Control System4
Control System4
✓ Identify the basic notions required for the design and implementation of a
control system
✓ Classify dynamic behavior of control systems
✓ Identify the system transfer function in various physical applications
✓ Illustrate application of feedback control systems
Physical
Inputs components
Outputs
within the
block
Fig.1. Block
Mathematical
Inputs Outputs
expression
Fig. 2 a D.C. motor speed control system and b Block diagram representation of speed control system
Closed loop system
It is a control system in which the control or action is influenced
by the output.
Feedback
For the connection shown in Fig.
3 a, the feedback is negative. If
the polarity of the
tachogenerator is reversed the
feedback is positive.
The control action (Va − VT )
decreases which decreases
the shaft speed ω. a Closed loop D.C. motor speed control system and b Block
diagram of closed loop D.C. motor speed control system
When there is disturbance in the
Closed loop system
It is a control system in which
the control or action is
influenced by the output.
A closed loop system is
defined as a system in which the
measured output is compared
with the reference input.
Here the control action depends
upon the changes in the output. a Closed loop D.C. motor speed control system and b Block
diagram of closed loop D.C. motor speed control system
Closed loop system
It is a control system in which the control or action is influenced
by the output.
Feedback
The control action (Va − VT ) is
also called by the name
Actuating Signal or Error Signal.
ω increases which results in
increase of (Va + VT)
The system is in
unstable mode of operation
a Closed loop D.C. motor speed control system and b Block
diagram of closed loop D.C. motor speed control system
BLOCK DIAGRAM
Block diagram is a rectangular block containing one input and one output.
All blocks are interconnected by arrows representing the signal flow path.
The operation the component is described by the mathematical function
enclosed within the block
Inputs 10 Outputs
Inputs dl
dt
Outputs
G (s)
Fig. 2. A Block
Block diagram representation of an equation
❖ Algebraic equations and mathematical functions can be represented by using
block diagrams
y = mx + c x m + y
+
c
25
z = 1.2 x − 10 y + 25 +
x + y
1.2
+
y
10
2) Summing points
Summing point is a block used to represent the addition and
subtraction of signals.
❖ It is shown as small circle connected to arrows representing
signal lines
❖ Incoming signal lines are further identified with either a positive
or negative sign indicating the addition or subtraction process
❖ Output of a summing point is again a signal shown with an
outgoing arrow. a + c c = a −b
❖ No sign is attached to an outgoing signal.
-
b
3) Takeoff points
a=b
b
4) Arrows
❖ Arrows represent the direction of the flow of signal or
information.
❖ This will tell us how the individual systems/subsystems are
connected.
Arrows
Output
Transfer Function (TF ) =
Input
System
Input TF Output
Transfer functions
Transfer function of a closed-loop system
❑ Closed-loop control system can be divided into two categories
based on the nature of the feedback signal.
❑ Negative feedback closed loop system
Forward path
❑ G is the gain of all
E
R +
G
EG C block in forward
Input Output feedback signal.
-
❑ H is the gain the gain
CH of all blocks in
H
Feedback path feedback signal.
Forward path
+ E C
R EG
G
Input + Output
CH
H
Feedback path
Fig. Negative feedback closed loop system
forward path gain
closed − loop transfer function =
1 − forward gain feedback gain
output C = closed − loop transfer function input R
C G
Positive feedback CLTF =
R (1 − GH )
G = 10
H =2
C G
CLTF =
R (1 + GH )
C 10
CLTF =
R (1 + 10 2 )
C 10
CLTF = = 0.476
R ( 21)
Example
❑ A negative-feedback closed loop system is subjected to an
input of 5V. Determine the output voltage. The system has a
forward gain of 1 and a feedback gain of 1
G =1
H =1
G H Output Important
R = 5V 1 1 2.5 ❑ With an increase in
C G forward gain the
CLTF =
R (1 + GH ) 2 1 3.333
output value
output C =
G
R 5 1 4.1666 approaches input
(1 + GH )
1 10 1 4.545 value but can never
output C = 5V
(1 + 11) 100 1 4.995 become equal to it.
