Cartography.

MOOC

Exercise
Thematic Mapping

Section 3 Exercise 4
January 20, 2021
 Cartography. MOOC

Thematic Mapping

Instructions
Use this guide and ArcGIS Pro to reproduce the results of the exercise on your own.
Note: The version of ArcGIS Pro that you are using for this course may produce slightly
different results from the screen shots that you see in the course materials.

Time to complete
Approximately 50-60 minutes

Software requirements
ArcGIS Pro 2.7
ArcGIS Pro Standard license (or higher)
Note: The MOOC provides a separate ArcGIS account (user name and password) that you
will need to use to license ArcGIS Pro and access other software applications used
throughout the MOOC exercises. This account (user name ending with _cart) provides the
appropriate ArcGIS Online role, ArcGIS Pro license, ArcGIS Pro extensions, and credits.
We strongly recommend that you use the provided course ArcGIS account to ensure that
you have the appropriate licensing to complete the exercises. Exercises may require
credits. Using the provided course ArcGIS account ensures that you do not consume your
organization's credits. Esri is not responsible for any credits consumed if you use a different
account. Moreover, Esri will not provide technical support to students who use a different
account.

Introduction
Special purpose maps, as opposed to general reference maps, are termed "thematic maps."
These maps tend to display a single theme of information by indicating the spatial distribution
of a single attribute or the relationship among many attributes. Thematic maps illustrate the
structural characteristics of the geographical distribution of a dataset.
Thematic maps vary considerably, but examples include maps depicting precipitation,
population distribution, hurricane incidence, and pollution. Thematic maps tend to be small
scale (showing a large area, which is expressed as a small representative fraction) because the
geographical distribution of a theme is often most appropriately shown and accurately
depicted over a large area.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 1

 Cartography. MOOC

Thematic mapping requires the transfer of empirical measurements into graphical signs that
can be mapped to illustrate the spatial variation in the difference between measured values.
Essentially, aspatial, tabular data is converted into a spatial form that, by definition, adds
further to the information by giving the map reader the distance, direction, shape, and
location of the theme. In a thematic map, the transformation of data from tabular to map form
adds spatial understanding.
In this exercise, you will develop a range of alternative thematic maps that tell a story of the
2015 general election in the United Kingdom. To see various types of thematic maps, you
should look at the ArcGIS Online thematic mapping gallery (https://bit.ly/2GQhgC6), which
shows a range of different ways of mapping the 2016 U.S. presidential election and includes
discussions of the map type and use.
For your reference, the project package includes a map view containing the final maps for this
exercise. Your final maps may not match exactly. You are encouraged to experiment with the
options available in ArcGIS Pro.

Step 1: Download the exercise data file

In this step, you will download the exercise data file.

a Open a new web browser tab or window.

b Go to https://bit.ly/2xh6IfE and download the exercise data file.

Note: The complete URL to the exercise data file is https://www.arcgis.com/home/
item.html?id=61e08fd43fe6415289ac67c757e31ce9. The file is 14 MB.

c Save the file in a location that you will remember.

Step 2: Open an ArcGIS Pro project

You will open the exercise project in ArcGIS Pro to get started.

a Start ArcGIS Pro and, if necessary, sign in using your provided course ArcGIS credentials
(user name ending with _cart).

b From the main ArcGIS Pro start page, click Open Another Project.

c Browse to the location where you saved the exercise data file and open the
ThematicMapping.ppkx project package.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 2

 Cartography. MOOC

The project opens with a map showing electoral constituencies for the 2015 UK Election.

d Save your project with a name such as ThematicMapping_<your first and last
name>.aprx in the folder on your computer where you are saving your work.
This dataset is the same one that you used in the Section 2 exercise Exploring Data for
Classification, so you should be familiar with its general contents. From that exercise, you will
also use data classification concepts to process some of this data for mapping.
A single layer in the Contents pane shows the electoral constituencies of Great Britain and
Northern Ireland. Additionally, a version of the data represents the election results as points,
each in the center of the constituency. Whether you use the area or point version of the data
depends on the map type, which is addressed later in this exercise.

