Environmental Effects On Viscoelastic !!
Environmental Effects On Viscoelastic !!
Abstract
In the last years, thermoplastic composites have been introduced as structural materials for high performance aerospace
applications. However, these materials can present problems when exposed to moisture, temperature, and UV radiation,
and besides it may occur as the synergy among the main degradation mechanisms. Among the thermoplastic composite
materials, carbon fiber reinforced poly(ether-ketone-ketone) (PEKK) laminates have shown excellent balance of proper-
ties, including high glass transition temperature, high strength, stiffness and fracture toughness values, low moisture
absorption, and good environmental resistance. The aim of the present work was to evaluate the influence of the
environmental effect on the viscoelastic behavior and glass transition temperature of carbon fiber reinforced PEKK
thermoplastic composites. In this work, the effects of environmental degradation on the viscoelastic properties of this
composite material were studied by dynamic mechanical analyses. The most significant change was observed for the UV
radiation accelerated weathering conditioning effects. A decrease of the storage modulus from 40 to 10 GPa and the Tg
from 147 to 105 C is observed, which decreases consequently the composite stiffness and the service temperature after
exposed environmental effects. A synergetic degradation mechanism between UV radiation accelerated weathering test
and hygrothermal conditioning is clearly verified.
Keywords
Polymer-matrix composite, environmental degradation, dynamic mechanical analysis
toughness, and tensile modulus. PEKK has a glass radiation, and temperature variation) on viscoelastic
transition temperature (Tg) of around 156 C and melt- behavior and glass transition temperature of carbon
ing temperature (Tm) between 305 and 310 C.5–8 fiber-reinforced PEKK thermoplastic composites.
The mechanical properties of polymer-matrix com-
posites can be affected by environmental conditions.
Composite materials are typically exposed to multiple Experimental
environments, such as moisture, temperature, UV radi-
ation, salinity, etc., during service, which leads to the
Materials
possibility of synergistic degradation mechanisms. Both Specimens of carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK thermo-
moisture and UV radiation have adverse effects on the plastic composites were produced by using hot com-
mechanical properties of the polymeric matrix and can pression molding. During the process, the appropriate
strongly affect the performance of the composite.9–14 thermal cycle obtained in previous work was used.5
Excess of moisture can cause the absorption of water PEKK amorphous thermoplastic polymer with glass
by the matrix and consequently generate the plasticizer transition temperature of 156 C and softening tempera-
effect that can reduce the glass transition temperature, ture of 310 C was used as matrix. Carbon fiber fabric
affecting the strength of adhesion between the fiber and style Plain Weave (PW) (282-3 K), supplied by Hexcel
matrix. Kinetics of moisture absorption in polymeric Composites, was used as reinforcement. The laminate
composite is governed by diffusion of water molecules was processed with around 60% of reinforcement con-
inside the micro gaps between polymer chains. Two tent in volume, according to the acid digestion experi-
other mechanisms are capillary transport into the ments carried out based on ASTM-D3171 (Procedure
gaps and flaws at the interfaces between fiber and the B) standard. The composite laminate quality was also
polymeric matrix, because of incomplete percolation evaluated by an optical microscopy from Olympus BH
during the manufacturing process, and transport of Company.
water by microcracks in the matrix.9–14
The absorption of UV photons by polymers results
in photo-oxidative reactions that can affect their chem-
Environmental conditioning
ical structure resulting in the material deterioration, In order to evaluate the influence of the environmental
thus causing chain scission and/or chain crosslinking. effects on the viscoelastic and glass transition tempera-
Chain scission decreases the molecular weight of the ture behaviors of carbon fiber reinforced PEKK
polymer, reducing the strength and heat resistance. thermoplastic composite, the specimens were exposed
On the other hand, chain crosslinking and/or reticula- to a combination of temperature, UV radiation, and
tion lead to excessive brittleness and can result in moisture in environmental conditioning chambers.
microcracking. However, for extended exposure to The hygrothermal conditioning has been performed
UV radiation, matrix-dominated properties can suffer according to Procedure B of ASTM D 5229 M-12
severe deterioration, for example interlaminar shear standard in conditioning chamber from
strength, flexural strength, and flexural stiffness can Marconi—MA835-UR. The moisture level in the
all decrease. The fiber-dominated properties, such as laminate was periodically monitored as a function of
tensile modulus and tensile strength, are usually not the time by measuring the weight of traveler samples till
affected significantly, especially the carbon fiber-rein- the moisture equilibrium state is reached. During con-
forced materials.9–13 ditioning, the temperature was set at 80 C and the rela-
In service, failures of carbon fiber-reinforced thermo- tive humidity (RH) in the chamber was set at 90%. The
plastic composites are commonly attributed to ageing of specimens were submitted to environmental condition-
the material in its particular environment, brought ing on a moisture chamber up to eight weeks. The mois-
about by a combination of the effects of heat, light, ture gain percentage (M) during water absorption was
water, and mechanical stresses on the material. determined by using the following equation.
