A Simple Approach To Short Circuit Calculations - EDP1
A Simple Approach To Short Circuit Calculations - EDP1
- -- C. A. INDUESCA
~ Apartado 70528 - Telex 24772
Av. Francisco de Miranda
Edif. Laino, Ofic. 31, Campo Alegre
CARACAS 1060 - Venezuela
TELFS.: (02)32.80.96 - 33.96.91
32.31.92 - 32.23-.62
(051) 51.49.24.51.81.43
ENGINEERING DEPENDABLE PROTECTION - PART I
A SIMPLE APPROACH TO ·SHORT -CIRCUIT CALCULATIONS"
INDEX
PAGE
Why Short-Circuit Calculations................ . . 3
Interrupting Capacity and the Short-Clrcuit Current. . 3
Short-Circuit Current Calculations . 4
3 ~ Short-Circuit Calculation - Ohmic Method Procedure . 6
3~ Short-Circuit Calculation - Per-Unit Method Procedure . 12
Per-Unit Method Procedure Made' Simple - Use of Constants . 18
Index to Tables - Use of Constants . 18
Table A - Utility Short-Circuit KV A - P.U.X . 19
Table B - Transformer Impedance Multipliers . 19
Table C - Component Impedance Multipliers . 20
Table D - Symmetrical RMS Short-Circuit Current Formulas . 20
Per-Unit Method - Use of Constants . 21
Dou ble Transformation Per-U nit Method . 23
1 g Short-Circuit Calculation on 1 % Transformer System . 26
Effect of Low Available Utility KV A . 32
General Discussions of Short-Circuit Calculations . 34
Data Section . 35
Index to Data Section . 35
Table 1 - Transformer Impedance Data . 36
Table 2 - Current Transformer Reactance Data . 36
Table 3 - Disconnecting Switch Reactance Data . 37
Table 4 - Circuit Breaker Reactance Data . 37
Table 5 - Copper Cable Impedance Data . 38
. Table 6 - Aluminum Cable Impedance Data . 39
Table 7 - Busway Impedance Data . 40
Table 8 - AsymmetricaIFactors . 40
Selective Systems . 42
BUSS Fuse Symbols, Trade Marks, Classes and
Interrupting Ratings.................................... Back Cover
-2-
WHV SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATIONS?
¡-'",'t.
The protection for an electrical svstem should not orilv be safe under
all service conditions but, to irisure continuitx yf service, it should be
selecrive as well~.A.sdective system is one \~he?-¡¡ñ o nly the faulted circuir
is isC;-lat~¿r\~,'irhbti~~disturbing any other part of the sysrern. Overcurrenr
protectio n devices should also pro vide short-circuit as wel] as low o ver-
current protectio n for system components, such as bus, wire, motor
controllers, ete. ' " ~ lo''':- ,tll_'
p.¡J-i.¡J,'.rv'
T o obtain safe, seleS1ti~J)operatio n and assure rhat system cornponenrs
are protected from danúge, we must first calculare the availahle faulV /) J-v'tA- :-ú/,,; . .)
current at various points in O~H e\ectrical systern. d.0,:-,.:--;""" ..{ 7
VNO .~( "" ·fi.~:~_.",Cv") '.....
i·u ..1"""""
INTERRUPTING CAPACITV
ANO THE SHORT-CIRCUIT CURRENT
To begin, ler's discuss interrupting capacitv, Interrupting capacity can
be defined as "the rnaximurn shorr-circuit current rhat a protective device
can safe\y c1ear.'UJ,}. ir. ;;).v¡~/' -1! d?
f/ /
.-
Z
~ ~+---~+-~~--;1--~~--+r--~----~--~--~~--l----\~
a:
:::>
U
TIME
1.•.-- Asymmetrical Current Ir -- Transient Component
15 -- Symmetrical Component
-3-
'\.) r
... "
o ,
.~' '1
The rms value of the symmetricai component may be dete~mined using Ohm's Law. To determine
ttansient component, it is necessary to know the XjR rario of the system. T o obtain the XjR
rano the total ~esistance and total reactance of the circt1tHo rhe point of fault must be determined. .
Section 240-60 and 240-83 of the National Electrical Code cover the requirements for
marking the interrupting capacitv on fuses and circuit breakers. See back cover for BUSS
Fase interrupting capacities.
,
To be able to determine the fault current at any point in the system, we need to first draw a one-
line díagram showing all of the sources of short-círcuit current feeding into the fault, as well as the
impedances furnished by the circuit components.
The impedances may be represented by ohms, percent ohms or per-unit ohms. The ohmic
method and then the per-unit method is used in the study of three phase faults and single phase faults
on typical distribution systems. An arbirrarv kva base and the system voltage are selected as base
values for the per-unit method.
To make the study, the system components, including those of the urilitv system, are represented
as impedances in the diagram, ...
Consider the following system, supplied by a 1000 KV A, three phase transforrner having a full
load current of 2400 amperes at 240 volts. (See System-A, next page.)
To start, we must obtain the available short-circuit KV A frorn the local urility company.
1 .IJ'/"':·V·
,.¡,., s-:
The utiliry estimates that their system can deliv~r a short-circuit of 100,000 KV A (100 MVA)
at the transformer. Since the XjR ratio of the utilitv system is usually quite high, only the reactance
need be considered. !/.
c71g~¿.i(" ".v¡-·)t Y'i' __ ¿L/- t:
With this available short-circuit fault information, we can begin to make the necessary
calculations to determine the fault current at anv point in the e!ectrical system. .
We can use an ohmic method, a per-unit method, or a percent method for calcularing short-
circuit current. In this text we will examine the ohmic and per-unit methods. The first method
presented is the ohmic method.
