LL.

B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABOUT THE AUTHOR ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3

PREFACE ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4

INTERNATIONALLY RECOGNIZED HUMAN RIGHTS ----------------------------------- 9

THE NOTION OF RIGHTS -------------------------------------------------------------------------12

CONCEPTUAL FOUNDATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS --------------------------------------14

THE LEGAL FOUNDATIONSS OF HUMAN RIGHTS --------------------------------------16

SOCIOLOGICAL UNDERPINNINGS ------------------------------------------------------------18

NORMS AND STANDARD OF HUMAN RIGHTS --------------------------------------------20

VARIOUS APPROACHES ABOUT HUMAN RIGHTS --------------------------------------22

ISLAMIC APPROACH OF HUMAN RIGHTS -------------------------------------------------22

SOCIALIST APPROACH OF HUMAN RIGHTS ----------------------------------------------24

EUROPEAN APPROACH OF HUMAN RIGHTS ---------------------------------------------26

NOTRH AMERICAN APPROACH OF HUMAN RIGHTS ---------------------------------28

IMPLEMENTATION OF THE INTERNATIONAL BILL OF RIGHTS -----------------30

ENFORCEMENT OF THE INTERNATIONAL BILL OF RIGHTS ----------------------33

REMEDIES OF INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS LAW -----------------------------35

ROLE OF UNITED NATIONS IS FORMULATING HUMAN RIGHTS -----------------38

STEPS BY UNITED NATIONS FOR INTERPRETATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS ---41

MONITORING OF HUMAN RIGHTRS BY UNITED NATIONS -------------------------44

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 1

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

WOMEN’S RIGHTS IN INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS REGIME -------------47

CONVENTION ON THE ELIMINATION OF ALL FORMS OF DISCRIMINATION

AGAINST WOMEN (CEDAW) ---------------------------------------------------------------------50

MINORITY RIGHTS IN INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS SYSTEM-------------52

HUMAN RIGHTS IN CONSTITUTION OF PAKISTAN 1973 -----------------------------57

REMEDIES AVAILABLE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS UNDER PAKISTAN’S

CONSTITUTION 1973 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------59

REMEDIES UNDER ARTICLE 199 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF PAKISTAN 1973

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------59

REMEDIES UNDER ARTICLE 184(3) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF PAKISTAN

1973 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------60

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 2

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Shahid Naeem emerges as a distinguished legal scholar and author, weaving a narrative of
academic excellence that spans his illustrious educational journey. Commencing his odyssey
at FC College Lahore, he distinguished himself in both Intermediate and Graduate studies,
laying the groundwork for a trajectory marked by intellectual prowess.
A true polymath, Mr. Shahid Naeem ventured into multiple disciplines, securing Master's
degrees in Computer Sciences, Economics, and Political Science from the esteemed University
of The Punjab, Lahore. This diverse academic foundation laid the groundwork for a
comprehensive understanding of legal, technological, and socio-economic facets.
His legal journey reached its zenith at the University of The Punjab, where Shahid Naeem
earned his LL.B with exceptional honours, earning a Gold Medal for his outstanding
achievements. Seeking specialized knowledge, he completed a Diploma in Labour Laws
(DLL), showcasing his dedication to the nuanced complexities of labour legislation.
The quest for legal knowledge transcended borders, with Mr. Shahid Naeem pursuing an LL.M
from England, infusing an international perspective into his formidable expertise. Beyond the
legal realm, he demonstrated prowess as a Software Engineer, serving as the Chief Programmer
in The Lahore Islamabad Motorway Project—a unique fusion of legal acumen and
technological proficiency.
Boasting over 25 years as an Advocate of The High Court, Shahid Naeem stands as a venerable
figure in the legal arena. His nuanced understanding of legal intricacies, coupled with practical
experience, positions him as a trusted authority and mentor within the legal community.
Currently serving as the Principal at "Kings Law College, Sheikhupura" an institution
affiliated with the University of The Punjab for LL.B, Mr. Shahid Naeem actively shapes the
future of legal education. His role extends beyond authorship and advocacy to encompass the
mentorship of aspiring legal minds.
Dedicated to the field of law, Mr. Shahid Naeem's extensive academic achievements and
multifaceted professional experience collectively define him as an influential force in legal
literature. As both an authoritative voice in legal discourse and a guiding light for future legal
professionals, his impact on the legal community is profound and enduring.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 3

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

PREFACE
Welcome to the enlightening journey through the intricate realm of human rights law—a
subject of paramount importance and perpetual relevance. In this comprehensive textbook
titled "Introduction to Human Rights Law," crafted specifically for LL.B students, we embark
on an exploration of the fundamental principles, international frameworks, and contextual
applications that define the landscape of human rights.
As advocates of the High Court, our shared passion for the pursuit of justice and the
safeguarding of human dignity has culminated in this collaborative effort. Shahid Naeem and
M. Farooq Sadiq bring to this endeavour a wealth of legal acumen and practical experience,
aiming to empower students with a nuanced understanding of the dynamic field of human rights
law.

Book Structure:
This book unfolds systematically, encompassing key topics essential for a foundational grasp
of human rights law. It commences with a robust "Introduction to Human Rights," delving into
the definition, notion, and conceptual foundation of human rights, including the legal and
sociological underpinnings. We explore the norms and standards governing human rights,
considering diverse approaches, including Islamic, socialist, and European/North American
perspectives.
Moving forward, we scrutinize "The International Bill of Rights," which comprises the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights (ICCPR), and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural
Rights (ICESCR). Implementation, enforcement, and remedies within the realm of
international human rights law are meticulously examined.
The pivotal role of the United Nations in shaping, interpreting, and monitoring human rights is
scrutinized in detail. Our exploration extends to specific themes, such as "Women’s Rights"
within the international human rights regime, including an in-depth analysis of the Convention
on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW).
"Minority Rights" form a crucial segment, highlighting their significance in the broader
international human rights system. The intricate interplay between human rights and the legal
framework in Pakistan is elucidated, with a specific focus on available remedies under the
Constitution of Pakistan 1973, including those under Article 199 and Article 184(3).

Educational Objectives:
This textbook is meticulously structured to facilitate a comprehensive understanding of human
rights law, equipping students with the knowledge and analytical skills necessary for navigating
this complex field. Real-world examples, case studies, and practical insights infuse depth into
theoretical concepts, fostering a holistic approach to learning.
We hope that this book serves not only as an academic guide but also as an inspiration for
students to critically engage with the evolving discourse of human rights. The subject matter
within these pages is not merely a theoretical construct; it is a living, breathing entity that
shapes societies, influences policies, and defines the pursuit of justice.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 4

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

May this journey through the intricacies of human rights law ignite your intellectual curiosity
and cultivate within you a profound appreciation for the principles that underpin the quest for
a more just and equitable world.

Shahid Naeem
Advocate High Court.

M. Farooq Sadiq
Advocate High Court



By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 5

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Introduction
To
Human Rights
Law

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 6

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

1. INTRODUCTION TO HUMAN RIGHTS

Human rights are the basic rights and freedoms that belong to every person in the world,
regardless of their nationality, ethnicity, religion, gender, or any other status. These rights are
inherent to all human beings, and they are often considered fundamental to the dignity, equality,
and well-being of every individual.

Definitions of "Human Rights" by Prominent Law Thinkers:

Here are few definitions of "human rights" by prominent law thinkers and dictionaries:

Eleanor Roosevelt:
"Where, after all, do universal human rights begin? In small places, close to home—so close
and so small that they cannot be seen on any maps of the world. Yet they are the world of the
individual person; the neighbourhood he lives in; the school or college he attends; the factory,
farm or office where he works. Such are the places where every man, woman, and child seeks
equal justice, equal opportunity, equal dignity without discrimination. Unless these rights have
meaning there, they have little meaning anywhere."

Nelson Mandela:
"To deny people their human rights is to challenge their very humanity." Mandela stressed that
human rights are not negotiable and are inherent to every person's humanity.

Black's Law Dictionary:

"Human Rights: The basic rights and freedoms to which all humans are entitled, often held to
include the right to life and liberty, freedom of thought and expression, and equality before the
law."

Oxford English Dictionary:

"Human Rights: The basic rights and freedoms to which all humans are considered to be
entitled, often held to include the right to life and liberty, freedom of thought and expression,
and equality before the law."

Explanation in Simple Words:

Human rights are the basic things that all people need to live a good life. They are the rights
and freedoms that belong to every person just because they are human. These rights are
important because they ensure that everyone is treated with dignity, fairness, and respect.
Human rights include simple but powerful things like the right to live, the right to be free, and
the right to be treated equally. They also include the right to have a home, to be safe, and to
express thoughts and opinions freely.
Think of human rights as the rules that make sure everyone is treated kindly and justly. No
matter where someone is from, what they believe, or how they live, human rights protect them.
These rights are protected by laws and agreements around the world to make sure that every
person, young or old, rich or poor, is treated with fairness and respect.
Human rights encompass a wide range of rights and principles that are essential for living a life
of dignity and respect. These rights are typically categorized into civil, political, economic,
social, and cultural rights.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 7

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

HUMAN RIGHTS CATEGORIES

Let's break down these categories for a better understanding:

1) Civil Rights:
Civil rights refer to the individual liberties that protect people's freedom from
infringement by governments, organizations, or private individuals. These rights
include freedom of speech, religion, and assembly. For example, the right to express
one's opinions without fear of persecution is a fundamental civil right.

2) Political Rights:
Political rights relate to participation in the political process, including the right to vote
and stand for election. These rights empower individuals to have a say in how their
countries are governed and who represents them in the government.

3) Economic Rights:
Economic rights pertain to the right to work, to education, and to a standard of living
adequate for health and well-being. These rights ensure that individuals have the
opportunity to earn a living, receive education, and enjoy a decent quality of life.

4) Social Rights:
Social rights encompass access to social services such as healthcare, housing, and social
security. These rights aim to provide a safety net for individuals, especially in times of
need. For instance, the right to adequate healthcare ensures that everyone can access
necessary medical services.

5) Cultural Rights:
Cultural rights protect the freedom to participate in cultural activities, preserve one's
culture, and access cultural heritage. These rights recognize the importance of cultural
diversity and the value of different forms of cultural expression.

Significance of Human Rights

Human rights are crucial because they protect individuals from discrimination, violence, and
other forms of harm. They promote equality and dignity for all, fostering a society where every
person is treated with respect and fairness. Upholding human rights is not only a moral
obligation but also a legal requirement under international law, including treaties like the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights and regional conventions.
In summary, human rights are the essential values that recognize and protect the inherent
dignity and worth of every person. They form the foundation of a just and inclusive society,
ensuring that individuals can live freely, peacefully, and with dignity.



By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 8

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

INTERNATIONALLY RECOGNIZED HUMAN

RIGHTS
Internationally recognized human rights, enshrined in various treaties and declarations, serve
as the bedrock of a just and equitable global society. These rights, delineated in key documents
such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), the International Covenant on
Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights (ICESCR), among others, encompass a broad spectrum of individual freedoms
and protections. In this comprehensive exploration, we delve into each right with additional
detail and real-world examples.

1. Right to Life (UDHR, Article 3):

The right to life is the paramount human right, emphasizing the inherent dignity of
every individual. It prohibits arbitrary deprivation of life and extends to safeguarding
against extrajudicial executions and capital punishment. Examples include international
condemnation of unlawful killings and campaigns against the death penalty.

2. Prohibition of Torture and Inhuman Treatment (UDHR, Article 5):

This right protects individuals from torture, cruel, or degrading treatment. International
instruments, such as the Convention Against Torture, underscore the absolute
prohibition of torture. Examples include the scrutiny of treatment in detention centers
and global efforts to hold perpetrators accountable for acts of torture.

3. Right to Liberty and Security (UDHR, Article 9):

The right to liberty safeguards against arbitrary arrest or detention. This encompasses
protection against enforced disappearances and unjust imprisonments. Notable
examples include legal challenges to unlawful detentions and international advocacy
for the release of political prisoners.

4. Right to a Fair Trial (ICCPR, Article 14):

Ensuring fair trial rights, this includes the presumption of innocence, right to legal
representation, and an impartial tribunal. Examples involve landmark court cases
setting precedents for fair trials and international tribunals ensuring justice in cases of
human rights violations.

5. Freedom of Expression (UDHR, Article 19):

The right to freedom of expression allows individuals to voice opinions and access
information freely. Examples range from advocacy for journalists' protection to global
movements promoting freedom of the press and online expression.

6. Right to Work (ICESCR, Article 6):

This right recognizes the importance of work for human dignity and includes fair
wages. Efforts globally focus on eradicating child labor, ensuring workplace safety, and
promoting fair labor practices.

7. Right to Education (UDHR, Article 26):

The right to education ensures access to quality education for all. Initiatives include
campaigns for girls' education, efforts to eliminate barriers to education, and
international cooperation to enhance educational opportunities.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 9

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

8. Right to Health (ICESCR, Article 12):

Ensuring the highest standard of physical and mental health, efforts range from global
health initiatives to campaigns addressing disparities in healthcare access, with a focus
on vulnerable populations.

9. Right to Adequate Standard of Living (ICESCR, Article 11):

This encompasses the right to food, clothing, housing, and an improving standard of
living. Examples include international aid programs addressing poverty and initiatives
ensuring affordable housing.

