Materials Today: Proceedings 43 (2021) 1246–1252

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Materials Today: Proceedings

journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/matpr

Self healing concrete based on different bacteria: A review

Pavan Kumar Jogi ⇑, T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi
Department of Civil Engineering, Dr.Y.S.R.A.N.U. College of Engineering & Technology, Acharya Nagarjuna University, Nagarjuna Nagar, Guntur Dist, Andhra Pradesh 522510, India

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: This paper discusses a brief explanation of the different properties of bacterial concrete. In concrete,
Received 10 July 2020 micro-cracks are inherently present. This causes concrete degradation due to the introduction of delete-
Received in revised form 10 August 2020 rious substances into concrete, leading to structural deterioration. Because of this concrete need rehabil-
Accepted 31 August 2020
itation. Bio-mineralization techniques yield promising results in concrete sealing of the micro cracks. The
Available online 8 October 2020
freshly composed micro-cracks can be sealed up in concrete through perpetual hydration process.
Microbiological induced calcite precipitation (MICP) method is more popular to resist the cracks in con-
Keywords:
crete. The literature indicates that the method of encapsulation can yield greater outcomes than the
Bacterial Concrete
Self healing Concrete
method of direct application, and also indicates that the use of bacteria will improve the strength and
Bacillus Subtilis toughness of concrete. Calcite precipitation in concrete results from the introduction of urease stimulate
Bacillus Pasteuri bacteria along with calcium source. The ureolytic bacteria that include Bacillus Pasteurii, Bacillus Subtilis
Micro structure that can give rise to urea are incorporated along with the calcium supply to seal Calcium Carbonate
(CaCO3) precipitation from the freshly formed micro cracks. The bacterial concentrations were designed
for improved outcomes for the durability of pore formation in concrete. This Paper mainly discusses
about the self healing concrete since it was invented to present studies of the researchers.
Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Confer-
ence on Advanced Materials Behavior and Characterization.

1. Introduction: tures needed light weight [2–5]. This type of lightweight

collection represent a superior carter for bacteria that improves
Concrete is mainly used building material in the world. For- remedial competence and structural robustness. Bacteria applied
merly it forms cracks in concrete, life span of concrete structures to rice husk ash concrete will improve concrete strength to all ages
may be reduced. There are numerous restoration methods existing due to calcite concrete precipitation. In concrete grade M50 a max-
to patch cracks although they are extremely pricey and protracted imum of 24% can be increased with maximum precipitation of cal-
procedures. There are mild methods for fixing the cracks in con- cium carbonate. The quality of concrete from fly ash may be
crete called self-healing concrete by itself. At the time of mixing, increased by the addition of bacteria Bacillus Pasteurii which also
bacteria with a calcium- lactate base are applied to the concrete. diminish permeability and porosity. It was resulted in an improve-
As several cracks exist in concrete microbes, the precipitation of ment of strength parameters by 22% in an average and a loss in
calcium carbonate [1]. It can clean out whatever occur the gaps standard concrete by 4 times of water absorption. The self-
and also self healing concrete strength will be greater than typical healing approaches recently showed potential consequences in
concrete. A biotechnological system support on calcite precipita- the remediation of cracks in the prior phase of crack development.
tion can amplify the strength and resilience of the structural con- Conversely, precipitation in concrete materials, calcite by hydrogel
crete. Fissure dimension more than 0.8 mm is more complicated encapsulation, tubes, and vascular structures tends to be skilfully
to patch but can recover with calcite precipitation and the use of suited for self-healing in building and science. It illustrates the pos-
bacteria cracks. Lightweight aggregates applied instead of fine sible mechanisms of self-healing, by applying cemented materials
aggregates contribute to a reduced bacterially-dependent mortar to concrete. The bacteria can follow different calcium sources for
strength. The bacterial mortar performance was greater than aver- the precipitation of calcite [6–10].
age inconsequential. This type of systems used, when the struc- Recent advancements like Biotechnology and Nanotechnology
are used to enhance the properties of concrete such as longevity.
The purpose of this work is to analyze the different chattels of
⇑ Corresponding author.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.08.765
2214-7853/Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Conference on Advanced Materials Behavior and Characterization.
P. Kumar Jogi and T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi Materials Today: Proceedings 43 (2021) 1246–1252

