Druce, 1970 LOWER CARBONIFEROUS CONODONTS FROM THE NORTHERN
Druce, 1970 LOWER CARBONIFEROUS CONODONTS FROM THE NORTHERN
by
E. C. DRUCE
SUMMARY
Fourteen conodont form-species referable to 10 form-genera from oolitic limestone
horizons in the Lower Carboniferous Rockhampton and Caswell Creek Groups of the
northern Yarrol Basin are described and figured. The faunas are of Tournaisian and
Visean age and can be correlated because of the presence of known European and North
American species. One new taxon, Taphrognathus capricornus sp. nov., is described and
figured. The Gudman Oolite is Tournaisian (upper cu I); the Gargoogie Oolite Member
is Lower Visean (cu II1l); the oolite horizon in the Caswell Creek Group equivalent
in the Southern area is Visean (cu IlIa) and an unnamed limestone horizon in the
Rockhampton Group is Tournaisian (cu Il,8/y).
INTRODUCTION
The results of studies carried out on Devonian faunas and the method of
operation of the field laboratory have already been published (Druce & Wilson,
1967; Druce, this Vol.). The conodont localities and faunas are given in the
appendix.
CARBONIFEROUS STRATIGRAPHY
Rockhampton Group
The type section of the Rockhampton Group (Rockhampton Series of Bryan
& Jones, 1946) is along Malchi Creek (Fig. 1). It was mapped in detail
by Fleming (1960), who defined it as extending from the Gudman Oolite
('Michelinia' Limestone of Hill, 1943) to the top of the Lion Creek Limestone
(Etheridge, 1900). The group is characterized by the development of oolitic
limestone at three stratigraphical levels; the Gudman Oolite, the Gargoogie
Oolite Member, and the Lion Creek Limestone. They are separated by
sequences of siltstone, mudstone, and sandstone (Kirkegaard et aI., 1966).
Apart from the limestone horizons exposure is poor and all samples collected
were isolated spot samples.
91
150°00' 151°00'
p- .,,--Pz
CL! Permion
~ Carboniferous
Gcea! ,K~' ~ Middle to Upper Devonian
~ Silurian to Middle Devonlan
[=:fi::J Undifferentlated Palaeoloic
~ Plutonic Rocks
Geological boundary
Unconformity
Fault I fault interpreted
x rn Palaeontological sample No.
0(251 Radiometric age Ix 10 6 years)
Rood
o Town
Homestead
10 Miles
\D
N
,
'°'\(~
0
24°00'
~~
Fig. 1: Lower Carboniferous rocks in the northern Yarrol Basin: conodont localities(.
The fauna from the Gudman Oolite consists of corals, brachiopods, goniatites,
gastropods, and conodonts. The fauna has affinities with the Schizophoria Zone
(Fleming, 1960), considered to be Upper Tournaisian by Maxwell (1953).
Whitehouse (1930) considered that the goniatites were of Lower Toumaisian
age. The conodonts are diagnostic. The p:enus Sivhonodella is restricted to the
Toumaisian in Germany (Voges, 1959) and the United States (Collinson et aI.,
1962), and to the Lower Tournaisian in the Bonaparte Gulf Basin (Druce,
1969). Polygnathus communis dentatus Druce is restricted and ranges from
the middle of the Siphonodella sulcata - Polygnathus parapetus Assemblage Zone
to the middle of the Siphonodella quadruplicata Assemblage Zone in the Burt
Range Formation in the Bonaparte Gulf Basin.
The Gudman Oolite can be correlated with the upper cuI and Lower cuIIa
Zones of Germany (Voges, 1959), with the middle Cleistopora Zone of Great
Britain (Rhodes et aI., 1969), and with the middle and upper Hannibal
Formation of the Upper Mississippi Valley.