10.Right to Participate in Government (UDHR, Article 21):

This right allows individuals to engage in their government directly or through
representatives. Efforts include campaigns for electoral transparency, initiatives
promoting civic engagement, and advocacy for inclusive political processes.

11.Right to Freedom of Religion (UDHR, Article 18):

Freedom of thought, conscience, and religion protects diverse beliefs. Examples
include legal battles for religious freedom and international efforts to combat religious
discrimination.

12.Right to Non-Discrimination (UDHR, Article 2):

This foundational principle ensures equal rights for all, irrespective of race, gender, or
other characteristics. Examples include anti-discrimination legislation and campaigns
promoting inclusivity.

13.Right to Privacy (UDHR, Article 12):

Protecting against arbitrary interference, this right extends to digital privacy. Examples
involve legal challenges to mass surveillance and advocacy for robust data protection
laws.

14.Rights of the Child (Convention on the Rights of the Child):

Children's rights include protection from exploitation and access to education.
Initiatives focus on ending child labor, preventing child trafficking, and ensuring access
to quality education.

15.Right to Nationality (UDHR, Article 15):

This right safeguards against arbitrary deprivation and statelessness. Examples include
advocacy for the rights of stateless individuals and legal challenges to nationality laws
that lead to discrimination.

16.Right to Asylum (UDHR, Article 14):

Ensuring the right to seek and enjoy asylum, this right addresses refugees' protection.
Examples involve international efforts to provide asylum to those fleeing persecution
and advocacy for humane refugee policies.
In essence, these detailed rights and examples underscore the international commitment to
creating a world where every individual enjoys fundamental freedoms, dignity, and equality.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 10

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the internationally recognized human rights, as outlined in various foundational
documents such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), the International
Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), and the International Covenant on Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), represent a collective vision for a world where every
individual is endowed with inherent dignity and enjoys a broad spectrum of rights and
protections. These rights, ranging from the right to life and liberty to freedom of expression,
education, and non-discrimination, form the basis for a just and equitable global society. Real-
world examples of advocacy, legal battles, and international initiatives illustrate the ongoing
efforts to uphold and advance these rights. As we reflect on the significance of these rights, it
is evident that the pursuit of a world where human rights are universally respected remains a
shared endeavour, requiring continued collaboration, advocacy, and commitment from
individuals, communities, and nations alike.



By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 11

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

THE NOTION OF RIGHTS

Introduction: The concept of rights forms the cornerstone of modern legal systems and ethical
frameworks. In the context of human rights law, understanding the notion of rights is
fundamental. Rights are essential claims or entitlements that every individual possesses
inherently. They establish the basis for a just and equitable society, ensuring that each person
is treated with dignity and fairness.

Types of Rights:
A. Natural Rights:
Natural rights are considered inherent to human beings. They are not contingent upon
laws or customs. Examples include the right to life, liberty, and property.
B. Legal Rights:
Legal rights are those bestowed upon individuals by a specific legal system. They can
vary from one country to another and may include rights to vote, education, and a fair
trial.
C. Human Rights:
Human rights are universal rights inherent to all individuals, regardless of nationality,
ethnicity, or religion. They are protected internationally and encompass a wide array of
rights, such as freedom of speech, right to education, and protection against
discrimination.

Characteristics of Rights:
 Inalienable:
Rights cannot be taken away arbitrarily. They are inherent and cannot be transferred
or surrendered.
 Universal:
Human rights apply to every person universally, irrespective of their background or
beliefs. They are not limited to specific groups or regions.
 Indivisible:
Human rights are interconnected and interdependent. The violation of one right can
often lead to the violation of others. For instance, suppressing freedom of speech may
impede the right to a fair trial.
 Equal:
All individuals are equal in the eyes of the law and, therefore, have equal rights.
Discrimination based on race, gender, religion, or any other factor is a violation of
human rights.

Sources of Rights:
Following are sources of rights.

1) Constitutional Documents:
Many countries have a constitution outlining the fundamental rights granted to their
citizens. These documents serve as a primary source of legal rights.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 12

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

2) International Treaties and Conventions:

Various international agreements, such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
(UDHR) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR),
establish and protect human rights globally.

3) Customary International Law:

Some rights are derived from established international practices and customs, which
are recognized as binding even without specific treaties.

Conclusion:
Understanding the notion of rights is pivotal in the study of human rights law. It underscores
the essence of equality, justice, and dignity for all individuals. As societies progress, the
protection and promotion of rights remain crucial in fostering a harmonious and respectful
global community.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 13

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

CONCEPTUAL FOUNDATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS

The conceptual foundation of human rights is a fundamental framework that underpins the
entire field of human rights law. It provides the theoretical and philosophical basis for
understanding and justifying human rights. This foundation is critical in addressing the
question of why human rights are important, where they come from, and how they should be
protected.

Historical Evolution:
Human rights have evolved over centuries. Concepts of justice and individual freedoms can be
traced back to ancient civilizations. However, the modern idea of human rights, as we
understand it today, was significantly influenced by events like the Enlightenment and the
horrors of World War II. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) in 1948 marked
a pivotal moment in the codification of human rights principles on a global scale.

Key Elements:
Here are Key Elements Of The Conceptual Foundation:

I. Inherent Dignity:
Human rights are founded upon the belief in the inherent dignity of every person.
This dignity is not contingent upon societal status, achievements, or affiliations but
is a birth right of all individuals. Recognizing this dignity forms the basis for the
respect and protection of human rights.

II. Universality:
Human rights are universal, applying to all people without discrimination.
Regardless of nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, or any other distinction, every
individual is entitled to the same set of fundamental rights. This universality
underscores the equal worth of all human beings.

III. Inalienable and Indivisible:

Human rights are inalienable, meaning they cannot be taken away or surrendered
under any circumstances. Moreover, these rights are indivisible, interdependent,
and interrelated. The fulfilment of one right often depends, wholly or in part, upon
the fulfillment of others. For example, the right to education enhances opportunities
for employment, contributing to economic rights.

IV. Rule of Law:

The rule of law is pivotal in upholding human rights. It ensures that laws are just,
enforced fairly, and accountable to safeguard individual liberties. Legal
frameworks, independent judiciaries, and effective law enforcement agencies are
essential components of the rule of law.

Philosophical Foundations:
Here we will discuss philosophical foundations briefly.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 14

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

A. Natural Law Theory:

Natural law theory posits that certain moral principles are inherent in human nature.
These principles form the basis for human rights, asserting that there are objective,
universal standards of morality that apply to all societies and cultures.

B. Social Contract Theory:

Social contract theories, articulated by philosophers like Rousseau, Hobbes, and Locke,
propose that individuals come together to form societies. In this social contract, they
agree to abide by certain rules in exchange for protection and the assurance of their
fundamental rights.

C. Utilitarianism:
Utilitarianism, championed by philosophers like Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill,
argues that actions, including the protection of rights, should be judged based on their
utility, promoting the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Upholding human
rights is seen as a means to achieve societal well-being and happiness.

Conclusion:
The conceptual foundation of human rights is a rich tapestry woven from historical lessons,
philosophical insights, and legal advancements. It stands as a testament to the collective moral
consciousness of humanity, emphasizing the shared aspiration for a world where every
individual is treated with respect, fairness, and compassion. This foundation not only informs
international agreements and domestic laws but also serves as a beacon guiding societies
toward a more just and inclusive future. Understanding these profound concepts is essential for
anyone studying, advocating for, or working within the realm of human rights.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 15

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

THE LEGAL FOUNDATIONSS OF HUMAN RIGHTS

The legal foundations of human rights constitute a complex and interconnected framework that
encompasses international treaties, national constitutions, legislation, and judicial decisions.
These legal mechanisms serve as the backbone of human rights protection, ensuring that
fundamental rights and freedoms are recognized, respected, and upheld globally. We can divide
them into following types:

A. International Treaties and Conventions

B. National Constitutions
C. Judicial Interpretation and Precedents
D. National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs)

A. International Treaties and Conventions:

International treaties and conventions can be better understand through following
points.
1. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR):
Adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1948, the UDHR is a foundational
document that outlines basic human rights principles. Although not legally binding, it
has inspired the development of numerous international and regional human rights
treaties.
2. International Covenants:
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International
Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) are core human rights
treaties. ICCPR focuses on civil and political rights (e.g., freedom of speech, religion),
while ICESCR emphasizes economic, social, and cultural rights (e.g., right to
education, healthcare). States that ratify these covenants are legally bound to uphold
the rights outlined within them.
3. Regional Human Rights Instruments:
Various regions, such as Europe, the Americas, and Africa, have established regional
human rights treaties and courts (e.g., European Convention on Human Rights, Inter-
American Court of Human Rights) to address specific regional challenges and promote
human rights standards.

B. National Constitutions:

1. Constitutional Protections:
Many countries incorporate human rights provisions directly into their constitutions.
These constitutional rights serve as the highest legal authority within a specific
jurisdiction, ensuring the protection of fundamental freedoms for citizens. For instance,

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 16

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

the U.S. Bill of Rights and the German Basic Law guarantee citizens' fundamental
rights.
2. Legislation:
National legislation complements constitutional provisions by further defining and
protecting human rights. Laws addressing discrimination, labor rights, privacy, and
other areas ensure that international human rights standards are translated into domestic
legal frameworks.

C. Judicial Interpretation and Precedents:

1. Case Law and Judicial Review:

Courts play a crucial role in interpreting and applying human rights laws. Landmark
cases set legal precedents, clarifying the scope and limitations of various rights. Courts
ensure that legislation aligns with human rights principles, offering remedies to
individuals whose rights have been violated.
2. International and Regional Courts:
International and regional human rights courts, such as the International Court of Justice
(ICJ) and the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), provide avenues for
individuals and states to seek redress for human rights violations. Decisions from these
courts contribute significantly to the development of human rights jurisprudence.

D. National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs):

Many countries have established NHRIs, independent bodies tasked with promoting
and protecting human rights at the national level. These institutions monitor human
rights situations, investigate complaints, and provide recommendations to
governments, enhancing human rights enforcement mechanisms.

Conclusion:
The legal foundations of human rights are multifaceted, ranging from international treaties and
conventions to national constitutions, legislation, judicial interpretation, and the work of
NHRIs. This complex legal infrastructure ensures the protection and promotion of fundamental
rights, fostering a global environment where individuals can live with dignity, equality, and
freedom. Understanding these legal foundations is essential for advocates, policymakers, and
citizens working towards a more just and humane society.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 17

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

SOCIOLOGICAL UNDERPINNINGS
In delving into the multifaceted realm of human rights, it becomes paramount to explore the
intricate interplay between societal structures and the principles of justice and equality.
Sociological underpinnings serve as the lens through which we comprehend the deeper layers
of human rights issues. By examining cultural norms, social movements, economic systems,
political ideologies, and the far-reaching impacts of globalization, sociology provides
invaluable insights into the complexities of human rights in the modern world. These
sociological perspectives illuminate the various ways in which societal dynamics influence the
recognition, protection, and sometimes, the violation of human rights. In this exploration, we
unravel the social fabric that envelops human rights, recognizing that the pursuit of a just
society demands a comprehensive understanding of the social undercurrents that shape our
world. Let’s dive deep to explorer more.

Cultural Relativism and Human Rights:

Cultural relativism emphasizes understanding human rights within diverse cultural contexts.
While universal principles exist, cultures interpret and prioritize rights differently. Sociological
analysis delves into these cultural nuances, acknowledging that what constitutes a fundamental
right can vary based on cultural norms and traditions. This perspective encourages dialogue
and negotiation, bridging the gap between universal rights and cultural diversity.

Social Justice Movements and Human Rights:

Social justice movements, rooted in sociological understanding, drive significant societal
change. Through in-depth sociological analysis, these movements identify systemic
inequalities, challenge discriminatory practices, and advocate for policy reforms. Movements
like the civil rights movement, feminism, LGBTQ+ rights activism, and indigenous rights
movements have reshaped legal landscapes, highlighting the sociological necessity of
grassroots activism in advancing human rights agendas.

Economic and Political Factors Impacting Human Rights:

Sociological examination of economic systems and political ideologies unveils disparities that
affect human rights. Economic inequality often leads to social unrest, highlighting the
importance of economic rights in the human rights discourse. Sociological research assesses
the impact of policies on marginalized communities, emphasizing the interconnectedness
between economic structures, political decisions, and human rights violations. Understanding
these dynamics is crucial for crafting policies that promote social justice and equitable human
rights outcomes.

Globalization and Its Complex Impact on Human Rights:

Globalization, while fostering interconnectivity, also poses challenges to human rights.
Sociological perspectives dissect how globalization influences labor rights, environmental
protections, and cultural preservation. Multinational corporations, migration patterns, and
international trade agreements all have sociological implications on human rights. Sociological
research scrutinizes power dynamics in global contexts, ensuring that human rights are not
compromised amid global economic shifts. This scrutiny is vital for addressing transnational
challenges and promoting ethical globalization practices.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 18

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Social Movements and the Intersectionality of Human Rights:

Sociological underpinnings emphasize the intersectionality of human rights issues. Societal
discrimination often overlaps based on race, gender, sexuality, and other factors. Sociological
research explores these intersections, revealing compounding effects of discrimination and
advocating for comprehensive legal protections. This understanding is crucial for ensuring that
human rights frameworks address the complex, multifaceted nature of discrimination faced by
marginalized communities.

