Veterinary Internal Medicne - 2022 - Gallego - Evaluation of Resting Cortisol Concentration Testing in Dogs With Chronic
Veterinary Internal Medicne - 2022 - Gallego - Evaluation of Resting Cortisol Concentration Testing in Dogs With Chronic
DOI: 10.1111/jvim.16365
STANDARD ARTICLE
This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.
© 2022 The Authors. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine published by Wiley Periodicals LLC. on behalf of the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine.
                                                   KEYWORDS
                                                   ACTH stimulation test, Addison's disease, chronic enteropathy, hypoadrenocorticism, resting
                                                   cortisol
College of Veterinary Internal Medicine - Companion Animal diplo-           T A B L E 1 Most common presenting clinical signs in the 282 dogs
mate in the patient record) were evaluated in all dogs. Hematology,         that were finally included
biochemistry values and ACTH stimulation test results were extracted         Clinical signs                                 Number of dogs (%)
when available.                                                              Diarrhea                                       145 (51.4)
                                                                             Vomiting                                       138 (48.9)
                                                                             Weight loss                                     74 (26.2)
2.5       |    Laboratory testing
                                                                             Lethargy                                        37 (13.1)
                                                                             Hyporexia                                       27 (9.6)
Resting cortisol concentration measurements for all dogs were evalu-
                                                                             Regurgitation                                   28 (9.9)
ated at The Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies, using the Immu-
                                                                             Anorexia                                        14 (4.9)
lite 1000 Analyzer (Siemens Healthineers, United Kingdom). The
ACTH stimulation test results for 63/70 cases were evaluated at The
Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies using the previously men-
tioned analyzer. The remaining 7 cases had ACTH stimulation tests
performed at the primary care practice. Three of these results were
reported by Capital Diagnostics Laboratory, United Kingdom, and for
the remaining 4, this information was not known. Hematology results
were unavailable for 8 dogs and serum biochemistry results
unavailable for 3 dogs. For dogs with >1 resting cortisol concentration
measurement, only testing associated with the first consultation was
considered.
      Final diagnosis was evaluated for all patients. A diagnosis of pri-
mary enteropathy was made if the patients either had endoscopic
biopsy results consistent with an inflammatory enteropathy or if it
was the main differential diagnosis suspected and the patients had a
good clinical response to appropriate treatment (hydrolyzed diet, pro-
biotics, immunosuppressive drugs, or antibiotics). Diagnosis was clas-
sified as suspected primary enteropathy if it was the main clinical
suspicion, but no endoscopic biopsy samples were taken and the
patients were lost to follow-up.
2.6       |    Statistical evaluation                                       F I G U R E 1 Resting cortisol measurements for all 282 dogs with
                                                                            chronic gastrointestinal signs. Red dashed line represents 2 μg/dL
Data were organized in Microsoft Excel (Microsoft, USA); data ana-          (55 nmol/L) cut-off for excluding hypoadrenocorticism
lyses were performed in R (R version 4.0.3) using RStudio (version
1.3.1093). Data were assessed for normality by visual assessment of
histograms and q-q plots. Statistical significance was set at P < .05.      1 month to 15.25 years; interquartile range [IQR], 1.8-8.8 years) and
                                                                            median body weight was 18.2 kg (range, 1.35-80 kg; IQR, 9-29 kg).
                                                                            The most common clinical signs on presentation included diarrhea
3     |       RESULTS                                                       (145/282), vomiting (138/282) and weight loss (74/282, Table 1).
F I G U R E 2 Cortisol measurements in 58 dogs with resting           F I G U R E 4 Cortisol measurements in 6 dogs with initial resting
cortisol <55 nmol/L (<2 μg/dL) with a post-ACTH measured cortisol.    cortisol >55 nmol/L (>2 μg/dL) with a post-ACTH measured cortisol.
