users. They can also add, edit, update, retrieve and
delete items from the system and post announcement to the home page such as class
The users are usually the Municipal Disaster Risk Reduction Management Office
(MDRRMO) personnel. In this system, the thirteen (13) Municipalties of Zambales can
easily submit their report to Provincial Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Office
(PDRRMO) Iba, Zambales by uploading PDF file that was more convenient than
Temporary users are almost the same with the user, the only difference is that
temporary account has more restricted and they can only access the system in a limited
time.
The visitors can access the emergency hotline of each Municipalities in case of
disasters and calamities. They can also inquire or ask the information, files and documents
The system can generate reports and calamities monitoring such as flood, road,
The system will have a chat box where users especially every Municipalities can
message the administrator and administrator can also message the users in return in case,
announcement section that is open for public like weather update and class suspension ; a
notification area, where both users and administrator will be notified if someone sent an
Limitation
The system only allowed to reset the password of regular and temporary user if they
answer the security question provided once forgotten. Security question are from what they
Only the administrator can post announcement that will be able to see at the
homepage of the system. Aside from that, only the administrator is the one who can active,
Visitors can’t get inside the system; they can only access the homepage that was
open for them. The temporary users are the one who has a time duration in using the system
and once it reached the time span given to him/her, the account will automatically block
unless the administrator permitted. Regular and Temporary users can only message the
This chapter discusses the existing study in the context of proceeding related
research. This research study cited articles and systems, which are pragmatic, based on the
Technical Background
The researchers had gathered all related research about the project and had
brainstormed about what technologies will be used. As the projects is still ongoing, the
researcher will still search for tools and software that can help improve the development of
the system.
The Online Records and Documents Management System is a system that will help
them to easier store, manage and keep track of all their documents. It will take all their
manual system into computerized and online one. The project will be an IT related study
so there will be terms or terminologies that only IT students and persons on the IT field
can understand. There are some of the technical terms that are being used by the researchers
CSS, WampServer and Webhost. Some of the terminologies being stated above are also
development, hosting upon offline development and hosting for offline purposes.
what users visually see first in their browser or the user interface of the system. Under
front-end development, the researchers used the following: WordPress is a free, open-
management system (CMS) written in PHP that uses a MySQL database. In non-geek
speak, WordPress is the easiest and most powerful blogging and website builder in
existence today, Bootstrap is the most popular HTML, CSS and JavaScript framework for
Hypertext Markup Language (HTML), the standard programming language for describing
the contents and appearance of Web pages and it was developed to solve compatibility
problems that affect the current standard, HTML4, JavaScript is a scripting language used
to create and control dynamic website content, i.e. anything that moves, refreshes, or
otherwise changes on your screen without requiring you to manually reload a web page
and CSS Cascading Style Sheets is a style sheet language used for describing the
of three parts: a server, an application, and a database. Under back-end development, the
researchers used the following: PHP which is a reflective programming language or server-
side scripting language that is used by the researchers for web development, MySQL is an
For hosting upon offline development, the researchers used WampServer which
refers to a solution stack for the Microsoft Windows operating system, created by Romain Bourdon
and consisting of the Apache web server, OpenSSL for SSL support, MySQL database and PHP
programming language.
Lastly, for hosting for offline purposes, the researchers used 000WebHost is a free
hosting platform that is powered by Hostinger and you can host your custom Html Site,
institution in this new era. As the population increases, the difficulty in disseminating or
giving the information seems to increase also. Online Records and Documents
Management System is one of the answers to this problem; this is where the group has
Provincial Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Office. Every year there is calamities
with number of affected families and persons increases, therefore it would be difficult for
the Municipal DRRMO to submit report to Provincial in real time. Using the Online
Records and Management System, the delayed reports, the late assistance and actions, the
low accuracy of the information about the calamities will be a thing of the past.
Visual Studio Code
The researchers will use Visual Studio Code because it is free source code editor
and Notepad replacement that supports several languages. Running in the Microsoft
Windows environment, its use is governed by GPL License, based on the powerful editing
component Scintilla, Visual Studio Code is written in C++ and uses pure Win32 API and
STL which ensures a higher execution speed and smaller program size. It has amazing
features like Syntax Highlighting and Syntax Folding, User Defined Syntax Highlighting
WampServer
The researchers will use WampServer because it is available for Zip archive, and
you can open and run the wamp server. It has an easy interface that provide with a
management interface that lets you start or stop the server with one click. It is also a Multi
PHP Version Change PHP version in one click and download new PHP version directly
from php.net repository. CPU Monitoring Real time Apache and MySQL process CPU
monitoring.