-4-
SYSTEM A
Available
Utility
S.C. KVA
100,000
Note: The above 1000 KVA !ransformer serves 100% motor load.
-5-
316 SHORT -CIRCUIT CALCULATION
OHMIC METHOD PROCEDURE
formulae": (Note that the transformer and utilirv ohms are referred
to the secondary KV by squaring the secondary voltage.)
(10)(%R)(secondary KV)2
Transformer R (in ohms)
Transformer KV A
ZT = vi (RT)2 + (XT)21
*For simplicity of calculations all ohmic values are single phase distance one wa'J...
later compensated for in the three phase short- circuit formula by the factor, Va'·
(See Step 7.)
tOnly X is considered in this procedure since utility X/R ratios are usually quite
high. For more finite details obtain R of utility source.
-6-
! .e
.• -C.' (,'
',;"'\ ...;W
y ,í
\ ! .
\
Step 8. Determin~ the motor load. Add up the full load motor
\ -
currents. ,he full load motor current in the system is
generally a ~ercentage of the fránsforrner fullload current,
depending upon the type of load. (The generally accepted
procedure assumes 50% motor load when both motor and
lighting loads are considered, such as supplied by 4 wire,
120/208 and 277/480 volt 3-phase sys~e~> 1 a (,? /
Step 9. The short-circuitcurrentthatthe motor load can contribute
~e:.>." 7: . -:-rc;
is an asyml1l.e¿üc¡fÁ.surrentusually approximated as bei.ng
equal to the lócl{'ed[otor current of the motors. * As a close
lZ,U"'« v¡:';. " .
approximatión wíth a margin of safety use:
Asym Motor Contribution* = 5 x (Fullload motor current)
Step 10. The symmetrical motor contribution can be approximated
by using the a~'Ef~~ª~Oasymmetryfactor associated with : s/>
",ncc<j
the motors in the system. This asymmetry factor varies /.'.{-o I
~t
according to motor design and in this text may be chosen 'i'&L<
as 1.25for approximate calculation purposes. To solve for './.. IOIJ"- .,f .r"
. I t .b ti ~L{ 7 ..,. '....L .
t h e syrnmetrica mo orocontri u Ion: .
(Asym Motor Contribution)
S ym Motor Contribution* = "--.....:...----------:
1.25
Step 11. The total symmetrical short-circuit rms current is
calculated as:
tTotal Is.c. rms sym = (Is.c. rms sym) + (Sym Motor Contribution)
Step 12. Determine X/R ratio of the system to the point of fault.
Total X (Ohms)
X/R ratio = ------
Total R (Ohms)
Step 13. The asymmetrical factor corresponding to the X/R ratio in
Step 12 is found i.nJable 8, Column Mm' This multiplier
will provide the ~st case asymmetry occuring in the first
X cycle. Where the average 3-phase multiplier is desired
use column Ma.
NOTE: Al! 01 the ohms 01 the circuit components must be relerred to the same
voltage. If there is more than one voltage translormation in the system,
the ohmic method becomes more complicated. It is recommended that
the per-unit method be u~ed lor ease in calculation when more than one
voltage translormation ex\sts in the system. See page 23.
\-7-
"J--0.rv
""
::¡
OHM-IC METHOD
ONE-LlNE DIAGRAM TO F4..ULT Xl-SYSTEM-A
SYSTEM CORRESPONDING
ONE-LlNE DIAGRAM IMPEDANCE DIAGRAM
Available
Utility -+
S.C. KVA
100,000
1000 KV A Transformer
+- 240 V, 3.0, 5.1% X,O.89% R
r"V"","" IF.l.= 2400 Amps.
-8-
OHMIC METHOD
3 t'6 SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCU.'-ATION - FAULT Xl
IMPEDANCE DIAGRAM
R X
100,000 KVA 1000 (.240)2
Source X = = .000575 .000575
100,000
3000A. (Table 3)
Page 37
X = .000040 .000040
Switch
-9-
OHMIC METHOD-Con't.
ONE-LlNE DIAGRAM TO FAULT X2 - SYSTEM-A
Available
Utility ~
S.C. KVA
100,000
--=r
1000 KVA Transformer
240 V, 30, 5.1% X, 0.89% R
IF.L.= 2400 Amps
25' -
3 Per 750 MCM
Phase .
Utility Service
Drop Cable
----t---~--
'-- Fault X,
~ Motor Contribution
-10-
1
OHMIC METHOD - Con 't.
3 Jl$SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATION - F'AULT X2
IMPEDANCE DIAGRAM
R X
-t---X-
400A
.000080
Switch
M
Motor
Contribution Total Z = y'(.002144)2 + (.006265)21= .00662 Ohms Per Phase
240
S.C. Sym RMS Amps = yI31(.00662) = 20,930 Amps.
-11-
3 e SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATION
PER-UNIT METHOD ,PROCEDURE*
Base KVA
Step 1. Utility per-unit Xt = ------
Utility S.C. KV A
(%X) (Base KV A)
Step 2. Transformer per-unit X = ----------
(100) (Transformer KV A)
(%R) (Base KV A)
Transformer per-unit R = ----------
(100) (Transformer KV A)
(Ohm X) (Base KV A)
Step 3. Component per-unit X =
(Cable, Switches, CT, Bus) (1000) (KV)2
(Ohm R) (Base KV A)
Step 4. Component per-unit R =
(Cable, Switches, CT, Bus) (1000) (KV) 2
Step 5." Next, total al! per-unit X and all per-unit R in system to
point of fault.
*The base KVA used throughout this text will be 10,000 KVA.