The Gargoogie Oolite Member contains corals and conodonts. Fleming (1960)
records corals, including Lonsdalia, suggesting a Visean age. The only identifiable
conodonts recovered from this member are all referable to Taphrognathus
capncornis sp. novo which is also recorded from the Bonaparte Gulf Basin in
the Utting Ca1carenite of Lower Visean (cullS - ?culIIa) age as Taphrognathus
sp. (Druce, 1969). The genus Taphrognathus is confined to the Valmeyeran Series
in the USA (Rexroad, 1959). T. caprieornis sp. novo has also been recovered
from the Kolonga Creek Limestone, in the southern part of the Yarro1 Basin,
in association with Gnathodus texanus Roundy, which is known from the Upper
Valmeyeran Series of the USA (Collinson et al., 1962) and the cullS Zone of
Germany. The geographic occurrence of T. capricornus sp. novo is extensive in
the Yarrol Basin. It is known from oolite beds in the Ma1chi Creek, Limestone
Creek, and Craigilee Anticline areas; from the northern and central western
coasts of Long Island; and in oolitic limestones overlying the Lower Devonian
in the Glenmore district.
H
LITTLE
LAACOfllVALE
FORMATION
- !.'}.~
0 "
..'"
z
Vl
;;
~l
GAAGOOGI[
OOLIT E
U> MEMBER
:::>
0
a::
'"u.
~
z
0
..
ID
a::
u
UNNAMED
LIMESTONE
HORIZON
a::
'"0,.
...J Z
~
Vl ~
<i
z u"
a::
:::>
0
I-
GUDMAN
OOLITE
-
"
u
M{P) 126
SYSTEMATIC DESCRIPTIONS
BRYANTODUS sp.
(PI. 18, figs 4a, b)
Description: The unit is broken: only the anterior bar and apical denticle are
preserved. The anterior bar is slightly depressed and deflected at its anterior
termination and bears 9 irregular, laterally compressed, fused denticles with
free chevron tips. In cross-section the bar is diamond-shaped, with a sharp
keel and inflated lateral walls. On the inner face of the medial part of the
bar a single denticle is developed on the edge of the inflation. The apical
denticle is short and blunt.
A small basal cavity is developed subapically and the unit bears a narrow
keel.
1938 Gnathodus delicatus Branson & Mehl, Univ. Mo. Stud., 13, 145, pI. 34, figs 25-27.
1938 Gnathodus perplexus Branson & Mehl, ibid., 145, pI. 34, fig. 24.
1939 Gnathodus texanus (Roundy); Cooper, J. Paleont., 13, 388, pI. 41, figs 26, 27.
1951 Gnathodus delicatus Branson & Mehl; Hass, Bull'. Amer. Ass. Petrol.. Geol.,
35, pI. 1, fig. 4.
1959 Gnathodus 'delicatus Branson & Mehl; Hass, U.S. geol. Surv. prof. Pap. 294-J, 394,
pI. 46, figs 3-7; pI. 48, figs 1-5, 8.
1959 Gnathodus delicatus Branson & Mehl; Voges, Palaont. Z., 33, 283, pI. 33 figs 31-33.
1964 Gnathodus delicatus Branson & Mehl; Rexroad & Seott, Indiana geol. Su'rv.
Bull. 30, 29, pI. 2, figs 4-6.
95
1966 GnatJzodus delicatus (sic); Burton, N. Mex. geol. Soc. 15th Ann. Field Cont·
Guidebook, Range chart.
1966 Gnathodus delicatus Branson & Mehl; Manzoni, G. Geol., 33, 474, pI. 59, figs
7, 9, 11.
1969 Gnathodus delicatus Branson & Mehl; Rhodes, Austin & Druce, Bull. Brit.
Mus. (nat. Hist.) Geol. Sup. 5, pI. 18, figs 12a-d.
Description: The platform is asymmetrical, the outer side being more inflated
than the inner, and is situated posteriorly. Both platforms bear nodose ornament;
on the inner platform it consists of a single row of nodes which increase in
size and height anteriorly; on the outer platform it consists of low irregular
nodes. The platform is bisected by the carina, which is continuous with the
free blade, and consists of a series of about 17 fused needle-like dentides
with free chevron tips.
In aboral view the basal cavity is situated beneath the platform, which is
formed by the flared cavity lips.
Remarks: Gnathodus delicatus Branson & Mehl ranges from the cuII,B/y
to the cuII8 Zone in Germany (Voges, 1959, table 1; Boger, 1961) and
throughout the Tn3 Zone in Belgium (Coni!, Lys & Mauvier, 1964). It is
known from the middle and upper Z Zone in Britain (Rhodes et aI., 1968)
and from the Siphonodella isosticha - S. cooperi Zone to the Bactrognathus-
Polygnathus communis Zone in the United States (CoIlinson et aI., 1962;
Rexroad & Scott, 1964) .
