Development of Fly Ash Usage in Thailand PDF
Development of Fly Ash Usage in Thailand PDF
ABSTRACT: This paper describes the situation of fly ash usage in Thailand. Firstly, the general
information including typical characteristics of fly ash in Thailand is given. Properties of fly ash in
Thailand were compared with those of the fly ash in Japan in terms of chemical composition and physical
properties. It was found that generally fly ash in Thailand has higher CaO content, higher alkali content
but lower silica content and LOI while fineness of the Thai fly ash was generally lower. It was also found
that water requirement of both countries fly ashes was about the same. Regarding strength, the Thai fly
ash was slightly better. The consumption of fly ash in Thailand increases significantly after the economic
crisis in 1997 and at present almost all fly ash produced in Thailand is used as cement replacing material in
concrete industry. The paper also describes problem at the early stage of introducing fly ash into the
construction industry together with the strategies to promote its use. Finally, examples of application of
fly ash in various types of concrete and cementitious products in Thailand are given.
Table 1 Comparison of Chemical Compostion between Fly Ashes in Japan and Thailand
Composition Japan* (%) Thailand** (%)
SiO2 47-70 20-55
CaO 0.49-7.55 1-35 (majority 7-20)
Al2O3 15.64-32.03 5-40
Fe2O3 2.54-15.68 (majority<5.0) 1-15
SO3 - 0+-10 (majority between 1.5-4.0)
MgO 0.22-2.81 0+-5
(Na2O+0.658K2O) 0.22-3.27 (majority <1.5) 0.5-2.5 (majority >1.5)
* from reference [10]
** from reference [11] and the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand.
2.1.2 Physical Properties and Loss on Ignition Thai fly ashes are thought to be coarser.
Table 2 compares some physical properties and However lower specific gravity of the Thai fly
loss on ignition between the Japanese and Thai fly ashes denotes that the Thai fly ashes have more
ashes. It can be observed from the Table that the cenospheres and plerosheres. The lower loss on
majority of the Thai fly ashes have lower specific ignition of the Thai fly ashes is considered to be
gravity, Blaine fineness and loss on ignition than due to higher allowable burning temperature of the
the Japanese fly ashes. From the data of Blaine coal powder in Thailand than that allowed in Japan
fineness and the amount retained on sieve#325, the due to the limitation of the emission.
Table 2 Comparison of Physical Properties between Fly Ashes in Japan and Thailand
Properties Japan* (%) Thailand** (%)
Specific gravity (g/cm3) 1.98-2.43 1.7 - 2.4 (almost half <2.0)
Blaine fineness (cm2/g) 2350-6580 1800 – 4000 (about 80% <2500)
% Retained on sieve #325 4.8-53.9 20 - 65
Loss on ignition (%) 0.4-13.9 0.1 – 5 (about 80%<1.0)
* from reference [10]
** from reference [11] and the Concrete Products and Aggregates Co.ltd
2.2 Properties of Paste, Mortars and Concrete and the sand to binder ratio is 2.0 while ASTM
using Fly Ash C311 specifies water to binder ratio of 0.484 and
sand to binder ratio of 2.75. However, though
2.2.1 Water Requirement both countries’ fly ashes were tested based on
Table 3 shows the comparison of water different standards but they have the same concept
requirement between the Thai fly ashes and the to evaluate the test results. If the two set of data
Japanese fly ashes. It should be noted here that are compared by discarding the difference of the
the test methods of both countries are not the same test methods, then both countries’ fly ashes have
(JIS A6201-1991 was used to test the Japanese fly similar water requirement as can be seen from
ashes and ASTM C311 was used to test the Thai Table 3. The lower loss on ignition makes the
fly ash). Mix proportion of the test samples, Thai fly ashes have similar level of water
apparatus and the test procedure are all different. requirement to the Japanese fly ashes though they
Especially for the mix proportion, in JIS are coarser.
