eneHa rypKO
bl
TE XT
de-
KoyoTPy uy
Kak geppuga
off ..4,°
a X
Vsaatenvcteo «| SOMONE.
TOMCK — 1999BBW 87
ro5
Yupearresn usaateanerua «Boxoseii>
Tonekan ofaaerias nayanar OudanoreKa ut. A.C. Tyan
Typo E. Texerss zexouerpysium. JLeppuaa At. Difté
rance.— Tose: Hsxareamerso -Boouelie 1909, -— 160 .
B wouarpadui anaatanpy ren pafon spyticr conpenennaro use
Sur (a crate leppus. saanupseun fori pas
ia Teer pacsorpanten teas cowry somientan sehen?
NYRUINM. snueuwenuoeres. vifferancess seneas. sauaenses "
Grarun sDifférances wnepwue nyannyene com ae
Prana bierane aunyeren wa pyeevow naunes On upea
crazaats ead exononoaaramagin pros, ra, eppwan nonener wten
Guise aifferanees. re wéveannenu ane euuiena. nerweDniy aon aevoner pee
{ine sauaaauivanie #0 wpeneun # oraaaauoanne apoerpacrae
0301030000
M46(03)-99
e3 ob ban.
O106. 9
Ko. eraTbit, HepeRos, 1999
ida «Marges de la philosophies, Les Editions de Minuit,
1972
© Boxoaeiis, odopaacnue, 1999
Moeit dowepu Oavee
BBEJIEHVE
rat
ra — anoiinoe npeaneaonne: HpestcaoBne no maMpy
ino cyt. Saaywanian Kak Buexeme 6 sup TeKCTOB /LeppuLta.
cme ne epeneenmiax 1/101 He onySnEKOBAMAEAN Ha pyecKon
ABLIKe, OIA NpeTeHAYeT Ha 9TY poab OGIOPOM TeX TEM ICKONC:
TYR, KOTOpHe MOryT MlOKAsATRCA MiITATE-HO AocTofDINM
obpauentin K HepsoneTosmRaM. TockoabKy avai oTHX Tem
MpuBASAH K KONKpeTHHIM paGoran Jleppiiaa (saKanbrvennDre
Testu! Map it ecTh HagNAMNNA STUN paGor), waKp MpeaucronNs,
ns6panuoiii 21m RanHoi KNUTH, DoAHe, KAK MpercTanancTen,
onpasaan. CroSoxa wmrepmperarm, KoTOpaR mpeanoaaraerca
FRANPOM NpeAUCHOBNA, OTPAINMHHAETER, HACKOABKO BOSMOAHO,
ceniaKasnt wa TeKeTst Leppliaa, a Takae Neperosom ero mpo-
rpansmoii paGornt «Différances.
Yro KacaeTea NpeANCTOBIIA NO eyTH TORENT, ABTOP Beck
‘er GyKUE M AYXY AeKONeTpYRIUH. MepBnIMt TEKCTOM 2eKO
mpeaneaosiie
°. Be
exes
HeTPYKUMH, KAK HSNECTHO, SLT MpeutesoBiE
Jleppnaa ryccepsenexomy «FTponexoataenne roowery
Cosa CHMMTOMATINHO, HTO AeKONCTPYKTHBIETERHE NaHEKAHIA
RAIOTCA UpeaitCIonuEN HMeHHO KDTOMY paste My
Texery Fyccepan, saereniem « Koropomy (# xneze npomtX
paniuix reketor) Fyccepa» nowttrat «Kpusite enponeiickux Hayk
it Tpaneuententaabiy1o «benoexoszoriies — no cyTH, HTor
cwoero Teopsectna. Hoxecrins paccyaaena jleppraa 0 Tom,
HE MOET UNMETH MpeacxoBHE K dutTocodscKsty
‘ery. K npiiepy, oTHocurerHo npextcrouita, nasmeannoro
Jleppitaa samexaer,
SHamtrerbHan sacTL OcHOBNOTO TeKCTa «PeHomenonoriie
fe Yro Oe, KAK Mpa Mpeaneaosuii.
Tpuvennreauto & comm codersenmmim Texeras Jeppuaa
BHoeIeReTBIIL eRAKCT, ITO Bee OIE NpercraBamoT coboit Gee
ROMEMMOE npeantcaoone Apyrosty TeKeTy, KoTOpUli oH xoTeR
Gut KOMA-MUGYAb HMeTH HOSNOWHOCTY NansteATs, sat oTUIEpA>
He TAKUMY TeRCTY, KoTOpHHli OH HIKOFIa, BLPOATHO, He EME.
Co spestenes: ara nepeacuayenan nurenuta
(Th MepTAd MPOTpassMOro Aosyura AeKOHETPY!-
uu (HNpIMep, B MeccHanesoit aekaapausm Jleppraa «Tp
Aeppsexa on
Terene x cnoelt «Penomenosoriat ayxa>
ro
ects,4 Exena Typxo. Texcimis aexonempyeuun
paxax Mapreas:
, ogaraapaenHas He coBCeN TOSHO B atrantiicKoM nepeBoxe
Speech and Phenomenay («Peas 1 enomentis), «L’Eeriture
et la différences ( (8 aurauiickom nepesore — «Of Grammato-
logys, 970 1 ¢ axrantitexoro, cpparttyscKoro ABLIKOB MoatHO
TepenecTit, KAK , XOTA, ETPOFO roBOpA,
camo eaonocoveranue de la grammatologie> Henepesoanso,
1160 no chpanuysckom AatiKe cyulecTatTembutbIe ¢ npearoros ede>
He iMeWoT caNOcTOMTesBHOF YHOTPEGACHIIA, @ MOTY'T sC110.1630
BATHCA AMUN HMEHHEIX KONCTPYRIUN THNA scyileeTBITEMbHOE
— npejior «des — eymectnurerpnoes; aqecn caeayer Take
ormerirs, 470 npsuareill y Hac rlepenom Hassaruia grofl KHHTH
+O rpausaroaoriitss — netowen!). C yserom seeit yeaosnto-
enn nepesora, orHo U3 BoaMosRHEIS ToaKOBAHItTt HasBainIA aToit
paGorst Jleppiiaa it ButeceHo B saraanie aaHMoro pasiena.
