B2B E-Commerce Models Explained
B2B E-Commerce Models Explained
[email protected], www.raakengg.com
IT-E81 E-COMMERCE
Unit II
E-commerce Models: Business-to-Business – Hubs - Market Places - Business-to-Business
Exchange -Business-to-Consumer - Consumer-to-consumer - Business-to-Government -
Government-to-Government.
B2B (business – to‐ business) is the major and valuable model of e‐commerce. B2B
(business – to‐ business) e‐commerce is conducted between two separate businesses and
has been in effect for many years.
As an example, a wholesaler places an order from a company's website and after
receiving the shipment, it sells the end product to the final customer who comes to buy
the product at the wholesaler's retail outlet.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 1
E‐commerce plays an important role in enhancing and transforming relationships
between and among business.
B2B (business – to‐ business)is also known as e‐biz, is the exchange of products,
services, or information between businesses rather than between businesses and
consumers.
B2B (business – to‐ business )is a kind of ecommerce, which refers to a company selling
or buying from other companies. One company communicates with other companies
through electronic Medias.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 2
processes, and any other collaboration between the organizations. From a technology perspective
this includes linking the CRM, ERP and SCM systems of the two organizations. This way each
organization can actually monitor sales activity, production schedules, inventory management,
and technical service exchanges.
Key Technologies
Architectural Models
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 3
on who controls the marketplace: the buyer, the supplier or the intermediary.
In a Buyer-Orientated Marketplace few buyers face many suppliers.
In a Supplier-Oriented Marketplace many buyers face few suppliers.
In an Intermediary-Oriented Marketplace many buyers face many suppliers.
Other important B2B models are virtual corporation, networking between the headquarters and
subsidiaries and online services to business. This paper concentrates on the three B2B EC
models.
This would be very costly and time consuming for big buyers, who purchase
thousands of items on the Internet.
As a result, such big buyers prefer to open their own marketplace, which is called a
Buyer-Oriented Marketplace.
Buyer-Oriented Marketplaces are found in industrial sectors with few and dominant
buyers.
Intermediary-Oriented Marketplace
Characteristics of the Intermediary-Oriented Marketplace
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 4
The Intermediary-Oriented Marketplace is a neutral business platform and offers the
classical economic functions of a usual market.
By offering search functions, the marketplace makes the comparison and transparency
of products possible.
Marketplaces can also offer auctions. These auctions can be organized by sellers
(products are sold) or by buyers (orders are sold).
The intermediary company running the marketplace can generate profits through
provisions for successful transactions and for negotiation of services (e.g. a logistical
company to deliver the products).
The company can also charge fees for membership and for presenting information,
offers or requests.
The company can also distribute its own products through the marketplace profiting
from more buyers entering the site than e.g. a normal e-store.
This would be very costly and time consuming for big buyers, who purchase thousands
of items on the Internet.
As a result, such big buyers prefer to open their own marketplace, which is called a
Buyer-Oriented Marketplace.
By supporting transactions and procurement processes, these market places offer great
potentials in cost savings.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 5
Buyer-Oriented Marketplaces are found in industrial sectors with few and dominant
buyers.
2. Inventory Management
Electronic applications make the order‐ship bill cycle shorter. Businesses can easily keep track of
their documents to make sure that they were received. Such a system improves auditing
capabilities, and helps reduce inventory levels, improve inventory turns, and eliminate out‐ of
stock occurrences.
3. Distribution Management
Electronic based applications make the transmission of shipping documents much easier and
faster. Shipping documents include bill of lading, purchase orders, advance ship notices, and
manifest claims. E‐commerce also enables more efficient resource management by certifying
that documents contain more accurate data.
4. Channel Management
E‐commerce allows for speedier distribution of information regarding changes in operational
conditions to trading partners. Technical, product and pricing information can be posted with
much ease on electronic bulletin boards.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 6
5. Payment Management
An electronic payment system allows for a more efficient payment management system by
minimizing clerical errors, increasing the speed of computing invoices, and reducing transaction
fees and costs.
