Philosophy: Human and Nature
Philosophy: Human and Nature
————————————————————————————————————————————————————
Week 7 - Sometimes, humans adopt an exploitive attitude
Human Person whenever nature is merely considered as an
- A human person is a living being that contains a real instrument for one’s profit or gain.
and existing to direct its own development toward
fulfillment through perfect, unconditional, and infinite Some Effects Of Antropocentric Model
Truth, Love, Goodness, Beauty, and Unity, and will do • Earth Pollution
so if all the proper conditions are met. • Stronger Typhoons
• Famine
Environment • Soil Erosion
- Environment is the place, people, things and nature
that surround any living organism. It is our basic life 2. ECOCENTRIC MODEL
support system. It provides the air we breathe, the water - Ecocentric model, the ecological or relational integrity
we drink, the food we eat and the land where we live. It of the humans provides meaning of our morals and
is a combination of natural & human made phenomena. values, and it is nature centered.
- Devoted to preserving the totality of earth’s biodiversity
Paradigm Shift and the functioning of its life-supporting system.
- The speculation of the pre-Socratic philosophers - Categories Included in an Econcentric Model
represent. • Nature
- a change from mythical explanation of the origins of • Wild
the cosmos to a more rational explanation. • Holism
- An example of a paradigm shift is when the Catholic
• Nature/Cosmos
Church and medieval scholar mistakenly thought the
• Body
earth is flat, until Magellan’s expedition and the age of
exploration proved this view wrong. • Relational
———————————————————————— • Earth/Wisdom
• Ecology over/against humans
The philosophers looked for the underlying laws of
nature. They wanted to understand the scientific NOTICING DISORDER IN THE UNIVERSE
progress by studying the nature itself, and not by - The domination of humanity is linked to the domination
listening to the stories about the gods. of nature based on anthropocentric model.
- An unfair or unjust utilization of the environment results
Though not as sophisticated in the 21st century in ecological crises and disasters.
standard, the pre-Socratic philosophers represent the - From this view, it follows that human arrogance toward
first and scientific intellectual attempt to study the nature is justifiable in order to satisfy human interests.
origins of the universe. - Sometimes, humans adopt an exploitable attitude
whenever nature is merely considered as an instrument
Lao Tzu for one’s profit or self-interest.
- On of the most prominent philosophers of nature is Lao - For example, quarrying or cutting age old trees
Tzu. The founder of Taoism, Lao Tzu compare the Tao justify our exploitative attitude toward nature.
or The Way to water, heaven, emptiness of vessel, color,
music and flavor, and even to weakness. Philippine Star Article
- "A legislated moratorium on open-pit mining is
Two Main Frame Works urgently needed because President Duterte's
1. Anthropocentric Model pronouncements of an open-pit mine ban, along with
- Based on the Anthropocentric model, humans are former Environment Secretary Gina Lopez's
superior and central to the universe, thus it is human Department Administrative Order and local ordinances,
centered. are being defied by mining corporations," Kalikasan
- Categories Included In An Anthropocentric Model People’s Network for the Environment national
• Human coordinator Leon Dulce said in a release.
• Culture - A moratorium is a temporary suspension of an activity
• Individualism or a law until future events warrant lifting the suspension
or related issues have been resolved
• Mind
- “The ecosystems and landscapes devastated by 25
• Calculative
years of open-pit mining under the Mining Act must
• Human over/against environments likewise be given 25 years of relief from such destructive
• Global/technology methods,” Center for Environmental Concerns -
Philippines executive director Lia Alonzo said in a
- The domination of humanity is linked to the domination release.
of nature based on the anthropocentric model. An unfair - “We must learn from our bitter experiences of
or unjust utilization of the environment result to ecologically disruptive open-pit mining such as in the
ecological crisis. From this view, it follows that Oceanagold mine in Didipio, Nueva Vizcaya and the
human arrogance toward nature is justifiable in Philex Padcal mine in Benguet.”
order to satisfy human interest. - Current researches by Zimmerman (1994), Elgin
(2009), and Pettman (2012), exposed the
Philosophy
————————————————————————————————————————————————————
environmental consequence of international political- - In 2004, indigenous grandmothers who represented
economic specialization for specific countries and different tribes from the Arctic Circle, Nepal, and
global regions. Tibet, held a meeting to be able to preserve the
community.