«De la Grammatologies cpaay axe craaa Han6oxee usseerHoit
M3 Tpex onySaKOBAMIMAX paGoT MoaoRoro ¢paituyscKore qh
Aocopa, KoToporo joTOAe 3HAIN MpEMMyYUECTBEHHO Kak Tepe:
Boauka texctos Fyccepaa. Sra padora, HanncanHan, KAsaA0Cb
Gxt, B erporom aKazeMINeCKOM cTHe, HaxOarO onpeaemuaa
oTHomenne MupoRoll dpiocodexoit oGutecrsenHoeTH « Jleppi-
ja, coazaaa eMy B MeTaduanieckuX Kpyrax TOT KpeaNT 20Be-
plin, KOTOpBI XOTA H NOApHIBAAICA ¢ BBIXOLOM KAAAOM HOBO
RHMTH Jleppuaa, OKOHIATeRBHO HE Hees MAO ceroaHmMUHero
mus. Tem, Koy [eppiia narecren mpenmyuectsento 10
(aaa yaoGersa npiMes 9To HasBarte, XOTA
ne caeayer aa6ninaTh, TO HoaHOe HasBaNe KH — «HeyTo,
ornocmuececn (ornociMoe) x rpanwarosorint, «Hexro, mpi-
MaiesKANLCe FpaMMATOTOrIaL; AT NasKArHA UMeIOT, KAK GyAeT
HOKAIAHO HVAC, MpHMUMATLHOe aHaveHne aan {leppitna),
AVCTATONNO CAOAO ONOSHATE B HEM aDTOpA, eKaxKeM, «Clase
(Goace nosanero TeKera, ogaraanaeHHoro Tpyanonepesoaunesn6 Exncna Typxo. Texcmes aexonempyruun
dbpannyacsis C208OM, OsHLLAOULUsT ocodrali por HONoponHOrO
auona) tau «Bperons: les styles de Nietzschee («lllnopet: eran
>). Pasapocme erisedi “Leppitia, eros vacro anazitsit
pyeMoe B KpUTHYECKOIt aTepatype, MpexcraBaneTen, oAHAKo,
cronb sHauitTeaBAAM Aan Tore, “TVGEI TOBOpIITE O TOAMON
LHI saxcatesmveeKoros :leppiiaa, awropa , ¢ saHapxnerayiouuins /leppiiia, abtopost «Ilnop». Toa-
‘ThepaMeHHEM TOMY MOAKET CY AIT cava «[’paMMaTo:IOrItA», Pe
a OTETAN-
Nod BHEMIMIM aKATeEMNsMOM It ETporocTHIO HaAOAEH
80 MpocwaTpuBaotca ocHoBHEe, H TOM HHICHe HF «anapxuve-
exues, Haen xexoneTpyKiutit (paso, srpowem, Kax 1H «LInopsss,
tae Geayaepautan, kasaauct Oot, cnoSona unTepuperansi nocra~
BaeHa B pawns ZekOHeTpyKTHBUCTCKOl eTpateritt)..
Orkaonenne , RAK ONpereaMeT Hx -Leppt
Aa, HO, no cyTH enoeii, (LIOcodeKax rpansaTooriA, AoA,
naderarh «piiocodperwonatia, © Oru nonpocts sine wuinoaNT
Ppaxsttroaoruueckniy anne sa nperert HopMactuttoi Hay
PawNo Kak Ht OCTARIAOY Cro aa HpeeaauT danTALOH dutTOCO-
dbus, amomelien ducocodpueii dpone/orouentpussa. It8 Exsena Fypro. Texcmet aekoncmoysyun
eae eee
Bonpoen npoSaewanusupyior caMy BoaMO‘MOeTS rpaystaTos0-
rit; ne cayyaiino HogToMy raapa «Cpanmaroaorit, osarias-
sienna , HawmHaeTeR
© yTRepaeHtA TOF, 4TO CaM TepsHIH , TIpexCTaRamonas €O-
BA rlocaeqoDaTe-IbNO JpYT Si APYTOM pAsKOpavnBaioULAXeA
npoueeea — nepexoa or ueporandrreckoro muicbata K dor0.40-
Hut Hh wbITeCHEIMIE HechoneTIMECKIIN. daeMeITTER HB dponernve-
cxoro iniepsta. Poneriaanua mepsermocrn, to Jleppura, 20-
Cruraer cHoero HaANBUICMIeTO PasBiITHA KAK pas B TO BpeMl,
Koraa nauimaer Bee Goaee ARETRENHO OGIApYAIEATRCA MIN”
HasLUEIe orpalntuenia «pono/zronenTpusMa, orparniise:
tut, npoapamouuecn B pasiux oGaaeTAX KYADTYpML H AAGKE,
kale 70 MH HapazoKeatnno, w pasnurine mayen (i MpmMepy,
Suosornn w KuUdepuETIRe). Irn orpanEHiia oGHapyanNaOT-
cn, cortacno Jleppiiia, we Menee TapadoKcaapunm o6paso.
(160 penn set 0 Hackno3 roroMeNTpHeTeKoli HayKe Bamaqa)
— Nepea amdepamtsaiine caoro nowiTits uneKMeIMoctit, er
‘THE ero aoroueHTpHeTeKO! GaoKaz.
