Ijiem 288
Ijiem 288
Global competition and public awareness drive organizations to improve their management                   Article history:
processes, including those related to logistics and warehousing. With the aim of improving
                                                                                                          Received March 16, 2021	
the efficiency and safety of the food warehousing processes, an analysis of the warehouse
layouts and storage areas layouts was carried out. Through the reorganization of the space                Revised July 14, 2021
and the review of storage policy, a practical proposal was made. To obtain more efficiency,               Accepted July 17, 2021
an improved equation for the calculation of the distances travelled within the warehouse was              Published online September 10, 2021
defined. The implementation of the proposed improvements provides efficiency to ware-
housing, taking the Navy food central warehouse as a real case study.                                     Keywords:
                                                                                                          Fixed location;
                                                                                                          Layout;
                                                                                                          Logistics;
                                                                                                          Warehousing;
                                                                                                          Warehouse flows;
                                                                                                          *Corresponding author:
                                                                                                          Armindo Frias
                                                                                                          [email protected]
items or cross-contaminations on its handling [1].                   Within the warehouse operation upstream, there
New technologies can help to prevent some risks, but             are several activities that may affect the entire cycle of
not all warehouses have the business size or financial           operation, as for example the location of warehouse
capacity to implement them, like power Warehouse                 and the definition of their macro layouts [6], [7]. The
Management Systems or smart packaging [2].                       layout establishes the location of the different areas
    The Armed Forces, for the fulfilment of their                of interest for the operation within the warehouses,
strictly military missions or to support civilian popu-          such as the reception, consolidation or unbundle of
lations emergency needs, should have a logistic struc-           cargo, shipping, support and administrative areas, as
ture that ensures the continuity of their operational            well as the material storing areas. There are a number
capability. Food is a critical factor for maintaining            of relevant factors that should be considered in the
the personnel physical and mental condition, and                 development of a layout: the location of the different
is therefore essential to ensure the continuity of its           areas of basic warehousing operations, the location of
supply. The Portuguese Navy is under a process of                the materials within the warehouse and the definition
updating its central food warehouse facilities, with the         of the different applicable storage techniques [8]. Re-
construction of new cold rooms, which poses an op-               gardless of the typology of the material to be stored,
portunity for improvement [3].                                   the layout should maximize the use of space, equip-
    This work aims to recognize opportunities for im-            ment and human resources, as well as ensuring acces-
provement on the handling of food items within the               sibility and protection for all materials [9]. To obtain
Navy food central warehouse facilities and, propose              an efficient layout, it will be necessary to consider the
the best layout solutions for the spaces under con-              different factors individually, and the analysis of the
struction. To achieve this, the movement of materials            dynamics arising from their interaction.
within the facilities was analyzed as well as its relation-          The cost of handling an item depends on the
ship with the storage place of the different clusters of         distance travelled and volumes occupied within the
food items. Based on knowledge, some options of                  warehouse. The layout, which maximizes each of
layout were discussed with the technicians, to under-            the handling variables (travelling distance and stor-
stand its practical applicability.                               age area), can be different. therefore, to evaluate the
    Being a real case study, it is expected that the             effects of different storage strategies and handling
change on the warehouse layout and storage method                techniques, it is necessary to specify the layout. Once
will make it possible to reduce the movements of ma-             the layout is defined, the cost associated to volumes
terials, and consequently, minimize the use of work-             becomes fixed, so the operating costs become a func-
ers and cargo handling equipment. The achieved                   tion of the average quantity of moved items, travelled
findings can be generalized to other similar food dis-           distances and frequency of the materiel movements.
tribution centers                                                The calculation of value based on these three factors
    This document comprises seven sections. Besides              can then be used to optimize the total warehouse op-
this introduction, section two presents the relevant             eration expenses [10].
