Browenfieldes Fromabandonmenttoengagement
Browenfieldes Fromabandonmenttoengagement
net/publication/292983279
CITATIONS READS
2 1,923
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Abdelrahman Abdelnaiem Abdelletif Mohamed on 04 February 2016.
The Housing and Building Cairo, Egypt , December 22-25, 2012 High Institute for Engineering
National Research Center and Technology
Topic stream:
AbdelRahmanAbdelNaeemAbdelLatif Mohamed
Associate Professor, Researcher
Mob.
01003315513
Hosting Major International Events
The Housing and Building Cairo, Egypt , December 22-25, 2012 High Institute for Engineering
National Research Center and Technology
Title:
Abstract:
1. Introduction
The redevelopment of derelict brownfields1 areas has received a lot of attention in the
past few years and has become a major landscape related problem. Since the mid-
1980s, policy makers and planners have been paying significantly more attention to
sustainable development and improve the quality of life in urban areas. The
redevelopment of derelict brownfield sites, which are often located in the core
sections of urban areas or sites of high ecological value are prime targets for urban
revitalization [10]. The transformation of derelict sites into parks and public spaces
represents a significant enhancement to the quality of life and land use, and at the
same time marks a new commitment to the transformation of once derelict sites to
new cultural, programmatic and environmental uses.
Study problematic - Derelict sites represent big challenges for the momentous
environmental problems (eg. soil contamination). This study demonstrate
revitalization of derelict sites, focusing on those that incorporate a significant amount
of public open space, throughout international and national two cases (Emscher
Landschaftspark, Germany and Azhar Park, Cairo, Egypt). These cases could be
prototypical for other renewal and revitalization projects and redesign of public or
mixed-use open spaces that "allowing for the interpretation of landscape …… as an
agent of social, cultural, ecological and technological change" (eg Corner 2000) [9].
Objectives and Methodology – Main objective of this study is to investigate design
strategies, which used in the reclamation of derelict areas of case studies and to show
how „livable spaces‟ can be produced from „spoiled places‟ [2]. Both case studies
adopted design strategies, which minimize the environmental impact assuring a
harmonious reclamation of the natural and built environments. They signify strategies
that reinforce the socioeconomic character, the naturalist and environmental character
and finally the historic and cultural character.
2. Design strategies for sustainable landscape reclamation
For creation a successful and sustainable reclamation design it is important to
understand how "landscape ecology and design can invent alternative forms of
relationships between people, place and cosmos so that landscape architectural
projects become more about invention and programs than the merely corrective
measures of restoration" [11]. Even in derelict and degraded areas can be created with
1
The term brownfields first came into use on June 28, 1992, at a U.S. congressional field hearing hosted by
the Northeast Midwest Congressional Coalition. They have been defined by Cabernet as sites: that have
been affected by former uses of the site or surrounding land that are derelict or underused, are mainly in fully
or partly developed urban areas, that require intervention to bring them back to beneficial use, and may have
real or perceived contamination problems [2]. Derelict land is defined as „„land so damaged by previous
industrial or other development that it is incapable of beneficial use without treatment‟‟. The land may be
contaminated by low concentrations of hazardous waste or pollution, and has the potential to be reused once
it is cleaned up [4].
a new spirit and can be made worth living by keeping visible the spirit of existing site,
by applying design strategies that contribute to economic prosperity, social cohesion
and environmental quality [11].
2.1 Restrictions and beneficiaries of sustainable reclamation
Many contaminated brownfield sites sit unused for decades because the cost of
cleaning them to safe standards could be more than land value after redevelopment.