Huexvennoets Hawnaer aemouerpuponars ce6a
470 Hpunelie earraaoes «criocoGom dpukeau coxepAva
HAN MHBIX BHLIOB TeATeABHOCTIL, HeKOTOpLIM BTOpINNtEIM OGpA-
SOM CBABAIHEIM ¢ AAIUTIMN BIIAAMIE AeRTeADHOCTHL, HO KaK TO,
470 mpercraziner coGoit cyumocTh conepaaHNe caMMIN OTHX
pig0B aeateabuocTu. Kak pas 8 oToM eMuese coupemennan
Suosorns, Hanpunep, aKastsnpyA HanGoace aremenrapmase HH
ehopwaiuonne npouecest # auipoli KaeTKe, roBopitT o Nporpas-
Me ATUX NpoueccoB & KOHTeRcTe TaKOrO HOIUTMAHIA MiteEMeH-
MOcTH, Koraa cata nporpanaa/miesMennocts onpereaser
coaepatamie ymtx Mpoueccos. H KoHeYHO ake, BEA edepa KIGEp-
HeTIMecKoro nporpasmuporania aocrKHa | pacemarpimaTteR.
kak edpepa mtebmentocrs. Eean reopus xuGepuerinn errocobua
BurecHTs it XoTA Ger oTecHITE nee MeTaduaHACEKHe KON
Mem — AYU, ‘RUSH, HeHHOCTH, BMGopa, Haat — T.e.
Te KOMEN, KOTOPME eerIa cayaNA AIM Tore, XTOGN
MBI, TO HMEHHO Ta Toop AOA
CoxpAIATL H oxpanstTr NOWTTIN nichMeOETH, cael, gramme
GuiesMennoro sara) ian rpademst ewe xe Tore. Kare Gyner
poaeMoHerpupOBAH HX coeTReHIE UCrOputo-MeTada
exit Napatrep. hue upeasre onpexesel ka
4ero-70, pie Mero geaORERY: (CO Bees NapaNrepHeTHKAM
eMmicrougiaweinin) sat Ka He NpHuaciedauero K MMIpY 4ea0
RevecKoro, aTOT saeMeNT AOMKEN GsITL NOMMeHOBAN — KaK
grammé sent rpacbewa... RAK oeMenT, NesantteHMe oT Toro,
RowsMaerea ait ON KAK HOepertuN ITM KAK AaAe’ HeseANMEAT
ATOM MeKOTOPOTO renepacbNoro apxu-ennTesa UaM TOO, wTO
NeaLsA HOMBCIITE B HHL KATerOpHAX MeTudanKH, ‘Toro,
YTO HeaBAN TAKE MASHATH OMILITOM; HpHACM He CTU. Vik BATKHO,
Homusaeror a OW Kak aaeMeNT BoOdULe, KAK TO, uTO HIMECT
Nenocpexetwentioe OTHOMIeNNE K Mpouecey enmecoosHaventa
MI RAK TO, ITO CAMO TO cede MOLOGHO NponeXoateniHE
snavensin. Yea ananetes ator npouece aecianu sero-ro HsKe
eTHLI NoCTe Tor, KAK OHO YaKE COCTOAAOCH?s!5,
Dror Houpoe uMeer upMIUITAKKHOe aMaMENE He ToADKO
AM uceii eTparernit AenONeTPYKIUHL, HO ML LIA ana niteE
Mentiocrit & Goslee YskOM EvBIeAe elon — RAN HpeAMETA
Fpannaroaorit (tai Toro, 4FO Nosker Guree oTHECEHO Ie TpaN12 Excna Typro. Texemes aexoncmpyxyuuu
axe yrownuner 8 exoew saraauitn Jleppiu) pan
i XOMMT K MONATHNO HICEMENHOCTH, OKASKIBAETCH
a cocrommt Kakiin-T0 o6pason GHapirTy casio NOWATITE
TCKMeHHOETH TOKO NlocTe TOTO, KAK Mpitcyiee sananoit
anrype KaMydanpowanite, AOrOWeNTpHETCKAK penpeccum mt-
chMeHHOCTH, JOCTHTHYB CBOErO HANIBEICUIeTO BHIpARelMA, Has
NaeT JeMOHCTpHpORATE HeKOTOPME cAaGOETH MACKHPOBKH, BLi-
AMasT® CBO MpUAIUUMIAAKHBIE Orparitiennia. JleMonerparpHo
atx eaaGocrell 1 orpaxitienitii MOAHO YeMOTpeTs He TOADKO B
HeKOTOpLIX OGAReTAX ConpeMEHHO! HayiE, HO MB KYABTYPE B
UenoM, B YacTHOCTH, & TeX BeckMa ETpaMHeAX Mpoueccax, KOTO-
phe umeror Meco B saLike. «TIpoGzema nsbika, — orwevacT
Jleppuaa, = wuKorza ne Guta pagonoli npoGaenoit cpemt
Tpowx, Ho ceituac Oa, Be ReAKOrO coMHeNKA, craaa r06a-
AbHBIMTOPHOHTOM caMBIX pasHooSpasHDix uCeTeRoBart I
auckypeon... Heropuko-meraditanaeckan atoxa xoaxHa coraa-
Wruch © TEM YTREpAAeIMIeM, TO AIKIK COCTARAKET HEC Ce
poCremuetii ropHsonT. Mearennoe, esa yaousMoe ABIEKEHIC,
NporoaxaioMecca B HeApAx 9TOt anOxMt axe MO MeNBIMe‘t Mepe
ABALATh BEKOB MON HMCHEM ABBIKA, CTH ABIEKEHHE K MOHATINO
uiebMenHocTit. MH XOTA OHO CaBa YAOBHMO, TeM He Mere
pexeTaBaneTeA, YT ATO AUHHAKEHME BCC GosIbINe BXOANT 3a
peseaut ania, [itcemeniocTs NOHIMaET AAMIK BO BCEX CMBIC~
nax ororo puipaxemin. Kar 970 mit mokaskeren erpainnam,
AucbMeHHOCT smaseTeH TeM wHeM, no cyTH, He rpositT
aeaoneKY, G0 Tox Aepenom YeronesecKoro NOsiaUMIEA HET Toit
qmepaoii o4nt, Ha KOTOpyIO Mor Ob ynacTh yenoReR HO
KOTOPYY OM Mor Gut yuNGITLEN, OxNAKO 9To Mpeacranaenite
Hoswirrea nose, «nok, & «'passatosorim, Heppiixa erpe-
MiTeH, ¢ ONO! COPENH, COXpAMUITL Te TONKNC HTH paLio-
IAIBHOCTH, KOTOPHE cBASHIBAIOT (KAK EMY Ka‘KeTeH) ero KOH-
uemUHO € AUCKYpCOM ganagHOl KYABTYpEl, a ¢ ApyT
MorkHo Sosice PLIVEAAKHO OTAeAIT EDO KOHILETTINO OT 14IeH
Horoca, nonmnioro » Toit peupeces miceseunoeri, Koropas
OcyULecTBAAAACy Ha MpOTAAEHI Beit HCTOPHH sanajnoll KYA
Type.
