Future Focus 2025
Pathways for Progress from
the Network of Global Future
Councils 2020–2022
INSIGHT REPORT
JUNE 2022
                              Images: Getty Images, Unsplash
                              Contents
                              Preface                                            3
                              Executive summary                                  4
                              1 Economy                                          5
                                  1.1 Economic growth and recovery               6
                                  1.2 Fiscal and monetary policy                10
                                  1.3 Investing                                 14
                                  1.4 Responsive financial systems              19
                                  1.5 Risk resilience                           23
                                  1.6 Trade and investment                      27
                                  1.7 Transparency and anti-corruption          31
                              2 Environment                                     35
                                  2.1 Clean air                                 36
                                  2.2 Clean electrification                     40
                                  2.3 Energy transition                         44
                                  2.4 Nature-based solutions                    48
                                  2.5 Net-zero transition                       52
                                  2.6 SDG investment                            56
Disclaimer
The findings,                     2.7 Sustainable tourism                       60
interpretations and
conclusions expressed         3 Society                                         64
herein are a result of a
collaborative process             3.1 Education and skills                      65
facilitated and endorsed
by the World Economic             3.2 Equity and social justice                 69
Forum, but whose
results do not necessarily
                                  3.3 Human rights                              73
represent the views of
                                  3.4 Mental health                             76
the World Economic
Forum, or the entirety of         3.5 New agenda for fragility and resilience   79
its Members, Partners
or other stakeholders,            3.6 Social cohesion and just transition       83
or the individual Global
Future Council members            3.7 Work, wages and job creation              86
listed as contributors,
or their organizations.       4 Technology                                      90
This document is a
contribution to the World
                                  4.1 Advanced manufacturing and value chains   91
Economic Forum’s
                                  4.2 Agile governance                          95
insight and interaction
activities and is published       4.3 Artificial intelligence for humanity      99
to elicit comments
and further debate.               4.4 Media, entertainment and sport            104
© 2022 World Economic             4.5 Quantum computing                         106
Forum. All rights reserved.
No part of this publication       4.6 Scientific collaboration                  112
may be reproduced
                                  4.7 Space                                     116
or transmitted in any
form or by any means,             4.8 Synthetic biology                         120
including photocopying
and recording, or by          Contributors                                      124
any information storage
and retrieval system.         Endnotes                                          126
                                                                                      Future Focus 2025   2
June 2022   Future Focus 2025
            Pathways for Progress
            from the Network of
            Global Future Councils
            2020–2022
            Preface
            The World Economic Forum Network of Global             and policies needed to address economic,
            Future Councils promotes innovative thinking to        environmental, social and technological
            shape a more inclusive, resilient and sustainable      challenges and opportunities through to 2025.
            future. The network comprises nearly 1,000 top
            thinkers who provide foresight, generate insights      This report draws from and supports the Forum’s
            and identify potential solution frameworks for the     platforms dedicated to catalysing a new economy
            world’s most pressing challenges.                      and society, accelerating action for people and
                                                                   the planet, leveraging Fourth Industrial Revolution
            This Insight Report shares the outcomes of             technologies, stewarding industry transformations
            multistakeholder dialogues organized by nearly         and enhancing global and regional cooperation.
            30 of the Global Future Councils of the 2020-          These platforms and their stakeholders work with
            2022 term between October 2021 and January             the Council experts and use the insights from
            2022.1 The dialogues engaged Council members           this report to shape their agendas for tackling the
            to define interdisciplinary perspectives on a vision   world’s greatest challenges and embedding greater
            for 2025 in their domain area and to offer insights    resilience and cooperation.
            on the important transitions and the essential
            actions required to drive progress and achieve         Since early 2022, the world finds itself in a new
            their vision.                                          geopolitical crisis. In such challenging times, it
                                                                   is imperative that the global community reflect
            Given the timing of these dialogues, the post-         on areas for cooperation and work towards an
            pandemic recovery occupies an important space          inclusive, resilient and sustainable future. It is
            in the Council visions. It is an inspiring agenda      hoped that these pages can provide a reminder
            around which a sustainable recovery can be             of the opportunity space for collaboration and the
            built and an important guide for the partnerships      pathways to get there.
                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025     3
Executive summary
The global economy has demonstrated significant           Chapter 2 on environmental matters proposes
resilience through the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet             avenues, strategies and policy frameworks for
societies, the global economy and the planet              advancing towards the net-zero transition by mid-
face unprecedented challenges and disruptions             century, seizing opportunities to foster cleaner air
that remain urgent and require an unprecedented           and clean electrification, to support the energy
transformation of the world’s economic,                   transition, to leverage nature-positive business
environmental and social systems. This is evidenced       practices and to nurture sustainable tourism.
by the recent geopolitical crisis that emerged not
long after these Council visions were finalized in the    Chapter 3 on social matters covers vital aspects
spring of 2022. Such a shock is a reminder that           of what a new social contract should embrace
while one crisis may be at the forefront at any given     in relation to education and skills, equity and
time, it is imperative that the global community          social justice, mental health and social cohesion,
remember to explore a wide variety of issues in the       and work wages and job creation. It emphasizes
longer term to ensure the overall health of society       avenues that will support the creation of more
and its readiness for the next change.                    inclusive economic and social outcomes, human
                                                          rights and the humanitarian and development
As compound global risks continue to evolve,              needs of fragile communities.
setting a sustainable, inclusive growth agenda
with clearly defined visions, pathways and                Chapter 4 on technological matters explores
partnerships will become the key to future                how to harness technological advances for
prosperity. Given the interdependencies of global         social progress, while supporting responsible
issues, nations and organizations cannot address          and equitable transitions into the digital future.
them in isolation. Instead, they require effective        It highlights measures to design digital-ready
public- and private-sector cooperation to set the         policies, deploy and scale up frontier technologies
ambition and address them in a more holistic way          for the benefit of people and the planet, and
through partnerships and policy.                          new opportunities for data commons and
                                                          collaboration in scientific research and space.
This Insight Report covers four thematic areas where
important transitions and essential action are required   Progress across these four areas holds the
to drive progress: the economy, environment, society      potential for achieving a sustainable and inclusive
and technology. It is not intended as a blueprint but     future. The visions for 2025 and the pathways
rather as a framework around which a positive and         proposed in this report are drawn from the
inspiring agenda can be built.                            insights of pre-eminent thought leaders in the
                                                          World Economic Forum Network of Global Future
Chapter 1 on economic matters looks at tools that         Councils and are laid out for reflection and action
policy-makers may deploy to build a more resilient,       by public- and private-sector decision-makers to
sustainable and inclusive economy, including fiscal       drive much-needed progress.
and monetary policies, specific types of and strategies
for investment, and resilience to global risks.
                                                                                          Future Focus 2025      4
1   Economy
1.1   Economic growth
      and recovery
      Bold government action can unleash private-
      sector initiatives to create new markets
      that will solve today’s biggest challenges.
      Governments will need to play a driving role in             of many technologies and business models, the
      orienting markets towards this transformation.              current economic and socio-technical systems
      The goal in several industries is to develop and            remain environmentally unsustainable.
      mainstream a new set of products, services and
      business models that provide solutions to the           –   Health crises. COVID-19 has highlighted the
      problems that societies face today.2                        importance of the timely development of, and
                                                                  open access to, new medical solutions to
      –   Increased inequality. The distribution of wealth        address both new and existing health crises.
          and income has become unsustainably unequal
          over past decades, leading to social tensions       The response to the COVID-19 pandemic
          and polarization and decreasing economic            represents one of the pivotal moments in history
          resilience in many countries.                       when radical change is possible, and societies have
                                                              been forced to question existing paradigms. Similar
      –   Climate change and environmental                    moments in the past enabled governments to lay
          degradation. In spite of the increased efficiency   new foundations for long-term, shared prosperity.3
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   6
                     Vision 2025
                     Economic transformation will depend on creating         about the role of government in the economy
                     new, inclusive and sustainable markets. The             remains focused on how big it should be rather
                     development of new niches into scaled markets goes      than on how bold. A new narrative on the role of
                     through three main phases: 1) design, research and      the public sector is needed, away from that of
                     development; 2) demonstration and experiments;          burdensome bureaucracy to one of market co-
                     and 3) market scale-up. The first phase can be          creator. This will in turn make public employment
                     focused on creating new institutional and societal      more attractive to the right type of talent.5
                     models as much as new products, technologies
                     and business models. This process must be cyclical      Only the combined efforts of the public and
                     and generative, with demonstrations and markets         private sectors will be able to transform techno-
                     feeding back to further design and development          economic paradigms and bring better and
                     for the healthy evolution of the ecosystem.4            broader growth. Yet public-private partnerships
                                                                             around innovation and market creation have
                     Accelerating progress in these three phases of          often been too unbalanced, and the benefits
                     market creation requires a new vision of how the        of successful projects have not been fairly
                     public and private sectors can work together to drive   distributed within the population.6
                     economic transformation.
                                                                             Innovation in governance has been slower
  A new narrative
                                                                             than innovation in technology and business
on the role of the
public sector is     Unleashing private-sector                               models. Addressing the growing tension
                                                                             between techno-economic systems – the way
needed, away from    initiative                                              economic value is produced and the incentives
that of burdensome                                                           that shape markets – and institutions – the
bureaucracy to       Over the past few decades, many advanced                set of values, formal and informal rules and
one of market        economies have progressively disinvested in the         beliefs shared in communities – will be key for
co-creator.          capabilities of their public sector. The debate         building stronger public-private partnerships.7
                     Turning today’s                                         declining competition levels could prevent the
                                                                             incumbents from effectively positioning themselves
                     challenges into the                                     in the most promising new markets. It is important
                     markets of tomorrow                                     to look at the political economy behind the choice
                                                                             of the innovation pathways: while government
                                                                             support is vital, it is too often co-opted to serve
                     Today’s economic transformation builds on               incumbent sectors.
                     the scientific and technological developments
                     of years past. Only a patient approach to               The creation of new markets often requires
                     innovation financing can deliver a continuous           a parallel approach on supply and demand.
                     pipeline of new discoveries that can shape              New products might struggle to find a space
                     tomorrow’s markets in the direction needed,             in the market even when they present superior
                     protecting people and the planet.                       characteristics, especially if they represent a
                                                                             transformation in complementary know-how,
                     With the need to provide for a long-term pipeline       infrastructure and other sunk costs. Governments
                     of R&D comes the tremendous opportunity to              can support the demand for key products, but
                     accelerate the uptake across different contexts,        transformative change often requires a change in
                     sectors and geographies of products and                 behaviour by entire communities, and a coordinated
                     technologies that are already mature. In all sectors,   shift by actors, regimes and institutions.8
                                                                                                            Future Focus 2025      7
                     Pathways to Vision 2025
                     Investing within public                                   –   Establish a new legal blueprint for patents
                                                                                   and other IP. The need is to balance
                     administrations to develop                                    private incentives and public interest for
                     dynamic capabilities and capacity                             transparency and the diffusion of knowledge.
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:9    –   Rebalance risks and rewards. One way
                                                                                   is to focus on specific cases where the
                     –   Encourage a new approach to public                        government provides support for research,
                         administration. This encouragement can be,                for example through equity stakes or golden
                         for example, supporting an approach based                 shares of IP rights.
                         on experimentation and learning-by-doing.
                                                                               –   Develop initiatives that can diffuse knowledge
                     –   Establish new norms of sharing rewards                    and IP. Specific challenges can be addressed
                         and develop skills in the public sector.                  through pools, pledges or mandatory licensing.
                         Adopting norms in terms of portfolio-
                         setting and risk-taking, coherently and               –   Increase scrutiny of anti-competitive
                         with an approach to public investment as                  practices. It is important, most notably, to
                         the investment of first resort, is needed.                address patent trolls through dedicated
                                                                                   legislation and changes in the breadth of
                     –   Design new metrics to evaluate public                     coverage granted to IP.
                         investments. This involves capturing the
                         dynamic spillovers that occur with bold
                         policies, which are hard to capture with static       Rethinking value
                         cost–benefit and net present value analyses.
                     –   Limit the outsourcing of key capabilities.            Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:11
                         Ramping up investment within the public
                         sector will enable it to become more capable          –   Scale hybrid methodologies for innovation. For
                         and develop “absorptive capacity”.                        example, social impact ventures, which better align
                                                                                   economic and societal value, embed a different
                                                                                   approach to governance and transparency.
                     Building symbiotic public-
  Shifting                                                                     –   Adapt the measurement and accounting
                     private partnerships                                          frameworks used to account for economic
practices and
behaviours within                                                                  value. This can be done at both the micro and
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:10       macro levels by assigning a proper value to
companies towards
                                                                                   parts of the economy in which prices do not fully
lower carbon         –   Introduce conditionalities for public                     reflect their economic and societal contribution.
emissions, better        investments, subsidies, guarantees and
working conditions       bailouts. Shifting practices and behaviours           –   Pilot new solutions and public-private
and fewer share          within companies towards lower carbon                     governance models. This entails embedding
buybacks is              emissions, better working conditions                      societal values in the development of new
central.                 and fewer share buybacks is central.                      technologies and business models.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025       8
Increasing patient investment                                 to prioritize those that do not get attention
                                                              from current investors and industries.
in mission-driven research
                                                          –   Shift government support. That support
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:12       should move from incumbent players and
                                                              sectors to new entrants.
–   Set up dedicated vehicles through public
    funding. Examples include national investment         –   Encourage partnerships among businesses,
    banks or innovation funds specialized in the              including small and medium-sized
    provision of long-term funding (10-plus years).           enterprises (SMEs). One means is to create
                                                              alignment on common production and
–   Create urgency on missions of vital                       innovation challenges, pool knowledge and
    importance in the long term. A good place                 diffuse benefits.
    to start is by ensuring that governments,
    businesses and civil society agree on the             –   Use demonstration effects. Possibilities
    statement of a problem, and highlighting                  include inspiring local producers and helping
    the fundamental threat it might pose to                   localize global solutions through pilots
    society and developing a clear plan.                      and prototypes.
–   Rewire private investments. This involves
    building on the growing success of                    Co-creating demand
    environmental, social and governance (ESG)
    principles and embedding patience much
    more strongly in the incentive mechanisms             Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:14
    that drive the decisions of funds and investors,
    throughout the full spectrum that includes            –   Change relative prices. This is possible, for
    venture capitalists and philanthropists.                  example, through taxes, subsidies or other
                                                              forms of economic incentives.
–   Strengthen available metrics. This includes
    adding qualitative dimensions, such as the time       –   Ensure initial market demand. This can occur,
    horizon of R&D projects, to existing indicators           for example, through public procurement, public
    in ESG standards and national statistics.                 works or other forms of direct public spending.
                                                          –   Align leading stakeholders, most importantly
Scaling up the production                                     governments. Building consensus on politically
                                                              feasible solutions that are a win-win within the
of goods, services and                                        broader ecosystem is key.
technologies of tomorrow
                                                          –   Work with communities to co-shape the
                                                              broader techno-economic system. Efforts
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:13       can influence their behaviours, preferences
                                                              and perceptions.
–   Strengthen supply. Subsidies, capital grants,
    government loans and other tools can help             –   Establish clear KPIs and rigorous assessment.
    new entrants and trigger economies of scale.              Assessing the relative performance of goods and
                                                              services brought to the market is critical.
–   Target specific market niches that can help
    address future challenges. It is important
1.2   Fiscal and
      monetary policy
      Public spending will need to become more
      pro-poor and provide the necessary public
      goods for sustainable inclusive growth.
      Pandemic-induced lockdowns and the                         –   Growing public- and private-sector debt.
      ensuing global recession have created a highly                 The rapid build-up of debt across many
      uncertain global outlook. Policy-makers are                    economies is among the key challenges
      challenged to recalibrate their priorities and                 policy-makers face as they look ahead to
      restructure their support by designing the right               the post-pandemic economy. With higher
      environment to shape fairer, more inclusive                    debt levels, small increases in interest rates
      and sustainable economies and societies.15                     can have a lasting impact on their fiscal
                                                                     sustainability, while also mechanically reducing
      Three main trends are shaping the global agenda                the fiscal leeway to respond to future crises.
      for fiscal and monetary policy:
                                                                 –   Intensifying climate imperative. According to
      –   Widening inequalities and divergent                        recent IMF estimates, GHG emissions are
          recoveries. Pandemic-induced lockdowns                     still projected to rise by about 20% by 2030
          and divergent recoveries on the back of                    under the most conservative scenario.18
          uneven vaccination coverage have created a                 Among all the announced fiscal packages
          highly uncertain and uneven global outlook.                since the beginning of the pandemic, only a
          Globalization is stalling, social capital is               limited share was allocated to climate-positive
          eroded by increasing inequality and political              measures. The global net climate impact of
          polarization, and the still-unfolding economic             these measures remains negative.19 Although
          crisis is threatening the livelihoods of billions of       several economies have already implemented
          people.16 Close to 95 million more people are              or are scheduled to implement carbon pricing
          estimated to have fallen below the threshold of            initiatives, these initiatives only account for
          extreme poverty in 2020 compared with pre-                 22.3% of the estimated global GHGs.20
          pandemic projections, reversing a two-decade-
          long trend of global poverty reduction.17
                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025   10
                      Vision 2025
                      Building back broader                                      through the social contract, which is crucial to
                                                                                 the long-term accountability of governments.23
                      High inequality within and across countries was            Tax systems need to be redesigned to achieve
                      already a major challenge before the pandemic              more efficient taxation on capital, in part to level
                      – a trend exacerbated by the pandemic. Despite             the playing field for smaller businesses and to rein
                      extraordinary policy support, the employment and           in monopoly power. International coordination
                      earnings effects of the pandemic have been highly          on tax matters is needed now more than ever,
                      unequal, disproportionately affecting disadvantaged        especially to deal with pressing challenges regarding
                      populations. Furthermore, the low coverage of              the taxation of multinational enterprises and tax
                      existing social insurance systems is still a significant   evasion by individuals using offshore accounts.
                      obstacle that prevents the prompt provision of             The highest priority in international tax coordination
                      lifelines to households that are most in need.             is with respect to climate change – where global
                                                                                 externalities have drastic consequences.
                      Public spending will need to become more pro-
                      poor and provide the necessary public goods for
                      sustainable inclusive growth. In the near term,            Rethinking the division of
                      international cooperation, including financial
                      support, is also crucial to ensure that vaccines,
                                                                                 labour between fiscal and
                      treatments and medical supplies are distributed            monetary policy
                      quickly and fairly across all countries.21 The uneven
                      access to vaccines and limited ability to mount an
                      appropriate policy response are setting back the           The current economic downturn raises questions
                      development prospects of lower-income countries.           about the division of labour between monetary and
                                                                                 fiscal policies. A fundamental reassessment of the
                                                                                 scope and roles of fiscal and monetary policy is
                      Transforming local and global                              required. The new framework needs to enhance
                                                                                 coordination between different policy tools during
                      tax architecture                                           recessions as well as recoveries. This implies
                                                                                 that, when fiscal space is available, fiscal policy
                      By designing more progressive taxation                     will need to play a greater role in supporting the
                      mechanisms, the tax burden can be shifted                  economy while ensuring independent monetary
                      from the bottom to the top and provide a higher            policy to anchor inflation expectations during
   A fundamental      tax base for revenue mobilization (especially in           periods of rising inflation. Furthermore, despite
reassessment of       countries with lower tax capacity) and contribute to       the effectiveness of current monetary policy tools
the scope and         financing social spending and structural reform.22         in maintaining liquidity and stability, monetary
roles of fiscal and   People and households on lower incomes should              policy alone cannot bring in the necessary
monetary policy       not be removed from the tax system, however,               structural transformations to build fairer, more
is required.          since inclusion here is linked to political citizenship    equitable and sustainable economies.24
                                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025   11
                       Pathways to Vision 2025
   Expanding           Strengthening automatic                                 Investing in human capital and
coverage of access     stabilizers and safety nets                             fostering social mobility
to automatic
stabilizers in the
social insurance       Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
systems should be
                       –   Broaden the coverage of formal social               –   Bridge the education and skills gap. UNICEF
a key goal of social
                           insurance. Between March 2020 and May                   reports that schoolchildren worldwide have
protection reforms         2021, over 3,330 social protection measures             lost an estimated 1.8 trillion hours of in-person
in the future.             were planned or implemented in 222 countries            learning due to COVID-19 lockdowns.30
                           or territories.25 Wage subsidies, cash transfers,       According to the International Monetary Fund
                           training measures or extending coverage of              (IMF), “Learning losses [are] especially large in
                           unemployment benefits have all been crucial             emerging market and developing economies
                           tools to protect the most vulnerable populations        and for children from poorer families and rural
                           during the pandemic. Of this spectrum, social           areas lacking access to digital infrastructure.”31
                           insurance and automatic stabilizers have                Unless forceful remedial actions are put in
                           several advantages,26 protecting families               place, the pandemic could result in a brutal
                           from the shock and supporting aggregate                 reversal of past gains. Improving education
                           consumption. However, currently a mere 30.6%            access, digital infrastructure and early childhood
                           of the working-age population is legally covered        development will be crucial to ensure individuals
                           by comprehensive social security system                 have more equal opportunities to acquire skills
                           benefits.27 Thus, expanding coverage of access          and improve social mobility. Also according to
                           to automatic stabilizers in the social insurance        the IMF, “Tax policy can affect incentives for
                           systems should be a key goal of social                  human capital investment, especially in one’s
                           protection reforms in the future.                       children. Particularly in countries with more
                                                                                   developed tax systems, child tax credits to
                       –   Expand the use of adaptive social protection            lower-income households can have large effects
                           mechanisms. Given the low coverage of                   on children’s school attendance, performance
                           automatic stabilizers especially in low- and            and future earnings.”32
                           middle-income countries, many families will
                           not be able to rely on them for the foreseeable     –   Support lifelong learning initiatives.
                           future, hence the importance of introducing             The public sector needs to increase support
                           social protection mechanisms that adapt to              for the reskilling and upskilling of at-risk
                           the nature of systemic shocks so that they can          or displaced workers in the midst of job
                           enhance the capacity to prepare, cope with and          transitions. Workers must urgently be
                           adapt to future shocks.28 Targeted cash transfer        encouraged to develop their skills throughout
                           programmes tend to have the most significant            their career while the public sector must
                           effect of all social assistance programmes in           decisively tackle long-delayed improvements
                           reducing poverty and can improve human capital          to education and training systems.33
                           accumulation and help households to smooth
                           out income shocks, reducing future inequality.29
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   12
   Stimulus         Embedding environmental                                 Creating progressive, efficient
programmes          sustainability in policy-making                         and fairer fiscal systems
should focus on
measures such
as tax incentives   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
and investments
                    –   Reduce long-term support to carbon-                 –   Improve the progressivity fiscal mechanisms.
in low-carbon,
                        intensive industries. Stimulus programmes               These include increasing top marginal income
energy efficient        should focus on measures such as tax                    and capital gains tax rates, which have
infrastructures,        incentives and investments in low-carbon,               declined in recent decades,37 and reforming
green R&D and           energy efficient infrastructures, green R&D             tax deductions that predominantly benefit
climate-smart           and climate-smart technologies.34 Facilitating          higher incomes. Inheritance/gift taxes and
technologies.           a green economic transformation will also               property taxation should also be considered.
                        entail a shift of workers away from carbon-             The introduction or expansion of value-added
                        intensive and environmentally destructive               taxes should be treated with caution. Although
                        production processes and towards jobs that              it can effectively raise revenues from domestic
                        help reduce GHG emissions and improve                   consumption, it is important to ensure direct
                        environmental sustainability.35                         transfers are in place to counterbalance the
                                                                                negative impact that higher consumption taxes
                    –   Create new multilateral decarbonization                 will have on the poor.38
                        frameworks. A framework that supports the
                        adoption of decarbonization tools such as           –   Transform the global corporate tax
                        national emission trading systems and carbon            architecture. A leap forward was made in
                        taxes needs to be created. An international             the recent multilateral OECD/G20 agreement
                        carbon tax price floor would serve as a                 on corporate taxation, but further progress is
                        reinforcing mechanism of near-term mitigation           possible on fairness and the effectiveness of
                        action, complementing the Paris Agreement.36            this agreement. Lower-income countries will
                                                                                continue to lose the greatest share of their
                                                                                current tax revenues to corporate tax abuse39
                                                                                and close to $483 billion in tax revenues are
                                                                                still lost every year to global tax abuse.40 The
                                                                                IMF and the UN have recommended a focus on
                                                                                an additional “solidarity tax”, in which revenue-
                                                                                raising is targeted on the wealth of the most
                                                                                affluent and excess profit taxes on those that
                                                                                have prospered during the pandemic.41
                                                                                                            Future Focus 2025   13
1.3   Investing
      By 2025, sustainability will truly be at
      the heart of capital allocation and future
      investment portfolios.
      Investors are stewards of the world’s capital              such as climate change, cybersecurity,
      and are key in shaping a more long-term and                pandemics and widening inequalities.
      sustainable global economy. Institutional investors,
      such as pension and sovereign wealth funds as          –   Greening the economy. The investment
      well as asset managers and private equity firms,           industry has the scale and influence to
      influence their investees through active ownership,        support global efforts to limit climate change
      including engagement and voting, in addition to            and drive the transition to net zero. As
      making decisions about how capital is allocated.           global pressure mounts to slash emissions,
                                                                 the investment industry is pushing for
      Climate change, widening inequality and social             greater disclosure on carbon and investing
      unrest are shifting the priorities of the investment       to decarbonize operations. There are
      industry. As the concept of stakeholder                    also significant opportunities to capitalize
      capitalism has gained endorsements from the                on the push for sustainable growth.
      Business Roundtable, academics and policy-
      makers, several trends have amplified the need         –   Increasing ESG reporting. ESG issues
      for responsible and sustainable investment:                have become the main theme of corporate
                                                                 reporting and investor concerns.43 Pressure
      –   Rethinking risks and opportunities.                    to consolidate and align ESG metrics
          COVID-19 has highlighted the fragility of              and approaches culminated in the recent
          economic, environmental and social systems.            formation of the International Sustainability
          Investors today need to manage 21st-                   Standards Board during COP26. Non-
          century business risk and opportunity.42 This          traditional reporting will continue to be high
          includes considering systemic changes,                 on the agenda for global regulators.
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025    14
                    Vision 2025
   Greenwashing     Incorporating sustainability                            –   ESG means different things to different
has emerged as                                                                  investors, however, creating confusion in the
a top challenge                                                                 marketplace and making it difficult for investors
as sustainable      Sustainability issues represent a material risk             to align their values and investments.
investing becomes   to investors and financial markets, and climate
mainstream.         change is high on the agenda for all industries.        Greenwashing concerns:
                    By 2025, sustainability will truly be at the heart of   – Greenwashing is a process of providing
                    capital allocation and future investment portfolios.       misleading information about sustainability
                    Recent estimates of the value of sustainability-           performance, mostly due to the lack
                    themed products put the industry at $3.2 trillion          of a clear, agreed definition.
                    in 2020, up more than 80% from 2019.44 This
                    is made up of sustainable funds, green bonds,           –   The lack of consistent and comparable ESG
                    social bonds and mixed-sustainability bonds.                reporting and rankings allows companies to
                                                                                cherry-pick the most flattering ratings, while their
                    Action on net-zero commitments:                             sustainability-related claims and commitments
                    – Despite several net-zero commitments and                  remain unchecked or unsubstantiated. A recent
                       industry alliances, solutions are needed to              study by the International Consumer Protection
                       develop innovative financing approaches                  Enforcement Network found that roughly 40%
                       and de-risking measures, including risk                  of environmental claims made by companies
                       sharing by stakeholders across the                       could be misleading.46 These greenwashing
                       investment ecosystem, policy-makers                      concerns affect the accuracy and depth of
                       and multilateral development banks.                      insight as investors make capital allocation
                                                                                decisions. On the flip side, companies may be
                    Full integration of ESG:                                    reticent to share information for fear it could be
                    – Investors are increasingly committing to                  taken out of context or used against them.
                        integrating ESG considerations in their
                        processes. As at 2021, 4,000 investors              –   Greenwashing concerns related to sustainability-
                        representing $110 trillion in assets under              linked financial products also exist. For
                        management are signatories to the                       institutional investors in particular, greenwashing
                        Principles for Responsible Investing.45                 has emerged as a top challenge as sustainable
                                                                                investing becomes mainstream.47
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025     15
Improving transparency                                       According to the United Nations Conference on
                                                             Trade and Development (UNCTAD), “sustainability
from investors, regulators                                   performance and ratings have expanded from
and companies                                                company disclosure to an emphasis on fund
                                                             disclosure by asset owners, such as pension
                                                             funds.”48 This has increased the pressure on
ESG reporting is in its infancy compared to traditional      investors to report on their own ESG progress
financial reporting, and an accurate assessment is           as well as commit to improved transparency and
hampered by a plethora of overlapping standards,             progress on diversity, equity and inclusion within the
resulting in a lack of consistent and comparable             industry and in how capital is allocated.
reporting. For asset owners and managers who
expect to be able to undertake a comprehensive               Regulators and policy-makers are also looking
analysis of company financial and non-financial              closely at transparency in financial markets,
performance, this means that there is no comparable          particularly as it relates to ESG corporate reporting
and consistent information across a portfolio. The           and scrutiny of ESG-related financial products.
establishment of the International Sustainability
Standards Board at COP26 aims to address this
friction, but this takes time and uptake is voluntary.
Operating in an environment of                               Private markets do not offer the same level of
                                                             transparency as public markets and are less liquid,
growing private assets and the                               providing limited opportunities to exit on a timely
democratization of markets                                   basis. This makes the selection of managers
                                                             very important – an issue that is explored by the
                                                             World Economic Forum Global Future Council
Public markets have historically driven massive              on Investing.51 It also limits the choices of retail
economic growth, job creation, innovation and                investors and their ability to invest in some of the
personal wealth-building. Therefore concerns have            world’s fastest growing (but private) enterprises.
been raised recently that corporations and investors         Although many risks are associated with investing in
are favouring raising funds via private markets.49 Initial   privately-held firms, such as uncertainty, information
public offerings and the number of public firms have         asymmetry, less liquidity and lower regulatory
declined, while the number of firms staying private          oversight, the popularity of private investing
longer has risen. This trend is likely to continue, with     continues to rise.
private markets predicted to make up 10% of global
assets under management by 2025, serving as an
important engine of economic growth.50
                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   16
                        Pathways to Vision 2025
   Integrating          Integrating a responsible                                 –   Create sustainable value creation
sustainability                                                                        through private equity. Due to the growing
                        investment approach                                           importance of private assets, private equity
goes well beyond
                                                                                      is poised to drive sustainability because it is
principles and
                        Although momentum is building, the shift to                   positioned to drive business transformation
reporting; it affects
                        fully integrate sustainability into investment                and align shareholders, management and
how investors           processes will take time. To do this in a way that            stakeholder communities to deliver a step-
price and think         is consistent will also require significant effort.           change in accelerating sustainable value
about risk, and                                                                       creation and adopt ESG practices. In a
requires investors      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:         similar vein to public markets, the alignment
to rethink the                                                                        of asset owner and private equity manager
traditional risk and    –   Be active stewards. Stewardship and ESG                   expectations when it comes to sustainability
return trade-off.           integration are complementary strategies that can         is needed. Through its work, the Global Future
                            enhance decision-making.52 Investors view active          Council on Investing has highlighted the
                            ownership as an important lever for generating            role private equity can play related to driving
                            sustainable financial returns, and a way to shape         sustainable value creation.
                            investees’ business practices. Investors need to
                            play an active role in fostering good governance      –   Scale investment in sustainable solutions.
                            policies and practices throughout their portfolios.       Integrating sustainability goes well beyond
                                                                                      principles and reporting; it affects how
                        –   Address reporting inconsistencies. Without                investors price and think about risk, and
                            consistent data it is difficult for investors to          requires investors to rethink the traditional
                            accurately assess and compare approaches                  risk and return trade-off. Practical examples
                            to sustainability and performance. The World              of how investors tackle environmental
                            Economic Forum-led Stakeholder Capitalism                 problems are needed. The Global Future
                            Metrics work is creating a common baseline                Council on Investing has highlighted
                            for corporate sustainability reporting.53 The             challenges in financing forest conservation54
                            establishment of the International Sustainability         and in natural capital.55
                            Standards Board is an important step forward.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025    17
                      “Walking the talk” on                                       More comprehensive strategies are needed
                                                                                  to ensure bottom-up action by investors
                      sustainability and diversity,                               to improve DE&I. This includes diagnosing
                      equity and inclusion                                        talent flow issues using data, documenting
                                                                                  commitments across DE&I, soliciting leaders to
                                                                                  make personal commitments and taking action
   Focusing the       Investors must instil a sustainability mindset              to track and report on progress.58,59
sustainability lens   when it comes to investment approaches, but
inward will allow     it is also equally as important that they “walk
investors to better   the talk” on their own reporting and efforts to         Tackling greenwashing
anticipate and        improve diversity, equity and inclusion (DE&I).
adapt to new risks
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:   As sustainability has reached the top of board
and opportunities                                                             agendas, so too has the risk of greenwashing. For
in the years ahead.   –   Report on own ESG performance. A majority           investors, greenwashing risks exist at an investee
                          of institutional investors look for information     level but also at a financial product level. Some
                          on sustainability issues “to better assess          regulators are taking aim at investment firms that
                          companies’ adaptability and resilience and          mislead the public and institutional investors about
                          monitor their risk management to inform             the sustainability credentials of their products
                          investment decision-making and votes …              and make misleading or erroneous claims.
                          Focusing the sustainability lens inward will
                          allow investors to better anticipate and adapt      Strategies for progressing along this pathway include:
                          to new risks and opportunities in the years
                          ahead.”56 The audience for these metrics will       –   Standardize what makes a “sustainable”
                          vary by organization; in some cases, those              investment. The CFA institute found that “78%
                          audiences may be internal or supervisory, or            of practitioners surveyed believe there is a need
                          represent the broader public. The Global Future         for improved standards around ESG products
                          Council on Investing paper entitled “Adapting           to mitigate ‘greenwashing’” when it comes to
                          Corporate Sustainable Value Creation                    financial products.60
                          Indicators for Investors” details the case for
                          investors to disclose non-traditional metrics       –   Instigate greater financial innovation.
                          and offers a summary of priority ESG metrics.57         Financial innovations, including green bonds,
                                                                                  green loans and sustainability linked loans, have
                      –   Improve DE&I. The business case for                     grown in the past few years, but innovation
                          prioritizing DE&I in the workplace has never            opportunities exist in financial instruments and
                          been stronger: a DE&I culture attracts                  business models can create impact and be
                          and retains the best talent, leading to a               implemented at scale.61
                          competitive advantage. Companies are also
                          more likely to have a deeper understanding          –   Improve public-private cooperation. An
                          of their clients and can evolve better to meet          industry movement, working with government
                          changing client demands and needs.                      policy, will transform markets more drastically
                                                                                  than is currently being observed.62
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025    18
1.4   Responsive
      financial systems
      The global financial system is playing an
      important role in enabling the ongoing
      economic recovery and financing the
      transition to a net-zero economy.
      The global financial system is playing an important     –   Quantitative easing infinity. The US Federal
      role in the ongoing economic recovery and in                Reserve System’s distorted discount rates and
      closing the net-zero funding gap to decarbonize             new fiscal paradigms raise new questions for
      economies and transform industries. However,                monetary policy.
      financiers and policy-makers are facing a changed
      macro environment affected by disruption from           –   Regulatory toolkit. Unconventional tools,
      the COVID-19 pandemic, international conflicts,             new questions and unintended consequences
      innovation, climate change and social inequality.           require innovative policy thinking. New digital
                                                                  forms of money, such as crypto assets,
      Six themes retain the attention of policy-makers            stablecoins and central bank digital currencies,
      and financial leaders:63                                    pose a range of opportunities and challenges
                                                                  to regulators.
      –   Digital-led recovery. Digital payments and
          e-commerce are reshaping the agenda for             –   Transformed world. Deglobalization,
          small businesses, financial inclusion and               divergence, inequality and scaring from the
          the future of money. While the pandemic                 pandemic pose a new set of problems.
          accelerated digital transformation, it also made
          addressing digital exclusion more urgent.           Collaborative efforts and innovative solutions
                                                              must be built by existing and emerging financial
      –   Green transition. Finance plays a pivotal           actors. To succeed, this shift requires policy
          role in facilitating the transition to a net-zero   leadership, a reconstituted regulatory framework
          economy, and innovative approaches are              and a fit-for-purpose governance framework to
          needed to bridge the net-zero funding gap.          guide a safe and smooth transition into a green
                                                              and digitalized economy.
      –   Finance reconstructed. Innovation is enabling
          new firms, partnerships and interlinkages,
          leading to a different financial architecture.