MySQL
relational database management system. This MYSQL is a graphical tool for creating
database, it based on the structure query language, which is used for adding, removing, and
modifying information in the database. Standard SQL commands, such as ADD, DROP,
INSERT, and UPDATE can be used with MySQL. MySQL can be used for a variety of
applications, but is most commonly found on Web servers. A website that uses MySQL
The researchers will use Google Chrome because it is an open-source program for
accessing the World Wide Web and running Web-based applications. The Google Chrome
browser can retrieve or fetches code, usually written in HTML (HyperText Markup
Language) and another language, from a webserver, interpret this code, and render
Related Literature
Dozier and L. Grunig (1992) suggested that public relations should be understood
as a component of the adaptive subsystem. They asserted that public relations should be
affects the organization's internal and external relationships with the public. To garner
stronger presence within the vertical structure, the public relations function should be
integrated into a single department, which would enable efficient use of scarce resources.
agencies and officials. For businesses of any size, navigating government circles can be a
tedious and confusing process. Communications agencies can help circumvent some of
management control of records. Kevin Smith and others defined records management in
three words; records management, broadly defined includes forms, reports, reproduction
management in its broadest sense concerns itself with creating record distribution
refers to a computerized system that facilitates the creation, capture, organization, storage,
This system will help the organization retrieve their files easily. Having an Electronic
Document Management System has many advantages. In the current generation, most
accepted that capturing and storing records in accessible form requires much earlier
intervention by archivists and information managers than was the case with paper records.
Within government, national archives have been seen to reorient themselves to focus much
more than before on proactive records management, working with software developers and
with records-creating agencies to influence how records are created. Archives failing to do
business files and records digitally, whether they started out in paper form or were
generated by software applications. Paper files are first converted to electronic format by
scanning. This provides a more compact means of storage, universal access for retrieval,
organization and electronic records management were thoroughly explored. In a study done
by Wang et al. Barangay Management Information System for San Carlos City. This will
many benefits to the organization, and these include the following informed policy making,
(ERM) strategy regulates how your organization's information is created, edited, shared,
tracked, stored and protected. Using ERM software simplifies the process of records
management by automating many functions like generating metadata for easy document
records without leaving the desk; indexing flexible and easily modified; full-text search;
less likely the file will be lost; save space; reduce the risk of damage to records for stored
digitally; facilitate the sharing (sharing) records; improving security; easy data recovery.
According to Joe Weller (Oct 2017) Keeping good records helps companies protect
An effective records management system can save money on storage and improve an
organization's efficiency. Implement a solid records management plan before it's too late.
According to Joe Weller (Aug 2018) document management systems are now far
more efficient and scalable. More than 90 percent of DMS solutions today are cloud-based,
meaning they are more secure, global, and accessible. These cloud-based solutions are
typically paid, though there are also free and open-source options. All document
management systems are designed so that an individual can create, modify, view, and store
documents. Users can also share documents with colleagues, supervisors, and clients, and
set permissions so that only certain people can perform certain functions on a document or
modify them.
Even though the cost and effort of implementing such a system is high, an EDMS
helps the organization to achieve more efficient operations by reducing transaction costs,
However, the high failure rates of EDMS implementation have prompted both academics
and practitioners to try to understand and pinpoint the critical factors that affect the success
of this type of project. (Johnston & Bowen, 2005; Kain & Koshy, 2013)
According to (Iron Mountain Inc. of 2019), "Align your Records and Information
Management and Governance Programs with firm strategic priorities to gain competitive
advantage". First, is to reduce your Real Estate Footprint. By re-purposing the records
space and moving records offsite, you can: Enhance Efficiencies, mitigate risks and
improve records accessibility and re-purpose space for collaboration areas. Second, is to
defensibly destroy legal records. By defensibly destroying records, you can: drive cost
savings, reduce risk and be compliant. Lastly, is to enable digital transformation. These
services enable you to: Improve agility with better access and use of information, increase
efficiency with streamlined processes and manage information growth and scale on-
demand.