theoretical background concerning the warehouse                      Three basic functions can be considered in ware-
activities; section three identifies the chosen method-          housing: inbound movement, associated with the re-
ology; section four presents the facilities under study;         ception and storage of material; storage of material
section five presents the proposed improvement                   until its need by an internal or external customer; and
solution; section six, the improvement quantification            outbound movement, related to the fulfilment of or-
process and the discussion of the achieved results,              ders [9].
which is followed by a conclusion.                                   Considering outbound movement, order picking
                                                                 is an extremely expensive activity and directly con-
                                                                 tributes to the quality of service provided to clients,
2. Background                                                    hence, it is often considered the main warehousing
                                                                 activity. Automated order picking systems require
     Nowadays, managers recognize the essential role
                                                                 high capital investment, but a manual system is a la-
played by logistics for the success of organizations [4].
                                                                 bor-intensive operation and may represent the main
Warehousing alone doesn’t produce much value and
                                                                 cost within the total warehouse operational costs.
it is indeed a source of costs for organizations. How-
                                                                 Order picking costs arise mostly from time travelling
ever, if seen as part of the logistical cycle, it produces
                                                                 and suboptimal layout designs [11].
an effective edge, making materials flow more agile
                                                                     Order picking refers to the transport of the cor-
and reducing uncertainty, while creating competitive
                                                                 rect materials, in the right quantity, from its storage
advantage [5].
                      International Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management Vol 12 No 3 (2021)
208                                                                                                           Frias et al.
area, in order to satisfy the order from a client, be it        is used. However, the problem needs to be present-
internal or external to the organization. For the time          ed as NP-hard TSP only when the warehouse lay-
needed to pick an order, three main components                  out is not a standard one- or two-block rectangular.
can be considered: (1) Routing – which refers to the            For simpler operations, where most movements in-
movement of an agent, a worker or machine, who                  side only have one point of origin and destination, a
arranges the orders, from one place to another, to              simpler model may be used [9]. For the calculation
retrieve the items; (2) Picking of items – which con-           of these distances, Carvalho et al. [8] proposes the
sists of a series of actions that goes from the worker          use of Equation 1, where the variable T refers to the
positioning near the location of the stored item to the         number of movements and D to the distance; the in-
actual collection of the intended items; (3) Remaining          dex I refers to the place of origin, j to the place of
activities – which includes the collection and return           destination, and n to the different number of existing
of support equipment to be used in the collection               areas.
and movement of the material or the acquisition of
information [12]. Order picking activity is critical be-
cause of the costs and loss of productivity, in case of
failure, and for keeping the level and quality of cus-
tomer service [5]. This relevance is self-evident in the
literature review led by Staudt et al. [13], regarding              Warehousing improvement is greatly influenced
the performance measurement within warehousing,                 by reducing time spend on movements, and they are
which suggests that inbound activities have received            easier to influence because they account to about
less attention than outbound activities. The inbound            50% of worker’s time in the order picking operations.
performance was measured in terms of time and pro-              The time needed for the pickup of items, which ac-
ductivity, while the outbound was evaluated in terms            counts to about 20%, and remaining activities, are in-
of time, quality and productivity. No study was iden-           fluenced by factors such as shelf type or staff training
tified to assess the cost of both activities as a way to        [5], [12].
evaluate warehousing performance.                                   According to Emmett [17] and Çelk & Süral [18],
     To improve the efficiency of order picking, dif-           one of the most relevant factors in order picking op-
ferent approaches can be taken, and these can be                erations is the location of the items. The closer to the
clustered into three groups of operating policies: (1)          pick-up/drop-off point the items are stored, the short-
Batching - put several orders or parts of orders to-            er the handling time. Similarly, Stock & Lambert [19]
gether to create one or more movements of picking.              suggest that the most popular materials, which have a
When several different orders are combined, the                 higher turnover or demand rates, should be located
products can be gathered without losing the integrity           in areas closer to the receiving and shipping areas,
of the orders, either during the picking (sort-while-           hence minimizing movements within the warehouse.