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   19
                       Vision 2025
   By 2025,            Today’s global financial system needs to evolve        Moreover, the new financial ecosystem becomes
investors will         to proactively respond to the needs of pandemic-       digital and data-driven to support a smooth
play a larger role     battered economies, thereby ultimately moving into     energy transition and to address the challenges
in financing the       an inclusive, sustainable and equitable net-zero       of inadequately servicing SMEs and lower-income
innovation that will   future society.                                        cohorts, putting inclusion as its core mission.
be key to reach                                                               As has been pointed out, “Digital service providers
                                                                              must find more innovative ways to educate their
the long-term 2050
net-zero targets.      Financing the green transition                         customers about the products they are offering
                                                                              and provide them with continued education as
                                                                              individuals become more sophisticated in their
                       The transition to a lower-carbon economy requires      use of investment products”.66 Effective digital
                       a large rewiring of the global economy, with some      infrastructure and payment processes benefit poor
                       $3.5 trillion of investment needed annually “for       communities and also open the door to the global
                       decades”.64 The shift to net zero will depend on       marketplace for small businesses.
                       a policy framework and companies and investors
                       also seizing the opportunities and navigating the
                       risks of a complex transition. By 2025, investors      Addressing governance
                       will play a larger role in financing the innovation
                       that will be key to reach the long-term 2050 net-
                                                                              issues in a digital age
                       zero targets. This new phase of climate-aligned
                       investing will include “comparable metrics on          As Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) gain
                       carbon footprints, throughout the entire value         momentum around the globe, several questions
                       chain and across a whole portfolio”.65 In the long     emerge regarding design characteristics and
                       run, this will facilitate greater climate engagement   feasibility. Among the various debates discussed
                       and activism.                                          between practitioners, policy-makers and regulators,
                                                                              the issue of governance is perennially difficult and
                                                                              one that will have a significant effect on the feasibility
                       Building an inclusive financial                        and usefulness of any potential initiative.
                       ecosystem                                              With the dawn of the age of digital money, by 2025
                                                                              common standards and approaches are shared to
                       Digital transformation offers the opportunity          widen access and ensure that everyone can join the
                       to achieve a digitally and financially inclusive       digitization journey. The need for autonomy and the
                       economy. As digital innovations continue to            increasing modularity of digital networks in finance
                       connect economies and supply chains, a fit-            demands a layered approach to governance,
                       for-purpose regulatory approach with new laws          aiming to promote innovation, competition and
                       for data sharing is created with appropriate           inclusion. Regulators work alongside technology
                       safeguards for privacy and security at an industrial   experts, local enforcement and intergovernmental
                       scale, ensuring cybersecurity and the integrity of     actors to design forward-thinking laws that keep
                       the global financial system.                           track of rapid developments in the digital age.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025   20
                               Pathways to Vision 2025
                               Accelerating the green transition                                 changing the capital frameworks and bank
                                                                                                 mandates, it is critical these institutions
                                                                                                 do more. A constructive debate is needed
                               Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:             about leveraging balance sheets to support
                                                                                                 innovation and the green transition.
                               –   Adhere to new high-quality sustainability
                                   disclosure standards. With countries and                  –   Reduce green premiums. Greater emphasis
                                   blocs seeking differing sustainability standards,             is needed on creating innovative policies that
                                   international bodies like the International                   accelerate change and increase innovation.
                                   Sustainability Standards Board are important                  Finance can play an important role in
                                   to shape globally aligned sustainable finance                 financing green innovations by ensuring a
                                   disclosures. Innovation by data companies                     focus on the measures that shift the post-
                                   and corporates on tracking carbon footprints,                 tax cost of capital. No government, public
                                   however, will also be key. Corresponding                      bodies or capital market alone can bring
                                   changes in investor behaviour involve or                      about a whole economy’s transition.
                                   entail a shift in focus to a more bottom-up
                                   approach to how individual businesses can
                                   abate their carbon footprint from a top-down              Building an inclusive financial
                                   view of the overall sector (Figure 1).67
                                                                                             ecosystem
                               –   Reform development banks to channel
                                   and leverage finance to emerging                          Strategies for operationalizing these pathways
                                   markets. Development banks provided                       include:
                                   $66 billion of green finance in 2020 and
                                   this could be multiplied to turbocharge                   –   Re-establish infrastructure to form a new
                                   clean-energy technology investment.68                         financial ecosystem. Special efforts must be
                                   Whether through capital increases for                         made to develop the following five elements:
                                   the key development banks, simpler and                        a digital ID to provide affordable access to
                                   smarter public-private partnerships, or                       financial services by households and SMEs;
           FIGURE 1            A new phase for green investing
                        Past                                         Present                                         Future
                       Niche                                      Scaling fast                                     Mainstream
                 Largely thematic or                             Focus on transition                                More focus on
                 exclusionary. Often                               and net-zero                                 bottom-up adaptation
                     values-led.                                   commitments.                                  and forward metrics.
Source: Huw van Steenis, Co-Chair, World Economic Forum Global Future Council on Responsive Financial Systems
                                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   21
   Data and AI            cybersecured and fully integrated infrastructure;           independently of other parts of payment
analytics can be          ethical and robust data governance frameworks;              processes and systems, such as authorizing/
leveraged to allow        an accessible enforcement regime on data                    authenticating transactions or applications.
                          and cybersecurity; and digital literacy through
access to financing
                          society-wide knowledge training and sharing.            –   Ensure data governance. The traditional
and reduce the
                          This requires global digital governance that                financial service ecosystem has struggled for
cost of financing         goes beyond the mandate of current standard-                years to come up with data-sharing models
and insurance             setting bodies, extending benefits to the                   that will boost competition and allow for new
premiums.                 underprivileged and connecting financial                    services and business models. A new CBDC
                          authorities with those in charge of data                    infrastructure could allow for a novel data-
                          protection, cybersecurity and competition to                sharing and integration layer that can deliver
                          preserve an integrated global financial system.             through APIs much more quickly and efficiently.
                      –   Embrace new fintech players. Fintech players            –   Improve financial inclusion. A key decision
                          have proven successful in leveraging mobile                 regarding network governance is who receives
                          technology to make small-ticket payments                    access to the infrastructure, and under what
                          more affordable. Data and AI analytics can be               terms and conditions. This has been a topic of
                          leveraged to allow access to financing and                  ongoing debates for decades when thinking of
                          reduce the cost of financing and insurance                  payment infrastructures nationally (e.g. access
                          premiums. In the future, innovation in financial            to payment schemes such as BACS in the UK)
                          data services can be utilized to differentiate              and internationally (e.g. access to payment
                          costs and risk measurements in ESG financing                communication networks such as SWIFT).
                          and digitalize measurement techniques in                    CBDC or digital money infrastructure will call
                          inclusive loans and insurance policies.                     into question governance issues commonly
                                                                                      seen in national payment infrastructure.
                                                                                      Depending on governance conditions, its
                      Rethinking governance in the                                    design can be more inclusive and contribute
                                                                                      to addressing financial exclusion.
                      age of digital currencies
                                                                                  –   Address risk and fiscal governance.
                      Strategies for operationalizing these pathways                  Naturally, CBDCs are characterized as central
                      include:                                                        bank money, thus they are understood to be
                                                                                      a direct liability to the central bank who also
                      –   Establish rules for digital identity governance.            manages the risks and ensures the monetary
                          In the formal economy, the greatest part of a               stability of the value transfer infrastructure (i.e.
                          payment transaction is verifying the identity               through maintaining the core ledger). While
                          of the individuals or entities on either side of            this archetype of fiscal and risk governance is
                          the transaction. While CBDCs promise to                     well-established as a model for CBDC design,
                          revolutionize payments and deliver efficiencies for         different governance conditions could be
                          consumers (retail or commercial), it is still unclear       envisioned to distribute the responsibilities and
                          how their architecture accommodates an identity             allow for other financial institutions to play a
                          layer. A digital identity layer should be developed         part in the running of the payment system.
                                                                                                                     Future Focus 2025   22
1.5   Risk resilience
      Management of frontier risks ensures that
      any negative impacts arising from human
      progress are minimized.
                                                         –   Advances into new territorial and geographic
      The progress called for in the collective vision
                                                             frontiers, such as space exploration
      for 2025 has the potential to better connect
      and equalize the world – but in doing so, it       –   Breaches to ecological and environmental
      could lower the natural containment barriers           boundaries, such as geoengineering
      to cascading global risks. Advances in digital
                                                         –   Technologies expanding frontiers in human
      equality, social equity and environmental
                                                             communication, such as through social
      resilience could both contribute to, and be
                                                             networks and AI
      destabilized by, several interconnected risks.
                                                         –   Advances in the human-technology interface,
      Among them, frontier risks require particular          such as through genetic enhancement
      attention. Frontier risks include the unintended
      consequences of human progress: risks that         The impact or likelihood of frontier risks is often
      emerge as technologies surface or human and        unknown and therefore almost impossible to fully
      societal forces shift. There are at least four     predict. Enhanced identification and monitoring
      critical areas of human development for which      of these risks, however, can ensure that any
      there is more limited understanding of whether,    unintended impacts on economies and societies
      when and how specific risks could emerge:          stemming from human development are minimized.
                                                                                        Future Focus 2025   23
                      Vision 2025
                      Developing an expanded                                      Enabling transparent
                      risk universe                                               risk communication
                      “The more obscure a risk or the more distant                Beyond organizational resilience, a clear and
                      someone is from a situation, the harder it is to pay        consistent risk narrative that is transparently
                      attention to it.”69 Frontier risks pose a particular        communicated to society will awaken policy-
                      challenge because early-warning signs are often             makers and the public to more uncertain threats.
                      subtle and ambiguous. Potential blind spots in              This narrative should be based on long-term risk
                      the management of frontier risks may arise from:            scenarios, outlining drivers and trends which
                                                                                  are played out in multiple future dimensions.
                      –   Systematic errors in judgement of the                   Importantly, effective narratives should focus
                          likelihood or impact of these risks, due                not only on protective actions, but also on clear
                          to weak monitoring signals and cognitive                explanations of the nature and known/unknown
                          biases around the perception of risk                    character of the risk, in language that is accessible
                                                                                  to the community.
                      –   Institutional architecture, where diffuse
                          accountability or momentum to push
                          towards a frontier may cause decision-                  Ensuring a resilient risk response
                          makers to discount these risks
                      –   Societal norms, such as a lack of public trust          Governments, regional bodies and international
                          in public- and private-sector institutions,             organizations have a role to play in preventing
                          or fragmentation between risk experts, the              or hedging against potential risks. For example,
                          scientific community and decision-makers                governments and international bodies should
                                                                                  prioritize closing gaps in legal frameworks
                      More effective identification and prioritization of         governing new frontiers, such as in the realm of
                      potential unintended consequences relating to               space or AI. This requires governing institutions
                      human progress will not only increase general               to develop or collaborate with the private sector
                      awareness, but also allow decision-makers take              to harness the expertise needed to responsibly
                      steps to mitigate exposure to these frontier risks.         regulate these issues.
                                                                                  It is equally important to facilitate recovery from
                      Refining risk management                                    the materialization of a frontier risk. COVID-19
                                                                                  has shown that economic buffers, such as
                                                                                  automatic stabilizers and agile emergency
                      Frontier risks do not usually fall neatly within existing   spending triggers, are key to ensuring markets
   Effective          enterprise risk management (ERM) frameworks.                can bounce back from unanticipated shocks.
narratives should     At a minimum, defined ownership of these risks              While debt is already at an all-time high, some
                      within senior management will ensure a more                 countries have managed to retain national
focus not only on
                      proactive response to emerging trends. Soft                 emergency funds and crisis reserves, while others
protective actions,   controls, or organizational culture, can also enhance       promote or provide insurance arrangements to
but also on clear     resilience to threats. Entities with an openness            shore up protections. Investment into critical
explanations of the   to uncertainty and alternative viewpoints, the              infrastructure and redundancy expenditure are
nature and known/     ability to track and learn from small failures, and         vital as well. Such initiatives are part and parcel
unknown character     a reliance on frontline knowledge will be better            of a country’s ability to absorb unanticipated
of the risk.          equipped to detect risks and recover from shocks.           shocks and, therefore, its competitiveness.
                                                                                                                   Future Focus 2025    24
                     Pathways to Vision 2025
                     Expanding risk perceptions                                    the Future of Humanity and the Centre for the
                                                                                   Future of Intelligence.
                     Effective management relies on robust identification      –   Ensure diversity of perspectives when
                     and prioritization. Frontier risks are uncertain,             mapping out the parameters of frontier
                     and risk assessment processes must be able to                 risks and future scenarios. Latent biases
                     correspondingly address information gaps and                  and groupthink can be addressed through
                     adapt to early signals in the risk landscape. Regular         mechanisms that elevate under-represented
                     horizon scanning that draws from a diverse set of             voices (such as on-site workers who can often
                     perspectives can help ensure that decision-makers             detect early warning signs), bring in lessons
                     do not miss, underestimate or underprepare for                from other fields (for example, task forces or
   Regular horizon   emerging frontier risks.                                      panels of cross-sectoral experts with a mandate
scanning that                                                                      to investigate a frontier risk), or are designed
draws from a         Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:         to stress-test existing perceptions (including
diverse set of                                                                     scenario-based peer reviews of crisis or
perspectives can     –   Leverage existing lists of risks developed                management decisions).
                         by business, government or civil society
help ensure that
                         organizations. This should be a starting point,       –   Prioritize frontier risks, acknowledging
decision-makers          with a particular focus on those that develop             potential information gaps. Consideration can
do not miss,             insights into new and developing risks alongside          be given to multiple factors, such as likelihood,
underestimate            existing risks. This includes existing intelligence       impact, time to impact, connectivity with other
or underprepare          developed by organizations that specialize in             risks, controllability and the cost/benefit of
for emerging             risks with uncertain characteristics, such as             mitigation measures.
frontier risks.          the Centre for the Study of Existential Risk,
                     Building risk-ready entities                                  investing in a coordinating body with direct lines
                                                                                   to both the head of government and local units
                                                                                   is one approach.
                     Reorienting risk functions to ensure a responsive,
                     whole-of-entity approach is not only vital to an          –   Undertake regular monitoring of existing
                     entity’s ability to see through a crisis, but can also        and new frontier risks. Scientific and legal
                     contribute to its broader competitiveness.                    developments should be considered, and big
                                                                                   data and machine learning harnessed, to better
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:         anticipate the direction of change and speed
                                                                                   of travel for trends that may not otherwise be
                     –   Assign accountability and develop                         visible to management.
                         escalation factors, prevention, mitigation
                         and recovery control measures. Frontier               –   Assess soft controls. For example,
                         risks should be integrated into existing ERM              interviewing and surveying the workforce
                         processes, with accountability assigned to                can help identify potential risk issues in
                         the C-Suite member(s). In the public sector,              organizational culture, which may require
                         accountability should be centralized to avoid             training or education to address.
                         narrow viewpoints and non-systemic solutions;
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025   25
   Well-formed        Developing effective narratives                         Reorienting resources to
scenarios developed
in a collaborative
                                                                              address frontier risks
process can help      While the above can help ensure organizational
draw out potential    resilience to these threats, broader societal           Resources should be allocated towards both
impacts and educate   preparedness requires transparent risk                  prevention (guardrails) and recovery (buffers).
the public on         communication across multiple stakeholder               Controls must be both broad and flexible enough
possible threats.     groups. When lacking data to quantify risks             to address the unknown nature of frontier risks.
                      and evaluate their likelihoods, well-formed
                      scenarios developed in a collaborative process          Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                      can help draw out potential impacts and
                      educate the public on possible threats.                 –   Adopt precautionary principles in the
                                                                                  development of new technologies. Proactive
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       regulation should also seek to anticipate
                                                                                  potential future applications of emerging
                      –   Develop clear scenarios that articulate                 technologies and related ethical issues.
                          the sources, drivers, amplifiers and tipping
                          points of a particular risk. They should            –   Prioritize closing gaps in legal standards
                          be robust enough to be useful to decision-              governing new frontiers, such as space and
                          makers mapping out potential avenues for                AI. International or transnational organizations
                          preparedness.                                           may be well placed to coordinate frameworks or
                                                                                  standards for new realms.
                      –   Be intentional about the language, format
                          and timing of communications. Use of                –   Reframe decision-making architecture to
                          behavioural science mechanisms, such as                 ensure adequate consideration of frontier
                          MINDSPACE (messenger, incentives, norms,                risks in the allocation of investment. For
                          defaults, salience, priming, affect, commitment         example, considerations around public financing
                          and ego),70 can help the narrative find greater         could evolve to account for the longer-term
                          traction. For example, sensory tools, such as           impacts and interconnections of frontier risks
                          art, gaming or virtual reality, can fill gaps and       that could exacerbate down-the-line costs.
                          make threats “feel” real.
                                                                              –   Provide innovative insurance options to
                      –   Protect against disinformation. Greater                 bridge gaps between frontier risks and
                          regulation of social networks and protection            opportunities. Similarly, this could be as
                          against false information could help take the           simple as a change to choice architecture to
                          onus off individuals to filter out misinformation       encourage forward-thinking decision-making in
                          or disinformation and place the responsibility          the selection of insurance products but, in some
                          on the government or businesses overseeing              cases, stronger regulation and public-private
                          these networks.                                         collaboration may be required. For example, in
                                                                                  light of increased flooding, France and Spain
                                                                                  have introduced government-backed schemes
                                                                                  that include a compulsory flat-rate surcharge for
                                                                                  flood and other hazard coverage, while in the
                                                                                  UK, mortgage lenders require flood coverage to
                                                                                  be included in standard household insurance.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   26
1.6   Trade and
      investment
      Trade and investment are crucial levers for
      a sustainable and inclusive recovery that
      benefits people and the planet.
      As the world enters an unequal recovery, four                 and labour right violations demands action
      trends stand out:                                             on trade and investment. Vaccine inequity
                                                                    is at the heart of the unequal recovery.
      –   Disruptions. Trade tensions, the COVID-19
          pandemic, demand and supply shocks,                   –   Dysfunction in trade governance. Existing
          fluctuating transport costs, natural disasters,           global trade rules have proven incapable
          national security measures and semiconductor              of adequately addressing complex trade
          shortages have contributed to supply chain                frictions arising from incompatibilities between
          disruptions and highlighted the importance of             market and non-market economies. Failure
          risk planning and resilience.                             to achieve redress through multilateral
                                                                    channels has led to an increase in unilateral
      –   Digitalization. The pandemic accelerated                  trade actions, some of which have been
          digitalization, with digital trade keeping the            taken on contentious grounds.
          economy going through the crisis. Digitally
          deliverable services grew from 52% of                 Trade and investment are crucial levers for a
          service exports in 2019 to 64% in 2020.71             sustainable and inclusive recovery that benefits
                                                                people and the planet. Yet global economic
      –   Sustainability and inclusion. Concern about           cooperation, rule-making and dispute settlement
          vaccine equity, climate change, environmental         are faltering, and the public is largely ambivalent
          pollution, biodiversity loss, societal inequalities   about globalization.72
                                                                                                Future Focus 2025     27
                       Vision 2025
                       Enhancing economic growth                               –   Raise living standards and wages; improve
                                                                                   working conditions, worker safety and pay;
                       and development                                             and protect labour and human rights
                       Over the next three years, trade and investment         –   Enable micro, small and medium-sized
                       must serve as engines of economic recovery,                 enterprises (MSMEs) to fully engage in the
                       growth and development. In 2025, the vision is              global economy
                       for policies and practices that:
                                                                               –   Benefit women73 and underserved and
                       –   Facilitate trade and investment by removing             marginalized communities, including ethnic
                           frictions and inefficiencies in the processes           minorities and Indigenous peoples
                           involved in moving goods, services and capital
                           across borders                                      Enabling environmental
                       –   Boost employment, incomes, competitiveness,
                                                                               sustainability
                           innovation and value chain upgrading through
                           economic integration, particularly in developing    Trade and investment policies and practices have a
                           and least developed countries                       significant impact on production and consumption
                                                                               around the world and can be powerful levers to
                       –   Enable digital trade, while keeping in check such   shift to more environmentally sustainable growth.
                           harms as threats to online competition or the       As countries move to tackle climate change and
   Trade and               lack of competition regulation and enforcement,     environmental degradation at different speeds and
investment policies        and the lack of transparency                        often through unilateral measures, international
and practices have                                                             cooperation will be essential to avoid conflicts.
a significant impact   –   Support developing countries, especially the
on production              least developed, to fully engage and benefit        Trade and investment policies and practices
                           from trade and investment                           must align with sustainability goals to:
and consumption
around the world
and can be
                       Reducing societal inequalities                          –   Mitigate climate change
powerful levers                                                                –   Enable a circular economy and reduce waste
to shift to more       For trade to be truly inclusive, it must benefit all
environmentally        sections of society. The vision is for trade and        –   Reduce environmental pollution and protect
sustainable growth.    flanking policies and practices that:                       biodiversity
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   28
Pathways to Vision 2025
Supporting evidence-based                                   scope, design and effects domestically and
                                                            internationally, as well as information on best
policy development                                          practices, should inform policy development.
                                                            Gender-disaggregated data, and data on trade,
Sound economic policies are built on a strong               ethnic minorities and Indigenous peoples, are
evidence base, inclusive and broad-based                    needed to inform more inclusive trade policy.
stakeholder dialogue and iterative and practical
testing and refinement.                                 –   Engage all stakeholders. Consultations must
                                                            include all stakeholders to ensure broad-based
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway                input and buy-in.
include:
                                                        –   Test and refine. There is scope for more
–   Support data collection and analysis. Data              piloting and iterative refining of economic policy.
    and analysis on current economic policies, their
Advancing discussions and                                   and fossil fuel subsidies; addressing tensions
                                                            between trade and climate policies, including
meaningful agreements                                       carbon taxes and border adjustment; and
                                                            reducing siloes between trade, environment
While many governments have advanced new                    and development policy-making by aligning
trade rules through bilateral and regional trade            trade action with international environmental
agreements, some areas would benefit from                   commitments, while ensuring a just transition.
multilateral and plurilateral rule-making through
the World Trade Organization (WTO).                     –   Advance ambitious agreements on trade
                                                            and gender, MSMEs and least developed
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       countries. This will ensure that the benefits
                                                            of trade reach all sections of society and all
–   Conclude a meaningful electronic                        WTO members.
    commerce agreement. The agreement must
    seek to improve access and interoperability,        –   Advance a trade and health agenda. A trade
    enable safe and efficient digital trade and             and health package may include lowering
    data flows, promote openness and trust,                 tariff and administrative barriers to trade in
    and address market access issues. Also,                 inputs and final products, facilitating global
    countries should abstain from applying                  manufacturing investment, improving supply
    customs duties on electronic transmissions.             chain transparency, removing export restraints
                                                            and addressing the relationship between IP
–   Conclude a meaningful investment                        rights and access to life-saving technologies.
    facilitation for development agreement.
    The agreement should aim to improve                 –   Discuss level-playing-field concerns.
    transparency and predictability, streamline             Members should initiate open and inclusive
    administrative procedures, reduce disputes              discussions to resolve level-playing-field concerns
    and enhance sustainable investment.                     on subsidies, state-owned enterprises, and trade
                                                            remedies and government procurement across
–   Conclude environmental agreements. This                 industrial, agricultural and service sectors.
    includes delivering agreements on fisheries
                                                                                         Future Focus 2025   29
                      Reforming trade governance                              certain that sustainable supply chains ensure
                                                                              environmental and societal benefits.
                      Various WTO members have put forward proposals          Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                      for reform. Members must work together to address
                      common concerns to revitalize multilateralism           –   Facilitate trade in goods. Efforts can include
                      and reduce the incentive for unilateral action.             supporting developing countries in implementing
                                                                                  the Agreement on Trade Facilitation and
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       encouraging public-private initiatives to identify
                                                                                  and tackle specific bottlenecks.
                      –   Revitalize rule-making. Trade rules can
                          be updated by working through open                  –   Streamline domestic regulation of services.
                          plurilateral negotiations (where necessary) and         This can be pursued by supporting developing
                          multilateral negotiations (where possible).             country implementation of commitments in the
                                                                                  Joint Statement Initiative Reference Paper on
                      –   Promote transparency. This can be                       Services Domestic Regulation.
                          furthered by supporting and incentivizing
                          the notification of measures by countries;          –   Facilitate investment. Action here can
                          encouraging independent, third-party                    include advancing an agreement on facilitating
                          initiatives that track trade measures; and              investment for development, supporting
                          monitoring compliance with commitments.                 developing countries in implementation, and
                                                                                  encouraging public-private initiatives to identify
                      –   Restore dispute settlement. Efforts in this area        and tackle specific bottlenecks and enable
                          can include addressing members’ concerns                sustainable investment.
                          with the WTO’s dispute settlement system
                          and appointing Appellate Body members.              –   Support sustainable trade. A range of
                                                                                  approaches is possible, such as creating
                                                                                  platforms to share best practices in meeting
                      Supporting public-private                                   the challenges of sustainable trade and
                                                                                  striking a balance across the economic, social,
                      initiatives to facilitate sustainable                       and environmental pillars of sustainability;
                      trade and investment                                        recognizing the role supply chains can play
                                                                                  in contributing to climate action, the circular
                                                                                  economy, labour protection, gender equity,
  Public-private      Facilitating trade in goods and services, as well           ethnic minorities, Indigenous peoples’ upliftment
action is needed to   as investment, can result in gains in efficiency            and MSME development; identifying and
make certain that     and boost economic growth and development.                  addressing barriers to making supply chains
sustainable supply    Facilitation involves simplifying, streamlining,            and business practices environmentally and
chains ensure         modernizing and harmonizing administrative                  societally sustainable; ensuring coherent
environmental and     processes throughout the supply chain. In                   regulation and standards; and supporting supply
societal benefits.    addition, public-private action is needed to make           chain traceability as an enabler.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   30
            1.7        Transparency and
                       anti-corruption
                       Technology-driven gains in transparency and
                       accountability are critical for confidence in
                       business and trust in government.
  Today,               Corruption costs the world economy approximately         –   An increase in transnational, cross-
organizations are      5% of GDP, or $3.6 trillion, annually.74 Moreover,           sectoral corruption risks. High-profile global
exposed to a wider     estimated monetary losses do not reflect the total           investigations, such as the “Panama”, “Paradise”
variety of legal and   cost of corrupt acts. A $1 million bribe can easily be       and “Pandora” papers, have drawn widespread
reputational risks     magnified into $100 million in damage to society,            attention to the role of certain industries in
                       as corruption can deter future investment, result in         relation to money laundering, financial fraud,
than ever before.
                       substandard infrastructure and lead to underfunded           corruption schemes, tax/sanctions evasion and
                       social programmes, among other harms.                        criminal/terrorist financing.
                       The field of transparency and anti-corruption is         –   The digital disruption of anti-corruption.
                       rapidly evolving, with key trends emerging in the            Developments in AI, blockchain,
                       following areas:                                             cryptocurrency and digitalized government
                                                                                    services are reshaping corruption risks and
                       –   The expansion of ethics and integrity risks.             anti-corruption mechanisms.
                           Today organizations are exposed to a wider
                           variety of legal and reputational risks than         The World Economic Forum Global Future
                           ever before. Factors such as employee voice,         Council on Transparency and Anti-Corruption
                           human rights and environmental sustainability        has developed an agenda for business integrity
                           have begun to redefine corporate priorities          based upon four pillars: 1) committing to ethics
                           and shed new light on the importance of              and integrity beyond compliance; 2) strengthening
                           integrity, accountability and transparency.          corporate culture and incentives to drive
                                                                                continuous learning and improvement; 3) leveraging
                       –   A growing focus on ESG frameworks. As the            technologies; and 4) supporting collective action.
                           momentum around ESG investing translates
                           into metrics, action and binding law, the role
                           and significance of corruption is often sidelined.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   31
                     Vision 2025
                     Breaking silos between ethics                             Embedding integrity into ESG
                     and integrity                                             performance
   Technology-       Public concern around inequity, human rights              The world’s attention has justifiably fixated on the
driven gains in      abuses, the environmental crisis and corporate            existential threats of corporate-caused climate
transparency and     hypocrisy are translating into an evolving and            change and, increasingly, human rights abuses
accountability       expanding regulatory agenda. The current                  and inequity. However, investors, regulators
prove critical       climate of heightened expectations and legal              and corporate actors should not lose sight of
                     obligations necessitate a more strategic and              the corrupt conduct that frequently enables
for increasing
                     coordinated approach to integrity commitments,            environmentally and socially corrosive behaviour.
confidence in
                     one that is driven by a culture of integrity
business and         beyond compliance. The disruption of long-                Within ESG, corruption is both a vertical and
restoring trust in   standing tendencies to silo integrity risks and           horizontal concern – directly measurable as a
government.          turn ethics into box-ticking, which serve neither         key factor within the “G”, while simultaneously
                     organizational nor stakeholder interests, is key.         impacting the “S” and “E”. The growing global
                                                                               momentum around combatting inequity, human
                                                                               rights violations and climate change will prove
                                                                               futile if corruption is not simultaneously reigned in.
                     Combatting transnational, cross-                          Maximizing the anti-corruption
                     sectoral illicit financial flows                          potential of tech innovation
                     No single country, company or industry can                Technological innovation is changing, challenging
                     achieve its anti-corruption goals alone. Although         and enhancing the field of anti-corruption. Most
                     governmental resources and attention have                 technological developments present both negative
                     powered anti-corruption efforts for decades, the          and positive anti-corruption potential – increasing
                     role and responsibility of the private sector is          transparency and accessibility while opening new
                     increasingly in the spotlight.                            avenues for abuse by hackers and criminals. To
                                                                               fully appreciate the corruption risks and anti-
                     While professionals in some countries are highly          corruption potential of digitalization, integrity,
                     regulated, others have no affirmative duty to report      accountability and transparency is placed at the
                     suspected criminal activity or verify the origin of the   heart of tech initiatives from the outset. Moreover,
                     assets they handle. This patchwork and frequently         from transparent public procurement processes
                     lacklustre approach to private-sector regulation          to data-driven early warning systems, technology-
                     has come at a high cost, allowing corrupt actors          driven gains in transparency and accountability
                     to manipulate markets, erode public services,             prove critical for increasing confidence in
                     fund criminal networks and waste trillions of             business and restoring trust in government.
                     dollars annually.75
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025   32
                       Pathways to Vision 2025
                       Leveraging practitioner insights                           Raising the role and profile of
                       to achieve holistic organizational                         organizational integrity within
                       integrity                                                  ESG frameworks
                       Increasing stakeholder expectations and an                 Organizational integrity should be understood as
                       expanding regulatory agenda require organizations          the foundational element of any ESG framework.
                       to foster internal alignment and collaboration across      It is impossible to achieve environmental, social,
                       ESG/sustainability, public affairs, risk, ethics and       governance or financial goals without properly
                       compliance. Organizational commitments can                 accounting for corruption risks. Corruption also
                       no longer be based solely on calculations that             impacts the entire range of stakeholders, from
                       will drive growth and increase profit. The integrity       shareholders and employees, to community
                       mandate must include all of an organization’s              members and the planet. As such, realizing a
                       regulatory and voluntary commitments, as well              stakeholder-centred and sustainable business
                       as other sources of stakeholder expectations.              agenda – the stated goal of the Business Roundtable
                       Speaking to and working with practitioners will            and the World Economic Forum International
                       prove vital to achieving and operationalizing an           Business Council – cannot be achieved without
                       integrated approach to ethics and integrity.               tackling corruption. Organizations and investors must
                                                                                  ensure that their values align with their ESG priorities
                       Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:      and that both include integrity at their centre.
                       –   Empower and expand the integrity function.             Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                           The World Economic Forum White Paper entitled
                           “The Rise and Role of the Chief Integrity Officer:     –   Chart a path for investing with integrity. In a
                           Leadership Imperatives in an ESG-Driven World”             forthcoming series on investing with integrity,
                           outlines key outcomes and recommendations                  the Global Future Council makes the case for
                           for chief integrity officers adapting to the current       raising the profile of corruption risks within
                           climate of heightened risk and opportunity.76              ESG investing frameworks. The series also
   Organizations                                                                      provides key recommendations for the investor
                       –   Foster integrity-based collective action and               universe (asset managers, asset owners,
and investors must
                           peer learning. The Council and the World                   rating agencies and transnational standard-
ensure that their          Economic Forum Partnering Against Corruption               setting organizations) on how to effectively
values align with          Initiative (PACI) convened a peer learning                 incorporate and prioritize corruption risks.
their ESG priorities       session with corporate compliance officers
and that both              from industry-leading organizations focused            –   Embed ESG within organizational integrity
include integrity at       on the intersection of and synergies between               priorities. The Forum White Paper, “The Rise
their centre.              anti-corruption and human rights compliance.               and Role of the Chief Integrity Officer”, includes
                                                                                                                   Future Focus 2025   33
                           recommendations on how integrity officers                convened by the Council and PACI, with the
                           can use materiality and risk assessments, as             support of the World Bank-UN Office on
                           well as a long-term and holistic outlook, to             Drugs and Crime (UNODC) Stolen Asset
                           effectively operationalize ESG integration.              Recovery Initiative.79
                                                                                –   Leverage existing fora. Dialogue and peer
                       Facilitating transnational and                               learning about anti-corruption trends, priorities
                                                                                    and future pathways can be facilitated. The
                       multisectoral anti-corruption                                Council leverages the expertise of the PACI
                       action                                                       community in guiding its research agenda and
                                                                                    shaping recommendations.
                       The transnational and multisectoral nature of
                       illicit financial flows demands a transnational          Promoting the advancement and
                       and multisectoral response. The adoption of
                       common frameworks and coalitions across a
                                                                                adoption of tech for integrity
                       diverse array of professionals presents various
                       benefits. First, such frameworks invite collective       Data-driven, tech-based anti-corruption solutions
                       recognition. At present, many private-sector             are rapidly expanding in sophistication and
                       professionals and even entire industries do not          potential. Tech innovations, powered by data
                       fully appreciate their role in facilitating harmful      and behavioural insight, are disrupting corruption
                       financial activities. Second, collective action          risks and boosting integrity systems. They are
                       more adequately addresses the reality of an              accelerating new forms of accountability based on
                       interconnected world, in which the weakness of           the smarter exploitation of big data and fostering
                       one actor or industry becomes the weakness               new public-private partnerships for integrity. In
                       of all. Third, there is strength in numbers. The         the digital era, data have become critical assets
                       development of a unified, collective approach            for integrity actors to detect and deter fraud risks,
                       to fighting corruption will minimize the costs of        complex networks and corrupt practices.80
                       illicit financial flows to society while maximizing
                       the benefits of increased integrity.77                   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
   The development
of a unified,          Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:    –   Facilitate peer learning around tech for
collective approach                                                                 integrity. PACI’s Tech for Integrity (T4I) platform
to fighting            –   Endorse the Unifying Framework for                       provides insight on digital anti-corruption
                           gatekeeping professionals. The Unifying                  solutions and builds networks across sectors
corruption will
                           Framework, launched in June 2021, is “a                  and the public-private divide. T4I helps
minimize the costs         value‑based self‑regulatory framework                    promote the advancement and adoption of
of illicit financial       for private-sector intermediaries who are                digital anti-corruption solutions through the
flows to society           strategically positioned to prevent or interrupt         sharing of best practices by industry experts,
while maximizing           illicit financial flows – collectively referred to       while also building awareness of the positive
the benefits of            as ‘gatekeepers’”.78 It was developed by a               and negative potential of tech innovation.
increased integrity.       cross-sectoral task force of industry leaders
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025      34
2   Environment
2.1   Clean air
      Reducing air pollution will allow healthier
      and more productive lives, a healthier
      natural environment, economic benefits and
      increased shared prosperity.
      Air pollution is a transboundary challenge that                is inequitable as it is influenced by age,
      affects everyone, particularly the most vulnerable.            gender, income levels, access to nutrition
      Reducing air pollution will provide benefits like              and healthcare, and underlying diseases.
      healthier and more productive lives, a healthier
      natural environment, economic benefits and                 –   Climate change. Reducing air pollution
      increased shared prosperity. Addressing air                    contributes to climate action as air
      pollution will contribute to keeping global warming            pollutants come from the same sources
      under 1.5° C.                                                  as GHGs. Many air pollutants are both
                                                                     bad for human health and are powerful
      –   Human right. Clean air is a human right and                accelerators of climate change, thus
          a priority. According to the United Nations                impacting people’s lives and making the
          Environment Programme, air pollution is the                future less safe for future generations.
          largest environmental risk to global public
          health.81 It harms human health and well-              Calls for urgent action on reducing air pollution
          being, reduces quality of life and is linked to        have increased in recent years. The World
          premature mortality. The majority of the world’s       Economic Forum Global Future Council on Clean
          population lives in areas with high air pollution.82   Air joins these calls for action and promotes an
                                                                 integrated approach to improving air quality for all,
      –   Equity. Although everyone is affected by air           based on scientific evidence, strong political action
          pollution, the distribution of disease burden          and a participatory, multistakeholder approach.
                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025   36
Vision 2025
Building strong networks at the                          –   Countries have the capacity to monitor air quality
                                                             and develop air pollution emission inventories
local, regional and national levels                          that are regularly updated and publicly reported.
Air pollution has local, regional, national and global
impact. The transboundary nature of air pollution        Rethinking education
requires regional and international, coordinated
and joined efforts with clear and ambitious
reduction targets. Strong networks enhance               Air pollution is part of curricula of different grades
knowledge and best practice exchanges and further        in various courses and modules. Education
understanding of the complexity of air pollution.        for Sustainable Development (ESD) is present
Cross-stakeholder collaboration and fora advise          in curricula across the world in different age
local and national governments on actions that           groups, and air pollution is one of the key themes
can be taken to design and develop appropriate           discussed explicitly in different grades and
mitigation pathways to reduce emissions.                 disseminated worldwide. Including air pollution in
                                                         the curricula builds the skills but also the attitudes
Local action                                             needed to approach this complex problem and
                                                         to foster new generations of problem-solvers.