specimens of concrete that to diverge in the midst of the accumu- hence its durability is compromised. Therefore, their long-term
lation of bacteria. Furthermore an assortment of kinds of bacteria performance is determined by interaction between concrete and
worn for the precipitation of calcium carbonate in concrete. A good its environment. Water permeation of exposed concrete structures
self-healing device would feel the damage or fractures that can typically impacts longevity and also induces degradation of steel
trigger the healing agent’s release. Self-healing approaches are reinforcement bars. Many cracks are not apparent, so access is
effective ways of rehabilitating concrete micro-cracks. The meth- not possible. Owing to spreading out, retrenchment and infiltration
ods of autogenous healing give successful success of repairing of materials, together size and number of cracks are growing.
micro-cracks on concrete floor. Adding bacteria can form a pervi- That’s why, we have drawn ever more attention to infrastructure
ous coating on concrete cracks that conforms to calcium carbonate inspection and repair techniques. Uninterrupted examination and
precipitation. Concrete is a strongly alkaline substance, and the safeguarding may be tricky to implement, particularly in the case
introduced bacteria are competent to tolerate alkaline conditions of hefty installations because of the enormous amount of money
[11]. available for this. Many other things like the damage location in
Micro biologically cause authentication of calcium carbonate the damaged system are preventing repair. It is the need of the
facilitate block up the minor fissures and fasten the supplementary concept of self-repair, or self-healing of these risky fissures with
materials including fine and coarse aggregates in concrete. a lowest amount of labor and the capital needs of the systems con-
Although germ presence in the form of precipitation will enhance cerned. The addition of bacteria in Rice husk ash concrete can
concrete’s resilience. The Bacillus Sphaericus can impetuous CaCO3 increase strength properties of concrete due to calcite precipitation
in the lofty alkaline atmosphere by altering urea into ammonium at all ages of concrete. Maximum of 24% can be increased in the
and carbonate. The formation of certain defects in self-healing con- M50 grade concrete, with maximum calcium carbonate precipita-
crete helps to wake the bacteria from hibernation. Throughout the tion [15–18] (Table 2).
self-healing process, calcium carbonate impulsive into the frac- Biomineralization is a process that develops the durability of
tures and repair them through the digestion of bacteria. Bacteria concrete. In addition, technology for biomineralization improves
return to the wintering stage after the cracks have been filled with concrete strength. This technique shows that the ITZ can be
calcium carbonate [12]. strengthened or concrete cracks repaired and concrete strength
Which are dependent of the water retention, acid tolerance and improved. The improvement of technology for biomineralization
chloride requirements for longevity. Tests are usually conducted at will afford the source for high quality concrete and eventually pro-
microstructure level to improve the precision of the tests. Very few gress structural durability.
nanostructure-level experiments are carried out. To develop Through the need for minimal labor and low capital expendi-
groundbreaking testing approach, it is worth exploring all possible ture, autohealing assessments of performance using a variety of
experiments and techniques for self-healing performance evalua- approaches became attractive. Efficiency in self-healing is tested
tion of cement-based materials. The most common methods for with different methods. Self curing capacity is the recovery from
achieving successful self-healing include the utilize of additional crack healing of the functionality of a cement base material and
cementing compounds [13,14]. the consistency criterion of its original shape.
The main problem is evaluating the consequence of self-healing
to effectively close the width of the crack. A crack of approx.
0.97 mm is repaired so far. The key methods for measuring the 2. Literature review of self-healing techniques and measured
depth of the filled cracks are visual inspection based on telescope, variable
optical imaging, and camera images. Yet, only a few researches
reported 32 mm and 27.2 mm crack depth healing. In comparison, Self-healing concrete is cement basis material, that can recover
only one article reported 5 mm crack length healing. the micro-level crack. Various scientists have been researching
The production of calcium carbonate can be mediated by sev- macro level cracks self-healing, biomineralization self healing
eral bacteria provided in Table 1. and the exploit of bacteria for copying a bone (natural) healing
Concrete is most used building material due to the quality, reli- mechanism to produce solid, sustainable technology self-healing
ability, resilience and compressive strength of their raw materials. materials. Expanding materials like polymers, fiber holes, mineral
But other concrete buildings, particularly infrastructures, ulti- admixtures, microcapsulation and microorganisms have been used
mately suffer over time corrosion and decay. This is due to water in the creation of self-healing concretes [19].
permeation which affects concrete efficiency. Crack forming at The spread of hydrate cement, calcium carbonate formation,
macro-levels is one of the causes of this degradation, and allows crack blocking by water contamination and the auxiliary hydration
passage for dissolved contaminants in waters, excessive acid of unreacted cement may naturally occur as a result of self-healing.
gasses and water entry. Therefore the reinforcement is affected; The development of concrete self-healing was augmented with

Table 1
Different types of bacteria and their performances.