In lateral view the carina is higher than the platform ornament. The basal
cavity extends beneath the whole platform.
Remarks: Rhodes, Austin, & Druce (1969, pI. 17, figs 5a-8d) described a
new subspecies, Gnathodus girtyi sonia, with additional nodes on the outer
96
platform cup. It is also present in the uppermost Visean and lowermost Namurian
strata in Eire (Collinson & Druce, unpubI.). The present specimen differs
from Gnathodus girtyi sonia in lacking the well developed transverse ridges
on the outer platform. Burton (1966, range chart) illustrates a specimen, very
similar to the present specimen which he places in Gnathodus bilineatus, from
the Lake Valley Formation of New Mexico. It is probable that both belong
to the same subspecies of G. girtyi, which is possibly a precursor of G. girtyi sonia.
Manzoni (1966) illustrates two specimens from the Carboniferous of the
Carnian Alps, northeastern Italy, which he refers to G. bilineatus (Roundy)
(pI. 59, fig. 4) and G. cf. texanus Roundy (pI. 59, fig. 10). His G. bilineatus
appears to be identical with G. girtyi sonia and his G. cL texanus is probably
referable to G. girtyi subsp. A.
1926 Gnathodus texallus Roundy, V.S. geol. Surv. prof. Pap. 146, 12, pI. 2, figs 7a,
b; 8a, b.
For complete synonymy see Druce, 1969, p. 63.
1934 Bryantodus acutus E. R. Branson, Vniv. Mo. Stud., 8, 325, pI. 28, fig. 28.
No. of specimens: 4; CPC 7784 figured.
Description: The unit is arched, with bars of equal length. The apical
denticle is massive and twice as wide as the bar denticles. The anterior bar
is deep and is depressed in the anterior quarter. The bar bears a series of
97
about 8 laterally compressed fused denticles. The posterior bar is slimmer
and deflected inward slightly and bears about 8 laterally compressed fused
denticles. The angle between the bars is about 150°.
1969 Polygnathus communis dentatus Druce, Bur. Mvner. Resour. Aust. Bull. 98, 95, pI. 18,
figs 13a-14.
1934 Polygnathus nodomarginata E. R. Branson, Univ. Mo. Stud., 8, 310, pI. 25, fig. 10.
For complete synonymy see Druce, 1969, p. 113.
cf. 1934 Pseudopolygnathus prima Branson & Mehl, Univ. Mo. Stud., 8, 298, pI. 24,
figs 24, 25.
1959 Pseudopolygnathus triangula Voges, PalclOnt. Z., 33, 301, pI. 34, figs 51-66.
pI. 35, figs 1-13.
The basal cavity is large and lanceolate, narrowing posteriorly. A sharp keel
is present beneath the free blade and the posterior termination; a narrow groove
bisects the free blade keel.
SIPHONODELLA sp.
(PI. 15, figs la, b)
Only one worn specimen was recovered. It is very close to Siphonodella sulcata
(Huddle), which is known to range throughout the Hannibal Formation of
the Upper Mississippi Valley (Collinson et aI., 1962).
SPATHOGNATHODUS sp.
(PI. 15, figs 2a-c)
1941 Staurognathus cruciformis Branson & Mehl, J. Paleont., 15, 102, pI. 19.
1959 Staurognathus cruciformis Branson & Mehl; Hass, U.S. geol. SurI'. proj. Pap.
2.94-J, 393, pI. 46, fig. 24.
1964 Staurognathus cruciformis Branson & Mehl: Lindstrom, CONODONTS, 169, fig. 60b.
1966 Staurognathus cruciformis (sic); Eurtcn, N. Mex. geol. Soc., 15th A nn. Field
Conf. Guidebook, Range chart.
The basal cavity extends beneath the intersection of the bars and is expanded.
It narrows along the posterior and outer lateral bars to form a groove and
has slightly flared lips beneath the anterior and inner lateral bars.
1969 Taphrognathus sp. Druce, Bur. Miner. Resour. Aust. Bull. 98, 139, plo 41, figs
la, b.