** As in the ohmic method procedure, all ohmic values are single-phase distance
one way, later compensated for in the three phase short-circuit formula by the
va'.
factor, (See Step 1.)
tOnly per-unit X is considered in this procedure since utility X/R ratio is usually
quite high. For more finite details obtain per-unit R of utility source.
-12-
Step 8. Determine the motor load. Add up the full !oad motor
currents. (Whenever motor and lighting :1oads are con-
sidered, such as supplied by 4 wire, 120/208 and 277/480
volt3 phase systems, the generally accepted procedure is
to assume 50% motor load based on the full load current
rating of the transformer.)
t Total Is.c. rms sym = (Is.c. rms sym) + (Sym Motor Contribution)
Step 12. Determine X/R ratlo of the system to the point of fault.
P.U,XT
XiR ratio = ---'-
P.U.RT
Step 13. From Table (8), Column Mm' obtain the asymmetrical
factor corres pon di ng to the X/R ratio determi ned in Step 12.
This multiplier will provide the worst case asymmetry
occurring in the first X cycle. Where the average 3-phase
multiplier is desired use column M .
a
t Total Is.c. asym rms = (Is.c. asym rms) + (Asym Motor Contribution)
.•A more exact determinaticn depends upon the sub-transient reactances of the
motors in question and associated circuit impedances. A less conservative
method would involve the total motor circuit impedance to a cornmon bus
(sometimes referred to as a "zer o reactance bus") and proceed there-from.
-13-
PER UNIT MJ;THOD
ONE-LlNE DIAGRAM TO FAULT Xl- SYSTEM-A
Available
Utility
S.C. KVA
100,000
--=r
1000 KV A Transformer
240 V, 3.0, 5.1% X, 0.89% R
IF.l.= 2400 Amps
--,r---------'----..--* .•
""-- Fault X,
Motor Contribution
-14-
PER UNIT METHOD
3 _ SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATION - FAULT Xl
10,000 KV A Base
IMPEDANCE DIAGRAM
P.U.R. P.U.X
100,000
(5.1) (10,000)
P.U.X = = .5100 .5100
1000 KVA (100) (1000)
Transformer
5.1% X (.89) (10,000)
.89% R P.U.R = = .0890 .0890
(100) (1000)
(.0003)t(10,OOO)
25' P.U.X = = .0520 .0520
(1000) (.240) 2
750 MCM
3/Phase
Service (.00016)t (10,000)
Drop Cable P.U.R = = .0281 .0281
(1000) (.240)2
(.00004) (10,000)
3000 A.
Switch P.U.X = = .0069 .0069
(1000) (.240)2
Total S.C. Sym RMS Amps (Fault X,) = 35,300 + 9,600 = 44,900 Amps .
.6689
X/R Ratio ~ .1171 = 5.72, Asym Factor'" = 1.290
-15-
PER UNIT METHOD (Con't.)
ONE-LlNE DIAGRAM TO FAULT X2 - SYSTEM-A
Available
Utility
S.C. KVA
100,000
1000 KV A Transformer
240 V, 30,5.1% X, 0.89% R
1 = 2400 Amps
F.L.
----+---~-
'- FaultXl
+-- 400 A. Switch
'--- Fault X2
~ Moto' Contribution
-16-
PER UNIT METHOD (Con't.)
3 _ SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATION - FAULT X2
(.00233)t(10,000)
50' P.U.X = = .4050 .4050
500 MCM (1000) (.240)2
Feeder
Cable (.00147)t(10,000)
P .U.R = = .2551 .2551
(1000) (.240) 2
M
Motor
Contribution Total P.U.Z.= ~(.3722)2 + (1.0878)21= 1.150
10000
S.C. Sym RMS Amps = ' = 20,930 Amps.
(y'JI) (.240) (1.15)
Asym Motor Contribution (100%) = 5 x 2400 = 12,000 Amps.tt
12,000
Sym Motor Contribution = -- = 9600 Amps.tt
1.25
Total S.C. Sym RMS Amps (Fault X,) = 20,930 + 9600 = 30,530 Amps.
1.0878
X/R Ratio = .3722 = 2.92, Asym Factor* = 1.112
-17-
PER-UNIT METHOD PROCEDURE MADE SIMPLE
-USE OF CONSTANTS-
The per-unit method lends itself rarher well to the use of co nstants based
on a base KVA (10,000) and a base voltage. The following tables" are con-
venient when used in conjunction with per-unit short-circuir calculations:
-18-
Table A-UTILlTV SHORT-CIRCUIT KVA-P.U.X.
Base KVA
P..U.X = ------
Utility S.C. KV A
25,000 0.400
50,000 0.200
75,000 0.133
100,000 0.100
200,000 0.050
300,000 0.033
400,000 0.025
500,000 0.020
1,000,000 0.010
Infinite O
(%X) (Base KV A) (
P.U.X = (100) (Transformer KV A) --
Transformer KV A Multiplier
50 2.0000
75 1.3333
100 1.0000
150 .6667
167 .5988
200 .5000
225 .4444
300 .3333
500 .2000 .