5V
output C = = 2.5V
2
Example
❑ Determine the transfer function for a positive-feedback closed
loop system with forward gain of 1 and feedback gain of 0.5.
G =1
H = 0.5
G
TF =
(1 − GH )
1
TF =
(1 − 1 0.5 )
TF = 2
Example
❑ A positive-feedback closed loop system was subjected to an
input of 5 V. Determine the output voltage. The system has a
forward gain of 1 and a feedback gain of 0.75
G =1
Important
H = 0.75 G H Output ❑ The output value
R = 5V
C G 1 0.9 50 increases as loop gain
CLTF =
R (1 − GH ) 1 0.99 500 (GH) approaches 1. the
output C =
G output becomes very
(1 − GH )
R
1.9 0.5 190 large and approaches
output C =
1
5V 1.99 0.5 1990 infinity when the loop
(1 − 1 0.75 )
output C = 20V 1.999 0.5 19990 gain approaches 1.
BLOCK DIAGRAM SIMPLIFICATION
1) Blocks in cascade.
When two or more blocks are in a cascade (one after the other), the
can be replaced by a single block with its gain equal to the product
of individual gains.
R C
G1 G2
R G1G2 C
G2
R + C R G1 + G2 C
+
G1
3) Eliminating a feedback loop.
E (s) C (s)
R (s) +
G (s)
H (s)C (s)
H (s)
If we just look at the block G(s) with E(s) as input and C(s) as
output,
C (s) = G (s) E (s)
Where E(s) is the difference or sum of the input and the
feedback depending upon the type of feedback.
❑ For a feedback that is negative, E(s) is the difference of the
input and the feedback and
❑ For a feedback that is positive, E(s) is the sum of the input
and the feedback.
E (s) = R (s) C (s) H (s)
C (s) = G (s) E (s)
E (s) = R (s) C (s) H (s)
C ( s ) = G ( s ) R ( s ) C ( s ) H ( s )
C (s) = G (s) R (s) G (s)C (s) H (s)
R (s) G (s) C (s)
C (s) G (s)C (s) H (s) = G (s) R (s) 1 G ( s ) H ( s )
C ( s ) 1 G ( s ) H ( s ) = G ( s ) R ( s )
C (s) G (s)
=
R ( s ) 1 G ( s ) H ( s )
4) Moving a takeoff point ahead of a block
R C
G
R C
G
C
G
R C
R C G
G
R
1G
R
R + C
G
+
A
1G
R + C
G
+
A
R + C
G
+
A
G
10 C
6 1.2 0.5
Gt = G1G2G3
Gt = 6 1.2 0.5 = 3.6 10
3.6 36
output C = Gt R
output C = 3.6 10 = 36
Example
❑ Determine the transfer function for the block diagram in
figure below and also determine error value E given that R=2,
G1=2/3 and G2=12
R + E C
G1 G2
-
R + E C
G1G2
-
H =1
2 Error E = reference R − feedback MV
G1 = Error E = R − C
3
G2 = 12 G1G2
TF =
G1G2 (1 + G1G2 H )
TF =
(1 + G1G2 H ) output C = TF R
2 Error E = 2 − 0.889 2
12
TF = 3 Error E = 0.222
2
1 + 12 1
3
8
TF =
9
TF = 0.889
Example
❑ Determine the transfer function for the block diagram in
figure below
G3
R + + C
+
G1 G2 G4
INPUT OUTPUT
-
R + C
G1G2 G3 + G4
INPUT OUTPUT
-
R G1G2 C
G3 + G4
INPUT
1 + G1G2 OUTPUT
R G1G2 ( G3 + G4 ) C
INPUT 1 + G1G2 OUTPUT
Table 1 shows the block diagram reduction rules
Table 1Block diagram reduction rules
Table 1Block diagram reduction rules
Table 1Block diagram reduction rules
Tutorial On Block diagram reduction
Example 1
Reduce the block diagram shown in figure and obtain its closed loop