Step 3: Explore the election data

If you completed the Exploring Data for Classification exercise in Section 2, you are already
familiar with the UK election data. This exercise uses the same dataset.

a Right-click the Constituencies layer and choose Attribute Table to review the fields and
their contents to refamiliarize yourself with the data.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 3

 Cartography. MOOC

The layer attribute table contains a number of fields, which are described in the following
table:

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 4

 Cartography. MOOC

Field name Description

ID Alphanumeric code used to identify individual constituencies
Constituency The name of the constituency
Headline The result of the election showing which political party won and by how
much
Winning_MP The name of the winning member of Parliament who represents the winning
political party
First Abbreviated name of the winning political party in that constituency
First_Votes The number of votes for the winning political party in that constituency
First_Share The overall share of votes for the winning political party in that constituency
(largest share wins)
Second Abbreviated name of the political party that came second in that
constituency
Second_Votes The number of votes for the political party that came second in that
constituency
Second_Share The overall share of votes for the party that came second in that constituency
Third Abbreviated name of the political party that came third in that constituency
Third_Votes The number of votes for the political party that came third in that
constituency.
Third_Share The overall share of votes for the party that came third in that constituency
Other_Votes The number of votes for all other political parties combined in that
constituency
Other_Share The overall share of votes for all other political parties combined in that
constituency
Turnout The number of people who actually voted in the constituency
Electorate The total number of eligible voters in the constituency
First_code A numeric code that can be used to reference the winning political party

b When you are finished exploring the data, close the attribute table.
First, you will make a simple thematic map showing the winning political party in each
constituency.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 5

 Cartography. MOOC

Step 4: Create a unique values map

The purpose of a unique values thematic map is to show how areas differ in type.

a In the Contents pane, turn off the Constituency Points layer.

b Right-click the Constituencies layer and choose Symbology to open the Symbology pane.

c In the Symbology pane, from the Primary Symbology drop-down list, choose Unique
Values.

d For Field 1, choose First.

Note: The colors are assigned automatically, so the colors on your map may be different than
the ones in the preceding graphic.
This data is a text field that identifies the abbreviation of the political party that won that
constituency. The result is a basic, descriptive map of the result of the election.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 6

 Cartography. MOOC

Default colors and labels rarely make an elegant map (as you can hopefully see). First, you will
update the labels to make them more meaningful.
Note: You can dock the Symbology pane next to your map by right-clicking the pane title and
choosing Dock. To auto hide the Symbology pane, click the Auto-Hide button at the top
of the pane.

e If necessary, at the bottom of the Symbology pane, scroll to the right to view the Label
column in the grid.
Note: Alternatively, you can make the Symbology pane larger by dragging its border.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 7

 Cartography. MOOC

f Under the Label column, double-click each label and change it to the appropriate political
party label, as shown in the following table.

Value Label
CON Conservative
DUP Democratic Unionist Party
GRN Green
IND Independent
LAB Labour
LD Liberal Democrats
Other Other
PC Plaid Cymru
SDLP Social Democratic and Labour Party
SF Sinn Fein
SNP Scottish National Party
UKIP UK Independence Party
UUP Ulster Unionist Party

The party names are now updated in the Contents pane. Remember, it is vital that your map
reader can interpret the map, and the way that data is stored is often not in an immediately
recognizable form.
It is useful to make use of sensible symbology to reinforce the map's message. For instance,
for this dataset, the default uses randomly selected colors, yet political parties have their own
color schemes. This project comes preconfigured with a style file of colors that are ready to
use, but you can always use a color picker to change them to what you prefer.
Next, you will change the colors for each of the political parties to match their party color
from the Political Colours style file.

g In the Contents pane (not the Symbology pane), right-click the color chip for Conservative
to open the color picker.

h In the color picker, in the Political Colours group, click the blue Conservative color.
Hint: Point to a color chip to see its name.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 8

 Cartography. MOOC

i Repeat this process to assign party colors based on the party name.
When you are finished, the symbols for the parties should look like the following graphic:

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 9

 Cartography. MOOC

j In the Symbology pane, click More and uncheck the box next to Show All Other Values.
You will also change the color of the outline of each symbol so it better matches the
basemap. It is always worth remembering that changing the outline of your area symbols is
often as important as the fill color itself. Sometimes, you may even make the outline
transparent or with a width of 0 pt to make it disappear, which can give a very nice effect and
avoid a lot of lines getting in the way.

k In the Symbology pane, click More and choose Format All Symbols.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 10

 Cartography. MOOC

l In the Format Polygon Symbols pane, from the Properties tab, change the outline color to
Gray 80% to better match the dark gray basemap.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 11

 Cartography. MOOC

m Click Apply.

n Close the Symbology pane to view the unique values map.

