CEMP Appendix A Smoke Management Plan Rev5 20210914
CEMP Appendix A Smoke Management Plan Rev5 20210914
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Revision History ............................................................................................................. 5
Abbreviations and Acronyms ...................................................................................... 10
Glossary ....................................................................................................................... 11
1.0 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 14
1.1 Objectives .................................................................................................. 14
2.0 Regulatory Context ........................................................................................... 14
2.1 Provincial Legislation .................................................................................. 14
2.1.1 Environmental Management Act and Open Burning Smoke Control
Regulation ........................................................................................ 14
2.1.2 Wildfire Act and Wildfire Regulation................................................... 15
2.2 Site-C – Specific Conditions........................................................................ 15
2.2.1 Federal Decision Statement .............................................................. 15
2.2.2 Environmental Assessment Certificate Schedule B – Table of
Conditions ........................................................................................ 15
3.0 Scope................................................................................................................. 15
4.0 General Requirements ...................................................................................... 16
4.1 Identify Sensitivity Zones ............................................................................ 17
4.2 Material to be Burned.................................................................................. 17
4.3 Timing of Burning ....................................................................................... 18
4.4 Setback Distances...................................................................................... 18
4.5 Burn Criteria ............................................................................................... 21
4.5.1 Division 1 – Open Burning by High, Medium, and Low Smoke
Sensitivity Zones............................................................................... 22
4.5.2 Division 5 – Open Burning Using Air Curtain Incinerators ................... 24
4.5.3 Venting Forecasts............................................................................. 25
4.5.3.1 Venting Forecast Sources........................................................... 26
4.5.4 Burn Duration / Burning Period .......................................................... 27
4.5.5 Change in Burning Conditions ........................................................... 28
4.6 Burn Registration ........................................................................................ 28
4.6.1 Category 3 Piles ............................................................................... 28
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1. Setback Distances ............................................................................................ 18
Table 3. Burn Criteria for Open Burning Completed Under Division 1 by High, Medium,
and Low Smoke Sensitivity Zones. ........................................................... 22
Table 5. Burn Criteria for Open Burning Under Division 5, Using Air Curtain Incinerators . 25
Table 7. Example Open Burning Pre-Burn Checklist for Category 2 and Category 3 Fires.
The Pre-Burn Checklist may be Modified or Adapted to Better Suit Aerial
Ignitions................................................................................................... 36
Table 9. Burn Tracking Form, including an example entry. Ignitions on different parcels,
different geographic location or Smoke Sensitivity Zone, or difference in
Burn Category (Category 2 / Category 3) would necessitate additional
entries or additional forms. An asterisk (*) indicates reporting requirements
from the OBSCR...................................................................................... 42
Table 10. An example of an acceptable burn period / smoke release monitoring form. ..... 43
Table 11. Geographical Units and Key Stakeholders for Notification. Contacts for key
stakeholders are found in Section 7.3. ...................................................... 45
Table 12. Key contacts for notification, party responsible for notification, and primary
method of notification. .............................................................................. 47
Revision History
Version Date Comments
Rev 2 March • Table detailing revision history to align with requirements in the CEMP S. 2.4.
2018 • Rationale f or edits to align with requirements in the CEMP S. 2.4.
• Add references to relevant legislation, as footnotes.
• Ref ormat and change order of content. Section changes are noted in revision
history table.
• Replace ‘Primary’ and ‘Secondary Smoke Sensitivity Zones’ with ‘Category A’ and
‘Category B Areas’, respectively, to align plan with wording and definitions used in
currently enacted legislation.
• Reduce scope of document; remove vegetation clearing activities, which are
guided by the Vegetation Clearing and Debris Management Plan (VCDMP).
Remove ref erences to VCDMP and all vegetation clearing activities which are
guided by the VCDMP.
• Move content in Appendices to body of document.
• Add definitions for BCWS, CEMP, EIS, MFLNRORD (update to reflect current
Ministry name), and VI. Delete definitions for acronyms VCDMP, PM 2.5, PSSZ,
SSSZ and reformatting and alphabetization (Abbreviations and Acronyms).
• Clarif y regulatory framework applicable to burning activities. Remove guidance
provided by OBSCR policy intentions. Addition of Wildfire Act and Wildfire
Regulation and Site-C conditions (Federal Decision Statement and Schedule B -
Table of Conditions). Add potential for ‘substitute requirements’ if new legislation is
enacted during the project (S. 2.1 / S. 2.1.1, 2.1.2, 2.2)
• Separate regulatory framework from plan scope to simplify plan organization (S.
2.0 / S. 2.0, 3.0)
• Remove vegetation clearing activities from plan scope (S. 2.2 / S. 3.0).
• Remove Vegetation Activities by Project Area; activities guided by VCDMP (S.3.0 /
N/A).
• Clarif y and distinguish in the plan those components that are: required by
legislation or are required as BMPs to meet open burning / smoke condition
objectives. Rename section to better reflect the contents. Removed reference to
VCDMP and ref erences to potential, future regulations. Changes align plan to
currently enacted legislation, remove irrelevant ref erences, clarify regulatory
requirements, and provide contractors and monitors operational best practices to
meet or exceed smoke management objectives (S. 4.0 / S 4.0).
• Clarif ication of annual burn program planning requirements. Content split into
subsections. Addition of prioritization of areas under good venting conditions (S.
4.2 / S. 5.1.1, 5.1.2).
• Change 'to be determined' to 'may be determined’ to more accurately reflect the
ground truthing activities and communications which have occurred since Ver. 1
(S. 4.3 / S. 5.1.3).
