Choices | Diavolo X Fem!

Reader X Lucifer
Posted originally on the Archive of Our Own at http://archiveofourown.org/works/38895087.

Rating: Explicit
Archive Warning: Choose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Category: F/M, Multi
Fandom: Shall We Date?: Obey Me!
Relationship: Diavolo (Shall We Date?: Obey Me!)/Reader, Lucifer (Shall We Date?:
Obey Me!)/Reader, Diavolo/Lucifer (Shall We Date?: Obey Me!)
Character: Diavolo (Shall We Date?: Obey Me!), Lucifer (Shall We Date?: Obey
Me!), Reader, Barbatos (Shall We Date?: Obey Me!)
Additional Tags: Polyamory, Polyamorous Character, Lucifer Feels, Soft Diavolo (Shall
We Date?: Obey Me!), Love Confessions, Confessions, Friends to
Lovers, POV Lucifer, Threesome - F/M/M, Threesome, Cunnilingus,
Rough Oral Sex, Oral Sex, Spanking, Nipple Play, Nipple Licking,
Vaginal Fingering, Finger Sucking, Party, Demonus, tipsy, Interrupted
Confession, Love Triangle, love corner, Choice, Throuple, butterfly
kisses, needy, Undressing, neck kisses, Shy Sub, Fellatio, light face
fucking, male moaning, Praise, Praise Kink, Cum Eating, Swallowing,
Creampie, Spooning
Language: English
Stats: Published: 2022-05-09 Completed: 2022-05-26 Chapters: 2/2 Words:
2263

Choices | Diavolo X Fem! Reader X Lucifer

Summary

When both Lucifer and Diavolo confess to you, you have an important decision to make.
 Choices Part 1

Lucifer's pov:

The ballroom was filled with hundreds of demons dancing to the music. Diavolo had hired a live
band to play and invited the exchange students.
Most of them were present already except for (Y/N). Asmo had told me he was getting ready with
her and knowing my little brother, he would be arriving 'fashionably' late.

A sigh passed my lips. "What's on your mind?" Diavolo asks me as he joins me in observing the
crowd.
"Asmodeus and (Y/N) still aren't here." I respond as I take the glass of Demonus Diavolo held out
for me.
"They'll be here any moment now." Not even five minutes later the doors opened and Asmo and
(Y/N) finally joined us.

My breath hitched as I took in (Y/N)'s outfit. She looked even more beautiful than usual.
"Goodness..." Diavolo took a sip from his Demonus, his eyes still on (Y/N). "She's amazing isn't
she?" He asks, nudging me. A weird feeling swelled in my chest as his words sunk in. I tried to
ignore it. "You sound a little smitten, Diavolo."

"I think I should ask her out tonight." I coughed loudly, my eyes widening. "What?" I ask, slowly
turning towards him. "Yeah, I've been thinking about it for a while... I was going to wait until the
exchange program was over but I can't wait any longer."

A sense of dread filled me and I couldn't understand why. "D-Diavolo... should you really do
something like that?" He just shrugged, finishing his glass of Demonus before walking towards
(Y/N).
I started panicking, still unsure why I was feeling like this. All I knew is that I had to stop Diavolo.

I pushed my glass of Demonus in Barbatos' hands as I quickly walked towards the demon lord.

Diavolo's pov:

I left Lucifer and entered the crowd, making my way over to (Y/N).
She smiled when she noticed me approaching her. "Hello, (Y/N)! Are you enjoying the party?"
She nodded happily. "Yeah, sorry we were late. Asmo wouldn't let me leave until he did my make-
up."

"Well, you were worth the wait." I said, grinning at her. A pink hue covers her cheeks as she takes
a sip from her drink.
"I really need to tell you something though." I took a deep breath, trying to gather some more
courage to ask her out.
"Well-" I was suddenly cut off when Lucifer appeared next to me.

"Hello, (Y/N). I'm afraid I need Diavolo for a minute." He said as he grabbed my arm and pulled
me away.
I was too surprised to protest, not expecting this kind of behavior from Lucifer. He pulled me into a
separate room, closing the door behind him. "Lucifer? What's going on?"

He massaged his temples, not looking at me. "I just... I can't let you do that Diavolo." I frowned,
confused. "Why not? Do you think she'll reject me or something?" He sighs loudly, clearly on
edge. "No, that's... not it."
"Then, why did you stop me?"

He stayed silent, shaking his head. I started growing impatient and walked towards the door to
leave.
"I like her too!!" He suddenly shouts, making me stop in my tracks. I slowly turned back to him.
He looked like he only just realized how he felt. I now understood why he had been acting so odd.

