Geometric Considerations in Anterior
Geometric Considerations in Anterior
AHMAD
10
While aesthetics is traditionally regarded as an artistic point of origin from which modifications can be devel- 7
concept, quantifiable scientific principles are used in its oped. In dental aesthetics this starting point is the law of
SEPTEMBER
development. Dental aesthetics are governed by mathe- nature. The clinician should commence with a knowledge
matical parameters that, when applied by the clinician of the geometry that nature uses to determine anterior
and laboratory technician, can achieve restorations with dental aesthetics. The four elements that contribute to ante-
a unique aesthetic appearance. These geometric laws rior aesthetics are the facial, dentofacial, dental, and gin-
should not be viewed as immutable, but as useful guide- gival compositions. This article presents a discussion of
lines for the fabrication sequence. This article demon- these principles as they relate to the achievement of aes-
strates a series of geometric principles for the anterior thetic maxillary anterior restorations.
maxillary dentition that can be utilized in the develop-
ment of aesthetic restorations. Facial Composition
The facial composition is the most important element to the
Nasolabial angle
(golden highlights) are eliminated, then the tilting could be caused by a slanted
maxilla. It is vital to determine which factor is responsible
for the misalignment of the incisal plane, as this will have
a profound impact on the proposed treatment plan.
From the sagittal aspect, the horizontal lines also
reinforce the cohesiveness of the profile. The nasolabial
angle (Figure 2) and Rickett’s E-plane must also be con-
sidered in this plane (Figure 3).3 The former is an angle
formed by the intersection of two lines using the nose and
lips as reference points. In males this angle ranges from
Figure 2. The nasolabial angle (golden highlights) is that formed by
90° to 95°; in females it ranges from 100° to 105°.
the intersection of two lines, using the base of the nose and the upper
lip as reference points. Rickett’s E-plane is a line drawn from the tip of the nose
Dentofacial Composition
The second component in anterior dental aesthetics is the
dentofacial composition (ie, orofacial view). The constit-
uents of this element are the oral orifice, the highly vascu-
larized red lips, and the teeth, which act as a gate to the
oral cavity. The color contrast between the lips and the
teeth of the patient also contributes to the dentofacial
composition. The optimal aesthetic appearance of this
view is determined by several factors, including static and
Figure 5. The LARS factor to determine the amount of tooth
exposure at rest: Age — an elderly individual showing dynamic muscular positions.
only the lower incisors.
Static
In the static position, the lips are slightly parted, the teeth
are out of occlusion, and the perioral muscles are relaxed.
In this state, four factors influence tooth exposure: lip
length, age, race, and sex, known as the LARS factor
(Figures 4 through 7).5 The amount of tooth exposure
at rest is predominantly a muscle-determined position
(Table). The length of the upper lips can vary from 10 mm
to 36 mm; individuals with a long upper lip exhibit more
of their mandibular rather than maxillary dentition.
Age is the second component of the LARS factor
which, in a manner similar to lip length, influences the
amount of tooth visibility. The amount of maxillary incisor
Figure 6. The LARS factor to determine the amount of tooth tooth display is inversely proportional to the age of the
exposure at rest: Race — black patients typically reveal patient; alternately, the amount of mandibular incisor dis-
less tooth exposure than white patients.
play is directly proportional to increasing patient age.
People age at differing rates, since aging is a multifac-
to the chin prominence. Accepted norms for the distance torial phenomenon and can be described as programmed,
from the upper lip to this imaginary line is 4 mm, while
that for the lower lip is 2 mm. Using the nasolabial angle
Table
and the measurements of the Rickett’s E-plane, the pro-
trusion or retrusion of the maxilla can be ascertained. Upper Lip Length in Relation to Anterior Tooth Exposure
If the nasolabial angle is less than 90° and the distance Upper lip Exposure of Exposure of
length central upper central lower central
of the upper lip to the E-plane is greater than 4 mm, the Upper Lip incisor (mm) Incisor (mm) incisor (mm)
maxilla is prominent and a convex facial profile results. Short 10 -15 3.92 0.64
In this example, the placement of less dominant maxillary Medium 16 -20 3.44 0.77
anterior restorations should be considered. If a concave Medium 21 -25 2.18 0.98
Long 26 -30 0.93 1.95
profile is present (ie, nasolabial angle is greater than 90°)
Long 31 -36 0.25 2.25
and the distance of the upper lip to the E-plane is less
PPAD 815
Practical Periodontics & AESTHETIC DENTISTRY
Dynamic
The dynamic position of the dentofacial composition is
characterized by the extent of tooth exposure during a
smile, and varies according to the degree of contraction
of the facial muscles, the shape and thickness of the lips,
the skeletal makeup, and the shape and size of the
dental elements. While horizontal symmetry is the most
important factor in the facial composition, it is radiating
symmetry that takes precedence in the dentofacial view.