Conclusion:
Sociological underpinnings provide critical depth to the conceptual foundation of human rights.
By examining cultural relativism, social justice movements, economic and political influences,
globalization's impact, and the intersectionality of human rights issues, sociological analyses
enrich our understanding of human rights challenges and solutions. This nuanced perspective
fosters inclusive, contextually relevant approaches, essential for creating societies where
human rights are universally respected and protected.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 19

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

NORMS AND STANDARD OF HUMAN RIGHTS

Human rights, as universally accepted ethical principles, are underpinned by a set of norms and
standards that provide the framework for the recognition, protection, and promotion of
fundamental rights and freedoms. These norms and standards are established at both
international and national levels, shaping the landscape of human rights law and practice.

INTERNATIONAL NORMS AND STANDARDS:

International Norms and standards for human rights can be understood through the
followings.

1. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR):

The UDHR, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1948, serves as a
foundational document. It outlines a comprehensive range of civil, political, economic,
social, and cultural rights. The UDHR sets the normative standards that guide the
creation of subsequent human rights instruments.

2. International Bill of Human Rights:

Comprising the UDHR, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
(ICCPR), and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights
(ICESCR), the International Bill of Human Rights is a cornerstone in international
human rights law. It sets the standards for civil, political, economic, social, and cultural
rights and obliges states parties to ensure their fulfillment.

3. Regional Human Rights Instruments:

Various regions have developed their own regional human rights instruments, each
tailored to address specific regional concerns. Examples include the European
Convention on Human Rights and the American Convention on Human Rights. These
instruments establish regional norms and standards, offering supplementary protection
to individuals within their jurisdictions.

NATIONAL NORMS AND STANDARDS:

Norms and standards for human rights at national level can be explained through the
followings.

1. Constitutional Protections:
Many national constitutions incorporate human rights provisions, often inspired by
international standards. These constitutional protections set the normative framework
for human rights within individual countries, with varying degrees of detail and
specificity.

2. National Legislation:
National laws complement constitutional protections by translating international human
rights standards into domestic legislation. These laws may address issues such as
discrimination, labour rights, and freedom of speech, ensuring that human rights are
upheld in local contexts.

MONITORING MECHANISMS:
To keep an eye on human rights following mechanisms can be applied.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 20

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

i. Human Rights Institutions:

Many countries have established National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) tasked
with promoting and protecting human rights at the national level. These institutions
monitor human rights situations, investigate complaints, and provide recommendations
to governments, thereby upholding national norms and standards.

ii. Treaty Bodies:

Treaty bodies, established under international human rights treaties, oversee states'
compliance with treaty obligations. They review state reports, issue recommendations,
and help uphold international norms and standards.

EMERGING NORMS:

 Rights in the Digital Age:

With the rapid advancement of technology, new norms and standards are emerging to
address issues related to digital privacy, online freedom of expression, and
cybersecurity.
 Environmental Rights:
Recognizing the environmental challenges facing the world, there is a growing
movement to establish norms and standards for environmental rights, emphasizing the
right to a healthy environment.

Conclusion:
Norms and standards of human rights, established at international and national levels, provide
the moral and legal framework for the protection of fundamental rights and freedoms. These
norms guide the actions of governments, international organizations, and civil society in their
efforts to uphold human rights, ensuring that individuals are treated with dignity, equality, and
respect worldwide. As the world evolves, these norms also adapt to address emerging
challenges and issues, making the protection of human rights a dynamic and ongoing endeavor.



By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 21

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

VARIOUS APPROACHES ABOUT HUMAN RIGHTS

Understanding human rights can be seen in different ways. Some people focus on laws and
rules, making sure everyone follows them to protect people's rights. Others think about rights
that should be the same for everyone, no matter where they live or what they believe. Some
consider the traditions and customs of different cultures, saying rights might mean different
things to different people. There are also those who connect human rights with having good
schools, health care, and fair chances in life. Some look at rights through the lens of gender,
making sure women and other gender groups are treated equally. Another way is to see human
rights in the context of fairness, where everyone has the same opportunities and resources.
Lastly, there are efforts to give power to those who are often left out, helping them speak up
for their rights. These different ways of thinking show that human rights are complex, touching
on various aspects of life and society. Exploring these approaches helps us understand how
people protect and fight for their rights in different ways around the world. We will discuss the
following approaches to explore difference between communities regarding human rights.

A. Islamic Approach
B. Socialist Approach
C. European Approach
D. North American Approach

ISLAMIC APPROACH OF HUMAN RIGHTS

The Islamic approach to human rights is deeply rooted in the teachings of The Quran, the
Hadith (sayings and actions of Prophet Muhammad ‫)ﷺ‬, and Islamic jurisprudence (Fiqh). It
emphasizes the dignity, equality, and well-being of all individuals while acknowledging the
broader ethical framework of Islam. This approach safeguards human rights through a
combination of legal and moral principles, with a strong emphasis on social justice and the
common good. Islamic approach regarding human rights can be understand through the
following points.

1) Human Dignity and Equality:

In Islam, the concept of human dignity is fundamental. The Quran explicitly states that
all human beings are equal in the eyes of Allah. Regardless of race, ethnicity, or social
status, every individual possesses intrinsic worth. Surah Al-Hujurat (49:13) emphasizes
mutual respect and understanding among diverse peoples, highlighting that true nobility
is determined by righteousness and good deeds. This principle of equality underscores
the importance of fair treatment and respect for every person, forming the basis for
human rights in Islam.

2) Freedom of Belief and Expression:

Islamic teachings promote freedom of belief and expression. The Quran asserts that
faith should be a matter of personal conviction and conscience. Surah Al-Baqarah
(2:256) unequivocally states that there is no compulsion in religion, emphasizing the
freedom to choose one's beliefs without coercion. This principle ensures that

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 22

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

individuals are free to practice their faith, fostering an environment of tolerance and
religious diversity within Islamic societies.

3) Right to Life and Security:

The Quran places immense value on human life and condemns any form of violence or
harm to innocent individuals. Surah Al-Ma'idah (5:32) equates the killing of one person
to killing all of humanity, emphasizing the sanctity of life. This principle establishes
the right to life as a fundamental human right, obligating individuals and societies to
uphold and protect the lives of others. It also implies the right to live in a secure
environment, free from fear and violence.

4) Social Justice and Economic Rights:

Islam places a strong emphasis on social justice and economic fairness. The concept of
Zakat, one of the Five Pillars of Islam, mandates giving a portion of one's wealth to the
less fortunate. Surah Al-Baqarah (2:267) emphasizes the importance of giving in
charity, ensuring economic resources are distributed equitably. These principles aim to
minimize disparities, provide for the needy, and create a just society where everyone
has access to basic necessities such as food, shelter, and education.

5) Women's Rights:
Islamic teachings provide specific provisions safeguarding the rights and dignity of
women. The Quran grants women the right to inheritance (Surah An-Nisa 4:7) and
emphasizes their role as equal partners in family life. Surah Ar-Rum (30:21)
underscores mutual respect and cooperation between spouses, promoting harmonious
relationships based on love and understanding. These teachings establish women's
rights within the family and society, emphasizing their value and contributions.

6) Judicial Fairness:
Islamic jurisprudence emphasizes the importance of justice in all legal matters. Surah
An-Nisa (4:135) encourages standing firmly for justice, even if it is against oneself or
close relatives. This principle ensures the fair and equitable treatment of all individuals
under the law, regardless of their social or economic status. Islamic courts are required
to adhere to these principles, ensuring justice is served and human rights are protected
within legal proceedings.

7) Protection of Minorities:
Islam promotes the protection of religious and ethnic minorities within Islamic
societies. Surah Al-Kafirun (109:6) emphasizes the right of individuals to practice their
religion freely, recognizing religious diversity and the importance of respecting
differing beliefs. Islamic history includes instances where religious minorities were
protected and allowed to practice their faith, demonstrating the inclusive nature of
Islamic teachings.
In summary, these principles demonstrate the holistic approach of Islam to human rights,
encompassing not only legal rights but also ethical and moral values. They emphasize equality,
justice, and respect for the rights and dignity of every individual, forming the foundation for
human rights in Islamic teachings.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 23

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

SOCIALIST APPROACH OF HUMAN RIGHTS

The socialist approach to human rights delves deep into the fabric of society, weaving a
narrative of collective welfare, economic parity, and social justice. Rooted in principles of
equality and fairness, socialism places economic and social rights at the forefront, aiming to
create a society where every individual has access to education, healthcare, fair employment,
and social security. Worker's rights are safeguarded, ensuring just wages, safe working
conditions, and the freedom to bargain collectively. Socialists advocate for wealth
redistribution, believing that extreme economic disparities impede the realization of basic
human rights. This approach champions universal access to essential services, encourages
political participation, fights for gender and social equality, and establishes robust social safety
nets. In this socialist vision, human rights are not mere ideals but tangible guarantees, fostering
a society where everyone thrives, regardless of their background or circumstance. We can
understand its sprit through the following points.

1) Economic and Social Rights:

Socialism underscores economic and social rights as fundamental human entitlements.
It advocates for universal access to quality education, healthcare, employment, housing,
and social security. The belief is that these rights are essential for human dignity and
societal progress. Socialists argue that individuals can only truly exercise their rights
and freedoms when basic economic needs are met, making these rights foundational in
any just society.

2) Worker's Rights:
Worker's rights are a central focus within the socialist framework. This includes not
only fair wages and safe working conditions but also the right to unionize, collectively
bargain, and strike. Socialists assert that a healthy economy depends on the well-being
of its workers. Consequently, they advocate for laws that protect workers' rights and
ensure their active participation in shaping workplace policies.

3) Wealth Redistribution and Economic Justice:

Socialism promotes progressive taxation and wealth redistribution policies to bridge
economic gaps. The goal is to reduce extreme wealth inequalities, ensuring that
resources are shared more equitably among citizens. By taxing the wealthy at higher
rates, socialist systems generate revenue to fund essential services and social safety
nets, fostering economic justice and providing for those in need.

4) Universal Access to Essential Services:

A hallmark of socialist societies is the universal provision of essential services. This
includes healthcare, education, and other vital services that are accessible to all citizens,
regardless of their financial status. Socialists argue that such universal access ensures
equal opportunities and helps eradicate disparities rooted in wealth, providing a solid
foundation for societal development.

5) Political Participation and Democracy:

Socialists advocate for participatory democracy, where citizens actively engage in
decision-making processes. This approach ensures that policies and laws are reflective
of the needs and aspirations of the majority, particularly the working class. Political

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 24

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

participation, according to socialists, empowers individuals and communities, allowing

them to influence the direction of their society and protect their rights effectively.

6) Gender and Social Equality:

Gender equality and the elimination of social discrimination are core tenets of the
socialist approach. Socialists champion policies and initiatives that promote gender
equality, aiming to eradicate disparities in opportunities and treatment between genders.
Similarly, they address discrimination based on race, ethnicity, religion, and sexual
orientation, striving for an inclusive society where every individual is respected and
valued.

7) Social Safety Nets:

Social safety nets, such as unemployment benefits, disability support, and pensions for
the elderly, are integral to socialist systems. These safety nets serve as a protective
cushion for vulnerable individuals and families, preventing them from falling into
poverty during challenging times. By establishing robust social safety nets, socialists
create a safety net that ensures the well-being and security of all citizens, particularly
those facing economic hardship.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the socialist approach to human rights offers a powerful vision of a society
founded on equality, justice, and shared prosperity. By placing economic and social rights at
the forefront, advocating for fair working conditions, wealth redistribution, and universal
access to essential services, socialists create a framework where every individual can lead a
life of dignity and fulfillment. The emphasis on political participation, gender equality, and the
eradication of social discrimination further enriches this vision, fostering inclusivity and
diversity. Moreover, the establishment of robust social safety nets ensures that no one is left
behind, even in times of adversity. In this socialist paradigm, human rights cease to be mere
abstract ideals; they become tangible realities shaping the everyday lives of people, irrespective
of their background or circumstances. Through this approach, societies can move closer to
realizing the fundamental principle that every human being deserves not just the opportunity
to thrive but the assurance that they will.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 25

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

EUROPEAN APPROACH OF HUMAN RIGHTS

The European approach to human rights stands as a beacon of international standards, woven
into the fabric of democracy, rule of law, and individual freedoms. Rooted in the aftermath of
World War II and the horrors of totalitarianism, Europe's commitment to human rights has
significantly shaped global discourse. Emphasizing the dignity and autonomy of every
individual, this approach combines legal frameworks, institutions like the European Court of
Human Rights, and a deep-seated cultural belief in human rights. European nations have
collectively pioneered ground breaking conventions and declarations, setting standards that
resonate across borders, ensuring the protection of fundamental rights for all. We can
understand this approach with following points.

1) European Convention on Human Rights:

At the heart of the European approach lies the European Convention on Human Rights
(ECHR), a seminal treaty that safeguards a range of civil and political rights. The
Convention establishes fundamental freedoms such as the right to life, freedom of
speech, and the right to a fair trial. European countries, through their membership in
the Council of Europe, are bound to uphold these rights, allowing individuals to seek
justice at the European Court of Human Rights.