• Add ‘schools in session, identified sensitive receptors, and continuing health care
centres’ as land use requiring minimum 1,000 m setback. Add list of identified
sensitive receptors. Changes are to remain consistent with the categories outlined
in currently enacted legislation (OBSCR), Appendix B of the CEMP, Appendix L of
the EIS, and Condition 57. Add allowance for application to relax minimum
MFLNRORD….Ministry of Forests, Lands, and Natural Resource Operations and Rural Development
Glossary1
Burnt surface area: the area that is underneath or surrounding the remains of a fire and
covered by charred or smoldering vegetative debris.
Community Care Facility4: premises or part of a premises (a) in which a person provides car e
to 3 or more persons who are not related by blood or marriage to the person and includes any
other premises or part of a premises that, in the opinion of the medical health officer, is used in
conjunction with the community care facility for the purpose of providing care, or (b) designated
by the Lieutenant Governor in Council to be a community care facility.
Custom ventilation forecast: a forecast of the atmosphere’s ability in a geographic area to
disperse smoke and which is (a) obtained from a custom ventilation forecaster, and (b)
submitted by email to the ministry, using the email address made known by the ministry for the
purposes of receiving custom ventilation forecasts, before starting open burning. 5
1 Unless otherwise noted, all definitions in the glossary are from BC Reg 405/19 Part 1 – Definitions.
2 BC Reg 38/2005, s. 1(1)
3 BC Reg 38/2005, s. 1(1)
4 Community Care and Assisted Living Act S.B.C. 2002, c. 75, parts 1 and 3 and BC Reg 405/19, Part 1.
5 BC Reg 405/19, s. 16
Dry basis moisture content: with respect to a given amount of vegetative debris, means the
weight of moisture contained in the vegetative debris divided by the weight of the vegetative
debris if the vegetative debris was dry, with both weights measured in the same weight units,
multiplied by 100 and expressed as a percentage.
End (with regards to open burning): (a) if the open burning is being done using an air curtain
incinerator, the point in time when the fire in the air curtain incinerator is emitting s moke from no
more than 10% of the base of the air curtain incinerator, and (b) respecting all other open
burning, the point in time when each pile of vegetative debris has ceased flaming and is emitting
smoke from no more than 10% of its burnt surface area;
Fire suppression system6: a system for suppressing fire by delivering: (a) water, (b) a
suppressant, (c) a surfactant, or (d) any combination of the substances (a) to (c) and may
include a water delivery system.
High smoke sensitivity zone: (a) land in the province that is outlined and shaded in pink and
labelled ‘High Smoke Sensitivity Zone’ in the legend, on a map listed in Schedule 3 except all
areas of that land that are designated under section 7 as being a medium smoke sensitivity
zone or a low smoke sensitivity zone, and;
(b) all areas of land that are designated under section 7 as being a high smoke sensitivity zone”.
Low smoke sensitivity zone: land in the province that is not a high smoke sensitivity zone or a
medium smoke sensitivity zone.
Medium smoke sensitivity zone: ( a) land in the province that is outlined and shaded in
yellow, and labelled "Medium Smoke Sensitivity Zone" in the legend, on a map listed in
Schedule 3 except all areas of that land that are designated under section 7 as being a high
smoke sensitivity zone or low smoke sensitivity zone, and
(b) all areas of land that are designated under section 7 as being a medium smoke sensitivity
zone”.
Opacity7: the degree to which smoke obscures the view of an object in the background,
expressed numerically from 0% (transparent) to 100% (opaque).8
Seasonal residence9: a fixed residence that, while not being occupied on a full-time basis, is
occupied on a regular basis. A regular basis does not imply a scheduled occupancy but implies
use of six weeks per year or more. The residence must not be mobile and should have some
sort of foundation or features of permanence (e.g., electrical power, domestic water supply,
septic system) associated with it. Summer cottages or mobile homes are examples of
seasonally occupied dwellings, while a holiday trailer simply pulled onto a sit e is not.
Seasoned vegetative debris: vegetative debris that (a) has been dried to the extent that the
dry basis moisture content is 30% or less, (b) has been put in piles for a period of at least 4
months, or (c) has originated from standing dead timber.
Water delivery system10: a system that can (a) deliver a sufficient volume of water to
effectively fight a fire of a reasonably foreseeable size, taking all factors into consideration,
including the conditions of the area where the water delivery system may need to be used, and
(b) deliver water to any place at the site of an industrial activity, on the burn area or the high risk
activity, or reasonably adjacent to the burn area or the site of a high risk activity.
1.0 Introduction
As part of the planning associated with the Site C Clean Energy Project (the Project), and the
environmental assessment process, a Smoke Management Plan (SMP) was developed and
submitted with the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) (BC Hydro 2013) and currently exists
as Appendix A of the Construction Environmental Management Plan (CEMP).11 The SMP
describes how project-related burning will be conducted compliant with the most current British
Columbia Ministry of Environment Open Burning Smoke Control Regu lation (OBSCR) and other
relevant regulatory requirements, outlines best management practices to reduce smoke
emissions and mitigate air quality impacts from burning, and remains in accordance with the
Site C Clean Energy Project Construction Environmental Management Plan (CEMP), section
5.1 Air Quality Management, which states:
• Manage smoke from the burning of clearing debris in accordance with the Smoke
Management Plan (Appendix A).
1.1 Objectives
The objectives of the SMP are as follows:
• Outline regulatory requirements of open burning activities;
• Detail Best Management Practices to avoid, mitigate, or minimize the emissions of
smoke and particulates from open burning; and,
• Ensure consistency and compliance with all relevant provincial and federal conditions
mandated as part of the environmental assessment process.