Your final unique values political color map should look like the following graphic.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 12

 Cartography. MOOC

o Zoom and pan the map to explore how this thematic map effectively shows the winning
political party in each area using a unique value (winning party) symbolized by the political
party color.
Much better than the default, right?

p When you are finished exploring, save your project.

Step 5: Create a choropleth map

Unique value maps show us one aspect of the political data that you are mapping, but there is
so much more that you can explore and map using alternative techniques.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 13

 Cartography. MOOC

You will now make a simple graduated colors (choropleth) map to show the share of votes that
the winning member of Parliament (MP) received. This data is in the First_Share field in the
Constituencies layer attribute table.

You will use a copy of the Constituencies layer.

a In the Contents pane, right-click the Constituencies layer and choose Copy.

b Right-click the UK Election 2015 map item and choose Paste.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 14

 Cartography. MOOC

The Contents pane now shows two layers named Constituencies.

c Rename the layer that you just created to Winning share of vote - choropleth.

d Turn off the Constituencies layer.

You will now work on the copy.

e Open the Symbology pane for the Winning Share Of Vote - Choropleth layer, and then
update the primary symbology to Graduated Colors.
Graduated colors are used to symbolize the layer by quantities. In this case, the quantity is the
percentage or share of votes that the winner received.

f For Field, choose First_Share.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 15

 Cartography. MOOC

Do you recall from the Section 2 exercise Exploring Data for Classification that you cannot use
a choropleth map to map totals? You are fine here, however, because you are mapping data
that has already been normalized by converting the raw totals to percentages.
Your final choropleth map should resemble the following graphic.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 16

 Cartography. MOOC

You now have a default choropleth map showing the share of the vote received by the
winning MP classified into five classes using the natural breaks method. Lower values are
shown in lighter colors (a lighter hue), and higher values are shown in a darker color (a darker
hue).
Challenge: Experiment with data classification and colors
In this optional challenge, create a map that shows enough variation to effectively represent
the results. With too few classes, the map will be too general. With too many classes, the map
will be too complicated. A good guide is four, five, or six classes.
Hint: Refer to the Section 2 exercise Exploring Data for Classification for a reminder of the
data classification options. You can also refer to ArcGIS Pro Help for more information about
data classification options (https://bit.ly/2qnFLzl).

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 17

 Cartography. MOOC

You can use your default choropleth map (make a copy of the Winning Share Of Vote -
Choropleth layer and name the new layer something like Choropleth - challenge) to
experiment with the following:

• Different classification types (available in the Symbology pane from the Method drop-
down list)
• Number of classes (available in the Symbology pane from the Classes drop-down list)
• Color schemes (available in the Symbology pane from the Color Scheme drop-down
list)

For a choropleth map, the best way to represent data that varies from high to low is to use a
color scheme that visually reflects that. A single-hue color scheme works well. A spectral color
scheme does not work well because there is no intuitive way to determine whether one hue is
"higher" or "lower" than the other. This issue is referred to as the classic "rainbow color
problem."

• Set the border (outline) color.

You could also remove the border.

• In the Symbology pane, in the Label section, change the way that the labels appear to
remove the trailing zeros and clean up the legend.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 18

 Cartography. MOOC

You could change the style so that you have an upper and lower label such as 0-40%, 41-50%,
and so on. Avoid overlapping classes (where you use the same label at the higher end of one
class and the lower end of the next class).

Step 6: Create a value-by-alpha map

This type of thematic map mutes the less important areas, making them fade into the
background and bringing focus to the key areas. A value-by-alpha map is a type of area-
based thematic map, such as a unique values map or a choropleth map. A value-by-alpha
map has two layers. The layer below is the standard unique values map or choropleth map.
The layer above has area shading that varies from transparent to opaque to encode a
secondary variable.
For a political map, like the one that you are working with, areas are somewhat arbitrary and
show the simple metric of who won. But you can create nuances by adding information, such
as the proportion of voters in the area or the turnout.
In ArcGIS Pro, a group layer contains multiple individual layers and can help you organize
related kinds of layers. Because there will be two layers in the value-by-alpha map, you will
use a group layer.

a In the Contents pane, verify that the Constituencies layer is turned off and turn off the
Winning Share Of Vote - Choropleth layer.

b If you completed the challenge at the end of the previous step, also turn off that layer.

c Right-click the UK Election 2015 map item and choose New Group Layer.

d Rename the group layer Value-by-Alpha.

e Make a copy of the Constituencies layer (symbolized using unique values).

f In the Value-By-Alpha group layer, paste two copies of the Constituencies layer.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 19