S. No Bacteria Concentration of bacteria Performance

1. Bacillus subtilis 2.8 x108 cells/ml Improvement of compressive strength by 12%
2. Sporosarcina pasteurii 105 cells/ml Compressive strength 35% more than the control concrete
3. Bacillus sp. CT-5 5 x107 cells/ml Improvement of compressive strength by
40% compared to control concrete
4. AKKR5 105 cells/ml Improvement of compressive strength by
10% contrast to control concrete
5. Bacillus megaterium 30 x105 cfu/ml Improvement of compressive strength by
24% contrast to control concrete
6. Bacillus aerius 105 cells/ml Improvement of compressive strength by 11.8%
7. Shewanella Species 105 cells/ml Improvement of compressive strength by 25%

1247
P. Kumar Jogi and T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi Materials Today: Proceedings 43 (2021) 1246–1252

Table 2 ordinary specimen and that the pulses are increased in ultrasonic
Self healing methods and outputs. speeds. In addition, some methods have been compared for self
S. Method Healing crack References sealing. Bacterial concrete via encapsulation technique was shown
No width to be more effective than using superabsorbing polymer. The first
1. Bacterial method 0.97 mm Wang et al. can be used for a variety of purposes as the technique doesn’t need
2. polymer 0.138 mm Snoeck et al. any water regulate to achieve the consequence of self sealing.
3. Auxiliary cementing material Below 200 mm Huang et al. The latest advances in the field of nanomaterials have shown
4. Other 0.22 Yang et al.
5. Natural 60 mm Stuckrath et al.
themselves to be innovative innovations that know how to be
worn to mimic the normal visual appearance of the materials of
erection. In the concrete mix for the creation of new products with
certain attractive features, nanoparticles were just recently intro-
duced. Due to their high volume-to - surface range, nanoparticles
give an extremely high chemical reactiveness potential to the fin-
chemicals, polymers and geomaterials. Nevertheless, the precipi- ished product. A novel substance with the preferred properties can
tating microorganisms in calcium carbonate have been shown to therefore be formed. Consequently, nanotechnology is worn to
induce self-healing in concrete. Their capacitance for self-healing considerably increase concrete efficiency for the production of
may be improved by materials that have expanding properties composites based on sustainable and fresh cement. Perez et al.
after they have been incorporated into cemented materials and explore and customary the prospective of functional silica
combined with mineral addition and mixtures. In the presence of nanoparticles as a hopeful source for generating self-healing con-
water, however, it must be covered to avoid premature expansion cretes. In this spot, further investigation is needed. Morsy et al.
after a cement reaction. Parks et al. It is known that micro cracks investigated the impact on hardness of cement-based materials
can be formed within if the concrete is prepared of immensity sur- of other nanoparticles. Mahomet et al. Recent days have recorded
round liquefy magnesium silicates and calcium salts. Nonetheless, nanocomposite usage to improve the water-resistant performance
cracks aren’t completely healed. Only by the plugging conse- of concrete. Bacteria were investigated into their ability as a con-
quence, they decrease their size. Hard work was also through crete auto-healing agent [24].
inflict some damage with a high-resistance concrete tensile An efficient screening of all cracks has been found for the appli-
preloading. The artificially induced crack demonstrates self- ance of isolated bacterial microorganism and diverse cultures keen
healing in the presence of water and environmental exposure. In on cracked concretes. It was caused by the accumulation of calcium
the cementitious composite, synthetic fibers were thus added. carbonate origin by the metabolic action of the bacteria. Microor-
Thus intentionally created cracks were successfully repaired. Addi- ganism of bacteria may be rubbed on the concrete exterior in order
tional cementing solutions have also been worn by Van. T. boom to cause self-healing. Bacterial cultivation in a parking garage was
et al. to increase the self-healing effects of micro-level concrete also dispersed on a fractured concrete floor. As a consequence, the
cracks. Such materials give two advantages in terms of both reduc- water permeability was greatly decreased owing to self-healing.