Shepherd and Bearman (2016) indicate that electronic records and data are usually
easy to delete and can be very easy to amend or update. The literature also indicates that
both the survival and the readability of records can easily be endangered in the electronic
environment. Thus, designing and building systems that ensure the survival, accessibility,
availability, and integrity of electronic records is a challenge that every record keeper and
organization needs to meet. There are security concerns when it comes to management of
electronic records. Shepherd and Bearman (2016) stated that electronic records depend on
technology for their generation, access and use over time and that they should be protected
intentional alteration.
Maintaining the security of electronic records over time is a big challenge to many
governments. According to the Cook, T., (2010), the manipulable nature of electronic
records means that, in the absence of appropriate safeguards, it is relatively easy to alter or
records.
Wato and Lekaukau (2012) have argued that technological developments have
allowed easy access to records and caution records managers to take the necessary
measures to maintain the safety of electronic records. As Thibodeau (2012) explains, one
of the difficulties of electronic record keeping is the ease with which electronic records can
be changed or deleted, hence the need for an electronic archive system to be designed to
recordkeeping systems. McLeod and Hare (2015) argue that without a high-level security
easily be deleted or changed at any time. With IT there is potential for an ever-expanding
access to the entire information process involved in the conduct of business. This creates
Rothenberg (2015) pointed out that there is also a danger that electronic records are
electronic records can become inaccessible. Hardware and software rapidly become
obsolete, which makes it difficult to maintain electronic records over time. Skelton (2010)
also discusses technological obsolescence when he states that records created using IT
technologies do become unreadable. Keakopa warns that technology can become outdated
According to Keakopa (2017) when the equipment becomes outdated, it is a threat to the
security of the records. It is also argued by Ngulube and Tafor (2006) that losing electronic
records is common and is one of the most feared situations. Hence there is need to provide
appropriate security controls in order to manage the electronic records and also as a means
. Duranti (2009) reported that electronic records are far more vulnerable than paper
records and must be carefully managed to ensure their accuracy and authenticity as proof
of accountability and that the term preservation as applied to electronic records no longer
refers to the protection of the medium of the records, but to that of their meaning and
trustworthiness as records.
Keakopa (2017) agrees with Bearman (2017) that the long-term preservation of
explains that long-term preservation of electronic records is one of the unresolved problems
associated with the impact of technology on recordkeeping. The major concern is, as Cook
(2010) put it, 'If electronic records exist as virtual documents, how does an institution
preserve evidence of and provide accountability of specific transactions?' This raises the
question as to how the electronic records are stored and maintained in the UPS.
World Bank (2016) notes that the rapid rate of technological change also means
that the hardware and software have to be upgraded constantly to ensure continuing use of
the electronic records. Reading and understanding information in electronic form requires
equipment and software, which is constantly changing. This raises the need for strategies
to maintain access to ERMS. Umi et al., (2009) argues that one of these is migration, where
it is possible to move an electronic record from one system to another while maintaining
the records' authenticity, integrity, reliability and usability. However, migration to give
maximum protection against loss of information comes at a cost. The cost of migrating
records is seen as far exceeding the resources of archival institutions especially in the
national archive has a significant implication for ERMS. The national archives often
provide guidelines to help agencies with how records can be identified, accessed, disposed
of, or transferred to new systems should their required retention extend beyond the system's
life in which they were originally created or stored. In order to ensure that electronic
records are properly managed, the national archives provide advice on ERMS. They define
the responsibilities of government agencies to organize, protect, provide access to, and
properly dispose of their records, including the transfer of non-current records with
value usually depends on cooperation between state agencies and the national archives
Yusuf and Chell (2018) indicate that the lack of trained records managers and
archivists affects the work practices related to electronic records management. User
education and training provide a solid foundation for managing electronic records, but it is
lacking in most of the developing countries. Yusuf and Chell (2018) argued that there is
sometimes no standard approach to the ERMS training, which affects the quality of the
services provided.
Barata, Cain and Thurston (2009) also advance the argument highlighting the
problem of training. They note that ERMS training and education is lacking in most
developing countries and hence a need for ongoing training and awareness raising about
the role of electronic recordkeeping within an organization. They also suggest that both the
keepers and users of records require more understanding of the value of records to improve
their organizations' economy and efficiency. Katuu (2013), in his analysis of education and
training of record practitioners in African countries indicated that little had been done in
terms of education and training specifically for ERMS, despite the push for electronic
government in many of the countries he surveyed. He even revealed that the records
managers and archivists were not thoroughly trained to function in the modern information
era, as ERMS requires specialized knowledge of computers and related technology which
Related Studies
named BlueDoc wherein the users the system has the capability of adding new categories
of documents and assigning additional information for some purposed. Another existing
similar system is the Doccept. This system has an audit trail and a function where
format. This system will help the organization retrieve their files easily. Having an
Electronic Document Management System (EDMS) has many advantages. In the current
Issuance System stated that this study focuses on the records management system of the
said Barangay. The Barangay treasurer/secretary is the one who performs permits,
certificates transactions community tax, business taxes, and other fees. They are also in
charge of keeping tracks of the records, capture and maintain up-to-date records of all
issuance transactions and daily, monthly, yearly reports. They manually handled
transactions daily; specially get Barangay clearance, certification, cedula and permits.