–   Cities join existing networks (e.g. C40, UN
    Sustainable Cities), working together to             Interdisciplinary approaches include:
    enhance their agenda on sustainable
    development and achieve the United Nations           –   Air pollution is explicitly present in curricula
    Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that                of all disciplines and all grades.
    include air pollution.
                                                         –   Air pollution is clearly presented as an
–   Cities have the capacity to monitor and report           interdisciplinary challenge that requires
    air pollution.                                           interdisciplinary solutions.
–   Cities develop air pollution emission inventories    –   Air pollution is presented with adequate scope
    that are regularly updated.                              and context so that the different disciplines and
                                                             grades understand the wide range of its impacts.
Regional and international
collaboration                                            Recognizing private-sector
                                                         leadership and action
–   Countries join and actively participate in
    conventions (e.g. United Nations Economic            The private sector measures and takes action
    Commission for Europe Long-range                     to reduce air pollution within the operations of
    Transboundary Air Pollution – LRTAP                  companies and uses its influence on supply chains
    Convention) that aim to limit, reduce and            to reduce associated air pollution. This increases
    prevent air pollution.                               the visibility of air pollution and its effects, and
                                                         more companies join to champion action for
–   Countries introduce and enforce regulations that     clean air. Companies use assets and abilities
    follow the Air Quality Guidelines set by the World   innovatively to tackle and reduce existing air
    Health Organization.                                 pollution emissions and prevent future emissions.
                                                                                            Future Focus 2025     37
Pathways to Vision 2025
Investing in local networks                                –   Invest in capacity building. Improvement
                                                               is needed in the capacity of local and
                                                               national governments to understand the
While actions to improve air quality at the national           complex nature of the issue scientifically, the
level remain critical, local and regional actions play a       institutional mechanisms that enable complex
key role in addressing the challenge of air pollution          coordination between different agencies
by targeting key sectors (transport, residential).             within government to achieve an outcome,
                                                               and policy formulation and monitoring
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:          based on data and scientific evidence.
–   Increase knowledge exchange between                    –   Join existing initiatives. Participating in
    regions. Establishing monitoring networks,                 networks or projects such as BreatheLife or
    assessing the health impacts and developing                C40 Cities’ Clean Air Cities Declaration
    appropriate local policies can play a critical role        demonstrates a commitment to bring air quality
    in reducing premature mortality, improving life            to safe levels and collaborate on accelerated
    quality and reducing costs related to air pollution.       clean air solutions.
Preparing the next generation of                           Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
thought leaders                                            –   Invest in the power of young people. Engaging
                                                               with them at an early age and informing and
Mapping and understanding the needs of                         educating them on the magnitude of the air
students, life-long learners and educators is a key            pollution challenge will motivate their efforts.
step to appropriately include ESD and, therefore,
air pollution in the different curricula. An open          –   Involve universities and educators.
and transparent dialogue between the various                   Educational institutions can incorporate air
stakeholders (educational institutions, students,              pollution into curricula.
government agencies) must be promoted, and
schools and universities need to respond to the            –   Promote transparent, multistakeholder
increasing demand for more ESD.                                dialogues. Diverse voices need to be
                                                               represented in the creation of the curricula.
                                                                                            Future Focus 2025    38
                      Monitoring, reporting and                               Adopting a “Learn, Act, Engage”
                      reducing emissions                                      framework
                      The private sector has a key role to play in            To achieve meaningful reductions in air pollution,
                      achieving the global reduction of air pollution.        the focus must be on widening the participation
                      Appropriate monitoring and reporting of emissions       and awareness of all citizens. The “Learn, Act,
                      are a critical step to achieve the desired air          Engage” framework represents steps and actions
                      pollution reductions. Despite the fact that most        that citizens can take to reduce air pollution.
                      companies have developed sustainability agendas,
                      very few companies monitor and report their air         Strategies for operationalizing this pathway
                      pollution emissions across their value chains.          include:
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                                                                              –   Improve access to real-time data. Citizens
                                                                                  should have access to reliable, real-time data
                      –   Share best practices. Either within a specific
                                                                                  that present air pollution levels in their area.
                          industry, or across diverse industries, best
                          practices need to be shared to achieve the
                                                                              –   Use participatory approaches in decision-
                          desired reductions in emissions as quickly and
                                                                                  making. To ensure all societal groups are
                          as efficiently as possible.
                                                                                  appropriately represented in decision- and
                      –   Develop emission inventories. This can                  policy-making, the focus must be on
   Appropriate                                                                    participatory approaches that take into
                          be done through integrated approaches that
monitoring and                                                                    consideration the different perspectives
                          address GHG and air pollution emissions.
reporting of                                                                      of citizens.
emissions are a       –   Join the Alliance for Clean Air. The Global
critical step to          Future Council on Clean Air has developed           –   Raise awareness. Raising awareness of
achieve the desired       the Alliance for Clean Air, which gathers               the issue of air pollution is critical as citizens
air pollution             business leaders to understand their impact             in many cities are exposed in harmful, life-
reductions.               on air quality and to act to reduce it.                 threatening pollutants in their daily lives.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025     39
2.2   Clean electrification
      60% of current emissions would be
      reduced by electrifying road transport,
      buildings and low-temperature
      industrial processes, in combination
      with renewable power generation.
      According to the International Energy Agency                 temperature rise must be limited to 1.5° C
      in its World Energy Outlook 2021, “electricity’s             by the end of the century. Halving carbon
      share of the world’s final consumption of energy             emissions by 2030 will require electrifying
      has risen steadily over recent decades”, and                 energy demand and supplying it with
      it promises to become the energy source on                   renewable generation.
      which consumers rely for all their everyday
      needs.83 The reliability, resilience and affordability   –   The new energy economy. Higher degrees of
      of electricity will become even more critical.               electrification of energy use in areas like mobility,
                                                                   industries and cities, and the increasing speed
      Two developments are particularly important:                 of technological developments, are driving the
                                                                   emergence of a new energy economy, which
      –   The climate imperative. To avoid the most                will be more electrified, efficient, interconnected
          damaging effects of global warming, the                  and clean.
                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025   40
                     Vision 2025
                     Increasing the electrification of                         approximately 6% fugitive emissions from the oil and
                                                                               gas industry.88 In total, 60% of current emissions
                     energy uses to reduce emissions                           would be reduced by electrifying road transport,
                                                                               buildings and low-temperature industrial processes,
                     The electrification of end uses offers higher potential   in combination with renewable power generation.89
                     in reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The
                     three energy uses that are ready for transformation
                     include:                                                  Benefiting from efficiency
                     –   Mobility: the electrification of road transport
                                                                               gains through electrification
                         would reduce current equivalent CO2 emissions
                         by approximately 12%.84                               One of the key benefits of electrification, particularly
                                                                               electrification powered by renewables, is the
                     –   Buildings: electrification of heating would reduce    enormous efficiency gain that can be realized: this
                         equivalent CO2 emissions by approximately 6%.85       approach will halve the primary energy requirements
                                                                               of most economies.
                     –   Industry: all processes with industrial heat
                         requirements below 1,000° C could be                  The current energy system is wasteful. In the United
                         electrified with technologies available today,        States alone, approximately 70% of primary energy
                         eliminating approximately 6% of equivalent            is “rejected energy”. An electric car uses about one-
                         CO2 emissions.86                                      third of the energy than a car with a diesel or petrol
                                                                               engine. A heat pump powered by clean electricity
                     Direct electrification is the obvious winner in           provides two to four times as much heat to a home
  Accelerating the
                     these three sectors for speed, scale and cost.            as a boiler powered by natural gas. Similarly, on
decarbonization of
                     This is because the technologies already exist,           the supply side, renewable power plants are far
the power sector     and in fact are easier to access for retrofit due         more efficient than their fossil fuel counterparts,90
(on current uses)    to shorter lifespans. In addition, accelerating           as coal and gas power plants lose almost half
would further        the decarbonization of the power sector (on               of their energy as heat. In addition, a typically
reduce emissions     current uses) would further reduce emissions by           underappreciated benefit of clean electrification
by approximately     approximately 30%.87 Finally, the displacement of         is the elimination of supply chains for mining and
30%.                 fossil fuels would have a positive impact on the          moving the fossil fuels around the globe.
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025   41
Pathways to Vision 2025
Mainstreaming policy and action                         –   Focus on critical industries. Several
                                                            industries must scale ten-fold: electric
                                                            vehicle production, heat pump production,
Clean technology has reached maturity. Now,                 battery production, and wind and solar
additional policy, regulation and strategy are              energy production.
needed for massive deployment. Governments
may take the lead on policies to support the            –   Train the workforce. Unprecedented
transformation, which will have major economic              levels of workforce training are needed,
and environmental benefits in the long run. This            including retraining and incentives for the
support includes:                                           fossil fuel industry workforce to transition
                                                            to electrification.
Enabling electrification by                                 from consumers to service providers. Those
                                                            providers, in turn, reach agreements with
empowering demand                                           insurers, energy companies and institutional
                                                            investors ready to take over both capital for
The electricity grid was designed for consistent,           retrofitting and even operational expenses, in
predictable power generation, while large                   exchange for reasonable performance paybacks.
amounts of variable renewables will be
needed for decarbonization. New digital
technologies, however, can be incorporated              Evolving economic policy
that can make the demand flexible enough to
accommodate fluctuations in generation.
                                                        Current policies in most countries are still adapted
Strategies for enabling electrification by empowering   to a fossil-fuel based energy system. This situation
demand include:                                         must change to unlock clean energy technologies.
–   Focus on deployment. Technology is ready            Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
    to meet that challenge. Both hardware and
    software technologies are readily available:        –   Align fiscal tools with decarbonization
    distributed energy resources, vehicle-to-grid           goals. Clean technologies typically have
    charging and smart metres are just some                 higher up-front capital costs and lower
    examples. What is missing now are the market            ongoing fuel and maintenance costs than the
    mechanisms to allow those technologies to be            polluting alternatives. This challenge needs to
    deployed at scale.                                      be met with financing that makes the future
                                                            more affordable.
–   Promote new business models. Such models
    should transfer capital expenditures and risk       –   Remove subsidies for fossil fuels. Subsidies
    from smaller players to financial providers and         and tax incentives for fossil fuels are still
    empower all stakeholders to become active               present in many countries. Due to this market
    contributors to a decarbonized power grid.91            distortion, a residential customer typically has
    A promising model is “Energy as a Service”,             no economic incentive to change their heating
    which shifts the cost and responsibility of the         system from fossil fuels to cleaner alternatives,
    design, installation, maintenance and even              and it also negatively impacts the economics of
    management of distributed energy resources              electric vehicles vis-à-vis petrol-powered cars.
                                                                                         Future Focus 2025    42
   Regulation is       Strengthening and                                          products and services but also the life-cycle
needed for new         improving standards                                        carbon footprint of products and services. Such
buildings to comply                                                               improvements in standards will push the world
with emission                                                                     towards better usage of existing resources
limits and for         Product standards provide the necessary tools              and a circular economy, which benefits both
                       and guidance to designers, producers, planners,            the climate and the wider environment.
existing buildings
                       builders, financiers and operators to ensure safety,
to meet a carbon
                       reliability and operability. Standards can also be     –   Strategize the application of standards
performance            a critical part of ensuring that products are being        to buildings. Regulation is needed for new
benchmark that         manufactured with climate change in mind.                  buildings to comply with emission limits
is increasingly                                                                   and for existing buildings to meet a carbon
stringent over time.   Strategies for strengthening and improving                 performance benchmark that is increasingly
                       standards include:                                         stringent over time. National building codes
                                                                                  should be based on carbon emissions (instead
                       –   Strengthen standards that have already                 of energy), be performance-based (instead of
                           proven effective. Good examples are                    prescriptive), encourage clean electrification
                           CO2 limits for new fleet emissions for car             and use total life-cycle costs, including the
                           manufacturers in Europe, renewable portfolio           social costs of carbon emissions, in cost–
                           standards in the United States, and efficiency         benefit analyses. Performance standards for
                           requirements for new buildings and large               existing buildings should build on existing
                           retrofits. These standards are crucial so              performance benchmarking and labelling
                           that value chains of future products and               policies by requiring owners to retrofit non-
                           services can be set up to push down costs              compliant buildings. This would significantly
                           and accelerate adoption. One of the most               increase the renovation rate of existing buildings
                           important areas for improvement is lowering            above the currently insufficient 1-2% per year.
                           not just the carbon costs of manufacturing
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   43
             2.3      Energy transition
                      A successful global energy transition needs a
                      strategic vision and clear ambition from leaders
                      from government, industry and finance.
                      The energy sector remains at the heart of climate          billion people continue to use destructive
                      challenges, with energy consumption and                    and polluting charcoal, wood and biomass
                      production responsible for more than two-thirds of         for cooking.92
                      global GHG emissions due to strong dependence
                      on fossil fuels. Energy also continues to play a       –   Widening gap between action and
                      central role in enabling economic development              commitments. Despite a plethora of climate
                      and growth, and the secure and reliable access             commitments by industry leaders, financial
                      to modern forms of energy is essential for the             institutions and governments, global emissions
                      realization of the SDGs. For global climate targets        are still on an upward trajectory with an
                      and the SDGs to be met, the clean energy transition        increase of close to 5% in 2021 over 202093
                      towards sustainable and inclusive energy systems           as the world economy recovered and policies,
                      therefore needs great acceleration globally.               investments and measures to put emission
                                                                                 on a path to continued decline have not
                      Key trends include:                                        materialized at a global scale. Scepticism is
                                                                                 growing about the robustness of these pledges
                      –   Sectoral energy transition approaches and              and the willingness to implement them.
                          revolutions. Recognition is growing that a
                          sector-by-sector energy transition approach        A successful global energy transition needs a
   New and                will be needed because of sector-specific          strong strategic vision and clear ambitions from
                          energy transition challenges, including specific   leaders from government, industry and finance.
strengthened
                          political and technological considerations.        With only eight years left to halve GHG emissions
commitments,
                                                                             to be on track to limit global warming to below
targets and           –   Increased focus on energy access and               1.5° C by the end of the century, a much stronger
partnerships are          modern cooking. Concerns are mounting that         focus on the execution and implementation of
required to put           COVID-19 has dismantled the steady progress        energy transition plans and strategies is needed
the world on a            towards affordable, reliable and sustainable       now. New and strengthened commitments,
pathway out of            energy. The number of people without access        targets and partnerships are also required to put
the climate crisis.       to electricity increased in 2021, and 2.6          the world on a pathway out of the climate crisis.
                                                                                                            Future Focus 2025    44
                        Vision 2025
                        Fostering industrial                                    Innovating low-carbon policy
                        competitiveness and
                        sectoral revolutions                                    Policy to support technological change will
                                                                                continue to play a crucial role in accelerating
                        In some sectors, decarbonization solutions are          the transition and scaling technologies. Even as
                        mature and readily available (e.g. electricity); in     more governments adopt carbon taxes and other
                        others, the solutions are still emerging (e.g. steel,   signals, the market alone will not cut pollution fast
                        cement, aluminium and aviation). At COP26 in            enough. The role of policy is to pick candidates
                        Glasgow, a sectoral approach to problem-solving         and potential enablers to accelerate developments.
                        was already on display and major commitments            These are technological systems that make it
                        were made.                                              possible for many other sectors of the economy to
                                                                                cut their emissions, such as hydrogen and carbon
                        In national conversations, the transformation           capture, utilization and storage (CCUS). In every
                        of fossil-fuel-based infrastructure needs to be         technological cluster where progress is fast, such
                        reframed as an opportunity to increase domestic         as wind and solar, batteries, efficient lighting and
                        industrial competitiveness by creating industries       electric vehicles, government policy has played
                        of the future. Countries that are leading the net-      an active role. However, a proper selection of
                        zero transition are creating incentives for the         technological contenders that should be supported
                        rest of the world to do the same. For example,          and the creation of markets for new technologies
                        announcements of the European Union (EU)                while avoiding mercantilism is challenging. Low-
                        introducing carbon-border tax adjustments have          carbon transition policy must focus not only on
                        sent shockwaves, with countries behind in the           stimulating new innovations but must also actively
                        race for decarbonization fearing impacts on the         phase out high-carbon technologies and sectors
                        competitiveness of their industry exports.              through both market incentives and industrial policy.
   Emerging             Mobilizing finance for transition                       Managing transition risks and
markets account                                                                 a just transition
for only one-fifth of
global investment       The deep decarbonization revolution will be
                        more capital-intensive than earlier energy              A just transition to a future clean energy system
in clean energy
                        systems, so the role for finance in the global          means one that takes care of the industries
yet for two-thirds
                        energy transition will be even greater. Finance         and workers directly impacted. Further, the
of the world’s          needs to be attracted to where it is most               transition also needs to be just with regard to
population.             needed, particularly to emerging markets, which         the countries that are experiencing some of the
                        account for only one-fifth of global investment         greatest impacts of global warming, particularly
                        in clean energy yet for two-thirds of the world’s       those enduring the effects of rising seas. A just
                        population.94 Access to finance remains a key           transition requires compensation and action.
                        bottleneck due to real or perceived risks, and
                        the costs of raising capital are often very high.
                        Nominal financing costs in some economies
                        are estimated to be up to seven times higher
                        than in the United States and Europe.95
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025   45
                  Pathways to Vision 2025
                  Scaling technological enablers                                capital, for example through Net-Zero Equity,96
                                                                                a new and innovative concept incubated within
                                                                                the World Economic Forum Global Future
                  The most important technological enablers for                 Council on the Energy Transition.
                  decarbonization are renewable electricity and electric
                  power. With renewables becoming the cheapest              –   Leverage Fourth Industrial Revolution
                  source of electricity in many countries already, energy       technologies. Emerging technologies, such
                  uses in the transport, heating and industrial sectors         as AI, have tremendous potential to accelerate
                  will increasingly switch from direct combustion of            and support the global energy transition, can be
                  fossil fuels to renewable electricity. The expansion          used to run energy systems more intelligently
                  of electricity will require sizeable investments into         and efficiently, and can help with the integration
                  renewable sources like solar and wind, but also in            of renewable generators that are more variable
                  transmission and storage facilities, and in emerging          and intermittent.97
                  digital technologies that can help run energy
                  systems more efficiently and intelligently. Investment    –   Help developing countries to leapfrog.
                  in clean, dispatchable power generation that can              Around 88% of the growth in electricity demand
                  adjust output in tandem with renewable generators             between 2019 and 2040 will likely come
                  that are more variable and intermittent will also be          from emerging markets.98 These countries
                  needed. Important enablers include hydrogen (in               have significant opportunities to leapfrog to
                  particular for some hard-to-abate applications, such          sustainable electricity systems and skip the
                  as high-temperature heat industrial applications) and         deployment of emission-intensive electricity
                  CCUS (for decarbonizing many industrial sectors).             infrastructure based on fossil fuels.99
   The most
important
                  Strategies for scaling technological enablers include:    –   Get global supply chains for critical energy
technological                                                                   transition materials right. Setting global
enablers for      –   Address the financing gap in developing                   standards and supporting innovation to boost
decarbonization       economies. It is possible to develop new                  supply diversity will help to eradicate potential
are renewable         and innovative financial concepts to support              choke points as global demand for materials
electricity and       the energy transition, tackle risk aversion of            such as lithium, cobalt and copper continues
electric power.       conventional capital and unlock new sources of            to increase.100
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025      46
                      Forming alliances                                     Enhancing international
                                                                            cooperation and public-private
   The First Movers   In every sector, transformative change is led by      partnerships
Coalition is an       alliances of the most committed governments and
example from hard-    firms willing to bear the risk of bringing emerging   The transformative changes described here will not
to-abate sectors      technologies to maturity and commercial scale.        be imposed by internationally agreed action plans
                      The more selective these alliances, the more          or orchestrated simply by setting global targets. It
willing to mobilize
                      they choose their members strictly based on           will require firms collaborating with governments,
the necessary
                      their ability to contribute to real innovation and    for when truly disruptive technologies are created,
investments           problem-solving, the more powerful they are and       the risks are daunting for private firms to bear
in emerging           the easier it is for cooperation to stay credible.    them alone. Such public-private partnerships are
technologies,                                                               an opportunity for the public sector to provide
thereby creating      Strategies for forming alliances include:             the foundational capital or financial conditions
a strong demand                                                             necessary to support private-sector innovation.
signal.               –   Demand alliances. To jump-start global
                          demand, governments and customers who             International cooperation will be essential so
                          need low-carbon products should send              that risks can be pooled and bigger markets for
                          credible demand signals to successful             successful innovation and clean new products can
                          innovators (for example through long-term off-    be created. Cooperation can also revolve around
                          take agreements), thereby helping to mobilize     removing regulatory barriers, supporting credible
                          the necessary investments and decrease            policy and creating common standards or joint
                          costs. For example, corporate demand for          declarations. At COP26, bold announcements were
                          clean electricity, through corporate power        made of new partnerships related to switching to
                          purchase agreements, has the potential to         electric vehicles for whole countries, sending a
                          drive significant investment in renewable         credible signal to the world’s suppliers that demand
                          energy. Alliances like the Clean Energy           for new technology will grow substantially.
                          Demand initiative (CEDI)101 are supporting
                          countries and companies to enable corporate       Strategies for enhancing international cooperation
                          renewable procurement. The First Movers           and public-private partnerships include:
                          Coalition is another example from hard-to-
                          abate sectors willing to mobilize the necessary   –   Build international cooperation on
                          investments in emerging technologies,                 compensation for loss and damage.
                          thereby creating a strong demand signal               Providing financial and technical assistance
                          to innovators and others capable of                   to the countries that will be most affected by
                          developing viable technological solutions.102         climate warming will be crucial.
                      –   Align climate and trade policies. Trade and       –   Realize the geopolitical reality. Deep cuts
                          investment regimes have a large impact on             in emission will not diffuse around the world
                          how capital and goods flow. For too long,             unless the United States, China, the EU and
                          the worlds of trade and climate have been             India find a way to engage and collaborate.
                          separated. Trade and investment regimes
                          should be designed in a way that first movers     –   Scale mature technologies through
                          do not only bear the costs of going first, but        cooperation. Examples include demand
                          also reap the benefits of bigger markets and          alliances, removal of regulatory barriers and
                          more robust competition.                              common standards that can help create
                                                                                larger global markets, and incentives to mass
                                                                                production and deployment (for example,
                                                                                common standards for electric vehicle plugs).
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   47
2.4   Nature-based solutions
      More than half of the world’s GDP is
      dependent upon nature and its services and
      is therefore at the risk of severe disruption.
      According to the International Union for                    and societal goals need to be addressed
      Conservation of Nature (IUCN), one-quarter                  simultaneously to feed the growing population.
      of flora and fauna species are at the risk of
      extinction. However, presuming that protecting,         –   Greater pressure on the public sector to
      restoring and safeguarding nature is merely an              remove and repurpose harmful subsidies.
      environmental question could not be farther                 Two per cent of global GDP is estimated to be
      from the truth. The World Economic Forum                    spent on environmentally harmful subsidies.
      New Nature Economy Report series shows                      There is an urgent need for intervention
      that more than half of the world’s GDP is                   so that taxpayer funds are not invested in
      dependent upon nature and its services and                  activities that harm public goods. This has
      is therefore at risk of severe disruption.103               huge implications for national budgets where
                                                                  it is not only about increasing the budget
      Three key trends are driving the agenda for nature-         for environmental outcomes, but defunding
      based solutions agenda:                                     harmful streams, such as subsidies on
                                                                  fossil fuel, overuse of chemical fertilizers
      –   Greater integration of climate change,                  and pesticides and water contamination.
          biodiversity and land restoration goals.
          Nature-based solutions may provide a third          –   Greater social equity and environmental
          of the solutions to mitigate climate change;            outcomes. Global resource extraction has
          this prioritization strengthens when looking            tripled over the past 50 years, yet 840 million
          at climate adaptation particularly in poor              people still lack access to electricity.104 Those
          countries with underdeveloped infrastructure.           who least benefit from modern lifestyles
          Companies will seek to invest in the protection         suffer the greatest impact of climate change
          and restoration of natural assets to compensate         and nature loss. Clashes and civil unrest will
          for their net-zero transition pathway shortfalls.       ensue unless these trends are reversed and
          Food and agriculture systems will especially            issues of social and racial equity are put at
          provide a space where multiple environmental            the centre of the environmental movement.
                                                                                                Future Focus 2025     48
                   Vision 2025
                   Unlocking private-sector                                  option. Lessons can be learned from the Indigenous
                                                                             and local communities that comprise less than 5%
                   investment in nature                                      of the world’s population but protect 80% of world’s
                                                                             biodiversity.108 Companies from across business
                   A nature-positive pathway could generate an               sectors are working with initiatives like the Tropical
                   estimated $10 trillion in new annual business             Forest Alliance and 1t.org to halt commodity driven
                   value and create 395 million jobs by 2030.105             deforestation and protect and restore forests,
                   To capture the $10 trillion available in all nature-      respectively. Since the launch of 1t.org’s global
                   positive business opportunities by 2030 would             pledge process in September 2021, over 30
                   require $2.7 trillion per year of redirected funding      companies have committed to conserve, restore and
                   through to 2030. Public-sector funds alone will not       grow more than 3.6 billion trees in over 60 countries.
                   be enough. Private-sector financial flows are also
                   needed to create better outcomes for nature.106
                                                                             Enhancing policy coherence for
                   To unlock private-sector investment in nature,
                   progress needs to be made to:
                                                                             environmental outcomes
                   –   Defund nature-negative activities, particularly in    More than $700 billion a year is needed to reverse
                       commodity supply chains                               the global biodiversity crisis.109 However, conflicting
                                                                             incentives in governments’ fiscal, economic,
                   –   Increase financial flows for nature-based solutions   finance, trading and development cooperation
                                                                             policies are a serious concern. For example,
                   –   Value nature for its intact habitats and              according to a report from the United Nations
                       ecosystem services                                    Development Programme and the Food and
                                                                             Agriculture Organization, almost 90% of the $540
                                                                             billion in annual farming subsidies are harmful.110
                   Living in harmony with nature
                                                                             Signs indicate that society may be locked into
                                                                             a system that put us on a path that is nature-
                   Earth Overshoot Day marks “the date when                  negative. At COP26 in Glasgow, nine multilateral
    A nature-      humanity’s demand for ecological resources and            development banks “launched a joint statement
positive pathway   services in a given year exceeds what Earth can           outlining actions that they will take to mainstream
                   regenerate in that year”.107 In 2021, this day was        nature into their policies, analysis, assessments,
could generate
                   29 July and it is arriving earlier every year, which      advice and assessments in line with their
an estimated $10   means current populations are borrowing from              respective mandates”.111 By 2025, increased
trillion in new    future generations and jeopardizing their right to        cross-sectoral policy coherence and alignment
annual business    an environmentally safe and sustainable life.             of public- and private-sector financing start
value and create                                                             to create environments that unlocks funding
395 million jobs   Awareness has increased recently in all sections of       to support nature-positive approaches.
by 2030.           the society that business as usual is no longer an
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   49
Pathways to Vision 2025
Implementing nature-positive                             –   Adopt nature-positive strategies. Nature-
                                                             positive strategies should be a normal part of
business models                                              decision-making, in that they are understood to
                                                             enable greater competitiveness and resilience.
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway                 Over the past decade, the MSCI Emerging
include:                                                     Markets ESG Leaders Index outshone the
                                                             broader MSCI Emerging Markets Index, with
–   Understand, value and disclose impact                    annualized gross returns of 6.3% versus
    and dependency on nature. This will help                 3.0%, a clear reflection of the profitability
    prevent risk mispricing and inaccurate capital           of ESG investing.113 Moreover, the 2016
    buffers to both short-term risk events and               Cone Communications Millennial Employee
    more chronic impacts. Nature-related risks               Engagement Study found that most millennials,
    can be incorporated within existing ERM                  who will make up 75% of the job market by
    and ESG processes, investment decision-                  2025, will not take a job with a company that
    making, and financial and non-financial                  lacks social responsibility values.114
    reporting.112 Many large companies have
    joined the Taskforce for Nature-Related              –   Lead and innovate to fast-track revenue-
    Financial Disclosures to help build out a                generating investments in nature. Corporates
    framework like climate-related financial risks.          can shift their procurement rules and supply
    chain investments to value nature-positive               2021.117 The private sector and corporate
    opportunities over harmful ones. Banks and               and financial organizations all have a critical
    investors, including multilateral development            responsibility to increase investments in nature.
    banks, can decline unsustainable business
    while providing capital, de-risking investments      –   Join existing initiatives. For much of these
    and creating asset classes for nature-positive           global commons’ challenges, there is no level
    projects.115 Deforestation, for example, can be a        playing field or clear rules of the game. Solving
    result of corporate supply chain and procurement         for these challenges requires greater public-
    decisions but also of financial institutions’            private dialogue and precompetitive collaboration
    decisions.116 Approximately $238 billion in credit       among committed actors. The success of
    was provided by banks and other financial                proposals such as payment for ecosystem
    institutions to deforestation-related commodity          services, high-integrity carbon markets and
    companies between January 2016 and June                  deforestation-free supply chains depends on
                                                                                          Future Focus 2025      50
    multistakeholder collaboration. Businesses              resources, making them cheaper and more
    should therefore look for a systems agenda              competitive than nature-positive investments
    by working together for a change that runs              in the short term.120 This must change.
    across the industry and economic segments.
    For example, World Economic Forum initiatives       –   Price externalities and support blended
    like the Tropical Forest Alliance and 1t.org.           finance. Formal pricing mechanisms for
                                                            carbon and ecosystem services, and blended
Creating an enabling policy                                 finance approaches to crowd-in private-sector
                                                            investment need to be created. For example,
environment                                                 the Inter-American Development Bank partnered
                                                            with the Global Environment Facility to establish
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       a $5 million Climate-Smart Agriculture Fund
                                                            for Latin America and the Caribbean. The fund
–   Enact policies to protect nature and                    offers risk-tolerant capital with long tenors to
    reform subsidies to value and provide                   encourage private investment by cushioning
    public goods. In most cases, current                    early losses and providing a concessional
    economic and financial norms and institutions           tranche of resources.121 Another example can
    do not consistently value and create a                  be seen in South Africa, which introduced a
    positive financial return for nature-positive           first-of-its kind biodiversity tax incentive into its
    investment.118 According to a United Nations            legislation. The tax incentive allows landowners
    2021 study, of the $540 billion agricultural            such as farmers or communities, who commit
    subsidies per year (15% of total agricultural           to setting aside and managing their land as
    production value), 87% is price-distorting              protected areas, to receive a fiscal benefit. It is
    and environmentally and socially harmful.119            estimated to contribute close to 10% additional
    This means that, ultimately, environmentally            finance in closing South Africa’s biodiversity
    harmful actions are often supported with public         finance gap.122
                                                                                          Future Focus 2025   51
2.5   Net-zero transition
      Transforming net-zero commitments
      into tangible company-level action with
      transparent metrics that can be monitored
      and evaluated has never been more urgent.
      With only eight years to achieve a 50% emission       –   Radical collaboration is essential to close the
      reduction target by 2030, transforming net-zero           2030 ambition to implementation gap. Current
      commitments into tangible company-level                   net-zero measures are not matching the speed
      action with transparent metrics that can be               and scale of the climate crisis and continuing
      monitored and evaluated has never been more               with business as usual will not move the needle
      urgent. COP26 in Glasgow saw a groundswell                fast enough. Delivering critical 2030 milestones
      of corporate net-zero commitments and over                will require radical collaboration, sequenced
      1,000 companies have logged 1.5° C-aligned                interventions between industry, government,
      targets.123 Yet business leaders across all sectors       finance and technology and a tangible pipeline
      are struggling to demonstrate tangible results            of bankable projects aimed at scaling up critical
      and measuring impact against targets through              components of the transition, including transition
      accountability mechanisms.                                fuels, infrastructure and production facilities.
      The three emerging trends to consider when            –   Investment must rapidly scale up. Clean energy
      advancing corporate action on net zero are:               investment must triple by 2030, to $4 trillion.124
                                                                At the same time, emerging technologies must
      –   Increasing accountability is critical.                be brought to market and significant R&D funds
          While leading companies have adopted                  are required for these technologies to reach
          net-zero targets, they are as yet unable to           commercialization.
          elaborate credible plans for transitioning
          to net zero. In the absence of plans and          The World Economic Forum Global Future Council on
          transparent mechanisms for tracking progress,     Net-Zero Transition has identified two critical thematic
          corporate commitments will continue to face       priority areas to address the tipping points and
          scepticism and greenwashing concerns.             advance solutions to reach net zero by mid-century.
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   52
                      Vision 2025
                      Increasing net-zero accountability                        –   Targets: Uncertainties include the availability
                                                                                    of technologies, abatement costs, consumer
                                                                                    behaviour and perception, and a lack of data.
                      Just before COP26, the Intergovernmental
                      Panel on Climate Change released its latest               –   Collaboration: Value chain collaboration,
                      assessment report, which warned about getting                 supported by government policy, is key to
                      closer to a series of climate breakdown tipping               address value chain emissions. Value chains
                      points. Following COP26, a range of analysis                  are often cross-border, therefore a systemic
                      was produced that illustrated the importance                  approach is needed. Coalitions such as the
                      of implementing the pledges made. The Global                  global Race to Zero campaign can help.
                      Future Council on Net-Zero Transition will focus
                      on delivering a framework for business leaders to         Standardizing accounting and reporting
                      follow and developing a common set of net-zero
                      metrics that may be integrated into corporate             –   Data harmonization and standards: No
                      governance models and ESG principles.                         standardization or common metrics across
                                                                                    industries and value chains exists. Harmonization
                      Defining net-zero pathways                                    is necessary to enable the flow of information
                                                                                    and the measurement of Scope 1, 2 and 3
   Data               –   Strategy: Corporate net-zero strategies must be           emissions, without double counting.
harmonization             tailored to their industry and region of operation.
                          Certain industries have more complicated value        –   Accounting and reporting: Climate accounting
is necessary to
                          chains and operations that are highly energy              and reporting is voluntary in most countries.
enable the flow of        intense with few lower carbon alternatives.               Collecting emissions data, summarizing findings
information and the       Hence it is not always easy to define the net-            and reporting their GHG inventories can be
measurement of            zero pathway. At the same time, countries                 challenging for actors with long or complex
Scope 1, 2 and 3          face similar challenges as they need to assess            value chains, given varying data quality and
emissions, without        impacts on the economy, job security and                  double counting.
double counting.          geopolitical aspects.
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025     53
   Net-zero action     Choreographing the net-                                     –   900,000 zero-emission trucks on European
in the hard-to-                                                                        roads with at least 290,000 charging points
                       zero transition                                                 and 2,500 refuelling stations
abate industry
sectors that
                       Net-zero action in the hard-to-abate industry               –   Over 300 sustainable aviation fuel (SAF)
account for 30%
                       sectors that account for 30% of global GHG                      plants (50 of them in the EU) producing
of global GHG
                       emissions is critical to lowering emissions. Existing           approximately 30 million tons of SAF to
emissions is           institutional frameworks and processes are not                  achieve a 10% share in global jet aviation
critical to lowering   adapted to the scale and urgency of the challenge.              fuel supply
emissions.             To achieve the step-change needed, collaborative
                       choreography must bring industry, government,               –   10 green corridors or approximately
                       financial institutions and other stakeholders                   100 deep sea zero-emission propulsion
                       together around tangible interventions. The Council             ready ships to ensure zero-emission fuels
                       has identified two key challenges in this area:                 comprise 5% of international shipping
                                                                                       fuels and 15% of domestic shipping fuels
                       A clear vision of decarbonization
                       2030 milestones                                         A net-zero choreography
                       –   For action to be efficient and effective, a         –   Creative thinking can identify the collaborative
                           more granular and clear-eyed understanding              models for radical action and collaboration
                           of the scale of the short-, mid- and long-              to respond urgently to the crisis.
                           term goals industry sectors must deliver
                           by 2030 is necessary. This vision will shift        –   Sectoral transition strategies and plans must be
                           the conversation and focus on the scale of              used as a basis for a pipeline of bankable net-
                           interventions and the choreography required             zero projects.
                           from leaders of industry, governments, financial
                           institutions and other stakeholders.                –   Sequenced interventions by government,
                                                                                   industry, finance, technology and other key
                       –   The Mission Possible Partnership has identified         stakeholders are needed to mobilize the
                           critical industry 2030 milestones:125                   green capital and technologies required
                                                                                   for bankable net-zero projects.
                           –   70 (near) zero steel plants producing
                               280 metric tonnes of steel annually
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025     54
                    Pathways to Vision 2025
                    Integrating strategy,                                       and address emissions across their value
                                                                                chain. Both countries and companies need to
                    measurement and reporting                                   establish long-term and interim targets that are
                                                                                ambitious and comprehensive. Targets need to
                    Immediate action must be taken to limit global              be science-based, for example via the Science
                    warming to below 1.5° C. This can only happen               Based Targets initiative.
                    when climate action is integrated in all business
                    and government decisions.                               –   Report and disclose emissions. The need
                                                                                has increased to monitor and track progress
                    Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       against net-zero commitments, including
                                                                                effective carbon accounting, implementation
                    –   Set the strategy. Countries are encouraged              plans and management strategies. Data
                        to update their Nationally Determined                   disclosure is key to ensure staying on track,
                        Contribution, alongside long-term goals.                for example using guidelines from the Task
                        Companies, on the other hand, need to include           Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures,
                        Scope 3 emissions in their climate strategies           and via CDP.