A6201-1991, the water to binder ratio of the
control sample (cement only mortar) is set at 0.65
Table 3 Comparison of Water Requirement between Fly Ashes in Japan and Thailand
Properties Japan* (%) Thailand** (%)
.Table 4 Comparison of Strength Index between Fly Ashes in Japan and Thailand
Properties Japan* (%) Thailand** (%)
3000000
2700000
2500000 2300000
2000000 1800000
1500000 1400000
1000000
1000000 800000
500000 400000
Fig.2 and Fig.3 show the statistics of fly ash used in confident with the fly ash application in concrete at
various types of concrete. It can be seen from Fig.2 that time. At present, fly ash has already become a
that up to 1997, fly ash was used mostly to produce conventional cement replacing material in Thailand so
special concrete like self- compacting concrete, sulfate that majority of the ready-mixed concrete plants,
resisting concrete and low heat concrete for mass including those in precast concrete and on-site ready
concreting. However, the situation changes in 1999 mixed plants, are using it as a major cementitious
when fly ash was used mostly in normal concrete. material and fly ash concrete has now become a
This expressed that fly ash had become more and conventional concrete in Thailand.
more popular and engineers were more and more
LHC
SCC
NC
LHC
82%
Others
Fig.2 Distribution of fly ash used in various types of concrete from 1994-1997
LHC:Low heat concrete, SRC:Sulfate resisting concrete,
SCC:Self compacting concrete, NC:Normal concrete
LHC
Others
SRC
12%
NC
46% SCC
LHC
35% NC
SCC SRC
2% 5%
Others
Requirement
Item Properties Second class
First class Third class
Type a Type b
1 Silicon dioxide (SiO2), min. % 30.0 30.0 30.0 30.0
Not less than
2 Calcium oxide (CaO), % - Less than 10.0 -
10.0
3 Sulfur trioxide (SO3), max. % 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0
4 Moisture content, max. % 3.0 3.0 2.0 3.0
1) 1) 1)
5 LOI content, max. % 6.0 6.0 6.0 12.0
Note: 1) The use of fly ash with up to 12% LOI may be approved if either acceptable performance records or
laboratory test results are made available.
Table 6 Chemical properties (optional)
Requirement
Item Properties Second class
First class Third class
Type a Type b
Note: 1) Fly ash with alkali content exceeding this limitation may be approved if the test results on control of
alkali-silica reaction satisfy the requirement.
Requirement
Item Properties First Second class
Third class
class Type a Type b
Fig.4 Demonstration of mass concreting using fly ash concrete at Mae Moh power generating plant
Fig.5a Concrete wall Fig.5b Concrete box culvert
Fig.5 Demonstration of Self-Compacting Concrete using fly ash at Mae Moh power generating plant
Fig.6 Demonstration construction of Roller-Compacted Concrete Pavement using fly ash at Mae Moh
power generating plant
Fig.7 A computer software for mix proportioning of fly ash concrete
Fig.8 Pak Mool dam in Ubol Rachathani constructed using roller-compacted concrete with fly ash content
of 68% of the total cementitious materials.
4.2 Precast Concrete, Concrete Products REFERENCES
For precast concrete and concrete product
industries, fly ash is normally used in the works 1. Huang, J.Y., Beneficial Use of Fly Ash, Michigan
that does not require early strength such as Technological University
non-prestressed concrete works. For prestressed
2. Sisomphon, K., Hongvinitkul, S.,
concrete industries, fly ash is also used but with a
Nimityongskul, P., Tangtemsirikul, S. and
maximum cement replacement of only up to 10%.
Rachdawong, P., Uses of Municipal Solid
The exception may be in the case of
Waste Ash as Construction Materials,
self-compacting concrete application in which fly
Proceedings of the 7th East Asia-Pacific
ash may be used up to a range of 30% to 50% even
Conference on Structural Engineering &
in prestressed concrete work..
Construction, 27-29 August 1999, Kochi
University of Technology, Kochi, Japan, pp.
