GIS Lucknow
GIS Lucknow
Lucknow, India
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by "Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad" on 06/12/23. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
Dhirendra Singh 1; Sheo Prasad Shukla 2; Mukesh Sharma 3; Sailesh N. Behera 4; Devendra Mohan 5;
Narendra Bahadur Singh 6; and Govind Pandey 7
Abstract: Megacities in India (population more than 10 million) have taken actions to control air-pollution emissions. However, the second-
level cities (population between one and 10 million) have not drawn an action plan, and people face serious air pollution in these cities. For
one such city, Lucknow, a geographic information system (GIS)-based methodology for emission inventory of on-road vehicles has been
developed. The pollutants include: sulfur dioxide (SO2 ); oxides of nitrogen (NOx ); carbon monoxide (CO); particulate matter (PM); 1,3
butadiene; formaldehyde; acetaldehyde; total aldehydes; and total polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Video recording was done
at nine road intersections of varying land-use patterns to assess traffic count and vehicle kilometer travel. Parking lot surveys were carried
out for assessing engine type, vehicle age, etc. and to arrive at a suitable net emission factor for each vehicle category. The 2-wheelers (2-Ws)
and 4-wheelers (4-Ws) dominate the total traffic with an 83% share and are main sources of NOx (46%) and CO (77%). The heavy duty
vehicles (HDVs: buses and trucks), although they account for only 2% of the vehicle fleet, emit disproportionately high emissions (23% of
SO2 , 36% of NOx , and 28% of PM). Spatial cell (2 × 2 km)-wise emission inventory of pollutants indicates that the city center has the highest
pollutant emissions resulting from a large number of vehicles, mostly 2-Ws, 3-Ws, and passenger cars. The inventory information can be used
for short-term and long-term planning to reduce emissions. DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)HZ.2153-5515.0000244. © 2014 American Society of
Civil Engineers.
Author keywords: Emissions estimation; Lucknow; India; Vehicular emission inventory; Traffic; Air pollution.
Fig. 1. The study area: (a) India (adapted from Delhi Tourism 2013); (b) state of Uttar Pradesh (adapted from Irrigation Department, Uttar Pradesh
2008); (c) city of Lucknow (adapted from Lucknow Nagar Nigam 2013)
(4-Ws), light commercial vehicles (LCVs), and heavy-duty ve- Lucknow were collected from different agencies (e.g., Lucknow
hicles (HDVs). Nagar Nigam, Lucknow Development Authority, etc.) and digitized
Emission inventory (EI) is a basic necessity for planning air pol- using ArcGIS 9.2. The topographical map, issued by the Survey of
lution control activities. EI provides a reliable estimate of total India (SOI) (prepared in 1977), having a scale of 1∶50,000, was
emissions of different pollutants, their spatial and temporal distri- geo-coded as the base map for geo-referencing other maps. The
bution, and identification and characterization of main sources. map projection chosen was world geodetic system (WGS) 1984
This information on EI is an essential input to air quality models (UTM Zone 44 N). The city was divided into 89 cells of 2 ×
for developing strategies and policies. With the above background 2 km size. Geo-referenced maps were digitized to extract desired
in view, as the first step to drawing up an air pollution action plan, information like city boundaries, road networks, landmark loca-
this paper focuses on developing EI of on-road vehicles on a geo- tions, and bodies of water. All the digitized features were superim-
graphic information system (GIS) platform for the city of Lucknow posed upon a layer of cells. Road lengths in each cell for major
in terms of emissions of particulate matter (PM); sulfur dioxide (number of vehicles more than 10,000 per day) and minor (number
(SO2 ); NOx ; CO; 1,3 butadiene; formaldehyde; acetaldehyde; total of vehicles less than 10,000 per day) roads were calculated from the
aldehydes; and total polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs; digitizing maps using the ArcGIS tool, ArcMap.
compounds having two or more benzene rings). The approach is Nine traffic intersections (Fig. 1) were video recorded from
unique, as the inventory will be available on GIS and all ArcGIS 9:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. for obtaining traffic composition, i.e.,
tools like ArcMap, ArcCatalogue, etc., which can be effectively 2-Ws; 3-Ws; 4-Ws; LCVs; HDVs; and also the traffic volume
used by various stakeholders for planning air pollution control (number of vehicles plying on-road per hour).
