ffi*pi:'#tr+ *'f she Fh.

iiipp;ne*
,,',, i{at[,sr]a$ F*fii,ee :d**r*i::issic,n
p{-*( g- (FP} ruU $"-$AT*GI{AL F*t-i C-=
,e
R.-f&T'$ fl,lft'$&"$- #AP' T&L ffi"$ S I * $',* F # i: i
fi H i:' F'F i * E
.;; ffiFFgffiffi ffiF Tfi-{E ffiE.&I#NAt j]IRH*T#R
C*rTrp Bagsng Gi:,lra. Eisrlan, Tagulg G.g
Ts$ N*- S3fr**434fffrneli sdnciFo2Cf 1 @yzn::.:+;n

lre ffie" S,*mrrmary'r FteurlmG,4gar*st P;T Arifi?lei Case i!,lal: FTS$LI 8-lu C R F C- :*n i ;-:5
P{3$ tq Faffi&crx* B Ag*arxu*ran *$r F,Gfl ; ffi s"aro,e .&dEmfira$gfrnat]ue #ff+uts+
ru*ffif#
ffiF6-$ALr, {f; rave Fta?E***n*u*r*fi re^q's -T remt;l
m_**-**-- *---.-*,-^-*":eI

ffiffi#$, $#ffi
Thia pertalme t* th* H*a;1n$ Fr,$*e*di*gs *n*duc,t*d *gai*sr: F*i
Sr"+rtrnar"ei
f;Ter*"rpmt"argr) Fae"rtrir:wB d Re#itr:al P*rs*nn*l F{rl*dang nm$ &*,.:r$#nt*^mgi
Agcafil&a"sn, *sr
ref6lr*"ii t'* aE ri$Si!,i],ndeni. A*lEtniS'ire,iir,:*Xy C:.1-r,rr,rq;,*r"i ilir,E,.'s,
_;:I ilIJi.':.'3 L:Jel:? I.srFr', 1- .Sr'.s',*'e Thrmat) lrr v:i*iatisrfl{ *f f",$S,tr* t.';*'$r'i
*:*r*ndlrrn #r,r*r:iar l4*" !{};)?

F; aac,*{ 9.** FM ef *e+*rftber G, ;:#1$. at:&l}ys ffi*si*n**- l*cat**I :;l Sareirgag

l"-,4aynga*a5, *ftur- Sia. Maria* iiace* Sur, a *+r*r',r*ti*,r'r irenspir*r* rr:"';+lvri:g ti:e
i'es,pcr:de*g^ $*$ark teus C Ccr*za an's rlhr-isilar'r G Piii*#a- iltvestigatis:: iiscro-set ::e:
#erse.r:rt*f *f 5t*, &$ari,a trnii*e, S{alicn wer: abc+i to r*spr*ns t; a vehs*ulai inciCe.ri =.
mri3y" t:s*. 5,h" Sn*ria. ilo**s Sili.s:.e-- li:+ l.r,;iet a ccir"r&ioticn a* s€\i. .3siil--'*,;=r-rt
ht#d*tg a g.tu-un prt*:r,:,ut?ng ihefii l P!ec= hi.r ;r;er e;-es1 tr#*r i* the i*c-ice;i ;. acl.-'!
'I:S* trfu4 of *acrxe ciate; Ce,r,*aa, Pe.ui R*;:te,r* a;',* Pi**da
'c+e,ru i* Aiiy's it-s{*L'ar i:
ririsik iiqr-ter. ,ry arqx-yld S:** Ptt4 *:f saii ca;-e, res:ciaai-ri ei*{*red Lh* sai* fiest*bai a;l:
md*;ed iiqucr ar'*d dun*E the rEtidsi cf $teir c*t:klng sessi.e*, resp.rndeni suspe;ie: .ie:
Coroza anc{ Fin*ca were I**kir":g ai hir* r::a{icicusilr. ,s,i ahqut 8.55 F&*. G*r*ea'trr*nt *,*
i.ronr ti:at har pury*s*{gr n6 srt?sk* y/i}c* res:*ndent ches.=* e$.,,,J pointee a gui-: .t
nrrll"wfii*tr a-rtterfmg. 'Sffu$ sr'*4lt'#? ir"ffiGPAP.4#,'qt'.1' f{"{Y.#,I i{4Hqf Y.ii 14
.FAl-ilif,4{-T-Lj#.4ru HAy#".SF. D ai-e gr*u.? You're srr*.*ani- pu*r.i.nant r*s tu slt+*t y*r*ri]r
Sr:hs*qxemt$p', s*?d Gri,t wes ais* pcz,imt* t* Pirueda r;ui-ui* #derFrg. "fl,f/qlr$S i{,4 r.l"fEl-
P#-{H6?- f'-#* TrI" F.&NH,fG,qd'\f rqA'iY*u t**" ycur na.ffimt n:e t* siteet gnrrl}" W}":*n r*err:h*m
of-,;'
Sie. fr,fla,ria F*iice mtpfi,rm arrs'veii, th+y wer* m{*l*'t* *r:r:fis**ie -srorrt t}t* resp+r"ir$**t a
mrre {.$} Pi*trr* ffi*nreta t}s^ r n'l pistm$ ,{PruP ,fir,;rpeny3 r+'ith S}* ffi14i55{ $me$*ri"rnth
'fmu.nlieen {"i4;} {rw* mmrmumitrcm mnd *xtra r-s:frSfre[fi* l*sded rrr't[{"r ihirteen {'t$i :i';*
aryt;'rii":n:t!*fl"

