Banking Sector Service Analysis
Banking Sector Service Analysis
net/publication/352781678
CITATIONS READS
5 762
3 authors:
Jini Saxena
Dr. D. Y. Patil Institute of Management and Research, India, Pimpri, Pune
20 PUBLICATIONS 308 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Atul Kumar on 29 January 2022.
CITATION: Kumar, Atul; Joshi, Jena and Saxena, Jini (2018), “Service Portfolio Analysis of
Banking Sector: A Comparative Study”, MERC Global’s International Journal of Management, Vol.
6, Issue 4, pp. 180-187.
ARTICLE HISTORY: Submitted: June 27, 2018, Revision received: July 30, 2018, Accepted:
August 14, 2018
ABSTRACT
India’s economic growth has been strongly driven by the Indian banking sector. The
development of the Indian economy has, also, in turn, developed the banking sector in the country.
The objectives of the research paper were to study the services rendered by the Indian banking sector,
to appraise those services and carrying out the comparative analysis of the service portfolio of banks.
Based on the secondary information, the study was carried out on three banks, viz SBI, Central
Urban Co-operative Bank and ICICI Bank. Primary data was also collected from respective bank
branches regarding the services offered through the survey. For the purpose of evaluation, the Boston
Consulting Group (BCG) matrix was considered.
1. INTRODUCTION
The Indian banking sector has witnessed numerous positive developments in the last decade.
Ministry of Finance, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), and several regulatory entities are the policy
makers that have contributed to improve the regulation in the banking sector. Various metrics like
profitability, growth and non-performing assets (NPAs) also show the favourable outcomes in the
banking industry. Many banks have emerged with extraordinary track records exhibiting value
creation, growth and innovation. The sector‟s market valuation has seen the improvement. But the
positive things are restricted to a small part. The cost linked to intermediation in Indian banking is
higher, whereas penetration is lower as compared to other markets. India‟s vision of becoming the
vibrant economy expects a lot of contribution from the banking industry. Consequently, the regulatory
framework and efficient policies need to be implemented for being successful. In many developing
countries, the development of the financial sector has been restricted as they were unable to respond
to the changing trends of the market. The long term status of economies is dominantly based on the
banking sector of the country.
~ 180 ~
MERC Global’s International Journal of Management Volume 6, Issue 4, October 2018
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Fantassi et al. (1992) suggested that the service provided should be appropriate in terms of
catering to customer requirement is not more than fifteen minutes within affordable price and doing
the right thing for the very first time. The importance of introducing flexibility is emphasized as there
is a limitation of strategic planning due to the shortcomings in forecasting the ever-changing future.
Hopkins (2005) concluded that banks should be customer-centric and that the customers should be
provided with online banking service to enable them easy tracking of their accounts. Considering the
increasing risk of identity theft and customer data privacy, Banks are emphasizing on risk
management. According to Agarwal (2005), banks should use services marketing where the
competition is not existing. The banking industry is highly profitable and the entry has been easy with
unlimited potential. Sivaloganathan (2004) coined that banks should provide personal and
professional customer services. Banks should try to improve customers‟ perception of bank services.
Customer population is increasing at a higher pace and likewise, there is a requirement of qualitative
competitive services.
Bielski (2005) concluded that the banking industry needs to improve the customers‟ service
levels regarding their brand and culture. It also emphasized that banks face problems with customer
service which is related to four different aspects including how to provide good service, enhancing
their organisational culture and brand, evaluating service levels in order to consistently illuminate the
information, motivating the members of the organisation to deliver up to the mark for best results and
finally providing the resources expected to attain the vision. Valentine (2005) suggested that a sale is
mostly due to how satisfied a customer is. Bank employees provide better services, but require a
proactive attitude. If such kind of attitude is developed among the employees, then, the organisation
will get to know the needs which are unfulfilled. Moreover, there is a need for developing a sales
culture through the proper system implementation which can track sales accurately.
Weun et al. (2004) coined that the severity of the failure of service can have a terrible impact
on the levels of satisfaction, trust and commitment, with unwelcomed negative word-of-mouth.