Thermoplastic composites can present problems due to
its moisture absorption. When this occurs, the moisture Mu Ms
M¼ 100 ð1Þ
plasticizes the matrix and weakens the fiber and matrix Ms
interface, leading to a reduction of Tg and changes of
mechanical properties, such as Young’s modulus. As where Mu is the wet weight (g) of specimen and Ms is
discussed previously, the Tg is an important material the initial weight of dry specimen.
property because it defines the temperature at which The UV accelerated weathering test has been based
the material properties are drastically reduced.9–18 according to the ASTM D 4587-11 and ASTM D 4329-
The aim of the present study was to report the influ- 13 standards, in conditioning chamber from Q-Lab
ence of the environmental effects (moisture, UV Corporation – QUV/Spray. The composite specimens
0.25
0.20
Moisture absorption (%)
0.15
0.10
Specimem 1
Specimem 2
0.05 Specimem 3
Specimem 4
Specimem 5
0.00
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time1/2 (h)
Figure 2. Graph of moisture absorption as function of exposed time (square root of hours) of carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK
thermoplastic composite.
b2 slope2
D¼ ð4Þ −0.1
42
−0.2
where b is the sample thickness.
The calculated moisture diffusion coefficient value −0.3
(D ¼ 16.5 106 mm2/s) is very low and is in the same
log (Mt/M∞)
20000
0.15
10000
0.05
5000
0 50 100 150 200 250
Temperature (°C) 0 50 100 150 200 250
Temperature (°C)
(c) 6000
162°C
Not weathered
5000
Hygrothermal conditioned
Loss modulus (MPa)
4000
154°C
3000
2000
1000
0
0 50 100 150 200 250
Temperature (°C)
Figure 4. DMA analyses of hygrothermal conditioned carbon fiber reinforced PEKK thermoplastic composite and non-conditioned
samples: (a) tan d; (b) storage modulus (E0 ), and (c) loss modulus (E00 ).
results obtained from tan d analyses, indicating a plas- the UV radiation conditioning did not show significant
ticization of the thermoplastic matrix. influence on the studied polymeric samples and it was
Figure 4(c) shows the loss modulus (E00 ) results for not possible to establish some correlation with the glass
not weathered and hygrothermal conditioned speci- transition temperature.
mens. It is observed that the Tg shows a decrease of Figure 5(b) shows the storage modulus (E0 ) results.
5.2% in the hygrothermal conditioned carbon fiber- Considering the temperature of 50 C, E0 values of 40,
reinforced PEKK thermoplastic composite specimens, 26, 18, and 10 GPa can be observed. This analysis
when compared with not weathered specimens. These shows a sharp decrease in the storage modulus (E0 ) of
results confirm the results of Tg obtained from tan d the conditioned specimens and the modification of the
and E0 analyses, indicating the plasticization of the profile of these curves. As observed by several research-
thermoplastic matrix. ers,9,10 this behavior suggests a relation with the deg-
Figure 5 shows the behavior of DMA as function of radation process (rupture of molecular chain bonds)
temperature for the carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK associated with the reticulation process. When UV radi-
thermoplastic composite specimens, after to be condi- ation and moisture (plasticization) act together, the
tioned in UV radiation accelerated weathering tests up matrix-dominated properties can suffer severe deterior-
to 200, 600, 1200 and 2400 h. ation, and consequently, some mechanical properties
According to the tan d results, it can be observed in such as storage modulus of polymeric composite may
Figure 5(a) that UV radiation accelerated weathering be affected. Analysing the Tg, a decrease from 147, 130,
specimens present glass transition temperatures of 161, 106 to 105 C is observed for the conditioned specimens
165, 169, and 167 C, respectively. Only the specimens for 200, 600, 1200, and 2400 h under these conditions,
conditioned for 200 h present a lower value (2.5%), respectively. The observed decrease of both modulus
unlike the other samples. This analysis suggests that and Tg indicates an interfacial weakening in the fiber
169°C 25000
tan δ
0.16
106°C
161°C
20000
0.12
15000
105°C
0.08 10000
5000
0.04
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 0 50 100 150 200 250
Temperature (°C) Temperature (°C)
(c) 4000
157°C
3500 200 h 160°C
600 h
3000 1200 h
2400 h
Loss Modulus (MPa)
2500
72°C
2000
162°C
1500
125°C
62°C
1000
500
118°C 162°C
0
0 50 100 150 200 250
Temperature (°C)
Figure 5. DMA analyses of UV radiation accelerated weathering test of carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK thermoplastic composite:
(a) tan d, (b) storage modulus (E0 ), and (c) loss modulus (E00 ).