ing cement consumption and activating the repair of enhanced Nevertheless, the frequency of compression was not recovered
cement cracks. Ahn et al. have found it possible to improve high- significantly. A great deal of work was conducted using micro-
performance fiber cementitious composites. Furthermore a greater organisms to compensate for this restriction, to augment the
self-healing response than earlier methods was pragmatic as soon compressive strength and longevity of cement mortar and cement.
as applied to certain treatment procedures [20]. There were water, As bacteria and concrete admixtures were used together, compres-
sea water and oil gas navel equipments. During a self-healing pro- sive strength was auxiliary enhanced. In addition, there was a 36
cess, merely cracks under 50 lm be lucratively crammed. Hostoda per cent increase in the compressive strength by rafat et al. Most
et al. beforehand healed, broken concrete, in a constant leak of work is still under way until now, when bacteria are deliberately
water and not quiet vapor. This has indicated that self-healing effi- incorporated into concrete for improved strength and longevity.
ciency has improved. Recently, post-tensing concrete with retract- In other research as a substitute of spraying and insertion meth-
able polymer improved the autogenous healing efficiency. In this ods, bacteria were mixed directly to the concrete mix. Cracks have
regard, Yıldırım et al. examined also cement content. The research- therefore been plugged following ureolytic action of the microbial
ers felt the material for self-healing was motivating with an precipitation bacteria. The solution has proven itself to be stronger.
enhanced degree of self-healing. Along with the cemented compos- The harsh climate has therefore condensed the life period of the
ite, Siad etc. added calcareous powder to their production. The bulk bacteria in the concrete matrix. As a consequence, the performance
of its functionality was found to be restored significantly. Pang et.al of self-healing diminished over time. Biomineralization precipita-
and other researchers. The consequence of carbonated concrete tion is dependent on a variety of variables such as pH, deliberation
steel slag as a self-healing agent has recently been studied. The of calcium ions, liquefy inorganic carbon content, and the occur-
tests showed that N.Z 1124 was the average volume. The split rence of nucleation at the site. Inconsolidated bacteria live in a
was healed for Muhammad and 5 mm and 20 lm. harsh environment, particularly high alkalinity of the concrete
Visual inspection methods for assessing the widths of the matrix. Therefore, it must be preserved in order to increase its life
plugged cracks have been used by many researchers. Use MRI, span. Through encapsulating the bacteria, they accomplished this
light-emitting, video and X-ray CT scans. They were working to defense. These thus augment the self-healing competence of the
boost concrete building service life in Snoeck et al. & Wang et al. concrete substance. In order to avoid bacterial cultivation in a con-
Researchers create a self-healing materials. They have a successful crete medium, Bang et al used polyurethane. Consequently the
end result. Though, competence depends taking place the polymer enzymatic activity (calcite precipitation) has decreased subse-
type [21–23]. further factors like polymer dosage, cement shape quently in their life cycles [25].
and water-cemetal relation have an effect on efficiency. Polymer This, however, stabilization over a long period of time of the
and other materials have also been combined for improved self- enzymatic process. Wang et al. confirmed this, where they
healing performance. Polymer can cause a self-healing effect in a reported 60 percent compression recovery due to the immobiliza-
further study by substantial at least 65% of the fissure diameter. tion of bacteria. The concrete matrix with ureolytic bacteria was
Farhayu et al. have been recently inveterate in their research work entered by Irwan and Othman et al. Their research triggered depo-
that the flexural strength recovery is 16 percent higher than the sition of CaCO3 in the crack surface and finally the cracks were
1248
P. Kumar Jogi and T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi Materials Today: Proceedings 43 (2021) 1246–1252