Under the authority of the Environmental Management Act12, the BC Ministry of Environment
(MOE) has the mandate to regulate smoke emissions from open burning activities through the
application of the Open Burning Smoke Control Regulation13 (OBSCR). The OBSCR is divided
into the Part 1 – Interpretation and Application, Part 2 – General Requirements for Open
Burning, Part 3 – Specific Requirements for Open Burning, Part 4 – Substituted Requirements,
Part 5 – Air Protection Measures, and Part 6 - Miscellaneous. The Open Burning Smoke Control
Regulation 405/19 is under effect as of September 15, 2019 and has replaced the repealed
Open Burning Smoke Control Regulation 145/93. Revision 3 (November 2019) of the SMP is to
reflect the regulatory changes reflected in the recently enacted OBSCR. This plan may need to
be reviewed and updated to reflect any future changes in legislation.
11 B.C. Hydro. 2016. Construction Environmental Management Plan, Site C Clean Energy Project Revision 4.
12 Environmental Management Act S.B.C. 2003, c. 53
13 BC Reg 405/19
3.0 Scope
The smoke management plan outlines the practices for burning clean woody / vegetative debris
(open burning) to manage the effects of smoke emissions from burning, to reduce the risk of an
escape, and to meet all regulatory requirements relevant to open burning. The scope of the
smoke management plan is limited to open burning practices implemented as part of the Site C
Clean Energy Project.
1. general requirements;
3. material to be burned;
4. timing of burning;
Best Management Practices (BMPs) are intended to provide operational direction to, as much
as practicable, promote fast and efficient burns which minimize the amount of smoke generated
and confine smoke emissions as much as possible to periods with favourable venting thereby
minimizing potential impacts of smoke from burning activities, and minimize the chance of fire
escape. BMPs are outlined in Sections 5.0, 6.0, and 7.0 include direction in the following areas:
3. pre-burn protocols;
4. light-up procedures;
18 BC Reg. 405/19
To identify the relevant sensitivity zone, use the provincial interactive mapping application found
here:
https://governmentofbc.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=6d288bc667b2452
8a5c1e3b4c0373d07.
The smoke sensitivity zone and relevant operational requirements (burn criteria) for open
burning is designated per pile and by pile location.19
In areas where operations vary between the two Category of burns (Category 2 and Category
3), differences will be noted, else, practices and operations will be the same.
Prior to open burning, BCH and the contractor must ensure that every reasonable alternative for
reducing, reusing, or recycling the vegetative debris has been used in order to minimize the
amount of debris burned. 21 Vegetative debris usage is detailed in the Vegetation Clearing and
Debris Management Plan.
Open burning that does not meet the definition provided above is outside the scope of this SMP
and may require additional permits from the MOE.
Regulations prohibit the burning of the following material in any quantity: animal carcasses;
asphalt or asphalt products; batteries; biomedical waste; carpets; construction waste other than
lumber that has not been treated with wood preservatives or other chemicals and is not coated
with paint, varnish, oil or other finishing material; demolition waste; electrical wire; fibreglass and
other fibre-reinforced polymers; fuel and lubricant containers; furniture and appliances;
hazardous waste; manure; paint and varnish; plastics; polystyrene foam; railway ties; rubber; tar
paper; tires; treated or painted wood products; and used oil.22
Modified Setback
Category Setback Distance (m) 29
Distance (m) 30
that is likely to result in the air quality not meeting the ambient air quality objectives set out in Schedule 2 of OBSCR.
27 BC Reg. 405/19, s. 30(1)(a)(b)
28 BC Reg. 405/19, s. 14(a)(b)
29 BC Reg. 405/19, s. 13(1) and the Site C Clean Energy Project Construction Environmental Management Plan Appendix B - Air
Modified setback distances are allowed under OBSCR, when open burning complies with
specific burning conditions. The burn criteria for modified setbacks is detailed in Table 4 of
Section 4.5.1. Open burning utilizing air curtain incinerators have unique setbacks to pile
burning; setbacks for air curtain incinerators are found in Table 5 of Section 4.5.2.
Sensitive receptors for the area have been identified in Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)
Volume 2 Appendix L. Those sensitive receptors which require a minimum setback of 1,000 m
are enumerated in Table 2. Regardless of sensitive receptors listed in Table 2, any and all
hospitals, community care facilities, or schools require setbacks based on relevant burn criteria,
as outlined in Table 1, Table 4, or Table 5.32
Alwin Holland Fort St. John Hospital Peace Lutheran Apt. Oscare
#1 Daycare/Oscare Tots
Baldonnel Elementary Fort St. John Medical Peace Lutheran Apt. The Zoo Daycare
Clinic #2
Bert Ambrose Fort St. John The Sunset Home Little Kritters Daycare
Elementary Pharmacy and
Wellness Centre
Bert Bowes Middle The Taylor Medical North Peace Care ABC & 123 Family
School Clinic Centre Daycare
Board Office ABC Medical Clinic Abbeyfield Houses of Baby Bear Daycare
Fort St. John
Keeginaw Pre-School
Totem Pre-School
Hudson's Hope
Playschool
Best Management Practices shall be employed so that smoke does not negatively impact a
nearby population centre or workcamp or pose a hazard at airports or on provincial highways by
significantly reducing visibility.33
There are five acceptable divisions within OBSCR under which open burning can occur, two of
which are likely to be employed under the Project:
4.5.1 Division 1 – Open Burning by High, Medium, and Low Smoke Sensitivity Zones
Table 3 outlines the specific burn criteria for burning in high, medium and low sensitivity zones.