The latter can be defined as an object having a central
point from which the right and left sides are mirror images.1
The fulcrum in this view is the maxillary dental midline, Figure 9. It is not necessary for the facial midline (red) to coincide
with the maxillary dental midline (yellow) to achieve aesthetic
from which the right and left maxillary anterior teeth should approval. The blue is the commissural line.
PPAD 817
Practical Periodontics & AESTHETIC DENTISTRY
Dental Composition
Golden
The dental composition consists of the dental elements Proportion
proper: the size, shape, and intra- and interarch rela- Golden Proportion
Formula:
tionships require evaluation. Tooth size is determined by S L 2
— = —— = —— = 0.618
measuring the incisogingival length and dividing it by its L S+L 1+ 5
PPAD 819
Practical Periodontics & AESTHETIC DENTISTRY
Figure 19. Correct angulation of the maxillary teeth that Figure 22. Up to 3 mm of gingival exposure (white line) is
contact with the mucosal part of the lower lip during the f aesthetically acceptable during a smile. The green line
and v sounds of speech. represents the incisal plane.
Gingival Composition
Figure 20. Inflammation of gingival margin around defec- Gingival contour follows the underlying bone architec-
tive crown on tooth #8(11) masking the gingival margin ture; a scalloped contour is associated with close root
zenith.
proximity, while a shallow appearance is evidence of
divergent roots and/or diastemata. The gingival zenith
is the most apical aspect of the free gingival margin and
is located distally for the maxillary central incisor and
canine to the long axis of the tooth. The gingival zenith
for the lateral incisors is in a direct line to the long axis
of the tooth. This zenith can be compromised by poor
dentistry (Figure 20), but can be reestablished by replac-
ing the defective restoration (Figure 21).
Extension of the free gingival margin in an apical
manner from the contact point to the attached gingiva
forms the interdental papilla. Following recession or
periodontal/iatrogenic insult, the gingival embrasures
become visible and form “black triangles.” Numerous
Figure 21. The gingival margin zenith (distal to the long
techniques for the preservation and restoration of the inter-
axis of the central) is apparent following replacement of the
defective crown on tooth #8(11) (compare with Figure 20). dental papilla have been described,17-19 and the clinician
GAL Angle
GAL Angle >45˚<90˚
GAL
Figure 23. Definition of the Gingival Aesthetic Line (GAL) Figure 24. GAL Class I. Note the position of the lateral
and GAL Angle. incisor in relation to the GAL.
guided tissue regeneration techniques; overeruption by Figure 25. GAL Class II. In this circumstance, the lateral
orthodontic intrusion; deficient pontic sites by ridge aug- incisor often overlaps the central incisor.
PPAD 821
Practical Periodontics & AESTHETIC DENTISTRY
Conclusion
The study of aesthetics is a combination of the numerical
and psychological aspects of beauty. Dental aesthetics
are realized by the adoption of a schematic approach,
giving due consideration to the facial, dentofacial, den-
tal, and gingival compositions. The fundamental geo-
metric laws of aesthetics and the patients’ desires must
Figure 27. GAL Class IV exhibits a lack of ordered gingival
contour progression from the central incisors to the canines. be considered before arriving at a definitive aesthetic
treatment plan. The prescription, while conforming to the
laws of nature, should also try to incorporate the creative
and artistic skills of the clinician and technician. The com-
pleted work should be unique and bear the signature of
the operators, and not merely be a facsimile based on
dogmatic principles.
References
1. Rufenacht CR, Fundamentals of Esthetics. Carol Stream, IL:
Quintessence Publishing; 1990:1-20.
2. Chiche GJ, Pinault A. Esthetics of Anterior Fixed Prosthodontics.
Carol Stream, IL: Quintessence Publishing; 1994:1-15.
3. Levin JB. Esthetic diagnosis. Curr Opin Cosm Dent 1995;3:9-17.
4. Spear F. Facially generated treatment planning: A restorative
viewpoint. American Academy of Esthetic Dentistry, 16th Annual
Meeting, Santa Barbara, CA; August 8, 1991.
5. Vig RG, Brundo GC. The kinetics of anterior tooth display.
Figure 28. Two classes of GAL are often apparent in a J Prosthet Dent 1972;39:502-504.
single mouth: the right side of the patient shows a 6. Heartwell CM Jr. Syllabus of Complete Dentures. Philadelphia,
GAL Class I, while on the left a Class II is evident. PA: Lea & Febiger, 1968.