Twenty-three dogs had also pre-ACTH resting cortisol concentration    One dog also had a pre-ACTH resting cortisol concentration
measurement. Dashed line represents 2 μg/dL (55 nmol/L) cut-off for   measurement. Dashed line represents 2 μg/dL (55 nmol/L) cut-off for
excluding hypoadrenocorticism                                         excluding hypoadrenocorticism
dogs       with    food-responsive       enteropathy,   immunosuppressant-        which has been estimated by previous studies as being between
responsive enteropathy, antibiotic-responsive enteropathy, and histio-            0.06% and 1.1%.2-5
cytic ulcerative colitis. Other frequent diagnoses included: extra-                    Hypoadrenocorticism and other nongastrointestinal diseases
gastrointestinal neoplasia (17/282, 6%), gastrointestinal neoplasia               (including pancreatic diseases, endocrinopathies, diseases of the liver
(13/282, 4.6%), protein-losing enteropathy (10/282, 3.5%), chronic                and kidneys and neoplasia) can present clinically with chronic gastro-
pancreatitis (10/282, 3.5%), megaesophagus (10/282, 3.5%), and                    intestinal signs and 23.4% (66/282) of the patients in our study had
enteritis, gastritis or gastroenteritis (8/282, 2.8%).                            nongastrointestinal disease as the final diagnosis. Our findings are in
    When          focusing   only   on    dogs   with    a   resting   cortisol   agreement with those of a recent German study that assessed resting
concentration <2 μg/dL (<55 nmol/L), the most common final diagno-                cortisol concentrations, with primary inflammatory enteropathy as the
sis was chronic enteropathy (43/79 or strongly suspected in 9/79,                 final diagnosis in more than half of the patients, both with resting cor-
65.8%) followed by megaesophagus (4/79, 4.8%) and giardiasis                      tisol concentrations higher and lower than 55 nmol/L.9 Our study also
(4/79, 4.8%).                                                                     agrees with a study that evaluated the final diagnosis in dogs with
    Only 1/282 dog was diagnosed with hypoadrenocorticism, giving                 chronic diarrhea.16 Inflammatory enteropathy was the most common
a prevalence estimate of hypoadrenocorticism in this population of                diagnosis in that study with a prevalence estimate for hypo-
dogs of 0.3% (95% confidence interval [95CI], 0.03%-1.5%).                        adrenocorticism of 0.73%.16
    Extragastrointestinal disease was the primary diagnosis in 66/282                  Repeat resting cortisol concentration measurements were per-
(23.4%)      patients.   Nongastrointestinal      diseases   included    non-     formed in 27 dogs with an initial resting cortisol <2 ug/dL (<55 nmol/
gastrointestinal neoplasia (17/66), chronic pancreatitis (10/66), neuro-          L), including the patient finally diagnosed with hypoadrenocorticism.
logical disease (6/66), exocrine pancreatic insufficiency (3/66), chronic         Out of 26 dogs with an initial resting cortisol concentration <2 μg/dL
kidney disease (4/66), portal vein hypoplasia (3/66), and hepatopathy             (<55 nmol/L) without hypoadrenocorticism, hypoadrenocorticism was
(2/66). Final diagnosis was not reached in 6/282 dogs (2.1%). Of                  excluded in 19 (19/26, 73%) based on a repeat resting cortisol
these, 5 patients had a resting cortisol concentration <2 μg/dL                   concentration >2 μg/dL (55 nmol/L; Figure 5). Previous studies have
(<55 nmol/L) and 1/5 did not have an ACTH stimulation test per-                   found a resting cortisol concentration of <2 μg/dL (<55 nmol/L) to
formed. This patient was also lost to follow-up and returned to the               have excellent sensitivity for hypoadrenocorticism (99.4%-100%).13-15
referring veterinarian.                                                           As a result, a resting cortisol concentration >2 μg/dL (>55 nmol/L) is
                                                                                  used as a screening test to exclude hypoadrenocorticism. Unfortu-
                                                                                  nately, specificity is low (between 63.3% and 78.2%) and, as a result, a
4      |    DISCUSSION                                                            confirmatory test (ACTH stimulation test) is performed on many dogs
                                                                                  that do not have hypoadrenocorticism,13-15 with increased cost for
The prevalence of hypoadrenocorticism in this population of dogs                  the client. Based on our results, in some circumstances (eg, limited
with chronic gastrointestinal signs and presented to a referral internal          financial resources, lack of tetracosactide acetate to perform the
medicine service was 0.3% (95CI, 0.03%-1.5%), lower than previously               ACTH stimulation test and its cost, low clinical suspicion, non-
described in a smaller population of dogs (prevalence estimate, 4%;               emergency presentation) repeated resting cortisol concentration mea-
95CI, 1.6%-8%).9 One possible reason for the difference between                   surement could be considered to try to rule out hypoadrenocorticism,
studies is that the prevalence of hypoadrenocorticism in Germany is               but an ACTH stimulation test is always required to make a diagnosis
higher than in the United Kingdom. We believe this possibility seems              of hypoadrenocorticism. Other diagnostic tests to consider in these
unlikely, with prevalence in other geographically diverse populations             circumstances include post-ACTH stimulation cortisol concentration
reportedly being similar.2-5 A further possibility is that referring practi-      or    cortisol-to-ACTH      ratio     to    exclude      or    diagnose
                                                                                                         1
tioners in the United Kingdom are more likely than those in Germany               hypoadrenocorticism.