Table 3. Burn Criteria for Open Burning Completed Under Division 1 by High, Medium, and Low Smoke Sensitivity Zones34.
Division 1 – Open Burning by Smoke Sensitivity Zone
Despite the setbacks detailed in Table 3, when completing open burning as per Division 1, open
burning may be carried out within modified setbacks, if the additional burn criteria conditions laid
out in Table 4 are met with respect to the open burning.
Table 5. Burn Criteria for Open Burning Under Division 5, Using Air Curtain Incinerators. 39
Distance of open burning Distance of open burning
from values (m) from values (m)
Neighbouring buildings 100 - 1000 1000+
residences (including seasonal
residences in use), and
businesses
Nearest property line of 500 – 2000 2000+
hospitals, schools, community
care f acilities, and identified
sensitive receptors.
Opacity40 requirements Does not exceed 40% during the 30-minute period following the
start of open burning and does not exceed 15% for more than 5
consecutive minutes during any other 30-minute period during open
burning
Vegetative debris stacking Vegetative debris is not stacked above the air outlet of the air
curtain incinerators.
Operational continuity Air curtain blowers operate continuously until the incinerators cease
combustion of the vegetative debris or until all the vegetative debris
has been reduced to ash
Ignition Time Not earlier than 1 hour af ter N/A
sunrise
Timing of addition of vegetative From one hour after sunrise to N/A
debris sunset
Ventilation forecast Fair or better for the day open N/A
burning is carried on; a Poor
f orecast for the day requires that
no more vegetative debris is
ignited
Venting forecasts are issued every morning for the current and next day. The forecasts include
the ventilation (or venting) index (VI), wind speed, and mixing height to help guide burning
operations. Forecast venting conditions for the day of the burn and the following day, if
applicable, must meet the minimum venting requirements laid out within the OBSCR and in the
relevant burn criteria table (Table 3, Table 4, Table 5).
BC Air Quality defines VI as; “a numerical value related to the potential of the atmosphere to
disperse airborne pollutants, such as smoke from a prescribed fire. It is based on both the
current wind speed in the mixed layer and the mixing height. The mixed layer is the surface
layer of air that is turbulent and well mixed. The mixing height is the thickness of this mixed
layer.” Greater wind speeds and thicker mixing heights will result in higher venting indices. It
should be noted; however, when wind speeds are too high, ground level mixing may be
reduced.
A VI of 0 means that there is no ability for the atmosphere to disperse smoke, whereas a VI of
100 means excellent smoke dispersion; the persistence of smoke from open burning is tied
39 BC Reg 405/19, s. 28
40 As defined under BC Reg 405/19, s. 28(1) and the glossary.
directly to atmospheric venting conditions. The numerical values are categorized into three
ranges: poor, fair, and good (Table 6). Category boundaries may differ in some jurisdictions; the
ventilation forecast provides both the numerical value, as well as the ventilation category.
Regulatory requirements outline minimum requirements for ventilation category.
0-33 Poor
34-54 Fair
55-100 Good
There are three acceptable sources for daily venting forecasts: custom venting forecasts
(CVFs), Environment Canada regional forecasts, and qualified independent forecasters (details
for each source are found in the following subsections). The source of daily forecasts for
burning under this SMP will be CVFs, with few exceptions as noted below.
There may be times when a CVF for the burn area is not available. In the circumstance that
CVFs are unavailable, contractors shall utilize the Environment Canada ventilation forecasts.
Contractors must record the daily forecast and source, as well as results of test burn, if
applicable. More information on recording and reporting is found in Section 5.
In summary, the source for daily ventilation forecast shall be used in the following order:
1. CVF subscription service, then
2. Environment Canada regional forecast.
It is not allowable to select the forecast that is the most favourable for operations or that best
suits burning objectives.
A retained, independent, MOE-approved forecaster would replace the CVF subscription service
for ventilation forecasts listed above.
To encourage the best dissipation of smoke, burning under this smoke management plan will
use custom venting forecasts prepared by a custom ventilation forecaster. Custom venting
forecasts are tied more closely to specific geographic locations than Environment Canada
forecasts which are prepared for a larger regional area. For this reason, custom venting
forecasts are generally thought to be a more accurate choice than Environment Canada venting
indices, which often can result in a forecast which is either too strict or too lenient for those
locations which are not well-represented by the average area or region for which the forecast
was prepared.
41 BC Reg 405/19, s. 16
The provincial fire centre weather forecasters are approved by the MOE and shall be retained
by the contractor through subscriptions for service to provide custom venting forecasts. Custom
forecasting subscriptions are generally available for the fall burning season. To set up
subscription and receive MOE-approved CVFs, the contractor shall contact the regional MOE
contact (see section 7.3 Key Contacts).
The contractor shall provide the following information to the forecaster, where burning is
anticipated: Burn Registration Number, location, latitude /longitude, elevation / elevation range,
and approximate number of piles. 42
The Environment Canada daily venting indices for the Fort St John Zone can be found at:
https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/environment/air-land-water/air/air-pollution/smoke-
burning/ventilation-index or by phoning 1-888-281-2992 (See Section 7.3).
BC Hydro may hire an independent, qualified forecaster to provide custom venting forecasts. It
is required that all independent forecasters meet the OBSCR definition of custom ventilation
forecaster and are approved by the MOE Director in advance of any burning activity which
depends upon their forecasts. 43 The first step in forecaster approval is contacting the regional
MOE contact (See Section 7.3).