filled. Nevertheless, a better performance in real estate was 3.1. Self-healing measurement methods
observed particularly in later ages. Upon combining with concrete,
Wang et al. also incorporated bacterial elements in a hydro gel. Image surveillance exploit a microscope was the leading tech-
Crack diameter 0.5 mm fully filled out. The concentration of water nique of determining the width of sealed cracks implement by
has also reduced by 68%. Another analysis resulted in an improved the preponderance of authors. Among the technologies used were
efficiency by immobilizing bacteria in the microcapsule, at the optical imaging, camera photography with a extremely large pixel
same time the total fracture thickness of 970 lm was crammed and X-ray computed tomography. The image reveals that due to
absolutely. More in recent times, graphite nanoplatelets have natural occurrence the average crack dimension of 60 lm was
encapsulated bacteria. The analysis showed that crack diameters sealed. In addition, polymer was used to fill the crack thickness
of 0.81 mm were effectively overflowing for samples pre-cracked up to 138 lm. Additionally, the utilize of auxiliary cementing
at 3 and 7 days. The splits cause the curative agent to be released material in the concrete mix has source 200 lm of crack width
from the capsule. Nanoplatelets have the advantage of being able to be plugged. Progressive enhancement was also accomplished
to be distributed in detail and uniformly over the entire matrix in healing wider cracks widths of 970 lm by means of encapsula-
of concrete. Therefore, compressive strength increased by 9.8%. tion of micro-organisms in concrete eresearch. It is the most effec-
This is also capable of plugging nano-level crack. Products that tive approach, however. Moreover, it was shown that the
are to be used as healers must usually satisfied certain container combined utilization of chemicals and microorganisms was
shape requirements, such as thermal strength, handling of the sur- screened up until the upper limit crack width was 0.22 m. Mostae-
vival cycle and in-situ healing capacities. D Koaster et al. also hhvi et al. and Achael et al. researchers testimony the technique of
enclose documented the use of geopolymer as a achievable cover- self-healing based on fracture scope, based on the literature avail-
ing representative for granulated bacteria. It can efficiently used as able for this study.
a concrete self-healing representative. It has been found to induce Most researchers apparently rely solely on the large-scale
self-healing in the concrete at an remarkable rate. The self-healing mechanical properties to verify the efficiency of self-healing. In
by plugged crack deep was measured by Achal etc. and Mustavi accumulation to the durability tests, several researchers have
et al. They recorded 27.2 mm and 32 mm of crack depth plugging. assessed the properties of the macrostructure as a enhanced
None of the different auto-healing approaches showed that encap- approach. Many other assessments included reliability checks for
sulation strategies have sustained effectiveness because bacteria macro and micro-effectiveness. Both have proven themselves to
have an extended life cycle. And this process also completely filled be stronger than the previous technique. However, only some
larger size cracks. Furthermore, another interesting approach to researchers performed resilience studies with less accuracy when
self-healing concrete production has been a mixture of biological analyzing the crack width by microscope. Other authors’ next less
and chemical agents. In this respect, the crack width 0.22 mm intense approach is to use only a microscope. Microstructure tests
was plugged successfully. are often performed to obtain more reliable results in addition to
microscopic observation. The efficacy of self-healing is assessed
with macrostructure and testing of microstructures. A few
3. Working of Bio concrete as a repair material microstructure tests were performed in adding together to the
durability tests. The reliability of auto-healing with only lasting
Self-healing concrete is a biologically produced calcareous pro- tests is another less effective method. The efficacy of the self-
duct for healing cracks which occur on the exterior of the concrete healing was tested by two researchers with nano scale measures.
constructions. The concrete materials are combined with specially The inclusive literature analysis showed that the self-curing test,
selected forms of species, bacillus, calcium lactate and nitrogen macro-mechanical testing, micro-structure testing and nanostruc-
and phosphorous. Such self-healing agents live in the concrete ture tests were not simultanously measured. It has been suggested
for up to 200 years. that a systematic method of calculating the efficacy of self-healing
So that, the spores of the bacteria germinate when water and should be implemented in future research.
nutrients come into contact as a concrete surface is porous and
water begins to escape throughout the fissures that exist in the
concrete. Upon activation, the bacteria initiate nourish on the cal- 4. Effect of various bacteria on properties of fresh and hardened
cium lactate. When the bacteria consume oxygen, the soluble cal- concrete
cium lactate is converted into calcareously impenetrable. Granite
solidifies on the broken surface and covers it. 4.1. Compressive strength
Because oxygen is consumed by bacteria in the process, it pre-
vents corrosion of the embedded reinforcement and thus increases The performance of the concrete used in the construction indus-
the robustness of the steel on the concrete control exterior, Cal- try has been enhanced by a biological process dependent on calcite
cium Carbonate will be created as a consequence of the CO2 reac- precipitation. In the initial phase and during the curing process,
tion with Calcium Hydroxide present in the concrete matrix bacterial cells may grow slowly under high PH. Calcite precipitates
according to the subsequent reaction: in the cycle of cell growth, which can be attributed to the incidence
CO2 + Ca(OH)2 ? CaCO3 + H2O of different ions in the media, on the cell exterior as well as in the
Because Ca(OH)2 is a soluble mineral, it dissolves in the form of concrete mortar matrix. This decreases the porosity and perme-
leaching when inflowing water and disseminate out of the fissure. ability of cement mortars. If some of the matrix pores are blocked
unsettled to the vigorous metabolic dispensation of Calcium nutri- in addition, the supply of bacterial cells with nutrients and oxygen
ents by the bacteria present in concrete, the self-healing cycle in ceases. Either the cell is dead or endosphorous in due time. The
bacteria embedded concrete is a great deal supplementary compression activity with microbial cells can thus be elucidated.
proficient: The precipitation in calcite was high in higher grades of concrete
Ca(C3H5O2)2 + 7O2 ? CaCO3 + 5CO2 + 5H2O compare to the inferior grade of concrete when concentrations of
Here Calcium Carbonate is formed unswervingly through Bacillus megaterium bacteria 30x105 cfu/ ml were introduced in
microbial metabolic processes and also indirectly through autoge- concrete [26]. Consequently , a higher level of concrete provides
nous curative processes. This method results in an effective system greater force than a lower level of concrete. For the uppermost
for sealing cracks dependent on bacteria. grade of 50 MPa concrete, the average production resistance rate
1249
P. Kumar Jogi and T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi Materials Today: Proceedings 43 (2021) 1246–1252

