RFX 4000071727

EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review

Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
1 General No deviation to PTS is applicable unless otherwise Confirmed.
mentioned specifically and accepted by SEC in writing.
Confirm to comply.
2 General No deviation to SEC Standards is applicable unless Noted.
otherwise mentioned specifically and accepted by SEC in
writing.
Deviations relevant to Protection and Communication are
not reviewed and shall be taken up separately by bidder
with PED and TESAD. Confirm to comply.
3 General Only SEC prequalified equipment shall be supplied. The Confirmed.
equipment shall be same as prequalified. Confirm to
comply.
4 General Manufacturer/vendor to ensure consistency in Noted.
nomenclature for complete project.
5 General The overall substation layout with PTS is only a tentative Confirmed.
layout. Contractor shall develop the detailed drawing
fulfilling all project requirements and submit it for SEC
review separately during design stage. Confirm to
comply.
6 General It shall be noted that, any communications, comments, Any deviations/comments
deviations, scope descriptions, etc. between the from the suppliers & related
manufacturer/vendor and the contractor shall not be to contractor scope, will be
reviewed by SEC. complied by the contractor; if
applicable as per PTS.
Technical Proposal for Major Equipment
Page 1 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
I. Equipment: 380kV GIS / HGIS, Type: ELK-3/420
Make: Hitachi Energy, Switzerland
Document Ref: Technical Quotation QT-22-00837731

1. PTS: Section The VT Burden shall be 100VA as per PTS, which shall
III, Clause be complied. Manufacturer has complied as per the data
2.A.c.4 schedule for 32-TMSS-02, Rev.2, Clause 4.13 and the
same shall be complied in all applicable documents.
2. General It shall be noted that the control cables and their cross
section used for the connection between the GIS and LCC
shall be submitted during design stage for further review
and approval.
3. PTS: Confirm to supply the special tools as per PTS Appendix-
Appendix- XIII.
XIII
4. General It shall be noted that the earthing arrangement for GIS
shall be submitted during design stage for further review
and approval.

5. General The mentioned PTS reference in the manufacturer’s

document under Chapter T3, page#26 of 59 shall be
corrected as PTS#22CR328

Page 2 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
6. General It shall be noted that, the division of work (Chapter T5)
shall be mutually agreed between the BSP Contractor and
the vendor/manufacturer and any deviations shall be
notified to SEC separately before awarding the contract.

7. General As per manufacturer’s technical submittal clause T 4.2.5,

it is mentioned that, Every barrier insulator is equipped
with a capacitive coupler, which can be connected to a
patented Hitachi Energy UHF sensor (not included in the
current scope of supply) even during normal operation of
the GIS. It must be clarified why the UHF sensors are not
included.

A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for ELK-3, 420kV GIS , HGIS & 420kV GIL

1. - Noted with no deviations, but the documents shall be

resubmitted with the signature from Contractor’s
responsible and Name of the equipment shall be clearly
specified with full elaboration. HGIS also to be included
with it. Further, it must be stamped by both the
Manufacturer and the contractor in the designated place.

B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS

Page 3 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01 Rev. 3
1. - Compliance for Clause 11.3 is missing. Also the signature
from Contractor’s responsible and stamp of manufacturer
is required on the document. Revised document shall be
submitted complying with the above.

Compliance Statement to TCS-P-105, Rev. 3

2. - Compliance statement for the same standard of Rev.03

shall be submitted with the signature from Contractor’s
responsible and stamp of manufacturer in the designated
place.
Compliance Statement to 38-TMSS-07, Rev. 1

3. Compliance statement for the same standard of Rev.01

shall be submitted with the signature from Contractor’s
responsible and stamp of manufacturer in the designated
place.
Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0

4. PTS- The VT Burden shall be 100VA as per PTS shall be

SECTION- complied. Manufacturer has complied as per the data
III, Clause schedule for 32-TMSS-02, Rev.2, Clause 4.13
2.A.c.4
5. PTS- It shall be noted that the Quantity & Location of 380kV
SECTION- GIS Surge arrestors shall be decided as per
III, Clause EMTDC/insulation coordination study during design
2.A.c.6 stage. If such calculations/studies are not under
Page 4 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
manufacturer’s scope, then contractor should comply
accordingly.
6. PTS- It shall be noted that the GIB routings are shown in the
SECTION- tender layout CT- 920223, Rev.0 is tentative only and
III, Clause actual shall be confirmed during design stage in co-
2.A.c.6 ordination with the existing GIBs. Bidder has to note the
latest change on the feeder reference based on the
revised orientation of OHTL gantries at Phase-1(refer
amendment-1 for details)
7. PTS- The partial discharge monitoring sensors for the proposed
SECTION- equipment shall be as per PTS requirements. Moreover, it
III, Clause shall be integrated with the On-line Partial Discharge
2.D. Monitoring System for existing/ongoing phase-1 or
otherwise a separate new standalone online PDMS require
under this PTS, if it can’t be integrated with the existing
system. Confirm to comply.
8. PTS- Bidders has mentioned that Special tools have been not
APPENDIX- included since they have been already provided with the
XIII, original GIS. We have noted it and bidder needs to
confirm to supply the same special tools as specified in
PTS#22CR328, Appendix-XIII.
9. - The compliance statement shall be signed and stamped
by both the manufacturer and the contractor.

Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1

10. 32-TMSS-05, ABB statement No 10413684 for IP65W shall be
Rev.1, Clause attached. Any deviations shall be listed out separately

Page 5 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
4.1.23 with proper justification.
11. 32-TMSS-05, The Bidder’s reply is not associated with the compliance
Rev.1, Clause statement for 01-TMSS-01, Rev.03. The revised
4.3.4 response shall be submitted for the particular clause.
Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2
12. 32-TMSS-02, We noted the Bidder’s clarification for the mentioned
Rev.2, Clause clause as “The GIS is equipped with self-closing non-
4.5.9 return valves. However, while taking the meter off the
valve an insignificant small amount of gas in the
Density meter will be lost“. We need the confirmation
from Manufacturer that the above clarification about the
gas lost already notified to SEC during pre-qualification
and accepted.
13. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be noted that the Quantity & Location of 380kV
Rev.2, Clause GIS Surge arrestors shall be decided as per
4.18.1 EMTDC/insulation coordination study during design
stage. EMTDC/insulation coordination study during
design stage. If such calculations/studies are not under
manufacturer’s scope, then contractor should comply
accordingly.
14. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be clarified with the approval reference for sub-
Rev.2, Clause suppliers for the components and attach the relevant
4.23.5 approved list of sub suppliers.
15. 32-TMSS-02, Submit the type test report for our references.
Rev.2, Clause
4.23.5
C. Compliance to Data Schedule

Page 6 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2 - For New Diameters
1. 32-TMSS-02, Column ‘A’ shall not be filled by the bidder as it is
Rev.2, Data designated for NGSA’s specified data/parameter.
Schedule, Revised data schedule shall be submitted. Moreover,
Page: 35 of each sheet of the same data schedule shall be signed &
62 sealed by both Manufacturer and the contractor.