and other activities. It is expected that the methodology presented Various agencies [e.g., U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
in this paper can be adopted by other cities in India for initiating air (USEPA), U.K. National Atmospheric Emission Inventory (NAEI),
pollution control activities. etc.] have developed emission factors for vehicles depending on
their speed, acceleration, braking, road type, number of axles,
Methodology and driving cycle. The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB
2011) has prescribed emission factors for Indian conditions. The
Fig. 2 summarizes the stepwise methodology used in this study. Indian emission factors are based on engine cubic capacity, vehicle
Various maps (of wards, road networks, bodies of water, etc.) of age, test vehicle model, and engine technology (ARAI 2008).
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Fig. 4. Pollutant specific emission contribution of each vehicle type in city of Lucknow: (a) SO2 , PM, and NOx ; (b) CO; (c) total aldehydes,
acetaldehyde, formaldehyde, and 1, 3 butadiene; (d) total PAHs
maps for various pollutants were generated for the city of 13, and 11%, respectively, to the total vehicular emissions of PM.
Lucknow. The 3-Ws are one of the frequent modes of public transport within
the city. The parking lot survey reveals that the majority of 3-Ws
were 10–15 years old and were diesel powered. The HDVs account
Results and Discussion for only 2% of the vehicle population, but were responsible for 23%
of SO2 , 36% of NOx , and 28% of PM emissions. HDVs are diesel
The 2-Ws, 3-Ws, and 4-Ws show morning and evening peaks be-
tween 9:00 and 11:00 a.m. and between 5:00 and 7:00 p.m. The powered and are 10–15 years old and poorly maintained, which
highest traffic count (214,244) was observed between 5:00 to may be responsible for high SO2 , NOx , and PM emissions.
7:00 p.m. Large traffic flow of LCVs and HDVs were seen on high- 3-Ws and 2-Ws are major contributors to formaldehyde (42 and
ways (Lucknow-Sitapur, Lucknow-Hardoi, and Lucknow-Kanpur 25%), acetaldehyde (68 and 17%), and total aldehydes (47
highways). In the inner part of the city, the traffic largely consisted and 26%) emissions. 2-Ws, LCVs, and 3-Ws contribute 36, 27,
of 2-Ws, 3-Ws, and 4-Ws. Table 2 presents fleet composition and and 21%, respectively, to 1,3 butadiene emissions. 2-Ws and
VKT. The percentage share (in terms of vehicle count and VKT) of 3-Ws contribute 47 and 37%, respectively, to total PAHs emissions.
2-Ws is the maximum and of LCVs is the minimum. The emission This reveals that limiting the usage of 2-Ws and passenger cars can
contributions of each type of vehicle are shown in Fig. 4. help to bring down CO emissions, and improving the emission con-
There were 563,710 2-Ws in the city of Lucknow, which ac- trol technology for heavy-duty vehicles is the key to decreasing the
counted for 56% of the vehicle population. These were responsible vehicular emissions of SO2 , NOx , and PM emissions in the city.
for 31% of NOx and 54% of CO emissions. This is because 2-Ws Table 3 presents the comparison of previous studies with the
are responsible for 59% of total VKT and the number of 2-Ws was current study on vehicular emissions carried in various cities. It
high. 3-Ws, HDVs, 4-Ws, 2-Ws, and LCVs contributed 33, 28, 16, can be seen that there is a large variation in the vehicular emissions
in different cities even though they have similar human popula- the population, emissions, and major vehicle type responsible for
tions. The emission depends on the number of vehicles, availability high emissions in each critical cell of the city. It can be seen from
of good public transport (e.g., metro or local rail network, etc.), Table 4 that in the outer city critical cell, the HDVs and 4-Ws pro-
congestion, etc. vide a major contribution to emission. In the critical cells of the
Figs. 5–11 show the spatial distribution of PM, SO2 , CO, NOx , inner city, the 2-Ws contribution to PM is high. The 2-Ws and
1,3 butadiene, total aldehydes, and total PAHs emission loads in 3-Ws share high emissions of formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, and