Duoxa Jloreca. — ormexacr Jleppraa, ~~ yumexaer. anexpu-
Auupyer tmewMelnoctD, KoTopaM pacewarpliBaetea ntl axe
MeaNatuia Mean Menno Jloree yeraiazannaer To oco-
oe, INITIMNOE OTHOMENIA cuHaN MH aaARKe conICHIA Ero ¢
ror0cOM, O YEN TAK MHOTO paccywaat Tyccepan WK sesty
oSpaiuaeres Jleppita B «Poaoce n (betoMenes. Iry une, xovH
B copeputcime iio Kalowe H.C HIME exeeTHUANIT, paate-tsIET
i Jleppuaa, xoraa munuer 8 «fpanvaroaormp: «B pasax
Aoroca ero Hepasppisian cnaat ¢ phoné, ¢ rodocom, copepiien-
ho ovesnana, Cyutnoert phoné necownenso Ganaka & TOMY, 470
B iipeacrauaciim o emuicau> Kak 0 Jloroce otnocTeN 1 eros!®, Yinrxenne, xoropomy moasepra-
era sutenennocTs B oUOXY JHoroca, saK.UONAETeR B TOM, ATO
TMebMeHHOCTS pAceMaTpHRAETCA dAeCL «KAK TO, YO BoINaLTAET
ia anaveni, oxaaninaeTeA HocropomNuM, BueIMMIM a1a4e-
wito>!9, NOTA HMeHHO MitchMEHHOcTh. NO JleppHaa. eeTe TO, 4TO
dopampyer snavenne, w vet peasuayeres 1 Mpomnaneren cpa
evmeaoosnaverua Kai enocos cyuLeeTRORANUG! MuIpa HeaoBeKA
i wesoneRa ®
Heumo, omnocaueccs x pansamo.ro2uu 15
Dro, # omes, upeHedpexacreasnoc ornomenne K aneEMeH-
Hoeni eqhopsmipowatocs, Kar ewNTaeT -JeppiLta, yae y ApneTo-
Teas. «Lin Apiieroresta estona ckaaaiiiele mamoren cistBo.ta Mt
MMCIEHHOFO OUMITA. TOA Kak IMICKMEHILE 3uAKH cers iG
cusnoanr co8 nponanecenmx. Foaoe, uporaBoaruutl enepai
CUMBOTHD, cocrOnT # exMMOETHOI IF METH MOT cBABK e pay
Mom. Dror nepps } HaNOAUITEH 8 OCOGOM NoaoAKeNIL
No cpaauenino € apyriinn osuayaTecut, on dukenpyer «atu:
Jenmme omerrets, KoTOpEAit cam oTpasalOr BeNL Mupa. Meway
PaayMon it sipoM eyimecrnyer oTHOMerNE ecreeTBEMIOi CHIH
(usa, Meaay pasyoxt u clorocow — otnourenne KoHBeNt-
KuonaspHoro cuswomtsa. Tepnoii Konncmuteli, nenoepeact-
BeHHO caagw@Mol ¢ ecreersenol curHipuKanueli, AbaneTen
yeruntit sauix, Aoroc. Kak Gut To un 6110, uMenHo ecrecrsen-
Holi aM OkALIBAETCA HaNGorCE GaKaKHM K osHasaesony,
HesanucuMo oT Tore. onpeserAeTEH AML OW KAK eMuLer (NBIC.
subtit 11H UBOI!) HAH KAK emp. HitcKMeNHiiT osnauateds, HO
Apueroremno, Rcersta cututh TEXTE H pertpeserTaTiBen, on He
uMeert KoneTpyKTiBHOrO snaxenuas2”, Hsenmo Apuerorert 3a-
AOU TY MATEpNpETALLINO MHCHNEHHOCTIL, KOTOPAN AO CH TOP
ABAReTeH JOMUNUpYOUel: H JaNAAHOi KYALTYpe, Fe 24, «loroc moxer Gorrm GeckonesHnin it HaCTORUIM, MOKET
Guns upneyrerByouNO, Mo‘eT MponisBonITEeA KaK npiBAga-
Hocr»-z-camomy-ce6e (auto-affection) ToabKo MocpeaerBoM rO-
aoca. Taxon, 10 Kpaiisieli Mepe, ombrr san coaHaune rosioca Kak
“AMULAHNA-HOHMSOIS-ceGs-roROpAULIM>25, B aToM eMBIere TO,
¥7O OkAAMHAeTeA a8 PAMKANI ro.TOCA HI HOAHOM pean, KaK ero
nasuamaer {leppniaa, eTaMoBiTeA, HO JOrHKe paccy”nennA, 3a
PexeALNDM mpieyrersine WB 9TOM EMBIERS BMIAAAIONUN 13
Jloroca/aormen 1 pauronaasnoctit, 160 roxopuTs o He-npitey-
Termin — 970 TaKas 7Ke GeceNMeNiMa, KAK TOROpITTh He-ro70-
com, Te. He ropopiiT» soofute. He-ckasannce snuaerer 6
hapaaurse MpucyTeTeiA KAKOrO Gb TO HM GbLIO CMBICAA, MOCKO-
IHKY EMCI 3nech O6HApYANIBAETCA NPeATe BCero Yepes MpHecy-
Terie npn Berriut, npsteyrersie, © KOTOpoM MozHO CKAgAT
ToAKKO ros0cOM.