If either BCH or a contractor retains an independent forecaster, the forecasts will take the place
of the CVF subscription service. Documentation of MOE approval must be recorded and kept on
file.
The burning period is the time between ignition and burn end, as outlined in the applicable burn
criteria. Burn ‘end’ for pile burning means the point in time when each pile of vegetative debris
has ceased flaming and is emitting smoke from no more than 10% of its burnt surface area. 44
Smoke release monitoring is the monitoring of burning activities in accordance with burn
duration commitments, based upon smoke sensitivity area, setback, and Division under which
open burning is occurring. Burn duration commitments are detailed in Table 3, Table 4, and
Table 5. Smoke release monitoring and tracking is detailed in Section 6.1.
Burn duration is measured per pile.45 Each pile that is ignited must individually adhere to burn
duration / burn period.
42 A general rule of thumb which may be helpful for estimating number of piles is: (NAR * 2 = # of piles), where NAR = Net Area
to be Reforested (ha) = Area Harvested / Cleared.
43 BC Reg 405/19, Part 1 and pers. comm. Gail Roth, Ministry of Environment, August 3, 2017.
44 BC Reg 405/19, Part 1
45 Personal communication (email), October 10, 2019 from [email protected].
The regulation allows for vegetative debris to be open burned up to 5 km from the point of
origin. In the case that longer burning period or more flexibility on venting conditions, vegetative
debris originating within the HSSZ may be moved to the MSSZ, within 5 km, for open burning.
Prior to the initiation of any Category 3 burns, the contractor shall obtain a Burn Registration
Number (BRN).47 BRNs are obtained through the BC Wildfire Service at 1.888.797.1717. BRNs
are valid for one parcel and for a two-week period after which time they may be re-issued
through the same process. A separate BRN is required for each parcel on which open burning is
planned. The following information is required in order to receive a BRN: contact information for
person initiating burn (contractor information), parcel description / coordinates of open burning
(center point of area for parcels with multiple piles), the number of piles to be burned under the
BRN, type of material to be burned, and any other information relating to the proposed open fire
that the official or the person answering the telephone number requires.48
The following is required for compliance with the BRN49: check venting indices (CVFs) prior to
ignition; comply with OBSCR, local bylaws, local and provincial fire bans, the Wildfire Act and
Wildfire Regulations. Following this SMP will ensure compliance with the BRN.
BRNs must be recorded and kept on site during burning activities. Details regarding required
contractor recording and reporting are found in Section 6.2.
46 BC Reg 405/19, s. 15
47 BC Reg. 38/2005, s. 22(1)
48 BC Reg. 38/2005, s. 24(1)
49 Pers. comm. Operator at BCWS BRN phone number.
Category 2 burns as part of industrial operations must adhere to all OBSCR regulations, and
therefore contractors must: check venting indices (CVFs) prior to ignition; comply with OBSCR,
local bylaws, local and provincial fire bans, the Wildfire Act and Wildfire Regulations.
Seasonal scheduling of burning activities will consider regionally important time periods, for
example periods with high recreational activity or periods with known Aboriginal use based on
the results of ground-truthing exercises. During, and two days prior to, sensitive time periods, no
debris piles will be ignited.
Based on regional recreation activity, the following periods have been identified as sensitive:
1. Piles should be roughly conical (haystack or bell-shaped) with a width to height ratio
of roughly 2:1. In all cases, piles must be stable. 52
2. Large piles typically burn hotter and cleaner than smaller piles. Efforts should be
made to make fewer, larger piles, while considering crew safety and meeting the
smoke release period criteria. Ideally, pile height of 4 m, or higher, is recommended.
4. To ensure the continuity of the burn, piles should contain a mixture of debris sizes
(mixture of fines with larger diameter material) with as few voids as possible. 53
5. To achieve efficient ignition, place smaller diameter fuels at the base to create an
ignition zone, ideally 2 m thick.
a. For Category 2 piles, create a good mixture of small and large diameter
fuels throughout the pile. Due to reduced size, a 2 m ignition zone is
neither ideal, nor feasible.
6. Minimize soil content that may be mixed in with vegetative debris; break root wads
up to remove any soils/rocks prior to piling and place pieces higher on the pile. 54
7. Within the high sensitivity smoke zone, all vegetative debris burned (piles) must be
seasoned, such that the pile is 30% or less moisture content, originates from dead
standing timber, or has been piled for a minimum of 4 months55. Pile covering is an
option to keep fuel moisture content low; remove covering prior to burning.
8. Within the medium sensitivity smoke zone, within each pile maximize the amount of
vegetative debris which is seasoned vegetative debris; piles should be seasoned
until they can easily combust. Ideally seasoned piles would be 30% or less moisture
content or piled for at least 4 months. 56 Pile covering is an option to keep fuel
moisture content low; remove covering prior to burning.
9. Establish a fuel break around each pile. 57 Determining necessary f uel break width
and type should consider, but not be limited to, the following variables: pile size,
proximity to adjacent fuels, type of fuels burning and adjacent, fire weather, slope,
and aspect. Fuel breaks are defined as: 1) a barrier or a change in fuel type or
condition, or 2) a strip of land that has been modified or cleared. 58
10. Maintain fuel breaks while the fire is burning and there is a risk of the fire escape .59
Additional considerations:
11. Do not construct piles in low, water-receiving sites. Low water-receiving sites are
defined as any location where the water table is at the soil surface such that fuels are
not be able to season or would not be able to achieve ideal fuel moisture content for
burning. Areas to avoid may include swales, wetlands, low-lying flood plains, or
areas of seepage. This is to ensure that fuels achieve the desired fuel moisture
content and therefore burn hotter and with less smoke emission. Piles should be built
in locations which are dry (water table not at the surface) for more than 4
consecutive months from spring to winter, not including moisture received during
precipitation events, and which are not likely to have the water table at the surface
during the desired burning window.60
12. Do not construct piles within riparian reserve zones (RRZ)61, unless directed by BCH
due to operational or topographic limitations. Any machine work will be conducted in
accordance with CEMP Section 4.5 (15 m machine-free riparian buffer from the
Ordinary High Water Mark).
