Scribd
Upload
847 views3 pages

First Appeal To SRA

1. The appellant filed this first appeal regarding the decision of the State Public Information Officer (SPIO) in response to an RTI application about the cancellation of a Letter of Intent (LOI) and stop work notice issued for a plot. 2. The appellant alleges that the SPIO did not understand the information sought and provided an order already collected by the appellant instead of addressing the cancellation of the LOI and stop work notice. 3. The appellant seeks cancellation of the LOI and stop work notice as the SPIO response did not provide the information requested regarding the action taken after a meeting on the plot in question.

Uploaded by

NILESH PARAB
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
847 views3 pages

First Appeal To SRA

1. The appellant filed this first appeal regarding the decision of the State Public Information Officer (SPIO) in response to an RTI application about the cancellation of a Letter of Intent (LOI) and stop work notice issued for a plot. 2. The appellant alleges that the SPIO did not understand the information sought and provided an order already collected by the appellant instead of addressing the cancellation of the LOI and stop work notice. 3. The appellant seeks cancellation of the LOI and stop work notice as the SPIO response did not provide the information requested regarding the action taken after a meeting on the plot in question.

Uploaded by

NILESH PARAB
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

The Right to Information Act, 2005

First Appeal for Central Government/State Government

I.D.No.__________Date___________(For Office Use)


To,
The First Appellate Authority under RTI Act
Shri S.V. Varade,
Assistant Engineer, - K/W (S.R.A.,
Administrative Building,
Anant Kanekar Marg,
Bandra (East), Mumbai 400-053.
Sir,
As I am aggrieved by decision State Public Information Officer, I hereby file this appeal for your kind decision.

1. Details of Appellant:
1.1 Full Name : Chandresh. C. Shah
1.2 Full Address : C/o Shri Bhanbai Nenshi Mahila Vidyalaya,
4, Shantinath Bhavan, 437, Shraddhanand Rd,
Opp. Shraddhanand Mahila Ashram,
Matunga (CR), Mumbai 400-019.
1.3 Mobile No. : 9870711306
1.4 Email ID : [email protected]

2. Details of Central/State Public Information :


officer (CPIO/SPIO)
2.1 Name/Designation : Public Information officer
2.2. Full Address : Shri V.C. Tirhekar, Sub - Engineer
Slum Rehabilitation Authority,
Anant Kanekar Marg,
Bandra (East) Mumbai 400-053.

2.3 Name of Public Authority : Public Information Officer


2.2. Full Address : Shri V.C. Tirhekar, Sub - Engineer
Slum Rehabilitation Authority,
Anant Kanekar Marg,
Bandra (East) Mumbai 400-053.
.

3. Details of RTI Application to A.E. : Information/Decision of the action initiated by your


Office in lieu of the Letter dated 17th February 2022
Issued by our Advocate M/s M. P. Savla & Co as
Regards the cancellation of LOI and issuance of Stop
Work Notice on Plot bearing CTS No. 455, 455/1 to
16 MHADA, 464 (PT), 1755, 1756 STGL of Village
Vile Parle situated at Gulmohar Road, Andheri
(West),
Mumbai for Hanuman Nagar SRA CHS Ltd, granted
To M/s Zodiac Developers Pvt Ltd. Please note that
It is regarding the Hearing held before the CEO on
31st December 2021 and the subsequent order
received
By us under Ref No: SRA/Exe/Karya/OW-
1476/2022/
KW dated 12th January 2022.

i) Date of Application : 20th May 2022.


ii) Delivery : Hand Delivery
iii) Date of receipt : 20th May 2022.
4. Particulars of payment of filing fee : No.

5. Details of Information Sought : Same as per Sr.No.3 of Appeal

6. Particulars of Decision of AE : Received reply dated 20th June 2022 from


Public Information officer,
Mr. V.C. Tirhekar Sub- Engineer (S.R.A),
Stating that as per the meeting the Letter is already
Forwarded to Collector (MSD). The copy of the
Same is attached herewith. However, nothing is
replied
Yet thereon by Collector (MSD).

7. Brief facts of the case : From the reply of the Sub Engineer Mr. V.C. Tirhekar
It seems that he has not understood the information
That has been sought by me or he is taking me on a
Roller coaster ride. It has been clearly mentioned
By our Advocates about the action initiated by your
Office and very coolly he is forwarding the Order of
Passed by the Executive Engineer – 5 dated
12/01/2022
Which I myself have collected it from your office.
He is well aware that the order of the Collector
(MSD)
For Demarcation was long back given to us and a
copy
Of the same was also forwarded to your office. The
Main issue is for the Cancellation of area
admeasuring
1110.37 Sq. Mts from the LOI issued to M/s Zodiac
Developers Pvt Ltd and Stop Work Notice on Plot
No. 1756 (PT) which was ordered in the meeting with
The CEO on 31st December 2021. After that in spite
Of various reminders written by me has been left
Unanswered. The copy of the Order issued by the
Executive Engineer – 5 is already the subject matter
Of our Advocate’s Letter at Sr. No.7 so there is no
Question of information to be submitted. The order
Of the Collector (MSD) for Sub-Division of CTS No.
1756 was issued on 14th July 2021 and is annexed by
Our Advocate in their letter dated 17th February 2022.
The LOI is issued by your office and the power to
Cancel or modify lies with you and not the Collector.

8 Reason/ground for this appeal : As aforementioned

9 Any other information in support of Appeal : No.

10 Prayer/relief sought for : Cancellation of LOI and stop work Notice to be


Issued.
11 Grounds for prayer/relief sought for : As aforementioned in earlier paragraph

12. Personal presence at hearing : yes, or my representative with letter of Authority.

13. Enclosures : (i) Xerox copy of the RTI filed dated 20.05.2022.
(ii) Reply dated 20th June 2022 received from
Mr. V.C. Tirhekar Sub- Engineer (SRA).
(iii) Xerox Copy of the Order of the Collector
(MSD) dated 14th July 2021.

14. Declaration : I hereby state that the information and particulars


Given above are true to the best of my knowledge
And belief. I also declare that this matter is not
Previously filed with any information commission
Nor is pending with any court or tribunal or
Authority.
Place: Mumbai
Date: 27th June 2022.
Signature of Appellant
Encl: As Above.

You might also like