"Uhm... ok. Shit." I sigh, thinking about what to do. Lucifer was my best friend and the only person
I trusted. I didn't want to ruin the relationship we had but (Y/N) was so important to me too.
I pulled up a chair and sat down. "Alright... do you want to tell her?" Lucifer seemed confused but
nodded. "I do."

"If we both tell her, she can choose who she wants to be with." Lucifer finally decides to join me
and pulls up a chair too. "We shouldn't do it in the ballroom." I nod in agreement. "We could take
her to the garden." I felt more nervous than before, sighing as I stood up.
I held out my hand to Lucifer and he took it. I pulled him into a hug, obviously surprising him.
"Whatever happens, we'll stay friends, ok?"
"Of course, Diavolo. Don't be obscene."

I chuckled at his comment, letting him go. "Let's go do this."

Your pov:

You were sitting on the windowsill with Levi. He didn't like crowds so you decided to stick by him
to keep him calm.
You were still wondering what Diavolo wanted to tell you earlier. It seemed quite serious.
You had your eyes on the door Lucifer had dragged Diavolo to, waiting for them to re-emerge.

It felt like ages before the door finally opened. "Levi, I'll be back in a bit." You didn't wait for his
response and immediately made your way over to Diavolo and Lucifer.
"Is everything alright?" You asked the two demons once you'd reached them. They both seemed on
edge, nervously looking at each other.

"Yeah but we need to talk to you. Let's go somewhere calmer." Lucifer says, taking the lead as he
walks towards the garden. You and Diavolo follow behind.
The music muffled as the door closed behind you. You shivered as the cold night air hit your face.
"Is something going on?" You were starting to get concerned. "Well, Lucifer and I were talking
earlier and we came to the conclusion... that we both like you."

You stared at them in disbelief. "What do you mean... like me?" You couldn't comprehend how
two of the most powerful demons were into you.
"We wanted to tell you together so you can choose... if you want to be with one of us, that is."
Lucifer said. You slowly let the information sink in. You had a major crush on both of them and
didn't feel like you could choose.

Why should you choose?

"How about... a throuple?" You carefully suggested, a little scared of how they would react.
They both seemed taken aback, obviously not expecting this. They slowly turn to look at each other
and Diavolo cracks a smile. "Seems like a good idea to me..." You both expectantly looked at
Lucifer.

"Alright, let's try that." He finally said with a smirk.

Your relationship with Diavolo and Lucifer is going well, especially in the bedroom.

Lucifer's arm was wrapped around your waist as you both rested on the couch. You were reading a
book while Lucifer read through some documents.
Diavolo suddenly walked in, taking his coat off after closing the door. "Hey, honey!" He greeted
you, leaning down to kiss you. You smile as he pulled away and plopped down next to you.

Most evenings were like this. Just the three of you together on the couch. You definitely hadn't
regretted starting a relationship with both of them.
Diavolo cuddled closer to you, quickly snatching the papers out of Lucifer's hand. "Hey!" You and
Diavolo giggled as he tossed the bundle on the coffee table.

"Just relax, Lucifer. It's 10 pm." The dark-haired demon sighed but sank deeper into the couch.
"You're lucky I love you both." You turn to face him, pecking his lips with a cheeky smile. His
hand found it's way to the back of your head, not letting you pull away from the kiss.

"Don't forget about me~!" Diavolo pleaded as he crawled closer to you. You giggle and pull away
from Lucifer, leaning in to kiss Diavolo.
Lucifer rubbed your thigh while your lips danced with Diavolo's.

"You wanna move this to the bed?" Lucifer whispered, his lips brushing over your neck. You nod
slowly, carefully pulling away from the demon lord.
You let them take you to the bed, sitting on the edge as you watched the boys starting to undress.

You blushed, taking off your shirt to keep up with them. Once Lucifer had kicked off his shoes he
joined you on the bed, pushing you so you were laying down.
His shirt was unbuttoned, his bare chest pressing against yours.
Diavolo's hands ran up your legs, undoing your pants and tugging them down while Lucifer kissed
you.

He pressed a finger against your clothed heat, making you moan against Lucifer's lips. The avatar
of pride pulled away with a smile, unbuckling his belt.
Diavolo did the same, letting his pants drop to the floor before pulling you closer. His lips pressed
against your neck, nipping at the sensitive skin.
Meanwhile, Lucifer pulled your panties down as he pressed kisses against your inner thighs.