13. Do not construct piles within the minimum setbacks outlined in Table 1, unless open
burning using an air curtain incinerator.
14. Do not pile where burning will negatively impact (scorch) the timber edge or retained
trees. Larger, machine-built piles will require larger setbacks, whereas smaller, hand-
built piles can be closer.
15. Avoid introducing soils and other non-combustibles into the pile. 62
Prior to the burning season, contractors shall collate information related to the smoke sensitivity
zone and the approximate number and location (coordinates) of the piles slated for burning.
This information is required in obtaining Burn Registration Numbers (BRNs) (see Section 4.6).
This information must be available for BCH upon request.
Confirm source of venting forecast: custom venting forecast, whether through a subscription
service provided by a MOE pre-approved forecaster or by retaining a qualified independent
forecaster, or regional forecasts from Environment Canada. See Section 4.5.2 for details
regarding venting forecast sources and acceptable utilization.
Strict adherence to the venting indices (the computed value or category) may conflict with the
practical objective of minimizing potential impacts of smoke. There are limitations to the venting
index calculations, which shall be considered by the contractor prior to ignition. For example,
wind direction and proximity to potential values impacted are not incorporated into the venting
index. There may be additional impacts from changing weather, such as changing wind patterns
and rain/snow events that may result in undesirable burning conditions or evening and overnight
venting conditions. It is important to consider wind direction and mixing heights.
Practical Application
The following adaptations shall be considered by the contractor prior to ignition, as appropriate:
• If wind direction is not favourable and smoke is likely to impact populations, highways, or
airports, burn instead in locations where wind direction works in favour of burn and
smoke travel.
• Consider moving to remote piles when forecaster confidence in continued good venting
is low.
• Consider prioritizing any high smoke sensitivity area burns when forecaster confidence
in continued good venting is high.
• Lower mixing heights will not have the capacity for large volumes of smoke, suggesting
that the ignition of a large number of piles should be avoided. Ignite fewer piles in these
situations to reduce overall volume of smoke emitted.
Despite acceptable venting forecast (e.g. good and fair) advancing weather conditions can
result in a rapid decline in venting leading to unacceptable levels of smoke.
Venting forecast validation can be completed through ignition and monitoring of a test pile. After
test pile ignition, monitor the performance of the burn for 15-30 minutes relative to:
• Fire intensity.
• Smoke release (direction, dispersion, quantity and relation to important infrastructure
such as highways, airports, sensitive receptors, and population centres).
• Potential for escape to adjacent piles or slash.
With confirmation that the test pile is burning as planned, continue with the daily burn plan and
monitor pile burning performance throughout the day. Where significant reductions in burn
performance are noted, burning shall be halted or the burn plan revised to increase burn
performance to an acceptable level. Documentation of venting forecast validation, results, and
pile performance monitoring are the responsibility of the contractor. See Section 6.2 for details.
During Burning
If, during burning, it is determined that smoke dispersion is not ideal, potential adjustments to
daily burn plans could include one, or more, of the following strategies:
1. Ceasing to add new debris to the pile earlier in the day or imposing earlier end time
for ignition period to allow for more daytime burning.
3. Using forced air mechanisms to encourage hotter fires and more complete
combustion.
The contractors shall communicate with the custom venting forecasters regarding burn
registration information. To maximize the effectiveness of the custom venting forecast, work with
the forecaster in identifying any additional information that may be required to ensure the most
accurate forecasts possible. This information may include specific pile elevation and timing
related to the issuance of forecasts. Forecast limitations should be discussed with the forecaster
and documented in the daily burn log, as applicable.
5.3.4 Training
Desired open burning outcomes are much more likely to be achieved if burning crews have the
appropriate level of experience and training. All supervisors, ground crews, and machine
operators shall be appropriately trained in regulatory requirements, BMPs, safe work protocols,
and Standard Operating Procedures and must be competent in operational fire and fire
suppression activities. Contractors must retain records of training and certification on site and
provide to BCH upon request. The following is a non-exhaustive list of areas of competency.
The pre-burn checklist should include all critical safety, regulatory, and operational variables. It
is the responsibility of the contractor to ensure that pre-burn checklists include smoke
management variables, as well as ensure compliance with other directly relevant legislation,
such as the Wildfire Act and Wildfire Regulation. A pre-burn checklist must be completed each
day one or more debris piles are ignited and separate checklists must be generated for each
area covered by a venting forecast and for burning in separate smoke sensitivity zones (e.g.,
separate pre-burn checklists are required for burns in a custom venting forecast area that spans
two or more smoke sensitivity zones). In the event that one or more boxes on the pre-burn
checklist are unable to be ‘ticked’, ignition must not occur.
63Pre-burn checklist adapted from a variety of sources, including: BCTS Strait of Georgia Open Burning Checklist and BCWS Burn
Plan Template.
Table 7. Example Open Burning Pre-Burn Checklist for Category 2 and Category 3 Fires. The Pre-
Burn Checklist may be Modified or Adapted to Better Suit Aerial Ignitions.