2. 32-TMSS-02, Each mentioned data shall be revised corresponding to

Rev.2, Data the units with the respective temperature or duration (in
Schedule Seconds)
clause 4.9
3. 32-TMSS-02, As mentioned in Data Schedule Page 62 of 62, other
Rev.2, Data particulars shall be filled in column ‘C’ by the bidder
Schedule such as the technical reference with clause number for
each data given by the bidder under clause 4.2, 4.4, 4.5,
4.9, 4.10. i.e. Clause Reference from technical standards
for each given data shall be provided.
4. 32-TMSS-02, Bidders has mentioned “No” under Special tools
Rev.2, Data requirements and also mentioned as “Project Specific”.
Schedule Need clarifications on the above.
clause 6.0
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2 - For HGIS Bays
5. 32-TMSS-02, In the respective clauses for HGIS, it is mentioned as
Rev.2, Data “N/A”. We understand that the same data schedule for
Schedule GIS has been copied for HGIS as well. It shall be
checked and revised accordingly. Moreover, each sheet
of the data schedule shall be signed & sealed by both

Page 7 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Manufacturer & Contractor.
6. 32-TMSS-02, As mentioned in Data Schedule Page 62 of 62, other
Rev.2, Data particulars shall be filled in column ‘C’ by the bidder
Schedule such as the technical reference with clause number for
each data given by the bidder under clause 4.2, 4.4, 4.5,
4.9, 4.10. i.e. Clause Reference from technical standards
for each given data shall be provided.
7. 32-TMSS-02, Bidders has mentioned “No” under Special tools
Rev.2, Data requirements and also mentioned as “Project Specific”.
Schedule Need clarification on the above.
clause 6.0

Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 38-TMSS-07 Rev. 1

8. - The type of PDM (i.e. PDMAR 120S / PDMAR56S/
PDMCR) under the proposed Power Diagnostix shall be
specified.
9. - Each sheet of the same data schedule shall be signed &
sealed by both Manufacturer & Contractor.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1
10. - Each sheet of the same data schedule shall be signed &
sealed by both Manufacturer & Contractor.
11. 32-TMSS-05, As mentioned in Data Schedule Page 34 of 34, other
Rev.1, Data particulars shall be filled in column ‘C’ by the bidder
Schedule such as the technical reference for each data given by the
bidder under clause 4.2, 4.3, 4.4, 4.5, 4.8 and 4.9. i.e.
Clause Reference from technical standards for each
given data shall be provided.
Page 8 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
D. Compliance to SLD & Layout
1. - The Single Line & Gas Diagram and GIS Layout &
Requirements shall be reviewed during design stage. We
cannot approve and fix any proposal at this stage as this
is LSTK project including Engineering and Design.
However, bidder has to note the swapping of OHTL
circuits (9025-9095) and the relevant modifications in
circuit references shall be done as per Amendment-1.
II. Equipment: 380kV Auto Transformer, 380/132/13.8kV,302/402/502MVA, ONAN/ONAF1/ONAF2
Make: Hyosung Heavy Industries Corporation, Korea (Main Manufacturer)
A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for 380kV Auto Transformer
1. - Bidder’s compliance on manufacturer’s responsibility
statement for 380kV Auto Transformer is noted with no
deviations.
B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS

Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0

1. - Compliance statement to SOW/PTS has been noted.
However, the compliances for the out of scope materials
or any deviations by transformer manufacturer shall be
covered by the substation contractor and the compliances
shall be revised accordingly.

Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01, Rev. 3

2. - Bidder’s compliance to 01-TMSS-01, Rev.3 is noted.

Page 9 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Compliance Statement to 53-TMSS-01, Rev. 2
3. - Bidder’s compliance to 53-TMSS-01, Rev.2 is noted with
no deviations.
Compliance Statement to 53-TMSS-03, Rev. 0
4. - Bidder’s compliance to 53-TMSS-03, Rev.0 is noted with
no deviations.
Compliance Statement to 54-TMSS-01, Rev. 2
5. - Bidder’s compliance to 54-TMSS-01, Rev.2 is noted with
no deviations.
C. Compliance to Data Schedule

Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 53-TMSS-01 Rev. 2

1. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed & sealed
by both Manufacturer & Contractor.
2. 53-TMSS-01, The Design Ambient temperature shall be a single value
Rev.2, Data i.e. 55 deg C (Max) and other values for monthly &
Schedule yearly shall be removed as it is not going to add any
clause 4.1 values for design or it shall be clarified why it has been
added under Design Ambient temperature.
3. 53-TMSS-01, It is mentioned that the temperature rise values shall be
Rev.2, Data as per 01-TMSS-01 and it must be clarified with the
Schedule particular clause reference where it is matching with.
clause 4.3.1
4. 53-TMSS-01, Impedance voltage at each tap position, Maximum
Rev.2, Data Design Flux Density, Current density at rated output, No
Schedule Load Current, BIL, BSL, Power Frequency withstand

Page 10 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
clause 4.3.1 voltage, shall be mentioned along with the relevant
clause numbers from the referred international standards
or with the particular reference from where the
manufacturer chosen such values and those references
with the particular clause number shall be mentioned
under column ‘C’.
5. 53-TMSS-01, The mentioned values for Guaranteed No-Load & Load
Rev.2, Data Losses shall be within the acceptable limit and the
Schedule supporting document shall be provided to prove the
clause 4.3.4 mentioned value of losses. The attached calculation
under Annexure-IX is made for Al Kahafah station and
separate calculation shall be submitted for Ar Rass
expansion project.
6. 53-TMSS-01, The reference from technical standards shall be provided
Rev.2, Data under column ‘C’ for the given values for Maximum
Schedule Symmetrical & Asymmetrical short circuit current for
clause 4.3.6 which windings are designed to thermally withstand.
7. 53-TMSS-01, It shall be confirmed that the accessories such as tap
Rev.2, Data changer, motor driving units, Oil/Gas relay for OLTC,
Schedule Buccholz Relay, Pressure relief Device, WTI, OTI and
clause 4.5 HV, LV, TV Bushings shall be from the SEC/NG
approved manufacturer.
8. 53-TMSS-01, The reference from technical standards with particular
Rev.2, Data clause number shall be provided under column ‘C’ for
Schedule the given values for BIL, Power Frequency withstand
clause 4.10 voltage, Creepage distance and cantilever strength for
each bushing. LV & TV bushing type designation shall
be cross verified whether it is oil to oil or oil to XLPE
Page 11 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
and confirm accordingly.
9. 53-TMSS-01, The manufacturer details for cooling Fans shall be
Rev.2, Data provided and also it shall be from NG/SEC approved
Schedule manufacturers.
clause 4.14
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 54-TMSS-01 Rev. 2
10. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed &
stamped by the manufacturer and contractor.
11. - Dissolved gases in the oil shall be interpreted as per IEC
60599. Test Report for Oil properties shall be submitted
for batch of oil to be filled complying to Table 2 of IEC
60296 during project execution stage.

Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 53-TMSS-03 Rev. 0

12. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed &
stamped by the manufacturer and contractor.

13. - The requirement, Online DGA shall be provided with

direct redundant FO interface (dual port) without any
converter between DGA and SAS LAN

14. 53-TMSS-03 Write up on Analysis Technique is not enclosed, which

Rev. 0, Data shall be submitted with the revised submittal.
Schedule
Clause 4.2
D. Compliance to Outline Diagram for 380kV, 500MVA Auto Transformer
1. The outline diagram for Power transformer shall be
Page 12 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
reviewed during design stage. We cannot approve and fix
any proposal at this stage as this is LSTK project
including Engineering and Design.

III. Equipment: 380kV Auto Transformer, 380/132/13.8kV,302/402/502MVA, ONAN/ONAF1/ONAF2

Make: Hyundai Electric & Energy Systems Co. Ltd., Korea (Alternate Manufacturer)
A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for 380/132/13.8kV Auto Transformer
1. - Bidder’s compliance on manufacturer’s responsibility Noted.
statement for 380/132/13.8kV Auto Transformer is noted
with no deviations.
B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS
Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0
1. - Compliance statement to SOW/PTS has been noted with Noted.
no deviations to all clauses. However, the compliances
for the out of scope materials or any deviations by the
transformer manufacturer shall be covered by the
substation contractor.

Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01, Rev. 3

2. - Bidder’s compliance to 01-TMSS-01, Rev.3 is noted. Noted.
Compliance Statement to 53-TMSS-01, Rev. 2
3. - Bidder’s compliance to 53-TMSS-01, Rev.2 is noted with Noted.
no deviations.

Page 13 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Compliance Statement to 53-TMSS-03, Rev. 0
4. - Bidder’s compliance to 53-TMSS-03, Rev.0 is noted with Noted.
no deviations.
Compliance Statement to 54-TMSS-01, Rev. 2
5. - Bidder’s compliance to 54-TMSS-01, Rev.2 is noted with Noted.
no deviations.
C. Compliance to Data Schedule
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 53-TMSS-01 Rev. 2
1. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall also be signed & Noted. Revised data
sealed by Manufacturer. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
2. 53-TMSS-01, The Design Ambient temperature shall be a single value Noted. Revised data
Rev.2, Data i.e. 55 deg C (Max) and other values for yearly shall be schedule will be submitted at
Schedule removed as it is not going to add any values for design or detail design stage.
clause 4.1 it shall be clarified why it has been added under Design
Ambient temperature.
3. 53-TMSS-01, It is mentioned that the temperature rise values shall be Please be noted that
Rev.2, Data as per 01-TMSS-01 and it must be clarified with the maximum ambient
Schedule particular clause reference where it is matching with. temperature is 55℃ for
clause 4.3.1 outdoor equipment. So
temperature rise limit shall
be deducted based on IEC
60076-02 table.2.
4. 53-TMSS-01, Impedance voltage at each tap position, Maximum Noted. Revised data
Rev.2, Data Design Flux Density, Current density at rated output, No schedule will be submitted at
Schedule Load Current, BIL, BSL, Power Frequency withstand detail design stage.
clause 4.3.1 voltage, shall be mentioned along with the relevant
Page 14 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
clause numbers from the referred international standards
or with the particular reference from where the
manufacturer chosen such values and those references
with the particular clause number shall be mentioned
under column ‘C’.
5. 53-TMSS-01, It shall be confirmed that the mentioned values for Please clarify the acceptable
Rev.2, Data Guaranteed No-Load & Load Losses shall be within the limit value for no load loss
Schedule acceptable limit. and load loss.
clause 4.3.4
6. 53-TMSS-01, The reference from technical standards shall be provided Noted. Revised data
Rev.2, Data under column ‘C’ for the given values for Maximum schedule will be submitted at
Schedule Symmetrical & Asymmetrical short circuit current for detail design stage.
clause 4.3.6 which windings are designed to thermally withstand.
7. 53-TMSS-01, It shall be confirmed that the accessories such as tap Confirmed.
Rev.2, Data changer, motor driving units, Oil/Gas relay for OLTC,
Schedule Buccholz Relay, Pressure relief Device, WTI, OTI and
clause 4.5 HV, LV, TV Bushings shall be from the SEC/NG
approved manufacturer.
8. 53-TMSS-01, The reference from technical standards with particular Noted. Revised data
Rev.2, Data clause number shall be provided under column ‘C’ for schedule will be submitted at
Schedule the given values for BIL, Power Frequency withstand detail design stage.
clause 4.10 voltage, Creepage distance and cantilever strength for
each bushing. LV & TV bushing type designation shall
be cross verified whether it is oil to oil or oil to XLPE
and confirm accordingly.
9. 53-TMSS-01, The manufacturer details for cooling Fans shall be Detail information of cooling
Rev.2, Data provided and also it shall be from NG/SEC approved fan shall be submitted at
Schedule manufacturers. detail design stage.
Page 15 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
clause 4.14
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 54-TMSS-01 Rev. 2
10. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be stamped by the Noted. Revised data
manufacturer as well. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
11. - Dissolved gases in the oil shall be interpreted as per IEC 1. Dissolved gasses in the oil
60599. Test Report for Oil properties shall be submitted shall be interpreted as per IEC
for batch of oil to be filled complying to Table 2 of IEC 60599.
60296 during project execution stage. →IEC 60599 standard is
applicable for oil filled
electrical equipment in
service and not for new oil.
So this is not suitable for this
new project.