and matrix interphase and a plasticizing effect on Tg is strongly affected by UV radiation. Thus, the Tg
PEKK, respectively. It should be remembered that obtained by E00 must be considered with some cau-
these temperatures (onset E0 ) are also considered as tion, because the UV radiation, in this case, did not
the most conservative Tg according to ASM show significant influence on material viscoelastic
Handbook—MIL 17. This behavior shows clearly the behavior. It is also known that UV radiation action
loss material elastic component, exposed to multiple occurs from the surface into the material, as men-
environments during service, caused by synergetic deg- tioned in the literature.9,10,19 However, different
radation mechanism (UV radiation and moisture). The from E00 , the Tg values obtained by onset E0 presents
decrease of elastic modulus and glass transition tem- significant differences due to the influence of the UV
perature indicates the decrease of the composite stiff- conditioning on the material stiffness. This correl-
ness after exposure to UV radiation and moisture. ation indicates that for structural applications, the
Figure 5(c) shows the loss modulus (E00 ) results for Tg obtained by E0 is much more suitable, as recom-
UV radiation accelerated weathering tests conditioned mend by literature.19
specimens. As can be observed, the weathered speci- Figure 5(c) also shows thermal transitions named
mens presented a Tg very close, i.e. at 157, 160, 162 sub-Tg. These transitions are classified in b and g and
and 162 C. This analysis suggests that the UV radi- their types of motion are related with increased mobil-
ation conditioning did not show significant influence ity in either side chains or small groups of adjacent
on molecular chain bond. However, when the Tg is backbone atoms, as recommend by the literature.20
analyzed according to E0 curves, it is verified that the The g transition is related to moisture absorption in
(a) (b)
50000
0.30
165°C
45000
0.25 40000 155°C
Not weathered
153°C
0.15 25000
0.05 10000
5000
0.00
0 50 100 150 200 250 0 50 100 150 200 250
Temperature (°C) Temperature (°C)
(c) 6000
162°C
5000 163°C
Not weathered
Thermal shock
Loss modulus (MPa)
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
0 50 100 150 200 250
Temperature (°C)
Figure 6. DMA analyses of thermal shock conditioned and non-conditioned of carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK thermoplastic com-
posite: (a) tan d, (b) storage modulus (E0 ), and (c) loss modulus (E00 ).
Table 1. Results of DMA analyses of carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK themoplastic composite of non-conditioned and conditioned
specimens.
the polymer. These transitions (b mainly) are also presence of tan d peaks at 62, 72, 118, and 125 C, for
related with impact damping/strength of the material. exposition times of 200, 1200, and 2400 h, respectively.
As can be observed, the weathering effect by UV radi- Figure 6 shows the DMA behaviors as function of
ation on polymeric composite contributes is probably temperature of carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK thermo-
due to the moisture absorption process by the polymer plastic composite specimens, after the thermal shock
polymeric matrix. This phenomenon is shown by g tran- conditioning.
sitions present in the composite exposed at 200, 1200, According to the tan d analyses, it is observed in
and 2400 h. In this case, the Tg is characterized by the Figure 6(a) that the thermal shock conditioned
specimens presented the glass transition temperature at radiation accelerated weathering test and the hygrother-
167 C, 1.2% higher than non-conditioned samples. mal conditioning.
Figure 6(b) shows the storage modulus (E0 ) analyses.
Considering the temperature of 50 C, it is observed Acknowledgement
that the storage modulus (E0 ¼ 48 GPa) is 37%
The authors acknowledge the financial support received from
higher than that obtained for not weathered
CAPES and CNPq (Project no. 159815/2011-8, 305478/2009-
specimens (E0 ¼ 35 GPa). Furthermore, it is verified 5 and 302115/2009-9).
that the Tg by onset of storage modulus increases
slightly (1.3%) for the specimen submitted to thermal
shock effect (155 C) in comparison to that not wea- Funding
thered (153 C). These results suggest that the thermal This research received no specific grant from any funding
shock increases the stiffness slightly but did not affect agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
the Tg.
Table 1 summarizes the results obtained in the References
dynamic mechanical analyses as function of tempera- 1. Daniel IM and Ishai O. Engineering mechanics of compos-
ture of the carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK thermoplas- ites materials. New York, NY: Oxford University Press,
tic composite specimens after weathering and not 1994.
weathering. 2. Rezende MC and Botelho EC. O Uso de Compósitos
Estruturais na Industria Aeroespacial. Polı´meros:
Cieˆncia e Tecnologia 2000; 10: E4–E10.
3. Faria MCM, Appezzato FC, Costa ML, et al. The effect
Conclusions of the ocean water immersion and UV ageing on the
The influence of environmental effects on viscoelastic dynamic mechanical properties of the PPS/glass
behavior of carbon fiber-reinforced PEKK thermoplas- fiber composites. J Reinf Plastics Compos 2010; 30:
1729–1737.
tic composites has been investigated.