   Ambitious        Synchronizing action to                                     –   Strong demand signals for greener products
companies should    support projects, policy,
put pressure                                                                    –   Supply scaling to meet that demand
on industry         demand and finance
                                                                                –   Public and private finance to facilitate the
bodies and other
                    In the global choreography efforts, five crucial                transition to cleaner supply
organizations to
establish sector-   areas must be considered: the supply side,
                    demand side, finance, policy-making and a just              –   A policy framework that mainstreams that
level targets for                                                                   shift from niche, premium markets to the
                    transition. Value chain collaboration supported
climate action.                                                                     wider economy and brings in or trains
                    by government policy is key to address value
                                                                                    workers with the skills and protections
                    chain emissions. Ambitious companies should
                                                                                    needed to deliver the transition, while
                    thus put pressure on industry bodies and other
                                                                                    caring for those unable to transition
                    organizations to establish sector-level targets
                    for climate action. Leading companies can also
                                                                            –   Join initiatives that address these challenges.
                    join forces with cross-sector policy groups to
                                                                                Some efforts, such as the Race to Zero
                    change the wider context for decarbonization                Campaign and the First Movers Coalition,
                    across value chains. Common policy                          are partnerships with governments, while the
                    recommendations provide a strong message                    Mission Possible Partnership supports sector-
                    that business wants support to decarbonize.126              level targets and cross-industry collaborations.
                    Strategies for operationalizing this pathway            –   Spread the message. Becoming a climate
                    include:                                                    leader in the region or industry, spearheading
                                                                                initiatives and supporting projects that lead to a
                    –   Coordinate movement across each of                      competitive advantage towards the transition
                        these levers:127                                        are key.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025     55
2.6   SDG investment
      The goals of the 2030 Agenda require
      concerted global stakeholder cooperation.
      Two years into the decade of delivery, the                 –   Integration of just-transition logic in
      financing gap that must be closed to achieve the               development and climate finance. While
      SDGs remains large. Indeed, according to the                   the net-zero transition has been the main
      Organisation for Economic Co-operation and                     catalyst for investment and sustainable and
      Development (OECD), the global financial impact                development finance, the COVID-19 pandemic
      of COVID-19 has caused the SDG financing gap to                has spurred greater emphasis on ensuring a just
      grow from $2.5 trillion annually to $3.7 trillion.128 At       and inclusive transition.
      the same time, the pandemic has also highlighted
      the ominous and uncontrollable power of nature.            –   Public-private cooperation and financing
      As a result, the past two years have represented               roadmaps. The private sector continues to
      a milestone in the financial world, witnessing the             increase investment and financing in the SDGs.
      flourishing of sustainable finance that is becoming            To scale this investment to reach the trillions
      increasingly mainstream. While there is still                  required to bridge the financing gap, the public
      time to meet the Agenda 2030 for sustainable                   sector has stepped in to facilitate and de-risk
      development, some trends that are shaping the                  these investments by providing non-financial
      SDG investment ecosystem are encouraging, while                interventions, blended finance and clear
      others are less so.                                            financing pathways.
      –   SDG mainstreaming. Though ESG metrics are              The fragmentation of efforts and activities has been an
          becoming embedded in portfolio management              enduring feature of development finance. Only through
          and financial decision-making, the SDGs are            a concerted, global effort of cooperation among
          increasingly seen by a few categories of investors     all relevant stakeholders can the goals of the 2030
          as a key measure of investment impact.                 Agenda for Sustainable Development be achieved.
                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025   56
                    Vision 2025
                    Mobilizing private capital for                            By 2025, there is greater understanding about
                                                                              climate change and social development being
                    emerging markets                                          two global, intertwined and equally important
                                                                              challenges: solving one without addressing the
                    The SDGs are intended to embody a global vision           other will fail to deliver an economy and a society
                    for a sustainable, inclusive and equitable world.         that works for all. Investor strategies to transition
                    The amount of investment required to meet such            to a more resilient and sustainable economy
                    an ambitious objective is substantial. A shift of 1.1%    incorporate the full range of ESG dimensions
                    of the $379 trillion assets managed globally towards      of responsible investment, supporting an
                    the SDGs could bridge the $3.7 trillion financing         inclusive and just framework for all people and
                    gap.129 Public finance alone cannot solve the issue.      communities.131 The SDGs offer a solid framework
                    The private sector will be critical to the realization    to incorporate these principles into their climate
                    of the SDGs.                                              and transition strategies.
                    By 2025, the private sector should increase efforts to
                    fill the investment gap needed for meeting the SDGs,      Harmonizing disclosure and
                    deployed closer to the speed and scale required.
                    This mobilization is also not happening where it is
                                                                              measurement
                    most needed: in emerging and developing countries.
                    Concerted effort is made by all stakeholders to           As investors turn the SDGs into a new asset class,
                    address key issues undermining the SDGs:130               the resulting plethora of impact measurement
                                                                              systems and reporting tools has created
                    –   The risk profile of these economies often             fragmentation, lack of transparency and
    A shift of          viewed unfavourably by investors due to               inconsistency. According to an analysis conducted
1.1% of the $379        macroeconomic, institutional and political            by the World Economic Forum Global Future
trillion assets         factors, and information asymmetry exacerbates        Council on SDG Investment, only 3 of the 15 most
managed globally        this situation.                                       prominent impact measurement and management
towards the SDGs                                                              frameworks are mapped to the 17 SDGs. This
                    –   Many large institutional investors perceive limited   situation can expose companies and investors to
could bridge
                        investments in climate-vulnerable economies,          accusations of green- and sustainability-washing.
the $3.7 trillion
                        for example in small island developing states.
financing gap.                                                                By 2025, nascent efforts to create international
                    –   Transparency and clarity around projects and          standards, such as the newly created International
                        outcomes are lacking.                                 Sustainability Standards Board, the development
                                                                              of a European taxonomy for sustainable activities,
                                                                              or the G7 Impact Taskforce, provide clearer
                    Integrating social factors into                           indications and definitions for investors and
                                                                              decision-makers, setting the foundations for the
                    climate and transition finance                            sustainability architecture that will accelerate the
                                                                              transition to a net-positive and just economy. This
                    The climate and energy transitions have been              architecture respects the diversity in the global
                    the main focus of sustainable and development             markets and does not channel money away from
                    finance since the adoption of the Paris Agreement         where it is most needed. To ensure this, regulations
                    on climate change in 2015. Similarly, the “E” in          should avoid restrictive propositions that impede
                    ESG has been the focus of mainstream investors            the flow of capital towards emerging markets or
                    in search of sustainable investments. As a result,        measurement systems that favour developed
                    other SDGs such as SDG 1 (no poverty), SDG 2              countries over developing ones. At the same time,
                    (zero hunger), SDG 8 (decent work and economic            regulations encourage and foster investments
                    growth) or SDG 10 (reduced inequalities) have             that generate financial additionality and support
                    received relatively less attention, and less funding.     transition efforts.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   57
Pathways to Vision 2025
De-risking emerging and                                    private investors.132 While development finance
                                                           institutions and multilateral development banks
developing countries for                                   have played a strategic role in the development
private-sector participation                               pathways, they have been slow in adapting
                                                           to changing markets and contexts and may
To unlock greater capital for sustainable                  crowd out greater private-sector involvement.
development in emerging and developing                     However, they continue to and can increasingly
economies, it is imperative to address the real            play a key role in lowering risk and crowd in
and perceived risk concerns of the private sector.         greater private-sector involvement.
Adopting a broader, more comprehensive and
macro approach towards risk is needed by all           –   Improve non-financial de-risking measures.
actors across the investment value chain.                  Risk mitigation predominantly has been
                                                           understood in the deployment of financial
Strategies that can serve this purpose include:            risk-sharing instruments, such as guarantees,
                                                           first loss facilities and insurance, to transfer
–   Leverage blended finance. The use of                   part of the risk premium associated with
    catalytic capital from public or philanthropic         specific transactions. However, risk mitigation
    sources to increase private-sector participation       needs to be understood beyond financial risk
    has been in place for a certain time. However,         mitigation products, towards a broader concept
    the actors involved have been slow in adopting         of non-financial risk mitigation measures and
    the necessary changes required to bring it to          in improving overall investment climates for
    scale and make it a mainstream approach for            increased private-sector participation.133
Creating pathways for                                      market players to jointly define the actions
                                                           required to increase the sources of capital
SDG investment                                             needed to finance meeting the SDGs through
                                                           an impartial, multistakeholder approach. The
The trillions needed to finance the 2030 Agenda            SIP initiative can support market players to:
must bring together public- and private-sector
finance, but real and perceived risks to investment        1. Outline risks and barriers preventing
prevent greater private-sector involvement in                 greater coherence and investment in the
emerging and developing economies. This is                    sectors or value chains where greater
partly due to the lack of clear strategies and                sustainable investment is needed
pathways that define and highlight the solutions,
actors and actions needed to address both the              2. Identify the policies, innovative solutions
non-financial and financial risks and barriers that           and financing mechanisms to build a more
currently prevent greater SDG investments.                    coherent and collaborative SDG investment
                                                              ecosystem in these sectors or value chains
–   Join the Sustainable Development
    Investment Partnership (SDIP). The SDIP                3. Decide and agree collaboratively on the “who
    has developed the Sustainable Investment                  and what” actions to be taken to complete
    Pathways (SIP) initiative to bring together               the formulation of an actionable SIP
    global and local public- and private-sector
                                                                                       Future Focus 2025   58
   Investors should   Raising ambition through                              Actionable recommendations include:
adopt impact          public-private cooperation
management                                                                  –   Promote an SDG investing label. Using this
principles,           and partnerships                                          label would allow asset allocators to know that
                                                                                they are part of the global movement to invest in
including impact
                      Commitments and sector-specific alliances calling         solving key global challenges but also to leave
measurement and
                      for a more sustainable-oriented financial sector          them discretion on which of the SDGs to focus on.
disclosures, and      have thrived in recent years. The Global Future
encourage investee    Council has been working with international           –   Overcome the perception that SDG investing
companies,            organizations and private-sector actors to launch         does not generate returns. Publishing
projects and          a new call to action towards the SDGs: the                reliable data on commercial returns from
funds to report       SDG Club. This call to action aims to provide             SDG investing, including the track-record of
on harmonized         practical recommendations to remove current               development finance institutions and private
impact metrics.       obstacles and bring together disparate labels,            impact investors, will make clear that impact
                      such as ESG and impact investing, with the                and returns are not incompatible strategies.
                      goal of helping asset allocators make the right
                      decisions on the “how and what” of investing in       –   Adopt impact management principles.
                      the SDGs. The initiative seeks to have 1% of global       Investors should adopt impact management
                      investable assets committed to SDG investing,             principles, including impact measurement
                      a number that could bridge the SDG gap.                   and disclosures, and encourage investee
                                                                                companies, projects and funds to report
                                                                                on harmonized impact metrics, so that
                                                                                asset allocators can obtain improved data
                                                                                and compare across their investments.
                                                                                                            Future Focus 2025   59
2.7   Sustainable tourism
      Tourism stakeholders can redesign
      sustainable destinations and practices
      across services and businesses.
      Although the tourism industry has been hit hard             both the inherent tourism and economic value
      by COVID-19, its hallmark resilience is expected            of protected areas and natural assets will be
      to foster its recovery. The prior decades’ tourism          crucial to preserving the long-term value of
      boom has challenged its sustainability, with                tourism to business and customers alike.
      overcrowding and the carbon footprint of flying
      remaining top public criticisms.                        –   Climate change action. Global industry
                                                                  has seen raised awareness and acceptance
      In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, key trends            of the urgency of climate action. Without
      that have amplified the need for swift and collective       adequate action and investment, climate
      action include:                                             change could disrupt the travel and tourism
                                                                  sector as it becomes particularly vulnerable
      –   Equitable and sustainable destinations.                 to climate impacts.
          Overcrowding, mismanaged growth and the
          degradation of natural and cultural assets          As the tourism industry recovers, stakeholders
          harmed the tourism sector prior to the              can redesign sustainable destinations and
          COVID-19 pandemic. Furthermore, benefits            practices across services and businesses. The
          from tourism were not adequately distributed to     World Economic Forum Global Future Council
          local economies and across the value chain.         on Sustainable Tourism evaluates the conditions,
                                                              metrics and policies needed for the success
      –   Value of the blue and green economy. Travel         of progressive business models that place
          and tourism investments and behaviours have         sustainability at the core and provide expert
          not adequately accounted for the value of the       guidance to the broader sector on how to build
          natural environment. Clear quantification of        forward better.
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025    60
Vision 2025
Ensuring equitable and                                  Consumer behaviour can drive demand and
                                                        shift practices in travel and tourism, but a
sustainable destinations                                lack of transparency and sufficient knowledge
                                                        exchange within the industry hinders coordinated
Over the past 50 years, the number of international     progress. Tourism organizations often struggle
travellers grew from 200 million to 1.5 billion.134     to determine which benchmarks or metrics to
As a result, many locations have struggled with         follow, and consumers have difficulty navigating
overtourism, while others have struggled to attract     and understanding relevant certifications. Smaller,
visitors and their capital for local conservation and   locally-based operators or tourism businesses are
local communities. Furthermore, tourism marketing       not well-enough resourced to adopt practices,
and the rise of social media have only served to        achieve certification or be appropriately compliant.
further stretch carrying capacity of many of the most
popular tourist destinations. Tourism marketing and     A rising demand for better tourism practices
management therefore must evolve to enable a            and services could be leveraged to build
sustainable future, with some conditions from the       more equitable and sustainable destinations,
COVID-19 crisis being conducive to an acceleration      capturing capital and value accordingly.
of sustainability practices and outcomes.
Investing in the blue and green                         not been accurately measured or considered in their
                                                        totality. Protected areas can provide a five-to-one
economy                                                 return on investment in direct revenue and have
                                                        a variety of benefits that are not captured by the
The tourism sector has long depended on the             market. Furthermore, there is potential for nature-
resources, beauty and economic activity                 based solutions to drive change in tourism as well
associated with natural environments. Coastal,          as contribute directly to broad economic efforts to
forest and mountain environments have served as         decarbonize and align with the SDGs. According
popular tourist destinations, and their popularity      to the EU Blue Economy Report 2021, in the EU27
has only increased during the pandemic where            alone, the blue economy provides 2-3% of total
customers have sought out nature-based locations        employment and 1.5% of GDP, excluding indirect
and experiences.                                        or induced income and employment. New sectors
                                                        such as blue biotechnology, algae production
Unfortunately, the true value and contribution of the   and ocean renewable energy are expected to
blue and green economies to and from tourism have       generate new green jobs and markets.135
                                                                                        Future Focus 2025   61
                     Aligning the travel and tourism                          industry was undertaken for COP26, which
                                                                              delivered a broad framework for achieving
                     sector with the climate ambition                         net zero in the sector.136 Several corporations
                                                                              have now committed to net zero and signed
                     Achieving net zero requires decision-making from         up for science-based targets, but this remains
                     the highest levels, a coordinated plan across            a small fraction of the entire supply chain
                     the public and private sectors, and appropriate          and does not extend to many SMEs.
                     financial and supporting mechanisms to achieve
                     the necessary transition. Given the diversity of         By 2025, all tourism stakeholders commit to
                     the sector, however, net-zero pathways differ            science-based targets and design their own
                     by industry vertical. Foundational work by the           net-zero pathways.
                     Pathways to Vision 2025
                     Aligning on global principles                                tourism behaviours. These can be showcased
                                                                                  to enable appropriate shifts in business, policy
                     for sustainable destinations                                 and consumer choices.138
                     To ensure a coordinated response that prioritizes        –   Reshape public policy. The crisis offers
                     the rebuilding of the sector in an equitable and             a reset opportunity; many destinations are
                     resilient manner, significant alignment among                considering taking action now or accelerating
                     stakeholders across the ecosystem will be required.          their plans for long-term sustainable destination
                                                                                  management and the Global Future Council is
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:        working on tools and guidance for experts.
                     –   Develop a shared vocabulary. Design a
                         coherent set of principles for sustainable           Making the case for the blue
                         destinations that will drive the behaviour of
   The inherent
                         businesses, governments and travellers alike.137
                                                                              and green economy
economic value
of the blue and      –   Demonstrate best-in-class innovations.               The inherent economic value of the blue and green
green economies is       Valuable examples already exist of cities, regions   economies is invaluable across geographies and
invaluable across        or countries that have adopted practices that        industries, but the need to highlight and stress
geographies              preserve culture and natural resources, calibrate    the opportunity to apply blue and green economy
and industries.          services and assets, and incentivize responsible     principles to the tourism sector is still great.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025      62
   Nature-based      Nature-based solutions, while addressing some of        journey of aligning with science-based targets,
solutions, while     the most pressing biodiversity and climate change       it is difficult to determine where to start, which
addressing some of   challenges, can drive tourism demand and revenues.      initiatives to prioritize, and how to measure
the most pressing    Practical guidance from industry leaders, such          progress and impact. It is therefore crucial for
                     as the Global Future Council, could broaden and         experts and leaders in the sector to highlight best
biodiversity and
                     accelerate the true valuation of natural assets and     practices, socialize well-respected methodologies
climate change       thus mobilize and scale the necessary investment        and mechanisms for measurement, and facilitate
challenges, can      into blue and green economy innovations.                transparency and accuracy in reporting.
drive tourism
demand and           Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
revenues.
                     –   Shape sustainable consumer behaviours.              –   Gather more commitments towards net-zero
                         Travellers demand more sustainable tourism              and metrics reporting. Experts can serve as
                         yet have a hard time knowing what to expect             champions for a net-zero future by encouraging
                         from businesses or what actions will really             the proliferation of efforts and commitments
                         have impact. The Global Future Council                  to climate action by many stakeholders.
                         is developing a set of behaviour changes,               Existing work on metrics and science-based
                         based on its work on destination principles.            targets can be built upon to facilitate progress,
                                                                                 consistency and transparency.
                     –   Provide practical guidelines for investment
                         decision-makers. The business case for              –   Highlight the role that tourism can play in
                         investment in blue and green economy initiatives        building resilience in destinations. As more
                         for the travel and tourism sector should be             businesses commit to reducing their carbon
                         articulated across stakeholder groups.139               footprint or reaching carbon neutrality, tourism
                                                                                 can play a large role in valuing nature-based
                     –   Advance global sustainability initiatives               carbon offsets and other benefits they bring
                         through tourism. The global reach and                   to destinations. This also intersects with work
                         importance of the tourism industry can                  done by the Friends of Ocean Action and its
                         be leveraged to further the application of              Mangroves Working Group.
                         blue and green economy principles.
                                                                             –   Emphasize public-private collaboration to
                                                                                 accelerate the energy transition. Collaboration
                     Advancing pathways to net zero                              across various tourism bodies should be
                                                                                 encouraged, and impactful collaborations across
                                                                                 the value chain that can accelerate action can
                     The development of clearly defined pathways to              be identified or highlighted. Work done by the
                     net zero and measurement to track progress are              World Travel & Tourism Council, the Science
                     key to shifting the sector’s trajectory and avoiding        Based Targets initiative and the UN High-Level
                     aggressive regulation down the track. However,              Champions serve as powerful foundations from
                     for many organizations newly embarking on a                 which to build such cohesion and collaboration.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025     63
3   Society
3.1   Education and skills
      The skills required to thrive in the post-COVID-19
      economy include innovation and creativity,
      global citizenship and civic responsibility,
      and interpersonal and intrapersonal skills.
      COVID-19 highlighted gaps in learning needs and             –   Unequal access to skills development.
      presented an opportunity to reassess them. An                   As the global pandemic continued to force
      especially high value is now being placed on human-             learning to shift online, new modalities of
      centric skills that cannot be easily automated, and             learning were being piloted and disseminated,
      there is newfound urgency to improve access to                  but uneven digital access further exacerbated
      skills for an increasingly automated world. The                 existing education and skills gaps between
      Great Resignation trend resulted from workers                   low- and high-resourced communities.
      seeking greater meaning and value from their
      jobs, and now employers struggle to find talent.            –   Limited recognition of skills pathways.
                                                                      Online credentialing, apprenticeships and
      Three key trends are driving the need for a new                 non-formal learning exist, yet these pathways
      education and skills agenda for the post-pandemic               are not broadly and equally recognized by
      economic recovery:                                              employers. The lack of systemic recognition
                                                                      of alternative learning pathways became a
      –   Unemployment and widening skills gaps.                      challenge in the pandemic context, where
          Employers struggle to find talent with the                  individuals required more flexible and rapid
          right skills due to the Great Resignation, new              forms of skilling to be able to keep pace
          immigration restrictions and limited labour mobility.       with changing labour-market demands.
          Additionally, reskilling and upskilling efforts have
          not kept pace. Competition among employers              Actors need to rapidly address these short-term
          for talent has increased bargaining power for           challenges to create resilient systems to meet the
          employees, and churns in job markets further            employment needs of individuals, businesses
          exacerbate skills gaps in the labour market.            and governments.
                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025    65
                     Vision 2025
                     Developing new economy skills                              prioritize teacher workforce training and development
                                                                                as an enabler of high-quality education systems.
                     The skills required to participate and thrive in the
                     post-COVID-19 economy include innovation and               Measuring new economy skills
                     creativity, global citizenship and civic responsibility,
                     digital literacy, and interpersonal and intrapersonal
                     skills.140 The 2030 vision in education and skills         As individuals gain and hone new economy skills,
                     systems is that every individual, regardless of            stakeholders will need to track these skills to
                     background, location or demographic, can access            make informed decisions about human capital
                     the tools needed to hone their skills. This has            management. Better data are needed to be able to
                     proven to be a challenge since the COVID-19                match people to jobs and learning opportunities,
                     pandemic has forced learning to shift online, casting      and to ensure that learning ultimately leads to
                     a new light on the digital divide and driving a further    employment. Several indicators must be measured,
                     gap between developed and developing economies.            including the mastery of these skills across
                                                                                different demographics, and gaps in access to
   Better data are   Accelerating the vision within this domain will require    skills training and development. Furthermore,
                     targeted training and development for educators to         new mechanisms are needed to assess the
needed to be able
                     support the right kind of learning; curricula developers   relevance of curricula to labour-market needs.
to match people to
                     to strategically integrate new economy skills into
jobs and learning    learning; workplace-learning opportunities to be made      The Vision 2025 is of data collected from
opportunities,       widely available; and all stakeholders – including         assessment, and measurement is used strategically
and to ensure        educators, employers, human resources technology,          to create direct lines between job seekers and
that learning        education technology, employment offices and               employment opportunities. New methods of
ultimately leads     others – to align on skills pathways. To ensure that       assessment must be applied to measure new
to employment.       these goals are met by 2030, policy-makers must            economy skills, and the development of new
                     assessment mechanisms often takes many years to            new skills and new approaches to learning.
                     design and implement. Thus, a reasonable priority          Innovating approaches will require fundamental
                     for the vision would be to – in the first instance –       shifts in norms and attitudes related to learning.
                     measure gaps and inequities in access to skills
                     development across different demographic groups.           The vision is that individuals proactively engage
                                                                                in lifelong learning to develop their new economy
                                                                                skills. Enabling this vision will require these skills
                     Mainstreaming new economy                                  to be valued by employers and governments.
                                                                                Stakeholders will need to signal demand for new
                     skills                                                     economy skills, develop and recognize alternative
                                                                                pathways to employment, and invest in targeted
                     Education systems have long been embedded in               skills development and deployment for groups with
                     traditional ways of learning, which often include          inequitable access to learning and jobs. While all
                     direct instruction of well-established subjects,           of these can be accomplished by 2030, a priority
                     such as mathematics, reading and writing. Yet              for the Vision 2025 should be to develop and
                     these systems could be complemented with                   implement alternative pathways to employment.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025   66
                   Pathways to Vision 2025
                   Providing education workforce                    –   Create educator-owned lifelong learning,
                                                                        training and development accounts.
                   training and development to                          Along with a centralized database of diverse
                   support new economy skills                           opportunities for teacher development, these
                   development                                          accounts would enable educators more flexibility
                                                                        and ownership over their learning needs.
                   A survey of industry employers shows that
                   the core set of skills required for employment   Recognizing alternative and work-
                   in the education sector is set to change by
                   41% by 2025.141 Another study indicates
                                                                    based pathways to jobs
                   that wide-scale investment in upskilling the
                   education sector alone could add 5.6% (nearly    Many mechanisms for developing new economy
                   $400 billion) to global GDP.142 The return on    skills, including online learning and short-cycle
                   investment in teacher training is multiplied     credentialling, have emerged in response to the
                   if focused on reinforcing the education          growing demand for learning and reskilling. These
                   workforce to support new economy skills          mechanisms promise to democratize learning,
                   development for the next generation of talent.   increase access to a broader set of individuals and
                   Furthermore, investing in teacher training and   provide rapid solutions to learning needs. Although
                   development ensures that education systems       apprenticeships and other forms of work-based
                   continue to be resilient through any future      learning have proven to be effective pathways to
                   unforeseen social and economic shocks.           employment, these strategies have not been widely
                                                                    adopted across economies and are not always
                   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway     recognized by employers, which places the burden of
                   include:143                                      risk on individuals as they decide whether to invest in
                                                                    these alternative pathways.144
                   –   Assess skills gaps in the education
                       workforce. This will support robust          To encourage individuals to engage in lifelong
                       workforce planning within this sector,       learning of new economy skills and take advantage of
                       including a combination of qualitative       alternative learning solutions, these learning pathways
                       and quantitative approaches to               must be recognized by governments and employers.
                       understand specific teacher needs.
                                                                    Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:145
                   –   Provide opportunities for educators
                       to observe how skills are deployed           –   Help businesses and governments create
                       in work contexts. These opportunities            and formalize work-based learning.
   Wide-scale
                       would enable teachers to create learning         Government subsidies can facilitate and
investment in          environments that more closely mirror the        encourage the creation of these opportunities.
upskilling the         future of work. This will require specific
education sector       partnerships between schools and local       –   Consider candidates with skills-based
alone could            employers and could be carried out through       certifications, where applicable. The
add 5.6% to            business commitments to ESG standards.           candidates to consider particularly are those
global GDP.                                                             engaging in mid-career transitions.
                                                                                                      Future Focus 2025   67
  Tracking the         –   Include skills certifications and micro          with disabilities, ageing populations, and those from
development and            credentialling in national qualifications        ethnic, racial and religious minority groups, can
deployment of new          frameworks.                                      support an equitable economic recovery. Having
economy skills                                                              these data points can empower stakeholders to
across traditionally   –   Require work-based learning in national          think critically about the targeted efforts needed
                           curricula.                                       to ensure equal access to new opportunities
under-represented
                                                                            created in the post-COVID-19 economy.146
and minority
                       –   Co-design work-based and online learning
groups can support         assessments. Supporting skills development       Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:147
an equitable               aligned to labour-market needs is required.
economic recovery.                                                          –   Create skills passports at the company
                       –   Develop signposting tools to help individuals        or country level. Passports can include
                           understand their skill set and the skills that       demographic data to track new economy
                           are needed for employment. Such tools should         skills across under-represented groups.
                           help overcome the information barrier
                           for individuals.                                 –   Measure engagement in new economy skills
                                                                                learning opportunities. These data can be
                                                                                used to identify and solve for potential barriers
                       Measuring gaps and inequities                            to access across demographic groups.
                       on the attainment of these skills                    –   Track the number of individuals across
                                                                                demographic groups. Tracking those who
                       Tracking the development and deployment of               enter jobs powered by new economy skills will
                       new economy skills across traditionally under-           help ascertain whether the skills are deployed
                       represented groups, including women, individuals         equitably.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   68
3.2   Equity and
      social justice
      Recovery from the pandemic provides
      an exceptional opportunity to build new,
      just systems that honour the dignity
      and equality of every human being.
      The COVID-19 pandemic has aggravated pre-                   existing inequalities in society. Increased social
      existing inequalities globally and heightened the           unrest and disruption heightens the global
      visibility of deep-rooted structural and social             demand for change.
      inequities in education, employment, housing and
      healthcare. The issues faced by people across the       –   Addressing the gap between commitments
      dimensions of diversity vary and are often further          and progress. Organizations and institutions
      complicated by their intersectionality. The increased       repeatedly negotiate the tension between
      mobilization and momentum for change, however,              intentions and progress while building systems
      have not translated into progress in building               that are truly more equitable and socially just.
      systems that are truly more equitable and just.
                                                              The recovery of economies and societies from the
      Two key trends are both challenging and                 pandemic provides an unprecedented occasion
      contributing to more equitable and socially             to leverage intentional, coordinated multisector
      just societies:                                         actions, driven and measured by data to build
                                                              new and just systems that honour the dignity and
      –   Deepening and exposing inequalities.                equality of every human being.
          COVID-19 has laid bare and deepened already
                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   69
                       Vision 2025
   Investing           Providing underserved groups                            Supporting business activism
in the lifelong        with job access, skills and                             through inclusive metrics and
employability of
all workers ensures    growth opportunities                                    reporting
social welfare
                       The COVID-19 pandemic is wreaking havoc                 Globally, 90% of businesses claim to prioritize
but is also critical
                       on global economies, disrupting supply chains           diversity, yet many are falling short on making
for business by
                       and causing labour shortages. In developed              progress towards creating more equitable work
addressing the         economies, retiring workers or those voluntarily        environments for all employees.150 For many
skills gap and         quitting roles are said to be the cause of the          institutions and organizations, the wave of change
building a resilient   shortage, but issues such as border controls and        is coming in the form of ESG requirements.
labour market.         immigration limits as well as demands for better
                       pay and flexible working arrangements are also          Governments, financial Institutions and the public
                       contributors.148 Despite this opportunity for jobs,     at large are demanding increased transparency and
                       racial, ethnic, age, gender and education-level         accountability around setting goals and reporting
                       unemployment gaps, among others, still exist.           progress against ESG targets, particularly on
                       Only structural changes to institutions, policies and   the social agenda. Measuring and reporting on
                       mindsets will lead to true equality of opportunity      DE&I efforts inclusively means engaging a wider
                       in the labour market. Investing in the lifelong         representation of groups in DE&I efforts and making
                       employability of all workers ensures social welfare     a commitment to progress that considers the
                       but is also critical for business by addressing the     needs of all people, especially those who have
                       skills gap and building a resilient labour market.      been previously under-represented in business and
                                                                               in business metrics. Gathering and using inclusive
                       The composition of the economy is changing,             metrics and reporting is a solution to realizing
                       labour markets are undergoing fundamental               equity and social justice, a tool for activism and a
                       transformations and new job roles are emerging,         mechanism for broader structural and behavioural
                       shifting the skills businesses need to innovate and     change in business.
                       grow. While these shifts hold the promise of more
                       rather than less work for people, significant gaps      Through measuring and reporting DE&I inclusively,
                       are already evident in many of these growing fields     businesses are raising awareness of existing
                       for under-represented groups. Structural changes,       inequalities, making progress visible as well as
                       including degree requirements, the recruiting           galvanizing commitment and momentum to DE&I
                       process, on-the-job training, and hiring for all        among employees and businesses. Inclusive
                       dimensions of diversity, will build a resilient and     metrics and reporting can also foster employee
                       equitable labour market.149                             trust and satisfaction, strengthen business
                                                                               reputation and help businesses secure more
                                                                               resources for DE&I. The data generated through
                                                                               inclusive reporting can help businesses influence
                                                                               political, economic and social decisions that
                                                                               ultimately ensure equitable work environments as
                                                                               well as contribute to closing the implementation gap
                                                                               of realizing more equitable and socially just systems.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   70
                    Pathways to Vision 2025
                    Providing underserved groups                                 secondary education completion rates, especially
                                                                                 for under-represented groups. More collaboration
                    with access to jobs, skills                                  between governments, education institutions
                    and growth opportunities                                     and businesses is needed. For example,
                                                                                 the National Academy Foundation connects
                    Businesses and governments must take a systemic              the business community to the education
                    approach to providing equitable access as well as            community to value learning other than at college
                    remove the college degree barrier and understand             and to develop on-the-job training.
                    the structural barriers to equal job access. In
                    addition, the following measures should be               –   Support workers through all phases of
                    captured in new ESG frameworks.                              life. Workers should be supported to remain
                                                                                 in the labour market after key life transitions.
                    Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:        For instance, EnterpriseAlumni helps large
                                                                                 organizations maximize relationships with
                    –   Support under-represented groups. OneTen                 former employees as a vast, untapped pool
                        is a coalition of executives committed to                of hires, referrals and advocacy as well as
                        upskilling, hiring and promoting 1 million Black         drive community and nurture the workforce.
                        Americans in the next 10 years. Another                  For the ageing population, reskilling, upskilling
                        example is Year Up, which provides young                 and lifelong learning programmes as well as
                        people with skills, work experience and support          supporting workforce re-entries are the
                        in finding a job. Organizations and governments          way forward.
                        should prioritize measuring the effectiveness
                        of these initiatives by tracking their impact on     –   Connect with young people on the jobs of
                        diverse people over time, such as success in             today and the future. Globally, the examples
                        securing and holding jobs.                               of mentorship programmes in which seasoned
                                                                                 professionals mentor young people towards
                    –   Offer flexible work options. Businesses                  success are many. Governments should
                        should ensure these options do not inhibit               support these programmes and companies
   Every business       future development opportunities, such as                should participate in them.
faces its own           skills upgrading and career advancement.
diversity, equity       Insurer Zurich made flexible working the norm        Amplifying the impact of
                        by offering all vacancies as part-time, full-time,
and inclusion
                        job-sharing or flexible working. This change
                                                                             business activism
challenges and,
                        resulted in applications doubling, one-third
therefore, must         more women securing senior roles and a rise          Every business faces its own DE&I challenges and,
develop its own         in belonging among part-time employees.151           therefore, must develop its own set of metrics and
set of metrics                                                               processes for measuring progress towards DE&I. In
and processes       –   Address gaps in school-to-work transitions.          gathering and reporting on employee and corporate
for measuring           The focus should particularly be on economies        data, protecting individuals from the unintended
progress.               with a high proportion of youth and rising           or negative consequences of data disclosure
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   71
   To realize       is critical. Furthermore, businesses must find              existing policies and procedures across
inclusive metrics   new ways to work with government frameworks                 all organizational functions. For example,
and reporting,      that hinder the ability of companies to measure             DE&I metrics could be owned by the full
                    workforce diversity. To realize inclusive metrics and       executive committee to ensure collaboration
businesses should
                    reporting, businesses should move away from a               organization-wide.
move towards
                    siloed approach to DE&I consolidated under the
an integrated       human resources function and move towards an            –   Align metrics and reporting structures.
approach across     integrated approach across all business functions           This will standardize and benchmark DE&I
all business        to support corporate cultural change. Governments           efforts across businesses and global indexes.
functions to        can amplify the impact of business activism by              Sustainability and resource indexes need
support corporate   setting standards for data analysis and disclosure          to ensure that the metrics cover all aspects
cultural change.    as well as holding businesses accountable                   of DE&I. Additionally, organizations should
                    and disseminating effective examples.152                    create a legal framework that lays out which
                                                                                diversities can be measured in different
                    Strategies for operationalizing this pathway                countries and how best to measure safely.
                    include:153
                                                                            –   Encourage employee resource groups.
                    –   Identify and prioritize DE&I goals. This                This encouragement includes mobilizing and
                        includes identifying areas of risk, assigning           advocating for their interests, metrics and
                        accountability and continually assessing the            inclusive policies, creating representation,
                        extent to which specified DE&I goals have               incentives and further momentum. For
                        been achieved. Businesses should also                   example, organizations should co-create
                        ensure they are looking at intersectional               and maintain DE&I metrics in collaboration
                        categories, which are often overlooked.                 with employee resource groups.
                    –   Devise an intersectional and corporate-             Governments can amplify the impact of
                        wide approach to DE&I metrics. This                 business activism by setting standards, holding
                        corporate approach should continually review        businesses accountable and disseminating
                        and respond to systemic inequities within           effective examples of business activism.
                                                                                                           Future Focus 2025    72
3.3   Human rights
      Human rights must be given a permanent
      place in the boardroom to fully integrate
      them in the strategy, leadership and
      operations of a company.
      Businesses must align their ESG work with              –   Legislation on business responsibility
      international human rights norms and ensure that           to respect human rights. While progress
      the voices and perspectives of affected stakeholders       in the last decade has been largely driven
      are brought to the attention of leadership.                by voluntary action and a small number of
                                                                 corporate leaders, regulation will likely be
      Three major trends related to business and human           an important factor in environmental and
      rights include:                                            social sustainability in the next decade.
                                                                 Governments began to introduce new
      –   Growing inequality. At the start of 2020,              legislation aimed at addressing the corporate
          70% of the world’s population was facing               responsibility to respect human rights.
          ever increasing inequality, a trend further
          exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.154           The corporate responsibility to respect human
                                                             rights, as set out in the UN Guiding Principles
      –   Expectations from stakeholders. Society            on Business and Human Rights and related
          expects powerful institutions to be increasingly   standards, is the foundation for business’ role
          accountable for their actions. Public trust in     in preventing human rights harms and helping
          institutions has decreased significantly and       remedy those that occur. It is also the standard
          young people around the world demand that          for responsible business conduct. Taking a
          all stakeholders deliver on the promise of a       human rights lens will help companies meet their
          post-pandemic world that tackles inequality,       responsibility to respect human rights, meet
          injustice and climate change.                      evolving societal expectations about business’
                                                             role and be a force in tackling inequality.