2) European Union's Charter of Fundamental Rights:

Within the European Union (EU), the Charter of Fundamental Rights plays a pivotal
role, enshrining political, social, and economic rights for EU citizens. It encompasses a
wide array of rights, including privacy, non-discrimination, and workers' rights. The
Charter acts as a guiding light for EU policies, ensuring a high level of protection and
respect for human rights across member states.

3) National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs):

European countries often have robust National Human Rights Institutions. These
organizations act as watchdogs, monitoring human rights situations domestically,
investigating complaints, and advocating for policy changes. NHRIs contribute
significantly to the protection and promotion of human rights at the national level.

4) Social and Economic Rights:

In addition to civil and political rights, the European approach emphasizes social and
economic rights. European countries prioritize social welfare programs, healthcare, and
education, ensuring citizens have access to a high standard of living. Economic
stability, coupled with social safety nets, forms a cornerstone of the European model,
reflecting the belief that economic well-being is intertwined with human rights.

5) Embracing Diversity and Inclusivity:

Europe's approach to human rights includes a strong emphasis on diversity and
inclusivity. Anti-discrimination laws and policies protect marginalized communities,
ensuring equal rights for everyone, regardless of race, religion, gender, sexual
orientation, or disability. European societies actively promote integration and cultural
diversity, fostering an environment where every individual's human rights are respected
and celebrated.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 26

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Conclusion:
In the European approach to human rights, we witness a harmonious blend of legal frameworks,
cultural values, and a profound dedication to individual freedoms. Through conventions like
the ECHR and the EU's Charter of Fundamental Rights, coupled with social welfare initiatives
and inclusive policies, Europe provides a compelling model for the world. It is a testament to
the belief that the protection of human rights is not merely a legal obligation but a moral
imperative. In embracing diversity, safeguarding social and economic rights, and upholding
the principles of justice and equality, Europe paves the way for a future where human rights
are not just ideals but living realities, shaping the lives of millions across the continent.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 27

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

NOTRH AMERICAN APPROACH OF HUMAN

RIGHTS
The North American approach to human rights reflects a diverse tapestry of ideologies and
legal frameworks within the continent. Predominantly influenced by democratic principles and
constitutional rights, North American nations, including the United States and Canada,
champion individual freedoms, civil liberties, and democratic governance. These countries
uphold the rule of law, emphasizing a combination of legal safeguards and social policies to
protect human rights. The North American approach navigates complex social, cultural, and
historical contexts, shaping a multifaceted perspective on human rights that underscores the
importance of individual autonomy, social justice, and equal opportunities. Here points to
understand the approach more perfectly.

1. Constitutional Protections:
North American countries, notably the United States and Canada, boast strong constitutional
protections for human rights. In the United States, the Bill of Rights, comprising the first ten
amendments to the Constitution, guarantees fundamental freedoms such as freedom of speech,
religion, and assembly. These constitutional provisions serve as a bedrock, allowing citizens to
challenge any infringements on their rights through the legal system. In Canada, the Charter of
Rights and Freedoms, part of the Constitution Act of 1982, safeguards various civil liberties
including freedom of expression, assembly, and association. Both nations' constitutional
frameworks provide a framework for legal recourse, ensuring that citizens are protected from
undue government intrusion and unjust legal practices.

2. Social Justice Movements:

North America has a rich history of social justice movements that have significantly shaped
human rights discourse. The civil rights movement in the United States, led by figures like
Martin Luther King Jr., fought against racial segregation and discrimination, leading to
landmark legislation like the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Similarly, the women's rights movement
and LGBTQ+ rights movement have challenged gender and sexual orientation-based
discrimination, leading to legal reforms and changing societal attitudes. Indigenous rights
movements in both countries have also played a crucial role, advocating for the recognition of
Indigenous sovereignty, land rights, and cultural preservation. These movements have not only
influenced laws but have also fostered societal awareness, promoting inclusivity and equal
rights for all.

3. Democratic Governance and Civic Participation:

North American nations uphold democratic governance as a cornerstone of human rights
protection. Through free and fair elections, citizens have the opportunity to choose their
representatives, ensuring that their voices are heard in the decision-making process. The
separation of powers among the executive, legislative, and judicial branches of government
reinforces checks and balances, preventing the abuse of power. Civic participation is
encouraged through mechanisms like town hall meetings, public forums, and grassroots
activism. Citizens can actively engage in political processes, influencing policy-making and
holding elected officials accountable. This active participation strengthens democratic values
and ensures that governance aligns with the interests and rights of the people.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 28

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

4. Human Rights Institutions and Advocacy Organizations:

North America is home to numerous human rights institutions and advocacy organizations
dedicated to upholding and promoting human rights. Governmental bodies like the U.S.
Commission on Civil Rights and the Canadian Human Rights Commission play vital roles in
monitoring human rights situations, investigating complaints, and providing recommendations
to policymakers. Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) like the American Civil Liberties
Union (ACLU) and Amnesty International USA in the United States, and the Canadian Civil
Liberties Association (CCLA) in Canada, are at the forefront of human rights advocacy. These
organizations raise awareness about human rights issues, provide legal assistance to
marginalized communities, and lobby for policy changes. Their work ensures that human rights
concerns remain in the public consciousness and contribute significantly to shaping progressive
human rights policies and practices.

Conclusion:
In the diverse landscape of North America, the approach to human rights stands as a testament
to the values of democracy, individual liberties, and social justice. Through constitutional
protections, social justice movements, democratic governance, and the tireless efforts of human
rights institutions, North American nations continue to champion the cause of human rights.
The evolution of laws and societal attitudes, spurred by activism and legal reforms, exemplifies
the region's commitment to ensuring that every individual, regardless of background, enjoys
the full spectrum of human rights. In North America, the journey toward a more equitable and
rights-respecting society is a dynamic and ongoing endeavor.



By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 29

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

2. THE INTERNATIONAL BILL OF RIGHTS

The International Bill of Rights refers to three key documents:
1) UDHR (Universal Declaration of Human Rights): Adopted by the United Nations
General Assembly in 1948, UDHR sets out fundamental human rights that are
universally protected.
2) ICCPR (International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights): ICCPR is a treaty
adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1966, and it focuses on civil and
political rights, such as freedom of speech and the right to a fair trial.
3) ICESCR (International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights): Also
adopted in 1966, ICESCR covers economic, social, and cultural rights, including the
right to work, education, and an adequate standard of living.
Together, these documents form the International Bill of Rights, promoting and protecting
various human rights across the globe.
These stand as a monumental milestone in the history of human rights. Enshrined in these
documents are the fundamental principles that recognize the inherent dignity and equal rights
of all individuals, regardless of their race, gender, religion, or nationality. The Universal
Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1948, sets
the stage by outlining a comprehensive array of civil, political, economic, social, and cultural
rights. It serves as the cornerstone upon which subsequent human rights treaties are built. The
ICCPR focuses on civil and political rights, including freedom of speech, religion, and
assembly, emphasizing the importance of political participation and individual liberties. In
parallel, the ICESCR addresses economic, social, and cultural rights, such as the right to
education, healthcare, and work, underlining the significance of equitable living standards.
Together, these international instruments create a robust framework, establishing a global
standard for human rights protection and guiding nations toward creating just societies. They
inspire advocacy, shape legislation, and empower individuals, ensuring that the ideals of
equality, justice, and dignity transcend borders, uniting humanity in the pursuit of a more
equitable and rights-respecting world.

IMPLEMENTATION OF THE INTERNATIONAL BILL

OF RIGHTS
The implementation of the International Bill of Rights, comprising the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights (UDHR), the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR),
and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), is a
multifaceted and ongoing endeavour. These international agreements provide a robust
framework for the protection and promotion of human rights on a global scale. However, the
practical realization of these rights involves complex challenges, which vary from country to
country and region to region.

National Legislation and Enforcement:

Implementation begins with countries adopting laws and policies that align with the
UDHR, ICCPR, and ICESCR. Nations need to ensure their legal frameworks guarantee
human rights, and these laws must be enforced effectively. Establishing constitutional

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 30

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

protections and legal mechanisms that allow individuals to seek remedies in cases of
rights violations is fundamental. Law enforcement agencies and judicial bodies play a
vital role in upholding these rights, ensuring that individuals have access to justice and
can hold perpetrators accountable.

Reporting and Monitoring:

Countries that are party to these international treaties are obligated to submit regular
reports detailing their progress in implementing human rights provisions. Expert
committees, such as the UN Human Rights Committee and the Committee on
Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, review these reports. Through this process,
states receive feedback and recommendations, guiding them in improving their human
rights records. Monitoring mechanisms serve as a critical accountability tool, enabling
international scrutiny of a nation's human rights practices.

National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs):

NHRIs act as independent bodies within countries, promoting and protecting human
rights. They monitor government actions, investigate complaints, and offer
recommendations to policymakers. NHRIs bridge the gap between international human
rights standards and local contexts, ensuring that policies and practices align with global
norms. Their role is pivotal in promoting human rights awareness and advocating for
necessary reforms within their respective nations.

Civil Society and Advocacy:

Civil society organizations, including non-governmental organizations (NGOs),
grassroots movements, and community groups, are essential watchdogs in the
implementation process. They engage in advocacy, educate communities about their
rights, and amplify the voices of marginalized groups. These organizations often work
closely with international bodies, sharing information, advocating for policy changes,
and holding governments accountable for their human rights commitments.

Legal Challenges and Cultural Context:

Implementing international human rights standards can face challenges due to legal
complexities and cultural diversities within nations. Legal reforms might be hindered
by existing laws, traditions, or political opposition. Additionally, cultural norms and
social attitudes can affect the interpretation and acceptance of certain rights. Balancing
cultural sensitivity with universal human rights principles requires careful
consideration and education to promote acceptance and understanding.

Socioeconomic Development:
Realizing economic, social, and cultural rights is closely linked to a nation's
socioeconomic development. Poverty eradication, quality education, accessible
healthcare, and social security programs are integral components. Governments need
to allocate resources effectively, prioritize social welfare, and ensure equitable
distribution of wealth and opportunities. Social and economic policies must be designed
to uplift the marginalized, ensuring that no one is left behind.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 31

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Progressive Realization:
The principle of progressive realization recognizes that some rights, particularly
economic, social, and cultural rights, may take time to fully implement due to resource
constraints. States are obligated to make deliberate efforts to achieve these rights
progressively. This involves taking immediate steps within their means while planning
and implementing long-term strategies to reach the ultimate goal. Governments must
show a clear commitment to advancing these rights over time, ensuring continuous
improvement in human rights conditions.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the implementation of the International Bill of Rights demands persistent
commitment, cooperation, and adaptability from nations and their societies. It is a dynamic
process that requires continuous efforts to bridge the gap between international human rights
standards and local realities. While challenges such as legal complexities, cultural diversity,
and socioeconomic disparities persist, the collective endeavour to protect and promote human
rights remains steadfast. The role of national legislation, transparent reporting, vigilant
monitoring, the active involvement of civil society, and recognition of cultural contexts are all
pivotal in this journey. As societies evolve, so too must the strategies for implementing human
rights. Through these concerted efforts, societies can move closer to the ideals enshrined in the
UDHR, ICCPR, and ICESCR, fostering environments where every individual's dignity,
equality, and fundamental freedoms are respected, protected, and fulfilled. Ultimately, the
ongoing pursuit of human rights embodies the shared vision of a more just, equitable, and
rights-respecting world for all.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 32

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

ENFORCEMENT OF THE INTERNATIONAL BILL OF

RIGHTS
The enforcement of human rights, as outlined in international agreements like the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
(ICCPR), and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR),
represents a global commitment to ensuring the dignity, equality, and well-being of all
individuals. These agreements provide a universal framework, setting forth fundamental
principles that every nation is expected to uphold. The process of enforcing these rights
involves intricate mechanisms, combining legal instruments, international cooperation, civil
society engagement, and diplomatic efforts. From ratification to domestic incorporation,
reporting obligations, legal recourse, and advocacy campaigns, a comprehensive approach is
deployed to hold nations accountable for their human rights commitments. This collective
endeavour signifies not only the importance of protecting individual freedoms but also the
shared responsibility of the global community in fostering a world where human rights are not
just ideals but tangible realities for every person, regardless of their background or location.
Here are the key steps taken for its enforcement:

1) Ratification and Incorporation into National Laws:

When a country ratifies international human rights treaties like the UDHR, ICCPR, and
ICESCR, it signifies the nation's commitment to upholding the principles outlined in
these documents. After ratification, many countries incorporate these rights into their
national legal frameworks. This process, often referred to as domestication, involves
aligning domestic laws with the international standards set by these treaties. By doing
so, individuals can invoke these rights in their local courts, allowing legal remedies for
human rights violations at the national level.

2) Reporting and Review Mechanisms:

States parties are obligated to submit regular reports detailing their human rights
progress to the relevant UN treaty bodies. These committees, such as the Human Rights
Committee for the ICCPR and the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
for the ICESCR, assess these reports. Additionally, non-governmental organizations
(NGOs) and civil society groups often submit alternative or shadow reports, offering
independent assessments. The treaty bodies review these documents and provide
recommendations, suggesting ways for countries to strengthen their human rights
protections. This process encourages transparency, facilitates dialogue, and holds
governments accountable for their human rights obligations.