Service failure severity should be diligently worked on for the organisation‟s well-being. Bhatt (2005)
explained that the quality of the service rendered by the foreign banks is far better as compared to that
provided by the Indian Banks. Moreover, service quality varies across different demographic
variables. Rahman (2005)‟s studied the service quality of different Indian banks. It scrutinises the
incongruence existing between the customer‟s perception and expectations regarding the quality of
services. The study uses SERVQUAL as an instrument for study. The results point out that there is a
perceptual problem among the sample population regarding the experience of the banking service.
4. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The present study was based on both exploratory research design as well as a descriptive
research design. The exploratory research design was used to determine the objectives for the research
and descriptive research design has helped in taking out the detailed facts and figures required for data
analysis. Both primary and secondary data have been collected. Primary data was collected through a
survey of banking personnel done in selected banks regarding what special services these banks offer.
A lot of secondary data has been collected from relevant books, magazines, newspapers, international
~ 181 ~
Service Portfolio Analysis of Banking Sector: A Comparative Study Kumar et al.
and national journals, websites of different banks, including the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and
National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD). For the survey of personnel from
a banking institution, a non-probability method of sampling- convenience sampling was used to select
the sample elements. The service portfolio of banks has been analysed with the help of the Boston
Consulting Group (BCG) Matrix. The comparative study of the service portfolio analysis has been
conducted by studying services offered by selected banks of the banking sector, including State Bank
of India (SBI) representing nationalized/public sector, ICICI Bank represents private sector and
Central Urban Co-operative Bank (CUCB) in Udaipur City, Rajasthan. The survey has been done in
the months of November and December in the year 2017.
~ 182 ~
MERC Global’s International Journal of Management Volume 6, Issue 4, October 2018
From the study, it was found that all the three banks, i.e. Central Urban Co-operative bank,
ICICI and SBI offer internet banking services. All three banks taken for study have different rules for
the price of services offered. The price of services offered by the bank is regulated by the government
or other organizations. The Central Urban Co-operative bank fixes the prices by involving the
government partially and SBI decides the prices according to RBI guidelines whereas ICICI Bank
fixes the price by them.
There is a separate cell to facilitate the customers by the Banks. From the study, it was
observed that ICICI bank has a dedicated cell and SBI has Grahak Mitra cell to provide this service
whereas the Central Urban Co-operative bank does not provide such services. SBI offers Credit cards,
auto loans, brokerage services, home equity credit, retirement vehicles, and savings as weak spots
with key customers, whereas ICICI and Central Urban Co-operative bank do not provide such
services.
ICICI and SBI offer the largest part of their services to corporate and retail patrons whereas
the Central Urban Co-operative bank gives it‟s a large part of services to retail patrons. For the
Central Urban Co-operative bank and SBI, the retail patrons are 90% and 80%, respectively, but
ICICI bank has only 55% as their retail patrons. SBI and Central Urban Co-operative bank have 10%
as their correspondent patrons while ICICI has only 5%. ICICI Bank provides special services to its
patrons. They provide technological services to their retail patrons, relationship management for the
corporate patrons and drawings are provided to the correspondent patrons. Central Urban Co-
operative and SBI don‟t have such special services for their patrons.
For the performance analysis, the ICICI bank is outsourcing the CRM software while the
Central Urban Co-operative Bank and SBI have their own software. ICICI bank has got a separate
team for image building or brand building, whereas SBI does not have any team for such activity. The
Central Urban Co-operative bank offers better customer services for building the image. Since it is a
co-operative bank, the Central Urban Co-operative bank doesn‟t have a strong portfolio while the
ICICI and SBIs have a strong portfolio.
All three banks (taken for research) offer customer services in different dimensions. ICICI
bank offers customer services in behaviour, technical, after-sales services, amenities and efficiency.
SBI focuses on behaviour and efficiency elements while the Central Urban Co-operative bank offers
after-sales service, behaviour and advisory dimensions.
~ 183 ~
Service Portfolio Analysis of Banking Sector: A Comparative Study Kumar et al.