Derivation of name: After the Tropic of Capricorn, which passes near the
type locality.
No. of specimens: 25; holotype CPC 7796; paratypes CPC 7797, 7798.
Description: In oral view the unit is bowed, with a median anterior free
blade equal in length to the platform. The platform ornament consists of two
lateral rows of low round nodes with a wide shallow median trough. A short
medial posterior free blade is present.
In lateral view the blade is massive and triangular, the denticles increasing
in height and size posteriorly and culminating in a massive main denticle.
The denticles are fused over their whole length apart from their free chevron
tips. The oral surface of the platform is less than half the height of the blade.
The aboral third of the unit is constricted, the greatest constriction occurring
either side of the basal cavity lip. The aboral margin is a shallow V shape.
The basal cavity is asymmetrical, being flared and extending further anteriorly
on the inner side. The cavity extends to the posterior termination as a
narrowing trough and the aboral surface of the anterior free blade bears a
sharp keel.
102
REFERENCES
BRANSON, E. B., and MEHL, M. G., 1941-Conodonts from the Keokuk Formation.
Denison Vniv. Bull., J. Sci. Labs, 35 (1940), 179-188, pI. 6.
BRANSON, E. B., and MEHL, M. G., 1941-New and little known Carboniferous conodont
genera. J. Paleont., 15, 97-106, pI. 19.
BRYAN, W. H., and JONES, O. A., 1946--The geological history of Queensland. A strati-
graphic outline. Pap. Dep. Geol. Vniv. Qld, 2(12), 1-103.
BURTON, R. c., 1966--A preliminary range chart of Lake Valley Formation (Osage).
Conodonts in the Southern Sacramento Mountains, New Mexico. N. Mex. geol.
Soc., 15th Ann. Field Conf. Guidebook, 73-75.
COLLINSON, c., SCOTT, A. J., and REXROAD, C. B., 1962--Six charts showing biostratigraphic
zones, and correlations based on conodonts from the Devonian and Mississippian
rocks of the Upper Mississippi Valley. W. geol. Surv'. Circ. 328, 1-32.
CONIL, R., LYs, M., and MAUVIER, 1964-Criteres micropaleontologiques essentiels des
Formations-types du Carbonifere (Dinantien) du Bassin Franco-BeIge. C.R. 5ieme
Congo Strat. Glial. Carbon., Paris 1963, 1, 325-332.
DRUCE, E. c., 1969-Upper Palaeozoic conodonts from the Bonaparte Gulf Basin, north-
western Australia. Bur. Miner. Resour. Aust. Bull. 98.
DRUCE, E. C., 1969a-Frasnian conodonts from Mount Morgan, Queensland. This Vol.
DRUCE, E. C., and WILSON, A. T., 1967-Conodonts from the Queensland Palaeozoic
processed in a mobile acid laboratory. Qld. Govt Min. J., 68, 187-190.
ETHERIDGE, R., 190o-Corals from the Coral Limestone of Lion Creek, Stanwell, nr.
Rockhampton. Publ. geol. Surv. Qld, 154, 1-24.
HAss, W. H., 1959-Conodonts from the Chappel Limestone of Texas. V.S. geol. Surv.
prof. Pap. 294J, 365-399, pis 46-50.
HILL, D., 1943-A reinterpretation of the Australian Palaeozoic record, based on a study
of the rugose corals. -Proc. Ray. Soc. Qld, 54(6), 53-66.
HUDDLE, J., 1934-Conodonts from the New Albany shale of Indiana. Bull. Amer. Paleont.,
21(72), 1-136, pis 1-12.
JELL, 1. S., 1961-The geology of the Mount Larcom area. Hons Thesis Univ. Qld
(unpubl.).
KIRKEGAARD, A. G., SHAW, R. D., and MURRAY, L. G., 1966--The geology of the
Rockhampton and Port Clinton 1:250,000 Sheet areas. Gear. Surv. Qld Rec. 1966/1
(unpubl.).
REXROAD, C. R, and COLLINSON, C., 1963-Conodonts from the St. Louis Formation
(Valmeyeran Series) of Illinois, Indiana, and Missouri. Ibid., 355, pp. 1-28, pis 1, 2.