to screen for hypoadrenocorticism before referral. This possible bias is               One dog in our study had a final diagnosis of eunatremic,
intrinsic to studying a referral population of animals because the pop-           eukalemic hypoadrenocorticism. These patients usually have a longer
ulation is dependent on the referring veterinarians' routine practices.           course of clinical signs before diagnosis,17 with anorexia, lethargy,
Finally, dogs with hypoadrenocorticism can present in acute crisis and            diarrhea, vomiting and polydipsia more frequently reported.17,18 Our
in our hospital these cases are seen by the emergency service rather              patient's presenting complaints included a chronic history of lethargy,
than the internal medicine service. Therefore, dogs with chronic gas-             hyporexia, polydipsia and acute vomiting, but further conclusions
trointestinal signs presenting in subsequent crisis would not be                  could not be made in our study because of the low number of hypo-
included in this population.                                                      adrenocorticism cases. Biochemical abnormalities in dogs with
    The prevalence of hypoadrenocorticism in the prior study was                  eunatremic, eukalemic hypoadrenocorticism are similar to those in
4%.9 Our clinical perception was that, in our referral population of              typical cases, except for normal serum sodium and potassium concen-
dogs with chronic gastrointestinal signs, the prevalence of hypo-                 trations.17 Other biochemical abnormalities our patient had included
adrenocorticism was lower, as was confirmed in our study. The preva-              eosinophilia and mild hypocholesterolemia. Hypocholesterolemia and
lence estimate in our study more closely corresponds with the overall             hypoalbuminemia appeared to be more marked in dogs with
prevalence of hypoadrenocorticism in the general dog population,                  eunatremic, eukalemic hypoadrenocorticism compared to cases with
GALLEGO ET AL.                                                                                                                                            7
changes in serum electrolyte concentrations.17 Eosinophilia is reported          3. Bellumori TP, Famula TR, Bannasch DL, Belanger JM, Oberbauer AM.
in up to 20% of hypoadrenocorticism cases.1 Eosinophilia also is associ-            Prevalence of inherited disorders among mixed-breed and purebred
                                                                                    dogs: 27,254 cases (1995-2010). J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2013;242:
ated with inflammatory disease in organs with large epithelial surfaces,
                                                                                    1549-1555.
such as skin, intestine or lungs as well as in parasitic infections.19 Eosin-    4. Kelch WJ. Canine Hypoadrenocorticism (Canine Addison's Disease):
ophilia was found in 10.3% (29/282) of the dogs in our study, with                  History, Contemporary Diagnosis by Practicing Veterinarians, and
more than half of them having a final diagnosis of primary inflammatory             Epidemiology [PhD dissertation]. University of Tennessee; 1996.
                                                                                 5. Schofield I, Woolhead V, Johnson A, Brodbelt DC, Church DB,
enteropathy and only 1 dog diagnosed with hypoadrenocorticism.
                                                                                    O'Neill DG. Hypoadrenocorticism in dogs under UK primary veteri-
    Our study had some limitations, mainly as a consequence of its ret-             nary care: frequency, clinical approaches and risk factors. J Small Anim
rospective design. Dogs selected in our study are not necessarily repre-            Pract. 2021;1–8:343-350.
sentative   of     the   general   population   of   dogs    with    chronic     6. Boag AM, Catchpole B. A review of the genetics of hypo-
                                                                                    adrenocorticism. Top Companion Anim Med. 2014;29:96-101.
gastrointestinal disease. Nineteen percent of dogs with resting cortisol
                                                                                 7. Agreed Language In Veterinary Endocrinology (ALIVE) Project Defini-
concentration <2 μg/dL (<55 nmol/L) did not have an ACTH stimula-                   tions; 2021. https://www.esve.org/alive/search.aspx. Accessed July
tion test performed. Six of 282 dogs (2.1%) did not have a final diagno-            2021.
sis and, of these, 1/5 did not have stimulation testing performed, and           8. Lyngby JG, Sellon RK. Hypoadrenocorticism mimicking protein-losing
                                                                                    enteropathy in 4 dogs. Can Vet J. 2016;57:757-760.
hypoadrenocorticism was not excluded. However, resting cortisol con-
                                                                                 9. Hauck C, Schmitz SS, Burgener IA, et al. Prevalence and characteriza-
centration in this patient was 1.92 μg/dL (53.2 nmol/L), close to the
                                                                                    tion of hypoadrenocorticism in dogs with signs of chronic gastrointes-
cutoff of 2 μg/dL (55 nmol/L) used to exclude hypoadrenocorticism.                  tinal disease: a multicenter study. J Vet Intern Med. 2020;34:1-7.