PLANNING
Has smoke sensitivity zone been determined? Is it
understood how the smoke sensitivity zone impacts
operational activities (burn criteria)?
Are the piles sufficiently seasoned, according to the smoke
sensitivity zone?
• HSSZ – piles were constructed 4 months ago or
more, debris originates from dead standing timber,
or are ≤30% moisture content.
Has piling been completed according to the SMP such that
burning can be completed safely and effectively (including
surrounded by a fuel break) and such that the pile can be
consumed and burning end within the applicable burn
duration? If no, re-pile or allow to season .
Are pile locations >500 m from any inhabited residences or
business and >1,000 m from schools in session, hospitals,
continuing care facilities, and identified sensitive receptors
(unless burning under the burn criteria conditions stipulated
for modified setbacks)?
Are pile locations outside riparian reserve zones?
Are there any Air Quality Burning Bans? Check with MOE.
Document communications.
Burn Registration Number received (Category 3 only)?
Legal obligations under the Wildfire Act and Wildfire Regulation
reviewed and understood?
Legal obligations under the Environmental Management Act
and Open Burning Smoke Control Regulation reviewed and
understood?
BCH SMP reviewed and understood?
Do the piles include only clean, woody waste / debris?
A daily ignition plan shall be developed and provided to BCH prior to each day’s ignition
activities. It shall include, but not be limited to, personnel; ignition method, tactics, and
procedures; ignition location (e.g. GPS points of piles to be ignited or extents of ignition); and
flight plan.
The daily ignition period is the recommended time of pile ignition and has been designed to
coincide with the time of day where venting conditions are typically best and to ensure that there
is sufficient time remaining after ignition for the burn to consume most of the pile (Table 8).
Following daily ignition periods will increase the potential for burns to occur during the time of
day when venting is most favourable and minimize the release of overnight smoke when venting
is generally less favourable.
1. Smoke Release
After the allowable burning period ends, piles will be inspected for compliance with the burn
duration. If, at the end of allowable burn duration, the pile is found to be emitting smoke from
more than 10% of its burnt surface area66 (or with the use of an air curtain incinerator, the burn
is emitting smoke from more than 10% of the base of the air curtain incinerator) , then the pile
will be extinguished (debris broken up to achieve burn end).
In the event that debris reduction objectives have not been met at the end of the burn duration ,
available options include and may implemented, at the discretion of BCH:
• extinguish the pile and consider all operations for the pile to be complete;
• re-pile to facilitate cleaner burning and reignite under a new burning period with
acceptable venting and according to the relevant burn criteria; or,
• buck any long pieces to a length <4 m.
New piles will be considered a new burning period and must comply with this SMP and
regulatory requirements as a new burn. 67
Under all scenarios, BC Hydro and the contractor shall review the contributing factors to a burn
which exceeds the burn period and shall make appropriate compensatory changes to
subsequent burn plans.
It is the contractors’ responsibility to ensure compliance with burn periods. The contractor shall
document compliance and submit documentation to BCH weekly with the burn tracking
requirements (see 6.2.1 for details).
2. Debris Reduction
Debris reduction shall be assessed to ensure that the appropriate reduction in debris mass has
been achieved. If it is deemed that the level of debris reduction is not acceptable, BCH may
determine that the pile shall be: 1) extinguished, re-piled and ignited again; 2) bucked into
lengths shorter than 4 m; or, 3) left as-is.
3. Hazard Abatement
For the purposes of hazard abatement, piles will be monitored to ensure that the pil es are
completely extinguished. Category 3 fires must be extinguished by the date specified by the
official or person who issued the BRN. 68 Contractors must be able to display that each individual
pile is out. This can be achieved by cold trailing by hand or assurance by a thermal scan.
Depending on seasonal timing of burns, there may be potential for holdover fires to pop up in
the spring. Pile monitoring in spring shall be completed by the contractor to ensure holdover
fires do not cause unintended ignitions or burns. This risk is highe st in spring after snowmelt
and prior to green-up.69 Infrared scanning shall be completed immediately after the site is snow-
free and prior to hazard build up. Site conditions shall be monitored to determine appropriate
timing for infrared scanning, rather than relying solely on calendar timing to schedule scans.70
6.2 Tracking
Tracking, or documentation, is required to demonstrate diligence to the process, to demonstrate
compliance with legislation and commitments, and to help track efficacy and improve
performance. Tracking documents produced though activities related to this SMP include, but
are not limited to:
• Burn tracking form;
• Pre-burn checklist;
• Ignition plan;
• Burn period / smoke release form;
• Den and bird nesting surveys; and,
• Associated photo-documentation of the above.
Burn tracking begins prior to ignition and continues through to the time it is confirmed that the
fire is extinguished. Burn tracking provides valuable data for continual improvement, helps to
achieve compliance with regulations and BMPs, and tracks productivity. It is the contractor’s
responsibility to:
1. Ensure a pre-burn checklist and ignition plan is completed prior to ignition and
provided to BCH upon request (Sections 5.4.1 and 5.4.2, Table 7).
a. Note any diversions from ignition plan.
2. Record GPS coordinates of ignited piles, date of piling, and allowable burning
duration.
a. Pre-ignition, georeferenced photos of piles is recommended (or
alternative documentation system of an equivalent and measurable
monitoring system developed by the contractor and approved by BCH).
3. Complete and submit the Burn Tracking Form daily (Table 9). The form provides
details on the progress of the burn plan, documents compliance, and provides
information related to burning criteria.
4. Document any changes to ongoing burn plans; note if or how the changes are a
direct result from monitoring feedback (Table 9).