#rzntir:ai *as* fsr T'c$r* fi*unt* *'f 'Sra:;e ?i:reafs r,n"es frlec! eq*:nnt t}'r,*r
{t}
r*sp.*onde;:-t befere tl-:* f,&ug"ri+ipal Circuit TrEcoi G**ri if-r}*Tf;] Sta" F"4erie. fln*es Si;t-
ei*eket*ei wilh C*n:i*al Sas,e H*s" 2?27-St*{ & f7tfi-Sfv}.u**tih,tre,{:fimt*t*nde*t hm$$ bs*d nf
Te* Th*usar':rj Fes;s {Fhp 1ft. *S*.*fi} fnr his pr*'*risinale$ lih**ir"

Tc ccrro$:e*rate 't{'r* a*rsrpnalnt agalnst ti.r* rp";sp*r;demt, 'ihe f*li,t'..*,ti*,9 !3r,*rs

pr*sent*r.$ - ?*Eir;* ts{,ptier CIf Sta- Frt?a$* F*iiqe Stati**; "-l*i'lx +\fffidavit ,*f f5"r.}erk S us
{lcraea aira$ S&?rist&mr"l Ftn*da" A'ffi*iavit *r Fausl **$is ffi.*v,r,*fls- "d'\''55*'rrit cf &i"aesl{. F$*tr
Arres{ ae^ld ffi**kintg Fa:rm'r; Crim:inr*{ &mf*rm:ati*ru ancS {mqu*s,t ffi*p*rf; &i**ti*;: teo ffi*rducs
ffi aii and r*sp*rad*nfl s trr'upe*5r A*k*c,,$'*dger*e*t ffi ec*ip'r-

m*3' p.oii** [r,*ina* a,lrhs i* in {emp*rar}+ stffi'tiis.

tlr*c*dure h*f'*re te'rn'aft:ati*n ef
rvas she,ere'sd ifi #$?*riSfr$"ls# wrth t$"r* gr*rrsrm.ns fl,f $\iAP{}L*&fti$ fsEe{flmraffidr-irm *ir*uisr
n"d*. ?ffi*74#$" Surrtrn*ns" t*,get?mr rr",ith the c,"ag:3+ *t frlre c*ffip{ffii};t. !"wffi$ s#rhr*d i* th*

,r':!eX,v-r i ,ui -i
's 4Er-S;tr]Ep{}tr:, t 7+5
st"fibject Pil}1 in Terepnemry $tatus dir*+firrg hirn i"o fri* lrls **s$*s'sr and t* arii*uiai* i:is
,S*i*l'lse in the eh"senramce *f aqJirrinselretiu"ne {ue p,r+;a+s.