750 .1333
1000 .1000
1500 .0667
2000 .0500
2500 .0400
-19-
Table C - COMPONENT IMPEDANCE MULTIPLlERS
-20-
PER UNIT METHOD-USE OF CONSTANTS
ONE-LlNE DIAGRAM TO FAULT Xl- SYSTEM-A
Available
Utility
S.C. KVA
100,000
1000 KV A Transformer
240 V, 3 0, 5.1% X, 0.89% R
IF.L.= 2400 Amps
--~~----~~--x
~ ~FaultXl
-21-
PER UNIT METHOD-USE OF CONSTANTS
3.16 SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATION-FAULT Xl
P.U.R P.U.X
100,0(){)
KVA .1000
Source
240 Volts
25'
750 MCM
3 Per Phase
P.U.X. = (.0003)tx(173.61) = .0520 (Table
Page 20
e) .0520
Service
Orop Cable
P.U.R = (.00016)tx(173.61) = .0281 (Table
Page 20
e) .0281
-22-
DOUBLE TRANSFORMATION
PER-UNIT METHOD
ONE-LlNE DIAGRAM TO FAULT Xl & X2
2000 A Switch
400 A Switch
Negligible
Distance ---{I)
200 KV A Transformer
'-'"...., .•....
,'-' 120/208 Volts, 30
1.665% X, 1.111% R
IF.L. = 555 Amp
Note: In this example, motor contribution is not included. See page 13 for motor
contribution procedure.
-23-
DOUBLE TRANSFORMATION
PER-UNIT METHOD
3 fll SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATIONS - FAULT Xl
P.U.R P.U.X
200,000 10,000
KVA P.U.X = 200,000 = .05 .0500
Source
(5.1) (10,000)
1500 KVA P.U.X = (100) (1500) = 5.1 X .0667 = .3402
Transformer
5.1% X, .83%R
\.83) (10,000)
P.U.R = (100) (1500) = .83 X .0667 = .0554
P.U.X
rc
30'
=~1000'
)(.0466y
-5-¿jX
10,000
(1000) (.480)2
10,000
2000 A
P.U.X = (.00005) 1000 (.480)2
Switch
Note: See P. 35 "Data Section" for impedance data for the electrical components
and P. 18-20 for the per unit constants.
-24-
DOUBLE TRANSFORMATION
PER UNIT METHOD
3 ~ SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATIONS - FAULT X
2
Fault ~ is located on the 120/208 volt system. The per-unit rnethod makes the calculatio ns
simple. Thé base voltage is 208 volts for the system components on the 120/208 volt system. These
P.U. impedance values can be added directly to rhe P.U. impedance values determined on the 480
volt system using the 480 volt base.
If the ohmic merhcd were to be used, the calculations would be considerably more complex.
To find Fault X2, the system ohms to the prirnary of the 200 KV A transformer would have to be
adjusted by the square of the turns ratio. However, the per-unit method automatically accounts for
this adjustrnent. In the calculations which follow, particular attention should be given to the voltage
in the per-unit rnultipliers.
10,000
400 A
P.U.X = (.00008) 1000 (.480)2
Switch
= .00008 X 43.4 = .0035
(1.665) (10,000)
200 KVA P.U.X = (100) (200) = 1.665 X .5 = .8325
Transformer
1.665% X
1.111% R (1.111) (10,000)
P.U.R = (100) (200) = 1.111 X.5 = .5555
P.U.X
lE
20' ~E·0491S1
=\s.1000') -2-zjX
10,000
(1000) (.208)2
10,000 27,758
S.C. Sym RMS Amps (Fault X2) = V3(.208) (1.5270) 1.5270 = 18,180 Amps
Note: See P. 35 "Data Section" for impedance data for the electrical components
and P. 18-20 for the per unit constants.
-25-
1fI SHORT -CIRCUIT CALCULATION
ON
SINGL~-PHASE TRANSFORMER SYSTEM
PER-UNIT METHOD PROCEDURE
SHORT CIRCUIT
2. The impedance of the center-tapped transformer must be adjusted for the half-winding (generally
line-to-neutral) fault condition.
The diagram at the right illustrates that during line-to-neutral
faults, the full primarv winding is involved but, only the half-
winding on rhe secondary is involved. Therefore, the actual
transformer reactance and resistance of the half-winding condition ~PRIMARY
is different than the actual transformer reactance and resistance of
the full winding condition. Thus, adjustment to the %X and %R
must be made when considering line-to-neutral faults. The
adjustrnent rnultipliers generaUy used for this condition are as
follows:
L2 WI
~~ECONDARY
The calculations on the following pages illustrate 1-0 fault calculations on a single-phase trans-
former system. Both line-to-line and line-to-neutral faults are considered.
-26-
ONE LlNE DIAGRAM
Available
3$0 Utility
S.C. KVA
l
100,000
75 KV A TRANSFORMER
120/240 Volts, 1$0
1.4% Z, i .13% X, .83% R
IF.L. = 312 Amps.
Negligible
Distance
50' #3/0
Feeder Cable.
2 Pale 1 Pale
-27-
LlNE TO LlNE FAULT @ 240 VOLTS
P.U.R P.U.X
10,000
100,000 P.U.X (30) = 100,000 = .1
30 KVA
Source
P.U.X(10) =2X.1 =.2 .2000
(1.13) (10,000)
75 KVA P.U.X = (100)(75) = (1.13) (1.33) = 1.5029
Transformer
1.13% X
(.83) (10,000)
.83% R 1.1039
P .U. R = (100)(75) = (.83) (1.33) =
2 (.00008) 10,000
400A P.U.X = 1000 (.240)2 = 2 (.00008) (173.61) = .0278
Switch
Note: See P. 35 "Data Section" tor impedance data for the electrical components
and P. 18-20 tor the per unit constants.
-28-
LlNE TO NEUTRAL FAULT @ 120 V .
SINGLE PHASE TRANSFORMER
PER UNIT METHOD
1f6 SHORT-CIRCUIT CALCULATION - FAULT Xl
(1.13) (10,000)
75 KVA P.U.X = (1.2) X (100)(75) = (1.356) (1.33) = 1.8035
Transformer
1.13% X (.83) (10,000)
.83% R P.U.R = (1.5) X (100)(75) = (1.245) (1.33) = 1.6559
(.00008) (10,000)*
400A P.U.X = 1000 (.120)2 = (.00008) (694.44) = .0556
Switch
10,000 83333
Une to Neutral S.C. Sym RMS Amps @ 120 Volts = .120 (2.6423) = (2.6423) = 31,540 Amps .