 Cartography. MOOC

g If necessary, turn on the upper Constituencies layer.

h Rename the upper Constituencies layer Turnout.

i Right-click the Turnout layer and choose Symbology to open the Symbology pane.

j For Primary Symbology, choose Graduated Colors and update the Field to Turnout.

k For Color Scheme, choose the White To Black gradient color scheme.
Note: If you do not see the White To Black gradient color scheme, you may need to click the
Color Scheme down arrow and check the box for Show All.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 20

 Cartography. MOOC

l In the Symbology pane, next to Color Scheme, click the down arrow and choose Format
Color Scheme.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 21

 Cartography. MOOC

m In the Color Scheme Editor, change the black color chip to be 100% transparent.
Hint: Click Color and choose No Color.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 22

 Cartography. MOOC

n Click OK to update the color scheme.

The idea is to make high values (high turnout) completely transparent and low values (low
turnout) more opaque.
Now you have built the value-by-alpha overlay.

o If necessary, in the Contents pane, in the Value-By-Alpha group layer, turn on the
Constituencies layer.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 23

 Cartography. MOOC

For a well-balanced result, you can use the various controls in the Symbology pane to adjust
how the white-transparent color ramp stretches across the data values.
The map brings into focus constituencies that had higher turnouts. The top layer in the group
effectively mutes areas where there were lower turnouts. This useful technique can show how
two related pieces of data interact with one another.

p Save your project.

Step 7: Create a graduated-symbol map

Graduated-symbol maps allow you to use totals directly on the map without first converting
data into ratios or percentages. Instead of using colors or shades of color that you process
and see as "more or less" across the map, a graduated-symbol map uses size of symbols to
communicate the relative difference between quantities. Larger symbols mean more, and
smaller symbols mean less.
For this step, you will use the point-based data because you are going to change a single
symbol in size that represents the area for which the data has been collected.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 24

 Cartography. MOOC

a In the Contents pane, turn off all layers except the Constituency Points layer and the Dark
Gray Canvas basemap layer.

b Open the Symbology pane for the Constituency Points layer.

c Change the symbology type to Graduated Symbols and use First_Votes as the field to
symbolize.

The default classification is Natural Breaks (Jenks) using five classes. Every data value falls into
one of these symbol classes.

d Using the Symbology pane, experiment with changing the color fill, outline, and sizes of
the symbols.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 25

 Cartography. MOOC

One of the challenges with any symbol-based map is congestion in parts of the map.
Balancing the symbol size with the appearance of the overall map is a good goal to keep in
mind. Transparent symbols with a solid outline can sometimes work, so include those in your
experimentation.
Also, notice how as you zoom in and out of the map, the symbols remain the same size at
which you designed them; as you zoom in to a larger map scale, your overlapping symbols
tend to become separated from one another. This useful feature of a multiscale mapping
environment counteracts the problems of seeing overcrowded symbols at smaller scales.
If you prefer that your symbols stay at their relative size as you zoom in and out, you can
achieve this result by setting a reference scale (https://bit.ly/34RkIsV).

e In the Contents pane, right-click the UK Election 2015 map item and choose Set
Reference Scale.

f Right-click the Constituency Points (the layer symbolized with graduated symbols) layer
and choose Properties.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 26

 Cartography. MOOC

g In the Layer Properties dialog box, from the Display tab, ensure that the Scale Symbols
When A Reference Scale Is Set box is checked.

h Click OK, and then zoom and pan the map to see the result of changing the reference
scale settings.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 27

 Cartography. MOOC

Effectively, this setting freezes the symbol sizes at the scale at which the reference scale was
set. As you zoom in and out, they become larger and smaller while maintaining their relative
size to the map and each other symbol.

i Clear the reference scale by right-clicking the UK Election 2015 map item and choosing
Clear Reference Scale.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 28

 Cartography. MOOC

Clearing the reference scale will take you back to the default for the next step in this exercise.

j Save your project.

Step 8: Create a proportional-symbol map

Another type of thematic map, the proportional-symbol map, can show how features differ in
quantity for the theme being mapped. It is a variation on the graduated-symbol map but
scales all symbols independently of any classification method.

a In the Contents pane, make a copy of the Constituency Points layer.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 29

 Cartography. MOOC

b Right-click the UK Election 2015 map item and choose Paste.

c Rename the new Constituency Points layer Proportional Symbols.

d Turn off the original Constituency Points layer.