2. Test report for oil

properties shall be submitted
for batch of oil to be filled
complying to Table 2 of IEC
60296 during project
execution stage.
→Noted.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 53-TMSS-03 Rev. 0
12. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed & Noted. Revised data
stamped by the manufacturer as well. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
13. - The requirement, Online DGA shall be provided with Noted.

Page 16 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
direct redundant FO interface (dual port) without any
converter between DGA and SAS LAN
D. Compliance to Outline Diagram for 380/132/13.8kV, 500MVA Auto Transformer
1. The outline diagram for Power transformer not submitted. Please clarify the meaning of
outline diagram. If required
document is outline drawing,
please refer to submitted
outline drawing.
IV. Equipment: 3ph 60Hz 380kV 60MVAR ONAN Shunt reactor
Make: Hyosung Heavy Industries Corporation, Korea.
A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for 3ph 60Hz 380kV 60MVAR ONAN Shunt reactor
1. - Bidder’s compliance to Manufacturer’s responsibility
statement is noted with no deviations.

B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS

Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0
2. - Bidder’s compliance to SOW/PTS has been noted.
However, the protection requirements shall be submitted
separately for the review by respective department.
Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01, Rev. 3
3. - Bidder’s compliances to 01-TMSS-01, Rev.3 is noted.

Compliance Statement to 58-TMSS-01, Rev. 2

4. - Bidder’s compliances to 58-TMSS-01, Rev.2 is noted.

Page 17 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Compliance Statement to 53-TMSS-03, Rev. 0
5. - Bidder has mentioned as N/A as a compliances to 53-
TMSS-03. It must be clarified why the above standard is
Not Applicable (N/A)

Compliance Statement to 54-TMSS-01, Rev. 2

6. - Bidder has mentioned as N/A as a compliances to 54-
TMSS-01. It must be clarified why the above standard is
Not Applicable (N/A)
C. Compliance to Data Schedule
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 58-TMSS-01 Rev. 2
1. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed & sealed
by both Manufacturer & Contractor.
2. 58-TMSS-01, The reactance value for 100% and 110% of rated voltage
Rev.2, Data and zero sequence reactance value shall be given with
Schedule the particular clause reference from mentioned IEC and
clause 4.2 those references shall be filled under column ‘C’.
3. 58-TMSS-01, Temperature rise values shall be as per 01-TMSS-01, it
Rev.2, Data shall be cross verified and it must be clarified with the
Schedule particular clause reference where it is matching with.
clause 4.2
4. 58-TMSS-01, Maximum Design Flux Density at rated voltage and Flux
Rev.2, Data density at 110% of rated voltage shall be mentioned
Schedule along with the relevant clause numbers from the referred
clause 4.3.1 international standards or with the particular reference
from where the manufacturer chosen such values and
Page 18 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
those references shall be given under column ‘C’.
5. 58-TMSS-01, Knee Point in Magnetic flux versus Current curve (curve
Rev.2, Data to be enclosed) – Response from Bidder is YES. But,
Schedule there is no such curve with the data schedule. It shall be
clause 4.3.1 enclosed with the revised submittal.
6. 58-TMSS-01, The reference with clause number from technical
Rev.2, Data standards shall be provided under column ‘C’ for the
Schedule given values for Impulse withstand voltage, Power
clause 4.3.2 Frequency withstand voltage and Switching Impulse
withstand voltage. The requirement of NGR shall be
complied as per PTS requirement and the compliance
shall be modified accordingly.
7. 58-TMSS-01, The mentioned values for Guaranteed Losses shall be
Rev.2, Data within the acceptable limit and the supporting document
Schedule shall be provided to prove the mentioned value of losses.
clause 4.3.6 The IEC Clause reference also shall be mentioned under
column ‘C’ with the particular clause numbers.
8. 58-TMSS-01, It shall be confirmed that the accessories such as
Rev.2, Data Buchholz Relay, Pressure relief Device, WTI, OTI, OLI
Schedule and HV & Neutral Bushings shall be from the SEC/NG
clause 4.3.7 approved manufacturer.
to 4.3.13
9. 58-TMSS-01, The reference with clause number from technical
Rev.2, Data standards shall be provided under column ‘C’ for the
Schedule given values for BIL, Switching Impulse withstand
clause 4.3.23 voltage, Power Frequency withstand voltage, Creepage
distance and cantilever strength for each bushings.
10. 58-TMSS-01, It is mentioned that Contractor to Reply for some data
Page 19 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Rev.2, Data under the mentioned clause, which shall be filled by the
Schedule contractor and submitted along with the revised
clause 4.3.28, submittal.
4.3.29
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 54-TMSS-01 Rev. 2
11. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed &
stamped by the manufacturer and contractor.
12. - Dissolved gases in the oil shall be interpreted as per IEC
60599. Test Report for Oil properties shall be submitted
for batch of oil to be filled complying to Table 2 of IEC
60296 during project execution stage.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 53-TMSS-03 Rev. 0
13. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed &
stamped by the manufacturer and contractor.
14. - The requirement, Online DGA shall be provided with
direct redundant FO interface (dual port) without any
converter between DGA and SAS LAN.

15. 53-TMSS-03 Write up on Analysis Technique is not enclosed, which

Rev. 0, Data shall be submitted with the revised submittal.
Schedule
Clause 4.2
D. Compliance to Outline Diagram for 380kV, 60MVAR Shunt Reactor
1. - The outline diagram for shunt reactor shall be reviewed
during design stage. We cannot approve and fix any
proposal at this stage as this is LSTK project including
Engineering and Design.
Page 20 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS

V. Equipment: 3ph 60Hz 380kV 60MVAR ONAN Shunt reactor

Make: Hyundai Electric & Energy Systems Co., Ltd., Korea (Alternate Manufacturer)
A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for 3ph 60Hz 380kV 60MVAR ONAN Shunt reactor
1. - Bidder’s compliance to Manufacturer’s responsibility Noted.
statement is noted with no deviations.
B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS
Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0
1. - Bidder’s compliance with no deviations to SOW/PTS has Noted.
been noted.

Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01, Rev. 3

2. - Bidder’s compliances to 01-TMSS-01, Rev.3 is noted. Noted.

Compliance Statement to 58-TMSS-01, Rev. 2

3. - Bidder’s compliances to 58-TMSS-01, Rev.2 is noted and Noted.
It shall be fully complied with PTS requirements. Any
deviations by Manufacturer shall be complied by the
Manufacturer and accordingly the compliance statement
shall be updated.

Compliance Statement to 53-TMSS-03, Rev. 0

4. - Bidder’s compliance is noted. Any deviations to 53- Noted.
TMSS-03, Rev.0 shall be prepared separately and
submitted to SEC along with the technical proposal.