Case Study 1 – B2B
Marketing Enterprise Software
B2B Communications helps FastTrack compete with giants
Fast Track, located in Queensland, Australia, offers regulatory compliance software for
large organizations. Over three decades, the 11-person company has been chosen over the likes
of IBM and Oracle for its innovative FastTrack.net platform.
The platform is deployed across major organizations such as Motorola, Parsons Brinkerhoff, the
Australian Department of Defence, and at hundreds of companies in medicine, mining, quality
management, and utilities.
In 2012, however, Sales was finding business decision makers more inclined to research their
options online than gather information via sales meetings. At the time, the Fast Track website
didn't support that kind of buying journey. Then, in June of 2012, founder and technical director
Greg Carroll ran across an article about B2B Communications' inbound marketing methodology.
Soon after, Fast Track retained B2B.
"B2B Communications, through their inbound marketing expertise, is helping Fast Track as it
competes against much larger competitors. It's certainly changed the level of management with
whom we are engaging."
Fast Track knew it needed to transform how it interacted with potential buyers - fast. "The way
that people buy has changed dramatically," observed Greg. "Prospects don't want to be sold to.
They expect to be better informed before making a selection; and as a company, we need to
provide helpful information that facilitates the buying process."
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 7
Building trust
Fast Track needed a website that inspired confidence in visitors and offered tangible
takeaways. The site needed to instantly convey to experienced executives that Fast Track has an
impressive track record and is worth comparing to brand name solutions
In fact, some customers had initially bought from big brands like IBM or Oracle, then
sought out Fast Track for its software features, service, and value. To help prospects compare
their options before buying from a big brand, Fast Track published the "10 Essentials" guide ,
which offers checklists, examples, and facts demonstrating that, when it comes to enterprise
software providers, big doesn't mean best.
Leadership also started sharing their expertise and opinions through webinars and a
company blog. Blog posts are frank and informative, not product focused. After the company's
inbound marketing had ramped up and it published the blog post, "Safety In Size? Not for IBM
Software Implementations", for example, site visits doubled and visit-to-response conversions
soared.
Today, Greg says, blogging and social media are keys ways that Fast Track gets in front
of the right people. "We're reaching a lot more prospects through our blog and LinkedIn. When
they're ready to buy, our name registers."
B2B helped Fast Track repurpose and expand on webinar content and blog content to
produce “Mastering 21st century Enterprise Risk Management”, a book that solidifies Greg's
position as an authority on risk (Figure 4).
"It's certainly changed the level of management with whom I am now engaging," he says.
"Without your initial ghost writing and subsequent review and advice, this would never have
occurred."
Customer case studies also began reaching the target audience via media coverage. A
case study B2B wrote and placed on Fast Track's behalf, for example, was published in the
mining industry's magazine, Ferrett. Fast Track's sales team could now offer the article to
prospects at appropriate times, and/or offer the new product guide, product demo, 10 Essentials
guide, other case studies, and more.
Measuring progress
As of spring of 2014:
Fast Track ranked above competitors in search engine results for often-searched phrases
like "compliance software" (Figure 6).
Site visits had risen 1,152% since the launch of inbound marketing efforts
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 8
Inbound links from reputable sites -- the currency of the internet -- rose from 4 to 118
Inbound requests for information averaged 12 per week, up from 5 per month
Among those requesting information: decision makers at major institutions in Fast
Track's target audience
"Both our COO and I are 'Top Contributors' on LinkedIn now, and are having active
conversations with the likes of the chairman of ISO31000 and leading counsel for the Australian
Institute of Company Directors," observes Greg. "B2B Communications, through their inbound
marketing expertise, has given Fast Track a great digital presence, which is helping Fast Track as
it competes against much larger competitors. B2B has not only elevated our standing as an expert
in the marketplace, but has also improved our standing with existing customers. It's certainly
changed the level of management with whom we are engaging."