Baxno eure pas noxvepkuyTh, 470 por roaoca OKAgHIBAeTCA
HOMMMMpytomelt au B KYATYpe onosorMuecKoro Tuna. «CHt-
crema aguika, accoumpyiomases ¢ cboneriseckn-aidanirTHoit
HebMeMOCTHIO, ecrh TO, B PANKAX vero GhLIa coaAAHa TOrO-
UeHXTpCTeKAA MeTadHaNKa, MeTadIsHKa, JeTepMIMpyIoUaA,
onpeacamoutan eamer Burris kar npueyrerancs26, B kyaety-
pax moro, neporsutitieckoro Tuma cRaagutBaeTeR CONEpIIEHHO
14H COUTYALNIA LC TIPHCYTCTRMEM, HC ABHIKOM, 1 ¢ dpiocodn-
i. i € michMenHocTb?”. Yo KacaeTen KyabTypLt avroueHT-
PHSMa, TO «LOFOUEHTpHIM, 9Ta aNOXA NodHOl pew, Bcerza
SAKAWUATA H CKOGE HB KONEWNOM cere AAITECHATA mOGyHO
cbodoanyw pedaexcitio OTHOCHTeTbHO MponexomAeHHA Ht CTATY-
ca mmiensennocri, mO6yw HayKY 0 MMCHEHHOCTH, Cecllt OH He
Sota Texnoaornelt 4 ucTopnell TexWMNKH (1uIeEMMa Ha cayAGe
pean. — E.P.)»28, ec ona He uta neaeA 3a peNio, KOTOpAR,
B chow ovepers, eaexowata (ILM eTpeniLtac cxexoRaT®)
Barres: 8 nonuirke yaonnT 1 gadpuKeNpoBath mpHcyTersite
wenonexa npi/s au13HN supa. Hoe nonuManne miceMeHHocTHE
— Kak TOrO, YTO He ABUAETCA BCTEA 3a Pebio/npucyTeTBHEM,
ne erpesnrren yaonirrb ipticyteraite 1 rloToMy He Mpunaracasirt
i oanotL_u3 sop nprcyreraun — nbunymaaer fleppnaa exe-
Aarh KaK GYNTO Gb yxKe OKOHATEAbHEII BEIBOA O TOM, 4TO TAKOE
Tomstaine MHIcbsICHOCTH He corer CTATS OBSEKTOM HEKOTO-
poit naysnoft rpawnaroaorimt. Hayka 0 mitcbwenHoers 8 70m ec
ToaKonaiiti, Koropoe mpeataraet jeKoHerpyRUA, He HMeET,
no {leppuaa, wiaicos Ha cyulecrnonarite — Toso TAK ae, KAK
he MOT} cyMeCTHOBATD HaYKI 0 MpOHICNOAAEHIN MpHeyTeTBIIA
Mai He-npitcyTeTBiA. HesosmoxHocth rpamMarouoriit 060CHO:
Bumaeten snece KaK OM Na HOROM BITTKE aNlastsa, € KemOTEIO-
BUNEM YAE NHCTO AeKONETPYKTHBNCTCKO! eTpaTerHt HM Tep-
utiozorit.
‘Takum o6pasom, To, K ¥eMy MpHNomuT Jleppita B pesyawrare
csoero passtuilitetitn © BosMOANOCTHL FpaNMaTosOrHHt KAK HO-
holt Konuentyaasuoit KonerpyKutt (drtocodeKoil wan na-
Sinoi, wan Toro 1 Apyroro.. sum AL -TOFO, IMF apyroro, cen
iets # Biay ditaocod>ine Kak MeTaduiaHRY npueyTermAER18 Encna Typxo. Texcme ,texoncmpyxyuu
pannoMMeTHuCcKRyIO HayEY) oTHOE 40 HOKOLO ToAAORA-
Win NitetMeMHOETH, Npereranancr COBO; KAK GM MHOACETRO
Hapagoxcos, OGMApy ARCMIN HME UA pAcIHGAN ypoBUAN ALTA
chopaynponaiuns & paAKTLAN HeccexoNATEATLERUN Anpact-
rway. Bee ati lapadoxent, 6 OSmeM, 1H BHHyaRAQOT put
ro Crpanwtoe HaAswANIUE FparvaroaoruaceKxore TeKeTa ;Teppute
— +Hearo, ornocnucees (ornocumoe) « rpavMaroaoriit, ol
470, cuirraiomeees rpawsmarosorucii>. Boace Toro, Ta woman
cnodoxa HHTepAperaLnUt, KOTOPAS NpeLOCTaBAReTeH MepeRoIOM
WM ToakouaiEN GeaanuMoi: HMermo KONeTpyKUUM «De la gram
matologies, muisnmaer coGaasn, tonsanouutiies & Xoxe anata
canoro TeKeTa, nepeneetit ero Hasnaue KaK «HuwTo, ornoes
meces (oTHociMoe) K rpannarosorin>. OxntaKo ator cob.aasll,
aK W npumanny differance, 0 KoTOpoiL TAK mOduT roROpHTE
Jleppinaa, nce axe caestyer npeosoaeTs 1 tonsiTarkes post!