Page 21 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS

Compliance Statement to 54-TMSS-01, Rev. 2

5. - Bidder’s compliance is noted with no deviations. Noted.

C. Compliance to Data Schedule

Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 58-TMSS-01 Rev. 2
1. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed & sealed Noted. Revised data
by Manufacturer as well. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
2. 58-TMSS-01, The reactance value for 100% and 110% of rated voltage The value of zero sequence
Rev.2, Data and zero sequence reactance value shall be given with will be submitted at detail
Schedule the particular clause reference from mentioned IEC and design stage. Additionally,
clause 4.2 those references shall be filled under column ‘C’. revised data schedule will be
submitted at detail design
stage.
3. 58-TMSS-01, Temperature rise values shall be as per 01-TMSS-01, it Please be noted that
Rev.2, Data shall be cross verified and it must be clarified with the maximum ambient
Schedule particular clause reference where it is matching with. temperature is 55℃ for
clause 4.2 outdoor equipment. So
temperature rise limit shall
be deducted based on IEC
60076-02 table.2.
4. 58-TMSS-01, Maximum Design Flux Density at rated voltage and Flux Based on 58-TMSS-01,
Rev.2, Data density at 110% of rated voltage shall be mentioned Rev.2 clause 4.3.1.b,
Schedule along with the relevant clause numbers from the referred maximum flux density of
clause 4.3.1 international standards or with the particular reference core is 1.4T. Please check.

Page 22 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
from where the manufacturer chosen such values and
those references shall be given under column ‘C’.
5. 58-TMSS-01, Knee Point in Magnetic flux versus Current curve (curve It shall be submitted at detail
Rev.2, Data to be enclosed) – Response from Bidder is YES. But, design stage.
Schedule there is no such curve with the data schedule. It shall be
clause 4.3.1 enclosed with the revised submittal.
6. 58-TMSS-01, The reference with clause number from technical Please be noted that those
Rev.2, Data standards shall be provided under column ‘C’ for the values are based on 01-
Schedule given values for Impulse withstand voltage, Power TMSS-01, Rev.3 and IEC
clause 4.3.2 Frequency withstand voltage and Switching Impulse 60076-10. Revised data
withstand voltage. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
7. 58-TMSS-01, The mentioned values for Guaranteed Losses shall be Please clarify the acceptable
Rev.2, Data within the acceptable limit and the supporting document limit value for no load loss
Schedule shall be provided to prove the mentioned value of losses. and load loss.
clause 4.3.6 The IEC Clause reference also shall be mentioned under
column ‘C’ with the particular clause numbers.
8. 58-TMSS-01, It shall be confirmed that the accessories such as Confirmed.
Rev.2, Data Buchholz Relay, Pressure relief Device, WTI, OTI, OLI
Schedule and HV & Neutral Bushings shall be from the SEC/NG
clause 4.3.7 approved manufacturer.
to 4.3.13
9. 58-TMSS-01, The reference with clause number from technical Please be noted that those
Rev.2, Data standards shall be provided under column ‘C’ for the values are based on 01-
Schedule given values for BIL, Switching Impulse withstand TMSS-01, Rev.3 and IEC
clause 4.3.23 voltage, Power Frequency withstand voltage, Creepage 60076-10. Revised data
distance and cantilever strength for each bushings. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
Page 23 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
10. 58-TMSS-01, It is mentioned that the particular clause is not under Noted. Revised data
Rev.2, Data manufacturer’s scope and in such a case, the contractor schedule will be submitted at
Schedule shall comply it and compliance statement shall be detail design stage.
clause4.3.29 revised accordingly.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 54-TMSS-01 Rev. 2
11. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be stamped by the Noted. Revised data
manufacturer. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
12. - Dissolved gases in the oil shall be interpreted as per IEC 1. Dissolved gasses in the oil
60599. Test Report for Oil properties shall be submitted shall be interpreted as per IEC
for batch of oil to be filled complying with Table 2 of IEC 60599.
60296 during project execution stage. →IEC 60599 standard is
applicable for oil filled
electrical equipment in
service and not for new oil.
So this is not suitable for this
new project.

2. Test report for oil

properties shall be submitted
for batch of oil to be filled
complying to Table 2 of IEC
60296 during project
execution stage.
→Noted.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 53-TMSS-03 Rev. 0
13. - Each sheet of the data schedule shall be signed & Noted. Revised data
Page 24 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
stamped by the manufacturer and contractor. schedule will be submitted at
detail design stage.
14. - The requirement, Online DGA shall be provided with Noted.
direct redundant FO interface (dual port) without any
converter between DGA and SAS LAN.

D. Compliance to Outline Diagram for 380kV, 60MVAR Shunt Reactor

1. - The outline diagram for shunt reactor is not attached and
Please clarify the meaning of
it shall be submitted with revised submittal. outline diagram. If required
document is outline drawing,
please refer to submitted
outline drawing.
VI. Equipment: 132kV Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS), Type of GIS: ELK-04 C/145kV
Make: Hitachi Energy, Saudi Arabia
Document Ref: Technical Quotation QT-22-00837731

1. PTS: Section The VT Burden shall be 100VA as per PTS, which shall
III, Clause be complied. Manufacturer has complied as per the data
2.C.c.7 schedule for 32-TMSS-02, Rev.2, Clause 4.13 and it shall
be complied here as well.
2. General It shall be noted that the control cables and their cross
section used for the connection between the switchgear
and the LCC shall be submitted during design stage for
further review and approval.
3. PTS: Confirm to supply the special tools as per PTS
Appendix- requirements. Appendix-XIII. One (1) set of special tools
XIII shall be supplied to each 132kV GIS#2 and 132kV GIS#3

Page 25 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
as both are located in different locations.

4. General It shall be noted that the earthing arrangement for GIS

shall be submitted during design stage for further review
and approval.
5. General It shall be noted that, the division of work shall be
mutually agreed between the BSP Contractor and the
vendor/manufacturer and any deviations shall be notified
to SEC separately before awarding the contract.
A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for 132kV Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS), Type of GIS: ELK-04 C/145kV

1. - Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility is missing.