Market Share
High Low
Deposits, Deposits, Saving Deposits,
Term Deposits, Yearly Deposits, Current
Deposits Non-Fund Based Advances,
Fund Based Advances, Sale of Draft,
Remittances, Secured, Collections, Letter of Guarantee, International Banking
High
Internet Banking, Safe Custody, CRM
Service, „GrahakMitra‟ Cell (To help
Market Growth
Market Share
High Low
Current Deposits, Short Term Deposits,
Demand Deposits, Deposits, Term
Saving Deposits, Fund Based Advances,
Market Growth
~ 184 ~
MERC Global’s International Journal of Management Volume 6, Issue 4, October 2018
Market Share
High Low
Demand Deposits, Deposits, Term
Deposits, fund Based Advances, Non-Fund
Based Advances, Saving Deposits, Yearly International Banking, Demat Services,
Deposits, Current Deposits, Short Term Internet Packs, NRI Services, Safe
High
Deposits, Secured, Remittances, Term Custody, Bank @ Home
Market Growth
6. CONCLUSION
The study shows that the three Indian Banks provide enough services to survive and grow in
the financial market. The nationalised bank State Bank of India (SBI) has been found to have 80%
retail clientele and offers a wide range of services to them. Central Urban Co-operative Bank (CUC
Bank) offers very restricted services to its customers as compared to SBI and ICICI. ICICI has a wide
range of portfolio of services to cater to their retail and corporate clientele.
SBI has CRM Service, Internet Banking, Non-Fund Based Advances, Sale of Draft,
Collections, Remittances, Safe Custody, Saving Deposits, Yearly Deposits, Demand Deposits,
Deposits, Fund Based Advances, Term Deposits, Current Deposits, Secured, „GrahakMitra‟ Cell,
Brokerage Services, ATM Services, Locker, E-Pay, E-Rail services are in star position & most of
these services are in the growth stage of Product Life Cycle. The strategy used by SBI is the
expansion strategy for further growth of these Stars position services, whereas International Banking
and Letter of Guarantee are found to be the question marks in BCG Matrix and thus need to be given
~ 185 ~
Service Portfolio Analysis of Banking Sector: A Comparative Study Kumar et al.
the huge investment in order to gain sufficient market share so as to convert them into BCG - star
category. Working Capital Advances, Gift Cards, Forward Inward Remittance, Gift Cheques, Bill
Discounting, Letter of Credit, Sale & Purchase of Foreign Currency, Travellers Cheque, SBI
VishwaYatra Foreign Travel Card, Payroll Cards, Pre-shipment Finance, Post-shipment Finance, NRI
Services, Domestic Treasury and Rbieft services are considered under the dog category which is in
the decline stage of the product life cycle (PLC).
The research found that for Central Urban Cooperative Bank, the services in star position
under BCG Matrix are Term Deposits, Secured, Remittances, Deposits, Yearly Deposits, Demand
Deposits, and After Sales Service. CUC has Question mark category services in which the bank has
applied expansion to some and retrenchment strategy for the rest of the services of CUC bank, which
includes services like Current Deposits, Non-Fund Based Advances, Term Loan, Clean Loan, Saving
Deposits, Short Term Deposits, Fund Based Advances, Unsecured, Draft, Collections, and Advisory
services. The Cash-cow position of CUC bank includes mature services and Trusteeship, through
which bank is reaping the experience curve benefits. The dog category of the bank has services like
Working Capital advances, International Banking, Letter of Guarantee where the former is applying
the retrenchment strategy.
The private bank- ICICI Bank, star category services are strategised to go for expansion as
there is a lot of potential for further growth. These star services are Non-Fund Based Advances,
Demand Deposits, Term Deposits, Current Deposits, Deposits, Yearly Deposits, Term Loan, fund
Based Advances, Saving Deposits, Short Term Deposits, Internet Banking, Customer Centre, Secured,
Collections, Remittances, Bill Payment, Shopping, Railway Ticket Booking via SMS, Prepaid Mobile
Recharge, Credit Cards, CRM Service, Anywhere Banking, Phone Banking, Mobile Banking, ATM,
Advisory Service, After Sales Service, Amenities, Debit cum ATM Card, Funds Transfer, Share
Trading services. Question mark/problem child category include Internet Packs, Safe Custody, Demat
Services, NRI Services, Bank @ Home, and International Banking services in which the services are
strategized for expansion as these are new in nature and have tremendous scope for growth in the
future. Cash cow services of ICICI bank are Trusteeship where the bank strategises for expansion
strategy with proper limits. The Dog category services of ICICI are Pre-Shipment Finance, Post-
Shipment Finance, Letter of Credit, Letter of Guarantee, Bill Discounting, Smart Money Order, Card-
2-Card FT, Third Party Service, Sale & Purchase of Foreign Currency, Donations, and travellers‟
Cheque. For this category, the bank is applying a retrenchment strategy.