transfer function C ( s )
R
C G1G2
(s) =
R (1 + G1H1 )(1 + G2 H 2 ) + G1G2
Tutorial 2
Using block diagram reduction technique find the closed loop T.F. of the
system whose block diagram is given in Fig.2
Fig.2
Tutorial 3
The block diagram of a closed loop system is shown in Fig.. Using block
diagram reduction technique determine the closed loop T.F
= V2 − V1
V1=5 -12V
Vout
11
R1
U2:A
R2 R1 10k 2
LM324
1
Output (Error)
V2=3 3
R2
V2 = Signal aplied at the non − inverting input 10k
4
12V +88.8
R4 Volts
11
R1
U2:A
2 Output (Error)
10k
1
LM324
V2=3 3
R2
10k
4
12V +88.8
R4 Volts
Reference 10k
R3
Feedback
10k
V=5
V1=5 -12V
11
R1
U2:A
2 Output (Error)
10k
1 V=-1.9961
LM324
V2=3 3
R2
10k
4
12V -2.00
V=3 R4 Volts
Reference 10k
R3
Feedback
10k
V=3
V1=3 -12V
11
R1
U2:A
2 Output (Error)
10k
1 V=2.00376
LM324
V2=5 3
R2
10k
4
12V +2.00
V=5 R4 Volts
Reference 10k
❑ Resistor R4 and R2 set the gain for the V2 input.
When R4 = R2, the gain for V2 is equal to 1.
❑ Similarly, R3 and R1, which set the gain for the
V1 input, can be made equal for unity gain.
100k
11
R1
U2:A
2 Output (Error)
10k
1 V=-1.9961
LM324
4
12V -2.00
SP ( reference ) + E ( error )
-
MV ( feedback )
❑ The preceding equation can now be written as
4
U2:A R1
4
10k 3 U2:A
1 10k 3
LM324
V2=5V 2 1
R2 V2=5V 2
LM324
R2
10k
11
+4.00 10k
11
R4 Volts +2.00
10k R4 Volts
-12V 10k
-12V
R3
R3
12V
10k 12V
10k
V1=5
V1=5
R1
4
R1
4
U2:A U2:A
10k 3
10k 3
1
LM324 1
V2=1 2 LM324
R2 V2=3
R2 2
10k 10k
11
11
-4.00 -2.00
R4 Volts R4 Volts
10k 10k
-12V -12V
Summing point with adjustable SP input
❑ In laboratory applications, potentiometer is used to provide an adjustable setpoint
input to a closed–loop control system.
❑ The diagram is similar to one without an adjustable setpoint control. All four
resistors, R1 to R4, have their values increased to 33kΩ.
❑ These resistors should generally be much larger than the resistor
used for set point adjustments (R5, R6, and R7)
❑ The potentiometer R7 allows the adjustment of set-point voltage.
❑ The set-point network (R5, R6 and R7) is connected across bipolar
supply.
❑ This permits the bipolar SP voltage to be applied to the circuit
❑ R5 and R6 allow the SP voltage range to be adjusted within the
bipolar supply voltage range
❑ Thus, finer control can be exercised over SP adjustment.
❑ The SP voltage range can be set with the help of the following
expression R5
R3
V1=3
R6 (Vcc − Vee )
3.3k 33k
B1 Feedback
V=3 -12V
11
MV
R1
U2:A
R5 + R6 + R7 R7
33k
R2
2
3
LM324
1
Output (Error
V=-2.35744
R6 (Vcc − Vee )
1k 33k
4
SP 12V
11
MV
R1
U2:A
2 Output (Error)
33k
1 V=-2.35744
R7 R2 3
LM324
1k 33k
4
SP 12V -2.36
V=0.638459 R4 Volts
B2 33k
5V
R6
3.3k
Example
❑ Refer to figure below. Assuming a bipolar supply voltage of ±15V, determine the
value of potentiometer R7, to provide an SP voltage range of ±1V.