B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS

Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01 Rev. 3
1. - Bidder’s compliance for 01-TMSS-01, Rev.3 is noted.
Compliance Statement to 38-TMSS-07, Rev. 1
2. Bidder has to reply for any out of scope supply by
Manufacturer i.e. PD monitoring system for GIS
Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0
3. PTS- The VT Burden shall be 100VA as per PTS shall be
SECTION- complied. Manufacturer has complied as per the data
III,Clause:2.C schedule for 32-TMSS-02, Rev.2, Clause 4.13
.c.7
4. PTS- It shall be noted that the Quantity & Location of 132kV
SECTION- GIS Surge arrestors shall be decided as per
III, Clause EMTDC/insulation coordination study during design

Page 26 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
2.C.c.8 stage. If the above studies/calculations are not by
Manufacturer’s scope, it shall be complied by the
contractor and compliance statement shall be revised
accordingly.
5. PTS- It shall be noted that the GIB routings are shown in the
SECTION- tender layout CT- 920223, Rev.0 is tentative only and
III, Clause actual shall be confirmed during design stage. However,
2.C.c.11 we have revised 132kV GIS#1 & 2 layout by showing
the GIB routings for only RE developer feeders and for
rest of the feeders only duct banks have been considered.
Bidder has to follow as per Amendment-1.
6. PTS- The partial discharge monitoring sensors for the proposed
SECTION- equipment as per PTS shall be integrated with the On-line
III, Clause Partial Discharge
2.D. Monitoring System for existing/ongoing phase-1 or
otherwise a separate new standalone online PDMS require
under this PTS, if it can’t be integrated with the existing
system. Confirm to comply.
7. PTS- Bidder has mentioned that Special tools have been not
APPENDIX- included since they have been already provided with the
XIII, original GIS. We have noted it and bidder needs to
confirm to supply the same special tools as specified in
PTS#22CR328, Appendix-XIII for each 132kV GIS#2
and 132kV GIS#3 as both shall be installed in different
locations.
8. PTS- Bidder has to consider the revised 132kV GIS#2 &
APPENDIX- 132kV GIS#3 SLD and Layouts as per the Amendment-
I, 1.
Page 27 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1
9. 32-TMSS-05, Compliance statement for 32-TMSS-05, Rev.1 is missing.
Rev.1
Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2
10. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be noted that the Quantity & Location of 132kV
Rev.2, Clause GIS Surge arrestors shall be decided as per
4.18.1 EMTDC/insulation coordination study during design
stage. If such study not included in Manufacturer’s
scope, it shall be complied by the main contractor and
compliance shall be revised accordingly.

11. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be clarified with the approval reference for sub-
Rev.2, Clause suppliers for the components and attach the relevant
4.23.5 approved list of sub suppliers.
12. 32-TMSS-02, Submit the type test report for our references.
Rev.2, Clause
4.23.5
C. Compliance to Data Schedule
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2 -
1. 32-TMSS-02, Each sheet of the same data schedule shall be signed &
Rev.2, Data sealed by both Manufacturer & Contractor.
Schedule
2. 32-TMSS-02, Each mentioned data shall be revised corresponding to
Rev.2, Data the units with the respective temperature or duration (in
Schedule Seconds)
clause 4.9
Page 28 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
3. 32-TMSS-02, As mentioned in Data Schedule Page 62 of 62, other
Rev.2, Data particulars shall be filled in column ‘C’ by the bidder
Schedule such as the technical reference with clause number for
each data given by the bidder under clause 4.2, 4.4, 4.5,
4.9, 4.10, 4.11 i.e. Clause Reference from technical
standards for each given data shall be provided.
4. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be clarified with the approval reference for sub-
Rev.2, Data suppliers for the components and attach the relevant
Schedule approved list of sub suppliers.
clause 4.11,
4.12, 4.13,
4.15, 4.16,
4.18
5. 32-TMSS-02, Bidders has not mentioned anything under Special tools
Rev.2, Data –SF6 Gas Maintenance Cart. Special tools for each 132
Schedule kV GIS#2 & 132kV GIS#3 shall be considered
clause 6.0 separately as both GIS shall be installed in different
locations.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 38-TMSS-07 Rev. 1
6. Compliance statement for 38-TMSS-07, Rev.1 data
schedule is missing.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1
7. Compliance statement for 32-TMSS-05, Rev.1 data
schedule is missing.
D. Compliance to SLD & Layout
1. The Single Line & Gas Schematic Diagram and GIS

Page 29 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Layout & Requirements shall be reviewed during design
stage. We cannot approve and fix any proposal at this
stage as this is LSTK project including Engineering and
Design. However, bidder has to modify the layout &
diagrams based on the relevant modifications in 132kV
GIB routing as per the revised substation layout &
132kV SLD attached with Amendment-1 and submit
with the revised submittals.
VII. Equipment: 132kV Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS), Type of GIS: 145SP-3
Make: Hyundai Electric & Energy Systems Co., Ltd., Korea

A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for 132kV Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS)
1. - Bidder’s compliances are noted with do deviations on Please refer to attachment #1
Manufacturer’s responsibility statement. However, the for the revised manufacture’s
type of 132kV GIS/GIL shall be mentioned with the responsibility statement.
revised document.

B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS

Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01 Rev. 3
1. - Bidder’s compliance for 01-TMSS-01 is noted with no Noted.
deviations.
Compliance Statement to 38-TMSS-07, Rev. 1
2. Bidder has to reply for any out of scope supply by Partial discharge monitoring
Manufacturer. Bidder has mentioned in PTS Compliance sensors are included in
statement for PTS-SECTION-III, Clause: 2.D that, On- 132KV GIS & shall be
line PDMS and HFCT PD sensors shall be supplied by integrated with the On-line
main contractor. In such a cases, the relevant portions of Partial Discharge Monitoring
Page 30 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
38-TMSS-07, Rev.1 shall be filled by the contractor and System for existing/ongoing
submitted with the revised submittal. phase-1.
If it can’t be integrated with
the existing system, then
PDMS technical offer from
SEC approved & pre-
qualified list will be submitted
at base design stage for SEC
review & approval.
Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0