                                                                                            Future Focus 2025    73
                    Vision 2025
                    Tackling societal challenges                             –   Societies expect businesses to be responsible
                                                                                 societal and environmental actors. These ESG
                                                                                 expectations are increasingly translating into new
                    Outside of their own operations, by 2025 business            laws and industry standards – some focusing
                    proactively engage in wider societal discussions on          on mandatory human rights and environmental
                    how to reduce inequality and promote human rights.           due diligence, others on mandatory disclosure or
                                                                                 on the non-financial responsibilities of company
                    –   Businesses cannot remain neutral on                      boards. Most of these approaches require, or
                        issues relating to growing inequality within             are enhanced by, engagement with affected
                        society and between generations; they must               stakeholders. Knowledge of the risks these
                        actively challenge discrimination or risk                groups and communities face, and the impact
                        being perceived as silently complicit. The               of companies on them, enable responsible
                        #MeToo, #BlackLivesMatter and other social               companies to comply more fully with these laws
                        movements have shown that gender, racial                 and standards.
                        and other forms of inequality are deeply rooted
                        everywhere, while climate justice demands an         –   Correspondingly, company boards must
                        intergenerational approach to all sections               reflect the broader composition of society. Too
                        of society.                                              many boards lack diversity and have little or
                                                                                 no representation from affected stakeholders
                    –   Flawed business practices, including                     and their representatives. Companies cannot
                        insufficient attention to harmful labour practices       address social inequality effectively if they
                        in global supply chains, exacerbate inequalities,        embody this same inequality in their senior
                        such as those resulting from inadequate                  management and board structures.
                        wages, a lack of workplace representation
                        or collective bargaining, or the exploitation of
                        vulnerable groups, such as migrant workers.          Building competence,
                    –   Businesses benefit from the rule of law
                                                                             experience and skills
                        and from a vibrant civil society. Efforts by
                        governments to undermine strong legal                As ESG expectations grow, boards of directors
                        accountability or to restrict civic freedoms will,   hold critical roles as stewards for the company and
                        in turn, have a negative impact on business.         its interests. By 2025, boards must recognize the
                                                                             evolving expectations on companies with respect
                                                                             to human rights, and ensure their own membership
                    Engaging with affected                                   has the right skills, knowledge and commitment to
  Boards must                                                                these issues.
recognize
                    stakeholders
the evolving                                                                 –   Boards need to be diverse in both their
expectations        Corporate responsibility to respect human rights             members’ backgrounds and identities, as
on companies        is fundamentally about people. Protecting and                well as their experience. This requires an
with respect to     empowering those most vulnerable to the impacts              intersectional approach to board composition.
                    of corporate actions is key to meeting that                  Composition cannot be about identity or visual
human rights, and
                    responsibility. By 2025, engaging with affected              appearance alone but must also be about
ensure their own    stakeholders should not be a box-ticking exercise            heterogeneous experience and mindsets.
membership has      but rather a way of truly and directly gaining
the right skills,   insights into the ways in which companies and            –   Training in ESG is an evolving requirement.
knowledge and       their practices affect people and communities.               Boards must also be sensitized to the true
commitment to                                                                    impact of their companies in societal and
these issues.                                                                    environmental terms.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   74
                      Pathways to Vision 2025
                      For human rights concerns to be fully integrated            impact on people and be held accountable for
                      across the strategy, leadership and operations              those impacts.
                      of a company, the topic must find a permanent
                      place in the boardroom itself. To be able to do         –   Establish engagement mechanisms.
                      that, companies must engage with stakeholders,              This includes creating clear and efficient
                      especially those most vulnerable to potential               mechanisms for a meaningful understanding of
                      negative impacts.                                           and engagement with affected stakeholders, in
                                                                                  particular those rights holders most vulnerable
                      The World Economic Forum Global Future                      to the negative effects of business actions.
                      Council on Human Rights challenges corporate
                      boards to examine their existing capacity and           –   Build competence. This means ensuring
                      commitments on human rights, providing tools and            that corporate boards have the expertise and
                      guidance for how they can prioritize stakeholder            competence to not only understand human
                      engagement on these issues as an exercise of                rights impacts but also actively engage
                      their board duties. Through a series of private             with internal functions in the company to
                      consultations with corporate non-executive                  address them. This may require the direct
                      directors, business leaders, corporate human rights         representation of affected stakeholders on
                      experts, affected stakeholders and civil society            the board or through the selection of board
                      representatives, in the coming year the Council will        members with human rights expertise and/
                      release guidance to boards on new and existing              or responsibility. It could also take the form
                      mechanisms for affected stakeholder engagement,             of proxy representation through, for example,
   Human rights are   understanding and signposting the experience                worker councils.
not simply the “S”    and competencies that are essential for board
in ESG. Companies     members to act effectively on this knowledge.           –   Ensure performance tracking and reporting.
                                                                                  Respect for human rights must be linked to
need to undertake
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       performance KPIs and clear incentives at all
comprehensive
                                                                                  levels of the organization. Board members
human rights          –   Conduct human rights due diligence. Human               should review performance tracking and
due diligence to          rights are not simply the “S” in ESG. Respect           reporting on an ongoing basis as part of
understand their          for human rights must underpin all business             the overall performance of the company.
impact on people          action inside and outside of the company                Corporate actions should also be evaluated
and be held               and cannot be reduced to a single indicator.            by independent assessors applying industry
accountable for           Companies need to undertake comprehensive               standards and metrics. The results of these
those impacts.            human rights due diligence to understand their          assessments should be transparently shared.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025     75
3.4   Mental health
      There has never been a more urgent
      moment to address long-standing issues
      in mental ill-health, or a better opportunity
      to build back better.
      The profound disruptions to daily life brought about       disadvantages and those with pre-existing
      by COVID-19 have led to an unprecedented rise in           conditions.
      rates of depression, anxiety, substance use and
      attempted suicide, particularly among young            –   Disruptive technologies. Restrictions on
      people. Additionally, mental health service                physical movement and rising rates of mental
      infrastructure has been disrupted. These                   health diagnosis are being countered by digital
      consequences will outlive the physical danger of           technologies that can operate remotely at scale.
      COVID-19 and must be systematically addressed.
      While this crisis is deeply concerning, it has         –   Harmful stigma. While much still needs to
      instigated a paradigm shift in regulatory structures       be done, advocacy, generational change and
      and treatment. It has done much to put mental              more frequent personal experiences of mental
      health on the map as an issue that needs                   ill-health are breaking the stigma around
      addressing, creating opportunities for innovative,         discussing a topic that has long been taboo.
      scalable solutions that transcend borders and
      economic sectors.155                                   In the past year, forward-thinking policy-makers,
                                                             advocates, psychiatrists, neuroscientists,
      –   Widening inequality. Rates of mental ill-health    psychologists, public health professionals,
          conditions have risen across all demographics,     technologists and business leaders have shown
          but those hit hardest are younger populations,     that the global community can face great
          those who were already subject to structural       challenges with resilience and determination.
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   76
                      Vision 2025
                      Ensuring trust in digital                                enable the inclusion of high-quality measures in
                                                                               population or school-based surveys, enabling
                      technologies                                             more nuanced understandings of outcomes,
                                                                               risks and determinants.”157 Key efforts to validate
                      Digital solutions are rapidly deployed to reach as       these measures, including younger age groups
                      many people as possible while demand for mental          (10 to 14 years) and employing innovative
                      health services and global inequality are both           approaches and the use of digital technologies
                      increasing. Questions remain on how these                to improve data collection, are in place. These
                      solutions should be put into place, and what             efforts contribute to closing the data gap related
                      mechanisms must be enacted to ensure they are            to child and adolescent mental health at the
                      properly protecting privacy, live up to claims and are   country level, ultimately extending benefits beyond
                      interoperable across systems and borders.                a reduction in mental disorders, optimizing the
                                                                               capabilities and quality of life of this generation.
                      Improving measurements for
                      better management                                        Crafting policies to bolster
                                                                               “mental wealth”
                      According to experts writing in the Journal of
                      Adolescent Health, “Addressing adolescent mental         Mental health is no longer one of the most
                      health starts with good data on the prevalence           neglected areas of public health. This neglect was
                      of mental health conditions as well as risk and          caused in part because, historically, a “deficit-based
                      protective factors. These data are essential for         approach” was adopted, focusing on avoiding
                      informing the design and implementation of               mental illness and relying on the health sector to
                      appropriate policies and programmes and allocation       manage problems and respond to acute events,
                      of resources to support adolescents. Yet, data           despite a recognition of broader social and
                      on adolescent mental health remain sparse,               economic drivers. This approach did not fully
                      especially in low- and middle-income economies           conceptualize the human potential that could be
                      (LMICs) where … nearly 90% of the world’s 1.2            unlocked by investing in mental assets, which in
                      billion adolescents live. The challenges inherent        turn can lead to wealth creation for individuals,
   The concept of     to measuring mental health are exacerbated in            communities, and economies. As countries
“mental wealth”       LMICs, as lack of investment has led to lack of          reconstruct in the post-COVID era, mental health is
helps policy-         resources and standardized validated tools for           reconceptualized as a key contributor to the mental
makers understand     measuring mental health in these settings.”156           wealth of nations, encouraging an asset-based
and choose the                                                                 approach that pushes governments to focus on
right policy levers   Data collection efforts focus on adolescent health       creating environments where people can flourish.
                      risks (such as bullying, substance use, lack of          The concept of “mental wealth” helps policy-makers
that contribute
                      physical activity), with scant data on adolescent        understand and choose the right policy levers
to increasing         mental health outcomes, and little information on        (across the economic, health and social sectors)
community             key determinants, including norms. According to          that contribute to increasing the community
connectedness,        experts, “Efforts to develop validated adolescent        connectedness, mental capital, mental health and
mental capital,       measures of population mental health (including          well-being that underpin productive, creative,
mental health         through UNICEF’s Mental Health Among                     resilient and thriving communities and contribute to
and well-being.       Adolescents at the Population Level initiative)          building national prosperity.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   77
                     Pathways to Vision 2025
                     Incentivizing the trusted, ethical                       resources across the potential drivers of mental
                                                                              wealth. Addressing these challenges is the primary
                     adoption of digital solutions                            preoccupation of the University of Sydney’s
                                                                              Mental Wealth Initiative, in partnership with the
   Digital mental    Digital solutions hold great promise to take away        Global Future Council and the United Kingdom’s
health regulations   some of the burden from over-stressed systems            SIPHER (Systems Science in Public Health and
can ensure that      while simultaneously reaching those who do not           Health Economics Research) Consortium. The
innovators know      have the resources or capability to interact with        primary objectives of the Mental Wealth Initiative
what to build        traditional mental health services or may feel           are to measure, monitor and forecast the mental
                     stigmatized in face-to-face locations. If regulated      wealth of nations and help identify those policy
towards, and end
                     properly, digital mental health regulations can          opportunities that will foster this broader measure
users have trust
                     ensure that innovators know what to build towards,       of national prosperity.
that the product     procurement offices (whether they be governments,
they are using is    employers or insurance organizations) have a clear       Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
safe, ethical and    sense of what they are getting, and end users have
efficacious.         trust that the product they are using is safe, ethical   –   Define and quantify a measure of mental
                     and efficacious.                                             wealth. The initiative is working to
                                                                                  operationalize national and population-based
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:        measures of mental wealth that broaden the
                                                                                  lens against which social and economic
                     –   Pilot the toolkit for digital mental health. In          progress are assessed beyond that traditionally
                         partnership with Deloitte, the World Economic            captured by GDP.
                         Forum has developed the Global Governance
                         Toolkit for Digital Mental Health to “provide        –   Apply a systems lens. Measuring and
                         governments, regulators and independent                  forecasting mental wealth requires a systems
                         assurance bodies with the tools to develop,              modelling approach, capturing the interacting
                         adopt and engage standards and policies that             factors that influence mental capital, mental
                         address major ethical concerns relating to the           health and well-being that in turn contribute to
                         use of disruptive technology in mental health.”158       productivity gains and losses not traditionally
                                                                                  accounted for in other measures of national
                     –   Contribute to future iterations of the toolkit.          wealth. The initiative is applying complex
                         Innovators, business leaders, policy-makers              systems modelling and simulation to forecast
                         and mental health experts are all needed to              national trajectories of mental wealth and to
                         ensure that the framework remains dynamic                understand the extent to which government
                         and up-to-speed with the latest trends.                  policy-mediated changes in the economic,
                                                                                  health and social environment could enhance it.
                     Rebuilding the mental wealth
                                                                              –   Move from research to action. The initiative
                     of nations                                                   is working with government, business, mental
                                                                                  health and social policy and community
                     Despite unprecedented investment in strengthening            leaders. It provides the forums needed to
                     economic, social and health systems that could               facilitate the exchange of knowledge and ideas
                     foster mental wealth in the wake of the pandemic,            to harness collective efforts, networks and
                     several challenges remain, including uncertainty             resources to develop mental wealth and to
                     regarding what impact those investments are                  coordinate advocacy and action nationally
                     likely to have and how best to allocate limited              and internationally.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025   78
3.5   New agenda for fragility
      and resilience
      Greater impact can be achieved by putting the
      needs of affected communities at the centre of
      humanitarian and development assistance.
      Fragile regions are faced with an increasingly complex       efforts. When states lack fundamental structures
      mix of challenges characterized by protracted                and economic systems have collapsed, broad
      conflicts, disease, poverty, climate change and weak         multistakeholder responses, including for
      governance. The United Nations estimates that 274            macroeconomic stabilization, are needed.
      million people will need humanitarian assistance
      and protection in 2022159 at a cost of nearly $41        –   The paradoxical impacts of digitalization.
      billion dollars, or nearly double the needs before the       Digital access and tools have helped boost
      COVID-19 pandemic,160 in addition to development             economic productivity and unlock access to
      aid needs.161                                                services. Yet, despite the potential to meet
                                                                   many humanitarian and development needs
      Yet, trends indicate that many challenges risk not           through digitalization, many rural and low-
      being addressed due to:                                      income communities around the world lack
                                                                   reliable, affordable internet access, or the tools
      –   The changing nature of conflict. The volume              and skills to use it. On the other hand, there is
          and length of humanitarian and development               a risk that these digital solutions, if designed
          needs are increasing as conflicts become                 and implemented without appropriate expertise,
          more protracted and globalized with more                 could harm those they are intended to protect.
          numerous and fragmented actors. This is further          For example, the use of autonomous weapon
          aggravated by the convergence of megatrends,             systems and cyberattacks pose threats to
          such as climate change, urbanization, the                humanitarian and development efforts162 as
          COVID-19 pandemic, corruption, violence and              they can attack critical infrastructure, influence
          poor governance, resulting in adverse effects            social and political environments, and affect
          on livelihoods and essential services, and               response preparedness in humanitarian and
          undermining development and humanitarian                 development organizations.163
                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   79
   Greater impact   –   The widening gap between needs and                     Actors across sectors are missing critical
can be achieved         resources. The World Bank estimates that an            opportunities to collaborate to meet the growing
by putting the          additional 20 million people live in extreme poverty   and evolving needs of fragile communities.
needs of affected       in countries affected by fragility, conflict and       Greater impact can be achieved by putting the
                        violence.164 Realizing the SDGs in the most fragile    needs of affected communities at the centre
communities
                        contexts requires mobilizing significant public-       of the response, with space for all actors to
at the centre of
                        and private-sector investments. Current financing      contribute their different skills, expertise and
humanitarian and        mechanisms remain insufficient, public finance         resources. In many settings, especially those
development             is plateauing, and business cases for private-         of deep fragility, this will occur through public-
assistance.             sector investments in fragile contexts are unclear     and private-sector collaboration at the local,
                        or lacking due to an absence of compelling             national and international levels. It is critical
                        proof-of-concept projects, financial de-risking        that these efforts are supported by an enabling
                        mechanisms, infrastructure and required supply         domestic legal, policy and operational framework
                        chain/ecosystem actors in the market. Such gaps        for which states are primarily responsible.
                        in resources lead to significant delays to provide
                        timely humanitarian and development assistance.
                    Vision 2025
                    By 2025, all communities have the infrastructure to        –   Climate-sensitive essential infrastructures are
                    access basic services, and the delivery of services is         established to shield local populations from
                    commercially sustainable. To achieve this vision,              intersecting shocks and vulnerabilities.
                    better alignment and cooperation among public- and
                    private-sector stakeholders at the local, national and
                    international levels are needed to make significant        Building capacity for locally
                    progress building these infrastructures and creating
                    the sustainable markets that put communities in
                                                                               based action
                    crisis on the path to resilience. Emphasis should be
                    placed on ensuring access to essential services,           By 2025:
                    enabling a life of dignity and opportunity, supporting
                    the development of thriving and resilient economies,       –   Local institutions partner with local private-sector
                    and expanding digital access.                                  organizations and international aid organizations
                                                                                   to design, fund and implement solutions.
                    Designing user-centric solutions                           –   Existing resources are maximized and long-term
                                                                                   strategies to transition responsibilities for more
                                                                                   sustainable and scalable operations are
                    By 2025:                                                       developed.
                    –   The needs of affected communities are placed           –   Local capacities are reinforced to scale and
                        at the centre of the response through an                   speed response in crisis situations, and whenever
                        iterative design and implementation process, so            possible, prioritized and routinely deployed to
                        that services and products are locally relevant            address issues within the community.
                        and accessible, individuals have choice, and
                        the quality-of-service delivery improves.
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025    80
Unlocking public- and private-                            Leveraging existing digital
sector finance to achieve the                             technology and building
SDGs and enable local markets                             new capacity
By 2025:                                                  By 2025:
–   Private-sector organizations provide food, health,    –   Local and international private- and public-
    education, water, sanitation, electricity and other       sector organizations partner to identify
    essential services in fragile regions where these         opportunities to promote infrastructure as a
    are lacking and where a business case could be            public good.
    made for this; humanitarian and development
    organizations, and local and international            –   The scaling of existing solutions is prioritized,
    governments, fill that role in other cases.               whenever possible, to build digital capacity and
                                                              infrastructure in humanitarian organizations and
–   Local and international private-sector                    local populations.
    organizations partner with public-sector actors
    to increase humanitarian funding and financing,       –   Local non-governmental organizations partner
    and to develop new market pathways that allow             with organizations focused on improving the
    aid-reliant groups to earn an income.                     digital experience to ensure designs are based
                                                              on the needs of local populations and provide
–   Government leaders enable markets as                      opportunities for aid-dependent populations
    the foundation for a community’s long-term                to explore opportunities for economic
    resilience. A more vibrant local economy provides         independence.
    increased access to employment for populations
    in local contexts, allowing them to move              –   Adherence to best-in-class data security and
    from aid reliance to increased autonomy and               privacy standards is achieved when handling the
    independence.                                             individual data of vulnerable populations.
                                                                                          Future Focus 2025   81
Pathways to Vision 2025
To achieve this vision, multistakeholder action is
                                                         Developing user-centric
required in four areas: developing user-centric
responses and solutions to crises; reducing              responses and solutions to crises
the gap between needs and resources, in
particular by leveraging and strengthening               –   Support existing multistakeholder action.
local capacities; deploying public- and private-             The Grand Bargain is “a unique agreement
sector finance to support SDGs, in particular                between some of the largest donors and
by developing entry points for private-sector                humanitarian organisations who have
investments in fragile contexts; and leveraging              committed to get more means into the hands of
and scaling digital solutions in fragile contexts.           people in need and to improve the effectiveness
                                                             and efficiency of the humanitarian action”.166
The World Economic Forum Global Future Council               Its workstreams 1 (Greater Transparency)167
on the New Agenda for Fragility and Resilience               and 6 (Participation Revolution)168 are
developed a set of “Guidelines for complementary             particularly relevant. Other key foci of action
action in fragile contexts”165 in line with these four       include the Charter for Change, USAID’s
pathways. The goal of the guidelines is to build             User-Centric Design Approach, Principles for
more resilient communities through public-private            Digital Development (Design with the User),
partnerships that are focused on the risks, needs            Core Humanitarian Standard on Quality and
and aspirations of local communities and on                  Accountability and World Resources Institute’s
enhanced complementarity of local, national and              Principles for Locally Led Adaptation.
international as well as private- and public-sector
actors, and that are facilitated by digital solutions.
Reducing the gap between                                 Deploying public- and
needs and resources                                      private-sector finance
–   Strengthen collective action. The Grand              –   Join existing initiatives. Initiatives to consider
    Bargain workstream 2 seeks to provide more               joining include the World Economic Forum
    support and funding tools for local and national         Humanitarian and Resilience Investing Initiative,
    responders,169 and the Joint Intersectoral               the World Bank’s PS4R (Private Sector for
    Analysis Framework provides further ideas                Refugees), Refugee Investment Network, Crisis
    for reflection.                                          Lookout coalition or the Anticipation Hub.
–   Support existing partnerships and initiatives.
    Partnering should be considered, for example         Leveraging and scaling of digital
    with networks like ICVA, NEAR and START
    Network, as should support for initiatives, such
                                                         solutions in fragile contexts
    as the UN Connecting Business initiative or the
    Somalia Nexus platform.                              –   Follow best practices. Additional information
                                                             can be accessed at Principles for Digital
                                                             Development.170
                                                         –   Join partnerships. Organizations to consider
                                                             for partnerships include the Digital Public Goods
                                                             Alliance or GovStack.
                                                                                          Future Focus 2025   82
            3.6       Social cohesion
                      and just transition
                      A just transition to sustainability is a
                      necessary condition for ambitious climate
                      action and to shape an equitable and
                      climate-proof recovery.
                      While the effects of climate and environmental           objectives is witnessing rapid increases, with
                      challenges undermine jobs, disrupt businesses            demand often outpacing supply, but also
                      and threaten communities, the transition to net          creating challenges related to transparency,
                      zero also involves deep restructuring of economies       accountability and ratings. A just transition
                      and labour markets with far-reaching social              offers a framework to better articulate, address
                      implications. The concept of a “just transition”,        and manage social risks and the potential
                      which originated from North American unions in           social impacts of the restructuring and
                      the 1990s as a framework to support workers              contraction of emission-intensive industries.
                      likely to lose their jobs due to environmental
                      protection policies, has since evolved to focus      –   Increasing attention and a proliferation
                      on deliberate, choreographed efforts to ensure           of initiatives and instruments. The United
                      environmental sustainability with more and better        Nations just-transition framework is gaining
   A “just            jobs, social inclusion and poverty eradication.          prominence in national and international policy
transition” focuses                                                            as policy-makers address the links between
on deliberate,        –   Ensuring net zero for all. The net-zero              employment and social impacts of climate
choreographed             shift may bring quality jobs and social              action to deliver fair and inclusive change. An
                          inclusion, but it will not happen by default.        understanding of the concept varies, risking
efforts to ensure
                          Unplanned and unmanaged, the transition              weakening the value of a just transition as a
environmental
                          may exacerbate inequalities between                  policy tool and way to achieve social consensus.
sustainability            and within countries and leave workers,
with more and             communities and businesses stranded.             It is critical to strengthen shared commitments and
better jobs,                                                               identify measures to align financial flows to social and
social inclusion      –   Expanding sustainable investment and             environmental objectives in an integrated manner
and poverty               green finance. The volume of financial flows     through a common just-transition framework.
eradication.              allegedly aligned to environmental and social
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   83
                      Vision 2025
                      A just transition to sustainability has gained           this momentum to provide robust and achievable
                      prominence as a necessary condition for ambitious        entry points for financial-sector actors to align
                      climate action and as a framework to shape an            their decisions and strategies to a just transition.
                      equitable and climate-proof recovery. Adopting a
                      just transition framework in public policies, business
                      strategies and investments enables recognition           Illustrating applications of just-
                      of the employment and social implications of
                      climate action to maximize positive impacts while
                                                                               transition financing logic
                      minimizing and addressing negative ones and
                      ensuring decent work. Strong consensus enables           To devise practical recommendations on what
                      bold and inclusive change. Social dialogue is a          financing for a just transition may mean and require
                      crucial basis for a just transition, which also relies   in practice, sectoral and topical perspectives are
                      on meaningful stakeholder engagement processes           key. Such sectoral and topical perspective focuses
                      with communities and Indigenous peoples.                 on sectors with high relevance to environmental
                                                                               sustainability, particularly action on climate change
                                                                               and biodiversity, the decent work agenda, poverty
                      Building a common understanding                          eradication and rights.
                      of a just transition                                     In the context of the energy transition, the mining
                                                                               sector is taken as the initial sector of focus, which
                      With the growing interest in a just transition and an    may generate lessons applicable to developing
                      increasing number of initiatives being developed,        analyses of other sectors. Mining in connection
                      the concept is rendered as an internationally            to a just transition is typically tackled in relation
                      negotiated and recognized framework in the UN,           to coal mine closures and impacts on workers
                      under the International Labour Organization’s            and communities, but broader dynamics are at
                      (ILO) 2015 Guidelines for a Just Transition. The         play that also deserve attention. Clean energy
                      Guidelines provide a whole economy approach              minerals are critically important for ambitious
                      to ensuring decent work, sustainability and social       climate action as mining has tight connections
                      inclusion, and focus on collaborative processes          to deforestation, ocean health and biodiversity
                      (termed “social dialogue”) with governments,             loss. Such environmental challenges need to be
                      companies, investors, workers and civil society.171      tackled if the transition is to deliver sustainability
                                                                               and avoid creating unmanaged trade-offs.
                      Supporting financial flows to a                          For a just transition in mining to be true to
                                                                               sustainability goals and future-proof, it must
                      just transition                                          also consider and plan for shifts towards greater
   Adopting a
just transition                                                                circularity. The value chain of clean energy minerals
framework in          By 2025, public- and private-sector financial            is closely connected to the decent work agenda,
public policies,      flows align to just-transition goals to ensure           poverty eradication and the rights of Indigenous
                      commitments translate into investments and               peoples. Delivering a just transition requires ensuring
business strategies
                      tangible changes. A just transition offers financial     jobs along the value chain are decent, the rights and
and investments       institutions and stakeholders a framework to             well-being of Indigenous people and communities
enables recognition   better articulate and address social risks and           are respected, and mining revenues can foster local
of the employment     opportunities in green finance and related portfolios    economic and social development. Articulating
and social            and to assess and manage the potential social            these considerations and drawing recommendations
implications of       impacts of the restructuring and contraction of          with a just-transition financing perspective can
climate action.       emission-intensive industries. It is vital to leverage   clarify opportunities, risks and strategies.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025      84
Pathways to Vision 2025
Enhancing understanding and                             –   Foster greater knowledge sharing from
                                                            existing national social dialogue processes
increasing support for a just                               on a just transition. Unions and workers’
transition                                                  associations are essential for worker
                                                            participation in transition. According to the ILO’s
Considering the emergence of many initiatives,              working definition, social dialogue “can exist
commitments and messages on the just                        as a tripartite process, with the government
transition, enhancing the awareness of the                  as an official party to the dialogue or it may
transition is needed, translating the existing              consist of bipartite relations only between
concept (and its internationally recognized and             labour and management (or trade unions and
negotiated references) into strategies, actions             employers’ organizations), with or without
and examples for key change agents.                         indirect government involvement”, and involves
                                                            formal processes of negotiation, consultation
To promote a greater understanding of a just                and information exchange and covers both
transition and its implications for stakeholders,           economic and social policies and agreements.172
the World Economic Forum Global Future Council
on Social Cohesion and Just Transition seeks to         –   Facilitate peer learning, knowledge transfers
develop models to apply financing mechanisms in             and best practice sharing. Examples include
line with the just transition and highlight emerging        organizing seminars and workshops with
areas for translating the transition with workers           practitioners to present and discuss just-
and communities into strategies and actions.                transition actions.
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway:           –   Encourage opportunities for multistakeholder
                                                            collaboration on successful just-transition
–   Produce and disseminate knowledge and                   processes and results. Multistakeholder
    communication products. This includes                   collaboration is needed to socialize the existing
    providing further information to stakeholders           ILO guidelines and further ensure their
    on their roles in driving a just transition             application across stakeholders, sectors and
    and showcasing existing examples where                  country contexts.
    the transition has been successful.
Aligning financial flows to a just                      –   Build use cases. Practical recommendations
                                                            can be drawn upon based on the just
transition                                                  energy transition and mining cases, tackling
                                                            multidimensional challenges and opportunities
Given the growing interest of investors and other           around decent work, local communities
financial institutions in a just transition, there is       and environmental management.
need to build on and contribute to the emerging
body of research on how to structure just-              –   Develop recommendations on just-transition
transition financing and draw recommendations               financing. It is necessary to understand
that can serve as a basis for action.                       existing cases where a just transition has been
                                                            successful, how it was financed, and which
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       best practices can be applied across contexts.
–   Define the state-of-play and map the just           –   Harness public-private cooperation
    transition finance ecosystem. Relevant                  and partnerships. One example is holding
    frameworks and initiatives can be drawn                 roundtables to discuss recommendations and
    upon, and gaps may be addressed.                        encourage action.
                                                                                         Future Focus 2025   85
            3.7         Work, wages and
                        job creation
                        Reskilling is critical for many career
                        transitions, and around half of all employees
                        will need reskilling between 2020 and 2025.
   Quality jobs, with   The triple disruption of the COVID-19 pandemic,               an opportunity exists to transform how work
decent wages and        accelerated automation and climate change is                  is conceptualized, organized and performed.
working conditions,     accelerating the following trends and leading to rising
                        social discontent:                                        –   Increased inequality. Wages have faced
are needed.
                                                                                      further downward pressure and the differentiated
Addressing the
                        –   Job disruption. ILO estimates project 52                  impact of the triple disruption on disadvantaged
disruption to               million fewer jobs worldwide in 2022 than in the          groups has reinforced challenges of declining
jobs, wages and             fourth quarter of 2019.173 The urgent need is             social mobility.
work requires a             to encourage job creation, especially for youth,
cross-sectoral,             women and vulnerable groups, and to support           Quality jobs, with decent wages and working
multistakeholder            the transitions of workers from at-risk roles.        conditions, are needed. Addressing the disruption
effort.                                                                           to jobs, wages and work requires a cross-sectoral,
                        –   Transition to the future of work. Job quality has     multistakeholder effort. Collaborative, large-scale
                            come into greater focus and the challenges of         action can ensure economic dynamism and build
                            new ways of working for well-being have become        a vibrant and sustainable ecosystem with an
                            apparent. As organizations respond to the current     employable and productive workforce in good-quality
                            disruptions and to changing worker preferences,       jobs paying decent wages.174
                                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025   86
                       Vision 2025
                       Investing in new economy                                 Reskilling is critical for many transitions; indeed,
                                                                                around half of all employees will need reskilling
                       sectors and emerging roles                               between 2020 and 2025.179 But reskilling is better
                                                                                established for high-skilled jobs than for the
                       Job destruction paired with widespread rejection         much larger number of lower-skilled jobs – the
                       of poor-quality jobs has created a need for              most susceptible to automation. The massive
                       more and better jobs. New economy sectors                expansion of online learning during the pandemic
                       with promising job creation potential include the        offers a potential solution.180 Also required is better
                       care and sustainable economies, infrastructure           assistance for workers to understand potential job
                       and sustainable agriculture. Investing in the            transition pathways and the skills they will need to
                       care economy not only directly creates jobs              develop for new roles. Moreover, career transitions
                       but also removes barriers to women working.              take time and often require extended support.
                       In the sustainable economy, jobs that help
                       preserve or restore the environment (whether
                       in traditional sectors such as manufacturing or          Providing minimum and living
                       in emerging green sectors) modify production
                       and lower energy use to achieve the objectives
                                                                                wages
                       of the Paris Agreement of limiting global
                       temperature rise to below 2° C, and could                The pandemic has called attention to the ways
                       create 18 million jobs globally.175 Infrastructure       in which undervalued and underpaid work puts
                       investment offers both short-term direct job             pressure on societies and economies and weakens
                       creation and longer-term indirect job creation.176       resilience to shocks. Although 90% of the 187
                                                                                ILO member states have a minimum wage,181
                                                                                according to the World Bank, wage regulations
                       Supporting workers through                               are often bypassed and “in most developing
                                                                                countries, between a quarter and a half of wage-
                       job and career transitions                               earners receive less than the statutory minimum
                                                                                wage”.182 Research shows that concerns among
                       Longer working lives will entail more job transitions.   economists that such policies would have adverse
   12 million more     In addition, the triple disruption will force many       effects on employment have not been realized.183
jobs will be created   workers to pivot into a new career path. The
                       World Economic Forum estimates that 12 million           It is important to set a base for wages that
than displaced
                       more jobs will be created than displaced by 2025         enables people to live with dignity and provide
by 2025 due to         due to AI,177 and public-private partnerships            for a family, including education and healthcare.
AI. Public-private     can help workers transition into these new jobs.         Universal basic income has been much discussed
partnerships can       Within companies, transitions can be smoothed            considering the risk to employment from
help workers           by internal training and mentoring. However,             automation, but evidence of its effectiveness is
transition into        many transitions take place across companies             less established than for minimum/living wages,
these new jobs.        and the support for such moves is limited.178            and it poses greater funding challenges.184
                                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025   87
                      Pathways to Vision 2025
                      Investing in new economy                                    and worker welfare. New employment
                                                                                  models, such as job-sharing, have the
                      sectors and emerging roles                                  potential to provide flexibility and security.
                      A multistakeholder approach is essential to             –   Support public-private partnerships for
                      investing in new economy sectors and emerging               job creation. Addressing the employment
                      roles. Businesses and governments should                    gap and ensuring that the jobs created are
                      work together to understand the relationships               good jobs require sustained collaboration
                      and dependencies between industries, and                    among all levels of government, employers,
                      how strategies for job creation map across this             workers, labour unions, education and
                      ecosystem of relationships.                                 training providers, workforce technology
                                                                                  companies, employment agencies and
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway                foundations. Business leaders and investors
                      include:                                                    must pay closer attention to the longer-term
                                                                                  dividends of investing in the workforce.185
                      –   Adapt to new employment models.
                          Traditionally, companies have either hired          –   Scale up net-zero employment policies.
                          people as full-time equivalents or defaulted            Companies can commit to reskilling people
  New employment          to using variable staffing, contractors and             in at-risk jobs into new roles within or beyond
models, such as           freelancers. However, the inflexibility of              the company. Governments need to ensure
job-sharing, have         traditional employment models can discourage            that public investments crowd in rather than
the potential to          job creation and prompt workers to leave                crowd out private investments and should
provide flexibility       the labour market, and short-term solutions             collaborate with business to scale up net-zero
and security.             can come at the cost of security, stability             employment policies to the sector level.186
                      Supporting workers through job                              have experimented with a range of approaches
                                                                                  to reskilling but most firms are not doing
                      and career transitions                                      enough. There is scope for streamlining and
                                                                                  standardizing approaches to allow for scaling,
                      Supporting workers through job transitions requires         for instance new types of certification such as
                      a strong focus on reskilling and fostering a culture        micro-credentials. Governments can provide
                      that recognizes the social and economic value of            incentives for reskilling by funding training
                      investing in workers. While many governments                programmes and investing in online learning;
                      and businesses are helping employees prepare                only 21% of businesses report being able to use
                      for the future of work, more should be done to              public funds to help employees’ upskilling
                      build flexibility and adaptability into the culture         and reskilling.187
                      and processes of the formal workforce.
                                                                              –   Consider AI-supported redeployment.
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       Effective job-switching strategies require the
                                                                                  dynamic mapping of opportunities available to
                      –   Develop public- and private-sector                      workers based on their skills. Advanced data
                          programmes for reskilling. Leading companies            and AI capabilities matched with user-friendly
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025   88
   Advanced data          interfaces have an important role to play in         data need to be translated into policies and
and AI capabilities       job matching and assessing career transition         methodologies backed by realistic commitments.
matched with user-        options. Companies can create alliances both
friendly interfaces       within and beyond sectors to provide transition      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
have an important         pathways. Support for people undertaking
                          transitions can come from publicly provided          –   Implement effective minimum and living
role to play in job
                          safety nets and from the private sector rethinking       wage policies. Where effective minimum wage
matching and
                          outplacement to provide more extended support.           thresholds already exist, the case in many
assessing career                                                                   developed economies, the aim should be to
transition options.   –   Embrace diversity and re-evaluate barriers               ensure living wages. In non-OECD economies,
                          to entry. Facilitating smooth career transitions         the focus should be on implementing minimum
                          across sectors means widening the pool of                wages as a first step.189
                          candidates considered for traditional roles.
                          Businesses can do this by re-evaluating rigid        –   Commit to living wages. Businesses can
                          barriers to entry, addressing biases in the              commit to paying fair living wages to their own
                          hiring process and introducing mentorship                employees and ensuring their suppliers do
                          programmes for knowledge exchange.                       the same.
                                                                               –   Define and share methodology for ensuring
                      Providing minimum and living                                 living wages. While many businesses
                                                                                   agree that a living wage is a good thing,
                      wages                                                        fewer have a coherent idea on how to
                                                                                   make it a reality. A multistakeholder-driven
                      The ILO has robust definitions of minimum                    methodology and framework is needed to
                      wages,188 and the Global Living Wage Coalition               pave the path for change, drawing on strong
                      estimates realistic living wage levels. These                case studies and robust labour data.