3) Universal Periodic Review (UPR):

The UPR is a unique mechanism under the UN Human Rights Council where all UN
Member States undergo a periodic review of their human rights records. During the
UPR, countries present their achievements and challenges in human rights. Other states
and NGOs provide input, raising concerns and offering recommendations. The UPR
process encourages self-reflection, promotes international cooperation, and leads to
national action plans for improving human rights situations.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 33

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

4) Human Rights Institutions and NGOs:

Many countries establish national human rights institutions (NHRIs) to monitor human
rights within their borders. These institutions act as independent bodies, collecting data,
investigating complaints, and promoting human rights education and awareness. NGOs
also play a vital role, conducting research, documenting violations, advocating for
policy changes, and raising public awareness. Their work often complements the efforts
of international bodies, providing critical insights into on-the-ground human rights
situations.

5) International Courts and Tribunals:

International courts and tribunals provide avenues for individuals, states, and
organizations to seek justice for human rights violations. The International Court of
Justice (ICJ) handles cases between states, while regional human rights courts like the
European Court of Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights
adjudicate cases related to human rights abuses within their respective regions.
Individuals and states can bring cases before these courts, seeking redress for human
rights violations when national systems fail to provide justice.

6) Diplomatic Pressure and Sanctions:

Diplomatic pressure from the international community can compel governments to
improve their human rights practices. This pressure can come in the form of
condemnatory statements, diplomatic dialogues, or sanctions. Diplomatic efforts often
focus on engaging with governments, encouraging reforms, and emphasizing the
importance of human rights in international relations. In severe cases, international
sanctions can be imposed, exerting economic and political pressure to promote
compliance with human rights norms.

7) Public Awareness and Advocacy:

Public awareness and advocacy campaigns are essential in shaping public opinion and
influencing policy decisions. Social movements, media coverage, and grassroots
activism raise awareness about human rights violations, fostering public demand for
change. Advocacy groups and activists work tirelessly to lobby governments, educate
communities, and mobilize public support for human rights causes. By amplifying the
voices of the affected and garnering public support, these efforts create pressure for
governments to respect and protect human rights.

Conclusion:
In the intricate tapestry of human rights enforcement, the dedication of nations, international
organizations, human rights institutions, and civil society stands as a testament to the enduring
pursuit of justice and equality. The process of enforcing the international Bill of Rights, marked
by ratification, reporting, legal recourse, and public advocacy, reflects a shared commitment to
upholding the dignity and rights of all individuals. While challenges persist, the relentless
efforts of individuals and organizations worldwide continue to push the boundaries of progress.
In the face of adversity, the collective resolve to protect human rights remains unwavering. As
societies evolve, the enforcement mechanisms will adapt, ensuring that the principles outlined
in these international agreements not only endure but flourish, creating a world where every
person's rights are respected, protected, and fulfilled.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 34

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

REMEDIES OF INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS

LAW
In the intricate tapestry of global governance, the realm of International Human Rights Law
stands as a beacon of hope and justice. Rooted in the fundamental principle of universal dignity,
this body of law encompasses a vast array of rights and protections, ensuring that every
individual, regardless of nationality, gender, race, or creed, is entitled to basic human dignities.
At the core of this framework lie mechanisms and remedies that not only hold states
accountable for their actions but also provide solace and redress to victims of human rights
violations. From international tribunals to truth commissions, these remedies represent the
collective conscience of humanity, striving to mend the wounds of injustice and pave the way
for a world where human rights are not just ideals but tangible realities. This exploration delves
into the multifaceted nature of remedies in International Human Rights Law, shedding light on
the intricate processes that seek to restore dignity, justice, and equality to those who have
suffered its loss.
Remedies of international human rights law are available which are discussed through the
following points:

1. Individual Complaint Mechanisms

2. State Responsibility and Remedies
3. Collective Remedies
4. Non-Judicial Mechanisms
5. Reparations
6. International Criminal Court (ICC)
7. Advocacy and Awareness
8. Truth Commissions

1) Individual Complaint Mechanisms:

Individuals who believe their human rights have been violated can submit complaints
to international bodies. For instance, the United Nations Human Rights Committee
oversees the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). When a
complaint is found admissible, the Committee investigates the case, issues
recommendations to the concerned state, and monitors the implementation of these
recommendations. Similarly, regional human rights courts, like the European Court of
Human Rights or the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, allow individuals to bring
cases against states for human rights violations. These courts can render judgments and
order reparations to the victims.

2) State Responsibility and Remedies:

States are legally responsible for human rights violations that occur within their
jurisdiction. When a violation is established, states are obligated to provide remedies to

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 35

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

the victims. Remedies may include compensation for material and moral damages,
medical and psychological care, and measures to prevent future violations. States can
be held accountable through national judicial systems or international courts and
tribunals.

3) Collective Remedies:
In cases where a community or a specific group faces systemic human rights violations,
collective remedies are essential. These remedies can include acknowledgment of
historical injustices, public apologies, and affirmative action programs to address
systemic discrimination. State-sponsored educational programs promoting tolerance
and understanding among different groups can also be effective collective remedies.

4) Non-Judicial Mechanisms:
Various international and regional organizations have established non-judicial
mechanisms to address human rights issues. Human rights commissions,
ombudspersons, and special rapporteurs investigate complaints, facilitate dialogue
between parties, and recommend remedies. These mechanisms provide avenues for
resolving disputes without resorting to formal legal proceedings.

5) Reparations:
Reparations aim to restore the dignity and well-being of victims. They can include
financial compensation for lost property or earnings, medical and psychological
support, vocational training, and measures to ensure non-repetition, such as legal
reforms and human rights education programs. Reparations are designed to address
both the material and non-material harms suffered by victims.

6) International Criminal Court (ICC):

The ICC is a permanent international court established to prosecute individuals for the
most serious crimes of international concern, including genocide, crimes against
humanity, and war crimes. When perpetrators are convicted, the ICC can order
reparations to victims, including restitution, compensation, and rehabilitation. The
ICC's decisions contribute to accountability and provide redress to victims of grave
human rights violations.

7) Advocacy and Awareness:

Human rights organizations and activists play a vital role in advocating for remedies.
By raising awareness about human rights violations, they create public pressure on
governments to acknowledge abuses, conduct investigations, and provide remedies to
victims. Advocacy efforts can lead to policy changes, legal reforms, and the
establishment of truth commissions or reparations programs.

8) Truth Commissions:
Truth commissions are temporary, official bodies established to investigate past human
rights violations, especially in transitional societies emerging from conflict or
authoritarian rule. While not focused on individual remedies, truth commissions
provide a platform for victims to share their experiences, document historical injustices,
and promote national reconciliation. Recommendations made by truth commissions can

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 36

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

inform reparations programs and contribute to preventing future human rights

violations.

Conclusion:
In the tapestry of human rights, remedies weave the threads of justice and healing, transforming
abstract ideals into concrete realities. The journey through the landscape of International
Human Rights Law reveals a nuanced and intricate system designed not just to punish
wrongdoers but to uplift the fallen, to heal the wounds of the oppressed, and to ensure that the
echoes of injustice do not drown the voices of the vulnerable. From individual complaints
mechanisms that give voice to the silenced, to collective reparations that acknowledge
historical wrongs, these remedies exemplify the resilience of the human spirit and the collective
determination to create a world where rights are not just spoken of but fiercely protected. As
we navigate the complexities of our global society, these remedies stand as testaments to our
shared commitment to a future where every individual walks in the light of justice, and where
the ideals of equality and dignity are not just lofty aspirations but the very foundation upon
which our societies are built.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 37

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

3. THE ROLE OF UNITED NATIONS IN HUMAN

RIGHTS
The United Nations (UN) plays a pivotal role in promoting and protecting human rights on a
global scale. Established in the aftermath of World War II, the UN sought to prevent the
recurrence of widespread human rights abuses. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights,
adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948, serves as a foundational document outlining
fundamental rights and freedoms for all.
The UN's role in human rights is multifaceted. It monitors and reports on the human rights
situation in member states through bodies like the Human Rights Council. Special Rapporteurs
investigate specific issues, contributing to a nuanced understanding of challenges worldwide.
Furthermore, the UN engages in peacekeeping operations to address conflicts that threaten
human rights. These missions aim to protect vulnerable populations and create conditions for
the realization of human rights.
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on
Economic, Social and Cultural Rights are key treaties overseen by the UN, emphasizing the
indivisibility and interdependence of human rights.
Despite these efforts, the UN faces challenges, including geopolitical tensions and the
limitations of enforcing human rights in sovereign nations. Nevertheless, its ongoing
commitment to fostering a culture of human rights and addressing violations underscores the
organization's essential role in shaping a more just and equitable world.

ROLE OF UNITED NATIONS IS FORMULATING

HUMAN RIGHTS
Human Rights, the bedrock of a just and equitable world, find their profound articulation in the
efforts of the United Nations (UN). At the heart of this global endeavour lies the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), a beacon forged in the aftermath of World War II.
Crafted with diverse inputs, it symbolizes the collaborative spirit essential for a shared
commitment to safeguarding the inherent dignity of every individual. As we embark on an
exploration of the UN's role in shaping human rights, we delve into treaties, councils, education
initiatives, and peacekeeping missions that form a comprehensive framework for the protection
and promotion of fundamental freedoms on a global scale.
The United Nations (UN) plays a crucial role in formulating human rights standards and
principles, reflecting a collective global commitment to the protection and promotion of
fundamental freedoms. The UN's involvement in shaping human rights is evident in several
key aspects:

1. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR):

The UDHR is a foundational document in the realm of human rights. Adopted by the
UN General Assembly in 1948, it encompasses a comprehensive list of civil, political,
economic, social, and cultural rights that should be universally protected. Drafted with
input from representatives of different legal and cultural backgrounds, the UDHR is a

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 38

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

testament to the collaborative effort to establish a common standard for human rights
globally.

2. International Treaties and Conventions:

The UN, through its various bodies and committees, facilitates the development and
adoption of international treaties and conventions that build upon the principles
outlined in the UDHR. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
(ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
(ICESCR) are examples of legally binding treaties that translate human rights principles
into specific obligations for states parties.

3. Human Rights Council and Special Procedures:

The Human Rights Council, a principal organ of the UN, monitors and addresses human
rights issues globally. It conducts the Universal Periodic Review (UPR), where the
human rights records of all UN member states are examined. The council also
establishes Special Rapporteurs and other special procedures to investigate and report
on specific human rights concerns, providing expert insights and recommendations.

4. Promotion of Human Rights Education:

The UN recognizes the importance of education in fostering a culture of human rights.
Initiatives such as the World Programme for Human Rights Education aim to integrate
human rights principles into educational curricula at all levels. By promoting awareness
and understanding, the UN seeks to empower individuals to be advocates for human
rights in their communities.

5. Peacekeeping and Conflict Resolution:

In conflict zones, the UN engages in peacekeeping missions with a mandate to protect
civilians and uphold human rights. These missions contribute to the prevention and
resolution of conflicts, addressing the root causes of human rights violations. They
often involve monitoring and reporting on human rights abuses, supporting the rule of
law, and facilitating the delivery of humanitarian aid.

6. Human Rights Declarations and Guidelines:

The UN regularly issues declarations and guidelines to address emerging human rights
issues or specific vulnerable groups. For instance, the Declaration on the Rights of
Indigenous Peoples establishes the rights of indigenous communities, and the Guiding
Principles on Business and Human Rights provide a framework for preventing and
addressing human rights abuses related to business activities.

7. Review Mechanisms:
The UN employs various mechanisms to review and address human rights situations in
member states. The Universal Periodic Review (UPR) is a unique process where each
country's human rights record is scrutinized by other UN member states. This peer-
review mechanism fosters transparency, accountability, and dialogue on human rights
issues.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 39

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Closing Remarks:
In the mosaic of human rights, the United Nations stands as a sentinel, tirelessly working
towards a world where justice, dignity, and equality prevail. From the drafting of the UDHR
to the establishment of review mechanisms and special procedures, the UN's commitment to
human rights is woven into the fabric of international cooperation. Challenges persist, yet the
UN's role in formulating and upholding human rights remains indispensable. As we reflect on
this monumental task, let us be reminded that the pursuit of human rights is not merely a legal
obligation but a shared moral imperative, echoing through the halls of the United Nations as a
testament to our collective aspirations for a more humane and just world.



By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 40

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

STEPS BY UNITED NATIONS FOR

INTERPRETATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
The United Nations (UN), in its tireless pursuit of fostering a world characterized by justice,
equality, and the inherent dignity of all individuals, has undertaken multifaceted steps for the
interpretation of human rights. The journey begins with the landmark Universal Declaration of
Human Rights (UDHR) of 1948, a testament to the collaborative spirit that envisions a common
standard for rights universally recognized. As we navigate through the subsequent development
of international treaties, the establishment of the Human Rights Council and its special
procedures, the innovative Universal Periodic Review, and the promotion of human rights
education, we witness a comprehensive framework taking shape. The UN, recognizing the
dynamic nature of human rights, has extended its efforts to regional instruments, guiding
declarations, and support for international courts, recognizing the diverse contexts in which
rights are interpreted and applied. These steps collectively affirm the UN's commitment to
shaping a global ethos where human rights stand as pillars of our shared humanity.
The United Nations (UN) has taken several steps to facilitate the interpretation and
implementation of human rights. These steps include:

1. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR)

2. International Treaties and Conventions
3. Human Rights Council and Special Procedures
4. Universal Periodic Review (UPR)
5. Human Rights Education and Awareness
6. Regional Human Rights Instruments
7. Guiding Declarations and Documents
8. Courts and Tribunals

1) Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR):

The UDHR, adopted in 1948, serves as a milestone in the interpretation of human rights.
Drafted with global input, it declares a common standard of rights for all people.
Although not legally binding, the UDHR has immense moral and political significance,
laying the foundation for subsequent treaties and influencing the development of
international human rights law.