❑ Given that R5=3.3kΩ, R6=3.3kΩ, Vcc=+15V, Vee=-15V
❑ The minimum SP voltage =-1V , The maximum SP voltage = +1V
V1=3
R3
R5
3.3k 33k
B1 Feedback
V=3 -12V
5V
11
MV
R1
U2:A
2 Output (Error)
33k
1 V=-2.35744
R7 R2 3
LM324
1k 33k
4
SP 12V -2.36
V=0.638459 R4 Volts
B2 33k
5V
R6
3.3k
Example
❑ Refer to figure below. Assuming a bipolar supply voltage of ±15V, determine the
value of potentiometer R7, to provide an SP voltage range of ±1V.
❑ Given that R5=3.3kΩ, R6=3.3kΩ, Vcc=+15V, Vee=-15V
❑ The minimum SP voltage =-1V , The maximum SP voltage = +1V
R6 (Vcc − Vee )
min SP voltage = + Vee
R5 + R6 + R7 14 ( 6.6k + R7 ) = 99k
3.3k (15 − ( −15 ) ) 99k
−1 = + ( −15 ) R7 = − 6.6k = 0.471k
3.3k + 3.3k + R7 14
3.3k 30 R6 (Vcc − Vee )
−1 = − 15 max SP voltage = Vcc −
6.6k + R7 R5 + R6 + R7
99k
−1 + 15 =
6.6k + R7
R6 (Vcc − Vee )
max SP voltage = Vcc −
R5 + R6 + R7
3.3k (15 − ( −15 ) ) V
max SP voltage = 15V −
3.3k + 3.3k + 0.471k
3.3k 30V
max SP voltage = 15V −
7.071k
99V
max SP voltage = 15V −
7.071
max SP voltage = 15V − 14.0008485363V = 0.99915146V
❑ The actual standard value for a potentiometer is 500Ω, which will be used.
The actual SP range for this potentiometer will be ±1.056V
Gain Block
❑ The input and output relationship of a control element can be described by an
expression containing algebraic, differential, and integral terms.
❑ A block is used to correctly represent each of these types of relationships.
G ( gain )
11
R(input) :A
2 C(output)
1
LM324
3
4
12V +88.8
R2 ( feedbackresistor ) R C
G = 1+ 12.5
R1 ( inverting term resistor )
R2
12.5 = 1 + R1=2K R2=23.2K
R1
-15V
R2
11
12.5 − 1 = R(input)
2
:A
C(output)
R1 LM324
1
3
R2 = 11.5 R1
4
15V +88.8
selecting R1 = 2k Volts
R2 = 11.5 2k = 23k
❑ Maximum input signal: A large supply voltage will result in greater range for
input signal.
❑ An LM324 opamp is employed, which can accept a bipolar supply of ±15V .
❑ A saturation loss of 1 to 1.5V can be expected for LM324.
❑ This leaves a maximum output voltage swing of ±13.5V.
❑ Because the amplifier gain is 12.5V, the maximum range of input signal that can
be safely handled by this opamp is
output saturation range
input signal swing =
amplifier gain
13.5
input signal swing =
12.5
input signal swing = 1.08V
❑ This amplifier is useful when the input signal can be limited to within ±1.08V
❑ Constant (inverting) gain block
❖ Figure shows Opamp representation of a constant-gain (inverting) block .
❖ The input signal is applied to the inverting terminal.
❖ The output signal is inverted and is 180 out of phase with the input signal.
❖ Resistors R1 and R2 set the amplifier gain, G.
C ( output ) = G ( gain ) R ( input )
R(input)
R1 R2
R2
-15V
11
G = − 2
:A
C(output)
R1
1
R3 3
LM324
4
15V +88.8
Volts
❖ It is recommended that a resistor be used between the ground and noninverting
terminal
❖ This resistor helps to cancel the error due to opamp input bias currents.
❖ Ideally, R3 is chosen to be equal to the parallel combination of R1 and R2.
❖ But if feedback resistor R2 is much larger than input resistor R1, R3 can be
made equal to R1
R1 + R2
R3 =
R1 R2
❖ Standard resistor values can be chosen for R1 and R2 for fixed gain or a
potentiometer can be used for feedback resistor R2 to allow gain adjustment.
Takeoff Point
❑ A takeoff point allows signal information to be communicated to more than one
point.