Now you will change the symbology type.

e Open the Symbology pane for the Proportional Symbols layer.

f Update the symbology type to Proportional Symbols.

g Zoom in to more clearly see the proportional symbols.

Note: Refer to ArcGIS Pro Help to learn more about varying symbology by size and graduated
symbols and proportional symbols (https://bit.ly/2JwLVGd).

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 30

 Cartography. MOOC

h Use the First_Votes field as the field to symbolize again or experiment with other fields.
In this map, the data value is scaled to the symbol size, so each symbol on the map is a
proportional representation of the data. Every value of data is represented uniquely, so this
map type shows much more variation in symbol sizes than a graduated-symbol map.

i Experiment with the scaling settings and symbol design to achieve a nice visual balance.
You are trying to achieve a balance where there is enough variation in size across the map to
show highs and lows in the data but without symbols becoming either too large and
dominating or too small and difficult to see. It is not a perfect science, and experimentation is
important to go back and forth until you feel like you have captured the optimum settings for
the dataset at hand. Importantly, ask yourself what you want the map to tell the reader. The
answer to this question should help you consider whether your scaling settings and symbol
design have met that goal.
One final aspect to scaling settings to consider is whether you need all your symbols to be
scaled uniquely. In the histogram view of the Symbology pane for this layer, you can move the
sliders to change the way scaling is applied.

j Move the top slider (lowest-level data value) down, as shown in the following graphic.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 31

 Cartography. MOOC

Updating the slider will lead to all data values below the threshold that you set being shown
at the same size. It can be useful to highlight variation at one end of the data array, or
conversely, if you have outliers (https://bit.ly/2VIciQC) or many data values of an extremely
small or large size, you can cluster them together and show them (and them only) with a
symbol of the same size.

k Zoom in to view of the final proportional symbols thematic map based on the First_Votes
field values.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 32

 Cartography. MOOC

Now you will modify the symbol color to make each of your symbols in a single layer
represent more than one data item using attribute-driven symbology. Taking the Proportional
Symbols map that you just made, you will make it multivariate.

Step 9: Create a multivariate proportional-symbol map

The proportional symbol map showed the number of votes that the winner in each
constituency polled. However, the color is the same for every symbol. The map might tell a
more interesting story if the symbols were also colored like the unique values map to
additionally show the winning party by their political color. For this step, you will use attribute-
driven symbology.
Note: For more information about attribute-driven symbology (https://bit.ly/2Hk2JTo), refer to
ArcGIS Pro help.
Because attribute-driven symbology works on numeric fields in the attribute table, you will use
a column called First_code rather than First.
The First_code column references the political parties as shown in the following graphic:

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 33

 Cartography. MOOC

a In the Contents pane, make a copy of your Proportional Symbols layer.

b Paste the copy in the UK Election 2015 map item, and then rename it Multivariate
Proportional Symbol.

c Turn off the original Proportional Symbols layer.

d At the top of the Symbology pane for the Multivariate Proportional Symbol layer, click the
Vary Symbology By Attribute button .

e Expand the Color section.

f For Field, choose First_code.

g For Color Scheme, click the down arrow and check the box for Show Names.

h Select the UK Political Parties Discrete color scheme.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 34

 Cartography. MOOC

This color scheme has been added to the project for you to make symbolizing easier. It is a
discrete color scheme that simply matches color stops to the codes used for each political
party.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 35

 Cartography. MOOC

Now you have a proportional-symbol map with size related to total number of votes for the
winning party and color representing the party itself.

i Zoom and pan the map to explore the proportional symbols.

The addition of more sensible colors really helps to communicate the patterns more
meaningfully.

j When you are finished exploring, save your project.

Step 10: Create a dot-density map

One drawback of the choropleth map is the way in which the different-sized areas take on
different visual prominence. In short, large areas are seen as more important than smaller
ones. The oddity of geography is that most people tend to live in dense urban areas
represented by small administrative units. Sparse populations live in much larger units, so the
problem of understanding the real situation is confounded by geography itself.
Look back at the unique values or choropleth maps that you made in previous steps. You can
easily see the large expanse of yellow in Scotland, which is relatively sparsely populated. Now
zoom in to the London area (that is a test for those not familiar with where London is in the
UK!) and see all those much smaller constituencies. The value-by-alpha technique helped