2) International Treaties and Conventions:

Building on the UDHR, the UN has facilitated the creation of legally binding
international treaties and conventions. The International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights (ICESCR) are key examples. These treaties provide a more detailed and
specific interpretation of rights, establishing legal obligations for states parties.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 41

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

3) Human Rights Council and Special Procedures:

The Human Rights Council, a UN body, plays a vital role in interpreting and addressing
human rights issues. It establishes special procedures, including Special Rapporteurs
and working groups, who investigate and report on specific thematic or country-specific
human rights concerns. Their reports contribute to nuanced interpretations and
recommendations.

4) Universal Periodic Review (UPR):

The UPR is a unique mechanism where each UN member state undergoes a periodic
review of its human rights record by other member states. This peer-review process
enhances transparency, facilitates dialogue, and contributes to the interpretation of
human rights within specific national contexts.

5) Human Rights Education and Awareness:

Recognizing the importance of education, the UN promotes human rights education
globally. Initiatives such as the World Programme for Human Rights Education aim to
integrate human rights principles into educational curricula at all levels. By raising
awareness and understanding, the UN empowers individuals to interpret and advocate
for human rights in diverse cultural contexts.

6) Regional Human Rights Instruments:

In addition to global treaties, the UN supports the development of regional human rights
instruments. For example, the European Convention on Human Rights and the African
Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights contribute to the interpretation of human rights
within specific regional contexts, recognizing the diversity of legal systems and cultural
perspectives.

7) Guiding Declarations and Documents:

The UN issues declarations and guidelines on specific human rights issues. These
documents provide guidance on the interpretation and application of rights in specific
contexts. For instance, the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples offers a
framework for understanding and respecting the rights of indigenous communities.

8) Courts and Tribunals:

The UN supports international and regional courts and tribunals that play a crucial role
in interpreting and enforcing human rights norms. The International Court of Justice
(ICJ) handles cases between states, while the International Criminal Court (ICC)
focuses on prosecuting individuals for the most serious crimes, contributing to the
development of human rights jurisprudence.
These steps collectively reflect the UN's comprehensive approach to interpreting and
advancing human rights, considering the complexities of diverse legal systems, cultural
backgrounds, and evolving global challenges.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the United Nations has played a pivotal role in the interpretation and protection
of human rights through a series of strategic and interconnected steps. From the foundational
UDHR to legally binding international treaties, the UN has provided a robust framework for
understanding and upholding human rights globally. The establishment of the Human Rights

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 42

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Council and its special procedures, coupled with innovative mechanisms like the Universal
Periodic Review, exemplifies the commitment to continuous scrutiny and improvement. By
promoting education, addressing regional nuances through instruments, and supporting
international courts, the UN has sought to make human rights a lived reality. Despite the
challenges, these efforts underscore the enduring commitment of the international community
to championing human rights as the cornerstone of a more just and humane world.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 43

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

MONITORING OF HUMAN RIGHTRS BY UNITED

NATIONS
In the tapestry of global governance, the United Nations (UN) stands as an unwavering beacon,
committed to the protection and promotion of human rights across borders. Its efforts in
monitoring human rights constitute a complex and multifaceted framework designed to
scrutinize, address, and rectify violations on the international stage. The cornerstone of this
endeavor lies in mechanisms such as the Universal Periodic Review (UPR), where member
states undergo a comprehensive evaluation of their human rights records. The Human Rights
Council, special rapporteurs, and treaty monitoring bodies contribute to nuanced assessments,
offering recommendations that resonate with the UN's foundational principles of equality,
justice, and dignity. As we navigate through the detailed efforts, from peacekeeping missions
to regional collaborations and early warning systems, we witness the UN's dedication to
ensuring that the promise of human rights is not merely an aspiration but a lived reality for
individuals across diverse contexts and cultures.
The United Nations (UN) has implemented various efforts to monitor and safeguard human
rights globally. These initiatives are crucial for assessing the adherence to international
standards and holding nations accountable for their human rights practices. The key efforts
include:

1. Universal Periodic Review (UPR)

2. Human Rights Council (HRC)
3. Special Rapporteurs and Working Groups
4. Treaty Monitoring Bodies
5. International Criminal Court (ICC)
6. Peacekeeping Missions
7. Human Rights Education
8. Regional Human Rights Mechanisms
9. Early Warning Systems

1) Universal Periodic Review (UPR):

The UPR is a distinctive mechanism conducted by the Human Rights Council,
involving a periodic review of the human rights records of all UN member states.
During these reviews, states present their human rights achievements and challenges,
while other member states provide recommendations. This peer-review process
encourages transparency and constructive dialogue, facilitating a comprehensive
assessment of the human rights situation in each country.

2) Human Rights Council (HRC):

The Human Rights Council, a principal UN body, serves as a focal point for global
human rights efforts. It convenes regular sessions to address emerging human rights

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 44

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

concerns, establishes special procedures like rapporteurs and working groups to

investigate specific issues, and facilitates discussions on key thematic areas. The HRC's
resolutions contribute to the development of international norms and guide human
rights discourse.

3) Special Rapporteurs and Working Groups:

The UN appoints independent experts known as Special Rapporteurs to investigate and
report on specific human rights issues. Working groups are established to address
thematic concerns. These experts engage in fact-finding missions, receive submissions
from stakeholders, and provide nuanced assessments and recommendations to address
human rights challenges.

4) Treaty Monitoring Bodies:

Various UN treaty bodies oversee the implementation of specific human rights treaties.
For instance, the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights or the Committee
against Torture reviews states parties' periodic reports, engages in constructive
dialogues, and issues recommendations to ensure compliance with treaty obligations.
These bodies contribute to the refinement and enforcement of human rights standards.

5) International Criminal Court (ICC):

The ICC, supported by the UN, is a judicial body tasked with prosecuting individuals
for the most serious international crimes. These crimes include genocide, crimes against
humanity, war crimes, and the crime of aggression. By holding perpetrators
accountable, the ICC plays a vital role in ensuring justice and deterring future human
rights violations.

6) Peacekeeping Missions:
UN peacekeeping missions, deployed to conflict zones, serve a dual purpose of
maintaining peace and monitoring human rights. Monitoring and reporting on human
rights abuses are integral components of these missions. Peacekeepers work to protect
civilians, prevent conflict escalation, and contribute to the restoration of stability while
upholding human rights principles.

7) Human Rights Education:

Recognizing the transformative power of education, the UN emphasizes human rights
education as a means to raise awareness, foster understanding, and promote a culture
of respect for human rights. Educational programs empower individuals to become
advocates, ensuring that human rights principles are ingrained in communities and
societies.

8) Regional Human Rights Mechanisms:

The UN collaborates with regional human rights mechanisms, such as the Inter-
American Court of Human Rights or the African Commission on Human and Peoples'
Rights. These bodies play a crucial role in monitoring and addressing human rights
issues within their respective regions, tailoring responses to regional contexts and
challenges.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 45

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

9) Early Warning Systems:

The UN employs early warning systems to proactively identify and respond to potential
human rights crises. By monitoring emerging situations and assessing risk factors, the
UN aims to prevent the escalation of conflicts and human rights abuses. Timely
intervention can mitigate the impact on vulnerable populations and address root causes.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the United Nations' tireless efforts in monitoring human rights form a dynamic
and comprehensive approach to confronting the challenges that threaten the dignity and well-
being of individuals worldwide. The intricate web of mechanisms, from the UPR fostering
transparency to the ICC holding perpetrators accountable, underscores the UN's commitment
to the fundamental tenets of human rights. Through regional collaborations, educational
initiatives, and proactive early warning systems, the UN adapts to the evolving landscape of
global affairs, striving to prevent, address, and remedy human rights abuses. As we reflect on
these detailed endeavours, it becomes apparent that the UN's role in monitoring human rights
is not merely a bureaucratic exercise but a profound commitment to weaving a world where
the tapestry of justice, equality, and respect encompasses every corner of the globe.



By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 46

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

4. WOMEN’S RIGHTS
The importance of women's rights resonates as a fundamental pillar in the quest for a just and
equitable society. Engrained within the very fabric of human rights, the empowerment and
protection of women's rights signify not only a moral imperative but a strategic investment in
the well-being and progress of societies worldwide. Recognizing and upholding women's rights
is pivotal for achieving gender equality, a goal enshrined in numerous international agreements
and conventions. These rights encompass a spectrum of dimensions, from the right to education
and healthcare to the right to participate in political processes and make decisions about one's
own body. The impact of advancing women's rights extends beyond the individual, influencing
families, communities, and economies. It is an acknowledgment that every woman, irrespective
of background or circumstance, possesses inherent dignity and agency.
In a world where gender disparities persist, the importance of women's rights becomes even
more pronounced. Gender-based violence, unequal access to education and employment
opportunities, and discriminatory legal frameworks underscore the urgency of addressing these
systemic issues. Elevating women's rights is not merely an act of rectifying historical injustices
but a strategic imperative for sustainable development. When women are empowered, societies
experience multifaceted benefits, including enhanced economic productivity, improved health
outcomes, and increased social cohesion. The acknowledgment of women's rights as human
rights is not a plea for preferential treatment; rather, it is a call for dismantling barriers that
hinder the full realization of potential.
Moreover, recognizing the importance of women's rights is acknowledging that women are
architects of change and progress. When women are granted equal opportunities, societies can
tap into a wealth of diverse perspectives and talents. The exclusion or marginalization of
women hampers the collective journey toward innovation, resilience, and social harmony. As
we navigate the complexities of the 21st century, embracing and championing women's rights
is not just a matter of morality; it is a strategic imperative for creating societies that are fair,
dynamic, and sustainable. In essence, the importance of women's rights transcends rhetoric; it
is a commitment to building a world where every woman is free to realize her aspirations and
contribute meaningfully to the tapestry of human progress.

WOMEN’S RIGHTS IN INTERNATIONAL HUMAN

RIGHTS REGIME
The recognition and protection of women's rights within the international human rights regime
are critical components of the broader commitment to equality and dignity for all individuals.
The international human rights framework, comprising treaties, conventions, and declarations,
underscores the significance of women's rights as an integral part of universal human rights.
Several key aspects illuminate the discussion of women's rights within this framework:

1) Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR):

The UDHR, adopted in 1948, laid the groundwork for the international human rights
framework. Article 2 of the UDHR explicitly prohibits discrimination based on gender,
recognizing the equal rights and freedoms of men and women. This foundational

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 47

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

document set a precedent for subsequent human rights instruments and established
gender equality as a core principle of human rights.

2) International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
(ICESCR):
The ICCPR (1966) and ICESCR (1966) are twin covenants that articulate a broad range
of civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights. Both treaties emphasize the
principle of non-discrimination, including gender equality. They affirm women's rights
to political participation, education, work, and healthcare, recognizing these as integral
components of human dignity.

3) Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination

Against Women (CEDAW):
Adopted in 1979, CEDAW is a landmark treaty specifically addressing discrimination
against women. It comprehensively outlines women's rights in political, economic,
social, and cultural spheres. CEDAW emphasizes the need to eliminate stereotypes and
prejudices and calls for substantive equality. It establishes the principle of substantive
equality, recognizing that achieving gender equality requires addressing both formal
and substantive aspects of discrimination.

4) Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action:

The Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action emerged from the Fourth World
Conference on Women in 1995. This document is a comprehensive roadmap for
advancing women's rights. It addresses 12 critical areas of concern, including women
in power and decision-making, education, healthcare, and violence against women. The
Beijing Platform for Action emphasizes the intersectionality of gender with other forms
of discrimination, recognizing that women experience discrimination differently based
on factors such as race, class, and ethnicity.

5) Security Council Resolutions on Women, Peace, and Security:

The UN Security Council has adopted several resolutions addressing the impact of
armed conflict on women. Resolution 1325, adopted in 2000, emphasizes the
importance of women's participation in conflict resolution, peacebuilding, and
decision-making. Subsequent resolutions expand on these themes and highlight the
specific challenges faced by women in conflict zones, including sexual violence as a
tactic of war.