Suponate To He#TO, OMEHH aHAaNHTEALHOC HeUTO, WOKHpO
Banaanyw ditocodpin, ¥TO NperCTAnaNeT coboii AckONeTpyK-
THBLETCKAR KoNNEMIUIs ttebMENnOCTH. .
Co6aasn imirepapernpovars rpaxmarosorine isa eutsTo>
YAUMITeTUNEIM OGpAgoM MOACKASMIRACTCH He TOABKO JCKOMETPY™
RriteTeRHM aHaTIOM, HOH caNoit HeTopuell mtcHMEHHOETH
aamaanoii kyIBTYpe, ToMHee, TeM HoANOAOM, KoTOpHLi eqhopNIt-
ponaiea azect. eme n antianocti. Fpenedpeanretbioe oFH0-
luenue Apnerotean i MitesMentioerH, 0 4eM YAke Una pede, He
GMAo WeM-TO MoRUIN aan rpesecKoii dpuocodint: averarowo
HECTHA Ta HeNpHASI HM HexXOREpHE, KOTOPOE HEILITARAT
uuteesentoers Hraron. Uno Kacaeren Copara, To on npeano-
uuraa ne meaty once (lepptiza Geper v Kaxecrne ommrpada,
Hinuue: «Coxpar, ror, . B xperianenoii,
PARHO Kak HB MLATOMINICEKO! TpaAMUM, HIebMO TaKAe CTA
BILIOCk HA BTOpOE MecTO — neaeA 3a peau Bora. Herumoe
e080 Bora -— ere nepnoe exono. ¢: asannoe: ckpIAAAN
Muatnet Bese; 34 nponovesisn. B atux 1 smosectne apyrix
Inrepuperaunit nienernioern ie urxourr sa mpeean, hoae
axemmie ene Taaronom — ectyaeGuore KowmonenT:
kuTopiit noswoiser dbusenponan, esuieiu at avaenns yersoit
PONE H BLICTYHAeT H KANCETHE nenoMOrATe. i
omy it Haparpadvoe «fpaxsarosoriie ianeerny¥ uuTaTy
Houmo, omuocaeccs x pax.warnor02iat 19
a
suntan (hypomnesis)30, [pi raxo rosnenann
Fem CAMOCTORTEADNOTO, BLINOARKEETO BL MeL tbl
AAMCLIIA {LIM SKBIRA: CO BHAKIMOOTHOMCHIDE €
ero NOBOTO MI, KAK TAKOBHIC,
HeeyIMceTRENHOE 4 ABH
yernoro c:108a, 3
AIUIKON HE MeEyT B cebe
oSpauaor ee w HeATO spesmanain
ysibrypht
Heropus duutocodint sadpuxenponacta 1 raKoe orHomenne
Amenvenuoeri, Korda, YAY No-HpeaneMy HocTasaeMMO!
Borer aa PEMA, Ola CTANONILIACH MapKepoM CreneMtt jerpaaa
LOI KYABTYpLL OTHOCHTEABHO Apo; PraocodeKan KoHUeET
hui Pyeco, 8 KoTopoii MCBMCHHOCTH OTBOIILIACL HMEHHO TAKAR
poan, XapanreprsoBadacs ye Me MpocTo GespasanaHAM OTHO-
IneHHeM Ke TTeDMCHMOCTH, HO ARTHBHAIM crpeNeHites eeaaT®
ce oTHCTeTBEHHOi BX MuOrHe MpoGaenbl KYAuTYpLE I ASBIKA
Pycco pacemarpnwa nicementocrs, kak Gosteant, xBbIKA, TOT
kak pedn, UCTHL sByK BMCTYNAAH aaN Hero oatMeTBopeHtiest
TPMpOAM D ALIKE H, RAK TAKOREIE, GecenopHo Mpenocxoasin
nitenarenitocrn. Oanako orHoutenite Pyeco Kk MepseHHOCTH, HO
Teppniaa, ue Gou10 croab oaHosnamtbM: Pycco-nmicaresty
Pyeco-dstzocorp nerynasn » apAbHit KoHsKT. Paspyuian npe-
cir muennennoetit, Pycco 20 nexoropoli crenent ero we
hoceTanagaupaer, CHITaN, 4TO THteHMENHOCTD enocoGHa zoNOI-
hire pew. Hepsan aacts atoii onenkit suityeres reoprteli
nanika Pyeeo. wropan — ero uneareanenust ontirom. B +Heno
nea Aaw-skax oGvacumer enoe oGpantene K mHCh
NonMITEY pecTaRpAIUI Toro MpMeYTeTHIA, KOTOPOE OF
Yrpaveripis 6 pew
Tas xaparrepnerusn ornomeniie Pycco K nitepseHnoeTi
kak cauraer Jleppinia, Kak Hea aye HoaxoauT noHATHE
“qonioanenies, «supplements, mpusert s OG0HX ero snavennAx
Li qono.nenie Yero-tHOo (B AMM cayYae — MpHeyter
yren ero dbutseausnt) H dawemenite wero-cui60 (Toro,
'YTCTOHA, GO tuichMeUHblTl anate saMeMmtaeT OTCYTETBY-
jotee 8 Agni MoMenT npHeyTersne), KosunMenrapHoeTt 1