pick) or after the picking is complete (pick-and-sort).             The movement of materials involve the move-
When several workers work on a single order, each               ment of people and often the use of cargo handling
worker is allocated to a specific storage area; (2) Stor-       equipment, making it critical for the inclusion of safe-
age assignment - focuses on establishing rules for as-          ty and security issues. In order to minimize the occur-
signing products to storage locations. Existing rules           rence of incidents with consequences for workers and
range from random, where new sites are randomly                 moving loads, in compliance with national and inter-
assigned to products, to full-turnover storage, where           national legislation, safety plans must be developed.
products with the highest frequency of movement are             These plans, in addition to the general rules, should
assigned to easily accessible positions. There are also         take specific rules into consideration regarding the
intermediate forms, such as ABC-storage; (3) Rout-              materials movement, facilities features or operators’
ing - the methods used range from simple heuristics             procedures. As far as their scope is concerned, these
to optimization schemes using dynamic program-                  should include the warehousing of material, due han-
ming [12].                                                      dling and the risk of fire [20].
     Routing optimization is a relevant factor for min-
imizing warehousing costs [14]. The optimization of
order-pikers routing can reduce the traveling distance          3. Methodology
in a very effective way [15], [16]. Often, to minimize
                                                                   In order to achieve the objective of identifying
the time/distance of material movement, the Travel-
                                                                improvements in the warehousing under study, the
ing Salesman Problem (TSP) or an equivalent model
                                                                layout of the different facilities, existing or under con-
                      International Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management Vol 12 No 3 (2021)
Frias et al.                                                                                                             209
struction, and the layouts of the storage areas were                to fulfil inbound and outbound activities; (8) verifi-
analyzed. By redesigning the layout, specifically the               cation of proposed amendments in terms of security
work areas and storage places, one is changing the                  and food cross contamination; (9) quantification of
distances to be covered for the inbound and out-                    the impact of changes in terms of cargo handling and
bound activities.                                                   financial impacts; (10) validation with experts con-
     Therefore, to carry out this study, the following              cerning the validity of the suggested proposals. The
steps were taken: (1) analysis of the existing layouts              followed steps can be summarized into the ten-stage
and the flows associated with inbound and outbound                  methodology that is shown in Table 1.
movements, in terms of efficiency and security; (2)
go back literature and technical expertise; (3) iden-
tification of potential improvement measures; (4)                   4. Facilities
cluster food items, simplifying the task of location
                                                                         The Portuguese Navy central food warehouse fa-
assignment and, while maintaining storage flexibility;
                                                                    cilities have a dry grocery store, eight cold rooms and
(5) computing of inbound and outbound distances
                                                                    several technical supporting areas, as per Figure 1.
for each class of food items and movement rate; (6)
                                                                         The current facilities present some vulnerabilities,
performing an ABC analysis in terms of movement
                                                                    such as the fact that unloading and shipping share the
rate; (7) proposing class-based storage where the item
                                                                    same docks, although with a time lag. The reception
classes with the highest handling rate are located de-
                                                                    and picking takes place in the same area, which is
pending on the minimization of the distance needed
                                                                    also a pedestrian crossing area. The reinforcement of
safety signage is also ensured.                                 terion and dependent on the subjective assessment
    The dry grocery store has three sets of pallet racks        of each worker. The movement of loads between the
with two levels in height. It includes an administrative        inbound and outbound docks as well as the location
office and a set of metal silos for storing liquids in          of the articles in the warehouse is mostly done on
bulk, as shown in Figure 2. Its main vulnerabilities            pallets, using hand or electric pallet trucks, forklifts
are: (1) the existence of unused spaces, the metallic           or stackers.
silos were used in the past for the storage of liquid               There are eight cold rooms, half of which are re-
oils in bulk, but with no use for a few years; (2) the          frigeration ones and the remaining are freezing ones.
distribution of the items on the racks do not take into         Each room has an associated food typology, as shown
account their handling rate; (3) part of the racks have         in Figure 3. The main vulnerabilities are the degra-
difficult access due to the location of the shipment            dation of the facilities and energy inefficiency of the
area; (4) the false ceiling has asbestos in its constitu-       equipment; the area for the reception and picking
tion; (5) the racks have no anti collision protection.          shares the same space as is the case with the cargo
    The storage method, in terms of allocation of               handling area, without temperature control; the racks
spaces, is made on the basis of an opportunistic cri-           have no anti-collision protection.