6) International Criminal Court (ICC):

The ICC, established in 2002, has jurisdiction over serious international crimes,
including gender-based crimes. The Rome Statute, the founding treaty of the ICC,
explicitly defines and prosecutes crimes such as rape, sexual slavery, enforced
prostitution, and forced pregnancy as war crimes and crimes against humanity. The
ICC's recognition of gender-based crimes is a significant step towards combating
impunity for such offenses.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 48

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

7) General Recommendations and Reports:

Treaty bodies, such as the CEDAW Committee, issue general recommendations and
reports to interpret and clarify the obligations of states parties. These documents
provide guidance on specific issues, including violence against women, trafficking, and
women's participation in public life. General recommendations contribute to the
evolving interpretation of international human rights law related to women's rights.
While considerable progress has been made in recognizing women's rights within the
international human rights regime, challenges persist. Implementation gaps, cultural barriers,
and persistent gender stereotypes remain obstacles to the full realization of women's rights.
Efforts to advance women's rights internationally continue through advocacy, awareness, and
the enforcement of existing legal frameworks. The evolving landscape reflects an ongoing
commitment to creating a world where women's rights are universally acknowledged,
protected, and fully realized.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the international human rights regime, marked by instruments such as the
UDHR, ICCPR, ICESCR, CEDAW, and the Beijing Declaration, reflects a collective
commitment to recognizing and safeguarding women's rights as inherent to human rights. The
journey has been characterized by significant strides, acknowledging the multifaceted
challenges faced by women and striving to address them comprehensively. From the CEDAW's
insistence on substantive equality to the Security Council's recognition of women's roles in
peace and security, the international community has embraced a holistic approach. The ICC's
explicit prosecution of gender-based crimes further exemplifies the commitment to combating
impunity. Nevertheless, challenges persist, requiring ongoing efforts to bridge implementation
gaps, challenge deep-rooted stereotypes, and ensure the meaningful inclusion of women in
decision-making processes. As we navigate the complex terrain of the 21st century, the
importance of women's rights within the international human rights framework serves as a
beacon, illuminating the path toward a world where gender equality is not merely an aspiration
but a tangible reality for all. The journey continues, propelled by the enduring belief that the
empowerment of women is essential for the realization of the universal ideals encapsulated in
the broader tapestry of human rights.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 49

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

CONVENTION ON THE ELIMINATION OF ALL

FORMS OF DISCRIMINATION AGAINST WOMEN
(CEDAW)
The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW)
is a landmark international treaty that specifically addresses gender-based discrimination and
inequality. Adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1979, CEDAW entered into
force on September 3, 1981.
It is often referred to as the
"International Bill Of Rights For Women"
It serves as a comprehensive legal framework to eliminate discrimination against women in
both public and private spheres.

KEY FEATURES OF CEDAW:

Here are key features of CEDAW.

i. Definition of Discrimination (Article 1):

CEDAW's Article 1 provides a comprehensive definition of discrimination against
women. It encompasses any distinction, exclusion, or restriction based on sex that
impairs or nullifies the recognition, enjoyment, or exercise by women of their human
rights and fundamental freedoms. This definition is broad, covering discrimination in
political, economic, social, cultural, civil, or any other field.

ii. Scope and Application:

CEDAW applies to all aspects of public and private life. It seeks to eliminate
discrimination against women in various spheres, including political participation,
employment, education, healthcare, and family relations. The Convention
acknowledges that discrimination against women is not limited to the actions of the
state but can also occur in private spaces and relationships.

iii. Principle of Substantive Equality (Article 2):

Article 2 of CEDAW underscores the principle of substantive equality. It recognizes
that achieving equality between men and women requires addressing both formal and
substantive aspects of discrimination. This includes modifying social and cultural
patterns that perpetuate gender stereotypes and prejudices, aiming for a transformation
of societal attitudes and structures.

iv. State Obligations (Articles 2-4):

States parties to CEDAW commit to taking all appropriate measures to eliminate
discrimination against women. This involves adopting legislative, administrative, and
other measures to ensure women's rights. States are also obligated to report regularly to
the CEDAW Committee on their progress in implementing the Convention. The
Committee reviews these reports and offers recommendations.

v. Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women:

The CEDAW Committee is composed of experts elected by states parties. It monitors
the implementation of the Convention by reviewing periodic reports submitted by states

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 50

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

parties. The Committee engages in a constructive dialogue with states, providing

recommendations to address challenges and advance women's rights. It plays a vital
role in interpreting the Convention and guiding its implementation.

vi. Optional Protocol:

The Optional Protocol to CEDAW, adopted in 1999, provides additional mechanisms
for the enforcement of the Convention. It allows individuals or groups to submit
complaints (communications) to the CEDAW Committee after exhausting national
remedies. The Protocol also empowers the Committee to conduct inquiries into grave
or systematic violations of women's rights, enhancing the accountability of states
parties.

vii. Areas Addressed by CEDAW:

CEDAW addresses a wide range of areas crucial to women's rights. These include
education, employment, healthcare, marriage and family relations, political
participation, and protection against gender-based violence. The Convention
emphasizes the right of women to access family planning services and to decide freely
and responsibly on the number and spacing of their children.

viii. International Cooperation (Article 16):

Article 16 of CEDAW recognizes the importance of international cooperation in
achieving its objectives. States parties commit to taking measures to eliminate
discrimination against women in all matters relating to marriage and family relations.
This includes recognizing the equal rights and responsibilities of spouses and
promoting the shared responsibilities of both spouses in the upbringing of children.
CEDAW, as a comprehensive and detailed international treaty, sets forth a robust framework
for addressing discrimination against women and promoting gender equality. Its principles and
provisions continue to guide efforts globally to advance the rights of women and eliminate
gender-based discrimination.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against
Women remains an enduring testament to the international community's commitment to
fostering a world where gender-based discrimination is not merely condemned but actively
eliminated. CEDAW, with its expansive scope, obligates states to take affirmative measures,
fostering substantive equality and dismantling deeply ingrained societal prejudices. The
vigilant oversight of the CEDAW Committee and the innovative Optional Protocol further
reinforce the Convention's role in holding nations accountable. As we reflect on the
achievements and challenges in the realm of women's rights, CEDAW stands as a beacon,
guiding the ongoing journey toward a future where every woman enjoys equal opportunities,
rights, and freedoms. The spirit of CEDAW echoes in the collective efforts to transform
societies and institutions, paving the way for a more just and equitable world for women
everywhere.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 51

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

5. MINORITY RIGHTS
In the mosaic of global societies, the importance of minority rights emerges as a fundamental
cornerstone in the quest for inclusive and equitable communities. Minorities, whether defined
by ethnicity, religion, language, or cultural identity, constitute integral threads within the rich
fabric of human diversity. Acknowledging and safeguarding minority rights is not merely a
matter of ethical imperative but a strategic necessity for fostering social cohesion, harmony,
and sustainable development. These rights encapsulate the principle that every individual,
regardless of their belonging to a numerical minority, possesses inalienable human rights that
must be protected and respected. The dynamics of globalization and interconnectedness
underscore the significance of minority rights on the world stage. In a landscape marked by
pluralism, respecting and upholding minority rights becomes a litmus test for the maturity and
fairness of any society or nation. Minority rights encompass a spectrum of dimensions, from
the right to practice one's culture and religion to the right to participate fully in civic and
political life. In this era of heightened awareness and advocacy for human rights, the protection
of minority rights becomes not only a moral imperative but also a barometer for measuring the
health and inclusivity of a society. As we navigate the complexities of the 21st century,
recognizing and valuing minority rights stands not only as a testament to our commitment to
justice but also as a pragmatic investment in building societies that thrive on the richness of
their diversity. It is an acknowledgment that the true strength of humanity lies in its ability to
embrace and celebrate differences, fostering a global community where every voice is heard,
and every identity is respected.

MINORITY RIGHTS IN INTERNATIONAL HUMAN

RIGHTS SYSTEM
Minority rights in the international human rights system are an essential component of efforts
to safeguard the rights and dignity of individuals belonging to minority groups. The
international community, through various treaties, conventions, and declarations, has
established a framework that emphasizes the protection of minority rights. Here's a detailed
discussion on minority rights within the international human rights system:

1) Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR):

The UDHR, adopted in 1948, laid the groundwork for international human rights
standards. While not explicitly addressing minority rights, its principles of equality and
non-discrimination form the bedrock of subsequent instruments. It affirms the inherent
dignity of all individuals, contributing to the overarching framework that protects the
rights of minority groups.

2) International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
(ICESCR):
Both covenants, established in 1966, set forth the principles of non-discrimination.
They recognize the right of all individuals to enjoy civil, political, economic, social,
and cultural rights without distinction. This broad coverage explicitly includes the
protection of minority groups from discrimination based on various grounds.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 52

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

3) Declaration on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic,

Religious and Linguistic Minorities:
Enacted in 1992, this declaration is a landmark document explicitly addressing minority
rights. It outlines the rights of individuals belonging to minorities to maintain and
develop their distinct identities. It emphasizes the protection of their cultural, religious,
and linguistic heritage, marking a significant step in recognizing and safeguarding
minority rights on a global scale.

4) European Framework Convention for the Protection of National

Minorities:
Adopted in 1995, this regional treaty by the Council of Europe focuses on the protection
of national minorities. It provides a comprehensive framework for the promotion and
protection of minority rights, covering areas such as language, education, and
participation in public life. The Convention serves as a model for regional approaches
to minority rights.

5) African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights:

The African Charter, adopted in 1981, recognizes the rights of individuals and groups
to equality, dignity, and non-discrimination. While not exclusively focusing on
minority rights, it acknowledges the importance of protecting the rights of ethnic,
religious, and linguistic minorities within the African context.

6) United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples:

Although primarily addressing indigenous rights, this 2007 declaration underscores
issues often faced by minority groups. It recognizes the right to maintain distinct
political, legal, economic, social, and cultural institutions. The declaration emphasizes
the importance of protecting minority rights within the broader context of indigenous
rights.

7) Case Law of Human Rights Bodies:

Human rights bodies, such as the Human Rights Committee and regional courts like the
European Court of Human Rights, have played a crucial role in interpreting and
applying minority rights. Their decisions contribute to the development of norms and
legal principles that protect minorities from discrimination and human rights abuses.

8) Protection from Genocide and Ethnocide:

The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide,
established in 1948, recognizes acts intending to destroy national, ethnic, racial, or
religious groups as genocide. This provides a critical legal framework for protecting
minority groups from acts that could lead to their destruction, demonstrating the
international community's commitment to preventing atrocities against minorities.

9) Universal Periodic Review (UPR):

The UPR process, initiated by the UN Human Rights Council in 2006, evaluates states'
human rights records. It serves as a platform for states to discuss and make
recommendations on various human rights issues, including the protection of minority
rights. The UPR contributes to a collaborative international effort to monitor and
improve the human rights situation, including the rights of minority groups.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 53

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the recognition and protection of minority rights within the international human
rights system signify a collective commitment to fostering a world where diversity is not only
acknowledged but celebrated. The various instruments and declarations, from the Declaration
on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities
to regional frameworks like the European Framework Convention, establish a comprehensive
foundation for safeguarding the rights and dignity of individuals in minority groups. Yet, as
the global community strives for inclusivity, challenges persist, demanding ongoing efforts to
bridge implementation gaps and promote a culture of respect and understanding. The
importance of minority rights transcends legal frameworks; it is a reflection of our shared
humanity, acknowledging that the richness of our collective experience is woven from the
threads of diverse cultures, languages, and identities. As we navigate the complexities of the
21st century, nurturing an environment where minority rights are not only protected but
embraced is essential for the realization of the universal ideals encapsulated in the broader
tapestry of human rights. The journey toward a more inclusive and equitable world requires a
continuous commitment to upholding minority rights as an integral part of the broader struggle
for human rights and social justice.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 54

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

6. HUMAN RIGHTS AS FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS IN

PAKISTAN’S LEGAL SYSTEM
In the context of Pakistan, the integration of human rights into the legal fabric is primarily
encapsulated within the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. This foundational document establishes
the framework for the protection and promotion of fundamental rights, reflecting the nation's
commitment to upholding universal principles of human rights. The Constitution serves as a
living document that not only delineates the rights of individuals but also underscores the
importance of human dignity, equality, and justice within the legal system. By examining key
provisions of the Constitution, we can unravel the intricate tapestry that interweaves human
rights as fundamental rights in Pakistan's legal landscape.

Constitutional Recognition of Human Rights:

The Constitution of Pakistan explicitly recognizes human rights as fundamental rights in
several provisions. Notably, Part II of the Constitution, titled "Fundamental Rights," articulates
a comprehensive range of rights that are inherent to all individuals, regardless of gender, race,
religion, or social status. These rights encompass civil liberties, such as the right to life, liberty,
and security of person (Article 9), the right to freedom of speech and expression (Article 19),
and the right to privacy (Article 14). Additionally, the Constitution safeguards social and
economic rights, including the right to education (Article 25A) and the right to a fair trial
(Article 10). The constitutional recognition of these rights establishes a robust foundation for
the protection of human dignity and individual freedoms within Pakistan's legal system.

Islamic Principles and Human Rights:

Pakistan's legal system, as outlined in the Constitution, operates within the framework of
Islamic principles. Article 227 of the Constitution mandates that all laws shall conform to the
injunctions of Islam as laid down in the Holy Quran and Sunnah. Importantly, this alignment
with Islamic principles is not antithetical to human rights; rather, it is envisioned to operate in
harmony with universal human rights norms. The Constitution, while recognizing Islam as the
state religion, explicitly protects the rights of religious minorities (Article 20) and ensures
freedom of religion and conscience (Article 22), highlighting a commitment to pluralism and
the protection of diverse beliefs.

Enforcement Mechanisms and Judicial Review:

The enforcement of human rights in Pakistan is fortified by mechanisms that empower
individuals to seek remedies for violations. Article 199 of the Constitution grants the High
Courts and the Supreme Court the power of judicial review to ensure the enforcement of
fundamental rights. The superior courts have played a pivotal role in adjudicating cases related
to human rights violations, providing a legal forum for citizens to challenge actions inconsistent
with constitutional guarantees. Landmark decisions by the judiciary have strengthened the
protection of human rights, setting precedents that resonate in subsequent legal discourse.