4.3 Other Cementitious Products 1366-1371
Some cementitious material products which use fly 3. Tangtermsirikul, S., Sudsangium, T. and
ash to replace cement in the production are such as Nimityongsakul, P., Class C Fly Ash as a
cementitious fibered roof tile, cementitious fibered Shrinkage Reducer for Cement Paste,
panel, etc. In this category, fly ash is normally Proceedings of the 5th CANMET/ACI
used up to a maximum of 30% of the total International Conference on Fly Ash, Silica
cementitious materials. Fume, Slag and Natural Pozzolans in
Concrete, 4-9 June 1995, Milwaukee,
4.4 Blended Cement Wiscosin, USA, Vol.1, pp.385-401
Some cement companies have made efforts to 4. Tangtermsirikul, S. and Chatveera, B.,
introduce ready-blended fly ash cement into the Development of Low Heat Concrete using
concrete market in Thailand. Most of them are Lignite Fly Ash, Proceedings of the 4th
introduced in the form of cement for durability International Conference on Civil
purposes such as cement for marine environment Engineering, 6-8 November 1996, Manila,
having high resistance against sulfate attack and Philippines, pp.786-795
chloride-induced steel corrosion, sulfate-resisting 5. Tangtermsirikul, S. and Chatveera, B.,
cement or low-heat cement, etc. However, these Expansion of Cement Paste and Mortar using
cements are still not popular especially for project Lignite Fly Ash, Supplementary Papers of the
constructions using ready-mixed concrete. For 3rd CANMET/ACI International Symposium
projects, where ready-mixed concrete is usually on Advances in Concrete Technology, 24-27
applied, it is more popular to mix fly ash at the August 1997, Auckland, New Zealand, pp.
ready-mixed concrete plants. This is because 1) 321-329
ready-blended fly ash cement is more expensive 6. Tangtermsirikul, S., Kaewkhluab, T. and
than cement with fly ash as a separate binder, 2) Jitvutikrai, P., A compressive strength model
the ratio of fly ash is usually adjusted according to for roller-compacted concrete with fly ash,
the required performances of concrete when it is Magazine of Concrete Research, Vol.56, No.1,
used as a separate binder. February 2004, pp. 35-44
7. Samranwanich, T. and Tangtermsirikul, S., A
4.5 Repair Materials Model for Predicting Time Dependent
Fly ash is also used in enhancing performances and Chloride Binding Capacity of Cement-Fly
reducing cost of some repair materials especially Ash Binder System, Materials and Structures,
for grouting materials. Fly ash has also been RILEM, Vol.37, No.270, July 2004,
studied as a stabilizer and to control expansion of pp.387-396
expansive cement [17]. 8. Krammart, P and Tangtemsirikul, S.,
Expansion, Strength Reduction and Weight
5. CONCLUDING REMARKS Loss of Fly Ash Concrete in Sulfate Solution,
Based on what mentioned in this paper, it can be ASEAN Journal on Science and Technology
said that Thailand has become a very successful for Development, Vol.21, Issue 4, December
country in regard of fly ash usage in concrete 2004, pp.373-390
industry. The success was obtained on great 9. Khunthongkeaw, J. and Tangtermsirikul, S.,
efforts and good strategic planning and patience of Model for Simulating Carbonation of Fly Ash
a number of academicians and professional Concrete, The 1st International Conference of
engineers. The use of fly ash has also become Asian Concrete Federation, Chiang Mai,
one of the significant factors to change the concept Thailand, 28-29 October 2004, pp. 907-917
of concrete practice in Thailand from that 10. Yamamoto, T. and Kanazu, T., Accelerated
considering strength only to considering both Chemic al Assessing Method for Pozzolanic
strength and durability.
Activity of Fly Ash, Abiko Research
Laboratory Report No. U98047, Central
Research Institute of Power Industry, Japan
11. Tangtermsirikul, S., Mix Design of Fly Ash
Concrete (in Thai), Engineering Institute of
Thailand, November 1999, ISBN
974-382-909-9
12. Ashino, M., Mix Design of Fly Ash Cement
Concrete using Mae Moh Fly Ash, M. Eng.
Thesis No. ST-84-1, Asian Institute of
Technology, April 1984
13. Chindapresert, P. and Horvichit, I., Properties
of Portland Cement mixed with Mae Moh Fly
Ash, Office of Technology for Rural
Development, Faculty of Engineering, Khon
Kaen University, 1985
14. http://flyash.learn.in.th
15. Committee on Concrete and Materials of
Engineering Institute of Thailand, Use of Fly
Ash in Concrete, October 2001, ISBN
974-7197-28-6
16. Committee on Concrete and Materials of
Engineering Institute of Thailand, Standard
Specification for Materials and Construction of
Concrete Structures, 1st revision, 2003, ISBN
974-91685-4-2
17. Jakpisal, V. and Limsuwan, E., Development of
Shrinkage-Compensating Cement, Proceedings
of the 1st National Concrete Convention,
Kanchanaburi, 14-16 May 2003, pp.23-27