SWM in Bangladesh
SWM in Bangladesh
Tarannum Dana a
a
Department of Population Science, Social Science Faculty, University of Dhaka, Bangladesh.
a
Corresponding author: [email protected]
Abstract: Hospital waste is infectious and hazardous community level clinics and about 1449 outdoor health
which poses serious threats to environmental health and facilities at Union level that falls under DGHS [1]. From
requires specific treatment and management prior to its the same study it was also found that at district level
final disposal. Appropriate and safe management of there are about 117 hospitals that are currently
healthcare waste is acknowledged globally. WHO and functioning [1]. Among the private hospitals there are
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have about 2501 registered hospitals and 5122 registered
emphasised the need to handle and dispose of hospital diagnostic centre throughout the country [1]. In addition
waste from the healthcare establishments in proper there are many clinics, including about 5000
ways. City Corporations are responsible for solid waste government and NGO run clinics, and doctor’s
management in the country. However the collection of chambers where health care waste is generated. In
the waste is often irregular, leading to unsanitary Dhaka City alone there are about 1200 hospitals, clinics
conditions near the primary collection points. Many and diagnostic centres [2]. According to Dhaka City
towns do not have the capacity to collect all the waste, Corporation (DCC) research report, waste generated per
and often proper sanitary disposal is problematic. In person per day is about 0.5kg. In the same report it was
Bangladesh hospital waste management is growing with identified that 3700 metric tons of wastes are generated
an ever-increasing number of hospitals, clinics, and per day in Dhaka City, of which about 200 tons are
diagnostic laboratories especially in Dhaka City. Thus hospital waste and 40 tons are infectious waste [3]. The
healthcare waste management is neglected and it falls amount is increasing every day, with rising number of
under the auspices of the local municipal bodies which medical establishments where wastes are not managed
are responsible for the collection, removal and disposal properly. The fact that knowledge on the means of
of different kinds of wastes from public places. This segregating hazardous and non-hazardous waste is low,
paper aims to discover and understand the current it is difficult to secure proper information upgrading the
situation of healthcare waste management that includes actual amount of waste that is generated every day. In
waste handling, collection and disposal as well as the different countries World Health Organisation (WHO)
knowledge and awareness level of individuals involved and Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) have
in healthcare. Furthermore, the paper also explores emphasized the need to handle and dispose medical
alternative options for the management of hospital wastes in properly. In Bangladesh hospital waste
wastes that is environmentally friendly. Research on this management which falls under the auspices of the
critical issue has been very limited, and there is a municipal bodies is being neglected. The Municipal
serious shortage of information which is essentials for authorities are responsible for the collection, removal
strategic for planning. and disposal of different kinds of medical wastes from
public places to the dumping grounds; naturally
Keywords: collection, disposal, hospital waste,
standing they are not efficiently handling the matter.
management, segregation, treatment
Until recently, the management of medical wastes
INTRODUCTION received little attention despite their potential
environmental hazards and public health risks. The
Non- Hazardous
Waste (80-85%)
Non-sharps
Hazardous Waste Liquid
(15-20%)
Chemicals &
Pharmaceuticals
Non-infectious waste
Infectious waste
Source: WHO, 2001, [5]
The composition of medical wastes varies from country the quantities produced. The minor sources are scattered
to country even within a country as it depends on the that produces similar kinds of waste as major sources
type of health services they are providing to the people. but these waste does not contain radioactive wastes, no
The following table 1 [6] shows the wastes that are human body parts and among the sharps they consist
commonly found in all the hospitals all over the world. mainly of hypodermic needles [7]. An attempt has been
made to demonstrate the sources below in figure 2:
Sources of Medical Waste: The sources of medical
waste can be grouped as major and minor according to
Tarannum Dana / OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development 02:09 (2011) 31
Effects of Medical Waste Respiratory infectious (c) Urinary tract infection (d)
Skin infection (e) Meningitis (f) Viral Hepatitis A, B
The poor management of medical wastes is an obvious
and C (g) Tetanus
risk to people and the environment as they contains
infectious agents, genotoxic materials, toxic or There are numerous other diseases, which could be
hazardous chemicals or pharmaceuticals and sharps transmitted by contact with health-care wastes. The
microorganisms, which enter the human body via a hazardous nature of hospital waste may be due to one or
number of ways and cause diseases. These risks have so more of the characteristics that cause health risk in
far been poorly investigated. Waste and by-products can different ways shown in figure 3 [9]. There are many
also cause injuries, for example radiation burns or people who are at risk directly and indirectly as they
sharp-inflicted injuries; poisoning and pollution, come in to contact with the medical waste while
whether through the release of pharmaceutical products, handling the waste. The public may also come in to
in particular, antibiotics and cytotoxic drugs, through contact as they are thrown in to open places or carried
the waste water or by toxic elements or compounds such environment by air and water. In this process of medical
as mercury or dioxins [8]. The common diseases waste management the people who are at risk are shown
connected are: (a) Gastroenteric infectious (b) in figure 4 [10].
