Consumer Equilibrium and Utility Analysis
Consumer Equilibrium and Utility Analysis
Class - XI
Consumer's Equilibrium and Demand – Notes
Who is a consumer?
The person who takes decisions about what to buy for the satisfaction of wants both as an individual
and as a member of a household is called a consumer.
A rational consumer
A consumer who seeks to maximize utility or satisfaction by spending his income on goods and
services is a rational consumer.
Meaning of Utility
Utility refers to the satisfaction, actual or expected, derived from consumption of a good. Utility
differs from person-to-person, place-to-place and time-to-time.
Total Utility (TU)
Total utility refers to the total satisfaction obtained from the consumption of all possible units of
a commodity.
It measures the total satisfaction obtained from consumption of all the units of that good.
TU = U1 +U2 + U3 +………..UN where U1 is the utility derived from the
first unit of the good, U2 from the second,
U3 from the third and so on.
Marginal Utility (MU)
Marginal utility is the additions to total utility when one more unit of the commodity is
consumed. It is the utility derived from the last unit of a commodity consumed.
MU is the rate of change in TU when one more unit is consumed or MU = ∆TU/∆Q Area
under the MU curve is TU
Utility Schedule
Units of X good Marginal Utility from X (Utils)
1 10
2 8
3 7
4 5
5 3
6 0
1
7 -1
The marginal utility from each unit of X keeps on declining as the consumer increases his
consumption from 1 unit to 7 units. MU is falling but positive from 1st unit till the 5th unit. At the 6th
unit the additions to total utility (MU) is zero. After the 6th unit, there is negative utility or disutility
from any more units consumed.
TU max.
TU falls
• When MU decreases but is positive, TU increases
TU increases at decreasing rate. (From 0 till the 4th unit)
at decreasing
rate
• When MU becomes zero, TU is
maximum.(at the 5th unit) This is called the
Point of Satiety
MU falls
but > 0
• When MU decreases and is negative, TU
Point of Satiety falls. (after the 5th unit)
MU =0
Consumer’s equilibrium – It refers to a situation when a consumer spends his income on the
purchase of a good (or combination of goods) in such a way that gives him maximum satisfaction
and he feels no urge to change.
Utility or Cardinal approach (It is assumed that utility or satisfaction can be measured cardinally
and expressed in quantitative terms i.e. in utils.)
• Single good case : When the consumer consumes only one good X. Condition 1:
MUx = Px
2
(Marginal utility of X in terms of money equals price of the good X)
Case 1: If MUx > Px then Marginal utility in terms of money is greater than the price of the good.
• Benefit received from the last unit consumed is more than cost for that unit, hence the
consumer will consume more of good X.
• As he consumes more of X, MUx declines (due to Law of DMU).
• This continues till MUx = Px and equilibrium is attained.
Case 2: If MUx < Px then Marginal utility in terms of money is less than the price of the good.
• Benefit received from the last unit consumed is less than cost for that unit, hence, the
consumer will consume less of good X.
• As he consumes less of X, MUx rises (due to Law of DMU).
• This continues till MUx = Px and equilibrium is attained.
• Two goods case : When the consumer consumes two goods X and Y
(Law of equi-marginal utility)
MUx = MUy
Condition 1: Px Py
(MU from last rupee spent on X equals MU from last rupee spent on of Y)
It means MU from last rupee spent on X is greater than MU from last rupee spent on Y.
• The consumer prefers good X to good Y.
• He will consume more of X and less of Y since income and prices are fixed.
• Due to Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility, MUx falls and MUy rises.
• This continues till MUx = MUy and equilibrium is restored.
Px Py
It means MU from last rupee spent on X is less than MU from last rupee spent on Y.
• The consumer prefers good Y to good X.
• He will consume less of X and more of Y since income and prices are fixed.
• Due to Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility, MUx rises and MUy falls.
• This continues till MUx = MUy and equilibrium is restored.
Px Py
If it does not hold true and MUx > MUy, then the consumer will end up spending all his income
Px Py
only on one good X and none on Y which is unrealistic and breaks the two-good assumption.