7. Dental Office Procedures, Swissedent Foundation, CA; 1990.
8. Miller EL, Bodden WR Jr., Jamison HC. A study of the relationship
of the dental midline to the facial median line. J Prosthet Dent
2 mm) the GAL and its mesial part overlaps 1979;41:657-660.
the distal aspect of the central incisor. This situ- 9. Levin EI. Dental esthetics and the golden proportion. J Prosthet Dent
1978;40:244-252.
ation is often observed in Class II angles or 10. House MM, Loop JL. Forum and Colour Harmony in the Dental
Art. Whittier, CA: MM House, 1939.
pseudo-Class II conditions, and adds variety 11. Williams JL. A new classification of human tooth forms with a
special reference to a new system of artificial teeth. Dent Cosmos
to the dental composition (Figure 25). 1914;56:627.
• Class III — The GAL angle equals 90°, and 12. Frush JP, Fisher RD. How dentinogenic restorations interpret the
sex factor. J Prosthet Dent 1956;6:160-172.
the canine, lateral, and central all lie below 13. Frush JP, Fisher RD. How dentogenics interprets the personality
factor. J Prosthet Dent 1956;6:441-449.
the GAL (Figure 26). 14. Frush JP, Fisher RD. The age factor in dentogenics. J Prosthet Dent
1957;7:5-13.
• Class IV — The gingival contour cannot be 15. Lombardi RE. The principles of visual perception and their clini-
assigned to the aforementioned classes. The cal application to dental esthetics. J Prosthet Dent 1973;29(4):
358-382.
GAL angle can be acute or obtuse. A myriad 16. Woelfel JB. Dental Anatomy: Its Relevance to Dentistry, 4th ed.
Philadelphia, PA: Lea & Febiger, 1990.
of conditions cause gingival asymmetries, 17. Beagle JR. Surgical reconstruction of the interdental papilla: Case
report. Int J Periodont Rest Dent 1992;12(2):145-151.
including recession, altered patterns of erup-
18. Lie T. Periodontal surgery for the maxillary anterior area. Int J
tion, loss of interdental papillae, clefts, and Periodont Rest Dent 1992;12(1):73-82.
19. Allen P. Use of mucogingival surgical procedures to enhance
high frenal insertions (Figure 27). esthetics. Dent Clin North Am 1988;32(2):307.
To submit your CE Exercise answers, please use the answer sheet found within the CE Editorial Section of this issue and
complete as follows: 1) Identify the article; 2) Place an X in the appropriate box for each question of each exercise; 3) Clip
answer sheet from the page and mail it to the CE Department at Montage Media Corporation. For further instructions,
please refer to the CE Editorial Section.
The 10 multiple-choice questions for this Continuing Education (CE) exercise are based on the article “Geometric consid-
erations in anterior dental aesthetics: Restorative principles” by Irfan Ahmad, BDS. This article is on Pages 813-822.
Learning Objectives:
This article reviews the geometric guidelines that comprise the fundamental elements of facial composition and proper
anterior aesthetics. Upon reading and completing this article, the reader should have:
• An understanding of the scientific principles used to develop aesthetic restorations.
• An improved ability to develop treatment plans that address varying clinical conditions.
1. Which of the following facial reference lines act 6. Which of the following decides the morphology
as a segregative force in the facial composition? of the teeth?
a. Interpupillary line. a. Gender.
b. Interalar line. b. Personality.
c. Midline. c. Shape of face.
d. Hairline. d. Heredity.
2. Which facial line is used to determine the 7. In the author’s opinion, which of the following
angulation of the incisal plane? should be used to finalize the tooth-to-tooth
a. Commissural line. width progression from the central to canine?
b. Hairline. a. Golden Proportion ratio of 0.618.
c. Ophiach line. b. Beautiful Proportion ratio of 0.577.
d. Interpupillary line. c. A ratio of 0.75.
d. None of the above.
3. The nasolabial angle is used to assess the
prominence of: 8. Which of the following buccolingual thicknesses
a. The mandible. of a central incisor may require adjunctive
b. The maxilla. endodontic therapy to achieve optimal aesthetics?
c. The nose. a. 3.5 mm or less.
d. The chin. b. 3.3 mm or less.
c. 2.8 mm or less.
4. The LARS factor is used to finalize: d. 2.5 mm or less.
a. Tooth exposure during a smile.
b. Tooth exposure at rest. 9. The zenith of the gingival margin for the
c. The mandibular incisor width. maxillary lateral incisor is:
d. The maxillary incisor width. a. In line with the long axis of the tooth.
b. Distal to the long axis of the tooth.
5. During a smile, which factor causes the most c. Mesial to the long axis of the tooth.
aesthetic reprisal? d. In line with the horizontal axis of the tooth.
a. Maxillary dental midline is not coincident
with the facial midline. 10. Which of the following GAL angles is aesthetically
b. Maxillary dental midline is not coincident acceptable?
with the mandibular midline. a. 30° to 44°.
c. Incisal edges of maxillary teeth do not b. 45° to 90°.
coincide with lower lip curvature. c. 90° to 110°.
d. Lack of radiating symmetry. d. Greater than 110°.