ffii,esp*r*dent demi d th* at{e6at!**s *f the +-*rr:piai*as'rt thai h* p*inie* his S:":n
amd t-*treatnsaed 'l* *tv*et th*cn aE er*ursd E:5# Fi\{ , ;'*ec+rrbe;- *, Zfr1fi. i{e f,**i:*r
stefed af, mr*,ur-:d S: 3# Ffl*tT mf S*sercrber g. ZSi*, rexp*i-r"lerrj t*geifoer vrriih G-c-alc
ffiimmpn* mn# h$emry ffi*$cer"'$a w.cmt i* m ffiestr*fuar 9r-car*d at fo$myxgenay $ur, $ia. X,.iiaris,
$$*ene Sutr f*r a sim,ipl* *ism,er a*d dri*,ks" -HtE::l* +rdering th*ir {e,*d amd pboui i* r-*rik
t# fu+ers fneXr.*rder*d- h* nwticed -the **n:p.$slnanrs i{der* u*:ru*y and *^ppe*r*d t*, be
fuesviBy drunk at ttret ti*:e- 'arLfhem the +*sraptai*ants n*tiq.ed ti'iat ?:e {r*sp*ndent} wra.*
tm:$*iarg a*'rd ehesrv*rzg tf"l*m, Gr}e mf thern wrfulsir*ree[ s*s:=.*thir,:g t*
his ,**mpanr,sn
pr*r*tpiing tfue r*sg:or:dent tc diue# hrs *tkemtirqm. '+,&#i"ll$* ta{king t* his frie**s. ih*'ee q3.i
person$ kepit *n sit*utir:g t$'nreet*nia:g w*Ms c*upl*d rr.+rth t}:*lr *lr#sy tr**[r* t<rwerde
r*spcmdemt. S.*fliem{* ed*rl**d r**p*nd*nt tm E* h*me ts aru**M ariSr tr*uh{.* is?'#Ri*h fu*
*mmptried csiii$* tlt* ntFser *st* f*tr{crsu*d ruam- &s they u,eere lla,*t appr**chlng r*w-.*,rds itirn"
rr*sp#ild*ftt stepped backwards rsrit*i a qr.daffixims ti:at he rs m pcii*emare- #espi'q* sa[$
,r+arr*6m9, t"*'a* tw* pae-s$ns $?sver h'*ed** amd istst+mrj tn*p e*m'rinu+d r*,r*{king tm*,:arctrs
Lalm- 'S*r"asErag ffiat &:is $ife rqras gg'! dartgier'. fre pu}$eel ftis service frraarum dire.#e.d t* tX,te
gn'r*a;nd tr
war:"x them and to$d them .tu st*p" {,i r.*,ras at t{t*t porrit wrtr"rerr res,umndsng
p,elicenmmr arrir-r** amcl a*ked t3l* respmmd*mt ts, go w,rtk &erft Em whi,*fu ir'* s*x,rpiiem m!'Td
"rolumfany h*ar*eC t?t* pratrm? ear-

FExrdrmge

ii appeared *n *-ie reaprd urhai res.pssnd*ril'u.,,as t**.e** at Aiiy's R*st*,bar at Sta

&fta;;e, Il.***s Sur iasi *.ecer*h*r g. 2*i5 rnrh*- ihe !n*i,=eni i-:appel"rei. in iacl. he
Iike,rrjse adnelttd tt:ai h*. xgethelraiti; **ir*mte. uue*r i* * ftest*kr at ar*u*d &:5* FP+*
fu f:grur* s#r&e 'f+c*t' asrd dri*ks" l-hre *,fexs* ,:f G;e'** T}:rasts li*pp**et r,*fi*n
resp*ndel:t eii*g,*ri ii:ai hre 1trfrs Frrs'ri,;.i+i by il-,e :cn:'Siaixe*is. ft,*:p nderi. .ir+i=,.:lie,
has t* bdng *ut hris *learm j*si t* scaj-E the tr"c- ii ',vas at ii:is situatiu;r; tl:ai ies,.:c,,*iirg
peiice *f*ccrs ravi inh resp*nde*t 'l!:at he was sfiii hclding nis iss*d flirearn: *n i:is
hands anci vs*s in &*t co*fiscated by SPG€ Sasargo- l*e w*s th*n sufujmted t* l*ee$ice5
Exax;inefi*"s'! v*hiieh reireaE*d thei he vras prciiive f*r aiar?-mlic intcxicat!*n- Th*s* fu*ts
'rJers r:rT dispu4ed fuy {fre respcmdent.

ini* c*asiderate#Ir alt tfu* pleces *f e+'ides'c*e fur th*is ffiseo 'thu resp*r:d*rat
Taklmg
**nm*t h* xpared iir*nt anXr edm:ii=istrea$u's $iabinity^ Tta*'r* san ,** rtcs dmuht tita't
nesp<:ra$emt asted enmsp*rasiblir and n*t hefrtrccn# s,f a geitt{erma:t emd a. p*{i** q.ffirer- TPre
*iaim,r e$ thry resp*nderrt Is a sme{tear t:'f defemse tr* ,e**ape fr'*rt: Bia*iEitr*s, Ti:e dis*deuly
mste mf the nesp*nde;"rt shor*ld n*t be t*fisraied mr **untem&mc*d" i:e h*img e mesmh*r *f
tflte. Fi:iiip6zifte $q#atiumatr trn{iae whs is cuetXe h*und t* uplt*fiS the n*w at aiE '6r::es ar-*d t*
#rmteet the *itiae+ts.