Research also shows the implications for both abuses - Deeply concerned with the destruction of Mother
of natural resources and of the generation of wastes and Earth, including the contamination of air, water, and soil;
emissions. war; poverty; and destruction of the indigenous life, they
have committed themselves to form an alliance that will
Numerous concepts and indicators have been used to embrace prayer, education, and healing for our Mother
understand environmental impact such as carbon Earth, for all her inhabitants, and for future generations.
footprint.
UDHR of Indigenous Peoples
Carbon Footprint - Recognizing that respect for indigenous
- A carbon footprint is the total amount of greenhouse knowledge, cultures and traditional practices
gas emissions that come from the production, use and contributes to sustainable and equitable development
end-of-life of a product or service. and proper management of the environment.
- Usually, the bulk of an individual’s carbon footprint will - Article 29 Sect. 1: Indigenous peoples have the right
come from transportation, housing and food. to the conservation and protection of the environment
- Carbon Footprint has Eight Categories and the productive capacity of their lands or territories
• Construction and resources. States shall establish and implement
• Shelter assistance programmes for indigenous peoples for such
• Food conservation and protection, without discrimination.
• Clothing
• Mobility Week 8
• Manufactured Good Appreciating Beauty of Nature
• Services Ancient Thinkers
• Trade Milesians
- Early Greek Philosophers, the Milesians, regarded
- If humanity overworks the soil and substitutes nature as spatially without boundaries, that is, as
domesticated species of plants and animals for wild infinite or indefinite in extent.
ones, human made changes threaten the health of
nature. Anaximander
- Unlike the changes brought by the evolutionary - One ancient thinker, Anaximander, employed the
process, human interventions have swift and even term “boundless” to convey further thought that nature
violent effects on nature. is indeterminate- boundless in the sense that no
- Study from the World Wildlife Fund blames human boundaries between the warm and cold or the moist and
activities for drastic decline in wildlife population. Due to dry regions are originally present within it.
hunting and fishing, 52% of wildlife population - According to Anaximander’s sketch of the genesis of
deteriorated. the world (cosmogony), the evolution of the world
- The study then establishes that the damage is not begins with the generation of opposites in a certain
inevitable but a consequence of our choices. region of nature.
- Accordingly, humanity needs to develop an ecological
conscience based on individual responsibility. Pythagoras
- Ecologists challenge us to adapt a lifestyle that - Another ancient philosopher, Pythagoras, described
involves simple living that honors the right of all life the universe as a living embodiment of nature’s order,
forms to live, flourish, and create rich diversity of human harmony, and beauty.
and non-human life. - He sees our relationship with universe involving
biophilia (love of the living things) and cosmophilia
(love of other living beings).
- Pythagorean beliefs such as vegetarianism,
abstinence, refusal to eat beans, refusal to wear animal
skins, celibacy, self-examination, immortality, and
reincarnation were conceived by the author as ethical
and ecological.
Chinese Cosmic
- The Chinese cosmic conception is based on the
assumption that all happens in the universe is a
continuous whole like a chain of natural consequences.
- All events in the universe follow a transitional process
due to yin and yang.
- The universe does not proceed forward but revolves
without beginning or ending.
Philosophy
————————————————————————————————————————————————————
- There is nothing new under the sun; the new is a - Deep ecologists encourage humanity to shift from
repetition of the old. anthropocentrism to ecocentrism.
- A human beings happiness lies in his conformity with
nature or tao; the wise, therefore, conforms with tao B. SOCIAL ECOLOGY
and is happy. - Social ecology is the study of how individuals interact
- "The Tao, or the Way, is the approach in accord with with and respond to the environment around them, and
the flow of Nature. The basic idea of the Taoists is to how these interactions affect society and the
enable people to realize that, since human life is really environment as a whole.
only a small part of a larger process of nature, the - The concept of social ecology was introduced by an
human life which makes sense are those which are in environmental activist named Murray Bookchin.
harmony with nature.