    In conclusion, prevalence of hypoadrenocorticism was 0.3% in a              10. Baumstark ME, Sieber-Ruckstuhl NS, Müller C, Wenger M,
referral population of dogs with chronic gastrointestinal signs, lower              Boretti FS, Reusch CE. Evaluation of aldosterone concentrations in
                                                                                    dogs with hypoadrenocorticism. J Vet Intern Med. 2013;28:154-159.
than in a previous study and closer to overall reported prevalence
                                                                                11. Klein SC, Peterson ME. Canine hypoadrenocorticism: part I. Can Vet J.
estimates of hypoadrenocorticism in the general canine population.                  2010;51:63-69.
Repeated resting cortisol concentration measurement excluded hypo-              12. Melian C, Peterson ME. Diagnosis and treatment of naturally occur-
adrenocorticism in 19/27 dogs with a second resting cortisol concen-                ring hypoadrenocorticism in 42 dogs. J Small Anim Pract. 1996;37:
                                                                                    268-275.
tration, meaning it could be of use as a test to exclude
                                                                                13. Bovens C, Tennant K, Reeve J, Murphy KF. Basal serum cortisol con-
hypoadrenocorticism, especially if ACTH is not available.                           centration as a screening test for hypoadrenocorticism in dogs. J Vet
                                                                                    Intern Med. 2014;28:1541-1545.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT                                                                  14. Gold AJ, Langlois DK, Refsal KR. Evaluation of basal serum or plasma
                                                                                    cortisol concentrations for the diagnosis of hypoadrenocorticism in
No funding was received for this study.
                                                                                    dogs. J Vet Intern Med. 2016;30:1798-1805.
                                                                                15. Lennon EM, Boyle TE, Hutchins RG, et al. Use of basal serum or
CONF LICT OF IN TE RE ST DEC LARAT ION                                              plasma cortisol concentrations to rule out a diagnosis of hypo-
Authors declare no conflict of interest.                                            adrenocorticism in dogs: 123 cases (2000–2005). J Am Vet Med Assoc.
                                                                                    2007;231:413-416.
                                                                                16. Volkmann M, Steiner JM, Fosgate GT, Zentek J, Hartmann S, Kohn B.
OFF- LABE L ANT IMICR OBIAL DE CLARAT ION                                           Chronic diarrhea in dogs—retrospective study in 136 cases. J Vet
Authors declare no off-label use of antimicrobials.                                 Intern Med. 2017;31:1043-1055.
                                                                                17. Wakayama JA, Furrow E, Merkel LK, Armstrong PJ. A retrospective
                                                                                    study of dogs with atypical hypoadrenocorticism: a diagnostic cut-off
INS TITUTIONAL ANIMAL CARE AND U SE C OMMITTEE
                                                                                    or continuum? J Small Anim Pract. 2017;58:365-371.
(IACUC) OR OTHER APPROVAL DECLARAT ION
                                                                                18. Thompson AL, Scott-Moncrieff JCR, Anderson JD. Comparison of
Authors declare no IACUC or other approval was needed.                              classic hypoadrenocorticism with glucocorticoid-deficient hypo-
                                                                                    adrenocorticism in dogs: 46 cases (1985-2005). J Am Vet Med Assoc.
HUMAN ETHICS APPROVAL DECLARATION                                                   2007;230(8):1190-1194.
                                                                                19. Lilliehöök I, Gunnarsson L, Zakrisson G, Tvedten H. Diseases associ-
Authors declare human ethics approval was not needed for this study.
                                                                                    ated with pronounced eosinophilia: a study of 105 dogs in Sweden.
                                                                                    J Small Anim Pract. 2000;41(6):248-253.
ORCID
Ana Fernandez Gallego       https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8290-7559
                                                                                SUPPORTING INF ORMATION
Alisdair M. Boag     https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3819-1821
                                                                                Additional supporting information may be found in the online version
                                                                                of the article at the publisher's website.
RE FE R ENC E S
 1. Scott-Moncrieff JC. Hypoadrenocorticism. In: Feldman EC,
    Nelson RW, Reusch C, et al., eds. Canine and Feline Endocrinology. 4th
                                                                                    How to cite this article: Gallego AF, Gow AG, Boag AM.
    ed. St Louis, MO: Elsevier; 2015:485-520.
 2. Hanson JM, Tengvall K, Bonnett BN, Hedhammar Å. Naturally occur-                Evaluation of resting cortisol concentration testing in dogs
    ring adrenocortical insufficiency—an epidemiological study based on a           with chronic gastrointestinal signs. J Vet Intern Med. 2022;1-7.
    Swedish-insured dog population of 525,028 dogs. J Vet Intern Med.               doi:10.1111/jvim.16365
    2016;30:76-84.