Before the accomplishment of the task the constituents who request must undergo a long
process. Same through with storing of files, updating, accessing of data and recording the
expenses, they used folders and log of papers for its storage. The staff encountered
carried out on management of records in Kenya, none of these studies has focused on MER
government in Kenya.
The study investigated how MER supported e-government in Kenya with a view to
objectives of the study were to: ascertain current status of MER in government ministries
government.
appropriate for use of barangay employees, who have access to profile information of
barangay residents for the direct reports. Moreover, departmental organizational staffs
which have a business need for this information for their business unit can also benefit.
This is responsible for an effective and efficient approach for barangay employees and
residents. It will help them accomplish tasks faster and would also eliminate the need of a
Anderson (2015), notes that health care provider ensures competent service
provision and proper health information management to keep costs down, secure patient
data, and maintain compliance in rapidly expanding regulatory environment. This means
that hospitals determine the priorities rolled by the record management policy. The role of
the health record manager is to develop policies for health records management and
procedures in order to promote better health records management practice in the hospitals
as working together with heads of departments. The major sources of health records in
General Hospital Minna, are from the hospital’s admissions office and the attending
physicians. The source and the process of creation of the records are vital since the two
determine the value of that record and its usability. Entries will be made in all inpatient,
outpatient, and service treatment, dental and occupational health records by the healthcare
provider who observes, treats, or cares for the patient at the time of observation, treatment,
or care. This documentation requirement applies to both electronic and paper records.
Based on the above-mentioned shortfalls faced by hospitals, this project focuses on the
availability of digital record management system, the degree of application as well as the
metropolis.
Polat (2016) stated that applying an EDMS for university is very important. In term
of security, most of the papers have not mentioned any specific technique to provide a
security level for the system. The proposed EDMS system in this study differs from the
other EDMS systems since various security levels have been applied. This system uses
digital signature besides the basic authorization technique that asks for a username and
password in order to login to the system. Every user that has manager permission should
use a digital signature in order to send files to other departments. The digital signature is
applied by using a hardware that contains username, password and serial of the hardware.
When a manager tries to send a document, the system checks the hardware as well as the
be accessed twenty four hours through EDMS’s web-based infrastructure. The developed
system can be accessed from inside-outside of the university using any mobile device
which has internet access such as PC, laptop, tablet. However, security for documents in
the system has not been provided and digital signature is recommended. This lack of
security has been solved as a part of the application developed for polytechnic institution
records of the University of Miami has been caused by the hurricane. He stated that this
led the organization to find a way to improve their system and to create a backup of all
their records. The solution they came up with is to implement an electronic document
management system. Now then no longer have to avail 400 square feet of space just for
them to store all the document they have collected. Like what was stated by P.A. Emalia
experiences difficulties in tracking and searching for specific files, but when the University
of Miami have implemented the electronic document management system, searching and
tracking became easy because they no longer have to search row after row of vertical and
The completed research, studies, systems, and articles presented above gave the
researcher insights, facts, and adequate information that will serve as the basis, guide, and
reference relevant and necessary for the development of the project entitled Online Records
The related studies on the development, web content management system, web
application, and design guidelines provide details and evidence that guide the researcher
The literature review was used to support additional materials to assist the
researchers in developing the Online Records and Documents Management System in PHP
and MYSQL.
The researchers found out some insufficiency and drawbacks that the researcher
want to fulfill. According to old studies and system, it doesn’t have a page that will benefits
concluded to have a homepage section that will open to the residence of Zambales for their
needs such as disaster emergency update, directory and for them to seek information and
documents.