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 9
Dedicated Team
Proven Method
Weekly Reporting
About B2B Communications
We are a business to business (B2B) marketing agency helping companies accelerate trust, leads,
and growth. We help marketing directors and business owners engage more potential clients,
while using limited resources. Allstate, National Business Group on Health, Qualys, Sutter
Health, Surewest, and Swagelok, as well as dozens of $1M-$50M firms have hired us since
2001. Close teamwork with clients has helped produce roughly $2.2B worth of qualified leads
over the last decade.
MARKET PLACE:
A (digital) marketplace is a piece of software with comprehensive E-Commerce
functionality.
It can be characterized by m suppliers and n customers (m>1, n>1).
Process and software are under control of the marketplace owner. It uses portal
technologies and enables the cooperation of different suppliers and different customers.
Providing and demanding organizations act autonomously.
It is possible, that members are at the same time providing and demanding organizations.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 10
trade.
Price components: material, service, production, transport, profit margin.
Consequences for the consumer: contract business, spot business.
Value creation: A-Products (Goods needed for the production),
C-Products (MRO =Maintenance/Repair/Operations).
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 11
Buying (E-Sourcing, E-Procurement, workflow),
Sales (ordering, order management),
Stock exchange,
Transport,
Invoicing,
Payment,
Additionally: All functions which can be offered centrally for various market actors, Interfaces
(Provider, customer, forwarding and shipping agency, other service providers, e.g. insurance
firms).
eCo Framework
There is a framework for electronic marketplaces. It has been developed between 1994
and
1999 by CommerceNet, an American industry association. Updates have been released with
respect to CORBA, Java and XML. This framework has 7 layers:
Network: aggregation of different marketplaces, is a kind of registry,
• Market: different actors, sorted by industries,
• Business: definition of a firm, can have different roles, can ask for different products
or services, can offer different products or services,
• Service: specific services which can be offered (e.g. download a catalogue, send an
order, delivery status), interaction of different companies,
• Interaction: communication between business partners, e.g. ordering, order
confirmation, exception reporting,
• Document: complete document for specific transactions, consists of different
data elements,
• Data element: basic elements, are defined according to specific patterns.
B2B marketplaces can be defined as a World Wide Web site where goods and services
can be bought from a wide range of suppliers.
Online exchanges vary according to the size and number of companies using them and
the type of commodity traded.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 12
There are successful exchanges in markets as diverse as energy, textiles and logistics.
Online exchanges allow participants to trade straightforwardly with a wide variety of
buyers and sellers.
Two of the biggest factors driving the growth of exchanges are that large businesses can
use them to reduce stock holdings while small businesses can bid collectively to earn
volume discounts or to jointly deliver a large contract.
Types of Exchanges
There are three types of e-marketplaces marketplaces based around a specific industry
sectors; marketplaces based around products and services; marketplaces focused on the
functions.2)
1. Marketplaces based around a specific industry sectors are called vertical marketplaces.
Petroleum industry is an example. Those help buyers source goods and services that are
largely specific to industries.
2. The type of marketplace which is formed around a wider supply market that cuts across
several industries is called horizontal marketplace. Examples include the marketplaces for
maintenance, repair and operating (MRO) goods such as safety and office supplies. The
value of the horizontal marketplaces is that they efficiently match the needs of the one with
the offerings of the other.
3. The marketplaces focusing on functions gain value from concentrating functional
capabilities and quality services. For example they help HR departments manage employee
benefits; help companies dispose of excess inventory and so on.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 13
Barriers in Usage
Trust is an important issue for B2B e-marketplaces. The most important trust issues for
participation in B2B e-marketplaces are the following:
Transparency, in particular of the terms and conditions of the contract and the transaction
procedure.
Security, Confidentiality
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 14
It is a natural progression for many retailers or marketer who sells directly to the
consumer.
