lOMoARcPSD|9293410

Workshop 7 Answers

Inroduction to Investments (University of Auckland)

StuDocu is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university

Downloaded by Lindinkosi Mdluli ([email protected])
 lOMoARcPSD|9293410

Finance 261 Workshop 7

Answers

1. Distinguish among the following performance measures:

a) Sharpe ratio
b) Treynor measure
c) Jensen’s alpha

i) Describe how each of the three performance measures is calculated.

ii) State whether each measure assumes that the relevant risk is systematic, unsystematic,
or total. Explain how each measure relates excess return and the relevant risk.

Answer:
i) The Sharpe ratio is calculated by dividing the portfolio risk premium (actual portfolio
return minus risk-free return) by the portfolio standard deviation.
The Treynor ratio is calculated by dividing the portfolio risk premium (actual
portfolio return minus risk-free return) by the portfolio beta.
Jensen’s alpha is calculated by subtracting the market risk premium, adjusted for risk
by the portfolio’s beta, from the actual portfolio excess return (risk premium). It is the
difference in return earned by the portfolio compared to the return implied by the
CAPM or SML.
ii) The Sharpe ratio assumes that the relevant risk is total risk, and it measures excess
return per unit of total risk.
The Treynor measure assumes that the relevant risk is systematic risk, and it measures
excess return per unit of systematic risk.
Jensen’s alpha assumes that the relevant risk is systematic risk, and it measures excess
return at a given level of systematic risk.

2. The finance committee of an endowment has decided to shift all of its investment in
an index fund to one of two professionally managed portfolios. Upon examination of
past performance, a committee member proposes to choose the portfolio that achieved
a greater alpha value.

a) Do you agree? Why or why not?

No. Alpha alone does not determine which portfolio has a larger Sharpe ratio. Sharpe
measure is the primary factor, since it tells us the real return per unit of risk. We only
invest if the Sharpe measure is higher. The standard deviation of an investment and its
correlation with the benchmark are also important. Thus, positive alpha is not a
sufficient condition for a managed portfolio to offer a higher Sharpe measure than the
passive benchmark

Downloaded by Lindinkosi Mdluli ([email protected])

 lOMoARcPSD|9293410

b) Could a positive alpha be associated with inferior performance? Explain.

Yes. It is possible for a positive alpha to exist, but the Sharpe measure declines in
which case, we would experience inferior performance.

3. Could portfolio A show a higher Sharpe ratio than that of B and at the same time a
lower M2 measure? Explain.

No. The M-squared is an equivalent representation of the Sharpe measure, with the
added difference of providing a risk-adjusted measure of performance that can be
easily interpreted as a differential return relative to a benchmark. Thus, it provides in
a different format the same information as the Sharpe measure.

4. Consider the two (excess return) index-model regression results for stocks A and B.
The risk-free rate over the period was 6%, and the market’s average return was 14%.
Performance is measured using an index model regression on excess returns.

Stock A Stock B
Index model regression 1%+1.2(rM-rf) 2%+0.8(rM-rf)
estimates
R-square 0.576 0.436
SD of excess returns 21.6% 24.9%

Calculate:
a. Jensen’s alpha
b. Sharpe ratio
c. Treynor index

Answer:
Stock A Stock B
Alpha=regression intercept 1% 2%
Sharpe ratio 0.4907 0.3373
=(r-rf)/�
Treynor measure=(r-rf)/β 8.833 10.5

Stock A:
E(r-rf)= 1%+1.2(rM-rf)=1+1.2(14-6)=10.6
Sharpe ratio: E(r-rf)/�=10.6/21.6=0.4907
Treynor measure: = E(r-rf)/β=10.6/1.2=8.833

Stock B:

Downloaded by Lindinkosi Mdluli ([email protected])

 lOMoARcPSD|9293410

E(r-rf)= 2%+0.8(rM-rf)=2+0.8(14-6)=8.4
Sharpe ratio: E(r-rf)/�=8.4/24.9=0.3373
Treynor measure: = E(r-rf)/β=8.4/0.8=10.5

5. Consider the following data for a particular sample period:

Portfolio P Market M

Average return 35% 28%

Beta 1.20 1
Standard deviation 42% 30%
Tracking error 18% 0
(nonsystematic risk, �e)

a) Calculate the following performance measures for portfolio P and the market: Sharpe
ratio, Jensen’s alpha, and Treynor index. The T-bill rate during the period was 6%.

Answer:

( ŕ−ŕ f )
Sharpe:
σ
SRP = (35-6)/42=0.69
SRM = (28-6)/30=0.733

Alpha: ŕ−[ ŕ f +β × ( ŕ M −ŕ f ) ]

aP=35-[6+1.2*(28-6)]=2.6
aM=0 (by definition)

( ŕ−ŕ f )
Treynor:
β
TIP = (35-6)/1.2 =24.2
TIM = (28-6)/1 = 22

b) Calculate the M2 measure.

Answer:
To match 30% standard deviation with P and risk-free, the weight on P is 30/42.

Downloaded by Lindinkosi Mdluli ([email protected])

 lOMoARcPSD|9293410

Hence, the adjusted portfolio is formed by mixing bills and portfolio P with weights
30/42=0.714 in P and 1-0.714=0.286 in bills. The return on this portfolio is
(0.714*35%) + (0.286*6%) =26.7%. This is 1.3% less than the market return.
M2 measure = -1.3
Notice that the negative M2 coincides with P’s Sharpe ratio lower than that of M.

c) Calculate the information ratio.

Answer:
Information ratio = Alpha / Residual standard deviation
IRP = 2.6 / 18 = 0.1444
IRM = 0 (by definition)

6. You obtained the following results when you estimated the security characteristic lines for
stocks A and B:

Stock A: (RA – Rf) = αA + βA (RM - Rf) +eA

Stock B: (RB – Rf) = αB + βB (RM - Rf) +eB
Where RA and RB are returns on Stock A and B, RM is return on the market, Rf is the risk-free
rate that has been constant throughout the sample period, and eA and eB are zero-mean error
terms that are not correlated with anything.

Stock A Stock B

Average return 19% 13%

Return Standard deviation 40% 30%
Alpha 0.00 0.00
Beta 1.40 0.80
R2 0.49 ?

a. What should the (constant) risk-free rate and the average market return have been?

19 - Rf = 1.4×(E[RM] - Rf)
13 - Rf = 0.8×(E[RM] - Rf)

E[RM] = 15%
Rf = 5%

b. What is Stock B’s R2?

Downloaded by Lindinkosi Mdluli ([email protected])

 lOMoARcPSD|9293410

0.49 = 1.42× σM2 / 0.42

σM = 20%
0.82×202 / 302 = 0.2844

c. Compute Stock B’s M2 measure.

5 + (13-5) × 20 / 30 – 15 = -4.67%

d. What is the correlation coefficient between Stock A and B?

1.4×0.8×202 / (40×30) = 0.3733

e. Assuming that the estimates are true descriptions of Stock A and B’s return generating
processes, calculate the smallest standard deviation one can get by forming a portfolio of
Stock A and B.
MV weight on A = (302-1.4×0.8×202)/ (402+302-2×1.4×0.8×202) = 0.2818
MV = 0.28182×402+0.71822×302+2×0.2818×0.7182×1.4×0.8×202 = 772.63
Minimum SD = 27.80%

Downloaded by Lindinkosi Mdluli ([email protected])