KoMMencaTopHoctt suciMWres jy MM HepaapLiRHo CBASAMHLIAMTE
Xaparrepnernkasit eyamanuenraproert. B Henosem Pyeco
Tonopitt © eyTiLAltwedrrapHocri NitcEseMHOCTHL, pie YRASH-
baer na onacHelii Xaparrep TaKOML LONOAMHTEMHOCTHT MO OTHO-
leo Kk AaMKY (169 UNeLMeHMOETD daMemaeT 1 HaMeHseT
npneyrernue pest). Housrne eymmumserraproctn cranoBirren
ONACHLM Hj cAMOi KONILEMIUME Pyeco, Fe OHO oRASDIAETEA
NeN-TO BpOAe TYE, BHINOLL HA MepAAK sted, KEAA eleAAAN-
pylores Henyaaude REMI, KONTELTTHL, NE YoeMaHONgICEA B TCO-
HeTpytEIUIH 1 HOTOMY YrpOaaTOMKHE HetaeTHOETH,
perimeckoit20 Enacna Typro. Texcmm aexoncmpyrqice
Hewmo, omnocaueeca x spaumaino.102H 21
HenpoTumopentoeri 1, B KoHME KONIOB, camomy eyiecTHORA-
smo cueresit Pycco. Bee oto no6yataaer ero oTaaTh pHopuTer
Herarimuol untepnperaiuint itcesentoctit, npeyMenbunrrn ee
SHAMUMOCTS B epaBHEHHIN ¢ peso HI OCTATKCH, TeM caMBIM, B
KpyFy Tpammuommx npexeransenmii o McDMe, KaK aN TEX-
MunKe pew (¢ ¢piutocodeKolt Tous apentia paRnoit M70)
Ha qhoxe yrparui camoctontersoro coxepaannta nitcnate
Moern, YTparo, yae caysuBuelicn B aanaanoit dutocodun,
scoserto aoomiTiiM BLiraauIT Gaaanenporarie na rpatt
‘uryT0/HexTo», KoTopoe HaGutoAaeTeA B AeKOHETpY KUMI DB CBA
31 € MmesMeMOcTHIO KaK OGbEKTOM rpanMaroctorit. CoepuleH-
HO OYeBHAHO, WTO AIA cOXpanentA 9TOrO HeBoaMoxNOTO (JIA
TpaRMUMOMMNE TorKOBANUI) axBILMGpa TpebyeTcA paINKa.rb
Huii NepecMorp H camoro NOHATUA MHCDMEHHOCTH, 1 Beero TOFD,
NTO TAK NaN HANE eBABBIBATOes ¢ THM HOMATHEM 8 sanaguoll
xyawtypnoll tpaamuut. Taxol nepecnorp m1 peamiayer aeKonc-
TPYRUUIA, Mpeaaaraiouan Mpst aTOM He Mpocto HoBOe TosORA-
We MebMeNNocTH, HO, HO eyTHL, NomHyIo NepeoHeEHKy M1 catbIC~
la, M enocoGon, st pesyaraton ducocodpersonanuia.
OG6pamtanch K mIcsMeHHOeTH m cRoeli apyroit sere —
«TuceMennoers 1 pasanines — fleppiaa rosopur o Hell, Ka 0
euene Meropuit 1 urpe smpa; 970 Onpexeacie queen uM B
KOHTeKCTe aNauNtsd McHMeMHOCTHL KAK MoepeAItIa B OTHOME-
MUX MexkaY Hacromu 4 penpesenTauueli, mUBHEIO HM eMep
roio3!, Ocoananan nec paumxanian cwoeii mtepnperaiut
Aeppuaa aake crasir Bonpoc 0 sakounoctH Henoataonsuus
caMoro nonaTia mienMennoerH. Coxpaneiie eraporo nent
ANELMeHHOCTIE MEET MeCTO H jENOUETPYKIOML OTHIOA HE 1OTO-
NY, TO fleppitta erpemnTes, nyeri, HwocosHaNHE, oerauitTE
Fpausatoxorine B npexeaax duaocodexoii mevaduanin. Cos
PAHEHUe UMteLI nutebMeEHHOCTH cooTRercrByET oCoGoit JOTI
AeKOHeTpYKTIBHETeKOTO AHAIaA, KOTOpyIO Jleppua HuabnacT
AoruKoii haaeosutsmit, T-e. BlieceMUt B Crapme MoUATIIN HOnOTO
coaepzkania YTeM HeKOTOpOTO OTeTpAHCHIIA, OTKAR ALBANIA HX
Mpexnero conepaxainta n npuousania (grafl) HoBEIX eateenoR.
B ), TO yake cAMNIM cbaKTOM TO-
TO, 470 HpiBiBante npeacranner coGoil TeKcronyio crpaTerito,
etpateritio coaqanis MeKOTOpOTO KDIITINECKOTO TeKCTA Ht Kak
TAKOBOE CCT NPOUeAYPA NUCAHIIA TEKCTA, MOAHO YTHEPALARTE,
ATO MHESMEHHOCTE B Moayce NpHBUBANHA/NeTeOHUMIL ech
utrpa — To, 0 Wem roxopirT /leppriaa, onpeseaaa rintestertocrt
Rak Urpy Mupa it cueny, Ha KoTOpofi 9Ta Mrpa passopasntmaeren.