    The current dry grocery store and the facilities            to the point of entry or exit, and the rearrangement
under construction that will provide new cold rooms             of the working spaces, will allow the reduction of total
and the technical and administrative warehousing                distances of inbound and outbound movements.
support will be the new Food Distribution Centre                    Taking one year of historical data related to the
(FDC). The layout of the ground floor of the new                activity of the Navy central food warehousing, a need
facilities is shown in Figure 4.                                is felt for clustering the food items in classes, by affin-
    A main innovation was the creation of separate              ity and storage needs. With this procedure, it is pos-
inbound and outbound docks and technical spaces,                sible to reduce by one-third the data to be processed,
one for cold products and one for products at nor-              giving flexibility to the activities of assigning classes to
mal temperature. For cold items, the new facilities             fixed storage locations.
will have separate reception and a picking spaces with              In order to rank the classes of items, an ABC anal-
temperature control. New cold room machinery will               ysis was carried out, according to their handling rate
be more energy efficient and greater storage capacity           and warehouse of storage. To carry out such analysis,
for fresh and frozen food will be available. As a disad-        the following assumptions were made: (1) it was con-
vantage, the smaller space for cold rooms may lead to           sidered that the items located in different warehous-
the need to create different temperature zones inside           es are independent, which led to separate analyses
the rooms. Because this construction project adapts             for each warehouse; (2) to estimate the number of
existing facilities, the layout is not the most suitable        movements between pick-up and drop-off points, the
for the activity in question.                                   average weight per pallet for each class of items was
                                                                taken into account; (3) the food items that are deliv-
                                                                ered by suppliers directly to the final clients were not
5. Proposed actions                                             considered, since they do not have physical existence
                                                                at this warehouse; (4) for cold food items, the future
    The storage location within the warehouse is a
                                                                FDC facilities were considered.
relevant factor in the definition of the layout and for
the improvement of the warehousing, specifically
through the reduction of the inbound and outbound               5.1 Layout proposals
movements [18]. Therefore, it is proposed to adopt a
                                                                    Taking into account the results of the ABC anal-
storage method based on opportunistic criterion, that
                                                                ysis, the verification of potential cross contamination
place the items with the highest handling rate closer
                                                                among different food items, and the objective of min-
imizing the distance travelled by workers and cargo                     proposed distribution. In each rack, the same class of
handling equipment in the warehouse, the following                      food items take up the floor and first stage positions.
changing proposals to layouts were made.                                Items with the highest rotation or weight go to the
    Dry grocery store - this space will remain active with              ground position.
the building of the FDC. A proposal was made to                             FDC cold rooms - being a new space, for which
move the area reserved for shipping next to the fu-                     there is no storage plan, it is not possible to perform a
ture access door, at the actual place of the first silos,               comparative analysis with the current situation. In the
hence freeing up access to all racks. This decision                     assignment of racks, it is considered that the quanti-
requires the dismantling of all metal silos. To opti-                   ties of food items managed by the entity remain sta-
mize materials movement, the change of its storage                      ble. As an example, Figure 6. shows the proposed
localization on the racks is also required. As an ex-                   layout for the future Cold room for charcuterie and
ample, Figure 5a) shows the current arrangement                         milk products. The space foresees ten racks for stan-
of food classes within the double racks central area,                   dardized pallets, at two levels in height.