3
Cardinal Utility Vs Ordinal Utility
1. Under cardinal utility approach, it is assumed that utility can be measured in cardinal or
quantitative terms. According to ordinal approach, utility cannot be measured, and we can
just rank the consumer’s preferences.
2. Under cardinal approach, the term ‘util’ was developed as a unit to measure utility, whereas
no such unit of measurement was developed under ordinal approach.
Indiffference Curve Approach or Ordinal Approach
(It is based on the assumption that the consumer can rank his preferences)
Indifference Curve
It is a graphical representation of various combinations of bundles of two goods among which the
consumer is indifferent or which give the same level of satisfaction to the consumer.
4
If we have more and more of good X our desire to
have more good X will diminish and we will
forego less and less of good Y for good X
(MRSxy) =Δy/Δx
Indifference Map
Indifference map refers to the family of indifference
curves that represent consumer preferences over all the
bundles of two goods at different levels of satisfaction.
5
Budget Line: It is a graphical representation of all possible combinations of two goods X and Y that
the consumer can buy given income and prices, which costs the consumer exactly his income.
Slope of Budget Line (Market Rate of Exchange): It is the rate at which the consumer has to
sacrifice units of good Y to buy an additional unit of good X. MRE = (ΔY/ ΔX)
It is the ratio of prices of the two goods (X and Y) to be exchanged in the market (-) Px/Py
Px/Py is constant since prices are constant so the budget line is a straight line.
Determinants of Budget Line : Px, Py and M (prices of commodities and income of the consumer)
Budget Set – It is a set of different combinations of two goods X and Y that the consumer can
afford to buy, given income and prices of the goods.
Shifts in Budget line: The budget line shifts parallel outwards or inwards if income level changes.
(No change in slope); slope changes due to change in Px/Py. Budget Line shifts due to changes in Px,
Py, M or all three.
6
There is a parallel shift
rightwards of the Budget
Line in case of increase in
income keeping prices
constant. Fig (a)
downwards in case of an
increase in price of good Y
keeping price of good X and
7
Condition 1: MRS = Px / Py
(The rate at which the consumer is willing to sacrifice units of Y for obtaining an additional unit
of X equals the market requirement i.e ratio of prices of X and Y)
Condition 2: Indifference curves are strictly convex to the origin (MRS declines along the IC) to
avoid flat spots and have a unique equilibrium.
Demand: It refers to the quantity of a commodity that a consumer (or group of consumers taken
together) are willing and able to buy at a particular price during a given period of time.
It refers to the quantity of a good that a It refers to the quantity of a good that all consumer is
willing and able to buy at a given consumers taken together are willing and able price during a given
period of time. to buy at a given price during a given period of time.
8
Demand Function
It gives the functional relationship between demand for a good and the factors affecting demand.
1) Own price of the commodity: There exists an inverse relationship between price and quantity
demanded of a commodity keeping all other factors affecting demand constant. It means, as
price increases, quantity demanded falls. For example, If price of given commodity (say, tea)
increases, its quantity demanded will fall . This relation is given by the Law of Demand.
The following determinants are termed as 'other factors' or factors other than own price.
2) Price of related goods: Related goods are the goods in which change in price of one good (say,
x) causes a change in the demand for other good (say, y). Related goods are of two types:
(a) Substitute Goods: Substitute goods are those goods which can be used in place of one
another for satisfaction of a particular want.
• An increase in the price of substitute good makes the given good relatively cheaper in
comparison to its substitute and so leads to an increase in the demand for given good.
• A decrease in the price of substitute good makes the given good relatively costlier in
comparison to its substitute and so leads to a decrease in the demand for given good.
For example: If price of a substitute good (say, coffee) increases, then demand for given
good (say, tea) will rise as tea will become relatively cheaper in comparison to coffee. So,
demand for a given good is directly affected by change in price of substitute goods. Hence
, there is a direct relationship between the price of substitute good and demand for the
given good.
(b) Complementary Goods: Complementary goods are those goods which are used jointly to
satisfy a particular want.