Challenges and Evolving Dynamics:

While Pakistan's Constitution enshrines an array of fundamental rights, challenges persist in
their effective implementation. Issues such as impunity, discrimination, and societal norms that
may run counter to human rights principles pose ongoing challenges. Furthermore, the evolving

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 55

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

dynamics of societal needs and global developments necessitate continuous efforts to ensure
that legal frameworks remain responsive and adaptive to emerging human rights concerns.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, Pakistan's legal system, as articulated in the Constitution of 1973, recognizes
human rights as fundamental rights. This constitutional commitment establishes a robust
framework that safeguards the dignity and freedoms of individuals. The incorporation of
Islamic principles, alongside a commitment to pluralism, reflects a nuanced approach that seeks
to harmonize cultural and religious values with universal human rights norms. The judicial
review mechanisms further reinforce the supremacy of fundamental rights, providing a legal
recourse for individuals. However, the journey towards a more just and rights-respecting
society is dynamic, requiring continuous adaptation to address emerging challenges and ensure
the effective enforcement of human rights in Pakistan.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 56

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

HUMAN RIGHTS IN CONSTITUTION OF PAKISTAN

1973
The Constitution of Pakistan 1973 stands as a testament to the nation's commitment to the
protection and promotion of human rights. Encompassing a diverse range of provisions, the
constitution embeds principles that safeguard the dignity, equality, and fundamental freedoms
of its citizens. This discussion delves into key aspects of the constitution, unravelling the
intricacies of how human rights are enshrined and protected within its framework.
We study about human rights in Pakistan’s legal system through the following points:
1. Preamble and Objective Resolution
2. Fundamental Rights (Part II)
3. Right to Dignity (Article 14 and 15)
4. Freedom of Religion (Articles 20-22)
5. Right to Fair Trial (Article 10)
6. Economic and Social Rights (Articles 37-38)
7. Enforcement Mechanism (Article 199)
8. Islamic Provisions and Human Rights Harmony (Article 227)

1) Preamble and Objective Resolution:

The Preamble of the Constitution encapsulates the aspirations of a democratic and just
society. It declares the intention to secure for citizens "equality of status, of opportunity,
and before the law." The Objective Resolution, an integral part of the Preamble,
reinforces principles of democracy, freedom, and social justice. Although not an
exhaustive enumeration of rights, these foundational elements set the moral compass
for human rights protection in Pakistan.

2) Fundamental Rights (Part II):

Part II of the Constitution, titled "Fundamental Rights," is a comprehensive section
specifying the rights and liberties of individuals. Articles 8 to 28 guarantee civil
liberties, including the right to life (Article 9), freedom of speech and expression
(Article 19), and the right to privacy (Article 14). Article 25 ensures equality before the
law, and Article 25-A recognizes the right to education as fundamental. These
provisions collectively create a robust foundation for human rights protection.

3) Right to Dignity (Article 14 and 15):

Article 14 explicitly prohibits the torture of any person in custody, affirming the right
to dignity and humane treatment. Article 15 safeguards personal liberty, reinforcing the
principle that no person shall be deprived of life or liberty except in accordance with
the law. These provisions underscore the constitutional commitment to protecting the
inherent dignity of individuals.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 57

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

4) Freedom of Religion (Articles 20-22):

Articles 20 to 22 guarantee the freedom of religion, recognizing and safeguarding
diverse religious beliefs. Article 20 ensures freedom to profess religion and to manage
religious institutions. Article 21 safeguards the rights of minorities to freely profess and
practice their religion, while Article 22 reinforces the right to educational institutions
that do not impart religious instruction against the conscience of minorities. These
provisions exemplify the commitment to religious freedom and diversity.

5) Right to Fair Trial (Article 10):

Article 10 ensures safeguards for arrest and detention, protecting individuals from
arbitrary deprivation of liberty. It guarantees the right to be informed of the grounds for
arrest, the right to legal representation, and the right to be produced before a magistrate
within 24 hours. This provision ensures that individuals have access to a fair trial and
due process of law.

6) Economic and Social Rights (Articles 37-38):

Articles 37 and 38 articulate principles of policy aimed at ensuring economic and social
justice. While not strictly enforceable as fundamental rights, these principles guide the
state in endeavors such as the provision of social and economic well-being, ensuring
the rights of workers, and preventing child labor. They reflect a commitment to socio-
economic rights and welfare.

7) Enforcement Mechanism (Article 199):

Article 199 empowers the High Courts and the Supreme Court with the jurisdiction of
judicial review for the enforcement of fundamental rights. This provision serves as a
crucial mechanism for citizens to seek remedies in cases of rights violations, ensuring
that the judiciary acts as a safeguard against arbitrary actions and human rights abuses.

8) Islamic Provisions and Human Rights Harmony (Article 227):

Article 227 emphasizes the conformity of laws to Islamic principles while explicitly
stating that no law shall be repugnant to fundamental rights. This demonstrates an effort
to harmonize Islamic principles with universal human rights standards, ensuring that
the legal system operates in tandem with the protection of fundamental freedoms.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 intricately weaves human rights into its fabric,
establishing a comprehensive framework for the protection and promotion of fundamental
freedoms. From civil liberties to socio-economic principles, the constitution reflects a
commitment to the inherent dignity and equality of all citizens. The enforcement mechanisms,
coupled with a nuanced approach to harmonizing Islamic principles with human rights,
underscore the constitutional journey towards creating a just, democratic, and rights-respecting
society in Pakistan.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 58

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

REMEDIES AVAILABLE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS

UNDER PAKISTAN’S CONSTITUTION 1973
Within the constitutional framework of Pakistan, avenues for seeking redress and upholding
justice are encapsulated through specific provisions that empower the judiciary to intervene in
matters of public importance and individual rights. Two such significant provisions are Article
199 and Article 184(3) of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. These articles furnish distinct
mechanisms through which aggrieved parties can seek remedies for violations of fundamental
rights, ensuring that the principles enshrined in the constitution are not mere lofty ideals but
actionable rights. Article 199 confers upon the High Courts the authority to issue writs,
providing a powerful tool for individuals to challenge actions or decisions infringing upon their
rights. On the other hand, Article 184(3) grants extraordinary jurisdiction to the Supreme Court,
allowing it to take suo-motu notice of matters of public importance relating to the enforcement
of fundamental rights. Together, these constitutional provisions serve as pillars for the
protection and enforcement of fundamental rights in Pakistan's legal landscape.

REMEDIES UNDER ARTICLE 199 OF THE

CONSTITUTION OF PAKISTAN 1973
Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan provides a comprehensive framework for the High
Courts to issue writs for the enforcement of fundamental rights. These writs serve as powerful
remedies to protect individuals from violations of their constitutional rights. The key writs
available under Article 199 are:

1) Writ of Habeas Corpus:

Purpose: To protect an individual's right to personal liberty by ensuring that they are
not unlawfully detained.
Example: If a person is detained without proper legal authority, a writ of habeas corpus
can be sought to secure their release.

2) Writ of Mandamus:
Purpose: To compel a public official or authority to perform a duty that they are legally
obligated to perform.
Example: If a government official is not taking action that is required by law, such as
the issuance of a license, a writ of mandamus can be sought.

3) Writ of Prohibition:
Purpose: To prevent an inferior court or tribunal from exceeding its jurisdiction or
acting contrary to the principles of natural justice.
Example: If a lower court is proceeding with a case beyond its legal authority, a writ of
prohibition can be sought to stop the proceedings.

4) Writ of Certiorari:
Purpose: To quash the orders of an inferior court or tribunal if they are found to be
without jurisdiction or in violation of the principles of natural justice.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 59

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

Example: If a decision is made by a tribunal without giving a fair opportunity to the

parties involved, a writ of certiorari can be sought to annul that decision.

5) Writ of Quo Warranto:

Purpose: To inquire into the legality of a person holding a public office and to determine
if they have the legal authority to hold that office.
Example: If there are doubts about the eligibility of a person holding a public office, a
writ of quo warranto can be sought to question their authority.

Procedure for Filing a Petition Under Article 199:

 Standing:
Any person whose fundamental rights are violated or are about to be violated can file a
petition.
 Petition Format:
The petition must clearly state the facts, the constitutional rights alleged to be violated,
and the specific relief sought.
 Notice to Respondent:
The court issues notice to the party or authority against whom the petition is filed.
 Hearing:
The court hears arguments from both sides and examines evidence, if necessary.
 Decision:
The court can issue the appropriate writ or order based on its findings.

Scope and Significance:

 Article 199 provides a broad and flexible remedy, allowing the High Courts to address
a wide range of violations of fundamental rights.
 It is a crucial tool for the protection of individual liberties, ensuring that state authorities
act within the bounds of the law and the Constitution.
 The writ jurisdiction under Article 199 is not limited to violations by the state; it can
also be invoked against private entities performing public functions.

Landmark Cases:
The High Courts in Pakistan have frequently used Article 199 to address cases related to
unlawful detentions, freedom of expression, protection of property rights, and challenges to
administrative decisions.
In essence, Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan serves as a vital mechanism for
individuals to seek redress for violations of their fundamental rights, offering a powerful means
for the judiciary to ensure justice, fairness, and constitutionalism in the country.

REMEDIES UNDER ARTICLE 184(3) OF THE

CONSTITUTION OF PAKISTAN 1973
Article 184(3) of the Constitution of Pakistan grants the Supreme Court of Pakistan
extraordinary jurisdiction, allowing it to take suo-motu notice of matters of public importance

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 60

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

related to the enforcement of fundamental rights. This provision has been crucial in enabling
the Supreme Court to play a proactive role in addressing pressing issues that impact the public
welfare. Here is a detailed explanation of the remedies available under Article 184(3):

1. Suo-Motu Jurisdiction:
Definition: Suo-motu means "on its own motion." Under Article 184(3), the Supreme Court
can take notice of a matter on its own motion without the need for a formal petition from an
aggrieved party.
Purpose: This extraordinary power allows the Supreme Court to address urgent and significant
issues affecting fundamental rights, even if no specific legal action has been initiated.

2. Matters of Public Importance:

Definition: Article 184(3) empowers the Supreme Court to intervene in matters of public
importance.
Scope: The court has interpreted this broadly, covering a wide range of issues such as
environmental degradation, human rights abuses, corruption, and issues affecting public
welfare.

3. Enforcement of Fundamental Rights:

Objective: Article 184(3) is primarily designed for the enforcement of fundamental rights
guaranteed by the Constitution.
Intervention: The Supreme Court can step in to protect and enforce fundamental rights,
ensuring that individuals and groups are not subjected to violations of their constitutional
guarantees.

4. Issuance of Orders and Directions:

Authority: The Supreme Court, when exercising jurisdiction under Article 184(3), has the
authority to issue orders, directions, or judgments necessary for the enforcement of
fundamental rights.
Scope of Authority: The court's power is broad, allowing it to delve into various aspects of a
matter and issue directives to address constitutional violations.

5. Public Interest Litigation (PIL):

Role in PIL: Article 184(3) has played a pivotal role in the development of Public Interest
Litigation (PIL) in Pakistan.
Expanded Jurisprudence: The court has used this provision to expand the scope of its
jurisdiction to address issues affecting the public interest, even in the absence of direct legal
disputes.

6. Constitutional Interpretation:
Authority to Interpret: The Supreme Court, while exercising jurisdiction under Article 184(3),
has the authority to interpret constitutional provisions.
Clarity and Consistency: This power allows the court to provide clarity on constitutional
matters and ensure consistency in the application of constitutional principles.

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 61

LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

7. Checks and Balances:

Limitations: While expansive, the Supreme Court's jurisdiction under Article 184(3) is not
unlimited.
Checks and Balances: The court is cognizant of maintaining a balance with other branches of
government and respecting the principle of separation of powers.

8. Impact on Governance:
Dynamic Role: Article 184(3) has given the Supreme Court a dynamic role in governance,
allowing it to address issues that might fall through the legislative or executive cracks.
Impact on Public Policy: The court's interventions have had a significant impact on public
policy and governance, influencing changes in laws and administrative practices.

In essence, Article 184(3) provides the Supreme Court with a unique and powerful tool to
address matters of public importance and enforce fundamental rights. While its use has been
instrumental in promoting justice and protecting constitutional rights, it also raises questions
about the balance of power and the role of the judiciary in shaping public policy. The court's
exercise of this jurisdiction requires careful consideration to maintain a delicate equilibrium
within the constitutional framework.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the remedies available under the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, particularly
under Article 199 and Article 184(3), establish a robust legal framework for the safeguarding
of fundamental rights. Article 199, empowering the High Courts, provides an accessible avenue
for individuals to seek redress, ensuring that violations of their constitutional rights can be
promptly addressed. Meanwhile, Article 184(3) endows the Supreme Court with an
extraordinary jurisdiction to proactively address matters of public importance, enhancing the
court's role as a guardian of the constitution. Together, these constitutional provisions
exemplify the commitment of the legal system to uphold justice, protect individual liberties,
and maintain the rule of law in Pakistan.


By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 62

 LL.B Part-II Introduction to Human Rights Law

By : Shahid Naeem (0321-3614222) Kings Law College, Sheikhupura. 63

online-pdf-no-copy.com