Note: See P. 35 "Data Section" for impedance data for the electrical components
and P. 18-20 for the per unit constants.
-The multiplier of two (2) is not applicable since on a line to neutral fault only
one switch pole is involved.
-29-
LlN': TO LlNE FAUL T @ 240 VOLTS
10,000 KV A Base
IMPEDANCE DIAGRAM
P.U.R P.U.X
P.U.X =
50')(
2 X ~1000'
~
,y 10000
.0519lJX (1000) (.240)2
P.U.R =
50' )(
2 X~1000'
~
Y 10,000
.0805¿jX (1000) (.240)2
10,000 41667
Une to Une S.C. Sym RMS Amps @240 Volts = .240 (3.6561) = (3.6561) = 11,400 Amps
Note: See P. 35 "Data Section" for impedance data for the electrical components
and P. 18-20 for the por unit constants.
-30-
LlNE TO NEUTRAL FAUL T @ 120 V
P.U.R P.U.X
(.0001) (10,000)*
200 A P.U.X = 1000 (.120)2 = (.0001) (694.44) = .0694
Switch
r?
50' \1 ** 10000
P.U.X = 2 X&1Ooo)(.0519 ~x (1000) (.120)2
10,000 83333
Une to Neutral S.C. Sym RMS Amps @ 120 Volts = (.120) (9.2395) = 9.2395 = 9,020 Amps
Note: See P. 35 "Data Section" for impedance data for the electrical components
and P. 18-20 for the per unit constants.
*The multiplier of two (2) is not applicable sinca on a line-to-neutral fault only
one switch pole is involved .
•• Assuming the neutral conductor and line conductor are the same size.
-31-
EFFECT OF LOW AVAILABLE UTILlTY KVA
Everi when utility faulr currents are held down to a low level, it is not
always safe to specífy prorective devices with limited inrerrupting capacity.
Over night the available fault KV A which rhe utility can deliver might
be doubled or tripled, Since rhe destructive therrnal a nd magnetic torees
vary as rhe square of the current, 'a ny increase in fault level could result in
a disastrous situation. The prorecrive device selected should be one rhat
takes system growth into consideration.
System B poi nrs out rhat despite a very lirnired utiliry sho rr-circuir KV A,
rhere is considerable short-circuir current available and any furure increase
in rhe utiliry system wil! result in even more fault curre nt.
SYSTEM B
!~ 25,000 KV A Available
T
IF.l.= 1800 Amps
-32-
3 f2j SHORT -CIRCUIT CALCULATIO N - SYSTEM B
10,000 KVA Base - Per-Unit Method
IMPEDANCE DIAGRAM
P.U.R P.U.X
25,000 KV A
0.4000
Source
Transformer
Reactance 5.1% P.U.X = (5.1) (.1333) = 0.6800 (Table B) 0.6800
TR Page 19
ransformer . 0.1250
P.U.RTR = (0.94) (.1333) = 0.1250 (~~~~e1~)'
esistance 0.94%
~Fault
0.1250 1.0800
-33-
GENERAL DISCUSSIONS
OF
SHORT -CIRCUIT CALCULATIONS
-34-
DATA SECTION
-35-
Table l-TRANSFORMER IMPEDANCE DATA*
Percent R, X and Z based on Transíormer KVA.
UJ • O
'-Current Transformer
NOTE: Values given are in ohms per phase. For actual values, refer to
manufacturer's data.
-36-
Table 3 - DISCONNECTING SWITCH REACTANCE DATA
The reactance of disconnecting switches for low-voltage circuits (600
volrs and below) is in the arder of magnitude of 0.00008 ohms per pole to
0.00005 ohms per pole ar 60 cvcles fOT switches rared 400-4000 amperes
respectively. *
APPROXIMA TE
REAcTANCES**
Switch Size X
(Amps) (Ohms)
200 0.0001
400 0.00008
600 0.00008
800 0.00007
1200 0.00007
1600 0.00005
2000 0.00005
3000 0.00004 1-pole
4000 0.00004
NOTE: Due to the me!hod of raling low-voltage NOTE: Above 600 amperes the reac!ances of molded
. power circuit breakers, Ihe reactance of the case breakers are similar lo those given in
breaker which is to interrupt the fault is not the Low-Voltage Power Circuit Breaker
included in calculating fault current.] Table above.