with two positions in height. Figure 5b) displays the
                                                                                                                               Corridor
              Coffee, Powder milk         Vinegar/vegetables             Sauces                    Canned fruit
                                                                                           Legend:
                                                                                           CLf1: Fat derivatives,
                                                                                           Mayonnaise & Marmalade
                                                                                           CLf2: Fresh derivatives
                                                                                           CLf3: Chorizo and Sausages
                                                                                           CLf4: Ham
                                                                                           CLf5: Gammon
                                                                                           CLf6: Bacon and Flour sausages
Figure 6. Proposed layout for a cold room. Source: adapted from Delaunay [3]
5.2 Safety solution                                                time spend and costs associated with. Parameters m,
                                                                   n and p represent the upper index limit of the index
    With the aim of ensuring workers' safety, food                 i, j and k, in the same order. Variable 𝐷  ∈  ℚ+, and
hygiene and safety practices, several proposals were               variable 𝑇 and index 𝑖, 𝑗, 𝑘, ∈ ℕ.
made: (1) training of workers in the areas of food hy-                  In this case, index i varies from n = 1 to 3, where
giene, safety practices and safety at work; (2) placing            the value 1 refers to the current unloading and ship-
shock protection structures at the base of the rack                ping dock, 2 to the normal temperature FDC unload-
supports; (3) implementing a preventive maintenance                ing and shipping docks and 3 to the cold temperature
plan for cargo handling equipment; (4) marking the                 FDC unloading and shipping docks. The index j var-
warehouse floor, defining pedestrian zones and di-                 ies from 1 to n = 56, concerning the different food
rection of movement; (5) placing concave mirrors or                item classes. Finally, the index k varies from 1 to p=2,
a traffic lights system, activated by motion sensors,              where the value 1 is for inbound movements and 2
at increased risk areas; (6) reinforcing safety signage;           for outbound movements. The first uses electric
and (7) replacing the false ceiling of the dry grocery             forklift or stacker (60%+40%) and the second electric
store.                                                             stacker or manual forklift (70%+30%), according to
                                                                   the usual procedure.
                                                                        From the application of equation 2, quantifying
6. Proposals quantification and due
                                                                   the improvement of introducing the layout propos-
discussion                                                         als, it is obtained a total difference of handling cargo
    To measure the efficiency of a system, it is neces-            movements of about 524Km/year, corresponding
sary to be able to measure it correctly by selecting the           to 35% of travelled distance reduction. To express
appropriate factors [21]. In order to quantify the ef-             the obtained improvement in terms of money value,
ficiency of the proposed solution, in terms of the to-             three criteria were observed: first, the increasing in
tal distance of cargo handling within the warehouse,               the useful life of cargo handling equipment due its
equation 1 was adapted to the specific case resulting              lower use; next the saving in operating and mainte-
on Equation 2.                                                     nance costs and; finally, the increase in productivity
                                                                   expressed in terms of man/hour. The percentages
                                                                   obtained are as per Table 2.
                                                                        The shown improvements do not reflect the total-
                                                                   ity of the potential benefits. Some positive effects are
                                                                   difficult to quantify or to observe in a simple way. As
                                                                   an example, one can point the simplification of the
   Where the variable T refers to the sum of car-                  monthly and annual inventories and weekly checking
go handling made for each k movement typology,                     of stocks and movements, or the greater flexibility in
between points i and j; D indicates the distance, in               the use of human resources from other warehous-
meters, between the location of points i and j, mea-               es, as a result of the fixed locations policy. Worker’s
sured over the used paths. The index i names the                   perception of self productivity may contribute to im-
physical locations of loading and unloading cargo                  prove motivation. The increase in productivity and
docks; j indicates the central physical locations of the           its consequence in reducing working hours, makes
storage spaces assigned to each class of food items;               possible to allocate the available human resources
k identifies the different types of load and mean of               to other tasks, increasing quality and service level or
transportation adopted, e.g. box carried in hand, on               collaborate with other warehouses belonging to the
pallet using a manual forklift or electric forklift, con-          same entity. The improvement of safety conditions at
veyor belt. This differentiation is due to the different           work, resulting from improvement proposals to ex-
isting physical conditions impact reduction of move-            the institution. The relocation of workspaces has also
ments within the warehouse. Being the movement of               been proposed, improving access to storage spaces
loads a critical factor for the safety of all those cir-        and reducing the distances to be covered. For the
culating in the warehouses, less movements and less             facilities under construction, a detail plan was pre-
crossing of flows means more safety.                            sented. The existing situation and the advanced pro-
    In order to validate the relevance of the suggested         posals were analyzed in terms of human safety, food
proposal, a series of interviews were carried out with          hygiene and safety practices.