7. REFERENCES
1. Agarwal, A. K. (2005), “Services Marketing- Stop, Observe, Go”, Indian Journal of Marketing, Vol.
XXXV, No: 5, May.
2. Bhatt, Mushtaq A. (2005), “Correlates of service quality in banks: An empirical investigation”, Journal
of Services Research, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 77.
3. Bielski, Lauren (2005), “Talk is cheap- Retail Banking”, ABA Banking Journal, March.
4. Choudhary, Nimit and Prahash, Monika (2005), “Service Quality: Revisting the two factors theory”,
Journal of Services Research, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 61-75.
5. Dharmalingam, S. and Kannan, K. V. (2011), “Customer perception on service quality of new private
sector banks in Tamilnadu - an empirical study”, Journal of Banking Financial Services and Insurance
Research, Vol. 1, Issue 5, pp. 39-49.
6. Fantassi, Chery; Giebutowsi, Frank and Hudner, Timothy (1992), “Technology: Ally or Enemy of
Customer Service”, ABA Banking Journal, September.
7. Fojt, Martin (1995), “Enhancing quality in service industries”, The Journal of Services Marketing, Vol. 9,
No. 3, pp. 3-4.
8. Gupta, Deepak and Tomar, Vikrant Singh (2011), “A comparative study of customer-friendly services of
selected private & public sector bank in India: a case study of ICICI bank vs SBI”, Journal of Banking
Financial Services and Insurance Research, Vol. 1, Issue 9, pp. 28-39.
9. Hopkins, Debby (2005), “The customer is the priority”, The Banker, Vol. 155 No: 949, March.
10. Karuppusamy, R. and Palanichamy, N. Venkatesa (2011), “Awareness and adoption of value-added
services offered by the banks in Coimbatore district”, Journal of Banking Financial Services and
Insurance Research, Vol. 1, Issue 9, pp. 40-56.
11. Kohli, Namita and Kaur, Jaspreet (2011), “Services Marketing-Winning and Creating Customers with
Special Reference to ICICI Bank”, Journal of Banking Financial Services and Insurance Research, Vol.
1, Issue 2, pp. 98-110.
12. Mohideen, Abdul Kamal (2011), “Customer service satisfaction in Indian banking sector (A study in
Visakhapatnam district)”, Journal of Banking Financial Services and Insurance Research, Vol. 1, Issue
6, pp. 25-36.
~ 186 ~
MERC Global’s International Journal of Management Volume 6, Issue 4, October 2018
13. Rahman, Zillur (2005), “Service Quality: Gaps in the Indian Banking Industry”, ICFAI Journal of
Marketing Management, Vol. IV, No. 1, February.
14. Rangriz, Vahid and Raja, M. G. Basava (2011), “Measuring of services quality in the banking industry
based on customer perception”, Journal of Banking Financial Services and Insurance Research, Vol. 1,
Issue 4, pp. 44-62.
15. Sivaloganathan, K. (2004), “Relationship Marketing in Banking Service: The need of the hour”, Udyog
Pragati: Journal for Practicing Managers, Vol. 28, Issue 2, pp. 13-15.
16. Thakur, Satendra (2011), “Service quality, customer satisfaction and customer loyalty: A study with
special reference to Indian banking industries”, Journal of Banking Financial Services and Insurance
Research, Vol. 1, Issue 5, pp. 83-93.
17. Tiwari, Shrish Kumar (2011), “Secure financial services (next-generation challenge)”, Journal of
Banking Financial Services and Insurance Research, Vol. 1, Issue 4, pp. 99-110.
18. Valentine, Lisa (2005), “Sales by any other name sometimes works better- bank marketing”, ABA
Banking Journal, May.
19. Weun, S.; Beatty, S. E. and Jones, M. A. (2004), “The Impact of Service Failure Severity on Service
Recovery Evaluations and Post-Recovery Relationships,” Journal of Services Marketing, Vol. 18, Issue
2, pp. 133-146.
Dr. Jena Joshi is an Assistant Professor, Siddhant Institute of Business Management, Pune, Maharashtra, India.
Dr. Jini Saxena is an Associate Professor, Siddhant Institute of Business Management, Pune, Maharashtra,
India.
~ 187 ~
View publication stats