ttFor actual values, consult manufacturero These values will vary with manufac-
turer and designo
-37-
Table 5-COPPER CABLE IMPEDANCE DATA*
OHMS PER 1000 FEET
R X Z R X Z R X Z R X Z
- - -----
___ o
----
8 .811 .0754 .814 .811 .0860 .816 .811 .0603 .813 .811 .0688 .814
8 (5011·d) .786 .0754 .790 .786 .0860 .791 .786 .0603 .788 .786 .0688 .789
6 .510 .0685 .515 .510 .0796 .516 .510 .0548 .513 .510 .0636 .514
6 (soli d) .496 .0685 .501 .496 .0796 .502 .496 .0548 .499 .496 .0636 .500
4 .321 .0632 .327 .321 .0742 .329 .321 .0506 .325 .321 .0594 .326
4 (soli d) .312 .0632 .318 .312 .0742 .321 .312 .0506 .31 6 .312 .0594 .318
2 .202 .0585 .210 .202 .0685 .214 .202 .0467 .20 7 .202 .0547 .209
1 .160 .0570 .170 .160 .0675 .174 .160 .0456 .16 6 .160 .0540 .169
1/0 .128 .0540 .139 .128 .0635 .143 .127 .0432 .13 4 .128 .0507 .138
2/0 .102 .0533 .115 .103 .0630 .121 .101 .0426 .110 .102 .0504 .114
3/0 .0805 .0519 .0958 .0814 .0605 .101 .0766 .0415 .08 71 .0805 .0484 .0939
4/0 .0640 .0497 .0810 .0650 .0583 .092 9 .0633 .0398 .07 48 .0640 .0466 .0792
250 .0552 .0495 .0742 .0557 .0570 .079 7 .Q541 .0396 .06 70 .0547 .0456 .0712
300 .0464· .0493 .0677 .0473 .0564 .073 6 .0451 .0394 .05 99 .0460 .0451 .0644
350 .0378 .0491 .0617 .0386 .0562 .068 1 .0368 .0393 .05 36 .0375 .0450 .0586
400 .0356 .0490 .0606 .0362 .0548 .065 7 .0342 .0392 .05 20 .0348 .0438 .0559
450 .0322 .0480 .0578 .0328 .0538 .063 o .0304 .0384 .04 90 .0312 .0430 .0531
500 .0294 .0466 .0551 .0300 .0526 .060 5 .0276 .0373 .04 64 .0284 .0421 .0508
600 .0257 .0463 .0530 .0264 .0516 .058 O .0237 .0371 .04 40 .0246 .0412 .0479
750
I .0216 .0445 .0495 .0223 ! .0497 .054 5
---
.0194 .0356 .04 05 .0203 .0396 .0445
--
Three-Conductor Cable
---------------------------- -----_. ----
In Magnetic Duct and Steel Interlocked Armar In Nonmagnetic Duct and Aluminum Interlocked Armar
-_._--- -_.--
AWG 5 kv Shielded and 600 v and 5 kv
600 v and 5 kv 5 kv Shielded and
or 15 kv 15 kv
Nonshielded Nonshield ed
MCM
R X Z R X
----
Z__ I__ R I__--_-
X__ Z
--
R X Z
8 .811 .0577 .813 .811 .0658 .81 4 .811 .0503 .812 .811 .0574 .813
8 (sol id) .786 .0577 .788 .786 .0658 .78 9 .786 .0503· .787 .786 .0574 .788
6 .510 .0525 .513 .510 .0610 .51 4 .510 .0457 .512 .510 .0531 .513
6 (sol id) .496 .0525 .499 .496 .0610 .50 O .496 .0457 .498 .496 .0531 .499
4 .321 .0483 .325 .321 .0568 .32 6 .321 .0422 .324 .321 .0495 .325
4 (sol id) .312 .0483 .316 .312 .0508 .31 7 .312 .0422 .315 .312 .0495 .316
2 .202 .0448 .207 .202 .0524 .20 9 .202 .0390 .206 .202 .0457 .207
1 .160 .0436 .166 .160 .0516 .16 8 .160 .0380 .164 .160 .0450 .166
1/0 .128 .0414 .135 .128 .0486 .13 7 .127 .0360 .132 .128 .0423 .135
2/0 .102 .0407 .110 .103 .0482 .11 4 .101 .0355 .107 .102 .0420 .110
3/0 .0805 .0397 .0898 .0814 .0463 .09 36 .0766 .0346 .0841- .0805 .0403 .090
4/0 .0640 .0381 .0745 .0650 .0446 .07 88 .0633 .0332 .0715 .0640 .0389 .0749
250 .0552 .0379 .0670 .0557 .0436 .07 07 .0541 .0330 .0634 .0547 .0380 .0666
300 .0464 .0377 .0598 .0473 .0431 .06 40 .0451 .0329 .0559 .0460 .0376 .0596
350 .0378 .0373 .0539 .0386 .0427 .05 76 .0368 .0328 .0492 .0375 .0375 .0530
400 .0356 .0371 .0514 .0362 .0415 .05 51 .0342 .0327 .0475 .0348 .0366 .0505
450 .0322 .0361 .0484 .0328 .0404 .05 20 .0304 .0320 .0441 .0312 .0359 .0476
500 .0294 .0349 .0456 .0300 .0394 .04 95 .0276 .0311 .0416 .0284 .0351 .0453
600 .0257 .0343 .0429 .0264 .0382 .04 64 .0237 .0309 .0389 .0246 .0344 .0422
750 .. 0216 .0326 .0391 .0223 .0364 .04 27 .0197 .0297 .0355 .0203 .0332 ·.0389
--- _ ..
Resis!ance based on tinned copper at 60 cycles. 600 volt and 5 kv unshielded based on varnished cambric insulation. 5 kv shielded
and 15 kv cable based on Neoprene insulation. Values shown are lar 1000 lee! of cable a! 75 C.