• An increase in the price of complementary good makes the joint consumption of the
given good with the complementary good costlier which leads to a decrease in the
demand for the given good.
• A decrease in the price of complementary good makes the joint consumption of the
given good with the complementary good cheaper which leads to an increase in the
demand for the given good.
For example: If price of a complementary good (say, sugar) increases, then demand for
given good (say, tea) will fall as it will be relatively costlier to use both the goods together.
Hence , there is an inverse relationship between the price of complementary good and
demand for the given good.
3) Income of the consumer: The effect of change in income on demand depends on the nature of
the commodity under consideration.
(a) Normal Good: Normal goods refer to those goods whose demand increases with increase in
income (or whose demand decreases with decrease in income) of the consumer.
9
• There is a direct relationship between income of the consumer and demand for the
normal good. For example: If with an increase in income of the consumer, demand for
wheat rises, it is a normal good for the consumer.
(b) Inferior Good: Inferior goods refer to those goods whose demand decreases with increase
in income (or whose demand increases with decrease in income) of the consumer.
• There is an inverse relationship between income of the consumer and demand for the
inferior good. For example: If with an increase in income of the consumer, demand for
Bajra falls, it is an inferior good for the consumer.
4) Tastes and preferences: Tastes and preferences of the consumer directly influence the demand
for a commodity. They include changes in fashion, customs, habits, etc.
• If there is a favourable change in tastes and preferences, then the demand for such a
commodity rises.
• On the other hand, demand for a commodity falls, if there is an unfavourable change in
tastes and preferences for the commodity.
5) Expectation of change in price in future: If the price of a good is expected to rise in future,
people will buy more of the good in the current period. For example: If price of petrol is
expected to rise in future, its present demand will increase.
(a) Size and Composition of Population: Market demand for a commodity is affected by size of
population in the country. An increase in population raises the market demand, while a
decrease in population reduces the market demand for a commodity. Composition of
population, i.e. ratio of males, females, children and number of old people in the population
also affects the demand for a commodity. For example: If a market has larger proportion of
women, then there will be greater demand for articles of use for women such as women’s
clothes, cosmetics etc.
(b) Distribution of Income: If income distribution is in favour of the rich, there will be more
demand for luxuries while if the income distribution is in favour of the poor, necessities would
be demanded more.
Law of Demand
The law of demand states that there is an inverse relationship between change in price of a good and
the consequent change in quantity demanded for that good, keeping all other factors affecting
demand constant (ceteris paribus).
‘Other factors’ refer to the income of the consumer, price of related goods (prices of substitute and
complementary goods) and consumer’s tastes and preferences.
Reason behind the Law of Demand
Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility – Since the marginal utility declines as a consumer consumes
more units of a good, he will be willing to pay a price equal to the marginal utility derived from that
unit of good. (MUx = Px). Thus, he will demand more units only at a lower price.
Proving the Law of Demand using Utility Approach
10
Now if the price of X falls,
Then, MUx > Px i.e. Marginal utility in terms of money is greater than the price of the good.
• Benefit received from the last unit consumed is more than cost for that unit, hence the
consumer will consume more of good X.
• As he consumes more of X, MUx declines (due to Law of DMU).
• This continues till MUx = Px and equilibrium is attained.
Conversely, if the price of X rises, less of X is demanded.
Hence, as price falls, more of X is demanded showing an inverse relationship between price
and quantity demanded of a commodity which proves the Law of Demand
Hence, as price falls, more of X is demanded showing an inverse relationship between price
and quantity demanded of a commodity which proves the Law of Demand
11
700
Price of Coffee Quantity (kg)
600 (` per kg)
P2 Q2
500 700 30
P1 Q1
600 40
P3
Q3
500 50 30
40 50
As price falls from ` 600 to ` 500, quantity demanded rises from 40 units to 50 units. As price rises
from ` 600 to ` 700, quantity demanded falls from 40 units to 30 units. This shows an inverse
relationship between price and quantity demanded of a commodity keeping all other factors
constant.
A B C D A D
Market demand curve is flatter than the individual demand curves. It happens because as price
changes, proportionate change in market demand is more than proportionate change in individual
demand.