RHODES, F. H. T., AUSTIN, R. L., and DRucE, E. C., 1969-British Avonian (Carboniferous)
conodont faunas and their value in local and intercontinental correlation. Bull. Brit.
Mus. (nat. Hist.) Geol. Supp. 5.
ROBERTS, I., and VEEVERS, J. J., 1967-Carboniferous geology of the Bomuparte Gulf
Basin, northwestern Australia. C.R. 6th Congo Strat. Geol. Carbon., Sheffield.
VOGES, A., 1959-Condonten aus dem Unterkarbon I and 11 (Gattendorfia und Pericyclus-
Stufe) des Sauerlandes. Palaont. Z., 33, 266-314, pis 33-35.
104
APPENDIX
Rockhampton Group
Sample Y A RIll 11: On track 6 miles N .E. of Armagh homestead; Grid ref. 288106;
Weight of sample: 7 kg; 2 specimens.
Taphrognathus capricornis sp. novo
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
Sample YAR 116/2: 300 yards N.E. of 111/1; Grid ref. 291108. Weight of sample: 6 kg;
1 specimen.
Taphrognathus capricornis sp. novo
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
Sample YAR 117/1: Immediately north of Ridgelands road at intersection with Seven
Mile Creek; Weight of sample: 7 kg; 8 specimens.
Cavusgnathus sp. Spathognathodus sp.
Polygnathus sp.
Age: ?Visean.
Sample YAR 11914: N.W. tip of Long Island; Weight of sample: 3 kg. 8 specimens.
Taphrognathus capricornis sp. novo
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
Sample YAR 11915: Central west coast, Long Island; Weight of sample: 3 kg; 1 specimen.
Taphrognathus capricornis sp. novo
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
Sample YAR 12112: 50 yards N of road at Grid Ref. 322093, Rockhampton Sheet.
Weight of sample: 7 kg; 7 specimens.
Taphrognathus capricornis sp. novo
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
Sample YAR 12114: Limestone Creek; Grid ref. 320095. Weight of sample: 6 kg;
2 specimens.
Taphrognathus capricornis sp. novo Spathognathodus sp.
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
Sample YAR 12115: t mile N of Limestone Creek; Grid ref. 320094; Weight of
sample: 12 kg; 87 specimens.
Gnathod"s dp/icatus Pr"n<~n & Mehl Ozarkodina acuta (E. R. Branson)
Pseudopolygnathus triangulus Voges Staurognathus cruciformis (Branson & Meh!)
P. nodomarginatus (Branson & Mehl) Lonchodina sp.
P. cf. P. primus Branson & Mehl Hibbardella sp.
Age: Upper Tournaisian, early cull,Bl v ·
Sample YAR 12212: On Malchi Creek; Grid ref. 329081. Weight of sample: 7 kg;
3 specimens.
Taphrognatlzus capricornis sp. novo
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
Sample YAR 12213: 50 yards W of Malchi Creek; Grid ref. 332088 (Gudman Oolite);
Weight of sample: 8 kg; 14 specimens.
Polygnathus communis dentatus Druce Siphonodella sp.
Polygnatlzus sp.
Age: Tournaisian, late cuI.
Sample YAR 14912: Near Glenmore; Grid ref. 341095. Weight of sample: 5 kg;
2 specimens.
Taphrognathus capricornis sp. novo
Age: Lower Visean cullS.
105
PLATE 15
Magnification x40
Siphonodella sp.
Fig. la Aboral view of specimen CPC 7793.
b Oral view of specimen CPC 7793.
Spathognathodus sp.
Fig. 2a, b Lateral views of specimens CPC 7794.
c Oral view of specimen CPC 7794.
106
BMR Bull. 108 - Druce Old L. Carboniferous Conodonts Plate 15
PLATE 16
Magnification x40
108
BMR Bull. 108 - Druce Old L. Carboniferous Conodonts Plate 16
PLATE 17
Magnification x40
110
BMR Bull. 108 - Druce Old L. Carboniferous Conodonts Plate 17
PLATE 18
1agnificntion x40
Bryall/otllls sp.
112
BMR Bull. 108 - Druce Old L. Carboniferous Conodonts Plate 18