You whimper as the two demons covered your body with kisses. Lucifer's lips finally pressed
against your heat, a yelp escaping you.
Diavolo's hands slipped under your body when you arched your back in pleasure. He unclasped
your bra, pulling it off and throwing it off the bed.

He wrapped his lips around your left nipple, pinching the other. Your moans grew increasingly
louder when Lucifer slowly inserted a finger into your pussy.
You tangled your fingers in Diavolo's hair as he gently bit down on your nipple. Lucifer suddenly
pulled his fingers out of you, sitting up with a smile.
"You want a taste too, Diavolo?" He stuck his finger out to the demon lord. Your juices coated his
finger and Diavolo eagerly sucked it clean. You blushed at the sight.
After Diavolo finished cleaning Lucifer's finger he looked over at you with a smirk. "Tasty~!" You
immediately cover your face with your hands, making both of them chuckle.

You peeked through your fingers as you felt them shuffle around. Lucifer had taken his boxers off,
leaving him completely bare.
He crawled up to you until his member was in front of your face.
He carefully guided one of your hands to his cock and you obediently wrapped your fingers around
it.

"How about you put it in your mouth?" You smiled at him, kissing the tip of his member.
Diavolo also finished taking off his clothes and sat down between your legs. His thumb pressed
against your clit and you moaned as you took Lucifer's tip into your mouth.

Diavolo used the tip of his cock to rub between your slit. You moaned out, the vibrations of your
voice adding to Lucifer's pleasure.
The dark-haired demon moaned, involuntarily thrusting into your mouth. Diavolo slowly pushed
into you, a deep groan escaping him as your walls tightened around him.

"You're amazing, (Y/N)!" The prince moaned out as he bottomed out. You wrapped your arms
around Lucifer's thighs and sped up as you sucked him off.
He groaned loudly, his hips bucking forward.
His nails dug into the sheets as he came close to climax. "Swallow it-!" He choked out right before
cumming in your mouth. You whimper as his seed filled your mouth, smiling when he pulled out
of you.

You swallow and show your empty mouth to Lucifer who pats your hair approvingly. "Good girl,
(Y/N)." Diavolo says, picking up his pace as he thrusted into you.
Lucifer sat down next to you, intertwining your fingers as he stroked his member. He intently
watched as Diavolo's cock repeatedly disappeared into your pussy.

Diavolo reached out to Lucifer, grabbing his chin to pull him in for a kiss. Your walls tightened
again as you enjoyed the sight.
Diavolo grunted into the kiss, his cock twitching inside of you as he came.
He sighed delightedly as he pulled away from the kiss and carefully pulled out of your body.

The demon lord moved to lean against the headboard and you quickly moved towards him.
You laid down on your belly, taking his cock into your hand as you sucked one of his balls into
your mouth.

Lucifer sat behind you, grabbing your hips and pulling you to sit on your knees. He positioned his
cock by your opening, teasingly pushing his tip in and out of you. You whimper against Diavolo's
member, the teasing only turning you on more.
The demon prince bunched your hair together, keeping it out of your face as you took him into
your mouth.

Lucifer's hand suddenly collided with your ass, the slap echoing through the room. Diavolo smiles
down at you as you moan against his member.
The avatar of pride finally pushes his cock into your heat with a soft groan as he bottoms out. You
moan out as he starts moving, his hands tightly holding onto your hips. Diavolo was getting closer
to his release, losing himself in the pleasure. He guided your head up and down his cock at a fast
pace, groaning as you twirled your tongue around his member.
"Oh, fuck! I'm close!" He exclaimed, his cock twitching as he came. You swallow his load after
pulling away, lifting your chest from the bed. Diavolo repositioned himself so he was now laying
under you, his head by your heat.
he watched as Lucifer pounded into you, eventually connecting his lips with your clit. A loud moan
instantly escaped you as your walls convulsed around Lucifer's dick.

You came only a few seconds later, Diavolo still licking circles on your clit as you screamed out in
pleasure. Your climax easily brought on Lucifer's and with a loud groan, he came deep inside of
your body. You collapsed after he pulled out.
"You did so well, (Y/N)." Diavolo gently spoke as he stroked your hair. Lucifer pulled the blankets
over the three of you and spooned you, pressing kisses against your shoulders.

"Now, get some rest. you deserve it." The prideful demon says. "We love you." Is the last thing
you hear before you drift off to sleep.

Please drop by the archive and comment to let the author know if you enjoyed their work!