managers and technicians with proven experience                     In order to quantify the improvement achieved in
and theoretical knowledge. The obtained answers                 the distances taken in handling cargo, an innovative
were quite positive and allowed a fine adjustment of            formula has been defined. In addition to calculating
the proposals submitted under the case studied. The             distances according to the different possible points
head of the responsible organization expressed the              of origin and destination, the proposed formula con-
intention to implement the proposed measures of                 siders that not all movements are equal. It allows
improvement in the near future.                                 the inclusion of different types of cargo movements,
                                                                which affect the level of aggregation of loads and the
7. Conclusions                                                  necessary equipment to perform it.
                                                                    The main limitation of this study is due to the fact
    Efficient use of resources is vital for most orga-          that it is an application to a specific case and therefore
nizations. The public sector is not immune to this              the replication needs some necessary adaptations. As
trend. The real reduction in available budgets and              future lines of research, it is proposed to apply this
legal limitations to resources dictates the need to im-         study to other types of warehouses and organizations
prove the use of existing resources. Warehousing,               (different types of goods, layouts and handling meth-
despite its importance for the proper functioning of            ods), as well as its extension to an integrated logis-
the logistical system, represents a consumption of              tical operation with several warehouses in different
human, financial and material resources that may                locations. It is also suggested to extend the study in
be essential for other activities. The food operations          order to quantify the impact on workers' motivation
present additional challenges to the warehousing ac-            and productivity, resulting from the improvement of
tivity [2].                                                     working methods and safety conditions within ware-
    With the aim of improving resource usage effi-              houses.
ciency a real case study was conducted within the                   This work shows that changing the layout of ware-
Portuguese Navy’s central food warehouse. Cargo                 houses in terms of the allocation of storage locations,
handling movements within warehouses has been                   taking into account the handling rate of the articles,
identified as an opportunity for improvement. Addi-             contributes to the improvement of warehousing.
tionally, it was intended to propose a layout plan for
a cold warehouse under construction. Safety at work             Acknowledgements
is a legal prerogative, a motivational factor and a so-
cial obligation, so safety aspects were also analyzed              We thank the Portuguese Navy, Direção de
in order to ensure that the proposed improvements               Abastecimento, in the person of its Director, Com-
do not represent a reduction of adequate safety stan-           modore Dias Gonçalves, the head of the Secção de
dards.                                                          Alimentação, Lieutenant-Commander Monteiro
    The existence of random strategies in assigning             Sereno and his staff, for making this work possible.
storage locations, in a human based warehouse, cre-
ates subjectivity, dependence on the workers that               Funding
perform the tasks and ultimately, inefficiencies. Fix-
ing the items that have the highest rate of movement               This research did not receive any specific grant
within locations, near the access and exit points of            from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or
the warehouses, boosts the reduction in distance of             not-for-profit sectors.
cargo handling and the working time of workers and
machines.
                                                                References
    A specific proposal to assign food items clustered
in classes to fix storage locations was made. Beyond            [1]		R. Guido, G. Mirabelli, E. Palermo, V. Solina, “A framework
the optimization achieved, this procedure makes                 		for food traceability: case study – Italian extra-virgin olive oil
                                                                		supply chain”, Int. J. Ind. Eng. Manag., vol. 11, no. 1,
possible to establish a correct storage policy within
                                                                		pp. 50-60, 2020, doi: 10.24867/IJIEM-2020-1-252.