The general idea is, if you could reach more customers, service them better, make
more sales while spending less to do it that would the formula of success for
implementing a B2C e‐commerce infrastructure.
In B2C model, a business website is a place where all the transactions take place directly
between a business organization and a consumer.
In the B2C model, a consumer goes to the website, selects a catalog, orders the catalog, and an
email is sent to the business organization. After receiving the order, goods are dispatched to the
customer. Following are the key features of the B2C model −
A consumer −
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 15
compares similar items for price, delivery date or any other terms.
places the order.
pays the bill.
receives the delivered item and review/inspect them.
consults the vendor to get after service support or returns the product if not satisfied with
the delivered product.
Disintermediation and Re-intermediation
In traditional commerce, there are intermediating agents like wholesalers, distributors, and
retailers between the manufacturer and the consumer. In B2C websites, a manufacturer can sell
its products directly to potential consumers. This process of removal of business layers
responsible for intermediary functions is called disintermediation.
Nowadays, new electronic intermediary breeds such as e-mall and product selection agents are
emerging. This process of shifting of business layers responsible for intermediary functions from
traditional to electronic mediums is called re-intermediation.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 16
Characteristics
The B2C model focuses on direct selling and marketing between a business and a consumer via
an e-commerce website. A lower purchase volume of higher priced products typically
characterizes B2C companies. Since the model depends on individual transactions and eliminates
the wholesale purchaser, the company can make a higher profit while the consumer spends the
same amount of money or sometimes less. B2C is effective for smaller companies since
individual consumers are not as concerned with company recognition as they are with getting the
product for the best price.
Types
B2C companies divide into five major categories: direct sellers, online intermediaries,
advertising-based models, community-based models and fee-based models. Each type is so
different from the others that they are not directly comparable. In fact, some B2C businesses
utilize more than one type to reach different audiences.
Direct Sellers
Direct sellers, such as online retailers, sell a product or service directly to the customer
via a website. You can further divide direct sellers into e-tailers and manufacturers.
E-tailers are electronic retailers that either ship products from their own warehouses or
trigger deliveries from other companies’ stocks. Product manufacturers use the Internet
as a catalog and sales channel to eliminate intermediaries.
Online Intermediaries
Online intermediaries perform the same function as any other broker.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 17
The business allows non-B2C companies to reap some of the benefits. Brokers offer
buyers a service and help sellers by altering the price-setting processes, according to
economics professors Thierry Pénard of the University of Delaware and Michael A.
Arnold of the University of Rennes in Rennes, France.
Advertising-Based Models
Popular websites rely on advertising-based models. These websites offer a free service to
consumers and use advertising revenue to cover costs.
They draw a large number of visitors, making them ideal advertising streams for other
companies. Advertisers will pay a premium to sites that deliver high traffic numbers.
Community-Based Models
Community-based models combine the advertising method that relies on traffic at sites
that focus on specialized groups to create communities.
Community sales and advertising take advantage of social and network marketing by
focusing on specific groups that want specific products. For example, sites used by
computer programmers are perfectly placed to advertise computer hardware and software
products. At least one social media website uses member information to target
advertisements to interests and locations.
Fee-Based Models
Pay-as-you-buy or paid subscription services fall under fee-based models.
The most common of these are online subscriptions to journals or movie sites such as
NetFlix. These companies rely on the quality of their content to convince consumers to
pay a usually nominal fee.
HEBEL
How CSR Hebel successfully changed a trade brand into a consumer one
The Challenge
For over 20 years, CSR, Australia’s largest building products company (and the second
oldest ASX listed company still in operation) had marketed Hebel AAC blocks and Aerated
Autoclaved Concrete (AAC) panels to the Australian building industry.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 18
Hebel Panels and blocks had many attributes that were becoming increasingly attractive
to both builders and consumers.