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 36

 Cartography. MOOC

mute sparsely populated constituencies in Scotland a bit, but when viewed at a small scale
(zoomed out), those smaller constituencies in London are still hard to see by comparison. And
you have seen how using differently sized symbols (graduated or proportional symbols rather
than choropleth fills) helps overcome some of those drawbacks—though large symbol
overlaps can also compromise the map.
Another alternative thematic mapping technique is dot density, which uses small dots to
represent some value of the data to create a patterned fill. Multiple dots are used to reflect
the total value.

a In the Contents pane, make a copy of the Winning Share Of Vote - Choropleth layer that
you made earlier and paste it in the UK Election 2015 map item.

b Rename the new layer Dot Density.

c Turn off all layers except the Dot Density layer and the Dark Gray Canvas basemap layer.

d In the Contents pane, ensure that the Dot Density layer is selected.

e In the Symbology pane, update the symbology type to Dot Density.

The map is still using the values from the First_Votes field, which is the number of votes
gained by the winning party.

f Set the Dot Size to 2 pt and the Dot Value to 2000.

A single dot is positioned randomly, in every area, for every 2,000 votes for the winning party.
You can begin to see the distribution of the voting population now with dense and sparse
areas being made visible simply through the mapping technique. The visually dominant colors
of the larger geographical areas in the choropleths are, to some extent, overcome with this
technique.
Challenge: Change the symbol to a point that does not have an outline.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 37

 Cartography. MOOC

g Experiment with changing the dot value to 1000 (people).

h Try some other values for both the dot size and dot value.
A good dot-density map has a balance between a dot size that is visible and a dot value that
creates a map where the dense areas have coalescing dots but which are not simply a large
splotch.
You will also remove the background line from the area because it gets in the way of this sort
of map.

i In the Symbology pane, click the Background symbol.

j On the Properties tab, set the Outline Color to No Color, make the Outline Width 0 pt,
and click Apply.
This update improves the overall appearance. Without the administrative borders, the map
takes on a smoother appearance.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 38

 Cartography. MOOC

k Save your project.

Step 11: Create a multivariate dot-density map

At the moment, all dots are the same color. You will improve the map a little further by
creating a version where the dots are the same color as the political party, like you did for the
proportional symbol map. First, you will make a few copies of the data.

a Create a new group layer and name it Multivariate Dot Density.

b Copy the Dot Density layer and paste it into the Multivariate Dot Density group layer.

c Paste four more copies of the Dot Density layer into the Multivariate Dot Density group
layer so that you have a total of five layers.

d Turn off the original Dot Density layer.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 39

 Cartography. MOOC

e In the Multivariate Dot Density group layer, rename the first Dot Density layer
Conservatives.
Next, you will use a definition query to set the dot colors to the political party colors.

f Double-click the Conservatives layer to open the layer properties and click the Definition
Query tab.

g Click New Definition Query and build the following clause: Where First Is Equal To
CON.

h Click Apply, and then click OK.

i In the Symbology pane for the Conservatives layer, in the Symbol column, click the box
next to First_Votes to open the Format Point Symbol pane.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 40

 Cartography. MOOC

j Change the dot's color to the Conservative blue and click Apply.
Note: Because there are so many dots on the map, it may take some time for the map to
redraw.
Now you have a map with only the partial dataset shown.

k Repeat the previous steps for the second Dot Density layer, using the following
information:

• Name: Labour (and turn on the layer, if necessary)

• Definition query: Where First Is Equal To LAB
• Dot color: Labour red

l Use the same approach to specify definition queries and symbol colors for two additional
layers—one each for the SNP (Scottish National Party) and LD (Liberal Democrats) parties.

m Finally, for the fifth Dot Density layer, specify a definition query that has four clauses:

• Where First Is Not Equal To CON

• And First Is Not Equal To LAB
• And First Is Not Equal To SNP
• And First Is Not Equal To LD

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 41

 Cartography. MOOC

This captures all other constituencies that have not been shown by the other layers in this
group.

n Rename the fifth Dot Density layer Other, and then symbolize it with the light gray
Independent/Other color.
Now you have an overall effect where dot density is colored by the winning political party.
You could create a separate layer for every party if you wish, though sometimes a map is far
clearer if you remove some of the detail. Here, you are showing the predominant parties and
removing a bit of visual noise by grouping every other constituency as Other.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 42

 Cartography. MOOC

o When you are finished, close the Symbology pane.

p Save your project.

q If you are continuing to the stretch goal, leave ArcGIS Pro open; otherwise, exit ArcGIS
Pro.