32 Tarannum Dana / OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development 02:09 (2011)
Occupational risk Risk to the public Indirect risks via the environment
During handling of wastes, health- The reuse of syringes by the general In addition to risks from direct contact with
care personnel and waste workers public represents one of the greatest health-care waste, waste can also
may come in contact with waste-if public health problems in the contaminate the environment, such as the
it hasn’t been packaged safely. developing world related to health- water or the air and so indirectly impact on
Many injuries occur because care waste. Worldwide, an estimated health.
syringe needles or other sharps 10 to 20 million infections of Hepatitis
B and C and HIV occur annually from When wastes are disposed of in a pit that is
have not been collected in safety
the reuse of discarded syringe needles not lined, the groundwater may become
boxes, or because these have been
without prior sterilisation. contaminated. As the same groundwater may
overfilled. Also, contact with other
If health-care waste is dumped on un- be used as a resource for drinking water,
infectious waste that has not been
controlled sites or in other areas, wastes may indirectly impact on health via
packaged or treated adequately
which the public, the public, can the water. If waste is burned or incinerated in
may cause a risk. On landfills or
access, and in particular children can an incinerator, which does not have an
waste dumps, waste recyclers or
come in contact with infectious emission control (which is the case with the
scavengers may come in contact
wastes. Also the contact with toxic majority of incinerators in developing
with infectious wastes if the waste
chemicals, such as disinfectants, may countries), the air may become contaminated
has been disposed of without prior
cause accidents when they are by a large number of pollutants and cause
treatment.
accessible to the public. serious illness in people who inhale this air.
Doctors, nurses,
health-care
auxiliaries
Patients in health- Hospital
care maintenance
establishments personnel
Persons at risk
House
Sewerage
Keeping Used plastic and glass, IV
Recycling bottles infusion sets, sharps,
Pathology & (at source) syringes are sold to third party
Laboratory
Disinfecting
Sewerage Sewerage
Activities
Manually transported
Transportation No safety precautions
Air pollution
Toxic ash
Municipal Disposal
Site Open Burning Municipality /
Recycling of waste by waste pickers
Tokai (Waste Unsafe disposal
pickers) Unaesthetic conditions
Odour nuisance
Ground water pollution
Tarannum Dana / OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development 02:09 (2011) 35
There are only three NGOs in Bangladesh that are the guideline in both public and private hospitals/clinics.