is 24%, 10% fly ash of 105 cells per ml of Bacillus Pasteurii bacteria Megaterium and their nutrients, fascinated by microbial calcite
inclusions was supplemented with cement. Instead of calcium car- deposition more than three times less water than controls. The
bonate accumulation on microorganism cell surfaces, the compres- addition of bacteria from Bacillus Aerius results in lower absorp-
sive strength of structural fly ash concrete was increased by 20%. tion of the water and decreased porosity due to the accumulation
Bacteria have increased their compressive force by applying min- of calcite which increases the resilience of concrete structures.
eral admixture silica fume concrete to the CaCO3 precipitation. All cement bag house filter samples have lofty to modest perme-
SEM verified the presence of calcium carbonate in concrete ability for 28 days but AKKR5 concrete samples (105 cells/ml)
microstructure analysis using XRD. Bacillus subtilis (2  109 cells demonstrate high to poor pores of calcium carbonate.
/ml) bacterium is 20% higher than bacterial concrete exclusive of
bacteria for 28 days, which is the compressive strength of con-
cretes with Sparcina pasteuri. Bacterial cells improved compres-
4.3. Chloride ion permeability
sion strength by 16%, 13%, and 9% in comparison to control
specimens. GNP serves since a strong hauler composite for unvary-
Ingesting chlorite in the corrosion of reinforced steel is one of
ing bacterial circulation, which results in optimal crack sealing
the majority frequent ecological assaults that lead to concrete
competence. The introduction of Bacillus subtilis bacteria together
structural corrosion. The amount of chloride ions in the concrete
with GNP has enhanced the compressive strength of the concrete
depends primarily on its inner porous structure. The composition
over all ages since microbial precipitation of calcium carbonate.
of the pores depends in part on certain factors, including the mix-
By the incorporation of reactive spore powder into cement mortar,
ture structure, curing environment, hydration, the use of additional
the compressive strength increased by 34% at 28 days relative to
cement materials and production methods. The fast chloride per-
the cement mortar regulation.
meability test is performed by calculating the quantity of electric
current that passes throughout the specimen. The ranking is con-
4.2. Water permeability stituted of concrete permeability. By adding concrete bacteria,
the concrete’s resistance to chloride permeation can be improved.
Permeability determines the dissemination of aggressive sub- The mean is found to be 11.7 % lower than bacteria-free concrete in
stances that cause concrete deterioration to pressure gradient, the number of concrete-containing coulombs. The use of Bacillus
and thus is considered the fundamental property to demonstrate Pasteurii and Bacillus Subtilis also reduces the penetration of con-
concrete toughness. The characteristics of the porous system of crete chloride; more effects are found as sulphate-exposed masses
cemented materials enumerate with porosity, accurate forms, size of concrete are reduced. The minimum healing charge transferred
distribution, connectivity and micro cracks depend on them. The W at all ages is demonstrated by bacterial concrete. The bacterial
/ Cement ratio (w/c), particle dimension allocations, period of hard samples of cement reducing their batteries load by 55,8%, 49,9%,
cement materials as well as penetration of aggressive resources, and 48,4%, as opposed to regular concrete for 7, 28, and 56 days.
among other things, control such parameters. CaCO3 deposits in The use of Bacillus Pasteursii in 10% silica-fume concrete demon-
concrete have reduced the absorption of water and the testing per- strated good resistance to rapid chloride penetration (380 C), at
meability of concrete. Studies consider the inclusion of Bacillus the optimum bacterium concentration (105 cells/ml). The highest
Pasteuri Studies. Concrete bacteria from fly ash contribute to a decrease in the chloride ions was pragmatic with Bacillus pasteurii
reduction in porosity as well as concrete permeability. Water 105 cells/ml concentration for all fly ash, but only very low penetra-
absorption was initiated to decrease by four in the midst of a con- tion of 762 C was obtained with 30% fly ash concrete. The longevity
centration of 105cells / ml of concrete bacteria [27]. of concrete buildings subjected to deicing sea conditions is well
Calcium carbonate precipitation is filled with pores of bacterial defined by their structural ability to prevent chloride ions from
concrete. Specimens cast with the accumulation of Bacillus entering [28].