With the changing emphasis and awareness on the environment, sustainability and rising
building costs, BrandQuest was commissioned by CSR Hebel to undertake a brand marketing
strategy to grow consumer demand for Hebel, whilst also integrating the existing trade brands.
The Solution
Working inclusively with the CSR Hebel Management Team, BrandQuest created a
consumer-driven brand marketing strategy designed to create consumer awareness of the Hebel
product and for the broader residential building trade to adapt to the demand of their customers
and become Hebel qualified builders.
Collaborating and engaging with management and staff the brand marketing strategy
defined a customer driven motivational segmentation that was proven through a consumer
research study.
A newly defined brand positioning and differentiation was created to ensure consistency and
discipline across all communication touch-points for the Hebel business. In addition the
introduction of a newly defined Hebel ‘brand essence’ was contained within the strategy for
inclusion internally and externally for the Hebel brand.
The Results
As an outcome of the brand marketing strategy a brand audit determined the need for a
fresher, more contemporary Hebel logo to reinforce the appeal of the Hebel product to its
broader and more diverse consumer audience. In addition the brand marketing strategy informed
the simplification of the previous brand architecture/hierarchy and simplied the range of sub
brands.
New Brand Guidelines provided the creative ‘look and feel’ for the development of the
new consumer driven marketing campaign that was underpinned with the theme; ‘You’ll love
coming home to Hebel’.
A dedicated Consumer website was created that delivered directly to the needs and
aspirations of this audience and the current Trade website was significantly updated to reflect the
newly developed branding. Importantly, all previous trade design and installation guides and
product brochures were created in line with the new Hebel Brand Guidelines.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 19
A Consumer magazine and radio campaign was test-marketed in two states as a precursor to a
broader national campaign. Following the success of the test market a television commercial was
produced to take the Consumer brand to a national audience.
In addition BrandQuest helped refresh/rewrite and reconstruct the trade side of the business. This
included developing and upgrading Product and Range guides along with Design and Installation
guides which had many intrinsic components.
Following the development of a television commercial the awareness of the new branding
showed a 30%+ increase.
Importantly in a struggling national building and construction category Hebel increased both its
market share and revenues in the immediate two years following the brand change project.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 20
platform on which C2C transaction takes place. Buyer can shop for free, but sellers sometimes
have to pay a fee to list their products. Consumers often play an active role in monitoring e-
commerce sites for scam and other inappropriate content .
In most cases, C2C e-commerce is helped along by a third party who officiate the
transaction to make sure goods are received and payments are made. This offers some
protection for consumers taking part in C2C e-commerce, allowing the chance to take
advantage of the prices offered by motivated seller. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the
origin, definition, business model, statistics, advantages and disadvantages of C2C e-
commerce.The paper will further look at some features of C2C e-commerce website.
A website following the C2C business model helps consumers to sell their assets like
residential property, cars, motorcycles, etc., or rent a room by publishing their information on
the website. Website may or may not charge the consumer for its services. Another consumer
may opt to buy the product of the first customer by viewing the post/advertisement on the
website.
This is a business model where two individuals or consumers transact or conduct
business with each other directly. Generally, an intermediary/third party maybe involved, but
the purpose of the intermediary is only to facilitate the transaction and provide a platform for
the people to connect to each other. The intermediary would receive a fee or commission, but is
not responsible for the product exchange. C2C normally takes the form of an auction where the
bidding is done online.
The C2C model involves transactions between consumers. Here a consumer sells directly
to another consumer. EBay and www.bazee.com are common examples of online auction
websites that provide a consumer to advertise and sell their product online to another consumer.
However, it is important that both the seller and the buyer register with the auction site. While
the seller needs to pay a fixed fee to the online auction house to sell their products, the buyer can
bid without paying any fee. The site brings the buyer and seller together to conduct deals.