actively working in the field of hospital waste Out of reasons for not being able to implement it
management. These NGOs are PRISM (Project in successfully is that authorities and owner of
Agriculture, Rural Industry, Science and Medicine) hospitals/clinics are not aware of the effects on the
Bangladesh in Dhaka city, BASA in Tongi and environment and people. They also lack interest and all
Shawpno in Bagura. They are collecting the waste from not bothered to improve or update their disposal
the hospitals with a nominal service charge. Among the methods as there is a cost involved. Thus there are only
three NGOs, PRISM Bangladesh along with DCC is few people who are aware of the issue but they are
properly collecting and treating the hospital waste up to outnumbered for which they cannot take any steps to
final disposal. There are only 342 hospitals, clinics and improve the situation. Moreover the staffs who are
diagnostic centres under PRISM Hospital waste handling wastes are illiterate and results have little
management programme (In conversation with PRISM). knowledge about the impact. In private hospitals/clinics
Rest of the healthcare institutions follow their own or the nurses dispose of wastes according to the
old system. The following figure 6 shows existing waste management instruction of the hospital. As a result the
management practice in some health care establishments staffs are not aware and responsible for executing the
organised by PRISM Bangladesh [16]: proper way in which of hospital waste should be
discarded. Institutions that are aware are don’t have
Majority of the hospitals, clinics and diagnostic centres
proper management system and guidelines. On the other
in the country do not have any waste management
hand the actual problems observed in both public and
treatment plant nor do they give proper attention to the
private hospitals/clinics and diagnostic centres are: (a)
problem of hospital waste management. Till today, all
No alternative methods for safe disposal (b) No system
the hospitals discharge their liquid pharmaceutical and
for segregating the waste before disposal (c) No specific
chemical waste into the general sewers or drains
regular awareness programme among all staff (d) No
because none of them have any proper liquid waste
protection for waste handlers, which are often infectious
management system. Liquid waste is mainly generated
and potentially dangerous (e) No specific training
from patients' service units, operation and surgical units,
program for the nurses and cleaners regarding waste
laboratories and other health-care units. As a result, the
handling, disposal or management.
water bodies in Bangladesh are being polluted by the
liquid wastes. The hospital waste management practices somehow
have not been given appropriate attention and
WASTE MANAGEMENT FAILURE
importance in Bangladesh for which it has not been
Hospital waste management in Bangladesh needs to be successful in achieving better medical waste
stressed as it is causing serious damage to both our management. Other problems include: (a) Lack of
health and environment. Despite having a hospital waste implementation of guideline (b) Existing gaps within the
management pocket book since 2008, the government waste management rule 2008 (c) Problem in
has not been successful to ensure the implementation of Environmental Act 1995 (d) Lack of interest and unity
36 Tarannum Dana / OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development 02:09 (2011)
No sense of
responsibility
Lack of
awareness of
health risk
Insufficient
national policy
and regulations Uncontrolled
scavenging
Lack of Inadequate waste
political system
commitment Insufficient
allocation of
resources Blood-borne
infections
Inadequate
protection of
Lack of workers
evidence for
certain Insufficient access
subgroups to information Effects from
Inadequate exposure to
training of staff or toxic
waste workers Reuse of pollutants
disposables
Poverty
Lack of safe low
cost options
Step 6-Bag filling Step 5-Fixed collection schedule Step 4-Different locations for black and yellow waste
To avoid any sorts of splitting that may cause There should be schedules for collection of wastes bags
injuries therefore it should the bags and containers and at least once a day from each department. There Both types of waste collecting bags needs to be placed in
should be filled up to three quarter should be different times to collect different types of separate location that will reinforce the importance of
wastes to avoid mis separating the waste in the point of generation.
Step 12-Central storage points Step11-Internal transport Step 10-Trollyeys and bag holders
In the central storage point places should be marked While the different types of wastes are transferred to All the trolleys, bags and containers holders should be
where the black and yellow waste bags/container should the temporary storage areas it should not be carried either black or yellow. If that is not possible in some
be placed before it is went off –site. In the summer it together as there could be a chance of waste mixture cases then clear signs should be in placed to identify the
should be collected every 24 hours and in winter it is 48 in the same trolley. wastes properly.
hours
Step 13-Highly infectious wastes Step 14-Other Hazardous health-care wastes Step 15-Traning
Highly infectious should be first autoclaved after Other five types of hazardous waste handling are not The waste management system in a hospital should be
that it should be put into the yellow bags. covered by these procedures. clearly set out in a waste management plan. All the staffs
should be well award if necessary new members and staffs
should be trained for better outcomes.