-38-
Table 6-ALUMINUM CABLE IMPEDANCE DATA*
APPROXIMATE OHMS PER 1000 FEET
Cross-Linked Polyethylene Insulated Cable Resistance, Reactance and Impedance Aluminum Conductor Cable
1/0 .210 .043 .214 .210 .056 .217 , .210 .034 .213 .210 .045 .215
2/0 .167 .041 .172 .167 .055 .176 .167 .033 .170 .167 .044 .173
3(0 .133 .040 .139 .132 .053 .142 .133 .037 .137 .132 .042 .139
4/0 .106 .039 .113 .105 .051 .117 .105 .031 .109 .105 .041 .113
250 .0896 .0384 .0975 .0892 .0495 .102 .0894 .0307 .0945 .0891 .0396 .0975
300 .0750 .0375 .0839 .0746 .0479 .0887 .0746 .0300 .0804 .0744 .0383 .0837
350 .0644 .0369 .0742 .0640 .0468 .0793 .0640 .0245 .0705 .0638 .0374 .0740
400 .0568 .0364 .0675 .0563 .0459 .0726 .0563 .0291 .0634 .0560 .0367 .0700
500 .0459 .0355 .0580 .0453 .0444 .0634 .0453 .0284 .0535 .0450 .0355 .0573
600 .0388 .0359 .0529 .0381 .0431 .0575 .0381 .0287 .0477 .0377 .0345 .0511
700 .0338 .0350 .0487 .0332 .0423 .0538 .0330 .0280 .0433 .0326 .0338 .0470
750 .0318 .0341 .0466 .0310 .0419 .0521 .0309 .0273 .0412 .0304 .0335 .0452
1000 .0252 .0341 .0424 .0243 .0414 .0480 I .0239 .0273 .0363 .0234 .0331 .0405
Three-Conductor Cables
R X Z R X Z R X Z R X Z
1/0 .210 .043 .214 .210 .050 .216 .210 .034 .213 .210 .040 .214
2/0
3/0
.167
.133
.041
.040
.172
.139
.167
.133
.049
.048
.174
.141
.167
.133
.033
.037
.170
.137
.167
.133
I .039
.038
.171
.138
4/0 .106 .039 .113 .105 .045 .114 .105 .031 .109 .105 I .036 .111
250 .0896 .0384 .0975 .0895 .0436 .100 .0894 .0307 .0945 .0893 .0349 .0959
300 .0750 .0375 .0839 .0748 .0424 .0860 .0746 .0300 .0804 .0745 .0340 .0819
350 .0644 .0369 .0742 .0643 .0418 .0767 .0640 .0245 .0705 .0640 .0334 .0722
400 .0568 .0364 .0675 .0564 .0411 .0700 .0563 .0291 .0634 .0561 .0329 .0650
500 .0459 .0355 .0580 .0457 .0399 .0607 .0453 .0284 .0535 .0452 .0319 .0553
600 .0388 .0359 .0529 .0386 .0390 .0549 .0381 .0287 .0477 .0380 .0312 .0492
700 .0338 .0350 .0487 .0335 .0381 .0507 .0330 .0280 .0433 .0328 .0305 .0448
750 .0318 .0341 .0466 .0315 .0379 .0493 .0309 .0273 .0412 .0307 .0303 .0431
1000 .0252 .0341 .0424 .0248 .0368 .0444 .0239 .0273 .0363 .0237 .0294 .0378
Values Are for 1000 Circuit Feet at 90°C Conductor *Courtesy of Kaiser Aluminum Electrical Produds Divisi
-39-
Table 7-BUSWAV IMPEDANCE DATA-
OHMS PER 1000 FEET
(Iine-to-neutral, 60 cycles)
Plug-In Busway
Ampere
Resistance Reaclance Impedance Resistance Reactance Impedance
Rating
225 0.0262 0.0229 0.0348 0.0398 0.0173 0.0434
400 0.0136 0.0218 0.0257 0.0189 0.0216 0.0288
600 0.0113 0.0216 0,0244 0.0179 0.0190 0.0261
[ The above data represents values which are a composite 01 those obtained by a survey 01 industry; values tend to be on the
low side.
Ampere XjR
Rating Resistance Reactance lrnp=dancr- Ratio
1000 0.013 0.063 0.064 4.85
1350 0.012 0.061 0.062 5.08
1600 0.009 0.056 0057 6.22
2000 0.007 0.052 0.052 7.45
2500 0.006 0.049 0.049 8.15
3000 0.005 0.046 0.046 9.20
4000 0.004 0,042 0.042 iO.50
-40-
Table 8 - ASYMMETRICAL FACTORS t
Ratio to Symmetrical Rms Amperes
jReprinted with the permission 01 NEMA. Puh. No RU 1·IQ72. Par\ 3, P<I. \?, 13.
--41-
SELECTIVE SYSTEMS
(Blackout Prevention)
Having determined rhe faulrs rhat musr he interrupred, rhe next step
is to specify Protective Devices rhat will pro vide a Selective System with
proper Inrerrupting Capacity .....
Such a system assures safety under al! service conditions and prevents
needless inrerruption of serviee on circuirs other than the one on which a
fault oecurs.
The topic of Selectiviry will be discussed in the next Ha ndbook , Parr n.
In order to prevent Blackours some simple exarnples of selectively
coordinared systems are sho~-n on the fr,llowing pages.
NOTE: The following systems also comply with Section 230-98 of the National Electrical.
eode - 1975 which requires adequate short-circuit rating of service equipment.
-42-
A SELECTIVE SYSTEM
for circuits of 600 volts or less -
having available fault current of 200,000 or less rms
symmetrical amperes - using HI-CAP® time-delay fuses
and FUSETRON® dual-element fuses throuqhout.
Transformer
FUSETRON dual-element Fuses
60 arnp.
FUSETRON dual-element Fuses
oto 30 ampo
KRP-C Lighting
HI-CAP Emergency Panel
time-delay Fuses Lighting .
1600 ampo Panel
FUSETRON dual-element Fuses
125 to 400 ampo
FUSETRON
dual-element Fuses
o lo 60 ampo
FUSETRON dual-element Fuses Lighting FUSETRON
125 to 400 ampo
Panel dual-element Fuses
.o to 60 ampo
~FUSETRON
FUSETRON dual-element Fuses dual-element Fuses Power Panel
400 ampo Lighting o to 60 ampo
Panel
FUSETRON dual-element
60 to 400 ampo
(
Fuses FUSETRON d 1_ I
ua e emen
t F
uses
~--o"-o{[] 010200amp. O ~~
Large Motor
FUSETRON dual-element Fuses
100 to 400 ampo
Transformer
FUSETRON dual-elernent Fus
Oto 60 ampo .