Two customers (customer 1 and customer 2) and a website providing the space for
advertisement. Customer 1 places advert on the website about products he wants to sell and
customer 2 visits the website to search for products he wants to buy. The transaction between
the customers goes on until payment and delivery of product is done.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 21
Some Important Features or Functionalities of C2C Web Application
It is always available so that consumers can have access to whenever they feel like
shopping
There is regular updating of the website
Consumers selling products to other consumers benefit from the higher profitability
that result from selling directly to one another
There is a low transaction cost; sellers can post their goods over the internet at a
cheaper rate far better than higher price of renting a space in a store
Customer can directly contact sellers and do without an intermediary.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 22
There could be theft as scammers might try to create their website with names of some
famous C2C websites such as eBay to attract customers.
There is lack of controlling quality of the products.
Government - to - Business
Governments use B2G model websites to approach business organizations.
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 23
Such websites support auctions, tenders, and application submission functionalities.
G2B (Government to Business) is a term that refers to the relationships between
organizations (subjects) of public administration and enterprises (businesses).
The designation can be used for any relationship between the subject of public
administration and the enterprises as one of the basic e-Government models (other
model are G2E, G2C or G2G).
In G2B model the initiative comes from a government organization and businesses are
the target group.
Some sources distinguish also B2G (Business to Government) where the initiative
comes from businesses, while other sources consider both G2B and B2G as equal
without important no significant difference, ie. with the same meaning.
How looks G2B / G2B model in practice?
The model covers an electronic exchange of any information between businesses and the
government, usually using internet so the cooperation or communication is more
efficient than is usually off the internet.
In G2B, government agencies and business use websites, procurement marketplaces,
applications, web services.
The relationship may refer the demand for information from the enterprises in any life
situation or a transfer of an official document to the statutory body.
The model is usually used to refer to the ICT solution that converts such communication
to the electronic form or to describe a solution that simplifies the communication
between public administration and enterprises (e.g. internet portal of the procurement
authority or electronic solutions for purchasing).
Examples of G2B / B2G services are:
government procurement
electronic procurement marketplaces
electronic auctions
e-learning
electronic incorporation forms
updating corporate information
sending filled-out electronic forms (eg tax forms, social insurance forms)
sending electronic payments
sending / receiving answers electronically
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 24
on-line meetings
project management cooperation
data centers, SaaS, PaaS or IaaS for e-government use
Government - to - Citizen
Governments use G2C model websites to approach citizen in general. Such websites
support auctions of vehicles, machinery, or any other material.
Such website also provides services like registration for birth, marriage or death
certificates.
The main objective of G2C websites is to reduce the average time for fulfilling citizen’s
requests for various government services.
G2C (Government to Citizen) is a term that refers to the relationships between
organizations (subjects) of public administration and a citizen(s).
The designation can be used for any relationship between the subject of public
administration and the citizen, most often it is used as one of the basic relationship
within e-Government models.
The initiative comes from a federal organization (public administration) and citizens are
the target group.
G2C concept is used for expressing the relationship between public administration and
citizens.
The relationship may refer the demand for information from the citizen in any life
situation or a transfer of an official document to the citizen.
The abbreviation is usually used to refer to the ICT solution that converts such
communication to the electronic form or to describe a solution that simplifies the
communication between public administration and citizens (e.g. office website or public
service catalog).
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 25
GOVERNMENT TO GOVERNMENT [G2G]
Several factors are driving local and federal governments to institute G2G initiatives.
By sharing information and systems, governments are able to reduce IT costs government
offices can be more efficient and streamline procedures, allowing citizens to access
information over the Internet.
They may also qualify for grant funding, depending on the project. An example of a
successful G2G project is the Northeast Gang Information System (NEGIS).
NEGIS is used by states in the northeast to share information about street gangs,
including gang-related activities and gang intelligence.
The system connects all the state police departments of the participating states, and the
police departments transmit the collected information to their states’ other law
enforcement and public service agencies.
1. Explain the difference business models of e-commerce with respect to the customers
and vendors? (11)
RAAKCET/IT/IT E81
Page 26