Conclusion
You have designed a range of different thematic maps that each show the data in different
ways. Along the way, you have learned about the differences between area-based thematic
maps and point-based thematic maps. You have applied some of the ideas that were covered
in Section 2 Exercise 2 for classifying data, and you have explored ways to design and modify
symbology.
There are other types of thematic maps that you can create in ArcGIS Pro. To explore some
additional thematic maps, click the Final Maps map tab. Examine each of the thematic maps
and experiment with their settings.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 43

 Cartography. MOOC

Ultimately, there is never a perfect thematic map, but making sure that your data
classification, map type, and symbology work in harmony will help make your choices make
sense for your map reader.

Stretch Goal: Make a Jackson Pollock-inspired map

The Jackson Pollock (https://bit.ly/1PF2EqC) inspired map is an artistic method of
representing thematic data. It is a little unusual, but it demonstrates what you can achieve
with a little lateral thinking, working with symbol layers, and attribute-driven symbology.
Before starting this stretch goal, take a look at the final Jackson Pollock map in the Final Maps
map view.
Hint: At the top of the map view, next to the UK Election 2015 map tab, click the Final Maps
tab, and then in the Contents pane, turn on the Jackson Pollock layer.

The map is covered in apparently randomly positioned paint splats. Actually, there are four
paint splats per constituency. They represent the winning political party, the runners-up, the

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 44

 Cartography. MOOC

third-place party, and a final symbol that represents the remaining candidates. But what else is
going on? Symbols are different sizes, so they are proportional to reflect the number of votes.
They are different colors, so they represent the political party colors. The symbols are
randomly rotated to create a more organic appearance. There is quite a lot going on here, so
you will slowly work your way through how it is constructed.
The tasks in this stretch goal are intentionally high-level. Use what you have learned in this
exercise to create your Jackson Pollock-inspired map. Pour yourself a cup of coffee or
tea—this will take a bit of effort.

Step 1: Create map layers

First, you will create the map layers.

a In the UK Election 2015 map view, in the Contents pane, turn off all layers except the
Dark Gray Canvas basemap.
Again, you will use a point feature class of the election data to create a group layer.

b Right-click the UK Election 2015 map item and create a new group layer named Jackson
Pollock.

c Make a copy of the original Constituency Points layer, and then in the Jackson Pollock
group layer, paste four copies.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 45

 Cartography. MOOC

d Rename the Constituency Points layers, starting with the first layer, as follows:

• Others
• Third place
• Second place
• First place

The order is important because you are going to have four layers showing at once, and you
want the larger symbols at the bottom of the stack (the winners) with the others (second place
and so on) atop. If you positioned these in the reverse order, the larger symbols would
occlude those underneath.

Step 2: Assign and scale picture marker symbols

Next, you will assign picture marker symbols for the paint splats and use an Arcade Expression
(https://bit.ly/2n9T6JP) to scale them proportionally.

a In the Contents pane, for the First Place layer, open the Symbology pane.

b Update the Primary Symbology to Unique Values and for Field 1, choose First.
You will assign picture marker symbols from the preloaded electionsplat style (located in the
Format Point Symbol pane under Gallery) to each point symbol so that each party has the
correctly colored paint splat. The paint splats will be quite large initially; you will scale them
after they are loaded.

c Near the bottom of the Symbology pane, for each symbol in the grid, click the point
symbol, and then in the Format Point Symbol pane, on the Gallery tab, using the same
colors as before, choose the appropriate paint splat symbol for that value from the
electionsplat collection.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 46

 Cartography. MOOC

Note: On the Gallery tab, click once on the paint splat symbol to choose it, and then click the
Back arrow to return to the Symbology pane. Because the initial paint splats are quite
large, you may need to scroll down in the grid at the bottom of the Symbology pane.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 47

 Cartography. MOOC

d Use the following table for assistance, if necessary.

Party Party name Color splat picture marker symbol

CON Conservative

DUP Democratic Unionist Party

GRN Green

IND Independent

LAB Labour

LD Liberal Democrats

Other Other

PC Plaid Cymru

SDLP Social Democratic and Labour Party

SF Sinn Fein

SNP Scottish National Party

UKIP UK Independence Party

UUP Ulster Unionist Party

Now you will vary the symbol size by an attribute to turn them into proportionally scaled paint
splats.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 48

 Cartography. MOOC

e In the Symbology pane, click the Vary Symbology by Attribute button .

f Expand Size.
You will now define a size based on the square root of the total votes received by the winning
candidate (which is how proportional symbols are calculated to ensure that the area of a
symbol relates to the value being mapped).

g To the right of the Field drop-down list, click the Set An Expression button .

h In the Expression Builder dialog box, ensure that Language is set to Arcade.

i In the Functions list, double-click Sqrt().

j In the Expression field, click between the parentheses.

k In the Fields list, double-click First_Votes to insert it into the expression.

l You should end up with an expression that reads Sqrt($feature.First_Votes), as

shown in the following graphic.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 49

 Cartography. MOOC

m Validate your expression and click OK.