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025    89
4   Technology
4.1   Advanced
      manufacturing
      and value chains
      Manufacturing is positioned to address
      global megatrends and to serve as a role
      model for a triple-bottom-line mindset.
      Representing more than 20% of the planet’s carbon         digital players and new entrants, manufacturing
      footprint190 and contributing to approximately            companies must go beyond digitalizing
      16% of global gross domestic product (GDP),191            operations and leveraging investments in
      manufacturing companies are positioned to drive           advanced manufacturing to transform their
      responsible growth while addressing the complex           operating and business models.
      challenges raised by consumers, climate change
      and digital transformation.                           –   The future of work. Work is shifting to become
                                                                more agile and flexible: the type of jobs and
      The challenges include:                                   skills needed are changing, while employees
                                                                are rethinking their work expectations regarding
      –   New consumer behaviours. The COVID-19                 volume, location, opportunities for advancement
          pandemic has deeply changed how consumers             and work-life balance. Companies can leverage
          select and buy products, and how they expect          these two developments by focusing on
          to be engaged by companies. Consumers                 workforce empowerment and retraining –
          seek frictionless purchases, full transparency        satisfying changing expectations of employees
          of product information, and personalized              while developing the necessary skill set for
          products, which require new levels of                 the future.
          performance and agility from manufacturing
          and supply chains.                                In addition, the risk profile associated with
                                                            manufacturing and value chains has increased
      –   Climate change and the imperative of a            significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic, with
          net-zero-emissions world. Current challenges      global events and growing challenges – such
          have elevated the importance of manufacturing     as the temporary blockage of the Suez Canal in
          companies in cutting CO2 emissions and            2021 or continuously increasing cybersecurity
          creating circular business models.                threats – become more prevalent, complex and
                                                            pressing. Manufacturing companies must be
      –   Digital transformation and disruption. To         empowered to embrace advanced manufacturing
          remain competitive in markets transforming with   towards more responsible and resilient growth.
                                                                                           Future Focus 2025   91
                    Vision 2025
                    Manufacturing is positioned to address global           achieve other targets. During challenges, such as
                    megatrends and to model a triple-bottom-                hiring employees and rising energy and regulatory
                    line mindset that benefits not only profits, but        costs, striving for more responsible production
                    also people and the planet. This vision can be          benefits not only shareholders, but also the whole
                    summarized under three strategic pillars:               ecosystem in which a company is integrated.
                                                                            Moving towards circular value chains and net-
                                                                            negative carbon manufacturing is imperative
                    Unlocking innovation in products,                       for a company to become more inclusive and
                                                                            sustainable. Companies drive sustainable and
                    technologies and business models                        profitable growth, set plans to achieve carbon
                                                                            neutrality and commit to ESG reporting throughout
                    Companies unlock and deploy innovative products,        manufacturing and production value chains.
   Moving towards   technologies and business models to create new
circular value      value and transform production industries with a
chains and net-     positive impact on society.                             Driving inclusive value creation
negative carbon
manufacturing
is imperative for
                    Moving to sustainable value                             Measures are taken to provide every manufacturing
                                                                            worker with new opportunities and to support
a company to        creation                                                companies of all sizes, regional governments and
become more                                                                 local communities in strengthening companies’
inclusive and       Sustainability in production is not just a vision and   competitiveness.
sustainable.        an explicit goal but also an enabler that can help
                    Pathways to Vision 2025
                    Creating value for all stakeholders                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                                                                            –   Provide clarity. Clear values must be
                    Innovative business models must ensure that                 established for all stakeholders when launching
                    value and growth are created for all stakeholders           new initiatives or adopting new technologies.
                    of a company, such as shareholders and
                    employees and their local business ecosystem,           –   Learn about the different stages of business
                    including customers, suppliers and government               model transformation. Strategies for each
                    agencies, among others. Leveraging innovation               stage exist and the board should ask key
                    and technology adoption are important to driving            questions to ensure a smooth transition
                    this transformation.                                        towards more digitalized business models.192
                                                                                                            Future Focus 2025   92
                      –   Join the cross-company accelerator. This             Leveraging technology adoption
                          accelerator, launched by the World Economic
                          Forum New Business Models enabled by
                          Advanced Manufacturing initiative, aims to           Companies cannot solely focus on technology
                          deliver interactions where organizations share       implementation; importantly, they must also
                          their own business model transformation              concentrate on its comprehensive adoption by their
                          journey.193                                          organization at all levels and in all functions and
                                                                               geographies. This requires significant adjustments to
                                                                               the work culture, organization and work processes
                      Building resilient value chains                          while considering local circumstances. Defining clear
                                                                               standards for excellence helps bring clarity and focus
                                                                               to the criteria for successful adoption, and sharing
                      Resilience must become a core part of supply             successful implementations and lessons learned can
                      chain strategies. Most legacy manufacturing              empower entire ecosystems to progress further.
                      and value chains have undertaken significant
                      upgrades to cope with unprecedented consumer             Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                      needs and demand volatility, increasingly complex
                      regulations and heightened expectations on               –   Become a global lighthouse. Companies
                      tracking the impact of sustainability. This has in           can submit a production site to be assessed
                      turn increased their reliance on complex digital             and designated as a “Global Lighthouse” to
                      systems – which can themselves face significant              showcase and share the experience.196
                      reliability issues and cybersecurity threats.
                                                                               –   Assess the readiness for introducing new
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway                 technologies. Companies can also use and
                      include:                                                     adopt the Smart Industry Readiness Index.197
                      –   Explore distinct resilience profiles and
                          identify best practices. The World Economic          Working towards human-centric
                          Forum White Paper, “Charting the Course for
                          Global Value Chain Resilience”, presents five
                                                                               production
                          distinct profiles of resilience leadership to help
                          companies in the manufacturing and supply            As the level of advanced manufacturing on the shop
                          chain ecosystem confidently chart a course           floor increases, a broader range of skills – some of
                          towards resilience with focus and action and         which are entirely new – becomes paramount to
                          to manage supply chain disruptions.194               the success of manufacturing businesses. It is thus
                                                                               important that companies identify and develop the
                      –   Assess the value chain resilience level.             right skill set today to ensure success in the future.
   Organizations          Organizations can use the resiliency compass,
can use the               a new framework for them to accelerate the           Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
resiliency                resilience-building process and define the
                          new priorities and actions needed to prepare         –   Develop the right skill set. The workforce
compass, a new
                          for and respond to future disruption.195                 must be enabled to participate in the modern
framework for them                                                                 manufacturing environment and interact with
to accelerate the     –   Consider resilience impacts when                         digitalized systems, enhancing their strengths
resilience-building       implementing new systems. The resilience of              and addressing their challenges for a more
process and define        value chains must be considered a key metric             inclusive environment. Both retraining and
the new priorities        when making investment decisions, keeping                increasing technical skills are important building
and actions.              both its positive and negative effects in mind.          blocks to achieve this.
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025   93
                       –   Nurture future leaders. Manufacturing               –   Internalize sustainability in the organization.
                           businesses should focus on nurturing future             An executive should be appointed for
                           leaders with the right mindset to address               sharing best practices and engaging in
                           global challenges.                                      cross-company dialogue about successful
                                                                                   sustainability initiatives and implementation.
                       –   Join the New Generation Industry Leaders
                           group. This Forum community comprises rising
                           industry leaders working to design and drive a      Unlocking data and value of data
                           responsible industry transformation.198
                                                                               sharing
                       –   Champion workforce augmentation.
                           Companies can appoint an executive with             Data are one of the most valuable digital assets that
                           responsibilities at the intersection of people,     serve businesses, consumers and employees.
                           operations and technology deployment to             Ensuring that data are captured, processed and
                           champion workforce augmentation initiatives         activated in an accurate and timely way is
                           within the organization.199                         paramount to maintaining trust in the digital
                                                                               ecosystem. Sophisticated applications often require
                       –   Share use cases and success stories.                the exchange of data beyond company boundaries
                           Manufacturing businesses could share                to effectively train AI algorithms and to support
                           successful cases of workforce augmentation          collaboration in complex networks that require full
                           in the production ecosystem with industry           transparency.200 It is also imperative to ensure a
                           pioneers, thought leaders, policy-makers and        responsible use of data and to be aware of potential
                           labour unions.                                      biases when training algorithms and AI.
                                                                               Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                       Developing sustainable
   Ensuring that                                                               –   Apply the Manufacturing Data Excellence
                       manufacturing systems                                       framework. The framework can help gain
data are captured,
                                                                                   actionable insights on the data maturity of the
processed and
                       Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:       organization.201
activated in an
accurate and timely    –   Adapt the business strategy. The core of            –   Join a community of senior executives.
way is paramount           the business strategy should incorporate                Such a community provides the opportunity to
to maintaining             sustainability, circularity and net-negative            discuss the change journey of becoming a data-
trust in the digital       carbon impact. This should be communicated              driven organization.202
ecosystem.                 throughout the organization.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025     94
4.2   Agile governance
      Agile governance helps ensure that emerging
      technologies can be harnessed for social
      progress, while supporting responsible and
      equitable transitions to the digital future.
      Traditional institutions and regulatory processes           connected. As social media, banks, healthcare,
      have lagged in adapting and responding to the               education and other fields integrate online, the
      technological advances that drive economic and              relationships between businesses, governments
      social changes. Agile governance approaches seek            and citizens will become more complex.
      to reform regulation and bridge divides by generating
      new approaches to policy-making that can unleash        –   Proactive business risk management. Business
      innovation while creating effective regulatory              and government must account for more risks
      frameworks and better governance outcomes.                  alongside growing social and environmental
                                                                  challenges. Mechanisms of traditional governance
      To support innovative ecosystems, agile                     have been slow to respond, resulting in
      governance will increasingly be influenced by               businesses voluntarily adopting social responsibility
      these trends:                                               measures, such as reporting on ESG metrics.
      –   Disruptive technologies. As a driver of agility     Such trends require agility to keep pace with the
          and an enabler of dynamic regulatory systems,       velocity of change in intricate systems, and
          technological disruption will continue to spur      governance frameworks to ensure governments
          adaptive policy systems that can keep pace          maintain control over regulatory and policy
          with digital advances.                              systems. Combined, agile governance helps ensure
                                                              that emerging technologies can be harnessed for
      –   Complex public-private relationships.               social progress while supporting responsible and
          The real and digital worlds are increasingly        equitable transitions into the digital future.
                                                                                                Future Focus 2025   95
                      Vision 2025
                      Agile governance represents a fundamental shift in       and regulations that better manage emerging
                      policy-making. To enable this shift, three actions for   technologies and are resilient to further
                      change are needed:                                       technological disruption. Many of the existing agile
                                                                               governance tools are only just starting to mature
                                                                               after being tested, refined and redeployed using
                      Harmonizing boundaries between                           identified best practices.
                      the public and private sectors                           Agile governance has evolved with the parallel
                                                                               imperative of using technology to deliver optimal
                      Governance can no longer be a one-way channel            regulatory and governance outcomes. The
                      from government to business. A more transparent          systematization of technologies can unlock
                      and collaborative process can steer innovation,          regulatory potential. An expanding field of
                      safeguard markets and protect consumers, all             deploying regulatory technologies, known as
                      without unduly curtailing advancement or burdening       “regtech”, leverages emerging technologies
                      the private sector. Harmonizing boundaries               such as artificial intelligence (AI) and blockchain
                      will require:                                            to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of
                                                                               regulatory processes. However, as businesses
                      Governments to:                                          increasingly take ownership of their social and
                                                                               economic responsibilities through proactive risk
                      –   Put consumers and businesses at the centre           management, it is also important to consider how
                          of the process of policy development                 technology will support agile-based structures
                                                                               like self-regulation or industry self-governance.
                      –   Work across departments and authorities to
                          coordinate supervision of the private sector
                                                                               Building demand and capacity
                      –   Innovate their policy-making process
                      Businesses to:                                           Agile methods can help government and business
                                                                               overcome structural disadvantages that impede
                      –   Engage policy-makers and other industry              fast-paced decision-making and adoption.
                          stakeholders proactively                             For government, challenges include complex
                                                                               bureaucratic processes and departmental silos.
                      –   Be open about their needs and objectives to          For business, complex legislation, high monitoring
                          help governments stay on top of the landscape        and reporting costs, and regulatory uncertainty are
                                                                               significant hurdles.
                      –   Invest in education and capacity building to
                          make new technologies more accessible                Greater awareness is about how agile techniques
   Agile governance                                                            provide value. Examples include sandboxes,
involves the          Redefining public-private relationships is essential.    machine-coded regulation and performance-
development           Without removing boundaries, implementing                based regulation – from facilitating the birth of
of governance         collaborative risk-sharing models can help avoid         new industries and delivering social services to
frameworks,           conflicts of interest while harmonizing exchange         managing environmental activities. Furthermore,
policies and          between government and business.                         capacity building is vital to create broader
regulations that                                                               understandings of agile principles, such as
                                                                               human-centred design and experimentation, and
better manage
emerging              Developing the tools                                     to enhance personal abilities to create more agile
                                                                               leaders. It empowers policy-makers with the right
technologies          and technology                                           knowledge and tools to facilitate their governance
and are resilient                                                              of technology and their use of technology to
to further            Agile governance strives to improve the regulation       govern. It also empowers businesses to iteratively
technological         and governance of technology. It involves the            improve and adapt their innovations to meet market
disruption.           development of governance frameworks, policies           demands and deploy technologies responsibly.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025   96
Pathways to Vision 2025
Establishing scale                                            learn” mindset. Programmes such as the Dubai
                                                              Programme to Enable Drone Transportation,
                                                              and designated physical experimentation fields,
For agile governance to scale beyond specific use             help foster innovation beyond in a safe space.
cases, pilots and champions, an environment must
exist where businesses and policy-makers can              –   Share agile governance techniques and best
embrace collaboration, experimentation and user-              practice. As an evolving area, it is important
centred design.                                               to invest in understanding how best to employ
                                                              and deploy agile governance. The Global Future
Strategies for putting this pathway to use include:           Council on Agile Governance is developing a set
                                                              of modules to help business leaders and policy-
–   Foster agile leadership. Leaders can                      makers feel confident in using agile governance.
    encourage others to embrace new methods of
    policy-making by sharing the achievements of          –   Evolve from sandbox to scalebox. While
    agile governance. The Agile 50 list, an initiative        small-scale experimentation (e.g. sandboxes)
    by Apolitical and the World Economic Forum                has proven fruitful for policy development, it
    Global Future Council on Agile Governance,                tends to involve a small number of market
    shares the contributions of such leaders.203              actors. The next stage is to establish
                                                              “scaleboxes” – as recommended by the Kalifa
–   Establish designated innovation fields.                   Review of U.K. Fintech – where experimentation
    Fostering experimentation is important to                 can occur in the market with consumers and
    shifting from a “set-and-forget” to a “test-and-          focus on growth.204
Integrating partnership models                            –   New public-private partnerships. Public-
                                                              private partnerships are evolving by
                                                              incorporating increased risk sharing, data
Multistakeholder collaboration is at the core of              sharing and insight sharing, moving from
agile governance. It is critical to engage all relevant       consultation to joint efforts to shape
stakeholders – from developers and users to                   responsible technology ecosystems. These
regulators – to foster knowledge exchange for                 partnerships exist along the spectrum from
the most optimal outcomes. These partnerships                 communities involved in early-stage innovation
are tools for deploying agile governance.                     to larger companies.
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:     –   International regulatory cooperation.
                                                              Digital technologies know no borders.
–   Joined-up regulation. Emerging technologies               Governments should collaborate internationally
    can be managed using a “whole-of-government”              on regulating innovation by sharing knowledge
    approach that promotes coordination across                and pooling resources. The Agile Nations,
    regulators to streamline processes and drive              of which the World Economic Forum is an
    consistency, especially for industries that may           observer, seeks to drive intergovernmental
    report to several authorities.                            regulatory cooperation.205
                                                                                         Future Focus 2025   97
                     Designing digital-ready policies                        –   Scan the horizon for future trends. Recent
                                                                                 developments should be considered to
                                                                                 extrapolate how they may evolve. For example,
                     Digital-ready policies are created with digital             what would make policies ready to manage
                     developments in mind to ensure they are future-             the metaverse?
                     proof and equipped to deal with the impact of
                     technological advances and digitalization.              –   Expand capacity of policy-making institutions.
                                                                                 At a minimum, relevant stakeholders must
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway                understand current technology and take
                     include:                                                    advantage of new technological capabilities in
                                                                                 their policy-making methodology.
                     –   Assess the readiness. Existing and new rules
                         must be reviewed to determine whether they can
                         be implemented using the latest technologies.
  Emerging           Deploying technology in support                         –   Foster government-driven consistency.
technologies                                                                     Even when governments do not have a direct
                     of regulation                                               regulatory role, they can foster consistency
hold significant
potential to                                                                     and clarity for voluntary mechanisms. This
                     Regulation and reporting represent a large                  includes enhancing public risk management and
improve regulatory
                     investment for businesses. Emerging technologies            government frameworks, as well as providing
processes, but
                     hold significant potential to improve regulatory            public data (see “Reuse data”). For example,
they are currently   processes, but they are currently underused.                government-driven consistency in ESG reporting
underused.                                                                       can help limit the potential of greenwashing.
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                                                                             –   Reuse data. Instead of business needing
                     –   Invest in regtech. The Global Future Council on         to establish duplicative data collection and
                         Agile Governance is developing use cases and a          measurement for compulsory and voluntary
                         roadmap for using regtech to improve processes          regulation, authorities can enable business to use
                         for heavily regulated industries. This will help        public databases (with appropriate safeguards)
                         governments and business to understand why              to help shape digital governance. This can
                         and how they can apply emerging technologies            decrease ambiguity and increase consistency of
                         to regulation, for example through machine-             reporting with comparable and verifiable data.
                         readable code or natural-language processing.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025   98
4.3   Artificial intelligence
      for humanity
      Equity and inclusion must be addressed
      throughout the AI life cycle.
      In response to the growing backlash against         Three areas to address include:
      harmful applications of AI systems, industries,
      governments, academics and civil society
      representatives have created numerous resources     –   Skills and knowledge gaps. Under-
      to encourage the responsible development                represented groups receive less information
      and use of AI across sectors and geographies.           about AI, creating a barrier to entry for
      While the long-term impact of AI – especially           advanced degrees, jobs, and economic growth.
      on marginalized groups – is yet unknown,
      engagement in design and policy development         –   Entrenched bias. AI systems and related
      is largely absent in communities most directly          public policy designed by homogeneous
      affected by automation and other AI applications.       groups fail to account for adverse impacts of
      A new blueprint for conceptual design,                  the technology’s use in the broader world.
      programmatic development and governance of AI
      is needed to include diverse perspectives at the    –   Rapid digital transformation. Companies
      table and mitigate risk of harm in deployment.          adopt strategies without proper governance
                                                              of training, testing and deployment to promote
                                                              safe, equitable and inclusive practices.
                                                          Equity and inclusion must be addressed in every
                                                          corner of the AI life cycle to ensure that the
                                                          development and use of AI technologies serve all
                                                          of society.
                                                                                          Future Focus 2025   99
                       Vision 2025
                       Increasing representation                              Ensuring equitable outcomes
                       Given the reach of AI, it is critical to ensure        Given the potential for AI systems to affect all lives, it
                       individuals and communities have a basic               is critical that these systems employ fair processes
                       understanding of AI, are protected from algorithmic    and produce equitable outcomes. This can be
                       bias, and are able to benefit from AI’s myriad         supported by appropriate training, business practices,
                       benefits. A more representative AI ecosystem will      regulations and tools, such as comprehensive
                       prioritize responsible technology, demystify AI        impact assessments of proposed systems.
                       and harness innovation to contribute to a more
                       equitable world.                                       Technical solutions for bias and fairness
                       Access to knowledge                                    –   Ensure that explainability, transparency,
                                                                                  robustness, bias and fairness principles are
                       –   Governments should mandate accessible AI/              integrated into programming standards,
                           tech literacy programmes in diverse languages          protocols, logic and encryption.
                           for all citizens, with greater attention on more
                           heavily affected communities.                      –   Ensure cloud platforms and stacks are upgraded
                                                                                  appropriately to address bias and fairness.
                       –   Companies should offer mentorship and
                           continuous skills development programmes.          –   Define success and measure progress through
                                                                                  specific key performance indicators (KPIs).
                       –   Society should gain greater awareness of
                           potential harm, and understanding of when and      Holistic approaches to promoting fairness
                           how AI is used.
                                                                              –   Ensure equitable access to infrastructure.
                       Equity and diversity at the decision-making level
                                                                              –   Ensure that data are produced and code is
                       –   The global South should be recognized as               signed by impacted communities.
                           having an equitable stake in the design,
                           development and financial return of AI.            –   Obtain informed consent from users of the AI
                                                                                  systems, and make options for redress and
   It is critical to   –   Decision-making bodies should be diverse in            debate available.
ensure individuals         composition and implement best practices
and communities            in inclusion throughout the AI life cycle.
have a basic                                                                  Deploying AI benefits for all
                       Opportunities for consultation
understanding of                                                              stakeholders
AI, are protected      –   Design, development and use should involve
from algorithmic           all stakeholders, especially women, girls,         What is considered beneficial in one community
bias, and are able         people of colour, persons with disabilities,       may be considered harmful in another. Seemingly
to benefit from AI’s       displaced populations and other under-             innocuous pieces of personal information in
myriad benefits.           represented groups.                                AI applications can be damaging if used for
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025 100
misinformation campaigns or government control             Benefits of AI are known, accessible and
of citizens. It is crucial that the provision of data or   shared across social groups
use of AI is made explicit along with a technology’s
proposed benefit. Companies should enable users            –   Benefits of AI are clearly articulated to
to opt out of an AI system if its proposed benefit is          stakeholders.
not valued by users, or if potential harms are seen to
outweigh benefits.                                         –   Stakeholders have access to AI social
                                                               entrepreneurship programmes.
AI is developed and used with a beneficial
purpose in mind                                            AI is beneficial even to groups without a voice
–   Socially beneficial use cases are clear.               –   AI development prioritizes a transgenerational
                                                               focus to benefit and not harm youth or future
–   Indigenous governance, traditional knowledge               generations, in alignment with human rights
    and perspectives of marginalized groups are                and the SDGs.
    integrated into organizational and technological
    decision-making.                                       –   AI’s effect on the environment is measured
                                                               and minimized.
–   Alternative options are available to stakeholders
    who prefer to opt out of AI use.
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025 101
                        Pathways to Vision 2025
                        Breaking linguistic barriers                            Expanding education and
                                                                                training opportunities
                        Most of the information on emerging technologies
                        is written in English, which creates a barrier of       AI impacts everyone, yet few specialists have
                        entry to AI jobs and monocultural AI products and       the requisite knowledge and training. Education
                        policy, both of which serve to limit the beneficial     systems, public entities and businesses must
                        opportunities of the technology.                        promote the acquisition of skills and competencies
                                                                                required for an AI-powered society. This will
                        Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:   stimulate innovation and new ways of seeing,
                                                                                valuing and using AI.
                        –   Place linguistic diversity at the core of AI
                            strategy. As access to knowledge depends            Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                            on language, give precedence to non-English
                            educational opportunities as the foundation of      –   Embrace a holistic approach. Formal and
                            national or corporate AI strategies, and provide        informal educational communities integrate
                            more visual messaging.                                  AI learning, regardless of school, company
                                                                                    or socioeconomic status, in culturally
                        –   Enable shared vocabulary across                         appropriate ways.
  Education                 stakeholders. Encourage interaction and
systems, public             collaboration across developers, business teams,    –   Make AI education engaging.
                            civil society and consumers to ensure the entire        Straightforward, exciting and engaging
entities and
                            AI ecosystem uses a shared vocabulary.                  education, integrated into arts and humanities
businesses must                                                                     pedagogy, will contribute greatly to increasing
promote the             –   Improve technical capabilities in various               diversity in the AI ecosystem.
acquisition of skills       languages of AI technologies. Leverage and
and competencies            expand on technological advances in translation     –   Implement role-specific training on AI
required for an AI-         through expanded training sets and funding of           fairness. Employees in all departments
powered society.            AI-based text recognition in new languages.             should receive basic information on what AI
                            is, what it can and cannot do, and how they         –   Apply a systems-thinking approach. The
                            can influence outcomes. The World Economic              potential unintended consequences of AI
                            Forum White Paper entitled “A Holistic Guide            technologies should be mapped out, moving
                            to Approaching AI Fairness Education in                 away from a transactional view that positions
                            Organizations” offers recommendations on                businesses and innovators at the centre of
                            how to implement this.206                               technology agendas, conversations and
                                                                                    development.
                        –   Reach the public sector. Supporting
                            education improvements in the public sector is      –   Encourage continuous learning. AI education
                            essential to ensure good AI governance and the          is accessible and encouraged from grade
                            implementation of responsible AI policies.              school through professional education in a
                                                                                    range of formats, including certifications.
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025 102
                       Building vital AI infrastructure                             additional resources will be needed to transmit
                                                                                    information from paper to digital storage.
                       Private- and public-sector actors must co-develop        –   Establish feedback channels for impacted
                       critical infrastructure, from data storage to fora           stakeholders. Creating opportunities for
                       for dialogue with diverse sectors. This foundation           increased communication between AI creators
                       will enable nations currently lagging in AI maturity         and consumers will be important, as will
                       to leapfrog ahead, both in their economy as well             communicating ways in which feedback has
                       as their efforts in governance. It would also offer          resulted in changes to the AI system. It is also
                       companies universal consumer engagement                      important to empower facilitating organizations
                       to help shape and improve AI systems.                        (e.g. consumer groups) and to offer opportunities
                                                                                    for redress.
                       Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
   Private- and                                                                 –   Empower the participation of stakeholders
                       –   Prioritize the set-up of AI infrastructure               in decision-making. Rather than passive
public-sector
                           to fully deliver impact to all communities.              community participation as currently employed
actors must co-            National governments, together with cloud                (often part of user experience [UX] testing), an
develop critical           providers and chipset companies, lead on                 “inclusive by design” methodology should be
infrastructure, from       infrastructure and data training projects to             embraced. Impact assessment tools should
data storage to fora       facilitate communities receiving the benefits of         be deployed wherever possible and an agile
for dialogue with          AI. This will be particularly crucial in countries       approach to feedback adopted, including via
diverse sectors.           lacking robust electronic data storage, where            social media.
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025 103
4.4   Media, entertainment
      and sport
      With almost 4 billion users consuming media,
      entertainment and sports content daily, these
      sectors have enormous potential to influence
      people’s perspectives and livelihoods.
      Several trends are accelerating the media               –   Metaverse. The metaverse refers to a set
      industry’s role in shaping the world:                       of concepts and trends that, some experts
                                                                  believe, represent the next major computing
      –   Digital safety. Harmful content, conduct and            platform. Central to the idea is extended
          contact have proliferated online and pose               reality (XR), defined as “a combination
          huge risks to all internet users, particularly          of augmented, virtual and mixed reality
          vulnerable groups such as children. Social              environments that are accessible and
          platforms have made it easier to create and             interactive in real time”.207 When combined
          distribute all types of information, but this has       with blockchain applications, XR could
          also resulted in harmful and illegal content.           blend the physical and digital worlds to
                                                                  increasing degrees, enabling new forms of
      –   DE&I. The decisions people make about how               social and commercial interaction, creativity
          they create content, whose stories they share           and value creation. This hybrid environment
          and what narratives and perceptions they shape          – the metaverse – may eventually become
          will have a lasting impact on society. Advancing        an extension of the real-world economy,
          DE&I in media and entertainment is crucial to           transforming consumer experiences and
          creating a more equitable, just society.                business models across industries.
                                                                                             Future Focus 2025 104
Vision 2025
Advancing digital safety                                      and security online as well as delineating
                                                              responsibilities between the public and
                                                              private sectors.
Mechanisms and tools for public-private
cooperation:                                              –   There is an agreed upon risk-based framework
                                                              for the optimal use of interventions, such as
–   Stakeholders define harmful content differently;          content removal and account suspensions.
    areas such as hate speech, sexual exploitation
    and misinformation are not understood uniformly       –   An industry‑wide accepted measure of user
    across platforms and national jurisdictions.              safety on digital platforms exists.
–   Regulators, companies and other stakeholders
    need to productively tackle these challenges in a     Ensuring diversity, equity and
    collaborative way and address underlying safety
    tensions and trade-offs.
                                                          inclusion in media
Industry accountability and effective regulation:         Accurate portrayals in content:
–   Industry accountability and oversight are currently   –   In-content diversity is directly seen, heard or
    lacking: no comprehensive third-party auditing            experienced by the audience. Measurements
    processes and practices to evaluate accuracy or           may focus on the number of diverse characters
    the effectiveness of content moderation practices         and their time on-screen, or portrayals or the
    and policy enforcement exist.                             stereotypes that are challenged or perpetuated.
–   Regulatory schemes are no longer fragmented           –   Diverse characters and fair portrayals allow
    national approaches that increase cost,                   audiences to hear their stories being told in an
    complexity and uncertainty for businesses,                authentic manner. Ads, games, videos and other
    especially smaller players. Alignment on a global         forms of media can have harmful unintended
    or multi-jurisdictional regulatory framework has          consequences when they portray groups
    significantly helped in this regard.                      in a certain way or reinforce stereotypes.
Safety principles to guide trade-offs,                    Diversity and representation in creative roles:
interventions and measures:
                                                          –   Creative diversity is vital to creating content
–   Alignment on common digital safety principles             that reflects the lived experiences of diverse
    is fundamental to shape policies and processes            audiences. It is important to assess who is
    for balancing safety, privacy, free expression            creating the content, who is greenlighting it,
                                                                                            Future Focus 2025 105
    and what cultures exist around that content to      way, transforming consumer experiences, value
    meaningfully measure how the output reflects        creation and business models across industries.
    its audiences.
                                                        The World Economic Forum Global Future Council
Measurement and transparency:                           on Media, Entertainment and Sport supports efforts
                                                        in two areas:
–   This requires the ability to measure DE&I impact
    based upon data and transparency from               –   The governance of extended reality (XR).
    organizations. An objective and neutral service         This involves working on policy frameworks for
    to measure the state of diversity in the industry       XR systems; promoting equity, inclusion and
    is critical for benchmarking and assessing              accessibility; ensuring economic opportunity
    success and opportunities for improvement.              and interoperability while preserving user
                                                            privacy; and reducing potential harms in
–   Audience sentiment is an effective metric for           immersive environments.
    successful representation as it can be influenced
    and assessed quickly.                               –   Value creation in the metaverse. This involves
                                                            defining how assets are designed, advertised,
Governance and value creation in                            marketed and sold; mapping value chains, IP
                                                            and investment models and trends influencing
the metaverse                                               the landscape; realizing the potential of the
                                                            creator economy; identifying incentives and
Several fundamental technologies come together              risks in developing the metaverse; and analysing
in an integrated, interoperable and inclusive               the metaverse’s impact on society and culture.
Pathways to Vision 2025
Harnessing public-private                                   1. A global charter of principles for digital
                                                               safety: Designing underlying principles and
cooperation to advance                                         responsibilities for governing digital safety
digital safety                                                 across the public and private sectors,
                                                               guiding decision-making that requires
Advancing public-private cooperation on tackling               balancing privacy, safety and security
harmful activity online will be critical as current
measures do not effectively attribute accountability        2. A toolkit for digital safety interventions:
to the relevant players in the ecosystem.                      Exploring digital safety interventions as well
                                                               as preventative measures across the public
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:          and private sectors; outlining appropriate
                                                               usage based on various risk factors
–   Join the Global Coalition for Digital Safety.
    This coalition aims to “accelerate public-private       3. New measures and standards for
    cooperation to tackle harmful content online and           protecting vulnerable groups online:
    exchange best practices for new online safety              Identifying mechanisms that are particularly
    regulation, take coordinated action to reduce              used to target vulnerable groups, and
    the risk of online harms, and drive collaboration          drive international standards in addressing
    on programmes to enhance digital media                     these successfully; outlining more effective
    literacy”.208 The coalition is working towards:            measures to assess how safe users are
                                                                                         Future Focus 2025 106
   Advancing                   on a given product or service, particularly           demographics can be prominent measures
public-private                 given that current measures do not capture            of the DE&I footprint. The taskforce has
                               outsized harm to vulnerable groups                    developed a Diversity Representation Maturity
cooperation on
                                                                                     framework to instil a clear, well-defined
tackling harmful
                        –   Ensure digital safety and protection by                  structure around the components that
activity online             design in the metaverse/Web3. As the                     constitute effective diversity and inclusion in
will be critical            exploration of how to operate safely in the              the media and entertainment industries.209
as current                  metaverse progresses, it will be imperative to
measures do not             consider digital safety components from the          –   Use the cross-sector index. Building on the
effectively attribute       outset to create safe online spaces and avoid            Diversity Representation Maturity framework,
accountability              replication of existing safety limitations in Web2       a cross-sector index that measures audience
to the relevant             and social media.                                        sentiment and demographics can be used
players.                                                                             to compare the attitudes and behaviours of
                                                                                     diverse identity groups. This index will help
                        Improving diversity and                                      to enable the adoption of best practices and
                                                                                     develop insights into where progress is lacking.
                        representation in content and                                Refreshing it periodically could illustrate the
                        creative production                                          collective progress and impact by sector. The
                                                                                     first Audience Representation Index serves as a
                        Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:        baseline for the industry to better measure and
                                                                                     advance the state of diversity and inclusion.210
                        –   Join the Power of Media taskforce and
                            follow guidance for improving measurement,           –   Prioritize inclusivity in the metaverse. The
                            transparency and accountability. Diversity               generation leading the growth on the metaverse
                            data from companies can be aggregated                    will not tolerate non-inclusive creative content.
                            and published to create a sense of urgency               Intentionality, transparency and accountability
                            and internal pressure for other organizations.           are critical to truly represent audiences and
                            The companies that voluntarily report their              empower creators in the metaverse. The
                            diversity data can gain the trust and favour of          optimism on DE&I needs to be acknowledged
                            consumers and investors. A common set of                 to create an inclusive environment in the
                            metrics and goals across sectors can help to             metaverse, where organizations will need to
                            hold all players accountable. It is widely agreed        lead by example to create an equitable future
                            by the taskforce that audience sentiment and             enabled by technology and innovation.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025 107
4.5   Quantum computing
      The path to scalable, commercial
      quantum computers will become
      increasingly clear in the next five years.
      The potential of quantum science and technology          –   Emerging market for first-generation
      could be as transformative as semiconductors                 noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ)
      in the 20th century, with massive economic                   computers. This is driven by early adoption
      impact in sectors ranging from information and               and experimentation across the public sector
      communications technology to healthcare, for                 and industries.
      example. The technology is in its early stages, with
      many options for underlying platforms. Due to this       The path to a scalable and commercial quantum
      emerging state, the road ahead is uncertain.             computer will become increasingly clear in the
                                                               next five years. Many system improvements are
      Three key trends are bound to drive the rapid change     expected, including a sizeable increase in the
      and require action from the international community:     number of qubits and better error-correction
                                                               techniques. Algorithms for use cases are under
      –   Rapid growth in venture financing and large          development for hybrid quantum-classical
          public (state) investments. This will lead to high   systems, and numerous tools for the supporting
          expectations, strong competition for talent, and     quantum infrastructure stack are emerging. As
          economic and geopolitical policy interventions.      quantum computing holds potential to redefine
                                                               power structures, the international community
      –   Growing quantum ecosystems. University-              should act now to guide it in a responsible way
          affiliated ecosystems will continue to drive         rather than exacerbate geopolitical tensions.
          hardware, software and application development.
                                                                                              Future Focus 2025 108
                     Vision 2025
                     Developing commercial                                  This means all governments, companies and
                                                                            individuals are treated fairly and equally while
                     applications and quantum                               protecting the intellectual property (IP) of all
                     solutions                                              parties. In turn, it requires a robust supply chain for
                                                                            components, as well as competitive and accessible
                     A bold vision for 2025 includes a clear pathway        (open-source) software with clear standards
                     towards a viable demonstration of quantum              and benchmarks so that competing hardware
                     advantage, wherein a quantum computer solves           and software can be meaningfully compared.
                     an application of interest cheaper, faster or more     This could include as diverse a set as materials,
                     accurately than a classical computer. The first        equipment for fabrication, the key quantum
                     demonstrations of potential quantum-computer-          components, control electronics and cryogenic
                     enabled results that are beyond the capabilities of    equipment, and software layers and algorithms.
                     the highest-performing classical computers will be
                     achieved. A pathway towards a proof-of-concept         To enable this, a coalition of like-minded countries
                     contributing quantum computing solutions to            signs a “Quantum Act” with a governing framework
                     global problems – for example, modelling climate       for collaborative research and development, export
                     change or finding new materials to use in the          controls, talent development and exchange, with
                     energy transition – leads to a future where quantum    the necessary funds and organization to support
                     computing will become a necessary part of all          implementation. The goal is broad trade
                     computing frameworks.                                  agreements between nation states and international
                                                                            markets that foster trust, transparency and equity
                     To achieve this, the availability of the relevant      and that encourage technology access for
                     algorithms as well as the necessary near-term          countries of all economic statuses. Specific
                     quantum hardware and supporting classical              roadblocks that prevent international collaboration
                     infrastructure, is required. At that time, end users   and the free flow of ideas and scientific know-how
                     will be positioned to scale the achieved proofs        should be overcome.
                     of concept(s) and further reinvest to enable
                     other demonstrations.