Mrak, corep:xarenpinii anus miesMextoern xoaKer OT
TamuBaTber OT TpARMUONNX MeTAdIaNMecKHX Mpercrante-
init Oo MHehMeHHOCTH, KAK Gar METATIBHO On K HEIL HE OTHOCT
aca. Sr npeasae ncero KAacaeten TOF, 470 cTaHOBHTEA OCHOBOI
AeKOneTpYkTHBHCTCKOll AOTURM MpuuBAniia/itaneounstit HO-
HaTHiA iiteeMeNocTH. — KoLMMERIUIH aHaKa. To, ro BITeRACT
Ng RaACEMECK. KOMYEHULT 1 GIO orMEMeHO JleppaAL. Cyt22 Exena Typso. Texcrnes rexonempyta
Hewno, omnocaiecca « tpaxmamo.ro:t0 23
potest. nosmuaiougte ¥ gin
HUM BpeMenest, ero KosMOARHOETL oTeyTeTBONATE B TOT MOMENT
ApeMeMt, KoTOpHit OH, KAR Gyro. AOcKEH OMNIEMBATH 1,
aOGOpOT. ero CyIMeETHOBAME Tora, KOLA OT ONMEMIBACMUN
UM maennit Yak H ceaA Ne ocratOEL, a TAKE MORUACINE y
44 HEROTOpOIT AOMOAHUTEAWHOlE CHIL, TOETATONON Aan TO-
TO, 8TOGM BLUPHATHER HS KOHTeKeTA (ikeHponarttoro sHaveNItA
KowevaTh no pasananum nenosKam eumceroosnavenstit. Nova
8 oroii snerepuperaium jleppiiaa perk user npoxe Gbt smuD 0
TUICHMEHIDIN aHAKAX, Cro HOMIMAKHE AOCTATONHO ULIPOKO ;AA
TOrO, WrOGMI HASLIBATE HX revepaauanponarubisi sMaKAMIL M10
cyMI oTomaectsaATs co aHaKAMI Kar TaOULION
Tpeactaszenne 0 noamoxnoctn oroxzectaaenia nicemen-
Horo 3HaKA co SHAKOM Kak TaKORMIM erantoBITeH mpeaAMeTOn
noaposuoro paceworpemia w xpytoli paGore Jleppuaa — «ose
qbenomen». O6p aac AUNOTOMI gkenpeeenBIAN 1 una
Aleppnaa nocaannaer, ero nomurna pasae-
saxpayent # cen HMATKaN, Passutue Meaay oxenpeccielt
(ouparcennies:) sw incuixannel: (o6osnatentes), Te. pasarute,
no Tyecepm, wexay suakom i He-alkikoM, steiiay C1OROM It
HHeEMEHUOETIO NpercTaRNET Cobol, coraacno jleppiaa, pas
SIEME }yUxUMOHLTHHOE HL mTEHNONAKHOE, HO ANKAK He
eynureeti9e (1160 To, 4To AOA oTAeANTL oKENpeCeHD oF
MIEKA ~~ HenoepereTHeHMOe e-cttranoe pHeyTeTatte ‘Att
ByMero Hacrommero - okAaMBAETeR He dbuKeHpyesN B AB
ke). Hy neyaaan eyccepaeeexoii mTepnperauin BiiTeEKaeT BO3-
MO:KHOCTH OTOAECTRACHIIA HuICHMEINOFO sta CO 3AKON KAN
Taxoe oro:
¢ npneytermem uw macros
bu
TATLEA NpHAOAT (LTH punts) K say HNeENe e
PAspaSOTEH, KoTOpUE HApAOTaltE KIaccuYeEKHMIL KOUMLEMULA-
HAKA, A Take cyMMeETHCHHO pacipiTL, OEM 11 Corep AKA
caNoro nowsTus stutceMenmtlt anak. Kaaceneckste KOM
Hemunt sHaKa wexoanT, no jleppiaa, 1m mpuanauia exunerna
B auaKe OsnayaeNOrO 1 oatiaYaloMero. 13 Toro. ¥ro Cocclop
HaswiBa GunapHoit omosuunel anaka. OjnaKo eumerRo »
AANHOM cayYae He OsHAIET paneneTBA: upeAMOWreHne Keer
oraauArOc® ostaYaeNOMy NO MUTE ere Gausoeru K JLorocy.
Popsaawnan csumwern oauesaesoro, Ho jLeppiiza, eer. upuey-
TeTOMe H ApuBiLierna ero Garsoert K cloroey tax Soyey. cosh
Aupumiiterint upuexveriany Soo weinGesxinait erver i wonpoc
b ANAK? MeNATeAHAN peau Ha awdyI nonuTEY
yuuNweTiL, HoNpocy «li estir, «Pop
M MUNOCTH «SHAK MOE ‘TOADKO
‘Tepannay npueyrersus. Hearn Hoaysirn orner Ma ater
Bonpoc, KpOMe KAK HBMeHCHEN caMoit chopstt Bonpoca 1
HAYAIOM PASMBUNLICIOT 0 TOM, HTO SHAK (MEHeXEPKHYTHE HO:
‘inerveponenit) ecrt. TO, ¥TO GMTO HEYAAMHO NABBAHO BENTO
(ranaxe nepedeprnytoii xaiiaerreponexiar cuocoBos); Hak eer.
eanmeraenoe, 170 enocoGno naGeaate merIETyHETAA HEpyIoMe-
ro woupoca pixocodpunt «ro ecrs...2%
Lia Jleppnaa ovesnano, To atak npeauecrayer HerHKe I
cyutoert Buitia yaxe notomy Xora 614, 470, BoNpOUIAT 06 ITON.
Kak 11 060 neem B atom spe (tro 9To TaKoe?+), sb noatay
eMCA SHAKOM 11 3HAKAMH, KOTOpHE olocpexywoT sNOdyIO HaMly
nounrky mixoxa 1K erpyKTypan Baitia. Ito onocperovanie
‘TpuauNionuo curradock MpeoroamAM B sanagnoii dpuaocodortt
38 CHET ARELEHI HpETCTARAEHILA O IpHEYTETBIM FeAOBeKA pH
{aHlt MUPA Ht CHOCOGHOETH NeAOBEKA NOCpeTCTBOM ASLAKA HIT
OAHOBpEMENIDIM € ‘AUBHLIO TOTO AIPA: T.e, AperCTABIENME o
TOM, 4TO. HO cyMeCTRY, sHAKH ASKIKA (M1 HOKE apyrue suAKH)
eyTe nexorepan jepHBALA, 4TO OLE BTOPHAM OTHOCETEALHO
Burnia ncriomayiores suis ero otuteartil 8 citTyaiuiAN Hpiiey
retain. Casa cbopma/raume orera Ha sonpoc «ro 90 Ta
oe?» —- «9To ect...» hpemeranarer coGoit sozye epumauit,
Hpesmioaaraeren, ITO BHAkOM MO;RIO YaoDITL HeHTO
‘Baga