4. Botelho EC and Rezende MC. Evaluation by free vibra-
It was observed for all composite specimens studied tion method of moisture absorption effects in polyamide/
that the moisture increases quickly in the first hours carbon fiber laminates. J Thermoplast Compos Mater
(0.18% wt.), reaching the water uptake (0.23% wt.) 2010; 23: 207–225.
after two months of hygrothermal conditioning. 5. Mazur RL, Botelho EC, Costa ML, et al. Avaliações
The moisture absorption of these composites fit well to Térmica e Reológica da Matriz Termoplástica PEKK
the Fickian diffusion model, in spite of little differences Utilizada em Compósitos Aeronáuticos. Polı´meros:
in the found results (0.38). This behavior is characterized Cieˆncia e Tecnologia 2008; 18: 237–243.
experimentally by an uptake of moisture that reaches an 6. Bai J, Leach D and Pratte J. Properties, processing and
asymptotic value after a period of time. The calculated fabrication of poly (ether-ketone-ketone) composites. In:
moisture diffusion coefficient value is D ¼ 25th Sample Europe conference, Cytec Engineered
16.5 106 mm2/s and can be influenced negatively by Materials, Paris EXPO, Porte de Versailles, Paris, 30
March–1 April 2004.
incomplete percolation during the manufacturing pro-
7. Salek MH. Effects of processing parameters on the mech-
cess or transport of water by microcracks in the matrix. anical properties of carbon/PEKK thermoplastic com-
The hygrothermal conditioning effect on the storage posite materials. MSc Thesis, Concordia University
modulus (E0 ) shows a significant influence on the glass Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 2005.
transition temperature (140 C). However, the thermal 8. Mckague L. Thermoplastic resins. In: ASM handbook
shock conditioning did not show the same influence on composites, vol. 21. Materials Park, OH: ASM
the Tg (155 C). International, 2001, pp.132–140.
The most significant change was observed in the UV 9. Kumar BG, Singh RP and Nakamura T. Degradation of
radiation accelerated weathering conditioning. The stor- carbon fiber-reinforced epoxy composites by ultraviolet
age modulus (E0 ) as well as the Tg presented a significant radiation and condensation. J Compos Mater 2002; 36:
degradation emphasizing the deleterious effect of both 2713–2733.
10. Tarantili PA and Kiose V. Effect of accelerated aging on
UV radiation and moisture on the material. Associated
the structure and properties of monolayer and multilayer
with this fact, it is also observed the presence of thermal
packaging film. J Appl Polym Sci 2008; 109: 674–682.
transitions named sub-Tg. The observed decrease of 11. Botelho EC, Rezende MC and Pardini LC. Hygrothermal
both storage modulus (40, 26, 18, and 10 GPa) and the effects on damping behavior of metal/glass fiber/epoxy
Tg (147, 130, 106, and 105 C) indicates an interfacial hybrid composites. Mater Sci Eng A 2006; 399: 190–198.
weakening in the fiber and matrix interphase and a plas- 12. Espert A, Vilaplana F and Karlson S. Comparison of
ticizing effect on PEKK. This behavior is attributed to water absorption in natural cellulosic fibres from wood
the synergetic degradation mechanism between the UV and one-year crops in polypropylene composites and its
influence on their mechanical properties. Compos A 2004; 17. Ray BC. Temperature effect during humid ageing
35: 1267–1276. on interfaces of glass and carbon fibers
13. Dhacal HN, Zhang ZY and Richardson MOW. Effect of reinforced epoxy composites. J Colloid Interf Sci 2006;
water absorption on the mechanical properties of hemp 298: 111–117.
fibre reinforced unsaturated polyester composite. Compos 18. Bismarck A, Hofmeier M and Dorner G. Effect of hot
Sci Technol 2007; 67: 1674–1683. water immersion on the performance of carbon rein-
14. Arici AA. Effect of hygrothermal aging on polyetheri- forced unidirectional poly(ether ether ketone) (PEEK)
mide composites. J Reinf Plastic Compos 2007; 26: composites: Stress rupture under end-loaded bending.
1937–1942. Compos A 2007; 38: 407–426.
15. Ruffer DR. The Boeing company. In: ASM handbook 19. ASM Handbook: The composite materials handbook –
composites, vol. 21. Materials Park, OH: ASM MIL 17: polymer matrix composites: guidelines for char-
International, 2001, pp.246–251. acterization of structural materials, vol. 1. West
16. Candido GM, Costa ML, Rezende MC, et al. Conshohocken (PA), 2002, p.624.
Hygrothermal effects on quasi-isotropic carbon epoxy 20. Menard KP. Dynamic mechanical analysis: a practical
laminates with machined and molded edges. Compos B introduction. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2008.
2008; 39: 490–496.