-43-
A SELECl'IVE SYSTEM
For circuits of 277/480 volts or less having
available fault current of 100,000or less rms
symmetrical amperes - HI-CAP® time-delay fuses, LOW-PEAK®
dual-element fuses and BUSS® Type SC fuses throughout.
Emergency
Panel
SC Fuses
60 ampo
~
SC Fuses
~030amp.
SC Fuses
KRP-C o lo 60 ampo
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses
2000 ampo
LOW-PEAK
dual-element Fuses Lightirig
125 lo 600 ampo Panel SC Fuses
o lo 60 ampo
SC Fuses
o lo 60 ampo
LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses .....•.•....
_ ..•••.
400 lo 600 ampo ~ '--
~_O~~----B-r-an-C-h-s-g-i-~-:-~-S-:-~-~-e-ct-io-n-(¿TM_o_t~o_r_C(¿To_n_tr_O_I~(~~e_n_~_r~(¿~_~(¿_d-ua-~:~ses
~--o~f---~---------------...,
LOW-PEAK
dual-element Fuses
~-¡~ LOW-PEAK
Iyl
dual-element Fuses
100 lo 600 ampo 125% Molar F. L. A.
I I
-44-
A SELECTIVE SYSTEM
for circuits of 600 volts or less -
having available fault current of 200,000 or less rms
symmetríeal amperes - using HI-CAP® time-delay fuses and
LOW-PEAK® dual-element fuses throughout.
Lighting
KRP-C Emergency
Panel
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses Lighting
2000 ampo Panel ~
LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses
125 lo 600 ampo ~
~
Lighting
LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses
. 125 lo 600 ampo
Panel ~
LOW-PEAK
dual-élernent Fuses
Oto 60 ampo
LOW-PEAK
dual-element Fuses ~\;:~:ng ...•.....__ LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses
125 to 600 ampo 'Q..J.....l.}-- oto 60 ampo .
~
Lighting
LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses Panel
125 to 600 ampo o to 60 ampo ~
~
LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses
400 lo 600 ampo Power Panel ~
t---O~---"""6--b~-"""b--b-r----O-r-i --6-r-- LOW-PEAK
dual-element Fuses
o lo 60 ampo
LOW-PEAK (( . ( (
dual-element Fuses Lighting
60 lo 600 ampo LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses
f---O~ 010200amp. O~r-rx.r-@ Panel
Large
LOW-PEAK dual-element Fuses
100 lo 600 ampo Motor
Transformer LOW-PEAK
dual-element Fuses
Oto 60 ampo
-45-
A 'St:l'ECTIVE SYSTEM
For circuits of 600 volts or less having available fault
current of 200,000 or less rms symmetrical amperes -
Iisinq HI-CAP® time-delay fuses, types KRP-C and JHq-
Lineside Fuse maintaining 2 to 1 ratio with Loadside Fuse.
Emergency
Panel
* JHC HI-CAP time-delay Fuses
...•......
__ JHC HI-CAP time-delay Fuses . JHC
"V1L.l.t-- H I-C A P
time-delay Fuses
KRP-C
Hi-Cap time-delay Fuses
JHC Lighting
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses Panel
JHC Lighting
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses Panel JHC
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses
JHC·
HI-CAP Lighting
time-delay Fuses Panel ~JHC
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses
JHC
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses .
Lighting "-orr:n-
Panel JHC JHC
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses HI-CAP time-delay Fuse:
"-orr:n- ~
JHC
Lighting
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses
Panel ~
I~--------------------------------------------~
JHC ~
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses
~JHC
Power HI-CAP time-delay Fuses
Panel
JHC
?¿ ???i
HI-CAP time-delay Fuses M t C tiC t
~ o or on ro en er
1----0
-46-
A SELECTIVE SYSTEM
for circuits of 115/230 volts or less - having available fault
current of 100,000or less rms symmetrical amperes - uslriq
BUSS® Type SC, size limiting fuses for protection
of Residential and Small Commercial circuits ,
SC Fuses
1.5 or 20 ampo
~ Appliance l.oad
~ Refrigerator
Range or
Range Top and
Oyen
~ Deep Freeze
~ Lights/Receptacles
t------- Water Heater
~ Lights/Receptacles
~Spare
"-o-[J}-- Dryer/Washer
2 Pole, SC Fuses
30 ampo
2 Pole, SC Fuses
60 ampo
.- ,Vi - .
FUSE SYMBOlS, CLASSES AND INTERRUPTING RATINGS
Underwriters' Interrupting
Fuse Laboratories Ine. Rating
Symbol Trade Mark Classífieation Listed Amps RMS Sym
Underwriters' Laboratories Ine. at the present time does not have test criteria established tor Time Delay Class J fuses.
Lrsted by eSA (Canadian Stds. Association) lo their Test Standard 01 100.nODA.
·Pending U.L. 300 Volt classification.
Some ampere ralings available as class K5 in NON 0-60A and NOS 0-60A
-----McGRAWiDlSom ---_._---
Bussmann
aUss.m~nnManufactL~ri"gDivi!.ion
McGraw-Edison Company
502 E"rth City "'Ia",a
P.€). Bo" 14460
Sto Louis. MO 63178
(314} 739-9600 Telex 44-U41
(038)
N Print,:.rl in I I e; A