                                                                            Defining common ethical standards
                                                                            on the use of quantum computing
                     Reaching the quantum
                     advantage through a trusted                            The transformative potential of quantum computers
                     ecosystem and community                                accelerates the need to anticipate and define
                                                                            common ethical standards that will frame the
   The Vision 2025   In this vision, international tension related to       future use of these machines. This is foreseen as
is to create an      critical technologies exists due to economic           a key area of work for the next several years.
open, trustworthy    competition and geopolitical manoeuvres that
and fair global      undermine fair and open competition. A growing         Before 2025, representatives from the quantum
marketplace          consensus emerges that quantum computing               computing industry, research organizations and
                     will create value as progress continues to shift       different governments meet and reflect on the core
that provides an
                     from basic research to commercial developments         ethical foundations of the technology. A constructive
ecosystem for        in established companies and new start-ups.            dialogue leads to regional and even international
robust competition                                                          consensus on ethical use principles, such as
for both the         The Vision 2025 is to create an open, trustworthy      accessibility, equality, inclusiveness, transparency,
development and      and fair global marketplace that provides an           accountability and the common good. Consensus
use of quantum       ecosystem for robust competition for both the          also extends to inappropriate use made possible by
computers.           development and use of quantum computers.              the future use of quantum computers.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025 109
Pathways to Vision 2025
Increasing the number of                                 workforce about standards, benchmarking and
                                                         new areas of the field.
quantum learners
                                                     –   Educate the future workforce. Efforts to
To meet the needs of the growing quantum                 expand education include increasing the
computing industry and accompanying basic                number of undergraduate and graduate
research, a larger workforce is necessary                programmes offering courses in quantum
worldwide. This requires training a new cohort           computing, as well as introducing quantum
of quantum specialists, including current                computing basics in secondary education.
professionals and future graduates. Efforts should
be made to encourage diversity and inclusion.        –   Attract a broad and diverse workforce. Vital
                                                         to ensuring fair, excellent quantum products
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway             and services that cater to global communities,
include:                                                 this can be achieved with outreach programmes
                                                         in secondary and post-secondary education,
–   Equip the current workforce. This involves           online platforms and courses that can reach a
    fostering open science and exchange                  global and diverse audience. Targeted initiatives
    programmes and establishing dedicated                to increase diversity (especially gender) and
    training programmes to teach the current             inclusiveness can also be part of this strategy.
Investing strategically for                          –   Align investment strategies. Public- and
                                                         private-sector investments should be balanced
optimal growth                                           by allocating government funding in broad
                                                         infrastructure projects, long-term research and
To support a sustainable framework for growth            overarching societal use cases.
in quantum computing globally, resources
and activities from public- and private-sector       –   Foster cooperation between the public
entities must be optimally aligned. A reliable           and private sectors. Public- and private-
overview of the global technology landscape,             sector actors can increase their interactions,
as well as the coordination of public- and               as academia and national labs bolster private
private-sector investment and activities, can            industry development and pave the way for
lead to more efficient resource allocation and           future ideas and innovations. This also helps
an acceleration of the technology and its use.           enable a cohesive and collaborative global
                                                         ecosystem with room for protecting IP.
Strategies for operationalizing this pathway
include:                                             Establishing a framework for
–   Monitor the global technology landscape.
                                                     international collaboration
    Neutral positional papers (“State of
    Quantum report”) should be produced that         To help global industry and markets develop and
    document existing global national quantum        support common goals and values, it is imperative
    investment strategies as well as industry        to start building the framework and governing
    development roadmaps, and identify               principles for this market now. A balance is
    opportunities for optimal future investments.    required between open science, the free flow of
                                                                                     Future Focus 2025 110
                         talent and ideas, and the protection of shared        Developing open-source
                         values, such as respect for IP arrangements
                         and responsible use of technology. To this end,
                                                                               resources for standards and
                         existing bodies, such as standardization groups,      software
                         will need to consider quantum computing as
                         part of their mission, and new frameworks             To appropriately enable an ecosystem to harness
                         will need to be established to guide the              quantum advantage in a fair and ethical way, it is
                         development of quantum computing systems.             critical that parts of the quantum computing stack
                                                                               are developed in open source.
                         Strategies for operationalizing this pathway
                         include:                                              Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                         –   Establish a trusted community. A group            –   Create open access to quantum systems
                             of experts from academia, industry and                over the cloud. Resource estimation for
                             government should be convened to serve as             applications of interest should be transparent,
                             the initiators of the trusted community. This         and open-source software communities need
                             group should implement tangible actions               to help ensure equitable access and learning in
                             that accelerate the trusted community,                quantum computing. Many existing open-source
                             such as membership models and screening               projects in this space can be developed further.
   To appropriately          procedures for investors and companies.
enable an                                                                      –   Stimulate the development of open-source
ecosystem to             –   Establish an international coordinating               quantum computing tools and software.
                             body. It should involve all major ecosystems          Open-source software communities can
harness quantum
                             and initiate the actions needed, with a special       help ensure equitable access and learning in
advantage in a fair
                             effort to include less advantaged countries and       quantum computing.
and ethical way, it          societies.
is critical that parts                                                         –   Safeguard open science. A diverse and global
of the quantum           –   Create internationally accepted standards             community of researchers should be maintained
computing stack              and benchmarks. This will help to foster              to build and investigate underpinning science,
are developed in             transparency over the efficiency of available         technology and applications of quantum
open source.                 hardware and software solutions.                      computing.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025 111
4.6   Scientific collaboration
      Global scientific collaboration is necessary
      to tackle global challenges, from climate
      change to health.
      The COVID-19 pandemic demonstrates once                    Some barriers are put in place deliberately
      more that global scientific collaboration is               by governments to prevent contact with
      necessary to tackle global challenges, from climate        people from other countries. Some are by
      change to health. Innovative solutions require             coincidence, such as reduced mobility due
      contributions from a diverse array of countries,           to closed borders. All make it more difficult
      disciplines, sectors and backgrounds to ensure             for scientists to collaborate internationally.
      access to the best talent, knowledge and data
      available, and to a variety of perspectives.           –   Balancing fundamental and mission-driven
                                                                 research. Most countries increasingly prioritize
      Three trends in scientific collaboration stand out:        mission-driven applied research. This favours
                                                                 research focused on specific goals, such as
      –   COVID-19. The pandemic has disrupted many              developing a COVID-19 vaccine, at the expense
          aspects of research. As the world establishes a        of open-ended, curiosity-driven basic research
          “new normal”, there is an opportunity to decide        that generates the fundamental knowledge to
          which changes may improve the research                 fuel future mission-driven research.
          system. The pandemic also provides lessons
          for dealing with other shared global challenges,   Approaches to these and other trends will shape
          like global warming and cybersecurity.             scientific progress for decades to come. They will
                                                             affect the type, quality and amount of knowledge
      –   Retreat from multilateralism. Reduced              produced, who gets trained to produce it, the
          collaboration between countries impedes            level of technological innovation and, ultimately,
          collaboration between their scientists.            humanity’s ability to respond to future global crises.
                                                                                              Future Focus 2025 112
                       Vision 2025
                       Ensuring scientific infrastructure                         –   Pre-print servers allow free publishing and
                                                                                      access to papers but without pre-publication
                       and funding                                                    vetting, leaving it to the reader to evaluate a
                                                                                      paper’s quality.
   Open science        Science is a public good that relies to a large extent
is a crucial tool to   on public investments in research to run laboratories      –   Open data repositories allow the direct
ensure scientific      and train the next generation of researchers.                  sharing of data. A lack of standards for
progress across        Scientists gravitate towards research for which                these repositories, though, means that their
                       funding and infrastructure are available, making               quality varies widely, and that data cannot
the world and thus
                       the development of scientific infrastructure and the           easily be shared across different platforms.
reduce inequalities.
                       availability of funding two of the most direct ways to
                       influence the direction of scientific research. A proper   Promoting scientific
                       balance between funding for mission-driven and for
                       fundamental research ensures both short-term and
                                                                                  communication and literacy
                       long-term scientific and technological progress.
                                                                                  Effective and transparent communication of
                       International collaborations currently face high           scientific findings, from public lectures to Wikipedia
                       barriers to success, as most countries focus on            edit-a-thons, can improve collaboration between
                       funding domestic research initiatives. A multilateral      scientists and make science accessible to the
                       approach to scientific funding enables larger, more        public. This brings new perspectives to scientific
                       ambitious projects that no single country can              endeavours, allowing for thinking that more directly
                       accomplish alone. The economic fallout of COVID-19         addresses the needs of the wider community,
                       and reduced multilateral collaboration may spur            from citizen science initiatives to industrial
                       governments to cut funding for international scientific    partnerships. On the other hand, poor scientific
                       collaborations and projects. These decisions will          communication can contribute to misinformation
                       jeopardize scientific progress, preparedness for           and reduce trust in science. Developing scientific
                       future global crises and the scientific diplomacy          literacy, through both the education system and
                       which arises from international collaborations.            interactions between scientists and the public,
                                                                                  can help promote trust in and support for science,
                                                                                  and collaboration across sectors and borders.
                       Disseminating knowledge
                                                                                  Ensuring academic freedom
                       In order to collaborate, scientists must be able to
                       easily share their findings and data. While scientists
                                                                                  and integrity
                       have traditionally shared knowledge with one
                       another through peer-reviewed journal articles,            Academic freedom and integrity are integral
                       high subscription fees make most of the journals           to the pursuit of scientific research. It is not
                       inaccessible to scientists in lower-income countries.      possible to conduct productive collaborative
                       Open science is therefore a crucial tool to ensure         work where partners may lack the full right to
                       scientific progress across the world and thus reduce       freedom of speech and opinion. The COVID-19
                       inequalities. Several platforms exist to circumvent        pandemic gave rise to cases where public health
                       these limitations:                                         measures were hindered by national pressure.
                                                                                  Climate change also provides examples where
                       –   Open-access journals make their articles freely        restrictions preventing government scientists from
                           available to readers without a subscription;           talking about climate science slowed action.
                           researchers or their institutions, however, must
                           pay to publish in them.
                                                                                                                   Future Focus 2025 113
                     Pathways to Vision 2025
                     Targeting scientific funding                                Key areas that warrant attention include
                                                                                 broad agreement on IP protection, regulatory
                     to support collaboration                                    oversight, and data privacy protection.
                     Public-and private-sector funders, together with
                     government, must collaborate to develop a strategy      Facilitating free movement of
                     to support both domestic and international science.
                                                                             people and data
                     Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                                                                             Some types of collaboration must take place
                     –   Create a long-term strategy for scientific          in person, such as training personnel in teams
                         collaboration. Governments must work                or using specialized facilities. Even remote
                         together to support international collaborative     collaboration requires data sharing. This can be
                         research in an enduring manner. This strategy       hindered by restrictions on sharing certain types
                         should be designed to resist changes in             of data, for-fee databases, or by lack of access to
                         governments and the political climate. Key          digital tools among some collaborators. Therefore,
                         elements include a plan to support durable          facilitating the free flow of people is essential for
                         access to and sharing of high-quality data          scientific collaboration.
                         and other scientific results, and infrastructure
                         investments, such as international labs and         Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                         research facilities enabling collaborative
                         research in different disciplines.                  –   Lift travel restrictions. Within the current
                                                                                 context of managing the COVID-19 pandemic,
                     –   Increase cooperation between                            restrictions on international travel must be
   Governments           governments and industry. Governments                   minimized. After the pandemic, all countries
should promote           should promote the participation of industry            must ensure the free movement of researchers
the participation        in funding scientific collaborations. At the            as a prerequisite for scientific collaboration.
of industry in           same time, scientific endeavours should
funding scientific       be transparent and free from undesired              –   Support open data. Removing legislative
collaborations.          industrial, economic, and political influence.          roadblocks to open data sharing and
                         supporting the necessary infrastructure to          Improving public awareness of
                         ensure long-term access to data are essential
                         for scientific collaboration. The FAIR Guiding
                                                                             and trust in research findings
                         Principles for scientific data management and
                         stewardship211 could provide a framework for        Research organizations and governmental
                         this pathway.                                       institutions and industry must work together to
                                                                             support effective scientific communication with the
                     –   Harmonize data-sharing protocols. Where             public to foster trust and eradicate misinformation.
                         completely open access to data is not feasible,
                         countries can harmonize protocols for data          Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
                         sharing so that scientists can access them
                         in a timely manner, no matter their location.       –   Protect the independence of scientific
                         This necessitates building a culture of trust           institutions. Collaboration between scientific
                         and responsibility among the institutions and           and government institutions is important
                         governments sharing data, including mutually-           for addressing national and international
                         agreed arrangements on how countries can                challenges and for implementing science-
                         share data and IP.                                      based policies. Scientific institutions must
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025 114
   Research                have the necessary independence from                      balanced representation of genders, a wider
organizations and          governments, however, to promote scientific               array of ethnicities and nationalities, and
governmental               findings even when these do not support                   diversity in other areas of life, such as age,
institutions and           their government’s policies and to advocate               career stage, physical disability and field of
industry must work         for policies in line with scientific findings. This       study. In medical science, increased female
                           independence must be communicated to                      representation has led to more research into
together to support
                           the public to avoid association of scientific             women’s health issues, improving the health
effective scientific
                           institutions with a particular government and             of women and other people suffering from
communication              the resulting politicization of scientific findings       conditions like osteoporosis and migraines.
with the public            and recommendations.
to foster trust                                                                  –   Support social science. Effectively translating
and eradicate          –   Increase diversity in scientific institutions.            scientific findings into the real world requires an
misinformation.            Increasing diversity – and particularly among             understanding of the different social settings in
                           decision-makers within those institutions –               which they will be applied. Science funders can
                           will bring a more diverse set of views to the             promote this by supporting collaborations that
                           table when making decisions about research                include social scientists who have knowledge
                           strategies and the allocation of funds. This              of and connections to the communities where
                           includes representation of groups historically            scientific knowledge is being created and
                           under-represented in science, such as a                   findings are being implemented.
                                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025 115
           4.7      Space
                    Accessing space for the benefit of the economy
                    and society on Earth is easier than ever.
   New              Space is facing accelerated change that is likely to       –   Geopolitics in outer space. Geopolitical rivalry
manufacturing       persist through 2025 and bring significant benefits as         is creating risk of conflict in orbit, posing enduring
approaches,         well as challenges for humanity. New manufacturing             risks to the space environment.
streamlined         approaches, streamlined assembly and reusability
                    have lowered launch costs and spurred new rocket           –   Growing demand for global connectivity and
assembly and
                    companies, providing greater choice and lower prices           Earth monitoring. Greater internet connectivity
reusability have
                    to access and use space. Mass-produced, affordable             (particularly to underserved, remote areas) and
lowered launch      and smaller satellites can be launched to perform              the availability of Earth monitoring data are
costs and spurred   meaningful missions and provide new services.                  prompting the development of new satellite
new rocket          As a result, accessing space for the benefit of the            constellations, especially within Low Earth Orbit
companies.          economy and society on Earth is easier than ever.              (LEO). This proliferation requires appropriate
                                                                                   regulatory approaches to prevent harmful radio-
                    The key trends creating a more active and crowded              frequency interference, guarantee the long-term
                    space environment are:                                         sustainable use of Earth orbits and ensure
                                                                                   security against cyberattacks.
                    –   High levels of private-sector funding and
                        growing public-sector interest. Private-sector         –   Climate change. Earth monitoring data
                        investment and public-sector support enable                collected from satellites will become even more
                        the buildout of significant infrastructure in              abundant and crucial to providing possible
                        space, including commercial alternatives to the            insights for the climate.
                        International Space Station, on-orbit space services
                        and missions to the Moon and cislunar space.
                                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025 116
                      Vision 2025
                      Addressing space traffic                                   –   Further research, coordination, data collection
                                                                                     and sharing are also needed in the field of space
                      and debris                                                     weather and its impact on space assets.
                      A more congested space environment means                   Finally, increased space activity has environmental
                      safe operations and a sustainable environment for          consequences on Earth, including from accelerated
                      future space development and operations must               launch cadence (burning of rocket fuel) and disposal
                      be ensured. The problem becomes more acute                 of satellites (burning them in Earth’s atmosphere, the
                      as debris from high-altitude, anti-satellite weapons       current practice of removing satellites from LEO).
                      tests further increases the risk of collisions in orbit,
                      reducing the projected lifetime of satellites and
                      negatively affecting space industry economics.             Coordinating space-based data
                      Satellite innovation and large constellations intensify    to better tackle the climate crisis
                      the need for jointly developed and widely adopted
                      norms of operation for space traffic interactions
                                                                                 Earth-sensing satellites enhance the understanding
                      between space actors around the world. This will
                                                                                 of earth science and the evolution of the planet’s
                      entail active and good-faith coordination among
                                                                                 climate, helping to measure relevant climate change
                      governments and the commercial operators licenced
                                                                                 indicators. Satellite measurements of air and sea
                      by them:
                                                                                 surface temperatures and of sea levels, as well as
                                                                                 other space-based observations, reveal important
                      –   Scientific and technical progress is needed to
                                                                                 consequences of a warming planet. While satellites
                          better characterize the orbital debris and enhance
                                                                                 provide vital data, gaps remain in full understanding,
                          means to avoid collisions.                             modelling, mitigation, adaptation and coordination.
                                                                                 Multiple organizations conduct research into relevant
                      –   Improved implementation of existing guidelines is      climate change processes, but there is not yet
                          required, as well as new best practices, technical     an organization dedicated to the continual and
   Earth-sensing
                          standards and economic incentives to allow             integrated development of this core modelling field –
satellites enhance
                          clearing debris from old missions.                     earth systems modelling – and to embedding results
the understanding
                                                                                 in a physical visualization environment that can inform
of earth science      –   With easy access to capital, new opportunities         and help shape decision-making.
and the evolution         exist for innovation in technology and techniques
of the planet’s           to improve the space environment. But there is         Beyond environment monitoring, space infrastructure
climate, helping to       also the risk that unsustainable business plans        plays a key role in supporting other ESG metrics.
measure relevant          will be funded and that potential bankruptcies         Data from space can help companies increase the
climate change            could create new challenges of managing and            efficiency of their operations and survey their overall
indicators.               disposing of space assets.                             supply chains.
                                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025 117
                      Ensuring a space-for-space                               such as space-based laser networks for inter-satellite
                                                                               and Earth connectivity, multiple space stations and
                      economy and space resources                              habitats, in-orbit refuelling depots and advanced
                                                                               satellite servicing. To ensure sustainable and
                      Space resource mining on the Moon or asteroids,          beneficial development, the character of outer space
                      along with space-based solar power, represent long-      as a global commons domain must be respected.
                      term opportunities with potential to provide materials   Current national political and regulatory approaches
                      to construct space-based habitats and eventually to      risk leading to disagreements among nation states
                      help address resource scarcity on Earth. A space-        and may result in either lower investments due to
                      for-space economy starts to emerge, with services        uncertainties or uncoordinated investments.
                      Pathways to Vision 2025
                      Encouraging sustainable                                  –   Encourage implementation of international
                                                                                   frameworks and best practices. Long-term
                      behaviour in space                                           sustainability guidelines were adopted by the
                                                                                   United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses
                      Governmental and non-governmental actors                     of Outer Space (UN-COPUOS) and the UN
                      must further collaborate to address orbital traffic          General Assembly and further work is ongoing,
                      and debris, as well as consider environmental                while the UN First Committee recently adopted
                      consequences on Earth of increased space activity.           a resolution on voluntary norms of behaviour.
                      With a lack of universally accepted and binding              The International Institute of Space Law, the
                      comprehensive principles and norms in a fast-                International Astronautical Federation and the
                      growing space economy in general, more is required           International Academy of Astronautics joined
                      to ensure safe operations and make space activities          in a trilateral, multidisciplinary effort to design
                      sustainable for future development and operations.           a space traffic management approach. For the
                                                                                   past 12 years, the Space Data Association,
                      Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:        which convenes both public- and private-
                                                                                   sector satellite operators, has operated global,
                      –   Establish metrics to measure the                         coordinated operational data sharing, improved
                          sustainability of space activities. The Space            collision warnings, developed best practices
                          Sustainability Rating (SSR), developed by                and identified capabilities for the next generation
                          an international consortium of partners, is a            of space traffic management systems.
   Governmental           voluntary framework to encourage and provide
and non-                  incentive to operators to behave responsibly             Additional global initiatives are needed to
governmental              in space by increasing the transparency                  implement overarching frameworks that help
actors must further       of organizations’ space environmental                    manage the space environment. For example,
                          sustainability and debris mitigation efforts.212         the World Economic Forum Global Future
collaborate to
                          The SSR will provide a space mission score               Council on Space is preparing a concept for a
address orbital
                          measuring efforts to maintain a sustainable              space sustainability monitor (SSM), which is a
traffic and debris,       space environment, including debris mitigation           tool to monitor, showcase and incentivize states’
as well as consider       and alignment with international guidelines.             implementation of international frameworks
environmental             From 2022, an organization can obtain a                  and best practices to promote the safety
consequences on           rating for their mission from the EPFL Space             and sustainability of outer space activities. In
Earth of increased        Center (eSpace) at the Swiss Federal Institute           addition to getting information about a state’s
space activity.           of Technology in Lausanne, Switzerland.                  willingness to apply different standards and
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025 118
                         regulations, the SSM will also incorporate the           expertise to conduct multidisciplinary science
                         notion of a space traffic footprint, which will          and engineering research to monitor and
                         further encourage national actors to promote             provide insights to manage climate change.
                         sustainable use of space by measuring the                The creation of this facility, as well as of a
                         number of objects (active and in-active) in orbit.       “digital twin” of Earth – a dynamic, digital
                                                                                  replica of the planet already being explored
                     –   Incentivize operators to reduce orbital debris.          by the European Space Agency and other
                         “Net-zero” or debris reduction incentives, fee           organizations – will provide a powerful
                         schemes, or escrow funds could help to reduce            symbol of the commitment to address these
                         the creation of space debris. Also, penalties for        challenges today, and to serve as the Earth’s
                         littering and regulatory oversight for discouraging      climate hub on behalf of future generations.
                         irresponsible behaviour and monopolistic
                         business practices are needed.
                                                                               Developing the space-for-space
                                                                               economy and harnessing space
                     Supporting the collation,
                                                                               resources responsibly
                     management and analysis
                     of climate data                                           The work of several organizations, such as the
                                                                               newly formed intergovernmental Working Group
                     To harness the full potential of climate change data,     on Exploration, Exploitation and Utilization of
   To harness        its management, analysis and integration need to          Space Resources of the Legal Sub-committee
                     be improved.                                              of UN-COPUOS, or the non-governmental
the full potential
                                                                               Hague International Space Resources Working
of climate           –   Establish an agency that leverages                    Group, should be continued to further address
change data, its         space technology and operations to                    and discuss the challenges of governance,
management,              better support climate action. The Global             technical safety and socio-economic benefits
analysis and             Future Council on Space has developed                 that will come with the development of a robust
integration need         a concept for an Earth Operations Centre              and sustainable space-for-space economy,
to be improved.          (EOC), a facility to leverage space data and          including space resource extraction.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025 119
            4.8        Synthetic biology
                       Synthetic biology develops tools and
                       frameworks that enable the purposeful
                       engineering of biology with greater precision,
                       predictability, sophistication and speed.
  Broadening           Over 4 billion years, biology has evolved countless     –   Emerging biostrategies. Countries, companies
biological data        sustainable solutions, resulting in millions of             and other organizations around the world are
sets and powerful      species existing in ecosystems in harmony with              focusing on advances in synthetic biology to
biological             planetary resources. People have learned new                help them recover from COVID-19 and to serve
engineering tools      ways to interact with biology such that this inherent       as an engine for new sustainable industries.
                       sustainability can be harnessed to develop new
are accelerating the
                       technologies that can benefit people and the            –   Platform-driven biosciences. Broadening
scope and scale of     planet. If employed thoughtfully and responsibly,           biological data sets and powerful biological
what is possible in    synthetic biology applications can respond to               engineering tools are accelerating the scope
the biosciences.       the world’s social, environmental and economic              and scale of what is possible in the biosciences.
                       needs, and help solve global challenges, including          Those who steward data and technology
                       transitioning to a more sustainable future.                 platforms in bioscience have significant power in
                                                                                   this revolution.
                       Three key trends identified by the Global Future
                       Council on Synthetic Biology are:                       The last two decades of synthetic biology have
                                                                               delivered new tools, approaches and communities.
                       –   Growing bioeconomies. Advances in synthetic         The challenge now is to develop the visions,
                           biology are enabling many valuable applications.    pathways and partnerships that can realize the
                           Investment in bio-based technologies, industries    vast promise of benefits in the decades to come.
                           and economies is growing rapidly, though
                           activity remains concentrated in a few regions.
                                                                                                               Future Focus 2025 120
                      Vision 2025
                      Building a bioeconomy for                                 and helps to advance towards a world in which
                                                                                everyone is entrusted and empowered to be a
                      everyone, everywhere                                      biological citizen.
                      The potential benefits of synthetic biology are
                      diverse, but they must be developed and distributed       Safeguarding global commons
                      equitably. The vision for 2025 is that every country,
                      including emerging and developing economies, has
                                                                                and maximizing cooperation
                      the capacity to build a bio-based circular economy,
                      benefit from record investments and increase              Bioscience data and technology infrastructures
                      sustainability across sectors using synthetic biology.    comprise a valuable global commons and foster
                      Every country can unlock new forms of value               improved cooperation across borders and sectors.
                      from their biodiversity; transition from polluting        Industry, governments and civil society collectively
                      industries and practices to use more sustainable          recognize the increasing power inherent in
                      bio-based solutions across manufacturing, energy          ownership and control of these biological assets
                      and beyond; and innovate for the health and               paired with the importance of developing and
                      well-being of local communities, including through        distributing these assets and capabilities equitably.
                      new diagnostics, treatments and vaccines.
                                                                                New public-private partnerships form to build
                      To encourage and sustain this transition towards          shared knowledge repositories to enable global
                      bio-based economies, nations and regions are              synthetic biology efforts. Shared digital sequence
                      launching mission-driven initiatives that embrace         data and other knowledge commons help to fuel,
                      equitable forms of collaboration, consensus-              shape and responsibly safeguard global synthetic
                      building and governance to work together across           biology efforts. Investments in the technical
                      sectoral and geographic boundaries alike. These           infrastructure for knowledge sharing are coupled to
                      initiatives demonstrate pragmatism and humility           investments in the social infrastructure that guides
                      through a focus on understanding which challenges         and supports its development and use. Education,
                      to prioritize, which of these challenges synthetic        business development and policy engagement help
                      biology can usefully help address and which it            drive leadership that connects technical, social and
                      cannot, and the timelines involved.                       policy issues. Such efforts empower millions of
   The vision for                                                               new participants in synthetic biology research and
2025 is that every    The tools, technologies and data capabilities             technology development, boosting the likelihood
country has the       emerging from these initiatives are shaped by all         that the real potential of global innovation can be
capacity to build     members of society for the benefit of all people and      harnessed, scaling advances in synthetic biology,
a bio-based           the planet.213 This aspiration informs strategy, policy   decreasing costs and increasing access to
                      and practice at all levels, including in innovation and   biologically-derived products and services.
circular economy,
                      regulatory policy as well as investment and benefit-
benefit from record
                      sharing arrangements.                                     In this future, cross-border and cross-sector
investments                                                                     collaborations are open, effective and, wherever
and increase          Building these foundations involves recommitments         possible, transparent. Working across geographies
sustainability        from all people, organizations and nations to             and ideologies, all people recognize that now is the
across sectors        safeguard the shared biological future against            time to collectively guide the trajectory of synthetic
using synthetic       potential misuse. By protecting against biological        biology development to maximize positive impacts
biology.              threats, society allows peaceful purposes to flourish     and safeguard shared biological futures.
                                                                                                                 Future Focus 2025 121
                   Pathways for Vision 2025
                   Embedding key values in                                     –   Embed design thinking and a plurality
                                                                                   of perspectives in bioeconomy strategy
                   bioeconomy strategies                                           development. Broad and early engagement in
                                                                                   strategy and policy development is essential to
                   If synthetic biology is to realize its potential to bring       building values of equity, humility, sustainability
                   social, economic and environmental benefits,                    and solidarity into the technology.214 It is also
                   bioeconomy strategies and policies must be                      necessary to develop better metrics for value
                   guided by values supporting and safeguarding                    in innovation ecosystems and amplify under-
                   all people and the planet. Harnessing the talent                represented voices in bioeconomy narratives.
                   needed to respond to global challenges requires
                   revisiting structures for resourcing and recognition.       –   Develop legal and financial tools that
   Bioeconomy                                                                      deliver investment to enable vibrant
                   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:           bioeconomies globally. Financing
strategies and
                                                                                   arrangements that combine public- and
policies must be   –   Identify global challenges where synthetic                  private-sector financing to support social
guided by values       biology could contribute to inclusive                       enterprises are needed. Risk assessment
supporting and         solutions. Centring collaborations on specific              techniques should incentivize a broad range
safeguarding           foci, including the SDGs, climate change and                of projects focusing on pragmatic outcomes.
all people and         pandemic preparedness, could encourage                      Investment strategies should combine financial
the planet.            sharing, comparing and collaborating.                       returns with measurable social impact.
                   Strengthening all geographies                                   essential to providing effective frameworks
                                                                                   for solutions and ensuring local benefits.
                   of innovation
                                                                               –   Form equitable partnerships to enable
                   To reach the full potential of synthetic biology,               geographic diffusion of synthetic biology.
                   the creativity and capability of the global research            The products and services that emerge from
                   community must be leveraged, and the benefits                   synthetic biology should be responsive to
                   of synthetic biology must be delivered globally.                societal and cultural differences. Partnerships
                                                                                   need to be established with all innovation
                   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:           stakeholders, creating enabling conditions for
                                                                                   the technology to flourish in both local and
                   –   Recognize and leverage strengths of                         global contexts.
                       geographic diversity. Value is derived from
                       genetic resources and talent sourced worldwide,         –   Increase local autonomy for research and
                       but innovation is concentrated in limited                   innovation. Local autonomy requires reduced
                       geographies. Greater benefit can be unlocked                dependency on foreign funding, increased
                       if local populations participate in discovery               capacity building and reduced scientific
                       and development. The Global South is under-                 dependency. This can be done by building
                       represented and should be further drawn in                  a qualified workforce and infrastructure,
                       both as developer and as beneficiary. Attracting,           increasing local job prospects and ensuring
                       educating and developing people in developed                that enabling technologies are readily available
                       countries is not enough: local innovation is                to students, researchers, business executives
                                                                                                                Future Focus 2025 122
                           and regulatory agencies all over the world.                of DSI and other tools and resources without
                           Partnering with organizations like the international       future restrictions on use will enable innovation.
                           Genetically Engineered Machine (iGEM)                      This alleviates the need for complicated tracking
                           Competition can engage local communities and               mechanisms while ensuring sustainability of
                           connect them with counterparts internationally.            the resource and incentives for contributors.
                                                                                      Numerous tool and databases already exist;
                                                                                      linking these through a central source will
                       Building knowledge, tools and                                  deliver benefits to all. The fund should be
                                                                                      financed by country members, industry and
                       data commons                                                   research communities.
                       The genetic code is a foundational toolset enabling        –   Develop a network of regional DSI producing
                       synthetic biology to solve global challenges. These            centres. Part of the fund can establish a
                       resources, however, are not effectively connected              centre devoted to sequencing local biodiversity
                       or accessible. Building a shared, global commons               and curating knowledge critical to its use.
                       of digital sequence information (DSI)215 and other             The investment can extend to establishment
                       resources will improve access and accelerate                   of biofoundries for innovation.
                       innovation. Making the knowledge, tools and
                       technologies to leverage DSI available through             –   Enhance biodiversity conservation and
   Building a          partnerships, databases and repositories will be               build local communities. Long-term
shared, global         critical. Establishing solutions that adhere to FAIR           benefits of investment require supporting
                       data principles (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable,          communities and environments. Focusing
commons of
                       Reproducible) can enhance equity and the                       regional centres on community development
digital sequence       positive impact of DSI, tools and technologies.                and conservation will enable them to
information and                                                                       become nucleate points for activities.
other resources will   Strategies for operationalizing this pathway include:
improve access                                                                    These shared commons provide a framework for
and accelerate         –   Establish a global commons fund. A global              delivering the values that should be embedded
innovation.                fund devoted to the production and sharing             in synthetic biology’s development.
                                                                                                                  Future Focus 2025 123
Contributors
World Economic Forum                        Production team
project team
                                            Studio Miko
Knowledge Communities Unit                  Design and layout
Pablo Burkolter                             Fabienne Stassen
Lead, Knowledge Communities, Global         Editing
Programming
Jaci Eisenberg
Head, Knowledge Communities, Global
Programming
Jeremy Packham
Specialist, Knowledge Communities, Global
Programming
Saadia Zahidi
Managing Director
Acknowledgements                            Equity and Social Justice
                                            Elselot Hasselaar
The World Economic Forum would like to      Fiscal and Monetary Policy
acknowledge the valuable contributions of   Guillaume Hingel
the following people in the development
of this document:                           Human Rights
                                            Ty Greene and Louise Thompson
Global Future Council managers              Investing
                                            Meagan Andrews
Advanced Manufacturing and Production       Media, Entertainment and Sport
Maria Basso and Benjamin Schönfuss          Hesham Zafar
Agile Governance                            Mental Health
Loren Newman                                Cameron Fox
Artificial Intelligence for Humanity        Nature-Based Solutions
Emily Ratté                                 Akanksha Khatri
Clean Air                                   Net-Zero Transition
Roderick Weller and Shannon Engstrom        Pim Valdre
Clean Electrification                       New Agenda for Fragility and Resilience
Kristen Panerali                            Andrej Kirn and Miriam Schive
Economic Growth and Recovery                Quantum Computing
Attilio Di Battista                         Grigory Shutko
Education and Skills                        Responsive Financial Systems
Genesis Elhussein                           Kai Keller and Marie Penelope Nezurugo
Energy Transition                           Risk Resilience
Dominique Hischier                          Sophie Heading
                                                                         Future Focus 2025 124
Scientific Collaboration              Synthetic Biology
Greta Keenan                          Cameron Fox
SDG Investment                        Trade and Investment
Alessandro Valentini                  Aditi Sara Verghese
Social Cohesion and Just Transition   Transparency and Anti-Corruption
Natalie Çilem                         Lisa Ventura and Houssam Al Wazzan
Space                                 Work, Wages and Job Creation
Nikolai Khlystov                      Aidan Manktelow and Steffica Warwick
Sustainable Tourism
Lauren Uppink and Rosaline Mouget
                                                                   Future Focus 2025 125
      Endnotes
1.    World Economic Forum, “Global Future Councils” [website], https://www.weforum.org/communities/global-future-councils.
2.    See World Economic Forum, Centre for the New Economy and Society, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for
      an Economic Transformation”, Community Paper, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_GFC_NES_Policy_
      Pathways_for_an_Economic_Transformation_2021.pdf.
3.    Ibid.
4.    Ibid.
5.    Mazzucato, Mariana, The Entrepreneurial State: Debunking Public vs. Private Sector Myths, Anthem Press, 2013.
6.    Laplane, Andrea, and Mariana Mazzucato, “Socializing the risks and rewards of public investments: Economic, policy,
      and legal issues”, Research Policy, vol. 49, Supplement, 2020, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
      S2590145120300025.
7.    See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
8.    Ibid.
9.    Ibid.
10.   Ibid.
11.   Ibid.
12.   Ibid.
13.   Ibid.
14.   Ibid.
15.   Farrell, Diana, Raghuram G. Rajan and Guillaume Hingel, “Building back broader: A new approach to fiscal and monetary
      policy”, World Economic Forum, Agenda, 2 June 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/06/new-approach-fiscal-
      and-monetary-policy.
16.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
17.   Gopinath, Gita, “Managing Divergent Recoveries”, IMF Blog, 6 April 2021, https://blogs.imf.org/2021/04/06/managing-
      divergent-recoveries.
18.   Dabla-Norris, Era, et al., “Fiscal Policies to Address Climate Change in Asia and the Pacific”, IMF Departmental Paper No
      2021/007, 24 March 2021, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/Departmental-Papers-Policy-Papers/Issues/2021/03/24/
      Fiscal-Policies-to-Address-Climate-Change-in-Asia-and-the-Pacific-Opportunities-and-49896.
19.   Vivid Economics, Greenness of Stimulus Index, 2021, https://www.vivideconomics.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/
      Greennes-of-Stimulus-Index-5th-Edition-FINAL-VERSION-09.02.21.pdf.
20.   World Bank, Carbon Pricing Dashboard, 2020 update, https://carbonpricingdashboard.worldbank.org.
21.   Agarwal, Ruchir, and Gita Gopinath, “A Proposal to End the COVID 19 Pandemic”, International Monetary Fund
      (IMF), Staff Discussion Note No. 2021/004, 2021, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/Staff-Discussion-Notes/
      Issues/2021/05/19/A-Proposal-to-End-the-COVID-19-Pandemic-460263.
22.   Rees, Daniel, “What comes next? Recovery from an uneven recession”, Bank for International Settlements, BIS Bulletin
      33, 2020, https://www.bis.org/publ/bisbull33.pdf.