5. Complete the burn period / smoke monitoring tracking form (or alternative equivalent
documentation system developed by the contractor).
a. Record ocular observations and photos related to achievement of burn
period per pile.
6. Complete and retain results of den and active-bird nesting surveys (Section 5.3.5).
The daily burn tracking form, burn period / smoke release monitoring documentation, photo-
documentation and den and bird nesting surveys shall be submitted weekly to the BCH
representative / project supervisor. All other documentation shall be available to BCH upon
request.
71
95 *Number of Piles
sitecproject.com
94 Piles Ignited
1 Pile Remaining
BRN Information
700 m Elevation
Page 42
11/18/2019, 4:00 pm Burn period end
sitecproject.com
description)
Page 43
smoke
Smoke release / burn duration monitoring
Revision 5: September 14, 2021 None recommended; one piece > 4m will Follow-up recommended
remain due to pile location and limited
accessibility
Debris reduction
The Ministry of Environment (MOE) may issue air quality advisories or burn bans should
particulate matter concentrations approach or exceed provincial objectives73. The current
provincial 24-hour ambient air quality objectives are as follows:
Particulate matter <2.5 microns (PM 2.5): 25 µg/m3
Particulate matter <10 microns (PM 10): 50 µg/m3
If an advisory and/or burn ban is issued, burn operators are required to adhere to the terms of
the advisory and/or burn ban. 74
7.1.1 Public
RCMP x x x x x x
City of Fort St
x x
John
Fort St John
Fire x x
Department
Charlie Lake
Volunteer Fire x
Department
Peace River
Regional x x x x x x
District
District of
Taylor and
x x x x x
Taylor Fire
Department
District of
Hudson’s x x x x
Hope
Hudson’s
Hope Fire and
x x x x
Rescue
Service
Chetwynd Fire
x x
Department
District of
X x
Chetwynd
BC Wildf ire
x x x x x x x
Service
Northern
x x x x x x
Health
MFLRNORD x x x x x x
Property
x x x x x x x
owners
Table 12. Key contacts for notification, party responsible for notification, and primary method of
notification. 77
Responsible Primary
Agency Contact for Method for
Notification Notification
Ministry of Earle Plain Contractor Email
Environment – Head, Air Quality Section Monitoring, Assessment,
Regional and Stewardship
Contact Environmental Protection
Ministry of Environment and Climate Change
Strategy
Of f ice: 250-739-8253
Fax: 250-751-3103
[email protected]
2080-A Labieux Road
Nanaimo, BC V9T 6J9
Gail Roth
Air Quality Meteorologist, Air Quality Section
(Assessments)
Monitoring, Assessment & Stewardship
Ministry of Environment and Climate Change
Strategy
Of f ice: 250-645-9358
Fax: 250-565-6629
[email protected]
Suite 325, 1011 4th Avenue, Prince George, BC
V2L 3H9
Environment https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/environment/air- N/A N/A
Canada Daily land-water/air/air-pollution/smoke-
Ventilation burning/ventilation-index
Forecasts
RCMP Cpl. Rob Gardner Contractor Email
Hudson Hope email: [email protected]
Detachment
Linda Cantlon
[email protected]
Responsible Primary
Agency Contact for Method for
Notification Notification
RCMP Fort St S/Sgt. Scott Watson Contractor Email
John Email: [email protected]
Detachment
Seyoum Gebeyehu
Environmental Health Officer, Health Protection and
Disease Prevention
[email protected]
78The Chetwynd Fire Department does not provide firefighting or rescue services for the West Pine quarry area. Highway
rescue only is available.
Responsible Primary
Agency Contact for Method for
Notification Notification
Ali Moore
Team Lead, Health Protection and Disease
Prevention
[email protected]
This plan was originally prepared (June 2015) in accordance with the BC Open Burning Smoke
Control Regulation (BC MOE 2012) and proposed updates to the regulation (BC MOE 2010), by
the following qualified professionals:
Alberta Wildfire. 2019. Brush Piles and Windrows Safe Burning Practices.
https://open.alberta.ca/publications/9781460122389. Accessed: 22 June, 2020.
British Columbia Ministry of Environment. “Open Burning Smoke Control Regulation.” Province of
British Columbia, Province of British Columbia, 29 Mar. 2017,
https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/environment/air-land-water/air/air-pollution/smoke-
burning/regulations/openburningregulation . Accessed: 25 October 2019.
BC Ministry of Environment. “Air Quality Objectives & Standards.” Province of British Columbia,
Province of British Columbia, 10 Apr. 2017, https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/environment/air-
land-water/air/air-quality-management/regulatory-framework/objectives-standards. Accessed
August 22, 2017.
British Columbia Ministry of Forests, Lands, and Natural Resource Operations. 2014. Industrial
and Resource Management Burning – A Guide to Category 3 and Resource Management Open
Fires. http://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/public-safety-and-emergency-services/wildfire-status/fire-
bans-and-restrictions/bcws_resourcemgmt.pdf. Accessed August 4, 2017.
Bulkley Forest District Burn and Smoke Management Plan (BSMP), Sept 8, 2016.
http://cleanairplan.ca/BOF2016/gq5SMP-BulkleySmokeManagementPlan2016-signed.pdf
Accessed: August 3, 2017.Continuing Care Act. R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 70
Ministry of Environment and Climate Change Strategy. 2019. Factsheet Open Burning Smoke
Control Regulation. https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/environment/air-land-
water/air/f actsheets/obscr_general_factsheet.pdf . Accessed June 24, 2020.