3. - PTS No. shall be corrected with the title of the Please refer to attachment for
document. the revised compliance
statement.
4. PTS- Bidder’s query about VT quantity is noted. We We did not receive
SECTION- recommend to follow the revised SLD for 132kV GIS#2 Amendment-1 during
III,Clause:2.C and 132kV GIS#3 attached with Amendment-1. If any bidding stage.
.c.6 further clarifications on VT quantity, shall be discussed
with the next cycle of post bid clarifications based on
bidder’s response.
5. PTS- The VT Burden shall be as per PTS. Bidder to confirm to Confirmed.
SECTION- comply accordingly.
III,Clause:2.C
.c.7
6. PTS- It shall be noted that the Quantity & Location of 132kV We did not receive
SECTION- GIS Surge arrestors shall be decided as per Amendment-1 during
III, Clause EMTDC/insulation coordination study during design bidding stage.
2.C.c.9 stage. However, Bidder has to consider the Surge arrestor
Page 31 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
requirements based on the revised 132kV GIS #2 & 132kv
GIS#3 SLD attached with amendment-1.
7. PTS- It shall be noted that the GIB routings are shown in the We did not receive
SECTION- tender layout CT- 920223, Rev.0 is tentative only and Amendment-1 during
III, Clause actual shall be confirmed during design stage. However, bidding stage.
2.C.c.10 we have revised 132kV GIS#1 & 2 layout by showing
the GIB routings for only RE developer feeders and for
rest of the feeders only duct banks have been considered.
Bidder has to follow as per Amendment-1.
8. PTS- The partial discharge monitoring sensors for the proposed Confirmed.
SECTION- equipment as per PTS and it shall be integrated with the
III, Clause On-line Partial Discharge Monitoring System for
2.D. existing/ongoing phase-1 or otherwise a separate new
standalone online PDMS require under this PTS, if it can’t
be integrated with the existing system. Confirm to
comply.
9. PTS- Bidder has to confirm to supply the same special tools as As per pre-bid clarification
APPENDIX- specified in PTS#22CR328, Appendix-XIII separately for #1, S/N 82, one set of special
XIII, each 132kV GIS#2 and 132kV GIS#3 as both GIS have to tools for 132 kV GIS is
be separately installed in different locations. required.
10. PTS- Bidder has to consider the revised SLD and Layouts as We did not receive
APPENDIX- per the Amendment-1. Amendment-1 during
I, bidding stage.
11. - Bidder has mentioned that the Outdoor equipment (Tublar Confirmed, please refer to
Conductor, Outdoor surge arresters, free standing current the attachment.
transformer, Aluminium bus bars, Termination Hardware,
Ring/Split core C.T's for TEE protection, XLPE/Air
terminations (Cable Pot Heads), etc.) were excluded from
Page 32 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
GIS supplier's scope. In such a case, it shall be confirmed
that the above will be supplied by the main contractor and
compliance statement updated accordingly.
Compliance Statement to 31-TMSS-06 Rev. 1
12. Bidder’s compliance to 31-TMSS-06, Rev.1 is noted Noted.
with no deviations.
Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1
13. 32-TMSS-05, Compliance statement for 32-TMSS-05, Rev.1 is missing. For 145 kV GIB, it will be as
Rev.1 per 145 kV GIS PQ (32-
TMSS-02, Rev.02).
Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2
14. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be noted that the Quantity & Location of 132kV Confirmed.
Rev.2, ClauseGIS Surge arrestors shall be decided as per
4.18.1 EMTDC/insulation coordination study during design
stage. It shall be confirmed by the contractor and the
compliance statement shall be revised accordingly.
15. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be clarified with the approval reference for sub- Confirmed. Sub-supplier list
Rev.2, Clause suppliers for the components and attach the relevant will be provided for SEC
4.23.5 approved list of sub suppliers. approval in design stage.
C. Compliance to Data Schedule
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2 -
1. 32-TMSS-02, Each sheet of the same data schedule shall be signed & Confirmed, please refer to
Rev.2, Data sealed by both Manufacturer & Contractor. the attachment.
Schedule
2. 32-TMSS-02, As mentioned in Data Schedule Page 62 of 62, other Confirmed, please refer to
Rev.2, Data particulars shall be filled in column ‘C’ by the bidder the attachment.
Page 33 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
Schedule such as the technical reference with clause number for
each data given by the bidder under clause 4.1, 4.2, 4.4,
4.5, 4.9, 4.10, 4.11 i.e. Clause Reference from technical
standards for each given data shall be provided.
3. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be clarified with the approval reference for the Confirmed, please refer to
Rev.2, Data components and attach the relevant approved list for the attachment.
Schedule such components mentioned under 32-TMSS-02, Rev.2,
clause 4.11, Data Schedule clause 4.11, 4.12, 4.13, 4.15, 4.16, 4.18.
4.12, 4.13,
4.15, 4.16,
4.18
4. 32-TMSS-02, Bidder to confirm that the Special tools for each 132 kV As per PTS & pre-bid
Rev.2, Data GIS#2 & 132kV GIS#3 shall be supplied separately as clarification #1, S/N 82,
Schedule both GIS shall be installed in different locations. only one set of special tools
clause 6.0 for 132 kV GIS shall be
submitted along with the bid.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 38-TMSS-07 Rev. 1
5. - Each sheet of Compliance statement for 38-TMSS-07, Confirmed, please refer to
Rev.1 data schedule shall be signed and sealed by both the attachment.
manufacturer and contractor.
6. - The clause number from the respective technical standards Please refer to attachment
with clause number shall be mentioned under column ‘C’ for revised data schedule
particular to Power frequency with stand voltage and #5 for test report of UHF
mentioned under clause 5.1 of data schedule 38-TMSS- PD sensor during SEC PQ.
07, Rev.1.

Page 34 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
7. - Bidder has mentioned in PTS Compliance statement for Partial discharge monitoring
PTS-SECTION-III, Clause: 2.D that, On-line PDMS and sensors are included in
HFCT PD sensors shall be supplied by main contractor. In 132KV GIS & shall be
such a cases, the relevant portions of 38-TMSS-07, Rev.1 integrated with the On-line
shall be filled by the contractor and submitted with the Partial Discharge Monitoring
revised submittal. System for existing/ongoing
phase-1.
If it can’t be integrated with
the existing system, then
PDMS technical offer from
SEC approved & pre-
qualified list will be
submitted at base design
stage for SEC review &
approval.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1
8. Compliance statement for 32-TMSS-05, Rev.1 data For 145 kV GIB, it will be as
schedule is missing. per 145 kV GIS PQ (32-
TMSS-02, Rev.02).
D. Compliance to SLD & Layout
1. The Single Line & Gas Schematic Diagram and GIS We did not receive
Layout & Requirements shall be reviewed during design Amendment-1 during
stage. We cannot approve and fix any proposal at this bidding stage.
stage as this is LSTK project including Engineering and
Design. However, bidder has to modify the layout &
diagrams based on the relevant modifications in 132kV
GIB routing as per the revised substation layout &
Page 35 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
132kV SLD attached with Amendment-1
VIII. Equipment: 132kV Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS), Type of GIS: HSG-144D
Make: Hyosung Heavy Industries Corporation, Korea

A. Compliance on Manufacturer’s responsibility statement for 132kV Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS)
1. - Noted with do deviations on Manufacturer’s responsibility
statement. The type of 132kV GIS/GIL shall be
mentioned with the revised document. Also 132kV GIL
shall be included with manufacturer’s responsibility
statement.