- Mt. Qiyun garden serves as a symbol of Taoism. Murray Bookchin
- He was an ecologist and believed there was a better
Modern Thinkers approach to the study. In his paper "What is Social
Immanuel Kant Ecology?", he argues environmentalists are too
- In his third critique, Critique of Judgement, Immanuel focused on studying the individual symptoms of a
Kant expressed that beauty is ultimately a symbol of problem rather than addressing the problem itself—
morality. the belief that humans can and should control
- According to Kant, we must ignore any practical motive nature.
or inclination that we have and instead contemplate the
object without being distracted by our desires. 3. ECOFEMINISM
- We should try our best to be free of our biases when - It is also called ecological feminism, branch of
we analyze opinions and express our ideas. For feminism that examines the connections between
instance, one should not be tempted to plunge into women and nature. Its name was coined by French
the water in a seascape portrait. feminist Francoise d’Eaubonne in 1974.
- The beautiful encourages us to believe that nature and - A philosophical idea that combines feminism and
humanity are part of an even bigger design. ecology concerns, emphasizing that both suffer from
- Kant believed that that orderliness and the harmony their treatment by a male dominated society.
of nature with our faculties guide us toward a deeper - Comes from the idea that women and nature have
religious perspective. significant connection, since women most often have a
- The vision of the world is not limited to knowledge close association with nature in many societies due to
and freedom or even to faith in the ordinary sense of the the nature of their traditional roles.
term. It is a sense of cosmic harmony.
Demonstrating The Virtues Of Prudence And
Understanding The Environment Refers Our Frugality Toward Environment
Relationship To Ecology And Nature Fromm proposed a new society that encourages the
Herbert Marcuse emergence of a new human being that will foster
- For Herbert Marcuse, humanity has dominated prudence and moderation of frugality toward the
nature. environment.
- There can only be change if we also change our 1. The willingness to give up all forms of having
attitude toward our perception of the environment. in order to fully be.
2. Being fully present where one is.
George Mead 3. Trying to reduce greed, hate and illusions as
- For George Mead, as human beings, we do not only much as one is capable.
have rights but duties. 4. Reaching the full growth of oneself and of
- In other words, rights contain in them duties. one’s fellow beings as the supreme goal of
- When a person claims that he has a right over living.
something, then he automatically does his duties 5. Not deceiving others, but also not being
related to the maintenance of these rights. deceived by others; one may be called
innocent, but not naïve.
Republic Act 10066: National Cultural 6. Freedom that is not arbitrariness but the
Heritage Act of 2009 possibility to be oneself, not as a bundle of
- This law aims to protect, preserve, conserve and greedy desires, but as a delicately balanced
promote the nation's cultural heritage, its property and structure that at any moment is confronted with
histories, and the ethnicity of local communities. the alternatives of growth or decay, life or death.
7. Happiness in the process of ever-growing
Environmental Theories That Show Care For The aliveness, whatever the furthest point is that
Environment fate permits one to reach, for living as fully as
A. DEEP ECOLOGY one can is so satisfactory that the concern for
- In this theory ecological crisis is an outcome of what one might or might not attain has little
anthropocentrism. chance to develop.
- The controlling attitude of humankind is extended to 8. Joy comes from giving and sharing, not from
nature when in fact, humanity is part of nature. hoarding and exploiting.
Philosophy
————————————————————————————————————————————————————
9. Developing one’s capacity for love, together - What we write down
with one’s capacity for critical, unsentimental
thought.
10. Shedding one’s narcissism and accepting Divine Law
that tragic limitations are inherent in human - This law is concerned with those standards that must
existence be satisfied by a human being to achieve eternal
salvation.
Week 9 - Example: Holy Bible of Christians
Freedom of the Human Person - A manual sent to us
- To be free is a part of humanity’s authenticity.
- Understanding freedom is part of our transcendence. Eternal Law
- Example: Achieving dreams despite being poor. - is the decree of God that governs all creation. It is the
law which is the Supreme Reason cannot be
All Actions Have Consequence understood to be otherwise than unchangeable and
A. ARISTOTLE: The Power of Volition eternal.
- The power to make your own choice or decisions - Which all others Laws are derived
- The imperative quality of a judgement of practical - The designer’s plan
intellect is meaningless apart from will.
- There is no intellect if there is no will. C. Thomas Aquinas’ Spiritual Freedom
- Humanity’s “free will” is an instrument of free choice.
- It is within the power of everyone to be good or bad, ACTIONS
worthy or worthless. (GOOD OR EVIL)