Tarannum Dana / OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development 02:09 (2011) 39
(e) Tax the polluter- implement “polluter pays” However the waste management guidelines on
principle hospital should include the following
recommendations for effective hospital waste
Along with these we also develop a in-house
management system: (a) More emphasis should be on
management plan for all healthcare establishments.
waste segregation at the source by introducing
The hospital, clinic, diagnostic centres and other
different colour code bags or containers that will help
healthcare institutions must have a separate
proper channelling of the hospital waste. (b) Hospital
department for managing the medical waste. This
Authority should provide proper disposal site for the
department will be responsible for arranging create
time being before any system developed (c) The City
awareness, training, do regular monitoring and
Corporation should take initiatives for regional waste
evaluate the system for updates. An attempt has been
treatment plan by providing places for medical waste
made in by identifying activities in figure 8 to
dumping (d) The government needs to upgrade the
develop a step by step approach for medical waste
waste disposal system and consider the international
management department.
principles as their guideline for better practice in
Currently increased interest on improper disposal of hospital waste management. (e) Strict law policy
medical waste has led to a movement to regulate the should be made and future plans of waste
medical waste more scientifically. We should try to management should emphasis on waste tracking
minimize and recycle some of medical wastes before system. (f) Implement polluter pays principle where
final disposal, if it is not infected or contaminated. hospital should be pay for their wastes. (g) More
Similar plan like PRISM could be used in medical private companies should be encouraged to come
waste treatment until which will be cheaper and forward and take initiative to manage the medical
effective. Emission of toxic substances from any wastes (h) The authority should have proper system
healthcare establishment should be closely monitored for recycling of hospital waste and removal, (i) Build
to reduce potential risks to humans and the strong communication across the Ministry of family
surrounding environment. Achieving a good standard Welfare, Ministry of Environment, City Corporation
of cleanliness in health-care institutions is an Local authorities and NGOs should communicate for
important component in controlling the better waste management.
infection.However at present there are practically no
CONCLUSION
environmentally friendly, low-cost options for safe
disposal of infectious hospital wastes. More research Hospitals in Bangladesh pose significant threat to
needs to be carried on hospital waste for better health and environment on account of inadequate
management of waste that will have less impact on waste management need to raise awareness and
the health of the human beings who are at risk. provide educational training on medical waste
management. Proper waste management policy is
RECOMMENDATION ON MEDICAL WASTE
required to ensure health and environmental safety
MANAGEMENT
and it is recommended that simple changes in policy
Firstly we need to develop a national policy for safe and support from government and private sectors
health-care waste management Along with the policy would bring innovative changes in healthcare waste
we also need to keep in mind that in a country like management. However the healthcare waste
Bangladesh where the waste handlers are illiterate, management guideline, planning and policy should
the hospital/clinical waste procedure should be very be under the shadow of legislation, emphasis should
simple. The national policies should include the be given in the development of educational training
following issue: (a) The government should be wade programme, record keeping, monitoring, review of
accountable. (b) Development of an enforcement existing situation and there should be collaboration
mechanism (c) Setting of practical targets or between inter ministerial, hospital authorities, and
objectives over a specified time period (d) active participation from the community.
Establishment of a national and regional
Indeed a good number of organisations are working
infrastructure for health-care waste disposal (e)
on Health Care Waste Management System. As such
Support of regional and municipal authorities in
the situation has improved considerably in some part
implementation (f) Integration of waste minimization
of Dhaka only but we are far frome appreciation for
into national purchasing policies (g) Routine
the responsibility of medical doctors and
monitoring of impact through process indicators
management with respect to hospital waste. Now the
(number of health-care establishments with safe
task is for government to formulate appropriate
waste management systems) and outcome indicators
policy with a manual that needs to be followed by all
(e.g. number of accidents involving health- care
the hospitals, clinics and diagnostic centres in
waste).
Bangladesh. Then, through training and guidance
supported by DGHS and private (training) NGOs, the
40 Tarannum Dana / OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development 02:09 (2011)