Especially when unexpected circumstances arise, the cost for clean-up increases, and
as a result, the cleanup work may be delayed or stopped entirely [20]. Although the
key Challenges in Brownfields Redevelopment include: Environmental, Financial
Barriers, Cleanup Considerations and Reuse Planning [3]. In one hand Development
of brownfield sites must be restricted to some particular uses in order to minimize
exposure to leftover contaminants on-site after the cleanup is completed. In the other
hand the redevelopment of brownfield sites is a significant part of new urbanism,
while most of them are left as green spaces for recreational uses. For historical
reasons, many brownfield sites are close to important thoroughfares; their reclamation
can consequently be a major asset to a city. Therefor the following fundaments should
be integrated in Sustainable reclamation design:
1. Perform well the functions for which they are redesigned;
2. Be long lasting and adaptable to new uses;
3. Respond well to their surroundings and enhance their context;
4. Have a visual coherence and create 'delight' for users and passers-by;
5. Be sustainable - nonpolluting, energy efficient, easily accessible and have a
minimal environmental impact [20].
2
The Emscher is a small river in the north of the Ruhr region, which was for decades the main
industrial drain of the area and its most polluted element.
3
For a long time, the Ruhr Region - named after the river “Ruhr” in the southern part of the area –
was known as one of the “old” industrial regions in the world [15].
4
The Term “International Building Exhibition” referred to the German tradition of building
exhibitions. Since the 1920ies, German municipalities have organized these “exhibitions” to find good
solutions for architectural or urban demands by inviting international architects and presenting the
solutions to the public [15].
A central focus of the IBA strategic plan was environmental enhancement, which has
come not only from brownfields cleanup, but also from innovative planning
components. The IBA from 1989 marked the starting signal for the development of
seven regional green belts (Fig. 1) in a north-south axis and the "New Emscher
Valley" (east-west) [7]. The main goals included returning many brownfields to
green-fields and creating parks and recreational green-spaces, surrounding 10,000
new and rehabilitated housing units, which 75 percent are to be social housing, also
included a series of business and technology parks as part of the “Working in the
Park”. IBA Emscher Park invested about $2 billion to transform the ecology of
derelict landscapes, rejuvenate the Emscher River, convert brownfields into exhibits
of industrial heritage, promote architecturally outstanding ideas, and promote cultural
heritage and the arts to enhance the environment and create new jobs [14].
• Green Space A: Oberhausen,
Mühlheim, Duisburg
• Green Space B: Oberhausen,
Bottrop, Mühlheim
• Green Space C: Gladbeck,
Bottrop, Essen, Gelsenkirchen
• Green Space D: Gelsenkirchen,
Herne, Herten, Recklinghausen,
Bochum
• Green Space E: Rechklinghausen,
Bochum, Herne, Castrop-Rauxel
• Green Space F: Waltrop, Castrop-
Rauxel, Dortmund
• Green Space G:Lünen,
Bergkamen, Kamen, Kreis Unna,
Dortmund
Figure 1: planning structure of Emscher Landscape Park
Based on the IBA- related tradition of coordinated regional action the region has
developed the “Concept Ruhr” as the new fundament for urban and regional
sustainable development in the next decade [15]. In 2001 the state commissioned a
master plan for the Emscher Park to take forward the work of the IBA. The Master
plan Emscher Landscharftspark 2010 (Emscher Landscape Park Master Plan 2010)
was published in 2006 and endorsed by the state and all the cities in the region. The
current park plan incorporates a variety of design elements [5]:
• A water park based on the ecological regeneration of Emscher Canal system;
• Promenades and parks along railway lines that connect adjoining cities;
• Gardens that serve as a testimony to the area's industrial history;
• Buffer zones between the parks which can be used by local residents for a variety
of recreational activities;
• Preservation of the steelworks as an active museum of the smelting process and
technical history of the blast furnace.
All these elements create a central attraction, which will be the route of industrial
heritage through the Emscher Park that links all the industrial heritage sites, now
converted to museums and other cultural uses [13].
3.1.3 Heritage character – New uses for old industrial buildings
Instead of creating a completely new landscape, the proposed design strategy attempts
to celebrate the area's industrial past by integrating vegetation and industry,
promoting sustainable development and maintaining the spirit of the place. In this
industrial landscape nearly everything has been reused in some manner, playing with
the distinctions between natural and artificial [11].