All symbols are now resized proportionally to the data value.

n In the Contents pane, turn on the First Place layer and zoom in to see the symbols on the
map.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 50

 Cartography. MOOC

You will notice a problem. All the symbols are on the large side, so you can add a constant to
the equation to scale them all larger or smaller.

o Update the expression to add a scaling constant, such as

Sqrt($feature.First_Votes)*0.3, to reduce all the symbols by a factor of 70 percent.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 51

 Cartography. MOOC

p Click OK.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 52

 Cartography. MOOC

You now have a map of the winning parties for each constituency with a proportionally scaled
paint splat symbol. This looks good, but the symbols all look a little regular and overlap one
another.

Step 3: Refine symbol appearance and position

You will add symbol rotation and use transparency to create a better result.

a To add rotation to the symbols, in the Symbology pane, ensure that you are still on the
Vary Symbology By Attribute tab.

b Collapse Size, and then expand Rotation.

c For Field, choose <random>.

d Expand Transparency, and then for Field, choose First_Share.

This modifies the symbols by scaling the range of data values across a transparency range so
that the overlaps appear like mixed paint. You can experiment with the controls to achieve a
result that you like. The random rotation makes the symbols appear irregular, a bit more like,
well … paint!

e Zoom and pan the map to see the variation.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 53

 Cartography. MOOC

You have changed transparency at the symbol level, but you can also change the transparency
of the whole layer.

f In the Contents pane, ensure that the First Place layer is selected.

g On the ribbon, from the Appearance tab, in the Effects group, in the Transparency field
type 14.0%.

h When you are finished, close the Symbology pane.

Now you will apply the same approach to the other three layers to add the results for the
second-place party, third-place party, and others data in the dataset. Instead of repeating the
steps, you will use a shortcut.

i In the Contents pane, in the Jackson Pollock layer group, right-click the First Place layer,
point to Sharing, and choose Save As Layer File.

j Browse to the same location that you saved your exercise data file, name the layer
Pollock_First, and then click Save.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 54

 Cartography. MOOC

The symbology specifications that you just set for the First Place layer are saved to a reusable
file.

k Open the Symbology pane for the Second Place layer, choose Unique Values, and then
specify Second as the field to map.

l At the top of the Symbology pane, click the Menu button and choose Import
Symbology.
The Apply Symbology From Layer tool opens in the Geoprocessing pane.

m In the Geoprocessing pane, for Symbology Layer, click the Browse button .

n Browse to and select the Pollock_First layer file that you saved and click OK.
Note: You can also use an existing layer.

o In the Geoprocessing pane, under Symbology Fields, verify that Type is set to Value Field,
and then set Source Field and Target Field to Second.

p For the Transparency Expression Field section, set Source Field and Target Field to
Second_Share.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 55

 Cartography. MOOC

q Click Run.
At the bottom of the Geoprocessing pane, you should see a successfully completed message.
If you do not, it is likely that you entered something slightly wrong, so go back and check your
work.

The symbology specification is now applied to the Second Place layer.

You might want to adjust the symbology settings for the Second Place layer to modify the
transparency and size. You could make the symbols a little smaller and more transparent than
those of the first layer, for instance. Second place is not nearly as important on the map as
first place, so the Second Place layer symbols should not dominate.

r Repeat the process to apply the symbology from the layer file for the Third Place layer,
again making the symbols a little smaller and more transparent.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 56

 Cartography. MOOC

s For the final layer (Others), use the Symbology pane to create a single symbol, using a
gray paint splat for Other.
Note: Do not forget to scale the gray paint splat.

t In the same way that you applied 14.0% transparency to the First Place layer, change the
overall transparency of the Second Place layer to 39.0%, the Third Place layer to 20.0%,
and the Others layer to 46.0%.
You should end up with a Jackson Pollock-style mix of symbols that quite literally paints a
picture of the mess of the election.

u Save your project and exit ArcGIS Pro.

Copyright © 2021 Esri. All rights reserved. 57