It:was likmplise r*vea{*d ttr-rat the rmpcu:dent p*trce *'ffi*er wss n*i cm dw.txi at,ftet
t;rae, fhe i* asslgr:*d *t RFS&. e}ffiffiP{}} b#t sti;g E:e hes r-s{."i{h frsrm itis seru",ic* Sr**,rm"
and has 3oln*d im a dri*kimq spiee at A-4i3,'s He*trnar- fit rclnisi h,e e'mpFtasie*cf ti:ai tlt*
gufi. des.*i1b*d a tr!*trc ffierrets ffia*- *m:n:'l piat*{ iPruP tr*:F*rty} q,criih Sf'"} r"nt4'{S5x
lca-*ed *v*Fr triwe ana{fruniti*ffis #r}{i *:Etra fi}&S*xine $*ad*d $ruth iS ?:ve avumut-ti*mns
be3**g"r {* tf'l* Gd}1r*flfteffi*ffit e&d t}.a* sarrre,'.a,a.* *:ltiy iss{;*{$ t* n:im as.$-t[s *#rviu* i!r,smm",t,
ln flh* fi&eirs* *€ his duty es *,ne pf ihe cfttr*i*fi*3ers *f tii* FI":[[!ppime ffiatimra*! {}*il**-
Esxemtxm{fi3r, flffip*ftdftru't X-ras an *btigal}*e"r t* sw"rel1' xe*F titi* Sr*arrm mnd just ms* tl"us
ffirlxffi'flor the puffi#see f*r ar*frE*'n ?'* v'rms *altriieted t* futr*,

The pr*v*catrmm harrug alies*d$3r hy the resp<imder*t ls har$ {m betri*v"e, S mcq

existimg at mX$- [ffi*re whlsp**r'lg t+ ea+fu stfu*r snd ]**kin# at respsmdectt pn*t'oeatiusiv ts
;r*t the pn*vo.ca-tl*fiT as c*srtempla'l*d b-1, trsvs ia jr;a"*ffi hi*n t* fonis"lE *rS hEs **rtriee.firsmrm
ar ed pft[fit t+ t'ne .ea,r.rzp iai*ar:-is"

,Icig*3.{*t
pTsSH B-i.t{:nFc+rj1 7-25
f
5t es in*iite# {,* glv* a::*re *reci*fifi.* {m rhe w*rsi<.rr'* of .r;ns *ompiaiatnnts an* tne
p*[ie* s3ffifr#rg as the .Ea$]'l# ffir,* *fio#Si]: tqr s$st*isr the q'*ar",tum ct'pr,rrf rrquir-e.: ii
mdrnirnistra&v# proa,e*ding*'q-,rd"ri*ir il* suhs,tergtral *.,ridencc"

, T*:*r-e are sushef*r$ies evl€f*r-t*e tc it*$d rasp*vtci**t adr*inis'ira$v*Iy lis**s *f tlie

a,*:ts *mmpialcne*i f. The s?a*dard *,f scrhs.tantia{ *ulderlee ix justifred rd*e* there is
reasr:maha$* gr+*umd tz*l fu*iis'.r* tfuat resp*r.",c9**t ;e r*sp**xible fur ti:e rxi***n*u#
**rmpi*ined *l' *rren if *u;r:h is rt*t sv#;Bt{h*{:i*ilir"lp, *r *\iaffi prcp*neie.-ant- iliq;:r; ,,:t
#am#**an*. Jr" .s,"FjI- il!c,. ft*}"?* trSfJS. &ugiusi 8;, 3i=#3].
Fpr e.,rid*rr** ttl hel!e',re. rt snelg'i ru*l *mi3i Sf*#****J fr*re"r thre e'"rtm*th mf q *r-*Sl*f*
'*,ritm*ss" fu.*t rn*st b* *nadihle ir: ffis*$f es th* ffir;'Ifi:{}n *hserv*ti*m rf mankin,s cen
*ppr.*v* as pimbah4e u*derthe cir*u*mstar**e*. itrecrri* rrs- {-lrrisga" $ES S*RS^.$?5,x-

The ahcv* traffissri#ssl#fi '*f re*p*r:d,e*'i ;s a fll**i- vi*$at?*n *f imvrs nrit!*h siai*s
tfua{ b*ing drulnk a"*d $is*rderfur whrie CIft *r *f dr:t1r ccr:siiiutcs i-*ss ,snave h,{is*mm,*u*i-

&frsp*s8t!$w, e Pmrtu*a,t

B^&'e{ffiffiHtr#ffiffi, prerv:iaes esmsle{.ere*" p*'$ in T*r:":pmrmrtr' Status Feu$Ecl$ ffi,

,&E*mm'amr:arl
"*r
Is h*r*hy tsnce?*mefrffie{ fr,mrw tfrt pm$frc* sq*rrr*ce"

s* ffiffiffi$ffiffim"

t1^^-,
#ilT e s ?*tT
* iit ;u 6i*;-
Lt ll; ai Ca."n* S*p*r":gffii,ii,a. Bi*Liian, Tag*,g Ciii.t

I Uii\ri; i\^;_^^r--.- *
uilU:'L-l1-t; :Pi
=.1i-'^^
F"egi*r: ai Slr*si"*r, f'{*ffi P*

,i:T,.!Sl'lB.-iijrl FC;ti.i ?*i2I :.q;i^:r-l i .,*',t