Duisburg Nord Park (Figure 2) represents only a small portion of the effort that has
been made to reuse old industrial areas in the Ruhr river basin. In Duisberg-Nord the
former steel works was completely integrated in a New City Park and have been
preserved as part of a recreation park called “Landschaftspark” Landscape Park [15].
The young and old can climb giant blast furnaces, practice rock climbing, or slide
down a chute. A former iron pit and steel works provide outdoor theaters, concert
halls, discotheques, restaurants, and cafes. A large gas tank or “gasometer” has been
filled with water and a sunken ship is used for scuba diving. Also part of the overall
program, the inner harbor in Duisberg is being rehabilitated as a mixed use and mixed
income residential, commercial, and recreational project. In Essen another giant
industrial works, previously known as the Zeche Zollverein5, has been readapted as
the Design Zentrum Nordrhein Westfalen, an art and industrial park. The park
includes an exhibition hall of industrial design located in a former boiler house that
was remodeled by Sir Norman Foster. The park also offers a gourmet restaurant
within one of the preserved Bauhaus buildings. Other buildings in the coal complex
have been readapted as artist studios, with space for design offices and workshops. In
Oberhausen the largest gasometer in the world been converted to another exhibition
hall. The mammoth structure allows the contemplation of art whether that art is
exhibited within, or painted on the exterior of, the gasometer. In Gelsenkirchen the
IBA‟s headquarters is located within the buildings of an abandoned coal company. In
addition to rehabilitating the beautiful brick structures, the redesign includes
preservation of various features of the prior use that now constitute land art [8].
Figure 2: reuse old industrial plants as recreational, cultural and sport facilities
5
The former worldwide largest coalmine “Zollverein” in Essen has meanwhile been announced as
“World Cultural Heritage” [15].
3.2 Case study - Al-Azhar Park project
3.2.1 Historical background
The origins of the Al-Azhar Park project date to 1984, when the Aga Khan Award for
Architecture organized a conference on the subject of The Expanding Metropolis:
Coping with the Urban Growth of Cairo. On this occasion the Aga Khan announced
his decision to finance the creation of a park for the citizens of the Egyptian capital.6
The only central location which was of suitable scale was the derelict Darassa site.
The 30hc hilly site, formed by debris accumulated over centuries7. It is surrounded by
significant historic districts of Islamic Cairo, provides elevated view-points that
dominate the city and offer a spectacular 360° panorama over the townscape of
historic Cairo. This, in turn, fostered the idea of utilizing the Park project not only as
public green space but also as a panoramic platform, to view and re-interpret the built
heritage of Old Cairo[16]. The status of the site thus shifted from a neglected and
derelict condition to a strategic resource for the surrounding neighbourhoods and the
entire metropolis [18]. The Park project was therefore intended to be a case study for
a variety of development challenges, ranging from environmental rehabilitation to
cultural restoration [19].
3.2.2 From a derelict site into a park
In 1990 a protocol was signed between the Aga Khan Trust for Culture and the
Governorate of Cairo [19]. By 1996, when the Trust took over the site from the Cairo
Governorate, the Historic Cities Support Programme had developed a more
comprehensive approach to urban rehabilitation. Thus gradually extended to include
the rehabilitation of the fringe of the adjacent Darb al-Ahmar district. The
construction of the Park is acting as a catalyst for a whole range of associated
rehabilitation projects in its surroundings. The Trust was fortunate to find other
donors, such as the Egyptian-Swiss Development Fund and the Ford Foundation, who
subscribed to the combined physical and socio-economic rehabilitation and are
generously supporting the current activities [18].
6
The amount of green space per inhabitant in Cairo is roughly equivalent to the size of a footprint. It
is one of the lowest proportions in the world [19].
7
The site was 500-year-old mound of rubble in the inner city, between the eastern edge of the 12th
Century Ayyubid city and the 15th Century Mamluk “City of the Dead” [19].
arid climate sites. Accordingly, the task of greening the site posed unique questions
and challenges to the landscape architecture and the horticultural team [16].