❑ In equivalent electrical systems, such communication can easily be done via simple
interconnection between two points. Sometimes circuit components can be overloaded
due to low input impedance of the destination. This can be prevented through the
use of unity gain buffers, which reduce the loading on the source and maintain
signal integrity.
❑ Figure below shows a unity gain buffer used to isolate different sections of a circuit.
❑ An input signal is applied to the noninverting terminal.
❑ The inverting terminal is connected to the output terminal.
❑ A circuits can be considered as a modified non-inverting amplifier, with zero feedback
resistance and an infinite resistance connected between the inverting terminal and
ground. R2
Amplifier gain, G = 1 +
R1
R2 = 0, R1 =
0
Amplifier gain, G = 1 +
G =1
❑ With gain of 1, the output signal is same in terms of magnitude and polarity as the
input signal.
❑ The input impedance of noninverting amplifier (and thus, unity gain buffer) is very
high
❑ This reduces the amount of power drawn from the source circuit.
Summing point with multiple inputs
❑ The difference amplifier used as summing point is not suitable for obtaining the
algebraic sum of multiple signals.
❑ Summing amplifier is basically an inverting amplifier.
❑ Each input is connected to inverting terminal through an input resistor
❑ Multiple inputs can be applied to the opamp.
❑ The ratio of the feedback resistor to the input resistor sets the gain for that input
signal.
R4 R4 R4
x + c output C = − Y + Y + Z
R1 R2 R3
+ ❑ If R1=R2=R3=R4, the expression
is simplified to
+ y z output C = − (Y + Y + Z )
X
R4 R4
R1 R4
X(input)
R4
Y
R2
output C = − X + Y + Z
Y(input)
-12V R1 R2 R3
❑ If R1=R2=R3=R4, the expression
11
Z
Z(input)
R3 C(Output)
U2:A
R5
2
LM324
1
is simplified to
output C = − ( X + Y + Z )
3
4
12V +88.8
Volts ❑ The inverting sign can be removed by
feeding the output signal to another
inverting amplifier with unity gain.
V1 V2
X X
X(input)
R1 R4 R7
10k 10k 10k
Y Y
Y(input)
R2
-12V
10k
11
Z Z
Z(input)
R3
11
U2:A
2 U1:B
10k
1
R6 6
R5 3
LM324
7
10k
5
3.3k R8
LM324
4
12V +88.8 4.7k
4
Volts +88.8
Volts
V1 V2
X X V=-7.99194 V=7.99576
X(input) V=1
R1 R4 R7
10k 10k 10k
Y Y V=3
Y(input)
R2
-12V
10k
V=4
11
Z Z
Z(input)
R3
11
U2:A
2 U1:B
10k
1
R6 6
R5 3
LM324
7
10k
5
3.3k R8
LM324
4
12V -7.99 4.7k
4
Volts +8.00
Volts
Problem
Construct a circuit to implement Figure below
X +
+ Output C = X + 2Y + 4Z
Y 2
+
Z 4
X +
+ Output C = X + 2Y + 4Z
Y 2
+
Z 4
Output C = X + 2Y + 4Z
R4 R4 R4
Gain = − Gain = − Gain = −
R1 R2 R3
10k 10k 10k
−1 = − −2 = − −4 = −
R1 R2 R3
R1 = 10k R2 = 5k R3 = 2.5k
V1 V2
X X
X(input)
R1 R4 R7
10k 10k 10k
Y Y
Y(input)
R2
-12V
5k
11
Z Z
Z(input)
R3
11
U2:A
2 U1:B
2.5k
1
R6 6
R5 3
LM324
7
10k
5
2k R8
LM324
4
12V +88.8 4.7k
4
Volts +88.8
Volts
V1 V2
X X V=-10.9837 V=10.9874
X(input) V=1
R1 R4 R7
10k 10k 10k
Y Y V=2
Y(input)
R2
-12V
5k
V=1.5
11
Z Z
Z(input)
R3
11
U2:A
2 U1:B
2.5k
1
R6 6
R5 3
LM324
7
10k
5
2k R8
LM324
4
12V -11.0 4.7k
4
Volts +11.0
Volts
❑ Draw a schematic diagram to represent Figure below with unity gain closed-loop
control system with a forward gain of 10.