Figure 1. Self healing process in bacterial concrete.

1250
P. Kumar Jogi and T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi Materials Today: Proceedings 43 (2021) 1246–1252

5. Microstructure verified by using SEM images. The consequences acquired via

microstructures have incorrigible the authentication of calcium
SEM analysis visualized calcite precipitation in mortar and con- carbonate surrounded by the fissures of the test samples (Fig. 1).
crete. Rod-shaped bacteria were found to be aligned with calcite
crystals. The impermeability of the concrete is enhanced due to 6. Conclusions
this evidence as this deposition acts as a hurdle to detrimental
material entering the sample. Adding bacteria keen on the concrete The significance of this research work is to be able to compre-
can progress the concrete microstructure by precipitating miner- hend the use by concrete crack healing of the species of isolates
als. This was confirmed by an study of SEM, EDAX, and XRD. The of urease-produced bacteria, such as Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus
researchers reported that an introduction of 30x105cfu/ml concen- Pasteurii. The research investigated various kinds of bacteria which
tration of Bacillus. M. bacteria had a maximal calcium weight can be used for cracks. This review work also found that concrete
(38.76%) relative to certain deliberation of bacteria and in the compressive strength ability have a beneficial effect on bacteria.
nonexistence of concrete bacteria. The SEM analysis revealed the The benefit of bacteria reduces water penetration and chloride
various calcite particles entrenched through bacteria. This was ion permeability. The results of the current review research sug-
found in the study and checked using an EDX and XRD analysis gest that with the ‘‘microbial concrete” can be an substitute and
[29–30]. It can amplify concrete robustness. Fig. 2 shows SEM pic- premium quality concrete which heals the cracks that is cost-
tures of bacterial and concrete sensors. These images in bacterial effective, environmentally friendly and ultimately go in front to
concrete can conform the calcite crystals. Because of the accumu- improved durability of building materials. Finally concluded that,
lation of calcium carbonate in pores, the strength of RHA concrete Bacillus Pasteuri and bacillus subtilis are most effective useful bac-
to be strengthened by the introduction of bacteria, and this was teria to heal the cracks in concrete (Fig. 3).

Figure 2. Self healing possible ways.

Figure 3. Radiance microscopic images.

1251
P. Kumar Jogi and T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi Materials Today: Proceedings 43 (2021) 1246–1252