23.   Cobham, Alex, The Uncounted, Polity Press, 2020, https://www.wiley.com/en-us/The+Uncounted-p-9781509536016.
24.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
25.   Gentilini, Ugo, et al., “Social Protection and Jobs Responses to COVID-19: A Real-Time Review of Country Measures”,
      “Living paper” version 15, World Bank, 14 May 2021, https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/33635.
26.   Blanchard, Olivier J., and Lawrence H. Summers, “Automatic Stabilizers in a Low-Rate Environment”, American
      Economic Association, AEA Papers and Proceedings, vol. 110, 2020, pp. 125-30, https://www.aeaweb.org/
      articles?id=10.1257/pandp.20201075.
27.   International Labour Organization (ILO), World Social Protection Report 2020-22, 2021, https://ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/
      public/@dgreports/@dcomm/@publ/documents/publication/wcms_817572.pdf.
28.   Bowen, Thomas, et al., Adaptive Social Protection: Building Resilience to Shocks, World Bank, 2020,
      https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/33785.
29.   International Monetary Fund (IMF), Fiscal Monitor: A Fair Shot, April 2021, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/FM/
      Issues/2021/03/29/fiscal-monitor-april-2021#Full%20Report.
30.   UNICEF, “Schoolchildren worldwide have lost 1.8 trillion hours and counting of in-person learning due to COVID-19
      lockdowns, says UNICEF”, Press Release, 16 September 2021, https://www.unicef.org/cuba/en/press-releases/
      schoolchildren-worldwide-have-lost-18-trillion-hours-and-counting-person-learning.
                                                                                                         Future Focus 2025 126
31.   International Monetary Fund (IMF), Fiscal Monitor: A Fair Shot, op cit.
32.   Ibid.
33.   World Economic Forum, The Future of Jobs Report 2020, Executive Summary, 20 October 2020, https://www.weforum.
      org/reports/the-future-of-jobs-report-2020/in-full/executive-summary#executive-summary.
34.   Dabla-Norris, et al., “Fiscal Policies to Address Climate Change in Asia and the Pacific”, op. cit.
35.   International Monetary Fund (IMF), World Economic Outlook: Recovery During a Pandemic, 2021,
      https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2021/10/12/world-economic-outlook-october-2021.
36.   Parry, Ian, Simon Black and James Roaf, “Proposal for an International Carbon Price Floor Among Large Emitters”,
      International Monetary Fund, Staff Climate Note 2021/001, 2021, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/staff-climate-
      notes/Issues/2021/06/15/Proposal-for-an-International-Carbon-Price-Floor-Among-Large-Emitters-460468.
37.   Kindermann, Fabian, and Dirk Krueger, “High Marginal Tax Rates on the Top 1%? Lessons from a Life Cycle Model with
      Idiosyncratic Income Risk”, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 2021, https://epub.uni-regensburg.de/44533.
38.   Inchauste, Gabriela, and Nora Lustig, The Distributional Impact of Taxes and Transfers: Evidence From Eight Developing
      Countries, World Bank, 2017, https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/27980.
39.   Cobham, Alex, “Is today a turning point against corporate tax abuse?”, Tax Justice Network, 4 June 2021,
      https://taxjustice.net/2021/06/04/is-today-a-turning-point-against-corporate-tax-abuse.
40.   Godar, Sarah, “The state of tax justice 2021: Report by the Global Alliance for Tax Justice, Public Services International,
      and the Tax Justice Network published online in November 2021”, EU Tax Observatory, 16 December 2021,
      https://www.taxobservatory.eu/repository/the-state-of-tax-justice-2021/#:~:text=TJN%20estimates%20that%20the%20
      world,99.4%25%20of%20corporate%20tax%20losses.
41.   Giles, Chris, “IMF proposes ‘solidarity’ tax on pandemic winners and wealthy”, Financial Times, 7 April 2021,
      https://www.ft.com/content/5dad2390-8a32-4908-8c96-6d23cd037c38.
42.   CFA Institute, Future of Sustainability in Investment Management: From Ideas to Reality, 2020, https://www.cfainstitute.
      org/-/media/documents/survey/future-of-sustainability.pdf.
43.   Hewett, Jennifer, “Boards suffer an ‘identity crisis’ as ESG demands rise”, Australian Financial Review, 6 September 2021,
      https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/boards-suffer-an-identity-crisis-as-esg-demands-rise-20210906-p58p73.
44.   United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), “Sustainable finance surges despite volatile markets
      during COVID-19, says UN report”, Press Release, 21 June 2021, https://unctad.org/press-material/sustainable-finance-
      surges-despite-volatile-markets-during-covid-19-says-un-report.
45.   Segal, Mark, “PRI Reaches 4,000 Signatories as Interest in ESG Investing Proliferates Across Sectors and Regions”, ESG
      Today, 14 June 2021, https://www.esgtoday.com/pri-reaches-4000-signatories-as-interest-in-esg-investing-proliferates-
      across-sectors-and-regions.
46.   International Consumer Protection and Enforcement Network (ICPEN), “Screening of websites for ‘greenwashing’: half of
      green claims lack evidence” News, 29 January 2021, https://icpen.org/news/1146.
47.   Schroders, “Schroders Institutional Investor Study 2020: Active engagement identified as key tactic for driving change as
      greenwashing becomes main challenge”, 29 October 2020, https://www.schroders.com/en/media-relations/newsroom/
      all_news_releases/schroders-institutional-investor-study-2020-active-engagement-identified-as-key-tactic-for-driving-
      change-as-greenwashing-becomes-main-challenge.
48.   United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), World Investment Report 2021: Investing in Sustainable
      Recovery, 2021, https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/wir2021_en.pdf.
49.   49 Weinberg, Andrew, “What to do about the shift from public to private markets”, World Economic Forum, Agenda,
      29 April 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/04/what-to-do-about-the-shift-from-public-to-private-markets.
50.   PwC, “Private markets forecast to grow to $4.9tn globally by 2025 and make up 10% of global AuM”, Press Release,
      13 January 2021, https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/news-room/press-releases/2021/prime-time-private-markets.html.
51.   Lu, Kevin, and Hongyi Shen, “Here’s how to choose the right fund manager for the future”, World Economic Forum,
      Agenda, 18 January 2022, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/01/choose-right-fund-manager-future.
52.   Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI), “Stewardship”, 19 February 2021, https://www.unpri.org/an-introduction-to-
      responsible-investment/an-introduction-to-responsible-investment-stewardship/7228.article.
53.   World Economic Forum, “Measuring Stakeholder Capitalism: Towards Common Metrics and Consistent Reporting of
      Sustainable Value Creation”, https://www.weforum.org/stakeholdercapitalism.
54.   Lerner, Josh, “3 lessons for financing forest conservation”, World Economic Forum, Agenda, 2 December 2021,
      https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/12/3-lessons-for-financing-forest-conservation.
55.   Hodgson, Tim, “Valuing natural capital is key to the future of investment. Here’s why”, World Economic Forum, Agenda,
      4 August 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/08/natural-capital-key-future-investment.
56.   Williamson, Sarah, “Sustainability metrics: why it’s time investors look in the mirror”, World Economic Forum, Agenda,
      1 October 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/10/sustainability-stakeholder-metrics-for-investors.
57.   World Economic Forum in collaboration with FCLTGlobal, “Adapting Corporate Sustainable Value Creation Indicators for
      Investors”, Community Paper, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_ESG_disclosure_for_asset_owners_2021.pdf.
                                                                                                            Future Focus 2025 127
58.   Dunsire, Fiona, Stefan Dunatov and Suni Harford, “Why private companies need to catch up on sustainability”, World
      Economic Forum, Agenda, 7 April 2022, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/04/why-private-companies-need-to-
      catch-up-on-sustainability.
59.   Weinberg, Andrew, “Why private-market investors need to accelerate their push for diversity”, World Economic Forum,
      Agenda, 15 July 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/07/private-markets-moment-for-diversity-equity-and-
      inclusion.
60.   CFA Institute, Future of Sustainability in Investment Management: From Ideas to Reality, op. cit.
61.   Andrews, Meagan, “How to address sustainable investment backlash and improve ESG reporting”, World Economic
      Forum, Agenda, 21 December 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/12/esg-sustainable-investment-backlash.
62.   Ibid.
63.   This section is based on World Economic Forum, “Global Future Council on Responsive Financial Systems: Three ways
      to accelerate a digital-led recovery”, White Paper, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_GFC_Three_ways_to_
      accelerate_a_digital_led_recovery_2021.pdf.
64.   Carney, Marc, “Fifty Shades of Green”, International Monetary Fund, Finance & Development, vol. 56, no. 4, December
      2019, https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2019/12/a-new-sustainable-financial-system-to-stop-climate-change-
      carney.htm.
65.   van Steenis, Huw, “A new phase for green investing”, Financial Times, 17 November 2021, https://www.ft.com/content/
      c2937d7b-98f1-4179-823c-4a58e21f8e30.
66.   van Steenis, Huw, and Alice Law Shing-Mui, “3 ways to accelerate a digital-led recovery”, World Economic Forum in
      collaboration with Forbes, Global Agenda, 1 November 2021, https://www.weforum.org/global_future_councils/gfc-on-
      responsive-financial-systems/articles/3-ways-to-accelerate-a-digital-led-recovery.
67.   van Steenis, “A new phase for green investing”, op. cit.
68.   African Development Bank Group, “MDBs’ climate finance rose to $66 billion in 2020, joint report shows”, 30 June 2021,
      https://www.afdb.org/en/news-and-events/press-releases/mdbs-climate-finance-rose-66-billion-2020-joint-report-
      shows-44420.
69.   World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
70.   Dolan, Paul, et al., MINDSPACE: Influencing behaviour through public policy, UK Institute for Government, the Cabinet
      Office, 2010, https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/sites/default/files/publications/MINDSPACE.pdf.
71.   United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), “Trade data for 2020 confirm growing importance of
      digital technologies during COVID-19”, 27 October 2021, https://unctad.org/news/trade-data-2020-confirm-growing-
      importance-digital-technologies-during-covid-19.
72.   Ipsos, “World Opinion on Globalization and International Trade in 2021: Ipsos Global Advisor 25-Country Survey for
      the World Economic Forum”, 2021, https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/news/documents/2021-08/World%20
      Opinion%20on%20Globalization%20and%20International%20Trade%20in%202021%20-%20Report.pdf.
73.   Naas, Penelope, Pamela Coke-Hamilton and Nisha Taneja, “5 ways trade can support a gender-equal recovery”, World
      Economic Forum, Agenda, 6 December 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/12/5-ways-trade-can-support-
      gender-equal-recovery.
74.   Johnson, Stephen, “Corruption is costing the global economy $3.6 trillion dollars every year”, World Economic Forum,
      Agenda, 13 December 2018, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/12/the-global-economy-loses-3-6-trillion-to-
      corruption-each-year-says-u-n.
75.   75 Based on World Economic Forum, “The Role and Responsibilities of Gatekeepers in the Fight against Illicit Financial
      Flows: A Unifying Framework”, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Gatekeepers_A_Unifying_Framework_2021.
      pdf; see also, International Monetary Fund (IMF), “Corruption: Costs and Mitigating Strategies”, IMF Staff Discussion
      Note, 2016, https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/sdn/2016/sdn1605.pdf.
76.   World Economic Forum, “The Rise and Role of the Chief Integrity Officer: Leadership Imperatives in an ESG-Driven
      World”, White Paper, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_The_Rise_and_Role_of_the_Chief_Integrity_
      Officer_2021.pdf.
77.   See World Economic Forum, “The Role and Responsibilities of Gatekeepers in the Fight against Illicit Financial Flows: A
      Unifying Framework”, 2021.
78.   World Economic Forum, “The Role and Responsibilities of Gatekeepers in the Fight against Illicit Financial Flows: A
      Unifying Framework”, 18 June 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Gatekeepers_endorsement_list_2021.pdf.
79.   United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime and World Bank, “Stolen Asset Recovery Initiative (StAR)”, https://star.
      worldbank.org.
80.   See World Economic Forum, Global Future Council on Transparency and Anti-Corruption, “Hacking corruption in the
      digital era: How tech is shaping the future of integrity in times of crisis”, Agenda for Business Integrity, 2020, https://
      www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_GFC_on_Transparency_and_AC_Agenda_for_Business_Integrity_pillar_3_2020.pdf.
81.   UN Environment Programme, “International Day of Clean Air for blue skies underlines link between healthy air and a
      healthy planet”, 23 June 2021, https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/story/international-day-clean-air-blue-skies-
      underlines-link-between-healthy-air.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025 128
82.    World Health Organization, “Ambient (outdoor) air pollution: Key facts”, 22 September 2021, https://www.who.int/news-
       room/fact-sheets/detail/ambient-(outdoor)-air-quality-and-health.
83.    International Energy Agency (IEA), World Energy Outlook 2021, 2021, https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/888004cf-
       1a38-4716-9e0c-3b0e3fdbf609/WorldEnergyOutlook2021.pdf.
84.    Climate Watch, “World Greenhouse Gas Emissions in 2018 by Sector, End Use and Gases”, World Resources Institute,
       2018, https://www.climatewatchdata.org/key-visualizations?visualization=5.
85.    Ibid.
86.    Roelofsen, Occo, et al., “Plugging in: What electrification can do for industry”, McKinsey & Company, 28 May 2020,
       https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/electric-power-and-natural-gas/our-insights/plugging-in-what-electrification-can-
       do-for-industry.
87.    Climate Watch, “World Greenhouse Gas Emissions in 2018 by Sector, End Use and Gases”, op. cit.
88.    Ibid.
89.    International Energy Agency, World Energy Outlook 2021, op. cit.
90.    Ibid.
91.    World Economic Forum, Getting to Net Zero: Increasing Clean Electrification by Empowering Demand, Insight Report,
       2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Increasing_Clean_Electrification_by_Empowering_Demand_2021.pdf.
92.    International Energy Agency, World Energy Outlook 2021, op cit.
93.    Adler, Kevin, “Global CO2 emissions to rise by 4.9% in 2021: Global Carbon Project”, IHS Markit, 4 November 2021,
       https://cleanenergynews.ihsmarkit.com/research-analysis/global-co2-emissions-to-rise-by-49-in-2021-global-carbon-
       proje.html.
94.    Haselip, J. A. (Ed.), Scaling up investment in climate technologies: Pathways to realising technology development
       and transfer in support of the Paris Agreement, UNEP DTU Partnership, 2021, https://backend.orbit.dtu.dk/ws/
       files/263889473/2021_10_Perspectives_Scaling_up_investments_WEB_3.pdf.
95.    Ibid.
96.    See World Economic Forum, “Net-Zero Equity: Mobilizing Capital to Fight Climate Change”, Briefing Paper, 2021,
       https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Net_Zero_Equity_Mobilizing_Capital_to_Fight_Climate_Change_2021.pdf.
97.    97 World Economic Forum in collaboration with BloombergNEF and Deutsche Energie-Agentur (dena), “Harnessing
       Artificial Intelligence to Accelerate the Energy Transition”, White Paper, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_
       Harnessing_AI_to_accelerate_the_Energy_Transition_2021.pdf.
98.    98 Bond, Kingsmill, et al., “Emerging markets adopt renewables”, IndiaWaterPortal, 19 July 2021,
       https://www.indiawaterportal.org/articles/emerging-markets-adopt-renewables.
99.    Carbon Tracker, “Reach for the Sun: The emerging market electricity leapfrog”, 14 July 2021, https://carbontracker.org/
       reports/reach-for-the-sun.
100.   Saraiva, Joisa, and Victor, David G., “Rethinking global supply chains for the energy transition”, World Economic Forum,
       Agenda 2022, 31 January 2022, https://www.weforum.org/global_future_councils/gfc-on-energy-transition/articles/
       rethinking-supply-chains-for-the-energy-transition.
101.   US Department of State, “The Clean Energy Demand initiative (CEDI), Fact Sheet”, 4 November 2021,
       https://www.state.gov/the-clean-energy-demand-initiative-cedi/#:~:text=CEDI%20creates%20a%20platform%20
       to,retail%2C%20technology%2C%20and%20transportation.
102.   See First Movers Coalition [website], https://www.weforum.org/first-movers-coalition.
103.   World Economic Forum, “New Nature Economy Report Series”, 14 July 2020, https://www.weforum.org/reports/new-
       nature-economy-report-series.
104.   Ellsmoor, James, “Global Population Without Access To Electricity Drops By 400 Million Since 2010”, Forbes, 23 May
       2019, https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesellsmoor/2019/05/23/sdg-7-at-current-rate-2030-renewable-energy-goals-
       will-be-missed.
105.   See World Economic Forum, “Scaling Investments in Nature: The Next Critical Frontier for Private Sector Leadership”,
       White Paper, 2022, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Scaling_Investments_in_Nature_2022.pdf.
106.   Ibid.
107.   Earth Overshoot Day, “About Earth Overshoot Day”, https://www.overshootday.org/about-earth-overshoot-day.
108.   Sena, Kanyinke, “Recognizing Indigenous Peoples’ Land Interests Is Critical for People and Nature”, World Wildlife Fund,
       22 October 2020, https://www.worldwildlife.org/stories/recognizing-indigenous-peoples-land-interests-is-critical-for-
       people-and-nature#:~:text=By%20fighting%20for%20their%20lands,they%20have%20lived%20for%20centuries.
109.   Farand, Chloé, “UN summit highlights $700bn funding gap to restore nature”, Climate Home News, 28 September
       2020, https://www.climatechangenews.com/2020/09/28/un-summit-highlights-700bn-funding-gap-restore-
       nature/#:~:text=Countries%20need%20to%20find%20%24700,restoration%20of%20nature%20on%20Monday.
110.   Lai, Olivia, “90% of Global Farm Subsidy Payments Harming Public Health and Climate, Says UN”, Earth.
       Org, 15 September 2021, https://earth.org/global-farm-subsidy-payments-are-harming-public-health-and-
       climate/#:~:text=Nearly%2090%25%20of%20the%20world’s,UN%20Environment%20Programme%20(UNEP).
                                                                                                           Future Focus 2025 129
111.   United Kingdom Government, “World leaders summit on ‘Action on forests and land use’”, Policy paper, 21 January 2022
       update, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cop26-world-leaders-summit-on-action-on-forests-and-land-use-
       2-november-2021/world-leaders-summit-on-action-on-forests-and-land-use.
112.   See World Economic Forum in collaboration with PwC, “Nature Risk Rising: Why the Crisis Engulfing Nature Matters for
       Business and the Economy”, New Nature Economy series, 2020, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_New_Nature_
       Economy_Report_2020.pdf.
113.   Morgan Stanley Capital International, MSCI Emerging Markets ESG Leaders Index, 28 February 2022,
       https://www.msci.com/documents/10199/c341baf6-e515-4015-af5e-c1d864cae53e.
114.   Cone Communications, “2016 Cone Communications Millennial Employee Engagement Study”, 2016,
       https://www.conecomm.com/research-blog/2016-millennial-employee-engagement-study.
115.   See World Economic Forum, “Scaling Investments in Nature: The Next Critical Frontier for Private Sector Leadership”,
       op. cit.
116.   Curtis, Philip G., et al., “Classifying drivers of global forest loss”, Science, vol. 361, no. 6407, 14 September 2018,
       pp. 1108-1111, https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aau3445.
117.   Forest and Finance, “Financial Flows and Policy Assessments Key Findings”, 8 November 2021,
       https://forestsandfinance.org/news/financial-flows-and-policy-assessments-key-findings.
118.   See World Economic Forum, “Scaling Investments in Nature: The Next Critical Frontier for Private Sector Leadership”,
       op. cit.
119.   FAO, UNDP and UNEP, A multi-billion-dollar opportunity – Repurposing agricultural support to transform food systems,
       2021, https://www.fao.org/documents/card/en/c/cb6562en.
120.   See World Economic Forum, “Scaling Investments in Nature: The Next Critical Frontier for Private Sector Leadership”,
       op. cit.
121.   Ibid.
122.   Ibid.
123.   Science Based Targets, “More than 1,000 companies commit to science-based emissions reductions in line with
       1.5°C climate ambition”, Press Release, 10 November 2021, https://sciencebasedtargets.org/news/more-than-1000-
       companies-commit-to-science-based-emissions-reductions-in-line-with-1-5-c-climate-ambition.
124.   International Energy Agency (IEA), Net Zero by 2050, 2021, https://www.iea.org/reports/net-zero-by-2050.
125.   Hobley, Anthony Robert, Johanna Lehne and Rob van Riet, “How to deliver on climate pledges? Look at these
       industries transitioning to net zero”, World Economic Forum, Agenda, 17 January 2022, https://www.weforum.org/
       agenda/2022/01/net-zero-industrial-transition-climate-action.
126.   See World Economic Forum in collaboration with Boston Consulting Group, Net-Zero Challenge: The supply chain
       opportunity, Insight Report, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Net_Zero_Challenge_The_Supply_Chain_
       Opportunity_2021.pdf.
127.   Hobley, Lehne and van Riet, “How to deliver on climate pledges? Look at these industries transitioning to net zero”, op. cit.
128.   UNDP, SDG Investor Platform, “Gender Equality Isn’t Just A Number’s Game”, 8 March 2022, https://sdginvestorplatform.
       undp.org/news/gender-equality-isnt-just-numbers-game.
129.   Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), “Global Outlook on Financing for Sustainable
       Development 2021 – A New Way to Invest for people and Planet”, 9 November 2020, https://www.oecd.org/publications/
       global-outlook-on-financing-for-sustainable-development-2021-e3c30a9a-en.htm.
130.   Kumar, Manmohan. S., et al., “Investing in Emerging and Frontier Economies: How Blended Finance can make the most
       of public funding”, ILN Position Paper for COP26 and G20, in collaboration with The Rockefeller Foundation, 2021,
       https://investorleadershipnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/ILN_2021_InvestingInEmergingFronteirEconomies_Report_
       v4.pdf.
131.   Robins, Nick, Vonda Brunsting and David Wood, “Climate change and the just transition: A guide for investor action”,
       Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment, 2018, https://iri.hks.harvard.edu/files/iri/files/
       jtguidanceforinvestors.pdf?m=1554219326.
132.   See UN-convened Net Zero Asset Owner Alliance, “Scaling Blended Finance”, Discussion Paper, 2021, https://www.
       greenfinanceplatform.org/guidance/scaling-blended-finance-un-convened-net-zero-asset-owner-alliance-discussion-
       paper.
133.   See World Economic Forum, “Reshaping Risk Mitigation: The Impact of Non-financial Levers”, White Paper, 2021,
       https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Reshaping_Risk_Mitigation_2021.pdf.
134.   United Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO), “International Tourism Growth Continues to Outpace the Global
       Economy”, 20 January 2020, https://www.unwto.org/international-tourism-growth-continues-to-outpace-the-economy.
135.   Addamo, Anna M., et al., EU Blue Economy Report 2021, European Commission, 2021, https://ec.europa.eu/oceans-
       and-fisheries/system/files/2021-05/the-eu-blue-economy-report-2021_en.pdf.
136.   World Travel & Tourism Council (WTTC), A Net Zero Roadmap for Travel & Tourism: Proposing a new Target Framework for
       the Travel & Tourism Sector, 2021, https://wttc.org/Portals/0/Documents/Reports/2021/WTTC_Net_Zero_Roadmap.pdf.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025 130
137.   An example of such efforts is provided by the Global Sustainable Tourism Council (see GSTC, “Criteria Overview”,
       https://www.gstcouncil.org/gstc-criteria) and by the Future of Tourism Coalition (see “About the Future of Tourism
       Coalition”, https://www.futureoftourism.org/about-us).
138.   The cases provided by Tourism Declares (see “Tourism Declares a Climate Emergency”, https://www.tourismdeclares.
       com) and the World Travel & Tourism Council’s latest report on net zero (WTTC, A Net Zero Roadmap for Travel &
       Tourism: Proposing a new Target Framework for the Travel & Tourism Sector, 2021, https://wttc.org/Portals/0/Documents/
       Reports/2021/WTTC_Net_Zero_Roadmap.pdf) provide useful references.
139.   See European Commission, “Sustainable blue economy: A new approach for a sustainable blue economy in the EU”
       (https://ec.europa.eu/oceans-and-fisheries/ocean/blue-economy/sustainable-blue-economy_en), which provides an
       example of how natural resources should be employed to mitigate climate change, in a circular way, to benefit the
       tourism industry.
140.   Ibid.
141.   World Economic Forum, The Future of Jobs Report 2020, 2020, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Future_of_
       Jobs_2020.pdf.
142.   World Economic Forum in collaboration with PwC, Upskilling for Shared Prosperity, Insight Report, 2021, https://www3.
       weforum.org/docs/WEF_Upskilling_for_Shared_Prosperity_2021.pdf.
143.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
144.   Samek, Manuela, et al., The effectiveness and costs-benefits of apprenticeships: Results of the quantitative analysis,
       European Commission, 2013, https://www.employment-studies.co.uk/resource/effectiveness-and-costs-benefits-
       apprenticeships-results-quantitative-analysis.
145.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
146.   Ibid.
147.   Ibid.
148.   Ellyatt, Holly, “There are millions of jobs, but a shortage of workers: Economists explain why that’s worrying”, CNBC,
       20 October 2021 update, https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2021/10/20/global-shortage-of-workers-whats-going-on-experts-
       explain.html.
149.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
150.   Ibid.
151.   Zurich, “Zurich sees leap in women applying for senior roles after offering all jobs as flexible”, Press Release,
       17 November 2020, https://www.zurich.co.uk/media-centre/zurich-sees-leap-in-women-applying-for-senior-roles-after-
       offering-all-jobs-as-flexible.
152.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
153.   Ibid.
154.   United Nations, “Rising inequality affecting more than two-thirds of the globe, but it’s not inevitable: new UN report”, UN
       News, 21 January 2020, https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/01/1055681.
155.   See World Economic Forum, “Global Future Council on Mental Health”, https://cn.weforum.org/communities/gfc-on-
       mental-health.
156.   Carvajal-Velez, Liliana, et al., “Increasing Data and Understanding of Adolescent Mental Health Worldwide: UNICEF’s
       Measurement of Mental Health Among Adolescents at the Population Level Initiative”, Journal of Adolescent Health, 2021,
       https://rest.neptune-prod.its.unimelb.edu.au/server/api/core/bitstreams/ffb93764-f2df-5de9-b4d4-43744bbde63d/
       content.
157.   Azzopardi, Peter, et al., “Bringing a Wider Lens to Adolescent Mental Health: Aligning Measurement Frameworks With
       Multisectoral Actions”, Journal of Adolescent Health, 2021, https://rest.neptune-prod.its.unimelb.edu.au/server/api/core/
       bitstreams/8af69190-6c15-5615-9da3-aad7a10ef420/content.
158.   See World Economic Forum in collaboration with Deloitte, “Global Governance Toolkit for Digital Mental Health: Building
       Trust in Disruptive Technology for Mental Health”, White Paper, 2021, https://www.weforum.org/whitepapers/global-
       governance-toolkit-for-digital-mental-health.
159.   United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), Prospects for children in 2022: A global outlook, 2022, https://www.unicef.org/
       globalinsight/media/2471/file/UNICEF-Global-Insight-Prospects-for-Children-Global-Outlook-2022.pdf.
160.   Figures are estimates from the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN OCHA) Global
       Humanitarian Overview 2022: https://gho.unocha.org.
161.   UNICEF estimates that 89% of all humanitarian funding goes to humanitarian needs, reducing the capacity and resources
       available for development aid projects; see UNICEF, “The Humanitarian-Development nexus”, https://www.unicef.org/eu/
       humanitarian-development-nexus.
162.   Guay, Joseph, and Lisa Rudnick, “What the Digital Geneva Convention means for the future of humanitarian action”,
       UNHCR, 25 June 2017, https://www.unhcr.org/innovation/digital-geneva-convention-mean-future-humanitarian-action.
163.   United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), “The Humanitarian Implications of Cyber
       Threats”, Virtual Session, 10 December 2021, https://www.unocha.org/sites/unocha/files/2021%20GHPF%20-%20
       Concept%20Note%20-%20Cyberthreats%20Panel%20-%208%20December.pdf.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025 131
164.   Figures are estimates from World Bank Global Economic Prospects; see, also, World Bank, “People Peace Prosperity”,
       Brief, 2 October 2020, https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/fragilityconflictviolence/brief/people-peace-prosperity.
165.   World Economic Forum, Global Future Council on the New Agenda for Fragility and Resilience, “Guidelines for
       complementary action in fragile contexts”, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Guidelines_for_complementary_action_
       in_fragile_contexts.pdf.
166.   Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC), “The Grand Bargain (Official website)”, https://interagencystandingcommittee.
       org/grand-bargain.
167.   Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC), “Greater Transparency”, OCHA, https://interagencystandingcommittee.org/
       greater-transparency.
168.   Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC), “A participation revolution: include people receiving aid in making the decisions
       which affect their lives”, OCHA, https://interagencystandingcommittee.org/a-participation-revolution-include-people-
       receiving-aid-in-making-the-decisions-which-affect-their-lives.
169.   Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC), “More support and funding tools for local and national responders”, OCHA,
       https://interagencystandingcommittee.org/more-support-and-funding-tools-for-local-and-national-responders.
170.   Principles for Digital Development [website], https://digitalprinciples.org.
171.   International Labour Organization (ILO), “Guidelines for a just transition towards environmentally sustainable economies
       and societies for all”, 2015, https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/@ed_emp/@emp_ent/documents/publication/
       wcms_432859.pdf.
172.   International Labour Organization (ILO), “Social dialogue: What is social dialogue?”, https://www.ilo.org/ifpdial/areas-of-
       work/social-dialogue/lang--en/index.htm)%20%20a.
173.   International Labour Organization (ILO), “ILO downgrades labour market recovery forecast for 2022”, News, 17 January
       2022, https://www.ilo.org/global/about-the-ilo/newsroom/news/WCMS_834117/lang--en/index.htm.
174.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
175.   International Labour Organization (ILO), World Employment and Social Outlook 2018: Greening with Jobs, 2018,
       https://www.ilo.org/global/research/global-reports/weso/greening-with-jobs/lang--en/index.htm.
176.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
177.   World Economic Forum, The Future of Jobs Report 2020, op. cit.
178.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
179.   World Economic Forum, The Future of Jobs Report 2020, op. cit.
180.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
181.   International Labour Organization (ILO), Global Wage Report 2020-21, 2020, https://www.ilo.org/global/research/global-
       reports/global-wage-report/2020/lang--en/index.htm.
182.   Betcherman, Gordon, “The challenges of regulating the labor market in developing countries”, World Bank, 26 August
       2021, https://blogs.worldbank.org/jobs/challenges-regulating-labor-market-developing-countries.
183.   Cengiz, Doruk, et al., “The Effect of Minimum Wages on Low-Wage Jobs”, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 134,
       no. 3, 2019, pp. 1405-1454, https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/134/3/1405/5484905; Ahlfeldt, Gabriel, Duncan Roth
       and Tobias Seidel, “The regional effects of Germany’s national minimum wage”, Economics Letters, vol. 172, no. C, 2018,
       pp. 127-130, https://econpapers.repec.org/article/eeeecolet/v_3a172_3ay_3a2018_3ai_3ac_3ap_3a127-130.htm.
184.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
185.   Ibid.
186.   Ibid.
187.   World Economic Forum in collaboration with Willis Towers Watson, “Human Capital as an Asset”, 2020, https://www3.
       weforum.org/docs/WEF_NES_HR4.0_Accounting_2020.pdf.
188.   International Labour Organization, Global Wage Report 2020-21, op. cit.
189.   See World Economic Forum, “Building Back Broader: Policy Pathways for an Economic Transformation”, op. cit.
190.   Ritchie, Hannah, and Max Roser, “CO2 and Greenhouse Gas Emissions by sector”, Published online at OurWorldInData.org,
       2020, https://ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector#energy-electricity-heat-and-transport-73-2.
191.   World Bank, “Manufacturing, value added (% of GDP)”, 2020, https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NV.IND.MANF.ZS.
192.   World Economic Forum, “Unlocking Business Model Innovation through Advanced Manufacturing”, White Paper, 2022,
       https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Unlocking_Business_Model_Innovation_through_Advanced_Manufacturing_2022.
       pdf.
193.   World Economic Forum, “New Business Models enabled by Advanced Manufacturing”, https://www.weforum.org/
       projects/new-business-models-enabled-by-advanced-manufacturing.
194.   World Economic Forum in collaboration with Kearney, “Charting the Course for Global Value Chain Resilience”, White
       Paper, 2022, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Charting_the_Course_for_Global_Value_Chain_Resilience_2022.pdf.
195.   World Economic Forum in collaboration with Kearney, “The Resiliency Compass: Navigating Global Value Chain
       Disruption in an Age of Uncertainty”, White Paper, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Navigating_Global_
       Value_Chains_Disruptions_2021.pdf.
196.   World Economic Forum, “Global Lighthouse Network”, https://www.weforum.org/projects/global_lighthouse_network.
                                                                                                             Future Focus 2025 132
197.   World Economic Forum, “Global Smart Industry Readiness Index Initiative”, https://www.weforum.org/projects/global-
       smart-industry-readiness-index-initiative.
198.   World Economic Forum, “New Generation Industry Leaders”, https://www.weforum.org/projects/new-generation-
       manufacturing-leaders.
199.   World Economic Forum, “Augmented Workforce Initiative”, https://www.weforum.org/projects/augmented-workforce-
       initiative.
200.   World Economic Forum, “Unlocking Value in Manufacturing through Data Sharing”, Projects, https://www.weforum.org/
       projects/data-sharing-for-manufacturing.
201.   World Economic Forum in collaboration with Boston Consulting Group, “Data Excellence: Transforming manufacturing
       and supply systems”, White Paper, 2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Data_Excellence_Transforming_
       manufacturing_2021.pdf.
202.   World Economic Forum, “Unlocking Value in Manufacturing through Data Sharing”, https://www.weforum.org/projects/
       data-sharing-for-manufacturing.
203.   Apolitical, “Agile 50: the World’s 50 Most Influential People Revolutionising Governance”, https://apolitical.co/list/en/
       agile-50.
204.   Srivastava, Arun, Nina Moffatt and Konstantin Burkov, “U.K. FinTech and Financial Services – Britcoin to the Scalebox;
       the U.K. Government Announces Plans to Boost the FinTech Sector and to Develop a Digital Pound”, Paul Hastings,
       29 April 2021, https://www.paulhastings.com/insights/client-alerts/u-k-fintech-and-financial-services-britcoin-to-the-
       scalebox-the-u-k.
205.   UK government, “Agile Nations”, https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/agile-nations.
206.   World Economic Forum, “A Holistic Guide to Approaching AI Fairness Education in Organizations”, White Paper,
       2021, https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_A_Holistic_Guide_to_Approaching_AI_Fairness_Education_in_
       Organizations_2021.pdf.
207.   Hall, Stefan, and Cathy Li, “The Technologies That Could Make Up the Metaverse”, BRINK News, 1 November 2021,
       https://www.brinknews.com/what-is-the-metaverse.
208.   World Economic Forum, “Global Coalition for Digital Safety”, https://www.weforum.org/global-coalition-for-digital-safety/
       about.
209.   See World Economic Forum, “In-depth Study of Diversity and Representation Shows Scale of Opportunity in Media and
       Entertainment Industries”, News Release”, 27 September 2021, https://www.weforum.org/press/2021/09/in-depth-
       study-of-diversity-and-representation-shows-scale-of-opportunity-in-media-and-entertainment-industries.
210.   See World Economic Forum, “World Economic Forum Launches Audience Representation Index to Provide Diversity,
       Equity and Inclusion Scores in Media, Entertainment and Sport”, News Release, 8 March 2022, https://www.weforum.
       org/press/2022/03/world-economic-forum-launches-audience-representation-index-to-provide-diversity-equity-and-
       inclusion-scores-in-media-entertainment-and-sport.
211.   Wilkinson, Mark D., et al., “The FAIR Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship”, Scientific Data,
       vol. 3, no. 160018, 2016, https://www.nature.com/articles/sdata201618.
212.   World Economic Forum, “Space Sustainability Rating”, https://www.weforum.org/projects/space-sustainability-rating.
213.   Chugh, Abhinav, “How can technological advancements in synthetic biology benefit everyone? An expert explains”,
       World Economic Forum, Agenda, 24 November 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/11/synthetic-biology-can-
       benefit-all-expert-explains-how.
214.   Vickers, Claudia, et al., “Realizing the potential of synthetic biology to help people and the planet”, World Economic
       Forum, Agenda, 5 April 2021, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/04/synthetic-biology-potential-people-and-the-
       planet-gtgs21.
215.   World Economic Forum Global Future Council on Synthetic Biology, Global Commons Working Group, “Why sharing data
       is crucial for progress in bioeconomy”, World Economic Forum, Agenda, 9 December 2021, https://www.weforum.org/
       global_future_councils/gfc-on-synthetic-biology/articles/why-sharing-data-and-benefits-is-crucial-for-bioeconomy.
                                                                                                              Future Focus 2025 133
The World Economic Forum,
committed to improving
the state of the world, is the
International Organization for
Public-Private Cooperation.
The Forum engages the
foremost political, business
and other leaders of society
to shape global, regional
and industry agendas.
World Economic Forum
91–93 route de la Capite
CH-1223 Cologny/Geneva
Switzerland
Tel.: +41 (0) 22 869 1212
Fax: +41 (0) 22 786 2744
[email protected]www.weforum.org