R + E C
10
-
❑ It contains two elements; R + E
10 C
▪ Summing block -
▪ Gain(noninverting) block
V1
R2 Summing Point Constant gain block V2
G = 1+ R4 R6 R7
R1 10k 10k 90k
R2
R2 Feedback signal(MV) -12V
10 = 1 +
11
10k
11
Reference(SP) V1
10k
U2:A
2 U1:B
1 6
R1 3
LM324
7
R2 Reference(SP) 5
10 − 1 =
10k
Error signal
LM324
4
10k
R5 12V +88.8
4
10k Volts +88.8
Volts
R2 = 90k
Feedback signal(MV)
V1
Summing Point Constant gain block V2
R4 R6 R7
10k 10k 90k
Feedback signal(MV)
R2 -12V
11
10k
11
Reference(SP) V1 U2:A
2 U1:B
1 6
R1 3
LM324
7
Reference(SP) 5
10k
Error signal
LM324
4
R5 12V +88.8
4
10k Volts +88.8
Volts
Feedback signal(MV)
V1
Summing Point V=0.270947 Constant gain block V2
V=2.73291
R4 R6 R7
10k 10k 90k
V=2.73291
Feedback signal(MV)
R2 -12V
11
10k
11
Reference(SP) V1 U2:A
V=3 2 U1:B
1 6
R1 3
LM324
7
Reference(SP) 5
10k
Error signal
LM324
4
R5 12V +0.27
4
10k Volts +2.73
Volts
Feedback signal(MV)
Group Assignment
Draw a schematic diagram to represent Figure below with unity gain closed-loop control
system
R + E C
2 10
-
Group Assignment
Develop a circuit to simulate the operation of a closed-loop control system represented by
the closed-loop block diagram in figure below. The circuit has to be tested for an input
voltage ranging from 0 to 2V DC. Given G1=2.5, G2=2, and H=1.25.
G2
+
R + G1 C
+
−
H
C G
=
C G
This states that for a given R, the change in the output C is
proportional to the change in G. If G is a control valve, a 10%
change in its characteristic will cause a 10% change in the flow
Examine the effect of G on the output C in a feedback system.
G
Assume that R and H remain constant. T =
1 + GH
C G
= dC dG GHdG 1 + GH
R 1 + GH = −
2
dC d G C (1 + GH ) (1 + GH ) G
=
R dG 1 + GH dC dG GHdG
= −
dC
=
dG
−
GHdG C G (1 + GH ) G For example, if GH = 100, a
R (1 + GH ) (1 + GH )2 10% change in G will result in a
dC GH dG
dC (1 + GH ) dG = 1 − 0.1 % change
= −
GHdG C (1 + GH ) G
( + ) ( + ) in the output C. Hence the
2 2
R 1 GH 1 GH
dC (1 + GH ) − GH dG
= performance of a system with
dC R dG GHdG 1 + GH C (1 + GH )
= −
2 G
R C (1 + GH ) (1 + GH ) G
feedback is insensitive to the
dC 1 dG
= changes in G
dC dG GHdG 1 + GH C (1 + GH ) G
= −
2
C (1 + GH ) (1 + GH ) G
GH 1
dC dG GHdG dC 1 dG
= − =
C G (1 + GH ) G C GH G
Effect of Feedback on Stability
•A system is said to be stable, if its output is under control.
•If the denominator value is zero (i.e., GH = -1), then the
output of the control system will be infinite. Thus, the control
system becomes unstable.
Effect of Feedback on Noise
To know the effect of feedback on noise is done comparing the
transfer function with and without feedback due to noise signal
alone.
Consider an open loop control system with noise signal as shown
below.
N
+
R C
G1 G2
+
Consider a closed loop control system with noise signal
N
+
R + C
G1 G2
+
+
H
The closed loop transfer function due to noise signal alone is
C G2
=
N 1 + G1G2 H
In the closed loop control system, the gain due to noise signal
is decreased by a factor of (1+G1G2H) provided that the term (1+
G1G2H) >1