The proposed Online Records and Documents Management is an online system that
promotes paperless transactions. In this study, the researchers are promoting less paper use,
and through this system, the files can be secured information. The system can be applied
to PDRRMO and MDRRMO. Unlike manual systems, Online Records and Documents
Management System can help provide the needed information more conveniently. The
system can provide updated records and reports fast but an easier way to help the
organization lessen the loss of data, reduce the work of the staff and ensure the security of
files. Lastly, by the use of online records management system they can quickly find and
METHODOLOGY
This chapter presents the research design in conducting this study. It includes the
research method used, procedure and technique, population and sampling, the data
gathering instrument, and the appropriate statistical treatment of data in gathering data in
Research Method
Descriptive method was used in this study as the questionnaire checklist in the main
tool in the gathering data. The researchers employed various data gathering procedures
purport to present facts concerning the nature of anything – a group of persons, a number
Van Dalen Mayer as cited by Pascua (1993) stated that the researchers used descriptive
method of research when they depict current status and sometimes identify relationships
that exists among phenomena or tends that appear to be developing occasionally, when
software development, where demands and solutions evolve through the collaborative
Agile principles are all about satisfying the client and the continually develop
software, changing requirements are embraced for the client's competitive advantage,
on the shortest possible time span, developers, and business people must work together
throughout the entire project, projects must be based on people who are motivated, give
them the proper environment and the support that they need. Agile processes will
1. Scope out and prioritize projects. During the first step of the agile software
development life cycle, the team scopes out and prioritizes projects. Some
teams may work on more than one project at the same time depending on the
department's organization.
For each concept, you should define the business opportunity and determine the time and
work it'll take to complete the project. Based on this Information, you can assess technical
2. Diagram requirements for the initial sprint. Once you have identified the
clearly show when certain work needs to be completed for the duration of the
sprint.
designers and developers begin work on their first iteration of the project, with
the goal of having a working product to launch at the end of the sprint.
Remember the product will undergo various rounds of revisions, so his first
iteration might only include the bare minimum functionality. The team can and
4. Release the iteration into production. You're nearly ready to release your
product into the word. Finish up this software iteration with the following steps:
Test the system. Your quality assurance (QA) team should test functionality,
Finalize system and user documentation. Lucidchart can help you visualize your
understands how the system functions and how they can build upon it further.
5. Production and ongoing support for the software release. This phase
involves ongoing support for the software release. In other words, your team
should keep the system running smoothly and show users how to use it. The
production phase ends when support has ended or when the release is planned
for retirement.
6. Retirement. During the retirement phase, you remove the system release from
production, typically when you want to replace a system with a new release or
model.
Research Locale
The study was conducted at the Provincial Disaster Risk Reduction and Management
Office (PDRRMO) Iba, Zambales. The respondents were the employees of the
Zambales who are the main client of the Online Records and Documents Management
System.
Figure 4.
Vicinity Map of Provincial Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Office
(PDRRMO) Iba, Zambales
Management Office (PDRRMO) Iba, Zambales, and thirteen (13) Municipal Disaster Risk
Reduction and Management Office (MDRRMO) who evaluated the proposed Online
simply because they are convenient sources of data researchers (Battaglia, 2013). A
convenience sample is simply one in which the researcher uses any subjects that are
The Instruments
The researchers used interviews and questionnaire to establish the profile of the
The first part of the questionnaire dealt with the respondent's profile. The second
part of the questionnaire covers the respondent's evaluation in terms of system quality using
portability. And was about the proposed Online Records and Documents Management
System in terms of content, accuracy, ease of use timeliness and security. Appropriate
Data gathering was done with the used of the survey questionnaire. Before the
administers the questionnaires to the respondents from their thesis adviser. A letter asking
permission to conduct a survey was address to the administrator or Provincial Disaster Risk
Reduction and Management Office (PDRRMO) Iba, Zambales. Upon approval, the
questionnaires were distributed among the respondents. The system was shown and tested
Statistical Treatment
The statistical tools used in analysis and interpretation of data include the
following:
P=f/n x 100
Where: P= Percentage
f = frequency
2. Weighted Mean. This was utilized to determine the average of the perceptions of
which include content, accuracy, ease of use, timeliness and security. The formula
is:
Xw = ∑f(x)/n
Where: Xw = weigthed mean
f = frequency
3. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). This was used to test the significance of the
difference among several means or to test the hypothesis that several independent
4. Interpretation of Data.
Likert Scale Method. It was used to provide data interpretation on the level of
Table 1
Table 2
Likert Scale Use to interpret the level of acceptability