12
Slope of Demand Curve
Slope of a curve is defined as the change in the variable on the Y-axis divided by the change in the
variable on the X-axis. So, the slope of the demand curve equals the Change in Price divided by the
Change in Quantity demanded.
• The demand curve is generally downward sloping showing an inverse relationship between price
and quantity demanded of a commodity. So, slope is Negative.
• Slope of the demand curve measures the flatness or steepness of the demand curve.
When price rises from `20 to `25, quantity demanded falls from 100
units to 70 units , resulting in an upward movement from A to B along the same demand curve
DD.
13
Shifts of demand curve (Change in demand)
It refers to a change in demand of a good caused by a change in any of the factors affecting demand
other than own price of the commodity.
14
Types of movements Types of shifts
15
15, )
• When price rises from `20 to ` quantity • At the same price `20,, demand
demand falls
rise from
demanded falls from 70 to 50 70to 100 units due to
units. Less is demanded at a higher other
in any of the factors affecting demand
price. (Contraction of demand than own price. More is demanded at the Less
same price. (Increase in demand
• When price falls from `20 to ` • At the same price `20 to 50 units due to
quantity demanded rises from 70 to 100 70unfavourable changes
units. More is demanded at a lesser in any of the factors affecting demand
price. (Expansion of demand) than own price. (Decrease in demand) is
demanded at the same price.
Increase in demand
Upward movement Rightward shift
Contraction of demand
Downward
movement
Expansion of demand
Decrease in demand
Leftward shift
O O
• A movement upwards along the same • A rightward shift of the demand curve from
demand curve is due to a rise in own price D to D1 is due to favourable changes in any
of the commodity from OP1 to OP3, keeping of the other factors affecting demand keeping
all other factors affecting demand constant. own price constant at OP.(Increase in
(Contraction in demand from OQ1 to OQ3) demand from OQ to OQ1)
• A movement downwards is due to a fall in • A leftward shift of the demand curve is due
own price of the commodity from OP1 to to unfavourable changes in any of the other
OP2 keeping all other factors affecting factors affecting demand keeping own price
demand constant. (Expansion in demand constant at OP. (Decrease in demand from
from OQ1 to OQ2) OQ to OQ2)
Contraction in Demand (Decrease in Quantity Demanded) Vs Decrease in Demand
Contraction in Demand Decrease in Demand
(Decrease in Quantity Demanded)
It refers to a fall in quantity demanded( of a good
due to an increase in own price, keeping all It refers to a fall in the demand of a commodity
other factors affecting demand constant. caused due to an unfavourable change in any of the
factors affecting demand other than own price of the
commodity.
For example: Due to unfavorable change in the other
factors like decrease in the prices of substitutes.
increase in the prices of complementary goods,
decrease in income of the consumer in case of
normal goods, unfavourable change in tastes and
preferences of the consumer etc.
Price Quantity Price Quantity any of
20 100 20 100 than own price
16
25 70 , quantity 20 70
The price elasticity of demand for a good is defined as the percentage change in quantity
demanded for the good divided by the percentage change in its price.
Where:
1. Change in Quantity (∆Q) = Q1 - Q0.
2. Change in Price (∆P) = P1 - P0
3. Percentage change in Quantity demanded = Change in Quantity (∆Q) x 100
Initial Quantity (Q)
4. Percentage change in Price = Change in Price (∆P) x 100
Initial Price (P)
For example: If price elasticity of demand is (-) 2, it means that one percent fall in price leads to 2
percent rise in demand or one percent rise in price leads to 2 percent fall in demand.
17
The value of price elasticity of demand (Ed) is always negative because of the inverse relationship
between change in price and change in quantity demanded.
O O
When the percentage change When the percentage change in When the percentage change in
in quantity demanded is zero, quantity demanded quantity demanded is equal to
no matter how price is is infinite even if the percentage change in price. In
changed, the demand is said to percentage change in price is a rectangular hyperbola, area
be perfectly inelastic. zero, the demand is said to of rectangles formed under the
be perfectly elastic. Infinite curve are equal i.e expenditure
demand at given price. (PxQ) remains same.