Figure 5: uncovering and restoring the city wall adjusting to the Park
3.2.4 The development of Darb al-Ahmar
The project for socio-economic development of the neighbourhood was conceived
with the idea that the removal of the former rubble dump and its metamorphosis into a
park would have a catalytic effect on the general improvement of the district.
However, to ensure this result, the project‟s scope had to encompass the cultural
monuments in the neighbourhood and the people of this area. This approach took the
form of an integrated urban area development plan containing a series of pilot
interventions aimed not only at the restoration of landmark buildings, but at wide-
based socioeconomic development [19].
3.2.5 Socioeconomic support for local society
Employment - During the peak of the park construction phase, approximately 400
workers were on site daily, involving. The Ayyubid wall project involves more than
200 workers and training positions which have gone primarily to the people from
Darb al-Ahmar community. In addition, most of the materials used in the restoration
of the historic wall come from the local market.
Training - The project has offered over 120 training positions in activities such as
stone carving, masonry work and materials conservation. Park construction has also
stimulated the rediscovery of lost skills, such as the restoration of the intricate
traditional windows (mashrabiyya). Because the project hires most of its staff
members from the Darb al-Ahmar community, by the end of project the local staff
will be technically and administratively able to carry out the activities and direct the
project [19].
Figure 6: many local workers has been trained and offered jobs by the project
4. Discussions, Results and Conclusion:
4.1.1 Sustainable design strategies for reclamation
"Sustainable design strategies for reclamation of derelict areas should integrate five
fundamental principles: perform well the functions for which they are redesigned; be
long lasting and adaptable to new uses; respond well to their surroundings and
enhance their context; have a visual coherence and create ‘delight’ for users and
passers-by; be sustainable - nonpolluting, energy efficient, easily accessible and have
a minimal environmental impact." [11]
New design strategies to reclaim derelict sites have been devised in recent years,
focusing on the sustainability, quality and multi-functionality of the space, with
attention to historic, socioeconomic and cultural aspects. Derelict areas can be filled
with a new spirit and can be made worth living by keeping visible the spirit of
existing site, by applying design strategies that contribute to economic prosperity,
social cohesion and environmental quality [10]. Brownfields sites seem particularly
suited to create public open space that allows for a variety of uses and activities, and
could potentially support the understanding of landscape not just as a product, but as
an agency for ecological, cultural and social change [9].
4.1.2 Sustainable landscape reclamation
The two case studies introduce evidence for sustainable reclamation of derelict
brownfields areas that necessitate design solutions that take into account their history,
both in its physical remnants and in its socio-cultural and economic contexts. The case
studies make it obvious that the redevelopment of brownfield sites constitutes a
valuable opportunity for increasing green spaces in urban areas and, bringing about
benefits such as soil quality improvement, habitat creation, recreational opportunity
enhancement and economic revitalization of neighbourhoods. It can be also concluded
that the involvement of communities in the whole redevelopment process is crucial, in
both the short and long term [10].
4.1.3 Framework for successful regeneration
The two case studies demonstrate the key elements of programme management that
can be brought to bear to help deliver ambitious regeneration programmes.
• A clear shared vision
• Clear and strong leadership
• A clear implementation plan
• A network of partners eager to deliver
• Marshaling of the resources needed
• Central supports for partners
• Monitoring of progress and assessment of impact [13]
5. Recommendations:
The reclamation projects of derelict areas should follow design principles that
promote sustainability, reduce negative environmental impacts, and foment economic
prosperity social inclusion and a better quality of life.
In order to achieve sustainable development reclamation projects should reinforce
landscape character taking into consideration the spirit of the place and integrating the
pre-existence in the new landscape [11].
In order to achieve sustainable development must be making environmental protection
and ecological function an integral part of the designing process. "This is why it is
necessary to develop new design strategies to reclaim these sites, focusing on the
sustainability, quality and multi-functionality of the space, with attention to historic,
socioeconomic and cultural aspects. Future reclamation activities may be in
consultation with a global land-use planning and design agenda for climatic stability,
sustainable food sources, renewable natural resources and protection of the globe's
biological inhabitants [I]" [11]
These tow case studies offer adaptable examples of urban revitalization and a promise
of hope for the most neglected of neighborhoods.