CRediT authorship contribution statement [11] J.Y. Wang, D. Snoeck, S. Van Vlierberghe, W. Verstraete, N. De Belie, Application
of hydrogel encapsulated carbonate precipitating bacteria for approaching a
realistic self-healing in concrete, Constr. Build. Mater. 68 (2014) 110–119.
Pavan Kumar Jogi: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing - [12] N. Chahal, R. Siddique, A. Rajor, Influence of bacteria on the compressive
original draft. T.V.S. Vara Lakshmi: Supervision. strength, water absorption and rapid chloride permeability of fly ash concrete,
Constr. Build. Mater. 28 (1) (2012) 351–356.
[13] N. Chahal, R. Siddique, A. Rajor, Influence of bacteria on the compressive
Declaration of Competing Interest strength, water absorption and rapid chloride permeability of concrete
incorporating silica fume, Constr. Build. Mater. 37 (2012) 645–651.
[14] W. De Muynck, K. Cox, N.D. Belie, W. Verstraete, Bacterial carbonate
The authors declare that they have no known competing finan- precipitation as an alternative surface treatment for concrete, Constr. Build.
cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared Mater. 22 (5) (2008) 875–885.
[15] R. Siddique, V. Nanda, Kunal, E.-H. Kadri, M. Iqbal Khan, M. Singh, A. Rajor,
to influence the work reported in this paper. Influence of bacteria on compressive strength and permeation properties of
concrete made with cement baghouse filter dust, Constr. Build. Mater. 106
(2016) 461–469.
References [16] Q.T. Phung, N. Maes, G. De Schutter, D. Jacques, G. Ye, Determination of water
permeability of cementitious materials using a controlled constant flow
[1] E. Mostavi, S. Asadi, M.M. Hassan, M. Alansari, Evaluation of self-healing method, Constr. Build. Mater. 47 (2013) 1488–1496.
mechanisms in concrete with double-walled sodium silicate microcapsules, J. [17] K. Van Tittelboom, N. De Belie, W. De Muynck, W. Verstraete, Use of bacteria to
Mater. Civ. Eng. 27 (12) (2015) 04015035. repair cracks in concrete, Cem. Concr. Res. 40 (1) (2010) 157–166.
[2] W. Khaliq, M.B. Ehsan, Crack healing in concrete using various bio influenced [18] N.K. Dhami, M.S. Reddy, A. Mukherjee, Improvement in strength properties of
self-healing techniques, Constr. Build. Mater. 102 (2016) 349–357. ash bricks by bacterial calcite, Ecol. Eng. 39 (2012) 31–35.
[3] M. Luo, C. Qian, Influences of bacteria-based self-healing agents on [19] R. Siddique, N.K. Chahal, Effect of ureolytic bacteria on concrete properties,
cementitious materials hydration kinetics and compressive strength, Constr. Constr. Build. Mater. 25 (10) (2011) 3791–3801.
Build. Mater. 121 (2016) 659–663. [20] J. Wang, K. Van Tittelboom, N. De Belie, W. Verstraete, Use of silica gel or
[4] M. Luo, C.-X. Qian, R.-Y. Li, Factors affecting crack repairing capacity of polyurethane immobilized bacteria for self-healing concrete, Constr. Build.
bacteria-based self-healing concrete, Constr. Build. Mater. 87 (2015) 1–7. Mater. 26 (1) (2012) 532–540.
[5] C.-C. Hung, Y.-F. Su, Medium-term self-healing evaluation of engineered [21] Y.Ç. Ersßan, F.B. Da Silva, N. Boon, W. Verstraete, N. De Belie, Screening of
cementitious composites with varying amounts of fly ash and exposure bacteria and concrete compatible protection materials, Constr. Build. Mater. 88
durations, Constr. Build. Mater. 118 (2016) 194–203. (2015) 196–203.
[6] E. Tziviloglou, V. Wiktor, H.M. Jonkers, E. Schlangen, Bacteria-based self- [22] J. Qiu, D. Qin, S. Tng, E. Yang, Surface treatment of recycled concrete aggregates
healing concrete to increase liquid tightness of cracks, Constr. Build. Mater. through microbial carbonate precipitation, Constr. Build. Mater. 57 (2014)
122 (2016) 118–125. 144–150.
[7] W. De Muynck, D. Debrouwer, N. De Belie, W. Verstraete, Bacterial carbonate [23] M. Luo, C.X. Qian, Performance of Two Bacteria-Based Additives Used for Self-
precipitation improves the durability of cementitious materials, Cem. Concr. Healing Concrete, pp. 1–6.
Res. 38 (7) (2008) 1005–1014. [24] V. Achal, X. Pan, N. Özyurt, Improved strength and durability of fly ash-
[8] R. Siddique, K. Singh, Kunal, M. Singh, V. Corinaldesi, A. Rajor, Properties of amended concrete by microbial calcite precipitation, Ecol. Eng. 37 (4) (2011)
bacterial rice husk ash concrete, Constr. Build. Mater. 121 (2016) 112–119. 554–559.
[9] R. Andalib, M.Z. Abd Majid, M.W. Hussin, M. Ponraj, A. Keyvanfar, J. Mirza, H.-S. [25] N.Z. Muhammad, A. Shafaghat, A. Keyvanfar, M.Z. Abd. Majid, S.K. Ghoshal, S.E.
Lee, Optimum concentration of Bacillus megaterium for strengthening Mohammadyan Yasouj, A.A. Ganiyu, M. Samadi Kouchaksaraei, H. Kamyab, M.
structural concrete, Constr. Build. Mater. 118 (2016) 180–193. M. Taheri, M. Rezazadeh Shirdar, R. McCaffer, Tests and methods of evaluating
[10] J. Wang, J. Dewanckele, V. Cnudde, S. Van Vlierberghe, W. Verstraete, N. De the self-healing efficiency of concrete: A review, Constr. Build. Mater. 112
Belie, X-ray computed tomography proof of bacterial-based self-healing in (2016) 1123–1132.
concrete, Cem. Concr. Compos. 53 (2014) 289–304.

1252