2) Number of substitutes : More is the number of substitutes of a good, more is its price elasticity
of demand.
18
• The reason is that even a small rise in its price will induce the buyers to shift the demand to
its substitutes. For example: A rise in the price of Pepsi encourages buyers to buy Coke
and vice-versa.
• Commodities with few or no substitutes like wheat and salt have less elastic or inelastic
demand.
3) Number of uses: More is the number of uses of a good, more is the price elasticity of demand.
• When price of such a commodity increases, its number of uses can be reduced, thus
reducing its demand. When its price falls, the number of uses it is put to, can be increased,
thus increasing its demand.
• For example: Milk can be put to many uses like making cheese, butter, curd, icecreams or
drinking as it is and so on. In case of a rise in price of milk, some of these uses can be cut
down, thereby reducing its demand, while in case of a price fall, it can be put to more
number of uses, thus increasing its demand. Thus, demand for milk is elastic.
4) Income level: Higher is income level more inelastic will be the demand for any commodity.
• It happens because rich people are not affected much by changes in the price of goods. But
poor people with lesser incomes are highly affected by a change in the price of goods as it
will affect their budget significantly. As a result, demand for lower income group is highly
elastic.
6) Time period: More is the time period, more will be the price elasticity of demand.
• Demand is generally inelastic when the time period is short. It happens because consumers
find it difficult to change their habits, in the short period, in order to respond to a change in
the price of the given commodity.
• However, demand is more elastic in the long-run as it is comparatively easier to shift to
other substitutes if the price of the given commodity rises.
Recap
• Utility refers to the satisfaction, actual or expected, derived from consumption of a good.
• Total utility refers to the total satisfaction obtained from the consumption of all possible units of
a commodity.
• Marginal utility is the additions to total utility when one more unit of the commodity is
consumed.
• Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility states that as the consumer consumes more and more units
of a commodity the additions to total utility (i.e marginal utility) ) derived from each successive
unit consumed keeps on decreasing.
• Consumer’s equilibrium refers to a situation when a consumer spends his income on the
purchase of a good (or combination of goods) in such a way that gives him maximum satisfaction
and he feels no urge to change.
• Indifference curve is a graphical representation of various combinations of bundles of two goods
among which the consumer is indifferent or which give the same level of satisfaction to the
consumer.
19
• Marginal Rate of Substitution is the rate at which the consumer is willing to sacrifice one good
in order get an additional unit of the other good without affecting total utility.
• Properties of indifference curves Downward sloping left to right
Strictly convex to the origin
Higher indifference curve represents higher level of utility
• Budget Line is a graphical representation of all possible combinations of two goods X and Y that
the consumer can buy given income and prices, which costs the consumer exactly his income.
Px.X + Py.Y = M
• The consumer’s equilibrium is located at the point of tangency between the budget line and an
indifference curve where MRS = Px/Py
• Law of Demand states the inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded of a
commodity, keeping all other factors affecting demand constant (ceteris paribus).
• The demand curve is generally downward sloping showing an inverse relationship between price
and quantity demanded of a commodity.
• Movement along demand curve occurs, when the quantity demanded changes due to a change in
its own price, keeping other factors affecting demand constant.
• Shift in demand curve occurs when the demand changes due to change in any factor other than
the own price of the commodity,
• Substitute goods are those goods which can be used in place of one another for satisfaction of a
particular want. For example: Tea and Coffee.
• Complementary goods are those goods which are used together to satisfy a particular want. For
example: Tea and Sugar.
• The demand for a normal good increases (decreases) with increase (decrease) in the consumer’s
income. The demand for an inferior good decreases (increases) as the income of the consumer
increases (decreases).
• The price elasticity of demand for a good is defined as the percentage change in quantity
demanded for the good divided by the percentage change in its price. The elasticity of demand is
a pure number.
• Factors affecting Price Elasticity of Demand
(a) Nature of the commodity (b) Number of substitutes.
(c) Income Level (d) Number of uses
(e) Proportion of income spent on a commodity (f) Time Period
20