B. Compliance to SOW /PTS and TMSS /SMSS

Compliance Statement to 01-TMSS-01 Rev. 3
1. 01-TMSS-01 Bidder’s compliance for 01-TMSS-01, Rev.3 is noted
Rev. 3, Clause with no deviations.
2.1
Compliance Statement to 38-TMSS-07, Rev. 1
2. Bidder’s compliance to 38-TMSS-07, Rev.1 is missing.
Compliance Statement to PTS#22CR328, Rev. 0
3. PTS- OHTL & U/G Cable feeders have been revised since
SECTION- there is no ROW for SEC OHTL feeders and those
III,Clause:2.C feeders have been revised as U/G cable feeders. Bidder
.b has to consider the latest proposal based on
Amendment#1.
4. PTS- CT-920222, CT-920223 revised latest drawings from
Appendix-I Amendment#1 shall be followed.
Page 36 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
5. PTS- Bidder’s query about VT quantity is noted. We
SECTION- recommend to follow the revised SLD for 132kV GIS#2
III,Clause:2.C and 132kV GIS#3 attached with Amendment-1. If any
.c.6 further clarifications on VT quantity, shall be discussed
with the next cycle of post bid clarifications based on
bidder’s response.
6. PTS- The VT Burden shall be 100VA as per PTS. Bidder to
SECTION- confirm to comply accordingly.
III,Clause:2.C
.c.7
7. PTS- It shall be noted that the Quantity & Location of 132kV
SECTION- GIS Surge arrestors shall be decided as per
III, Clause EMTDC/insulation coordination study during design
2.C.c.8 stage. However, Bidder has to consider the Surge arrestor
requirements based on the revised 132kV GIS #2 & 132kv
GIS#3 SLD attached with amendment-1
8. PTS- It shall be noted that the GIB routings are shown in the
SECTION- tender layout CT- 920223, Rev.0 is tentative only and
III, Clause actual shall be confirmed during design stage. However,
2.C.c.11 we have revised 132kV GIS#1 & 2 layout by showing
the GIB routings for only RE developer feeders and for
rest of the feeders only duct banks have been considered.
Bidder has to follow as per Amendment-1.
9. PTS- The partial discharge monitoring sensors for the proposed
SECTION- equipment shall be as per PTS requirements and it shall be
III, Clause integrated with the On-line Partial Discharge Monitoring
2.D. System for existing/ongoing phase-1 or otherwise a
separate new standalone online PDMS require under this
Page 37 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
PTS, if it can’t be integrated with the existing system.
Confirm to comply.
10. PTS- Bidder has to confirm to supply the special tools as
APPENDIX- specified in PTS#22CR328, Appendix-XIII separately for
XIII, each 132kV GIS#2 and 132kV GIS#3 as both GIS shall
be installed in different locations.
11. General Bidder has to mention about the scope of supply of
Outdoor equipment (Tublar Conductor, Outdoor surge
arresters, free standing current transformer, Aluminium
bus bars, Termination Hardware, Ring/Split core C.T's for
TEE protection, XLPE/Air terminations(Cable Pot
Heads), etc

Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1

12. 32-TMSS-05, Compliance statement for 32-TMSS-05, Rev.1 is missing.
Rev.1
Compliance Statement to 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2
13. 32-TMSS-02, Bidder’s compliances for 32-TMSS-02, Rev.2 , clause
Rev.2, Clause 4.22. is noted. For integration of PD sensors, contractor
4.22.2 has to add their compliance with it.
14. 32-TMSS-02, Special tools shall be supplied for each 132kV GIS#2 &
Rev.2, Clause 132kV GIS#3 as each GIS is installed in different rooms.
6.1.1
C. Compliance to Data Schedule
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-02 Rev. 2 -

Page 38 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
1. 32-TMSS-02, As mentioned in Data Schedule Page 62 of 62, other
Rev.2, Data particulars shall be filled in column ‘C’ by the bidder
Schedule such as the technical reference with clause number for
each data given by the bidder under clause 4.1, 4.2, 4.4,
4.5, 4.9, 4.10, 4.11 i.e. Clause Reference from technical
standards for each given data shall be provided.
2. 32-TMSS-02, It shall be clarified with the approval reference for the
Rev.2, Data components and attach the relevant approved list for
Schedule such components mentioned under 32-TMSS-02, Rev.2,
clause 4.11, Data Schedule clause 4.11, 4.12, 4.13, 4.15, 4.16, 4.18 .
4.12, 4.13,
4.15, 4.16,
4.18
3. 32-TMSS-02, Bidder to confirm that the Special tools for each 132 kV
Rev.2, Data GIS#2 & 132kV GIS#3 shall be supplied.
Schedule
clause 6.0
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 38-TMSS-07 Rev. 1
4. Compliance statement for 38-TMSS-07, Rev.1 data
schedule is missing.
Compliance Statement to Data Schedule under 32-TMSS-05 Rev. 1
5. Compliance statement for 32-TMSS-05, Rev.1 data
schedule is missing.
D. Compliance to SLD & Layout
1. The Single Line & Gas Schematic Diagram and GIS
Layout & Requirements shall be submitted separately for

Page 39 of 40
 RFX 4000071727
EXPANSION OF AR RASS PV 380/132kV BSP#9095 – Technical Proposal Review
Subject: S& ESD Com m ents on TECHNICAL PR OPOSAL from AL-BABTAIN
Department/Division: PCDD/S&ESD
CONTR ACTING CO., Saudi Arabia
ITEM PTS/CLAUSE/ CONCLUSION
SEC COMMENTS BIDDER’S REPLY SEC REPLY
NO. PAGE NO. / REMARKS
132kV GIS#2 & 132kV GIS#3 and it shall be reviewed
during design stage. We cannot approve and fix any
proposal at this stage as this is LSTK project including
Engineering and Design. However, bidder has to modify
the layout & diagrams based on the relevant
modifications in 132kV GIB routing as per the revised
substation layout & 132kV GIS #2 & #3 SLD attached
with Amendment-1
IX. Equipment: 13.8kV Grounding transformer
Make: Hyundai Electric & Energy Systems Co., Ltd., Korea

1. General We found manufacturer’s compliances on 13.8kV Noted.

Grounding transformer and we hadn’t reviewed such
related compliances, since the grounding transformers
are not required as clarified with pre-bid clarification.

Page 40 of 40