2009. The high emission cells, LK-72, 73, 74, 75, 87 in the inner total aldehydes due to their high VKT.
city and LK-44, 89, and 102 in the outer city have been identified as The variations in the emission levels in various cells can be ex-
critical cells. In inner critical cells, the emission is due to significant plained by comparing land-use pattern, socioeconomic conditions
movement of all types of vehicles except HDVs. Table 4 presents of the populations, and its proximity with highway/industrial
activity. The cell numbers LK-72, 73, 74, and 75 fall in the center of 100, 102, 113, and 114 are at the outskirts of the city where land use
the city, where the land-use pattern is mainly residential and com- is mainly residential, but these cells are in proximity to national and
mercial. There are a number of offices (government as well as pri- state highways. The movement of 4-Ws and HDVs is high in these
vate) in this area and commercial activities (shopping centers, cells, and these are predominant vehicle types responsible for
restaurants, etc.) are also prevalent. One of the prominent reasons emission. The areas that have the minimum vehicular emission
of high vehicular emission load in these cells is that the vehicle (Figs. 5–11) have low population density and the land-use pattern
movement (dominated by 2-Ws, 4-Ws and public transport) is high is purely residential. The majority of areas are newly developed or
in comparison to other cells in the city. Cell numbers LK-76, 89, under development and have low occupancy. One of the major
Fig. 9. Spatial cell-wise emission inventory of 1,3 butadiene (kg=day) (2 × 2 km cell size)
Fig. 10. Spatial cell-wise emission inventory of total aldehyde (kg=day) (2 × 2 km cell size)
reasons of low emission in these areas is the fact that the minor The work presented in this paper has further scope for improve-
roads account for about 80% of road length, and movement of ment. It is important to validate the data, apply more accurate and
HDVs and LCVs is restricted to a certain extent. locally relevant emission factors, and account for nonexhaust emis-
The vehicular emission inventory developed in this study can be sions caused by road-tire interaction. The emission factors used in
used both for making broad decisions at the city level and at the cell this study do not account for driving cycle, including speed of ve-
level to reduce emission. It is important to note that 3-Ws contribute
hicles. Braking, acceleration, idling, and speed can all influence
significantly in inner cells of the city, and technological improve-
emissions. In addition, cold and hot starts of engines also influence
ments in 3-Ws including changes in fuel from diesel to CNG may
greatly help in reducing the emissions. For long-term planning, a emissions. In future work, the authors propose to establish a driving
public transport system should be revamped to include introduction cycle in Indian cities using a global positioning system (GPS) and
of a nonpolluting metro system so that people would feel discouraged account for start and stop emissions using vehicle occupancy char-
to use individual 2-Ws, which also contribute heavily to emissions. acteristics enumerator (VOCE) units.
Fig. 11. Spatial cell-wise emission inventory of total PAHs (kg=day) (2 × 2 km cell size)
emissions. 2-Ws are responsible for 59% of total VKT, and 3-Ws con-
Major vehicle type contributor in emissions
tribute over 30% to the total the emissions of PM. The HDVs make up
2-Ws and 3-Ws
References
ArcGIS version 9.2 [Computer software]. Redlands, CA, ESRI.
Automotive Research Association of India (ARAI). (2008). “Air quality
monitoring project-Indian clean air programme (ICAP).” Rep. on Emis-
HDVs and LCVs
HDVs and 4-Ws
HDVs and 2-Ws
sion Factor Development for Indian Vehicles, Pune, India, 7–15, 〈http://
PM and SO2
14.89
16.44
15.65
25.39
8.46
7.11
.defra.gov.uk/resources/RoadtransportEFs_NAEI11_v1.xlsx〉 (Apr. 2,
11
10
12
2014).
1
2
4
3
5
6
7
8
City.” M.Tech. thesis, Institute of Engineering and Technology sion inventory and its uncertainty analysis for Shanghai, China.” Sci.
Lucknow, UPTU, Lucknow, India. Total Environ., 398(1–3), 60–67.