References:
1. Allegato, 2005, Report Parchi, Eco-Industriali Europei, Progetto Life
Ambiente 524/04 SIAM, Rapporto finale Task 2.1
- http://www.uneptie.org/pc/ind-estates/casestudies/Emscher.htm
2. Dixon, T. and others ed., 2007, Sustainable Brownfield Regeneration -
Livable Places from Problem Spaces, by Blackwell Publishing Ltd, UK
3. EPA-560-F-06-245 October 2006, Anatomy of Brownfields Redevelopment,
Brownfields Solutions Series, www.epa.gov/brownfields
4. EPA, Last updated on 2009, Brownfields and Land Revitalization,
http://epa.gov/brownfields
5. EPA, Last updated on 2010 October 12, International Brownfields Case
Study: Emscher Park, Germany, Brownfields and Land Revitalization
http://www.epa.gov/brownfields
6. KiHyun, K. 2005, Rails-to-Green rails: Green space is the future for rail
stations and rail corridors, Arch 407/507 Human Factors and Research
Methods
7. Kötters, M., Oktober 2004, The Ruhrgebiet (Ruhr Area) - Somewhere to
discover in the heart of Europe, PRESS Office, Regionalverband Ruhr
8. Kushner, J. A., 2000, Social Sustainability: Planning for Growth in
Distressed Places - The German Experience in Berlin, Wittenberg, and
The Ruhr , Chapter 13: Germany, Journal of Law and Policy, Volume 3,
formerly titled : Journal of Urban and Contemporary Law, Washington
University
9. Langhorst, J. W., 2004, Rising from Ruins: Postindustrial Sites Between
Abandonment and Engagement,
http://www.openspace.eca.ac.uk/conference/proceedings
10. Loures, L. & Panagopoulos, T., 2007, Sustainable reclamation of industrial
areas in urban landscapes, in WIT Transactions on Ecology and the
Environment, Vol 102, WIT Press www.witpress.com
11. Loures, L. and others, 2006, Strategies to Reclaim Derelict Industrial
Areas, WSEAS Transactions on Environment and Development Issue S. Vol.
2. 2006
12. MAI, 2011/09/15, Facts-and-Figures, http://www.mai-nrw.de
13. NAO, 2007, How European cities achieve renaissance, Design and
Production by NAO Marketing & Communications Team DG Ref: 7487RF
Printed by Heronsgate
14. Schilling, J., 2008, Buffalo as the Nation’s First Living Laboratory for
Reclaiming Vacant Properties, from Cities Growing Smaller, Kent State
University‟s Cleveland Urban Design Collaborative
15. Seltman, P., 2007, Renaissance of an Industrial Region: “Internationale
Bauausstellung Emscher Park”
http://www.riss.osaka-u.ac.jp/jp/events/point/P.Seltmann.pdf
16. Stino, M., and Rashti, C., 2001, Converting a Derelict Site Into an Urban
Park, in The Aga Khan Trust for Culture, Historic Cities Support Programme,
, The Azhar Park Project in Cairo and the Conservation and
Revitalization of Darb El-Ahmar, by (IRL), Switzerland, www.akdn.org
17. Siravo, F. and Matero, F., 2001, Uncovering and Restoring the Ayyubid
City Wall, Historic Cities Support Programme, www.akdn.org
18. The Aga Khan Trust for Culture, Historic Cities Support Programme, 2001,
The Azhar Park Project in Cairo and the Conservation and Revitalization
of Darb El-Ahmar, by (IRL), Switzerland www.akdn.org,
19. The Aga Khan Trust for Culture, in Auguration of Al-Azhar Park, Cairo,
Programme Brief, May 2004, www.akdn.org
20. Wikipedia, 2011/09/17, Brownfield land, http://en.wikipedia.org
21. Wikipedia, 2011/09/17, Brownfield regulation and development,
http://en.wikipedia.org